hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

32

Transcript of hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

Page 1: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

� ������������ ��������������� ������ !�#"%$������&���

')(+*�,.-/(%021/3�4657*�1.8:9<;>=?1.@ A�5B3DCE-/8FHGJIKGMLONQPBPSR�T.U:V?WXTZY+V?W\[BNQ]_^

`.a?acb V?dfe!YDTZ[BegF�h?Nb dfW\W+Tjigk�[lPBP7^�m�n a!o.p?oZq

rs1.@BtD-/@vuxwy@z1.(+{b V?eETZ]X|~}�ef[zh?N_W\]X[zY�i

� P�Tji�Y+V?e ^f��[B��Y+V?W\[�T)^�F%df]�Y+WXT.PB[BT�f1/3�-/8g��1.8

� N_�fT.W\YX��NQe�Y�V.���HPBNQ�QY+W\[B�_T.PS�Hef�?[lefN_NQWX[Be)�� Y+T.e)��V?W\��}�ef[lh.N_W\]X[lY�i.^ � F p.q!�?a!�

� NQUfWXdETZW\i � ^ � p?p!�

�J�f�\���D� �¡�¢�£J¤ ¥7¦�¤.¦Q§¨£J©2§�ª#©Dª7«¬§6ª¨«®­�©�¯±°²¦j³ £�¯±´µ¦Q¥>§¨«·¶Q¸/©Dª7¹ ¥7£OºQ£�¥7«¼».­�©Dª7«·¦Q¸¾½_¿¾­&¦Q°OÀ

¤ ¹ ª¨£�¥XÁÂù ¥S°²¦�³�£�¯Ä¥¨£X­&¦�¶Q¸ «¬Å�£\§ª7Æ/©Dª�¥7£�¤.£\©¡ª¨£\³%§¨«·¶Q¸/©Dª7¹ ¥¨£X§Ç½j¿�ª¨Æ £KȨ¦DÉS¸ £�¥#Ê©�¥¨£�§¨«·°²«¬¯¬©�¥Ë½ ¹ ªÃ¸ ¦�ªË«¬³ £�¸_ª¨«®­�©�¯lÁÃÂù ¥Ã°²¦j³ £�¯�­�¦�¸/§¨«®§�ª#§�¦¡´±©KÌÎÍ�Ï�Ð?Ñ·ÒDÌÎÍ˧¨«¬¶�¸/©¡Àª7¹ ¥¨£�´µ¦Q¥ £X©�­#Æ�«·¸/³ «·ºj«®³�¹/©¡¯BÓ/©�¸/³�§¨£�ºQ£�¥#©¡¯Z´z©�­&ª¨¦�¥#§ ÉSÆ «®­#Æ%©�¯·¯¬¦DÉÔ´µ¦�¥ÇºD©¡¥7«®©Dª¨«¬¦�¸Z§«¬¸2£\©Q­#ÆK¥¨£\¸/³�«·ª¨«¬¦�¸2¦�´fª¨Æ «®§Ãª¨£�°²¤ ¯®©Dª7£�Á�ÕÇÆ £\§¨£�ºD©¡¥7«¬©¡ª¨«¬¦�¸/§Ë«·¸Z­&¯¬¹/³�£�ª7Æ £JÖBÐ/Í#Í7צ�´.ÉS¥7«¼ª7«·¸/¶/Ó�©Q§EÉ£\¯·¯Z©�§E§¨¯·¦DÉS¯¬¿�ºD©¡¥7¿j«·¸ ¶H©¡Ø²¸/£Çª¨¥#©¡¸/§6´µ¦�¥7°�©Dª¨«¬¦�¸Z§)§¨¹/­#Æ�©�§E§¨«¬Å�£�Ó¥7¦¡ª#©Dª¨«¬¦�¸%©¡¸/³�§¨Æ £\©�¥\Á±ÕÇÆ/£H£\§6ª¨«¬°²©¡ª¨£X³�ª7£�°²¤ ¯®©Dª7£H¥¨£\¤ ¥¨£X§6£\¸_ª7§ ª¨Æ/£KÈ6°²£\©�¸/ÊO¦¡´©2§7©¡°²¤ ¯¬£J¦�´S§¨«¬¶�¸/©¡ª¨¹ ¥7£\§y´µ¥7¦�°Ù©�¸Ú«·¸/³ «·ºj«®³�¹/©¡¯BÓE©¡¸/³Úª¨Æ £�º+©�¥¨«®©Dª7«·¦Q¸/§H«¬¸Úª¨Æ/£´z©Q­�ª¨¦Q¥7§ ­�©�¸�½.£y¹/§6£X³�ª7¦>£X§�ª#©¡½ ¯¬«¬§¨Æ�§¨£�ºQ£�¥#©¡¯.°²£\©�§¨¹ ¥7£\§¦¡´ËȨºD©¡¥7«¬©�¸/­&£XÊ Á�ÕÇÆ/£\§¨£Û ¹/©�¸Qª7«¼ª#©Dª7«·ºQ£Ã°²£\©Q§6¹/¥¨£X§S©¡¥7£Ã£X§¨§¨£�¸_ª¨«®©¡¯?´µ¦Q¥S¥¨£\¯·«®©¡½/¯·£H§¨«·¶Q¸/©Dª7¹ ¥¨£�º�£\¥¨«·»Z­\©Dª¨«¬¦�¸ÄÁ

Ü Ý�Þ�ßfàá%â�ã2ä ß±å�á�Þ

æ7çgè&é�êµë�ìÄíjìfîDïJð�î2ì�ï�ñ�ì)ñ ë&î�í<ë�è&íjè&êµë&è&êµòDí�óËôKñ?õ!î¡óSöBñ�ï�é.÷�ô2í�çgë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î2ï&î¡ò+ñ�ø ç�ê®ùè&êvñ çÚí�ç�õ�ú�îDï�ê®û�òDíjè&êµñ ç¾üZý�ò+ñ ô2ìÄ÷!è�îDï¡þ�ÿ�÷!ï�ô2ñ.õ!î¡ó)ï&î¡ò+ñ�ø çÄê��Dî¡ëHè&é�íjèyï&îDìfî¡íjè�î¡õ¾è�î¡ë�èë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ëËü.ýKè&é!î��#ñ�ð ç!îDï��%íjï�îOë&êzô2êµóµíjïSüÄ÷�èÃç!ñ�èyêµõ!î¡çZè&êµòDí�óÎþ���é!îOôKñ?õ!î¡óÄêµçZú�ñ óvú�î¡ëí�� �����������ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î ð>é�êµò�é~êµë�û��?î¡õgöBñ�ïKí�ç�êzç�õ�êvú?êµõ�÷�í�ó�þ��Ãí�ò�é è&êµô2î é!î¾ë&êvø ç�ëé!î>è�ï\í�ò+î¡ëÃñ ÷�èÃè&é�êzë�è�î¡ôKìÄózíjè�î��.ç!ñ�è�î��!í�ò+è&óvý2üÄ÷!èÃð êvè&é ë&ô2í�óµó�ë�è�ñ.ò\é�í�ë�è&êµò>újíjï�êµíjè&êvñ ç�ëñ ç î¡í�ò\é ñ?òDòDí�ë&êvñ ç±þ���é!î¡ë�îcú_íjï�êzíjè&êvñ ç�ë�êzç�òDóµ÷�õ!îÚè&é�î�ë�ìfîDî¡õsñ�ö�ð ï�êvè&êµç!ø��yí�ë ðÃî¡óµó

Page 2: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

í�ëJë&óvñQð óvý<újíjï&ý?êµç!ø¾í�� ç!î�è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êµñ ç�ë²ë&÷�ò�éÔí�ë²ï�ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç �:ë&òDí�óµî��:í�ç�õ ë&é!î¡íjï¡þ� é�êzóvî�è&é!î�î¡ë&è&êµô2íjè�î¡õ<è�î¡ô2ìÄóµíjè�î�ë&îDï&ú�î¡ë>í�ë è&é!î ��ô2î¡í�ç��2ñ�ö�íKð ï�êvè�îDï�� ë�ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î��è&é!îJújíjï�êµíjè&êvñ ç�ëHíjüfñ ÷!èHè&éÄêµë�ôKî¡í�ç<òDí�çcüfîJ÷�ë�î¡õ¾è�ñ2î¡ë�è&íjü�óµêµë&é¾è&é!î �#ú_íjï�êzí�ç�ò+î �?þ

��é!îyë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&îÃõ�íjè&í²êµëñ�ü�è&í�êµç�î¡õ�ñ ç!ù6óµêµç!î�öBï&ñ ô íOõ�êvø êvè&ê��DîDï �jêzç�ë�è�ï�÷�ô2î¡ç/è�î¡õ�ì)î¡çñ�ï²ë�êµô2êµóµíjïOõ!îDú?êµò+î�þ �Ëý.ìÄêµòDí�óµóµý��Äè&é!î�ñ ÷!è�ìÄ÷�è>ñ�öËë�÷�ò�é í�õ!îDú.êzò+î�ø êvú�î¡ë²è&é�î�ìfñ ë&êvè&êµñ ç� êµç ����� � ò+ñjù�ñ�ï\õ�êµç�íjè�î¡ë�ï&î¡óµíjè&êvú�î2è�ñ í�ç íjï&üÄêµè�ï�íjï&ý ñ�ï�êvø êµç � ñ�öyè&é!î2ìfî¡çÔíjè�î��Z÷�êvùë�ìÄí�ò+î¡õ<è&êzôKîJêµçZè�îDï&ú_í�ózëDþ��>óµñ ç!øKð êvè&éÚî¡í�ò\écóvñ?òDíjè&êvñ ç<ô2î¡í�ë&÷!ï&î¡ôKî¡çZè �Äñ ÷�ï õ�êvø êvè&ê �DîDïí�óµë�ñ2ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï\õ�ë�è&é!îJõ�ñ�ð çZð�íjï\õ<ì�ï&î¡ë�ë&÷!ï&î²ñ ç<è&é�îJìfî¡ç �!ñ�ï è&é!î�ölñ�ï�ò+î�î��.îDï&è�î¡õcñ ç<è&é!îè&êvì<ñ�ö è&é!îJìfî¡çEþ

æ7ç è&é�îÚì�ï&ñ�è�ñ�è6ý.ìfî<ë�ý?ë�è�î¡ô í�óvï&î¡í�õ�ý~õ!îDú�î¡óvñ�ìfî¡õ �ÃíÔõ�íjè&íjüÄí�ë�î<êµëKò+ñ çÄë�è�ï�÷�ò+è�î¡õölï&ñ ô ë&í¡ý�� è�ñ ��� ë�ìfî¡òDêµô2î¡ç�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ëKölï�ñ ô î¡í�ò�é ñ�ö�� ð�ï�êvè�îDï�ë¡þ��!ñ�ï�î¡í�ò�éð�ï�êvè�îDï � í²è�î¡ô2ìÄóµíjè�îHë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&îHêµë î¡ë�è&êµô2íjè�î¡õ �Zí�ç�õ�ölñ�ïSî¡í�ò\é2è&é!îyújíjï�êµíjè&êvñ çÄëÇñ�öÄè&é!î¡êvïë&í�ôKìÄóvî�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëHíjüfñ ÷!èyè&é�êµë�è�î¡ôKì�óµíjè�îJíjï&î�ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ�î¡õEþ��²êvú�î¡ç<íKç�îDð ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�îòDóµí�êµô2êµç�ø è�ñ ü)î¡óµñ ç!ø è�ñ ð�ï�êvè�îDï�� �>ñ ÷!ï�ë&ý.ë�è�î¡ô ò+ñ ôKì�íjï&î¡ë¾êvè�è�ñ è&é!î è�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�îë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�ölñ�ïÃð�ï�êvè�îDï���þSæ7öfè&é!î�újíjï�êµíjè&êvñ ç�ëÃêµçKè&é!î>öBí�ò+è�ñ�ï\ëÃíjï&î>üfîDý�ñ ç�õ2è&é!î>ï�í�ç!ø�î¡ëî¡ë�è&íjüÄóµêµë�é!î¡õ¾ölñ�ï è&é!î¡ë�îJö�í�ò+è�ñ�ï�ë�öBñ�ï�ð�ï\êvè�îDï�� ��è&é!î�ú�îDï�ê®û�òDíjè&êµñ çÚöBí�êzóµëDþ

��é!îDï&î�êµë í�çcî��.è�î¡ç�ë�êvú�î�óµêµè�îDï�íjè&÷!ï&î�ñ ç í�÷!è�ñ ô2íjè&êµò�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&îJú�îDï�ê®û)òDíjè&êvñ çcí�ç�õð�ï�êvè�îDï êzõ!î¡ç/è&êvû�òDíjè&êvñ ç�üZýÚò+ñ ôKì�÷!è�îDï � ë�îDî�� �! #"%$öBñ�ï íKï&î¡ò+î¡çZè�ï&îDú?êvîDð � þ

��é!î�ô2îDè&é!ñ.õ�ñ óvñ�ø�ý¾ölñ�ïOõ!ý.çÄí�ô2êµò�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&îJú�îDï�êvû�òDíjè&êvñ ç<ö�í�óµóµëHêzç/è�ñ è6ð�ñ ô2í�êµçø�ï&ñ ÷!ìÄë�&

' ôKîDè&é�ñ.õ�ë�è&é�íjè>÷�ë�î²öB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë�è�ñKï&îDì�ï�î¡ë�î¡ç/è�í�ç¾î¡çZè&êvï&îJë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�þ�(>îDï&î�è&é!îò+ñ ôKì�óvîDè�î�ë&êvø ç�í�óEêµë�ï&îDìÄï&î¡ë�î¡çZè�î¡õÚí�ë�í�öB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ñ�ö:è&êµô2î���í�ç�õ¾è&é!î²ú_í�óz÷!î¡ëyñ�öè&é!îOö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç íjèyõÄê*))îDï�î¡ç/è�è&êµôKî>ì)ñ êzç/è&ë�íjï&î²ò+ñ ç�ë&êµõ!îDï�î¡õ�è�ñ�üfî è&é!îOöBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëDþ

' ôKîDè&é�ñ.õ�ëè&é�íjèÇë&÷�ô2ô�íjï�ê��DîËè&é�îÃñ�ï�êµø êµç�í�ó.ë&êvø ç�í�ó/üZý�íOç.÷�ô�üfîDï ñ�öÄóvñQðHù6õ�êµôKî¡ç!ùë&êµñ ç�í�ó:ì�íjï�í�ôKîDè�îDï�ëOñ�ï²ölî¡íjè&÷�ï&î¡ëDþ ��é!î¡ë&î�ìÄíjï\í�ôKîDè�îDï�ë²ï&îDì�ï�î¡ë�î¡ç/èOè&é!î�ë&êvø ç�í_ùè&÷!ï�î�ölñ�ï�è&é�î�ìÄ÷!ï&ìfñ ë�î²ñ�öÇï&îDì�ï&î¡ë&î¡ç/è&íjè&êvñ çcí�ç�õÚï&î¡ò+ñ�ø ç�êµè&êvñ çEþ

�>ç î¡ç!ñ�ï\ôKñ ÷�ëcç.÷�ô�üfîDï�ñ�ö2ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î~ölî¡íjè&÷!ï�î¡ë éÄí¡ú�î�ü)îDî¡ç ì�ï&ñ�ìfñ ë�î¡õ±þ æ7ç�,+�ÿ- #.%$Sí�ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î�ñ�ö0/#/ õ�ê1))îDï&î¡çZè�öBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëOíjï&î�÷Äë�î¡õ �Äõ!îDï\êvú�î¡õ<öBï&ñ ô2.2ë&êvø ç�í�óµëø�î¡ç!îDï�íjè�î¡õ ü.ý�í¾öBñ�ï�ò+î+ù6ë�î¡çÄë&êvè&êvú�îKìfî¡çEþ43?ñ ôKîKìÄíjìfîDï�ë²é�í¡ú�î í�óµë�ñÚíjì�ìÄóµêµî¡õ�ë�ìfî¡òDê®û)òè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ çÄë è�ñ�è&é!î�ë�êvø ç�í�óµë>í�ç�õ<è&é!î¡ç ÷�ë�î¡õ í�ë>ölî¡íjè&÷!ï�î¡ë>í è�ï�÷�ç�òDíjè�î¡õ ë�îDèOñ�öò+ñZî5� òDêµî¡ç/è&ë ölï&ñ ô è&é!î¡ë�îJè�ï�í�çÄë�ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç�ëDþ0�!ñ�ï>î��?í�ô2ìÄóvî��6�,798: #�%$÷�ë&î¡õ¾è&é!î�ûÄï�ë&è/ � óvñQðHù�ölï�î��Z÷!î¡çÄò+ý ò+ñ.î5� òDêvî¡çZè&ë�ñ�öHè&é!î2ìfñ�ð�îDï%ë&ì)î¡ò+è�ï\íÚñ�ü�è&í�êµç!î¡õ~÷�ë&êµç�ø¾í� í�óµë&éè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ôÚþ;�yèOûÄï�ë�èOêvè>ë�îDî¡ô�ë>ú�îDï�ýcíjè�è�ï�í�ò+è&êvú�îKè�ñ¾ï&î¡õ�÷Äò+î�è&é!î%è&í�ë=<cñ�öÃë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�îú�îDï�ê®û�òDíjè&êvñ ç�è�ñ�è&é!îOè6ð�ñ2ë�è�îDìÄë�ñ�öóµñ�ðHù6óvîDú�î¡ó)öBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î²õ!îDè�î¡ò+è&êvñ ç �!öBñ óµóvñQðÃî¡õ�ü.ý�ë�ñ ôKîë�è&í�ç�õ�íjï�õ�ôKîDè&é!ñ?õÚñ�öSöBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î+ù�ú�î¡ò+è�ñ�ï�ò+ñ ôKìÄíjï�êzë�ñ çEþ ��é!îJì�ï\êµò+î�ñ ç!î�ì�í¡ý?ë�öBñ�ï è&é�êµëë&êµôKìÄózê®û�òDíjè&êvñ ç êzë�è&é�íjè%è&é!î�ñ�ú�îDï�í�ózóyï&î¡ë&÷�óvè�êµë�ñ çÄóvý í�ë%ø�ñZñ?õ í�ë�è&é�î öBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëKë�î+ùóvî¡ò+è�î¡õEþ æ¨è%êµë�õÄê*� òD÷�óvè�è�ñcû�çÄõgí ë�îDè�ñ�öHöBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë%è&é�íjè�í�õ!î��.÷�íjè�î¡óvýgõ�î¡ë&ò+ï�êvüfî�í�óµó

>

Page 3: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

è&é!îKêµôKìfñ�ï&è&í�çZè>í�ë�ìfî¡ò+è&ëOñ�öËè&é!î%üfî¡é�í¡ú?êvñ�ïOñ�öËí¾ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î�þ ��êvú�î¡ç ë&÷�ò�é í � óµíjï&ø�î �ë�îDè �>è&é�îDï&îÔêµë�è&é!î í�õÄõ�êvè&êvñ ç�í�ó>ì�ï&ñ�ü�óvî¡ô ñ�ö%í�ë&ë&êµô�êµóµíjè&êµç!øgè&é!î¡ë�î ölî¡íjè&÷�ï&î¡ëÚêµçZè�ñ íòDóµí�ë&ë&ê®û)òDíjè&êvñ ç<ë&ò\é!î¡ôKî�þ �Ôî�üfî¡óµêvîDú�î�è&é!î¡ë�îJöBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î�î��.è�ï�í�ò+è&êµñ ç�ôKîDè&é�ñ.õ�ë íjï&î�óµêzô�ùêvè�î¡õ�êzç�ë&ò+ñ�ìfî��füfî¡òDí�÷�ë�î�è�ñZñÚô%÷�ò�é êµç!öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ ç�êµëOõ�êµë&òDíjï�õ�î¡õcõ�÷!ï\êµç!ø2è&é!î�êµç�êµè&êµí�óì�ï&ñ?ò+î¡ë&ë&êµç!øKë�è&íjø�î¡ë¡þ

ÿ²÷!ïÚð�ñ�ï�< êµëÚôKñ�ï&î í�óµêµø ç!î¡õ ð êvè&é è&é!î ûÄï\ë�è<òDóµí�ë&ë¾ñ�ö�ôKîDè&é!ñ?õ�ëÚôKî¡çZè&êvñ ç!î¡õíjü)ñQú�î��>ôKîDè&é�ñ.õ�ë�è&é�íjè õ�î¡í�ó ð êµè&é�î¡ç/è&êµï&îcö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çÄë ��í�çÄõ ô2í <�î ÷�ë�îcñ�öJí�óµó�è&é!îí¡újí�êµóµíjüÄóvî%õ�íjè&í?þ � óµíjï&ø�î�ú�ñ óz÷�ôKî%ñ�ö�õ�íjè&í êzë ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï\õ!î¡õcöBñ�ïOî¡í�ò�é ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î�þOÿ²ç!îç!ñ�è�ñ ç�óµý�ø�îDè&ë%íÚï&îDì�ï�ñ.õ�÷ÄòDêvüÄóvî%ï&î¡ç�õ!îDï\êµç!ø � ë&é�íjìfî � ñ�öHî¡í�ò\é~ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î��üÄ÷!èJí�óµë�ñè&é!îcë�ìfîDî¡õsí�ç�õsì�ï&î¡ë&ë&÷�ï&î¾ð êvè&é ð é�êzò�é è&é!îDý ð�îDï&î<ì�ï&ñ?õ�÷�ò+î¡õ±þ�æ¨è2ë�ñ.ñ çsüfî¡òDí�ôKîíjì�ìÄíjï&î¡çZè<è&é�íjè<ð>êvè&é è&é!îgíjüÄ÷Äç�õ�í�ç�ò+îÔñ�ö�õ�íjè&í �Jð�îgç!îDî¡õ!î¡õ ísôKñ?õ!î¡ó²è�ñsüÄêµçÄõí�óµó è&é!îKêµç!öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ ç�è�ñ�ø�îDè&é!îDï¡þ ��é!î�ôKñ.õ�î¡ó ë�é!ñ ÷�óµõ ò+ñ ç!öBñ�ï�ô ð êvè&é è&é!î%ìÄé/ý?ë&êµòDí�óì�ï&ñ?ò+î¡ë&ëËè&éÄíjè�è&í <�î¡ëyì�óµí�ò+î ð é�î¡ç ë�ñ ô2îDñ ç!îOë�êvø ç�ëÃè&é!î¡êvïÃçÄí�ôKî��!í�ç�õ�è&é�îOêµçÄõ�êvú?êµõ�÷�í�óò+ñ ôKìfñ ç!î¡ç/è&ë>í�ç�õÚìÄíjï\í�ôKîDè�îDï�ë�ë&é�ñ ÷�óµõ¾üfî�í�òDò+î¡ë&ë&êvüÄóµî�í�ç�õÚ÷�ë�îDö�÷�óÎþ

ÿ²÷!ïyôKñ?õ!î¡óÄõ!ï\í¡ð ëÃñ ç�è6ð�ñ�ë&îDè&ëÃñ�ö±ô2îDè&é!ñ.õ�ñ óvñ�ø�ý�êµç�è&é!îOózêvè�îDï�íjè&÷!ï&î�þ���é�î�ûÄï�ë&èêµë�í�ø�î¡ç�îDï�í�óHç!ñ ç?ù6óµêzç!î¡íjï�ò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡óµíjè&êvñ ç�ôKîDè&é!ñ?õ òDí�óµóvî¡õ��Oý.çÄí�ô2êµò ��êµôKî�� íjï&ìÄêµç!ø� � � � � ð éÄêµò�é êµë>î��.è�î¡ç�ë�êvú�î¡óvýc÷�ë&î¡õ�êµç ë�ìfîDî¡ò�é ï�î¡ò+ñ�ø ç�êvè&êvñ çEþ ��é�î�ë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õÔêzë è&é!îíjï&î¡í2ñ�ö ø�îDñ ôKîDè�ï�êµò�ë&é�íjìfîJí�ç�í�óvý?ë&êµëDþ

(>í�çÄõ!ð�ï�êvè&êzç!ø���ô%÷�ò�éJózê1<�î�ë�ìfîDî¡ò�é �jêµëfè&êµô2î�õ!îDìfî¡ç�õ!î¡çZèDþ�� ñ è6ð�ñ>ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ëEð êzóµóé�í¡ú�î�î��?í�ò+è&óvý¾è&é!î�ë&í�ôKîJè&êµô�êµç!ø�ìÄíjè�è�îDï�ç ��í�ç�õÚè&é!î¡ë�î�è&êµô2êµç!øKõ�ê1))îDï&î¡çÄò+î¡ëHð êµóµófç!ñ�èü)î%óµêµç!î¡íjï�þ ��êµôKî�ð�íjï�ìÄêµç!ø�í�ózóvñ�ð ë>ñ ç!î%è�ñ¾ø�îDèOí ìfñ êµç/è#ù�è�ñjù�ìfñ êµçZè²ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+îü)îDè¨ðÃîDî¡ç è¨ðÃñ ë&êvø ç�í�ózë2ð é�êzò�é êzë2ï&î¡óµíjè&êµú�î¡óvý�êµç�ë�î¡ç�ë�êvè&êvú�îÚè�ñ ë&ô2í�óµó�õÄê*))îDï�î¡ç�ò+î¡ë�êµçè&é!î¡êvïKè&êµô2êzç!ø�ì�íjè�è�îDï�ç�ëDþ ÿ²÷!ï2ô2ñ.õ!î¡óH÷Äë�î¡ë�� ��� è�ñ~ô2íjè&ò�é è&é!î<ë�ìfîDî¡õ ë&êvø ç�í�óµëñ�öÃè¨ðÃñcë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë¡þ��Ôî2õ!ñÚç!ñ�è�üfî¡óµêvîDú�î��±é�ñ�ð�îDú�îDï �:è&é�íjè�� ��� ë&é!ñ ÷ÄóµõcüfîK÷�ë�î¡õè�ñ ò+ñ ô2ì)î¡çÄë&íjè�î öBñ�ï�ñ�è&é!îDï�ú_íjï\êµíjè&êvñ ç�ë�üfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç�ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë � ë&÷�ò\é í�ë �Ã÷�òDóµêµõ�î¡í�çë&é�íjìfîJè�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç�ë � þHæ#ç � (�� %$Sí�ç�õ � ��� $�� ��� ðyí�ë>÷Äë�î¡õcè�ñ�ô2íjè&ò�é è&é!î���� ���� � ò+ñjù�ñ�ï\õ�êµç�íjè�î¡ë:ñ�ö.è¨ðÃñ>ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ëDþ:æ#çJõ!ñ êµç�øyë&ñ�è&é!îDý²êµç/è�ï�ñ.õ�÷Äò+î¡õ�ç!ñ ç�óµêµç�î¡íjïõ�êµë�è�ñ�ï&è&êµñ ç�ëSêµç�è&é!îHè&êµô2î�õ!ñ ô2í�êµç�è�ñ�ò+ñ ô2ì)î¡çÄë&íjè�î�öBñ�ï�ï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç �.ë&òDí�óµêµç�øJí�ç�õKë&é!î¡íjïð é�êµò\é<íjï&î�ózêµç!î¡íjïHè�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç�ë�êµç<è&é!î � �� õ�ñ ô2í�êµçEþ ��é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õ<ë�êvø ç�í�ó �!ñ çè&é!îHñ�è&é!îDï�é�í�ç�õ � êµëÇî5))î¡ò+è&êµú�î¡óvý%êzç/újíjï�êµí�çZè ÷Äç�õ!îDïÇè&é!î¡ë�îHè�ï�í�çÄë�ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç�ëDþ �Ôî�õ!î¡í�óð êvè&é¾è&é!î�ë�é�íjìfîJí�ç�í�óvý?ë&êµëyë�îDìÄíjï�íjè�î¡óµý�þ

��é!î²ë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õ�íjï&î¡í%ð é�êµò\é�êµëËñ�ö±ï&î¡óvîDújí�ç�ò+îOè�ñ�è&éÄêµëËð�ñ�ï�<2êµë�ò+ñ ç�ò+îDï�ç�î¡õ ð>êvè&é2è&é!îí�ç�í�óvý?ë&êµëHñ�öÇø�îDñ ôKîDè�ï�êzò�ë&é�íjìfî¡ëDþ ��é!îDï&îJêµë í2újí�ë�è í�ôKñ ÷�çZè�ñ�öSóµêvè�îDï\íjè&÷!ï&îJêµç<õÄê*))îDï&ùî¡ç/è&êµí�ó±ø�îDñ ôKîDè�ï&ýÚí�ç�õÚò+ñ ôKìÄ÷�è�îDï�ú.êzë&êvñ ç�è&é�íjè�õ!î¡í�óµëyð>êvè&é¾è&é!î�ì�ï&ñ�ü�óvî¡ô2ë�ñ�ö ë�é�íjìfîë&êµô2êµózíjï�êvè&êvî¡ëÇ÷�ç�õ�îDïÃõ�ê*)fîDï&î¡çZè�è�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç�ë �/ë�÷�ò�é�í�ëËìÄï&ñ��#î¡ò+è&êµñ ç�ë �/ìfîDï�ë&ì)î¡ò+è&êµú�îí�ç�õÚí�� ç!î²è�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç�ëDþ0(>ñ�ð�îDú�îDï ��êµç�è&é!î�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&îOú�îDï�ê®û�òDíjè&êµñ çÚóµêvè�îDï�íjè&÷!ï�îè&é�êµëHì�ï�ñ�üÄóvî¡ôMé�í�ë�ï�î¡ò+î¡êvú�î¡õ<é�íjï�õÄóvý í�çZýÚíjè�è�î¡ç/è&êvñ ç � �,3 > $ � � � �� $ � þ

ÿ²÷!ï ô2ñ.õ!î¡ó±ï&îDì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&ë�î¡í�ò\écñ�öSë�îDú�îDï\í�ó±ï&î¡ç�õÄêvè&êvñ ç�ë�ñ�öSí�çcêµçÄõ�êvú?êµõ�÷�í�óµëÃë&êvø ç�í_ùè&÷!ï&î2ü.ý í<ë&êµç�ø óvîKè�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�î��Çè�ñ�ø�îDè&é!îDï�ð êµè&é í�çgêµçÄõ�êvú?êµõ�÷�í�óìÄíjï&èJè&éÄíjè�õ!î¡ë&ò+ï\êvüfî¡ë

.

Page 4: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

õ!îDú.êzíjè&êvñ ç�ë²öBï&ñ ô è&é!îKè�î¡ôKì�óµíjè�î�þ ��é!î¡ë&î2êµç�õ�êvú?êµõ�÷Äí�óEìÄíjï&è&ëJíjï�î2êµç è&÷!ï�çÔôKñ?õ!î¡óvî¡õ÷�ë&êµç!ø¾ë�ñ ôKî2çÄíjè&÷!ï�í�ó ï�÷�óvî¡ëOè&é�íjèJõ�î¡ë&ò+ï�êvüfî�é!ñ�ð�õ�ê1))îDï&î¡çZè²ú�îDï�ë&êvñ çÄë²ñ�öÃí¾ìfîDï�ë�ñ ç � ëë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¾ô�êvø é/èKüfî¾î��?ì)î¡ò+è�î¡õsè�ñgõ�ê*)fîDï �ËêÎþ î�þ�êµç�ë�ê��Dî��Ëñ�ï�êµî¡ç/è&íjè&êvñ ç í�ç�õ�ë&é!î¡íjï¡þ��é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õÔð>êvè&éÔð é�êzò�é è&é!î�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î2êµë�ï&î¡ç�õ�îDï&î¡õ êµëJícë�îDìÄíjï�íjüÄóµî2ìÄíjï&èJñ�öyè&é!îôKñ.õ�î¡ó��Zë�ñ%îDú�î¡ç�êvöEíJöBñ�ï&ø�îDï�òDí�ç¾ô2êzô2êµòyè&é!îOë&é�íjìfî�ñ�ö±é�êµëËú.êzò+è&êµô � ë�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î>ú�îDï&ýí�òDòD÷!ï�íjè�î¡óvý��Eêvè êzë�÷�ç�óµê <�î¡óvý�è&é�íjèOé!î�ð>êµóµóEé�í�ú�î�ô2í�ë�è�îDï�î¡õcè&é!î�ï&î¡óµíjè&êvú�î%ë�ìfîDî¡õÚð êvè&éð é�êµò\é¾è&é!î�óvîDè�è�îDï�ë>íjï&î�è�ï�í�ú�îDï�ë�î¡õEþ

( îDï�î öBñ óµóvñQð ë�í~üÄï&ñ í�õ ñ�ú�îDï&ú?êvîDð ñ�ö�í�ç í�óvø�ñ�ï�êµè&é�ô è�ñ�ûÄè�ñ ÷!ïÚôKñ?õ!î¡ó>è�ñ íë&í�ôKìÄóvî ñ�ö�ë&ê��Dî�� ñ�ö�í�ç êzç�õ�êvú?êµõ�÷�í�ó � ë2ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î¡ë � êµç ì�ï�í�ò+è&êµò+î���� � ë�îDî¡ô2ëï&î¡í�ë�ñ ç�íjüÄóµî � þ �Ôî�ûÄï\ë�è�ë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�è&é!î ����� � ìÄí�êvï�ë�íjø í�êµç�ë�è���� � %÷�ë�êµç!ø�í òD÷!üÄêzòë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç!øcë&ìÄóµêµç!î�ç!ñ�è�ë�ñ�ô�÷�ò\é è�ñ ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é ñ ÷!è�ï&ñ ÷!ø é í�ç!ñ ô�í�óµêvî¡ëJü�÷!è�ï�íjè&é!îDïè�ñgé�í¡ú�î í õ�ê*)fîDï&î¡çZè&êµíjüÄóvî+ù�ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ ç~ï�îDì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&íjè&êvñ ç�ñ�ö²è&é!î<î¡çZè&êvï&î<òD÷�ï&ú�î�þ �>î��.èðÃîÔí�óµêvø ç í�ç�õ ë�îDø ô2î¡ç/èÚî¡í�ò\é ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î êzç/è�ñ í ë�îDï�êvî¡ë�ñ�ö�ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êµç�ø~ë&÷!ü�ùòD÷!ï&ú�î¡ë�ñ�ï � � ��� �Xþ � é�êµëOêµë�í�ò�é�êµîDú�î¡õ êµç ë�îDú�îDï�í�ó�ë&è�îDìÄëDþ � êµï�ë�èOè&é!î2ë�ìfîDî¡õ ë&êvø ç�í�óµëñ�öSè&é!î�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë�íjï�î ��� � ���� � �� ��íjø í�êµç�ë�èOí2ï&îDöBîDï&î¡ç�ò+î�òD÷!ï&ú�î�þ ��é!î�ìÄíjï&è&êµòD÷�ózíjïë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î � í�ç�õgêµè&ëJí�ë&ë�ñ?òDêµíjè�î¡õ�ë�ìfîDî¡õ ë&êvø ç�í�ó � è&é�íjè�êµë�ò�é!ñ ë�î¡ç�í�ë�í<ï&îDölîDï�î¡ç�ò+î êµëë�ñ ôKîDð é�íjè<íjï�üÄêvè�ï�íjï&ý���ð�î ò�é!ñ.ñ ë�îÔè&é!î �#üfî¡ë�è¾üfî¡é�í¡ú�î¡õ ��êµç í�ë�î¡ç�ë�îÔõ!î¡ë&ò+ï\êvüfî¡õü)î¡óµñ�ðJþ ��éÄêµëOè&êµôKîKðyíjï&ìÄêµç!ø¾î¡ë�è&íjü�óµêµë&é!î¡ë�ícò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+î%üfîDè¨ðÃîDî¡çgì)ñ êzç/è&ë²ñ çè&é!î�ï&îDölîDï�î¡ç�ò+î2ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î%í�çÄõ�î¡í�ò\éÔñ�öËè&é�î%ñ�è&é�îDï�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î¡ëDþ ��é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õ ë&êvø ç�í�óñ�öËè&é!î%ï&îDöBîDï&î¡ç�ò+î�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î%êµë>è&é!î¡ç ÷�ë�î¡õ�è�ñÚë�îDø ôKî¡çZè�êvèOêzç/è�ñ¾õ�êµë�è&êzç�ò+è�ìÄêvî¡ò+î¡ëOñ�ï�� � ��������í�ç�õ~÷�ë&êµç!øÚè&é�î ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë&ì)ñ çÄõ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ë�è&é!î�ñ�è&é!îDï�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ë�íjï�î ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè�î¡õí�òDò+ñ�ï�õ�êµç!ø óµý�þ ��é!î�è�î¡ôKì�óµíjè�î�êµëHò+ñ ôKì�÷!è�î¡õ<íjè è&é�îJóvîDè�è�îDï>óvîDú�î¡ó &�ölñ�ï î¡í�ò�écë&îDè�ñ�ö��óvîDè�è�îDï�ë ��í�çÚí�ú�îDï�íjø�î�ë&é�íjìfî�êµë�î¡ë�è&êµô�íjè�î¡õÚ÷!ì¾è�ñ2í�ç�í���ç!î²è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ ç �.ð>é�êµò�éí�óµóvñ�ð>ë¾ölñ�ï<õ�ê1))îDï&î¡çÄò+î¡ëÚêµç óvñ.òDíjè&êµñ ç �Oë�òDí�óµêµç!ø��>ñ�ï�êvî¡çZè&íjè&êvñ ç �²í�ç�õ�ë&é!î¡íjï¡þ ��é!î¡ë�îè�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�î�óµîDè�è�îDï�ë íjï&î�ø óz÷!î¡õÚè�ñ�ø�îDè&é!îDïOè�ñ2öBñ�ï�ôÙè&é!î�è�î¡ôKì�óµíjè�î�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�þ

� é�î¡ç í¾ç!îDð ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�íjï�ï�êvú�î¡ëOölñ�ï²ú�îDï�êvû�òDíjè&êvñ ç �fêvè²ç!îDî¡õ�ë>ñ ç�óvýÚè�ñ¾üfî�ò+ñ ô�ùìÄíjï&î¡õ�è�ñÔè&é!î�è�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�îÚë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�þ ��é!î¾ë&í�ôKîÚë�îDè�ñ�ö>è�î¡ò�é�ç�ê �Z÷!î¡ë�íjï&îÚ÷�ë&î¡õgè�ñú_í�óµêzõ�íjè�î�í ç!îDð ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î%í�ë>íjï&î%÷�ë�î¡õcè�ñ�ûÄè>è&é!î�ô2ñ.õ!î¡ó±è�ñ è&é!î�è�ï�í�êµç�êzç!ø2ë&êvø ç�í_ùè&÷!ï&î¡ë�&

' êvè&ëHë&ì)îDî¡õcë&êvø ç�í�óEêµëyè&êzôKî+ù�ð�íjï�ì)î¡õcíjø í�êµç�ë�è�è&é�î�ï&îDölîDï�î¡ç�ò+î�

' êvè�êzëHë�îDø ôKî¡çZè�î¡õcêµçZè�ñ�óvîDè�è�îDï�ë��

' î¡í�ò\é�óµîDè�è�îDïyêzëÃí�� ç�î¡óvý�è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ôKî¡õ è�ñ%ô�íjè&ò�é¾è&é!îOè�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�îOóvîDè�è�îDïHí�ë�ðÃî¡óµóí�ëHìfñ ë&ë�êvüÄóvî�þ

�Ëý.ìÄêµòDí�óµóµýsí~öBñ�ï&ø�îDï<òDí�ç üfî êµõ!î¡çZè&ê®ûÄî¡õ íjè�è&é�î è&êzôKî+ù�ð�íjï�ìÄêµç!ø ë�è&íjø�î���í�óvè&é!ñ ÷!ø éè&é!îJõ!îDú?êµíjè&êvñ ç�ëyè&é�íjè>í�òDòD÷�ô�÷Äóµíjè�îJíjè�î¡í�ò�écñ�öè&é�îJë�è�îDìÄëHñ ÷!è&ózêµç!î¡õ¾íjüfñ�ú�îJì�ï�ñ.õ�÷Äò+îñ�ú�îDï&ð é�î¡óµô2êµç!ø>îDú.êzõ!î¡ç�ò+îyíjø í�êµç�ë�èÇí�÷!è&é!î¡çZè&êµòDêvè¨ý�þ �Çêvø ÷!ï�î � ë&é!ñQð ë:è&é�ï&îDî�ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë

/

Page 5: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

Euclidean Distance: 158.337

Euclidean Distance: 154.0287

Euclidean Distance: 515.7095

� êµø ÷!ï&î � &���� ����� ����� ����� ����� �� � � ��� �� �� �� � ��� ������ �������� � � �� � �� ����� � 3?÷!ï�î¡ë&é �²ñ�ý í�ó � ë ����� ����� ��! "� ����� ���#� � �$�� �&%�� � � ��� ��� ���� ��������� ����������� ')(�� � �*� �+%�� -, �/.�� � � ��� ��0��� ��� � � �1� ��� *%��� � � � ��2%*� � � �������435 �� �� � � � � ������� �� �&%��6% � � 7�8��� � � �-� ��� � ���#� � � ������ � � �9��%�� ��� � � ���� ��� � � � �:�&������ 7�

Page 6: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

ñ�ö�è&é!î�çÄí�ôKî � ��� � ����� � �Eè&é!î�ózí�ë�è>ñ�öSð>é�êµò�é�êµëOí2öBñ�ï&ø�îDï&ý�þ 3?÷!ìfîDï�êµôKìfñ ë�î¡õ�ñ çî¡í�ò�écêzëÃè&é�îOè�î¡ô2ìÄóµíjè�î�õ!îDï�êvú�î¡õ�öBï&ñ ô "� �*��� ����è�ï\í�êµç�êµç!ø�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ëDþ���é!îDï�î²êzë�íòDóvî¡íjï>ô2êzë&ô2íjè&ò�écêµç¾è&é!îJòDí�ë�î�ñ�öè&é!î�ölñ�ï&ø�îDï�ý�þ

��é�êµë%ìÄíjìfîDïKêµë%ñ�ï&ø í�ç�ê �Dî¡õ�í�ëKölñ ózóvñ�ð ë¡þ 3.î¡ò+è&êvñ ç > õ!î¡ë&ò+ï\êvüfî¡ë�ñ ÷�ï�ë&è�ñ.ò\é�í�ë�è&êµòë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�îJôKñ.õ�î¡ó �!í�ç�õ3.î¡ò+è&êvñ ç.Kø êvú�î¡ë�íKë�è�îDì<ü.ý¾ë�è�îDìcõ!î¡ë&ò+ï\êvì�è&êvñ ç�ñ�öÇñ ÷!ï�í�óvø�ñjùï�êvè&é�ô öBñ�ïÇûÄè�è&êµç!ø²è&é!î>ôKñ.õ�î¡óÎþ �Ôî õ�î¡óµêvüfîDï�íjè�î¡óvý�í�ú�ñ êµõKî��!ò+î¡ë&ë&êvú�î è�î¡ò�é�ç�êzòDí�ó�õ!îDè&í�êµóµëêµç è&é�êµë²ë�î¡ò+è&êvñ ç �:ð êvè&é è&é!î2é�ñ�ì)î�è&é�íjè�êvè²ï&î¡í�õ�ë²î¡í�ë&êµóµý�þ 3?î¡ò+è&êvñ ç /<ø êvú�î¡ëJë&ñ ôKîKñ�öè&é!î�è�î¡ò�é�çÄêµòDí�óEõ!îDè&í�êµóµëyí�ç�õ �&÷�ë�è&êvû�òDíjè&êvñ ç�ë�ñ ô2êvè�è�î¡õÚêzç�ë&î¡ò+è&êvñ ç..þ ��é�îOôKñ?õ!î¡óEí�ç�õûÄè�è&êµç!øKì�ï�ñ.ò+î¡ë&ë íjï&î�êµóµóz÷�ë�è�ï�íjè�î¡õ¾÷�ë&êzç!ø�î��?í�ôKì�óvî¡ëHè&é!ï&ñ ÷�ø é!ñ ÷!èHè&é!î�ìÄíjìfîDï¡þ

�Ôî õ!ñJç!ñ�èSìÄï&ñ�ú?êµõ!î�î��.è�î¡çÄë&êvú�îHè�î¡ë�è�ï�î¡ë&÷�óvè&ëÇêµç%è&é�êµëÇì�íjì)îDï�þSÿ²÷�ï î��?ìfîDï�êvî¡ç�ò+îHë�ñöBíjï éÄí�ëHüfîDî¡ç<óµêµô2êµè�î¡õ è�ñ íjü)ñ ÷�è ��� ë&í�ôKìÄóµî¡ëyî¡í�ò�é�ölï&ñ ô > � ò+ñ óµóvî¡íjø ÷!î¡ë �Äð é!ñ2í�óµë�ñì�ï&ñ�ú?êµõ!î¡õ è&é!îKöBñ�ï&ø�îDï�êµî¡ë²ölñ�ïJî¡í�ò\éÔñ�è&é!îDï�ë��±ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ëDþ �Oóvè&é!ñ ÷!ø é è&é�î¡ë�îKì�ï&î¡óµêzô2ê®ùç�íjï&ý�ï�î¡ë&÷�óvè&ëHíjì�ìfî¡íjïHì�ï�ñ ô2êµë&êµç�ø��/ð�î�íjï&îJí�òDòD÷�ô%÷�óµíjè&êµç�ø�íKô%÷�ò\é<ôKñ�ï&î²î��?è�î¡ç�ë&êvú�îõ�íjè&íKüÄí�ë�î�è�ñ2î��.îDï\òDêµë�î�í�ç�õÚòDí�ózêvü�ï�íjè�î�ñ ÷!ï>ôKñ.õ�î¡óÎþ

� ��ß��Hß±å��ß±å\ä���� á�â������é!î�è6ð�ñjù6õ�êµôKî¡çÄë&êvñ ç�í�óSêµô�íjø�îKñ�ö�íÚë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�ô2í¡ý üfî�ï&îDø íjï�õ!î¡õÔí�ë�í¾ìÄêvî¡ò+îDð êµë&îò+ñ ç/è&êµç.÷!ñ ÷�ë í�ç�õ<óvñ?òDí�óµóvý�ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&éÚìÄíjè&é �Äê�þ î�þ�íKú�î¡ò+è�ñ�ï>ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ ç

� ��� � ����� ��� �� ��� ���ìÄíjï�í�ôKîDè�ï�ê �Dî¡õÔüZý ë�ñ ôKî2ë�òDí�óµíjïJìÄíjï�í�ô2îDè�îDï � þ �Oóvè&é!ñ ÷!ø é è&é!î2ò\é!ñ êµò+î2ñ�ö�è&é!îKìÄí_ùï�í�ôKîDè�îDïKêµëJíjï&ü�êvè�ï�íjï&ý�� ðÃî�è6ý.ìÄêµòDí�ózóvý êzõ!î¡ç/è&êµölý êvè�ð>êvè&éÔè&êµôKî#&%è&é!î è&êµôKî�è&í <�î¡ç í�ëè&é!îcë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î<êµëKè�ï\í�ò+î¡õsñ ÷!èDþ 3?êµç�ò+î¾è&é!îcè&êµô2êµç!øÔêµë�óµê1<�î¡óvý~è�ñgüfî<õ�ê*)fîDï&î¡çZèKölñ�ïè6ð�ñcõ�ê*)fîDï&î¡çZèOï�î¡ç�õ!îDï�êµç�ø ë>ñ�öÃî��?í�ò+è&óµý è&é�î�ë�í�ôKî2ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î��±êvè�êµë�÷�ë�îDö�÷�ó êµçÔë�ñ ôKîî��.ì�ï�î¡ë&ë&êvñ ç�ëÃè�ñ�÷�ë�îOè&é!î � � � �ìÄíjï�í�ô2îDè�ï�ê��¡íjè&êvñ ç è&é!ï&ñ ÷!ø é�ñ ÷!è��?ölñ�ïyè&é!î¡ë�îOìÄ÷!ï�ì)ñ ë&î¡ëðÃîJï�îDø íjï�õ � í�ë�í �# ��, ������� � � � � ���\þ

3?÷�òDò+î¡ë&ë�êvú�î>ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëSü.ý�è&é!î>ë�í�ôKî ð�ï\êvè�îDïËíjï&î ç�ñ�èÃêµõ!î¡çZè&êµòDí�ó!ü�÷!èSð êµóµó!õÄê*))îDï �ü)ñ�è&é ø óvñ�üÄí�óµóµý~í�ç�õ óvñ.òDí�ózóvý���êzçsóvñ?òDíjè&êvñ ç �yë&òDí�óvî�í�çÄõ�ñ�ï�êvî¡çZè&íjè&êvñ çEþ � ìÄóµí�÷�ë&êµüÄóvîôKñ.õ�î¡óEölñ�ï è&é�êµëyì�ï&ñ?ò+î¡ë&ë�êzë

� ��� � ��� ��� � ' ��� ���! ��� ���!"9��� � � ��# � #��%$ � � �

ð é!îDï&î&� ��' � í�ç�õ " íjï&î�î¡í�ò�é > ù�ú�î¡ò+è�ñ�ï�ë �Äð>é!ñ ë�î�î¡óvî¡ôKî¡çZè&ëHíjï&î�ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çÄëÃñ�ö � þ3?÷�ò�é ú�î¡ò+è�ñ�ï�öB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë�íjï&î <?ç!ñQð çÔí�ë�ìÄíjï�í�ô2îDè�ï�ê��Dî¡õÔòD÷!ï&ú�î¡ë¡þ 3!êµô2êµóµíjï\óvý'� êµë�í>�( > í�� ç�î>è�ï�í�çÄë�ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç�ô�íjè�ï�ê��2ð é!ñ ë&î î¡óvî¡ôKî¡çZè&ëyíjï&îOöB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç�ë�ñ�ö � þ���é!î¡ë�îò+ñ ôKìfñ ç!î¡ç/è&ë>é�í¡ú�î�è&é!îJöBñ óµóvñ�ð>êµç!øKêµçZè�îDï&ì�ï&îDè&íjè&êvñ ç &

)

Page 7: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

' è&é!î�û��?î¡õ�ç!ñ ç!ù�ï�í�ç�õ!ñ ô öB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç6' ��� � ô2í�ý<üfî�ï&îDø íjï�õ�î¡õ�í�ëOè&é!î�êµõ!î¡í�óµê �Dî¡õè�î¡ôKì�óµíjè�î�ñ�ï ��ôKî¡í�ç �2ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î�ölñ�ï è&é!î�ð�ï�êvè�îDï>êµç �Z÷�î¡ë�è&êvñ çEþ

' è&é!îËöB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç�ë � ��� � í�ç�õ ;��� � ú_íjï�ý²ô2ñ�ï&îËë&óvñQð óvý>è&é�í�ç ' ��� � í�ç�õ�íjï&îÃë�è�ñ.ò\é�í�ë#ùè&êµò�êzçÚç�íjè&÷!ï&î�þ

' " ��� � êµë�í�ë�è�ñ.ò\é�í�ë�è&êµò�ú�î¡ò+è�ñ�ï�ñ�öEõ!îDì�íjï&è&÷!ï&î¡ëÇöBï&ñ ô�è&é�î ôKñ?õ!î¡ó�� ð�î�î��?ì)î¡ò+è�� " �è�ñ2üfî�ô%÷�ò�é�ë&ô2í�óµóvîDïHè&éÄí�ç��*'�� ��ð é�îDï&î�� � �>êµëyè&é�î �Ë÷�òDózêµõ!î¡í�ç¾ç!ñ�ï�ôÚþ

�cñ?õ!î¡ó � � � õ�î¡ë&ò+ï�êvüfî¡ëSè&é!î � � � �²ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î��Zí�ëÃðÃîOô2êvø éZèÃë�îDîOêvè�ñ ç�íJìÄêvî¡ò+îñ�ö:ìÄíjìfîDï �.í�ç�õ¾õ!ñZî¡ëyç!ñ�èyé�í�ú�î²í�çZý êzç!ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç�íjüfñ ÷!è � � �Ôêvè�ðyí�ë�ë�êvø ç!î¡õEþ �>î��.èðÃî õ!î¡ë�ò+ï�êvüfîcè&é!îÔõ!ý?ç�í�ô2êzò�í�ë�ìfî¡ò+è¾ñ�ö�ñ ÷�ï<ôKñ.õ�î¡ó���í�ç�í�ë�ìfî¡ò+èÚè&é�íjè¾è�ï�í�õ�êvè&êvñ ç!ùí�óµóvý�é�í�ë�ç!ñ�è�üfîDî¡ç í ð�ñ�ï&ï&ý�è�ñ�ölñ�ï&ø�îDï\ëDþ æ#çsì�ï�í�ò+è&êzò+î���ðÃî õ!ñgç�ñ�è ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï\õ è&é!îë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î � ��� � í�ë%í öB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç ñ�ö � þcæ#ç�ë�è�î¡í�õ �Sñ ÷�ï%õ�íjè&í ò+ñ ç�ë�êµë�è&ë�ñ�ö� ìfñ êµç/è&ë�� � � � þDþDþ � ��gñ�ö?è&é!îËë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�ë&í�ôKì�óvî¡õ�íjè:õ�êµë�ò+ï&îDè�îSè&êµôKî�ìfñ êµçZè&ë���� � �� � þDþDþ � ���� ÷�ë&÷�í�óµóµý�î��.÷�ê®ù6ë�ìÄí�ò+î¡õ � �!ð é!îDï&î

�� � � ��� � � � � � � > � þDþDþ � �� � ��� � � � $ � ��� �� � ��� � ��� � $ ' ��� � ��� � $ �! ��� � ��� � $ � " ��� � ��� � $ ��� � � > �

( îDï&î��Ãè&é!î¾ôKñ ç!ñ�è�ñ ç!îÚö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�� � � � õ!î+û�ç!î¡ë%è&é!î¾è�ï�í�çÄë�ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç �0<?ç!ñ�ð>ç�í�ëKí��� � �� � � ����!ç!îDî¡õ!î¡õ�è�ñ�ò+ñ çZú�îDï&èÃöBï&ñ ô è&é!î�è&êµôKî ìÄíjï�í�ôKîDè�ï�ê �¡íjè&êvñ ç2ñ�öEè&é!î ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�è�ñ�÷�ç�êvè&ëyñ�öÇè&é!îJ÷Äç�êvú�îDï�ë&í�ófì�íjï�í�ôKîDè�îDï � þ ��é�êzëyè&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ì<ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çÚêµëï&î¡óµíjè�î¡õ�è�ñ�è&é�îOë�ìfîDî¡õ íjèÃð éÄêµò�é è&é!î>ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&îOêµë�ð ï�êvè�è�î¡ç �?í�ëyë&÷�ò�é�êvèÃð êµóµó�ò\é�í�ç!ø�îölï&ñ ô ñ ç�îKï&î¡ç�õ�êvè&êµñ çcè�ñÚè&é!îKç!î��?è �:í�ç�õÔë�é!ñ ÷�óµõ í�óµë�ñÚüfî%ï&îDø íjï�õ!î¡õÔí�ëJë&è�ñ.ò\é�í�ë�è&êµòjþ� êzç�í�óµóvý��!è&é!î � � � ë>õ!î¡ç!ñ�è�î�è&é�îJîDï&ï&ñ�ï�ë>êµç<ôKî¡í�ë�÷!ï�êµç!ø�è&é!î%ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&îJíjè è&êµô2î¡ë�� � �"! þæ7ç�ñ�ï�õ�îDïSè�ñJë�ìÄíjï&îyè&é!îHï&î¡í�õ�îDïSölï&ñ ô ��éÄêµë�#_é!îDï �²ò+ñ çZè�ñ�ï&è&êvñ ç�ë �/ð�îyé�îDï&î¡íjölè�îDïÃí�ë&ë&÷�ôKîè&é�íjè�ñ ÷!ï�ø�î¡ç�îDï�êµò²ð�ï�êµè�îDï êµëHô2í�óvî�þ

��é!î ç�ñ ç?ù�ï�í�ç�õ!ñ ô è�î¡ô2ìÄóµíjè�î�ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç ' ��� � ò�éÄíjï�í�ò+è�îDï�ê��Dî¡ëÃè&é!î êµçZè�ï�êµçÄë&êµò �*� ����ñ�ö è&é!î¾ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î���êµçZú�ñ óvú.êzç!øcüfñ�è&é�è&é!î¾ë�ìfî¡óµóµêµç!øÚñ�ö>è&é!î�ð�ï�êvè�îDï�� ë%ç�í�ôKîÚí�ç�õ�é�êµëë�è6ý?óvî�ñ�öyð�ï\êvè&êµç!ø � î�þ ø!þ<òD÷!ï\óvý�ú�îDï\ë&÷�ë�ë&è�ï�í�êvø éZè�òDíjìÄêvè&í�óÃóvîDè�è�îDï�ë �SòD÷!ï�óµý�ñ�ï%ò+ï&ñ ë&ë�î¡õ� � ë �ÃîDè&òjþ � þ ��é!îÚï�í�çÄõ!ñ ô ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë$� ��� � � � ��� � í�ç�õ ��� � ò�éÄíjï�í�ò+è�îDï�ê��Dî � � � é!îð�ï�êvè�î¡ë�éÄêµëHë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î���í�ç�õÚé!ñQð êvè�ò\é�í�ç!ø�î¡ë�öBï&ñ ôÙñ ç�îJñ.òDòDí�ë�êvñ çÚè�ñ2è&é!î�ç!î��.è�&

' ï&î¡ózíjè&êvú�îcè�ñ�ë�ñ ôKî�û��?î¡õ í �!êµë ñ ç í�ç î¡óvî¡ò+è�ï�ñ ç�êµò�ìÄí�õ ��é!î ð êµóµó ë�è&íjï&è¾íjè¾íõ�ê1))îDï&î¡çZè2ìfñ êµçZè2î¡í�ò�é è&êµô2î���í�ç�õ íjè�ígì�íjï&è&êµòD÷�óµíjï í�ç!ø óvî�þ���é�îcôKñ?õ!î¡ó êµëêµçZújíjï�êµí�çZèO÷�çÄõ!îDï�ë&÷�ò�é ï\êvø êµõ üfñ.õ!ýcè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ çÄë �fð é�êµò\éÔíjï&îKòDíjì�è&÷!ï&î¡õêµç¾è&é�î�è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ çÄë � í�ç�õ þ

Page 8: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

' é�êzë>ð ï�êvè&êµç!ø¾ë�ìfîDî¡õ ð êµózó ò\é�í�ç!ø�î2öBï&ñ ô ñ ç!î ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î%è�ñcè&é!î2ç!î��?è �:í�ëJð êzóµóêvè&ë�ò+ñ çÄë&êµë�è�î¡ç�ò+ý ñ�ú�îDï%õ�ê*)fîDï&î¡çZè�ï&îDø êvñ ç�ë²ñ�öyè&é!î2ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�è&é!îKöB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç �ï&î � î¡ò+è&ëHè&é!î¡ë�î�ë&ì)îDî¡õ<ú_íjï�êzíjè&êvñ ç�ë

' é!îJô�êvø é/è�ë�êvø çÚë&óµêvø éZè&óvý üÄêvø�ø�îDï�ñ�ï ë�ô2í�óµóvîDïHñ ç<õÄê*))îDï�î¡ç/èHñ?òDòDí�ë&êvñ ç�ë �Äí�ç�õ

' ð é�î¡ç�é!îKë&êµø ç�ëOöBí�ë�è�îDï �Eè&é!îKóvîDè�è�îDï�ë�ô2í�ý�ë&óµí�çZè�ôKñ�ï&î � êµç ô2íjè�ï�ê���óµí�ç!ø ÷�íjø�îè&é�êzëHêµë <.ç�ñ�ð ç<í�ë>ë&é!î¡íjï �

��é!îJóµí�ë�èHè¨ðÃñ êvè�î¡ô2ëHíjï&î�í�ózë�ñ2òDíjì�è&÷!ï&î¡õ¾ü.ý�è&é!îJí�� ç!î�è�ï�í�çÄë�ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç¾ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë� ��� � í�ç�õ ��� � ��ð é�êµò\é í�óµóvñ�ð è&é!î¡ë�î õ!îDöBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ çÄë¾è�ñsú_íjï�ý ë&óµñ�ð óvý í�óvñ ç!ø�è&é!îë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�þ

� ì�íjï&èHölï�ñ ôMì�ï&ñ�ú?êµõ�êzç!ø�è&é!î�ôKî¡ò\é�í�ç�êµë�ôMölñ�ï�õ!îDöBñ�ï�ô2êzç!ø�è&é�î�è�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�î ' �!è&é!îöB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç�ë � ��� � í�ç�õ � ��� � ÷�ë�îDö�÷�óµóµý�öBñ.òD÷�ëËè&é!î>õ�îDú.êµíjè&êµñ ç�ëSüfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç�î¡í�ò\é¾ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�îí�ç�õKè&é!î�è�î¡ô2ìÄóµíjè�î�þ0�!ñ�ï�î��?í�ôKì�óvî��/íJë&í�ô2ìÄóvîHñ�ö)ï&î¡í�óµê��¡íjè&êvñ çÄëSñ�ö�è&é�î�è&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç�øöB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç�ë ���OöBñ�ï � õ�ê1))îDï&î¡çZèyë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ë�ô�êvø é/èyî��!é�êvüÄêµèÃôKñ�ï&îOújíjï�êµíjè&êvñ ç¾êµç¾ë�ñ ôKîï&îDø êvñ ç�ë¾ñ�ö%è&é!î ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î è&é�í�ç�êµç ñ�è&é!îDï�ë¡þ 3?êzô2êµóµíjï�óµý��Hè&é!îÔú_íjï\êµíjè&êvñ ç�ëÚêµç è&é!îè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ çÄë&� � ��� � òDí�ç üfî%ò\é�íjï�í�ò+è�îDï�ê �Dî¡õ �±í�ç�õ�ü�ï&ñ#<�î¡ç õ!ñ�ð>ç�îDú�î¡ç ö�÷!ï&è&é!îDïè�ñ ìÄ÷�ï&îJë&òDí�óvî%ò�é�í�ç!ø�î¡ë ��ï&ñ�è&íjè&êµñ ç�ë>í�çÄõcë&é!î¡íjï�þ � é!î¡ë�î�ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ ç�ë�í�ç�õ<.ç!ñQð óvî¡õ!ø�îñ�ö:è&é!î¡êvï�è&é!î¡êvï�è6ý.ìÄêµòDí�ó)üfî¡é�í�ú.êvñ�ïHòDí�ç�üfîO÷Äë�î¡õ�è�ñKõ!îDè�î¡ò+èHöBñ�ï&ø�î¡õÚë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë �?ë&êµçÄò+îölñ�ï&ø�îDï\ëíjï&î�÷�ë&÷�í�ózóvý>÷�çÄíjüÄóvîSè�ñ ï�îDì�ï&ñ?õ�÷�ò+îSè&é!î¡ë�î�õ!ý?ç�í�ô2êµòSöBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë:ñ�ö!è&é!îËø�î¡ç.÷�êµç�îë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�þ

ÿ²÷!ï�õ�íjè&í_ù�üÄí�ë�î¾öBñ�ïKí�ç/ý ø êµú�î¡ç~ð ï�êvè�îDï�êzë�üÄí�ë&î¡õ~ñ ç � ë&ì)î¡òDêzôKî¡ç~ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë� � � �� � � � ��� ��� ü.ý è&éÄíjè�ð�ï�êvè�îDï �!ð é!îDï&î� � ��� � � � � ��� � ' ��� ��� � ��� � �!" � ��� � � . �

��# � #�� ��� � � � > � þDþDþ � ���é!îDï&î�êµëfñ ç�î�è�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�î ' ��� � öBñ�ï:í�óµó�ë�ìfî¡òDêµôKî¡ç�ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëfü.ýOè&é�íjè±ð�ï�êµè�îDï �¡ð é!îDï�î¡í�ëè&é!î � � � ë � � � ë%í�ç�õ " � � ë�íjï&î�í�ë&ë&÷�ô2î¡õ è�ñcüfî�êzç�õ!îDìfî¡ç�õ!î¡çZè�ï&î¡í�óµê��¡íjè&êµñ ç�ëJñ�öHè&é!îò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êzç!ø�ï�í�ç�õ!ñ ôMö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çÄëDþ

ÿ²ç�ò+î�íjø í�êzç ��ð�î�õ!ñ2ç!ñ�è�ñ�ü�ë�îDï&ú�îJè&é!î�öB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç�ë�� � ��� � õÄêvï&î¡ò+è&óvý�þ�æ#ç�ë�è�î¡í�õ ��ðÃîñ�üÄë�îDï&ú�î¾è&é!î � ù�è&é�ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î � � ��� � íjè � � õ�êµë&ò+ï&îDè�î�è&êµôKî�ìfñ êµçZè&ë � � � � ! �Ãê�þ î�þ���ðÃîñ�üÄë�îDï&ú�î

� � � � � � � � � � � � �=� ��� � � � / �� � � � > � þDþDþ � � � ��� � � � > � þDþDþ � �

ð é!îDï&îJöBñ�ï � � � � > � þDþDþ � ����è&é!î�ôKñ ç!ñ�è�ñ ç�î�ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë�� ��� ��� � ! ò+ñ çZú�îDï&è>è&é�îJè&êµôKî¡ë� � � è�ñ�î��Z÷�êµú_í�óvî¡çZèHújí�óµ÷!î¡ëHñ�ö è&é!î�÷�çÄêvú�îDï�ë&í�ó)ìÄíjï�í�ô2îDè�îDï � þ

Page 9: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

��é!îcô2ñ.õ!î¡óyìÄï&ñ�ìfñ ë�î¡õsêµëKú�îDï�ý�ø�î¡ç�îDï�í�ó�� è�ñ.ñgø�î¡ç!îDï\í�ó êµç ö�í�ò+è�è�ñ~ü)î<÷Äë�îDöB÷Äóð êvè&é!ñ ÷!èOë�ñ ôKîKí�õ�õ�êµè&êvñ ç�í�ó±ï�î¡ë�è�ï�êµò+è&êvñ çÄëDþ���é�î�óvñ?òDíjè&êvñ ç öB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë � �Eêvö�í�óµóvñQðÃî¡õè�ñ újíjï&ý<êµç�í�ç�íjï&ü�êvè�ï�íjï&ý�öBí�ë�é�êvñ ç ��ðÃñ ÷�ózõÚüfî�ë&÷ ��òDêvî¡ç/è è�ñ�ôKñ?õ!î¡óí�ç/ýÚø êvú�î¡ç ë&êvøjùç�íjè&÷!ï&î��Çí�ç�õ è&é�îDï&îDölñ�ï�î í�çZý õ!îDú.êzíjè&êvñ ç öBï&ñ ô è&é�î2è�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�î '�þ ��é!î2ï�î¡ë�è�ï�êµò+è&êvñ çè&é�íjè�ñ?òDòD÷!ï�ë%ç�íjè&÷!ï�í�ózóvý�êµçgñ ÷!ï�ô2îDè&é!ñ.õgñ�öyî¡ë�è&êµô2íjè&êvñ ç�êµë�è�ñ í�ë&ë&÷�ô2î�è&é�íjè�ü)ñ�è&é� � ��� � í�ç�õ � ��� � íjï&îOìÄêvî¡ò+îDð êµë&î>ò+ñ ç�ë�è&í�çZèyñ�ú�îDï�ë�îDø ô2î¡ç/è&ëyñ�öEè&é!î²ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�þ0�!ñ�ïò+ñ ç/ú�î¡ç�êµî¡ç�ò+î¾ðÃî¾ð êµózóSï&îDöBîDï�è�ñ è&é!î¡ë�î¾ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&ëKí�ë �� � �������Ëí�óµè&é!ñ ÷!ø é~è&é!îDýgô2í�ýî¡ç�ò+ñ ôKìÄí�ë&ë�ô2ñ�ï&î�ñ�ï�óvî¡ë�ë>è&éÄí�ç í�ë&êµç�ø óvî�óvîDè�è�îDï�ñ�öËè&é!îKí�óvìÄé�íjüfîDèDþOæ7ç�ï&îDè�ï&ñ ë�ìfî¡ò+è �è&é�êµë�ìÄêvî¡ò+îDð>êµë�î+ù6ò+ñ ç�ë�è&í�çZè2ï&î¡ë&è�ï�êµò+è&êvñ ç�ë�îDî¡ô�ë�ç�íjè&÷!ï\í�óyölï&ñ ô í ìÄé/ý?ë&êµòDí�óyìfñ êµçZè�ñ�öú.êvîDð í�ëyð�î¡óµóÎþ���é�îOì�é/ý?ë&êµòDí�ó)í�ò+è&êvñ çÚñ�ö ë�ðÃîDîDì�êµç!ø�ñ ÷!èHí�ë&êµç!ø óvî²óvîDè�è�îDï ��ë�÷�ò�éÚí�ëHí�ç� �!êµë�üÄí�óµózêµë�è&êµò�êzç�çÄíjè&÷!ï&î²í�ç�õ¾êµëyóµê1<�î¡óvýKè�ñKüfî²ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&éEþ ��é!î²ë&ê��Dî��?ñ�ï�êvî¡çZè&íjè&êvñ çÚí�ç�õë&óµí�çZè�ô2í¡ý�õ�ê*)fîDïSë&óµêvø éZè&óvý�íjèSî¡í�ò\é2íjè�è�î¡ôKì�è �.üÄ÷!è è&é!î�ò+ñ ç�ò+îDì�èSñ�öfíOû��?î¡õ�è�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�îë�îDî¡ô2ë�ì�óµí�÷�ë&êvü�óvî�þ ��é�î�ò�é�í�ç!ø�î+ù�ìfñ êµçZè&ë�üfîDè¨ðÃîDî¡ç�óvîDè�è�îDï�ë �Zñ ç2è&é!î ñ�è&é!îDïÃé�í�çÄõ �/ô2í�ýî��?é�êµüÄêvèHë�ñ ôKî�õÄêµë&ò+ñ çZè&êµçZ÷Äêvè&êvî¡ëDþ

� �~å&ß)ßEåXÞ�� ß���� á�â�� �æ7ç�è&é�êµë�ë&î¡ò+è&êvñ ç ðÃî�ø êvú�î%í ôKñ�ï&î%õ!îDè&í�êµóvî¡õ�í�ç�õ�êzóµóµ÷�ë�è�ï\íjè�î¡õÚí�òDò+ñ ÷�ç/è²ñ�öSè&é!î%ë�è�îDìÄëêµç ñ ÷!ï<í�óvø�ñ�ï�êµè&é�ô�ölñ�ïÚû�è�è&êµç!ø � � � ñ�ï � > � þ ��ñ ë�èÚñ�ö�è&é�î õ�êµë&òD÷�ë�ë&êvñ ç ò+ñ ç�ò+îDï�ç�ëûÄè�è&êµç!ø�è&é!î ôKñ?õ!î¡óÃè�ñ í�ë�îDè%ñ�ö � è�ï�í�êµçÄêµç!øcë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë�ölñ�ï�ícø êµú�î¡çgìfîDï�ë�ñ ç±þ �:ñé!î¡óvì2è&êvî è&é!î ë�ñ ôKîDð>é�íjèËò+ñ ôKìÄózêµòDíjè�î¡õ�ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î ñ�ö)ñ�ìfîDï�íjè&êµñ ç�ëSè�ñ�ø�îDè&é!îDï �?ð�î�è&é!î¡çø êvú�îÚí�ë&÷Äô2ô2íjï&ýÔñ�ö é�ñ�ðMî¡í�ò�é�ë�è�îDì�êµë�öBñ.òD÷�ë&î¡õ�íjèKí�ìÄíjï&è&êµòD÷Äóµíjï�í�ë�ìfî¡ò+è�ñ�ö�è&é!îôKñ.õ�î¡óÎþ � êzç�í�óµóvýÚð�îKõ!î¡ë&ò+ï�êvüfî%é!ñ�ð í¾ç!îDð òDí�ç�õ�êµõÄíjè�î%ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�êµë²ò+ñ ôKìÄíjï&î¡õ è�ñè&é!î>ôKñ?õ!î¡ó�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�þ �Ôî²õ!î¡óµêµü)îDï\íjè�î¡óvý�óvî¡í�ú�î>ñ ÷�èËî��!ò+î¡ë&ë&êvú�îOè�î¡ò�é�çÄêµòDí�ó�õ�îDè&í�êµóµë�êµçè&é�êµë�ë�î¡ò+è&êvñ ç¾è�ñKô2í <�î�êvèyôKñ�ï&îOï&î¡í�õ�íjüÄóvî�!ë&÷�üÄë�î��.÷!î¡ç/èyë�î¡ò+è&êvñ çÄëÃð>êµóµóÄé�ñ�ì)îDö�÷�óµóµý�û�ózóêµçÚë�ñ ôKîJñ�öÇè&é!î¡ë&îJè�î¡ò�é�çÄêµòDí�óEø íjìÄëDþ

� ��������������� ����� �

�Ëí�ò�é ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&îHêµëÇï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õKí�ëËíJë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+îHñ�ö ����� � ò+ñZñ�ï\õ�êµç�íjè�îHìÄí�êµï�ë ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õíjèyí%÷�ç�êµölñ�ï�ô�ölï&î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+ýKñ�öíjü)ñ ÷�è!. �#� ìfñ êµç/è&ëÃìfîDï�ë&î¡ò+ñ ç�õEþ0�>óµñ ç!ø�ð>êvè&é2è&é!î²ë�ìÄí_ùè&êµí�óò+ñ.ñ�ï�õ�êzç�íjè�î¡ë �Eí�è&éÄêvï�õcò+ñ.ñ�ï�õ�êzç�íjè�î��fì�ï&î¡ë&ë&÷�ï&î��)êzë�ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ�î¡õ íjè²è&é!î�ë&í�ôKî%è&êµôKîì)ñ êzç/è&ëDþ��Çêvï\ë�èÃè&é�î�ì�ï&î¡ë&ë&÷�ï&îOë�êvø ç�í�ófêµëH÷�ë�î¡õ�è�ñ2ë�îDø ô2î¡ç/è�è&é�î²ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�êµçZè�ñ2ë�îDìÄí_ùï�íjè�î�ð�ñ�ï�õ�ë ��üÄí�ë&î¡õcñ ç�è&é!î%ì)î¡ç�÷!ì!ù6õ!ñQð çcë&î��Z÷!î¡çÄò+î¡ëDþ æ#ç �Çêvø ÷�ï&î > è&é!î�ìÄï&î¡ë&ë&÷!ï�îë&êvø ç�í�óî¡í�ë&êµóvý<ë&îDìÄíjï�íjè�î¡ëOè&é!î%è6ð�ñ�ð�ñ�ï�õ�ë"!� � ����#>í�ç�õ$! � �������#Xþ � é!îJûÄï\ë�è è¨ðÃñë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ë�íjï&îJø�î¡ç.÷�êµç!î��!è&é�î�è&é�êvï�õÚíKöBñ�ï&ø�îDï&ý�þ

�>óµè&é!ñ ÷!ø é è&é!î ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õ õ�íjè&í êµë è6ý.ìÄêµòDí�óµóµýsë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é ��è&é!îDï&îÔíjï&î ñ?òDòDí�ë&êvñ ç�í�óø�ï&ñ ë&ë ñ ÷!è&óµêvîDï\ë:í�ç�õ�ç!ñ êµë�ý²ìfñ êµçZè&ë±ð é�êzò�é�ç�îDî¡õ�è�ñOüfîËï&î¡ôKñQú�î¡õ � óvî¡ë&ëè&é�í�ç �&% ñ�ö�è&é!îè�ñ�è&í�ó � þ ��é!î¡ë&î íjï&î�î¡í�ë&êzóvýKêµõ!î¡çZè&ê®ûÄî¡õ�ü.ý%è&é�î¡êvïÃóµíjï�ø�î �Ë÷�òDózêµõ!î¡í�çKõ�êµë&è&í�ç�ò+î�öBï&ñ ô�è&é!î

"

Page 10: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

Time0 500 1500

01

23

45

6

Time0 500 1500

01

23

45

6

Time0 500 1000 2000

01

23

45

Time0 500 1500

5010

020

0

Time0 500 1500

5015

0

Time0 500 1000 2000

4060

80

� êµø ÷!ï&î > & ��� �� ��� ������� �:�&������ �� � 6� �"� �� ��4���� % ����� � � � 3?÷!ï&î¡ë&é � ë����������� -� � � � �� ��� ���� � � � ��� � � �� ���$� ��� ������ 4� � ��� � � � ��� � �:�&������ ����� �� � � ,� ��� ��� � �%��� � 2� ����� � � � ���� � ��� � � �:�&�� � ��� � ��� ��� � � ��� �� �� ��� ������� � � � �&%�� �����������

���

Page 11: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

ç!î¡êvø éZü)ñ�ï\êµç!øHìfñ êµçZè&ëDþ �Ôî�è&é!î¡çJû�è:í ë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�ìÄíjè&éJè&é�ï&ñ ÷!ø éJè&é�îËï&î¡ô2í�êzç�êµç!ø ��� �� �ò+ñZñ�ï�õÄêµç�íjè�î¡ëSöBñ�ïSî¡í�ò�é�ðÃñ�ï�õ�êµç%î¡í�ò�é�ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�þ���éÄêµëÇêµëSõ!ñ ç!îyü.ý%ë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�êzç!ø²î¡í�ò�éò+ñZñ�ï�õÄêµç�íjè�î�ë�îDì�íjï�íjè�î¡óvý¾íjø í�êµç�ë�è�è&êzôKîJ÷�ë&êµç�ø�íKòD÷�üÄêµò�ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç�ø�ë&ìÄóµêµç!î�þ

��é!î2í�ôKñ ÷Äç/è�ñ�öHë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç�ø¾êzë�ò�é!ñ ë�î¡çgí�÷!è�ñ ô2íjè&êµòDí�óµóµý�ü.ý�ø óµñ�üÄí�óSò+ï&ñ ë&ë#ù�újí�óµê®ùõ�íjè&êvñ ç ñ�öEè&é!îOêzç/è�îDø�ï�íjè�î¡õ��Ã÷�òDóµêµõ!î¡í�ç�õ�êµë�è&í�ç�ò+î>üfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç è&é�î ñ�üÄë�îDï�ú�î¡õ í�ç�õ�ûÄè�è�î¡õì)ñ êzç/è&ëDþ �Ëý.ìÄêµòDí�óµóµý�ú�îDï&ý~óµêvè�è&óvî�ë�ôKñZñ�è&éÄêµç!øcêµë�ìfîDï&ölñ�ï\ôKî¡õ � ð é�êµò\égêµë�ð é�íjè%êµë�êµç!ùè�î¡ç�õ!î¡õ �jí�ç�õ�è&é!î�ûÄè�è�î¡õ�òD÷!ï�ú�î¡ë:÷�ë&÷Äí�óµóvý>ò+ñ ô2îÃòDóvñ ë�îËè�ñ>êµçZè�îDï&ìfñ óµíjè&êµç!øyè&é!îËñ�üÄë�îDï&ú�î¡õë�î��Z÷�î¡ç�ò+î¡ëDþ � é!îDï&î�íjï&î�è&é!ï&îDî2ï&î¡í�ë&ñ ç�ëJöBñ�ï�ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç�øÚè&é!î�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î2ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î¡ëêµç¾è&é�êµëHðyí¡ý9&

' îDú�î¡çÔè&é�ñ ÷!ø éÔè&é!î2í�ôKñ ÷Äç/è�ñ�öyë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç!øÚêµë�ë�ô2í�óµó �Eêvè�è�î¡ç�õÄë²è�ñÚî¡óµêµô2êµçÄíjè�îë&ô�í�óµó�õÄêµë&ò+ñ çZè&êµçZ÷Äêvè&êvî¡ë�êµç/è�ï�ñ.õ�÷Äò+î¡õ�ü.ý ôKî¡í�ë�÷!ï&î¡ôKî¡çZèyîDï&ï&ñ�ï�õ�÷!îOè�ñKè&é!î�õ�êµë�ùò+ï&îDè&ê �¡íjè&êvñ çgõ�÷�ï�êµç!ø¾è&é!î ï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ�êµç�øÚì�ï&ñ?ò+î¡ë&ë �:ñ�ï�ë&ô2í�ózóSôKñ�ú�î¡ôKî¡çZè&ë�õ�÷!ï�êzç!øè&é!îJë�êvø ç�êµç!ø!þ

' è&é!î>òD÷!üÄêµò�ë&ìÄóµêµç!îyï&îDìÄï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&íjè&êvñ ç2è&÷!ï\ç�ë�è&é!î>ë�î��Z÷�î¡ç�ò+î>êµçZè�ñ�í�öB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ çKè&é�íjèòDí�çÚüfî²îDújí�óµ÷�íjè�î¡õcíjè>í�ç/ý�ìfñ êµç/è � �!è&é�êµëHé�í�ë ò+ñ ç�ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î¡ë ózíjè�îDï�ñ ç<êµç¾è&é!îí�óvø�ñ�ï\êvè&é�ôÚþ

' è&é!î�òD÷!üÄêµò�ë�ìÄóµêµç�î�éÄí�ë�è¨ðÃñ ò+ñ ç/è&êzçZ÷!ñ ÷Äë�õ!îDï\êvú_íjè&êµú�î¡ë �è&é�î2ûÄï�ë&èJñ�öHð é�êµò\égêµë÷�ë&î¡õÚêµç¾è&é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õÚò+ñ ôKì�÷!è&íjè&êvñ çEþ

3.î¡ò+è&êvñ ç4/!þ � ø êvú�î¡ëSôKñ�ï&îyõ!îDè&í�êµóµëñ ç%è&é!îy÷�ë�î�ñ�öÄë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç!øOë�ìÄóµêzç!î¡ë±êµç�è&é�êµë ò+ñ ç/è�î��?èDþ

� ����� ��� � ������ � � � � � � ����� �� � ���

�ÔîJò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è�î²è&é!î²ë�ìfîDî¡õ¾ë&êvø ç�í�ó � � � � � í�ëHí%öB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç ñ�ö ��öBñ�ïHî¡í�ò�éÚë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é!î¡õ¾ë&êvøjùç�íjè&÷!ï&î�÷�ë&êµç�ø�è&é!î�õ!îDï�êvújíjè&êvú�î¡ëOí¡újí�êµóµíjüÄóµî�öBï&ñ ô è&é!î%òD÷�üÄêµò�ë&ìÄóµêµç!î�ï&îDì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&íjè&êvñ çEþÿ²÷!ï�ìÄózí�çÚêµëyè�ñ ÷�ë&î�è&é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õ<ë&êµø ç�í�ófölñ�ï è&êµôKî�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç!ø2í�çÄõÚöB÷�ï&è&é!îDï�ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&í_ùè&êvñ ç �!üÄ÷!èyû�ï�ë�è�í�üÄêvèHñ�ö üÄí�ò <Zø�ï&ñ ÷Äç�õEþ

�>ç î¡ë�ë�î¡ç/è&êzí�ó�í�ë�ìfî¡ò+è�êµç�ûÄè�è&êµç!ø¾ñ ÷!ïJôKñ?õ!î¡óÇêµë�êµç î¡ë�è&êzô2íjè&êµç!ø¾è&é!î�è&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìöB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç�ë � � � � � �!ð éÄêµò�é�î¡ë�è&íjüÄózêµë&é�íKò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+î>üfîDè6ð�îDî¡çÚè&é!î�ì�íjï�í�ôKîDè�ï�ê��¡í_ùè&êvñ ç�ñ�ö è&é�îÚï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õsë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë$ � í�çÄõ è&é!î<÷�ç�êvú�îDï\ë&í�ó�ìÄíjï�í�ôKîDè�îDï � þ ��é!îDýí�óµë�ñÚî¡ë�è&íjüÄózêµë&é íÚë&êµô2êµózíjï>ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë&ì)ñ çÄõ!î¡ç�ò+î�üfîDè6ð�îDî¡çÔè6ð�ñ<õ�ê*)fîDï&î¡çZèOï�î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õÔë&êvøjùç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëDþ �Ëë&è&êµô2íjè&êµç!øÔè&é�î¡ë�î � � üfñ êµóµëKõ�ñ�ð ç è�ñgî¡ë�è&íjüÄózêµë&é�êµç�ø ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ëü)îDè¨ðÃîDî¡ç�ë&îDø ôKî¡ç/è&ë¾ñ ç è¨ðÃñsõ�ê1))îDï&î¡çZè òD÷�ï&ú�î¡ëDþ:�!ñ�ïÚî��!í�ôKìÄóvî�� ë�÷!ì�ìfñ ë�î�í~ìÄíjï�ùè&êµòD÷�óµíjï�ìÄêvî¡ò+î�ñ�ö è&é!î 3 ñ çgè&é�î2ûÄï�ë&è�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�ò+ñ ç�ë�êµë�è&ë�ñ�öHè&é!î�ìfñ êµçZè�ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+îï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õ�üfîDè6ð�îDî¡çcè&êµô2î¡ë > �2í�çÄõ .#"2ô�êµóµóµêµë&î¡ò+ñ ç�õ�ë��?è&é!î�ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êµç�øKìÄêvî¡ò+îJñ çè&é!îÚë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õ�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î���í�óvè&é!ñ ÷�ø é�ë�óµêvø éZè&óvýÔè&êµóvè�î¡õ í�ç�õ óµíjï&ø�îDï ��ô2êvø éZè�ò+ñ çÄë&êµë�è%ñ�öè&é!î�ë&î��Z÷!î¡çÄò+î�ï�î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õ�üfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç .#. í�ç�õ ��/Ôô2êµóµózêµë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õ�ë¡þ �:ñ î¡ë�è&íjüÄózêµë&égë�÷�ò�éí2ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�î¡ç�ò+î���ð�î�ç!îDî¡õ<ë�ñ ô2îJöB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ çÚõ!î+û�ç�î¡õÚí�óvñ ç!ø2î¡í�ò\é�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î²è&é�íjè

���

Page 12: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

Time

Spe

ed

0 500 1000 1500 2000

02

46

Time

Cur

vatu

re

0 500 1000 1500 2000

-2-1

01

2

� êµø ÷!ï&î . & ���� ����� � �� �� �*�#� � � ��� � ��� � � �# % ������%*��� � � �� � � 2� � ��� %��"����%� ��� �� � � � � ��������5� � �� � � 3?÷!ï&î¡ë&é �Oñ�ý í�ó � ë ����� ����� ��*� ��� ����� ��� � � �� ��*� � � � ��� 9%�� -, ����� 7�

ï&î � î¡ò+è&ë�è&é!î¡êvïËêzç/è�ï�êzç�ë&êµòHë&éÄíjì)î��.êvï&ï&î¡ë&ì)î¡ò+è&êµú�îHñ�öEè&é!î¡êvïËñ�ï\êvî¡ç/è&íjè&êµñ ç í�ç�õ óvñ?òDíjè&êvñ ç�êµçè&é!î �Ë÷ÄòDóµêµõ!î¡í�ç�ìÄóµí�ç�îJõ!î+û�ç!î¡õ¾ü.ý è&é�îJï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ�êzç!ø�ìÄí�õEþ

��é!îKòD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&î%ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ñ�öÃí¾ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�ë�îDî¡ô2ë²è�ñ¾ûÄèOè&é!î�üÄêµóµó�þ �>ñ�è²ñ ç�óvýcêµëêvè óvñ?òDíjè&êvñ ç<í�ç�õcï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç�êµç/újíjï�êµí�çZè ��üÄ÷�è�êvè õ!ñ.î¡ë�ç!ñ�è õ�îDì)î¡çÄõÚñ ç<è&é!î�ìÄíjï&è&êµòD÷�ózíjïìÄíjï�í�ôKîDè�ï�ê �¡íjè&êvñ ç ÷�ë&î¡õ êµçsõ�î+û�ç�êµç!øÔè&é�îcë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î�þ � ñ êµçZè&ë ñ�ö²éÄêvø ésòD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&îêµç�õ�êµòDíjè�î üÄêvøJò�éÄí�ç!ø�î¡ëyêµç2ë&é�íjìfî��.í�ç�õ�ë&é�ñ ÷�óµõ�è&é!îDï&îDöBñ�ï&î>ü)î>÷�ë�îDö�÷�ó?ölñ�ïyë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&êµç!øíÚë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î%êµçZè�ñÚóvñ�ø êµòDí�ó ìÄêvî¡ò+î¡ë �±êvï&ï&î¡ë�ìfî¡ò+è&êvú�î�ñ�öÃêvè&ë²ñ�ï\êvî¡ç/è&íjè&êµñ çEþ���ý�ô2íjè&ò\é�êµç!øè&é!î�òD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&îKö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ ç�ë²ñ�öÃè¨ðÃñ ë&êµô2êzóµíjï�óvýÚë&é�íjìfî¡õÔòD÷!ï�ú�î¡ë �:î¡í�ò\é~ôKî¡í�ë�÷!ï&î¡õÔ÷�ë#ùêµç!ø õÄê*))îDï�î¡ç/è>è&êµôKî�ì�íjï�í�ôKîDè�ï�ê��¡íjè&êµñ ç�ë �Äñ ç�î%ë&é�ñ ÷�óµõÚüfî�íjü�óvî�è�ñ�î��.è�ï\í�ò+èOè&é�î�è&êµôKîò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+î¡ëHñ�ï�è&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ì<ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ ç�ëDþ��Çêvø ÷!ï&î �Kë�é!ñ�ð ë�è&é!îJï&î¡ë&÷Äóvè&ëyñ�ö ë�÷�ò�éí2ô2íjè&ò�éÄêµç!ø!þ

æ7ç%ì�ï\í�ò+è&êµò+îyè&é!î�òD÷�ï&ú_íjè&÷�ï&îHë&êvø ç�í�óZè�î¡ç�õ�ë è�ñ²üfî�ç.÷�ôKîDï�êzòDí�óµóvý�÷�ç�ë�è&íjü�óvîËüfî¡òDí�÷�ë�î

��>

Page 13: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

Speed, cm/s

Cur

vatu

re, 1

/cm

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

-20

-10

010

20

.

.

.

.

.

.

........

.......

.................

..

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................................

..

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......................................................................................................

...... . ..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................................

..

..

..

......

.....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

....

.

.

.

.

.............

.

..................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...........

......................

................................................

...

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...............................

...................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.............................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

....

........

................

.

.............

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .........................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .........................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .....................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.............................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.............................................................

.

....

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.................................................................................................

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

..........................

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . ....................

..

..

..

..................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................................................

............. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..........................

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

..............

........................

.....

...................................

...........

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

....................

....................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.........

.

.

.

.

.......................

...............

.

.

.

..

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...................................... . . . . . .................. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..............................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.............

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.....................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

....

......

.............................. . . . . . . . . .....................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . ............................

....

............. . . . . . . . . . . .............

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.

... ...........

.

..

.

.

.

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............................

..

.

.

.

........

.

.

..

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......................................................................................

. .. . . . ........................... .

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..................................

..

..

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

............

..

............

.

.

.....

.

.

.

..... . ...................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

........

.

...............................................

........

......

.............

..

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..........................

......................................

.

..

..

.

.

.......

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.................................

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . ....

...........

....

............

....

.

.

.

.....

.

.

...... .....................

...

..

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...........................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

....

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .....................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

... ....................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

......................................

......... .

..................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

......

.

.....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

....................................................................................................................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

..........

..............

.

.

.....

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...............................

..

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..................

..

...

.........................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................................

..

..

.....

..

.. . . . . . . . ........ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................

..

..

..

............. . ...

.....

..........

....

..

..

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . .............

..

............................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..........

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

...........................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................................................

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...................................

..

..

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..........

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

....

.....

............................. .

... . . . . . . . ...... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . .........................................

.. . . .........

............

.

.

.

...........................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................................................................................................. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

....................................

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

......

..................................

........................

...........

................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

......................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..........

.............

....

........................... .

.........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...........

........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

......................

.....

...

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............................................................

.......

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

... .

..........

.

.......

.

.

.. .

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . ........................ . ...................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . .....................................................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.........

.

.

.

.

.....................

.........

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............

..................

..

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . .............................

..............................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................................................. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..............

.....

.

.

.

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . ...

............

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.........

...

.

.

.

..........

............................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

....

.

.

.

...................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................................................. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...........

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..........

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..............................

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . .......................

..............................................

.

.

.

.

. .

.

....

.

.

.

.

...............

........

.

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............................

..

..

..

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......................................................................

. .. . .

. . . . . . ............................. .

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

......................

......................

...........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..........

..

............................................

....

..

................

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

......................................

......

.

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.........................

......

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

... . . . ..................................

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........

........

..

..

...

...............

..........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

... . . . .

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.... . . . . . . . . . . . .............

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

............................................

...

.................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

......

.....

...

.

.

.

.............................................................................................................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . ............

......................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................

.............................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................................. . . . . . . . ............... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................

..

..

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

......................................................

................ . . . . . . . . . ..............

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...............

......

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. ............

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..................................................

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......................................

...............

.....

.

.

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...........

.

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.

....................... .

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...............

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . ......................

..

..

...............................

....

.....................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. .

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................................................................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...........................

........

.................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.............

..............................................

...............................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.....................................

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.................................

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . ....................

....

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.... .

. . . . .. . .

.....................

.....

.........

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

... . . ..........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.. . . .

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..................................

..

..

.

.

.

.

....

.

.

.

.

..

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...........................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...................

..

....

...

...................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.................

....

.

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.

....... . . . . . . .. .............

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

........

...............................................................................................................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.............

....

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............................

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............................................................

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................................................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...............................

..

.

.

...

.

.

.

.........

.............

...

...

....

...........................

....................

...............

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.... . . . . . . . . . .............................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

..............

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

............

................... .

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................................................ .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......................................

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

................

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.....................

...

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

................

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

.

.......... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

..

.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......................

..

.

.

.

.

.

...

.

.

.

....... . . . . . . . . . . ..........

400

-400

500

-500

600

-600

700

-700

800

-800

Constant Centripetal Acceleration Contour, cm/s/s

� êµø ÷!ï&î / & ���� ���, � � ���������� �*� � ��� ��� �� ���� � � � %7� -, ����� � � � � �� ��� � ��� � , ����� ����� �� � � 3?÷!ï�î¡ë&é�Oñ�ý í�ó ( � ����� � 2� ��������� .�

êvè:êµë:üÄí�ë�î¡õJñ ç%ë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õ�õ!îDï�êvújíjè&êvú�îËêzç!ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç �_õ!î¡ë�ìÄêvè�îËè&é!îËö�í�ò+è:è&é�íjè êvè:êµëõ!îDï�êvú�î¡õölï&ñ ô è&é!î�ë&ô2ñZñ�è&é!î¡õÚë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&îOòD÷!ï&ú�î¡ëDþ ��é�êµë�êµë�ë�ìfî¡òDêµí�óµóvýKè�ï�÷�îOíjï&ñ ÷Äç�õ�ìfñ êµçZè&ë�ñ�öé�êvø é¾òD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&î��?ð é�êzò�é¾íjï&î�è&é!î�íjï&î¡í�ëHñ�öÇêµçZè�îDï&î¡ë�èyöBñ�ï�ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&íjè&êvñ çEþ ��é�î²ë&ì)îDî¡õöB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç �Çñ ç�è&é!î ñ�è&é�îDï�éÄí�ç�õ �SêµçZú�ñ óvú�î¡ë�ûÄï�ë�è�ï�íjè&é!îDï�è&é�í�ç�ë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õ õ!îDï�êvújíjè&êvú�î¡ë �í�ç�õ�ü)î¡éÄí¡ú�î¡ë2êµç�í ôKñ�ï&îÚë�è&íjüÄóµî�ö�í�ë&é�êµñ çEþ ��é!î¾ë�ìfîDî¡õ~ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ ç~ñ�öOí ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�îè�î¡ç�õ�ëJè�ñ�é�í¡ú�î�í�çgêµçZú�îDï�ë�î2ï�î¡óµíjè&êvñ ç�ë&éÄêvì ð êvè&é è&é!î�òD÷�ï&ú_íjè&÷�ï&î��ë&÷Äò�é è&éÄíjèJìfñ êµç/è&ëñ�öJé�êvø ésòD÷!ï�ú_íjè&÷!ï�îcò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õsè�ñ~ìfñ êµçZè&ëKñ�öJóvñQð ë�ìfîDî¡õEþ �Çêvø ÷!ï&î /�ë&é!ñQð ë�í�çî��?í�ôKì�óvî2ñ�ö�è&é�êµëJêµçZú�îDï�ë�îKï�î¡óµíjè&êvñ ç�ë&éÄêvì ölñ�ï�è&é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õÔí�ç�õ òD÷�ï&ú_íjè&÷�ï&î�ë&êvø çÄí�óµë²ñ�ö� êµø ÷!ï&î ..þ>æ7èOë&îDî¡ô2ëOè&é!î¡çcè&éÄíjèOð�î�òDí�ç ÷Äë�î%ë&ì)îDî¡õ í�ë²í ë�÷!ï&ï&ñ�ø íjè�î%ölñ�ï²è&é!î�ôKñ�ï&îêµç/újíjï�êµí�çZè�üÄ÷�èËç!ñ êµë�ýKòD÷!ï�ú_íjè&÷!ï�î�þ ��ñ�ï�î¡í�ò\é¾ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�è&é!î>ë&ì)îDî¡õ êµëËë�í�ôKìÄóvî¡õ�ölï&ñ ôè&é!î ë�ì�óµêµç!î%ï&îDì�ï&î¡ë&î¡ç/è&íjè&êvñ ç~ñ�öHêvè&ë�ò+ñ.ñ�ï�õ�êzç�íjè�î¡ëJ÷�ç�êµölñ�ï�ô�óvýcêµçÔè&êzôKî�þ 3?î¡ò+è&êvñ ç /!þ >ø êvú�î¡ë ígôKñ�ï&îcï\êvø�ñ�ï&ñ ÷�ë �&÷�ë�è&êvû�òDíjè&êvñ ç öBñ�ï ÷�ë&êzç!øÔè&é!îcë�ìfîDî¡õ ë&êvø ç�í�óyï�íjè&é�îDï�è&é�í�çòD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&î�öBñ�ï è&êµôKî�ðyíjï&ìÄêzç!ø!þ

� .

Page 14: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

Time

Spe

ed

0 100 200 300 400

0.0

0.4

0.8

Two speed Signals Superimposed

Time

Spe

ed

0 100 200 300 400

0.0

0.4

0.8

Two speed Signals Superimposed after Time-warping

� êµø ÷!ï&î � & ��� ��� � � �� �� �*� �� � ��� � ��� � ��������� � � � ��� ����� � ��� �� ����� � ���� � ���� ���� � �-� ��� � ���#� � � � ��� %7� �,� � � %*��� �% �� � �#��� ��� � � ��� � �� ����� ���"� � � ��� ��� �� � � � � � % � ��6�������� � �� � �"� � � 7� ���� �*��� ��� � � �� � �*� �� ���� �� ��� � ���� � ��� � �7� ��� ��� �&%�� ����� ���

� ����� ��� ������� �� � ��� � �� ��� � � ��� � ��

��é!îcç!î��?è�ë�è�îDì êµëKè�ñ�÷�ë�î<è&é�îcë�ìfîDî¡õsö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çÄë�ölï&ñ ô í�ç/ý�è¨ðÃñ�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î¡ë � ñ�ïò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êzç!ø�ð�ñ�ï�õ�ë�öBï&ñ ôMè6ð�ñ�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë � è�ñ2í�óµêµø ç è&é�î¡ôÙêµç¾ë&÷�ò�éÚí�ðyí¡ý�è&é�íjèò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êzç!ø2ìfñ êµçZè&ë í�ç�õ�ï&îDø êvñ ç�ë>ñ ç î¡í�ò�éÔòDí�ç üfî�êµõ�î¡ç/è&ê®û�î¡õEþ ��é!î�è�î¡ò�é�ç�ê �Z÷!îðÃîK÷�ë�î%êµë <.ç!ñQð ç í�ë�� ���� � ��% � � � ���� � �� �� ���Eí�ç�õ êµëOé!î¡í¡ú?êµóvý<÷�ë&î¡õ�êµç�ë�ìfîDî¡ò�éï&î¡ò+ñ�ø ç�êvè&êvñ ç � �,3 #.%$ � þ�æ7èJêµëJícõ!ý.çÄí�ô2êµò%ì�ï&ñ�ø�ï�í�ô�ô2êµç!øÚôKîDè&é!ñ?õ ÷�ë&î¡õ è�ñcñ�ü�è&í�êµçí�ç!ñ ç�ózêµç!î¡íjï � -��� � �����*� � �Eè�ï\í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ çcü)îDè¨ðÃîDî¡çcè6ð�ñ���ù6õÄêµôKî¡ç�ë&êµñ ç�í�ófë&êvø ç�í�óµë� � � � êµç ñ ÷!ï<òDí�ë�î � þ ��é!î è�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç�ò+ñ ç�ë&êµë&è&ë¾ñ�ö%óvñ?òDí�ó²ë�è�ï&îDè&ò\é�êµç!ø�ñ�ïò+ñ ôKì�ï&î¡ë&ë�êvñ ç ñ�ö�è&é!îÔè&êµô2î+ù6í �?êµë�ñ�ö�î¡êvè&é!îDï<ë&êvø çÄí�ó ï&î¡ózíjè&êvú�î è�ñ�è&é!î è&êµôKî+ù6í �!êµë¾ñ�öè&é!î�ñ�è&é�îDï¡þ ��é!î�í�êzô ñ�ö�è&é�î¡ë�î%óµñ.òDí�ó í�õ��&÷�ë�è&ôKî¡çZè&ë²êµë è&é�î%ô2êzç�êµô2ê��¡íjè&êµñ çÚñ�öËë�ñ ôKîø óvñ�üÄí�óÄô2î¡í�ë&÷!ï&î ÷Äë�î¡õKè�ñ �.÷�í�çZè&êvöBý�è&é!î>õ�ê*)fîDï&î¡ç�ò+îHüfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç�è&é�î�è6ð�ñ%ë�êvø ç�í�óµë � ë�÷�ò�é

� /

Page 15: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

í�ëyè&é!î�óvî¡í�ë�è#ù6ë��.÷�íjï&î¡õ¾îDï&ï�ñ�ïyë�÷�ô2ôKî¡õ ñ�ú�îDï�è&é�îOè�ï\í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ ç�ìÄíjè&éÚêµç è&é!î�òDí�ë�îñ�ö�õ�êµë&ò+ï&îDè�î�è&êµôKî�÷�çÄêvè&ëDþ � é!îJè�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç<ìÄíjè&écï&îDì�ï&î¡ë&î¡ç/è&ë è&é!î�ìfñ êµçZè�ò+ñ�ï&ï&î+ùë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ëHî¡ë&è&íjüÄóµêµë&é�î¡õ üfîDè¨ðÃîDî¡çcè&é!îJè6ð�ñ ë�êvø ç�í�óµëDþ

� ì�íjï&è�ölï�ñ ô ìÄï&ñ�ú?êµõ�êµç�ø�è&é!î2ò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ëOüfîDè6ð�îDî¡çÔè6ð�ñ<ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ë �Eè&é!îè&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç!ø í�óvø�ñ�ï�êvè&éÄô ìÄï&ñ.õÄ÷�ò+î¡ë�í�ç êµô2ì)ñ�ï�è&í�ç/è õ�êµë�è&í�ç�ò+î ôKî¡í�ë&÷�ï&î�êzç è&é!îë�ìfîDî¡õ<õ!ñ ô2í�êµç¾üfîDè¨ðÃîDî¡çcè&é!îJè6ð�ñ�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëDþ

�>ózó�ìfñ ë&ë&êvü�óvîHìÄí�êvï�ëËñ�ö±è&é!î � ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ë�öBñ�ïyí�ø êvú�î¡ç ìfîDï�ë�ñ ç íjï&î>è&êzôKî+ù�ð�íjï�ì)î¡õíjø í�êµç�ë�èHî¡í�ò\éÚñ�è&é!îDï �!ì�ï�ñ.õ�÷ÄòDêµç!ø � � ��� � ��� > ë�îDè&ë�ñ�ö:è&êµôKî�ò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ë �!í�ç�õè&é!î¡êvïJí�ë&ë�ñ?òDêµíjè�î¡õÔóvî¡í�ë&è#ù6ë��Z÷Äíjï&î¡ëJõ�êµë&è&í�ç�ò+î¡ëDþ��!ï�ñ ô è&é!î¡ë�îKè&é!îKë&êzç!ø óvî�ôKñ ë�è²ï&îDì�ï&î+ùë�î¡ç/è&íjè&êµú�î�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�êµëHë�î¡óvî¡ò+è�î¡õ &�ðÃîJò\é!ñ.ñ ë�îJè&é!î�ñ ç!î�ð>é!ñ ë�îJôKî¡í�çÚè&êzôKî+ù�ð�íjï�ì)î¡õë�ìfîDî¡õ�õ�êµë�è&í�ç�ò+î¾öBï&ñ ô í�óµó�è&é!î¾ñ�è&é!îDï ��� � ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î¡ë�êµëKë&ô2í�óµóµî¡ë�èDþ �Ôîc÷�ë&î¾íè�ï�êµô2ôKî¡õ�ôKî¡í�çcêzç<è&é�êµë òDí�óµòD÷�óµíjè&êvñ ç ��êµçÚè&é�î�îDú�î¡çZè>è&é�íjèOè&é!î%êµç�õ�êvú?êµõ�÷Äí�óÄìfîDï�é�íjì�ëé�í�õ�ñ ç!î�üÄí�õ¾ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&îOêzç�è&é!î²üÄíjè&ò\éEþ �>ñ�è�î�è&é�íjèyè&é�êµë�ï&îDì�ï�î¡ë�î¡ç/è&íjè&êµú�îJë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�îêµëHç!ñ�èyð é�íjèHð�î�é�í¡ú�îJüfîDî¡çÚòDí�óµózêµç!ø�è&é�î�è�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�îJë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�!êvèHêµëyë&êµô2ìÄóvý2í�üÄí�ë�îë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�ölñ�ïHî¡ë�è&íjü�óµêµë&é�êzç!ø%ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ë¡þ�3?÷!ì�ìfñ ë�îOè&é�êµëyï&îDìÄï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&íjè&êvú�î�ë&êvøjùç�íjè&÷!ï&îyêµëè&é!î�ûÄï�ë�è � � � � � þ0�Çêvø ÷!ï�î ) ë&é!ñQð ë í>ì�êvî¡ò+îÃñ�ö�í>è¨ýZì�êµòDí�ó?ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+îòD÷!ï&ú�î���í�ç�õ~ðÃî¾ë�îDî¾êvè%öBí�êvï\óvý�ï�ñ ÷!ø é �Ëêµç~ö�í�ò+è%òDóvñ ë&î�êµçÄë�ìfî¡ò+è&êvñ ç ë&é!ñQð ë%è&é�íjè�êvè�êµëìÄêvî¡ò+îDð êµë&îyózêµç!î¡íjï¡þ �Ëí�ò�é�ë�ìfîDî¡õKë&êvø ç�í�ó?êµë ï&îDì�ï�î¡ë�î¡ç/è�î¡õKíjèÃíOë&îDèSñ�ö�è&êµô2î�ìfñ êµçZè&ë � ç!ñ�èç!î¡ò+î¡ë&ë&íjï�êzóvý�è&é!î>ë&í�ôKî ç.÷�ô�ü)îDï�þ �Hð�ñJñ�ïËôKñ�ï�î�í�õ���í�ò+î¡çZèËìfñ êµçZè&ëÇñ çKñ ç!î>ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�îô2í¡ý�ü)î�ölñ ÷Äç�õcè�ñÚò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ<è�ñÚí�ë&êµç!ø óvî�ìfñ êµç/è>ñ ç è&é!î�ñ�è&é�îDï �fð é�êµò\écî��?ìÄóµí�êµçÄëè&é!î�ë�ñ ô2îDè&êµôKî¡ë � íjè2ï&îDø êvñ ç�ë êµç üfñ�è&ésè&é!îcú�îDï&è&êµòDí�ó í�çÄõ é!ñ�ï�ê �Dñ ç/è&í�ó�õÄêvï&î¡ò+è&êvñ ç�ë¡þ�Ëí�ò�égñ�öÃè&é�î ��� � ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�î¡ç�ò+îKòD÷!ï&ú�î¡ëJêµë²ë&êzô2êµóµíjï�óµýÚìÄóvñ�è�è�î¡õÔí�ëJí¾ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çñ�öè&é!î²è&êµô2îOújí�óµ÷!î¡ë�öBñ�ïHè&é!î²ï&îDì�ï&î¡ë&î¡ç/è&íjè&êvú�î�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î��.í�ç�õ¾î¡í�ò\é<êµëyë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é!î¡õ¾è�ñü�ï&î¡í <Kè&é!î>è&êvî¡ëDþ0�!ñ�ïyî¡í�ò�é è&êµôKî>ì)ñ êzç/è�ñ�öfè&é!î>ï&îDì�ï&î¡ë&î¡ç/è&íjè&êvú�î²ë�ìfîDî¡õ�òD÷�ï&ú�î � � �Zè&é!îò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êzç!øJè&êµôKî¡ë�öBñ�ïyî¡í�ò�éÚñ�ö±è&é�î>ñ�è&é!îDï ��� � ë&ì)îDî¡õ�òD÷!ï&ú�î¡ë � � òDí�ç¾üfî ï&î¡í�õñ )¾öBï&ñ ô è&é!î¡ë&î�ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é!î¡õ2ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë&ì)ñ çÄõ!î¡ç�ò+îHòD÷!ï&ú�î¡ëDþÇæ7öÄè&é!îDï�î�íjï&î� �Së&ì)îDî¡õ�újí�óµ÷!î¡ëë&í�ôKìÄóvî¡õ�ölï�ñ ô ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î � íjè � ��è&êµôKî¡ë �.ð�î ø�îDè � �yò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õÄêµç!ø�è&êµôKî>ìfñ êµç/è&ëölï&ñ ôMî¡í�ò\é<ñ�öè&é!î²ñ�è&é!îDï ��� � ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ëDþ ��é�î¡ë�î�òDí�çÚè&é!î¡ç¾üfîO÷Äë�î¡õ¾è�ñKï&îDè�ï�êvîDú�îè&é!î ��� �� � ò+ñ.ñ�ï�õ�êzç�íjè�î¡ëËöBñ�ïyè&é!î²ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ëËè&é!î¡ô�ë�î¡óvú�î¡ëyöBï&ñ ô è&é�î¡êvï�òD÷�üÄêµòXù6ë�ìÄózêµç!îï&îDì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&íjè&êvñ ç�ë¡þ�æ7ö�è&é!î�è&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç�ø�õ�êzõ�í¾ø�ñ.ñ.õ ��ñ�ü �fð�î2ô2êvø éZè²ç�ñ�ð î��?ì)î¡ò+èè�ñcé�í¡ú�î2ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êµç�ø�ë�îDè&ëJñ�ö ��� �� � ì�í�êvï�ëOölñ�ï�î¡í�ò\é ñ�ö�è&é!î ��ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ë²ölñ�ïè&é!î�êµç�õÄêvú.êzõ�÷�í�óÎþ

� ����� �� ��� ��� �� � ��� �

��é!îÚï&îDì�ï�î¡ë�î¡ç/è&íjè&êµú�îcòD÷!ï&ú�îcêzëKë�îDø ôKî¡çZè�î¡õ íjè2ï&îDø êµñ ç�ëKñ�ö�óvñ�ð ë�ìfîDî¡õ � é�êvø é�òD÷!ï�ùú_íjè&÷!ï�î � þ �Çêvø ÷!ï&î �~ë&é!ñ�ð>ë è&é�î ìfñ êµçZè&ë ñ�ö�ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&íjè&êvñ ç�ü�í�ë�î¡õ ñ ç è&é�î ë&ì)îDî¡õë&êvø ç�í�ó�öBñ�ï2è&é!î¾ï&îDì�ï&î¡ë&î¡ç/è&íjè&êvú�î�òD÷!ï&ú�î¾ölñ�ï�è&é!î "� ��*��ð�ñ�ï�õEþ��é!îÚóvñQðÃîDï�ë&ì)îDî¡õè&é!ï&î¡ë&é!ñ ózõ�êzëHò�é!ñ ë�î¡ç<è�ñKü)î � � % ñ�ö:è&é!îJôKî¡í�çcë�ìfîDî¡õ �!í�ç�õÚí�ë�òDí�çÚüfî�ë�îDî¡ç<êµç�è&é!î

� �

Page 16: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

**

**

**

* ** *

***

** *

***

** *

* ***

**

* ***

**

* ** *

*

Time in Reference

Tim

e W

arp

200 205 210 215 220 225 230

205

210

215

220

225

230

235

� êµø ÷!ï&î ) & ��� %*� � � �� � � %��� � ��� � ����� ����� ����� �� � � � � � �% �� � � � � �� �� �# % ��������9���, �� � � � �&%�� ��� � ��#� �� � � �� � �:�&������ ������� %�� � ���#�� ��� ��#� �� �2(��/. �� ��� 9����� ����� � �8�7����� %7� -, � � � � ��� ��� 9%�� � ���#�� � � % � ��� �� ������ ��� ��� �� � %*� �� �#� � �� � ��� � �#� �� � �8(������è&êzôKî>ðyíjï&ì¾ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç#.9% �� ��� ����� �� � � � � ��� � � � �8�7����� %7� �,�7��� � � �*� �� � ��� � � � �#� ������� � � ��� ���� � ��� � � � � % ������ �� ��� � �� � � 3?÷!ï�î¡ë&é �²ñ�ý í�ó � ë ����������� � �� �$� � � � � � % ����������� 7�

� )

Page 17: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

ûÄø ÷!ï&î���è&é!îJìfñ�ï&è&êvñ çÚñ�öSè&é�î�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î�í�ë&ë�ñ?òDêµíjè�î¡õ�ð êvè&éÚè&é�î�óvñ?òDí�ó:ô2êzç�êµô2í%üfî¡óvñ�ðè&é�êµë�è&é�ï&î¡ë&é!ñ óµõcíjï&î�ï&î¡ô2ñ�ú�î¡õ õ�÷!ï�êµç�øKè&é!î�ë�îDø ô2î¡ç/è&íjè&êvñ ç±þ ��é�êµë�éÄí�ë>óµêµè�è&óvîJë�ìÄíjè&êµí�óò+ñ ç�ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î��yë&êµç�ò+î¾ü.ý~õ!î+û�çÄêvè&êvñ ç~ì)ñ êzç/è&ë�ñ�öOóvñ�ð ë�ìfîDî¡õ�íjï&î<òDóµñ ë�î¾è�ñ�ø�îDè&é!îDï êµçë�ìÄí�ò+î�þ �Ôî¾é�í¡ú�î¾êµôKì�óvî¡ôKî¡çZè�î¡õgícõ�ý.ç�í�ô�êµò2ôKñ?õ�ê®û�òDíjè&êµñ çÔè�ñcè&é�êzë � � % è&é!ï&î¡ë&é!ùñ óµõ �Äð>é�êµò�é�ò�é!î¡ò <.ë�êµöÇí�çZýcç!îDð óvñ?òDí�óô2êzç�êµô2íKíjï&î�õ�êµë�ò+ñ�ú�îDï&î¡õ�üfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç�è&é�î � � %í�ç�õ � � � � � � % è&é!ï&î¡ë&é!ñ ózõ �!êvöë�ñKè&é�î�è&é!ï&î¡ë&é!ñ ózõÚêµëHêµç�ò+ï&î¡ô2î¡ç/è�î¡õÚè�ñ � ) % í�ç�õÚè&é!îë�è�îDìÚêµë�ï&îDìfî¡íjè�î¡õEþSæ7ç ì�ï�í�ò+è&êzò+î>è&é�êzëËï&î¡ë�÷�óvè&ë�êµç�è&é�ï&î¡ë&é!ñ óµõÄë�üfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç � ��� � % �Äí�ç�õè&é!î�ë�îDø ô2î¡ç/è&íjè&êvñ ç�ì�ï&ñ?ò+î¡ë&ë>êµë�ôKñ�ï&î%ë�è&íjüÄóvî�þ ��é!îJóµñ�ð�îDï>ìÄí�ç�î¡ó±êµç¾ûÄø ÷�ï&î ��ë&é�ñ�ð ëè&é!îcë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&ëKè&é!î¡ô�ë�î¡óvú�î¡ë �yë�îDìÄíjï�íjè�î¡õ üZý ë�ñ ôKîÚð>é�êvè�îÚë�ìÄí�ò+î�þ ��éÄêµëKêµë <?ç!ñ�ð çí�ë ��ë&î¡óvözù6ë&îDø ôKî¡ç/è&íjè&êµñ ç�� êµç è&é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡ò�é~ï&î¡ò+ñ�ø ç�êvè&êµñ ç~óµêµè�îDï�íjè&÷!ï&î � � � > $ � þ ÿ²ç�ò+îè&é!î�ë�îDø ô2î¡ç/è&íjè&êvñ ç é�í�ë>üfîDî¡ç<ìfîDï&öBñ�ï�ôKî¡õÚöBñ�ïOè&é!î�ï&îDìÄï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&íjè&êvú�î%ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î��)êvè êµëí�÷!è�ñ ô2íjè&êµòDí�óµóµý¾õ�î+û�ç!î¡õ¾öBñ�ï>í�óµófè&é!î�ñ�è&é!îDï>ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëHüfî¡òDí�÷�ë&îJñ�öÇè&é!îJò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç?ùõ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ëDþ �Ôî%ï&îDölîDï>è�ñ�î¡í�ò\é�ñ�öÇè&é!î%ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&ë>í�ë � � �������fêµç<ô�í�ç/ý<òDí�ë�î¡ë>è&é!îDý<íjï&îë&êµç!ø óvî�óvîDè�è�îDï\ë ��üÄ÷!èHè&éÄêµëHêµëHç!ñ�è í2ï&î��Z÷Äêvï&î¡ôKî¡çZèDþ

� ����� ����� � � ������ � ���� ��� � � � ��� �æ7ç�è&é�êµëOë�è�îDì ðÃî%î¡ë�è&êµô�íjè�î%è&é�î�è�î¡ôKì�óµíjè�î%ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î%íjè>è&é�î%óvîDè�è�îDï�óvîDú�î¡ó �fí�çÄõcè&é!îñ�ì�è&êµô2í�ó±í���ç!î�è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êµñ çÚüfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç<î¡í�ò�é�óvîDè�è�îDï>í�çÄõ<êvè&ëHè�î¡ôKì�óµíjè�î�þ

�!ï&ñ ôÙè&é�îOìÄï&îDú.êµñ ÷�ëÃë&è�îDìÚðÃî�é�í�ú�îJí�ì�íjï�í�óµóvî¡ó)ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î²ñ�öóvîDè�è�îDï\ëyölñ�ïHî¡í�ò\éÚñ�öè&é!î �së&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î¡ë�� �Çêvø ÷!ï�î � ï�êvø éZè�è&é!ï&îDî2ìÄí�ç�î¡óµë �Eè&é�êµò <�îDï�òD÷!ï&ú�î¡ë � ë&é!ñQð ë�è&é!ï&îDî39� ë�ölï&ñ ô "� ��� � ����� � � ��ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î��.ð é�êµò\é�ð�îDï&î²ñ�ü�è&í�êµç!î¡õ�öBï&ñ ô è&é!î²í�÷!è�ñ ô2íjè&êµòë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&íjè&êvñ ç�êzç¾è&é!î�ð�í�ý<õ!î¡ë&ò+ï�êµü)î¡õ±þ

�Ôî�õ�î¡ç!ñ�è�î2è&é!î¡ë�î �sï&î¡ç�õ�êµè&êvñ ç�ë²ñ�öyè&é!î � è&é óvîDè�è�îDï%ü.ý�� ��� � î¡í�ò�é�í�ç�� �&( >ô2íjè�ï�ê���ñ�ö ��� �� � ò+ñ.ñ�ï�õ�êzç�íjè�î¡ëKñ�ï�õ!îDï�î¡õ üZý�ï&ñ�ð �Ãí�ç�õ ð êµè&é�ígò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+îí�ò+ï&ñ ë&ë�ï�ñ�ð ëDþ �Ôî�õ!î+û�ç�îOè&é�î�í¡ú�îDï�íjø�î�óvîDè�è�îDï��� � è�ñ2üfî²è&é!î�ô2êµçÄêµô2ê��DîDï�ñ�ö

����� ����

� � ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� � �� � �� � � �

ñ�ú�îDï �� � � � ��� í�çÄõ�� ��� �)ð é!îDï&î �� � êzë>í�ç � � ( > ô2íjè�ï\ê�� �!� � �#" %$� í óvñ?òDíjè&êvñ çë&é�êvöBè�í�çÄõ è&é�î � ��� íjï&î > (�> ç!ñ ç�ë&êzç!ø ÷�óµíjïÃè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ çÄëDþ ��é!î²ë�ñ óµ÷!è&êµñ ç é�í�ëHíò+ñ ç�òDêµë�îOô2íjè&é!î¡ô2íjè&êµòDí�ófõ!î¡ë�ò+ï�êvì�è&êvñ çKêzç2è�îDï�ô2ëÃñ�öEè&é!îOë&ô2í�óµóvî¡ë&è�î¡êvø ç!îDú�î¡ò+è�ñ�ï�ë�ñ�ö±í�çí¡ú�îDï�íjø�îHì�ï�ñ��#î¡ò+è&êvñ ç�ñ�ìfîDï�íjè�ñ�ï � ë&îDîÃë�î¡ò+è&êvñ ç /!þ / � þ ��é!îDï�îËíjï&îËè¨ðÃñOðyí¡ý?ë:è�ñ²ò+ñ ôKìÄíjï&îè&é!î�êzç�õ�êvú?êµõ�÷�í�óÇóvîDè�è�îDï\ë�è�ñ è&é!î¾í¡ú�îDï�íjø�î�þ �Ôî¾òDí�ç~î¡êµè&é!îDï%ë�÷!ìfîDï�êµôKìfñ ë�î&� ��� í�ç�õ� ��� � �� � �(' ���� öBñ�ïSî¡í�ò�é � ë�îDì�íjï�íjè�î¡óvý�� ñ�ïSî¡óµë&îyë�÷!ìfîDï�êµôKìfñ ë�î�í�óµó.è&é!î � � ��� �)� ��� ��� ���ñ ç �� � þ��Çêvø ÷!ï�î4 2ò+ñ ô2ìÄíjï&î¡ë>è&é!î 39� ë ð êvè&éÚè&é�î�í¡ú�îDï\íjø�î�3ÚêµçÚüfñ�è&écð�í�ý.ë �fí�ç�õ�ðÃîë�îDîJè&é!î�ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+îJêzëHòDóvñ ë�î�þ

�yè�è&éÄêµëJìfñ êµçZèJè&é!î�í¡ú�îDï�íjø�î<óvîDè�è�îDï\ë �� � òDí�çgüfî ��ñ êµç!î¡õg÷!ì~ë�î��.÷!î¡çZè&êµí�óµóvýÔí�ç�õë&í¡ú�î¡õ í�ëHè&é!îJè�î¡ô2ìÄóµíjè�î�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î ' öBñ�ï "� ���/þ

� �

Page 18: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

Time

Spe

ed

0 500 1000 1500 2000

02

46

oooooooo

ooooooooo ooooooooooooooooooooooooo ooooooooooooooooo ooooooooo

ooooo

ooooooooo

oooooooooooooooo

ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ooooooo ooooo

� êµø ÷!ï&î � & ��� ������� � �� ��� � � � ���� ���� � ��������� � � ��, � � 4��� ��� � � � � � �����,� 3?÷!ï&î¡ë&é �Oñ�ý í�ó � �:�&������ -� � � ���� ��%����� � ��� � ���� � � �������� ��� ��� � � �&� ��� �:� � � � � �� �*� � � � ��� � ��� � � � ��� �� � � ,� ���

Page 19: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

**********

*****

**

**********

**

**

**

******************** * * * * * *

*******

**

***********

**************

**

*

*************

*

*

*

*************

**

*

**

* * * * * * **** * * **** * **** * * * * ****

**

**********

*******************

*

*

***************************

**

********** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ****

**

**

**

***********

*****************

*

* * * * * * ***** * * * *

**

**

**

* **

************

**

********************

*

***********

****************

*** ** * * * * *

** * * *** * * * * **

**

**

* *** * * * *******

**

**

***************************

********

*********

* * * * **** * * *****

* *

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * **********

**************************************

******

** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

� êµø ÷!ï&î & ��� ��� � � �8� � � � � �� �*� � � � ��� �435 � � ��, � ��� � �� ���������� !� # � � ���(���� ��% � %�� -, 4. � 4��� 3?÷!ï�î¡ë&é��Oñ�ý í�ó � ë � �:�&������ -� � � ��� ��� � 2��� *% ������ � � � ��� �� � � � � � �:�&������ � �-� ��� � ���#� � � � ��� �� � �� �� � ���� �� � ��� � � ���� ���� ��, ������������������� ��� � � ��� ���� � 4��� *% �� � ������������� ��� ����� ���#� � �&�

� � � ��� � � ��� � � � � ��� �� � � ����� � ��

�Ôî�ç!ñ�ð ë�÷�ô2ô2íjï�ê �Dî>è&é!îOûÄú�îJë&è�îDìÄëHõ!î¡ë&ò+ï�êµü)î¡õ�íjüfñ�ú�îJí�òDò+ñ�ï�õÄêµç!ø�è�ñKè&é!î¡êvïHï&ñ óµîOêµçî¡ë�è&êµô2íjè&êµç�øKè&é!î�ò+ñ ôKìfñ ç!î¡çZè&ëHñ�öÇè&é!îJôKñ?õ!î¡ó > þ�� "� " � ����������������� �Oóvè&é!ñ ÷�ø é è&é�êµëJë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�êzç!øÚë�è�îDìgêµë�ìÄï�êµô2íjï�êzóvý<í�êµôKî¡õÔíjè

ø�îDè�è&êµç�ø�íJö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ çKï&îDì�ï&î¡ë&î¡ç/è&íjè&êvñ ç�ñ�öEè&é!î>ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�òD÷�ï&ú�î¡ë �?êvèËí�óµë�ñ%ë�îDï&ú�î¡ëè�ñ�í�ú�îDï�íjø�î%ñ ÷!èHè&é!î�ôKî¡í�ë�÷!ï&î¡ôKî¡çZè�îDï&ï&ñ�ï\ë � � êµç¾è&é�îJï&î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õcë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ëDþ

�� "��� � � " "�� ��é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õ ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çgölñ�ï�î¡í�ò�é ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�êµë�í�ç�êµçZè�îDï�ôKî¡õ�êµíjè�îë�è�îDì è�ñQð�íjï�õÄëKò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è&êµç�øcè&é!î�è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êµñ ç�ë � � � � � �Ãè&é�îDýgòDí�ç�í�óµë�ñ üfîú?êvîDð�î¡õ�í�ëKí�ç í�õ�õÄêvè&êvñ ç�í�óÃò+ñ ôKìfñ ç!î¡ç/è�ñ�ö>è&é!îÚôKñ.õ�î¡ó �Sí�ëKêµë%è&é!î ìÄï&î¡ë&ë&÷!ï�îë&êµø ç�í�óÎþ

�� "�! �#" �$� "&%(' )* ����� ��é�êµë�ë�è�îDì ì�ï&ñ?õ�÷�ò+î¡ë�î¡ë�è&êµô�íjè�î¡ëÔñ�ö�è&é!î�ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë� � � � � ð é�êzò�éÚöBñ�ï>î¡í�ò\é ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�ò+ñ ç/ú�îDï�è>è&êµô2î�è�ñ í�ú_í�óz÷!î�öBñ�ï è&é!î%÷�ç�êvú�îDï&ùë&í�ó)ìÄíjï\í�ôKîDè�îDï � è&é�íjè�êµçÄõ!î��.î¡ë�è&é!î²è�î¡ôKì�óµíjè�î�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î '�þ � é!î�÷�ç�êvú�îDï�ë�í�óìÄíjï\í�ôKîDè�îDï�êµë êµõ�î¡ç/è&ê®û�î¡õ<ð êvè&écè&é!î%è&êµôKî�ì�íjï�í�ôKîDè�îDï²ñ�öSè&é!î%ï&îDì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&íjè&êvú�îë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&îcêzç ë�è�îDì ..þ���é!î ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�î¡ç�ò+î¡ë�õ!îDï\êvú�î¡õ è&é�îDï&îcì�ï�ñ�ú?êµõ!î¡õ íô2íjìÄìÄêµç!ø%ölï�ñ ôÙè&êµôKî�ìfñ êµçZè&ëHêµç¾è&é�íjè ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�è�ñ�è&êµôKî�ìfñ êµçZè&ëyñ çÚî¡í�ò�é�ñ�öè&é!î�ñ�è&é�îDï>ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ë��!è&é!î¡ë&îJô2íjì�ìÄêµç�ø ëHíjï&îJè&é!î¡çÚî¡ë&è&êµô2íjè�î¡ë�ñ�ö � ' �� þ

�� "�,+ � � " �� " �� ' �*�-�� ��é�î�ï&îDölîDï�î¡ç�ò+î�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&îJêµë�ë&îDø ôKî¡ç/è�î¡õ�íjè�ìfñ êµçZè&ëHñ�öóvñQð ë&ì)îDî¡õ�êµçZè�ñ%í�ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+îOñ�ö � � ��� �Xþ/.>ë�êµç!ø�è&é�îOò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ëÃî¡ë�è&íjü!ùóµêzë&é!î¡õ¾êµçÚë�è�îDì . ��í�óµófè&é!î�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë�íjï�îJë&êµô2êµózíjï�óvý2ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè�î¡õEþ

�� "��0 � ��é�êzë ë�è�îDì ò+ñ ô2ìÄ÷!è�î¡ë¾è&é!î è�î¡ôKìÄózíjè�î$' í�çÄõ è&é!î ìÄêvî¡ò+îDð êµë&î ò+ñ ç�ë&è&í�ç/èö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çÄë � � ��� � í�ç�õ � ��� � öBñ�ï2î¡í�ò�é ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�þ ��ñ�ï�újí�óµ÷!î¡ë�ñ�ö � ò+ñ�ï�ùï&î¡ë&ì)ñ çÄõ�êµç!ø�è�ñÔè&é!î � è&é óvîDè�è�îDï � � $� ��� � � �(' ���� í�ç�õ � ��� � � ��� þ ��é�î

� "

Page 20: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

ï&î¡ë�êµõ�÷�í�óµë�ölï&ñ ô è&é!î�í�� ç!îKí�ú�îDï�íjø êµç!øÚêµç ë�è�îDì ��íjï&î�è&é�î%ï�î¡ô2í�êµç�õ!îDï>è�îDï�ô2ë� � þ� � ����� � � � � ��� �� �� ��� � � � �

� é!î¡çgí<ç!îDð�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&îKì�ï&î¡ë&î¡ç/è&ë�öBñ�ïJú�îDï�êvû�òDíjè&êvñ ç �:ë&è�îDìÄë � � /cíjï&î�ï&îDìfî¡íjè�î¡õ &�æ¨èêµë2ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é!î¡õsí�çÄõsêvè&ë2ë�ìfîDî¡õsë�êvø ç�í�óHêµë2ò+ñ ô2ìÄ÷!è�î¡õEþ � é�êµëKë�ìfîDî¡õ�ë&êvø çÄí�ó�êµë�è&é!î¡çè&êµôKî�ð�íjï&ìfî¡õ�íjø í�êµç�ë�è�è&é!î¾ë�ìfîDî¡õ�ë&êvø ç�í�óÃölñ�ï�è&é!î�è�î¡ôKìÄózíjè�î¾ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î��Sí�ç�õ�è&é!îò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+î%êµë>î¡ë�è&íjüÄózêµë&é!î¡õEþ��Ëý.ìÄêµòDí�óµóµý¾í�öBñ�ï&ø�îDï&ýcòDí�ç üfî�êzõ!î¡ç/è&êvûÄî¡õcíjè²è&é�êµëë�è&íjø�î�ü)î¡òDí�÷Äë�î�ñ�ö�è&é�î�óµíjï&ø�î�ë�ìfîDî¡õcõÄêµë&ò+ï&îDìÄí�çÄò+ý�ï�îDì)ñ�ï�è�î¡õcü.ýÚè&é!î�è&êzôKî�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç�øì�ï&ñ?ò+î¡õ�÷!ï&î�þ¾æ7öyç�ñ�è �è&é!î�ç!îDð ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î êµë�ë�îDø ô2î¡ç/è�î¡õ �Çè&é!î�óvîDè�è�îDï�ë%íjï&î í���ç!î¡óvýè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ôKî¡õ�è�ñ�ô2íjè&ò�é�è&é!î�è�î¡ôKìÄózíjè�î�� í�ç�õ�óvî¡í�ë�èÇë��Z÷Äíjï&îÃõ�êzë�è&í�ç�ò+î¡ëÇíjï&îyò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è�î¡õñ ç2í�óvîDè�è�îDï�üÄí�ë�êµë ü)îDè¨ðÃîDî¡ç2è&é!îHè6ð�ñ!þ ��é!î¡ë�îHõ�êzë�è&í�ç�ò+î�ë�è&íjè&êµë&è&êµòDëSòDí�çKüfîHò+ñ ôKìÄíjï&î¡õè�ñ�è&é�î � ë&êµô2êµózíjï õ�êµë�è&í�çÄò+î¡ë öBñ�ï²è&é!î�ñ�ï\êvø êµç�í�óë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ë öBï&ñ ô è&é!î�è�î¡ô2ìÄóµíjè�î�þ²æ¨èêµë�î��?è�ï&î¡ôKî¡óvýÔ÷�ç�ózê1<�î¡óvýcè&éÄíjè�íÚöBñ�ï&ø�îDï�òDí�ç�ô2êµô�êµò%ü)ñ�è&é è&é!î�ë&é�íjìfî�í�çÄõÔï&î¡óµíjè&êvú�îë�ìfîDî¡õ<ð êvè&écð é�êµò\é<í2ìfîDï�ë&ñ çcë&êvø çÄëHè&é!î¡êvïOç�í�ôKî�þ �Çêvø ÷!ï&î � ñ ç�ìÄíjø�î4��ë&é!ñ�ð>ë è&é!îï&î¡ë&÷�óvè&ëyñ�öSë&÷Äò�é<íKú�îDï\ê®û�òDíjè&êvñ ç<÷Äë&êµç!øKí�öBñ�ï&ø�îDï&ý�þ

� �yä �2Þ2åXä � ��� �Ëß��>å ��æ7çÚè&éÄêµëHë�î¡ò+è&êvñ çcðÃîJî¡ózíjü)ñ�ï\íjè�î�ñ çcë�ñ ôKî�ñ�öè&é!î�è�î¡ò�é�ç�êzòDí�ó±õ!îDè&í�êµóµë�ø óvñ ë&ë�î¡õÚñQú�îDï>êµçè&é!îJì�ï&îDú?êvñ ÷�ëHë&î¡ò+è&êvñ çEþ

����� ��� �� � � � �

�Ôî ë&ô2ñZñ�è&é è&é!î�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&îÚü.ýsë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç!øÔî¡í�ò\é ò+ñZñ�ï�õÄêµç�íjè�îcë�îDì�íjï�íjè�î¡óvýs÷�ë&êzç!øí òD÷!üÄêµò¾ë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�êzç!ø ë&ìÄóµêµç!î¾ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é!îDï � � " � $�þsæ7ö è&é!îÚñ�ü�ë�îDï&ú�î¡õsë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î<ë�î+ù�Z÷!î¡çÄò+î²êzë�õ�î¡ç!ñ�è�î¡õ�üZý� � � � � � � þDþDþ � � �!ôKî¡í�ë�÷!ï&î¡õ¾íjèHè&êµôKîOìfñ êµç/è&ë ��� �!è&é!î¡ç�è&é!îë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é!î¡õ<ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î � � � � ô�êµç�êµô2ê �Dî¡ëÃè&é�îJò+ï�êvè�îDï�êvñ ç

��� � � �� � � � � � � � � ����� �� ��� � � � � ��

�� � � ) �ñ�ú�îDïÃí²ë&÷Äêvè&íjüÄóvî�3.ñ�üfñ óvîDú�ë�ìÄí�ò+îHñ�ö�öB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë ��í�ç�õ%öBñ�ï�ë�ñ ôKîyújí�óµ÷!îyñ�öÄè&é!îHë&ô2ñZñ�è&é?ùêµç!ø ìÄíjï�í�ôKîDè�îDï � þ ��é�êµë%ò+ï�êvè�îDï\êvñ ç�í�ç�õ êvè&ëKë�ñ óµ÷�è&êvñ ç êµëKêµçZè�îDï&î¡ë�è&êµç!ø öBñ�ï�ë�îDú�îDï�í�óï&î¡í�ë�ñ ç�ë�&

' è&é!î<ûÄï�ë�è2ì�íjï&è2ñ�ö�è&é!î ò+ï�êvè�îDï�êvñ çsî¡ç�ò+ñ ÷!ï�íjø�î¡ë û�õ!î¡ózêvè6ý�è�ñgè&é!î õ�íjè&í �Hð é�êzóvîè&é!î�ë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õ ì�íjï&è>î¡çÄò+ñ ÷!ï�íjø�î¡ëJë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�ç�î¡ë&ëOüZý<ìfî¡ç�í�ózê��¡êµç!ø2ï�îDø êvñ ç�ëOñ�öËé�êvø é

> �

Page 21: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

òD÷!ï�ú_íjè&÷!ï�î��è&é!î�ìfî¡ç�í�óvè6ý � ô2î¡í�ë&÷!ï&î¡ë>è&é!î¡ë�î%è6ð�ñÚò+ñ ç � êµò+è&êµç�ø2ø�ñ í�óµë²íjø í�êµç�ë�èî¡í�ò\é<ñ�è&é!îDï¡þ

' ��é�î2ò+ï�êvè�îDï�êvñ çÔêzë�ï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç~êµç/újíjï�êµí�çZè �:í�ç�õgé!î¡ç�ò+î�êvè&ë�ë�ñ óµ÷!è&êvñ çÔêzë�ï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ çî��.÷�êvújíjï�êµí�çZèDþ�3?ñ êvö ðÃî%ï&ñ�è&íjè�î%è&é!î�ìfñ êµçZè&ë ��Sì�ï�êµñ�ï�è�ñ ë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�êzç!ø��Äð�î�ø�îDèî��!í�ò+è&óvýsè&é!î�ï&ñ�è&íjè�î¡õ ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é ñ�ö�è&é!î�÷�ç�ï&ñ�è&íjè�î¡õ ì)ñ êzç/è&ëDþ 3!êµô2êµóµíjï\óvý��Ëè&é!îë�ñ óz÷!è&êvñ çÚêµëyî��.÷�êvújíjï�êµí�çZèH÷�ç�õ!îDï�÷�çÄêvölñ�ï\ô ë�òDí�óvî�ò�éÄí�ç!ø�î¡ëDþ

' ��é�î ò+ï�êvè�îDï�êµñ ç2ë�îDìÄíjï�íjè�î¡ëyêµçZè�ñ�è&é�î>ë&÷�ô ñ�öEè6ð�ñ%ò+ï\êvè�îDï�êµí �Zñ ç!î öBñ�ïËî¡í�ò\é�ò+ñ.ñ�ï�ùõ�êzç�íjè�î�þ ��é!î¡ë�î%î¡í�ò�égé�í¡ú�î2í�ë�íÚë�ñ óz÷!è&êvñ ç�è&é!îK÷�ç�êvújíjï�êµíjè�î%ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é ñ�öËè&é!î¡êvïò+ñ.ñ�ï�õ�êµçÄíjè�î�ú_í�óµ÷�î¡ë�íjø í�êµç�ë�èHè&êzôKî�þ

' ��é�î>ë�ñ óµ÷�è&êvñ ç�ò+ñ.ñ�ï�õ�êµçÄíjè�î ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ëÃíjï&î²òD÷!üÄêµò�ë&ìÄóµêµç!î¡ë�ð êvè&é <?ç!ñ�è&ëyíjè�î¡í�ò�éñ�ö.è&é!î�è&êµô2îSì)ñ êzç/è&ë ��� �jí�ë:ë&÷�ò�éJè&é!îDý�òDí�çJüfîSîDú_í�óz÷�íjè�î¡õ�íjè � � è&êzôKîSìfñ êµç/è&ë �ç!ñ�è ��÷Äë�è�è&é!î ñ�ï�êvø êµçÄí�ó � � þ 3!êµç�ò+î2è&é!îDý íjï�î ìÄêµî¡ò+îDð êµë�î�òD÷�üÄêµò2ìfñ óvý?ç!ñ ô2êzí�óµë �è&é!î¡êµïyûÄï�ë�è�í�ç�õÚë&î¡ò+ñ ç�õcõ!îDï\êvú_íjè&êµú�î¡ë�íjï&îJí¡újí�êµóµíjü�óvî�îDú�îDï&ý.ð é!îDï&î�í�ë�ðÃî¡óµó�þ

��é!î�ë�ñ óµ÷�è&êvñ ç%ú_íjï�êµî¡ëSõ!ï�í�ô2íjè&êµòDí�ózóvýJð êvè&é�è&é�îHú_í�óµ÷�î�ñ�ö)è&é!î�ë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�êzç!ø>ì�íjï�í�ôKîDè�îDï �ð é�êµò\é é�í�ë�è�ñ�üfî>ë&÷�ì�ìÄóµêvî¡õ±þ �Ôî�÷�ë�îOè&é!î²ò+ï&ñ ë&ë#ù�újí�óµêµõ�íjè�î¡õ �.êµçZè�îDø�ï�íjè�î¡õ ���Ã÷�òDóµêµõ�î¡í�çë��Z÷Äíjï&î¡õ<õ�êµë&è&í�ç�ò+î �

� ��� � � ��� � � ���

� � ���� ��� � � � � ���

� � �

í�ë>í ò+ï�êvè�îDï�êvñ ç<ölñ�ïOë�î¡óvî¡ò+è&êµç!ø � þ�(>îDï&î � � � ��� � ��� � êµëHè&é�î�újí�óµ÷!î�ñ�öSè&é!î%ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&écòD÷!ï&ú�îîDú_í�óµ÷Äíjè�î¡õ íjè � � �Zè&é�î>ë&÷!ü�ë&ò+ï�êvì�è � � � êµç�õÄêµòDíjè�î¡ëSè&é�íjèÃè&é!î � è&é�ìfñ êµç/èÃêvè&ë�î¡óvö)ð�í�ëÃñ ô2êvè#ùè�î¡õ�êµçJè&é!î�ûÄè�è&êzç!ø�ñ�ö?è&é!îÃòD÷�ï&ú�î�þ � é�êµë±ò+ï�êµè�îDï�êvñ çJë�îDï�ú�î¡ë÷�ë:ðÃî¡ózó �Që&êzç�ò+îËêvè±ï�î¡ò+ñ�ø ç�ê��Dî¡ëè&é!î�ë&êµø ç�í�ó±êµçÚè&é�î�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î���í�ç�õcë�î¡óvî¡ò+è&ëOí2újí�óµ÷!îJöBñ�ï � ë&÷�ò\é<è&é�íjè>ñ ç�óvý�î¡ç!ñ ÷!ø éë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç!ø êzë±ìfîDï&öBñ�ï�ôKî¡õ�è�ñOî¡óµêµô2êzç�íjè�îSè&é!îÃë�ô2í�óµó/í�ô2ñ ÷�ç/èñ�ö�ôKî¡í�ë&÷!ï�î¡ôKî¡ç/èîDï&ï&ñ�ï¡þ

��� � � � ��� � � ����� � � � � ��� � � ����� �

( îDï&î¾ð�î ø êµú�î¾í�õÄõ�êvè&êvñ ç�í�ó ��÷Äë�è&ê®û�òDíjè&êvñ çgölñ�ïK÷�ë�êµç!øcè&é�î�ë�ìfîDî¡õ�ë&êvø ç�í�ózë�î��?è�ï�í�ò+è�î¡õölï&ñ ô è6ð�ñ ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ë�í�ë%í<üÄí�ë&êzë�ölñ�ï%î¡ë�è&íjüÄózêµë&é�êµç�ø¾í�ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�î¡ç�ò+î��ñ�ï%è&êµôKî+ùð�íjï&ì�êµç!ø!þ

��é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õcñ�öÃí õ�ê1))îDï&î¡çZè&êµíjüÄóµî�òD÷!ï&ú�î%ìÄíjï�í�ô2îDè�ï�ê��Dî¡õ üZý � êzë è&é!î�í�ôKñ ÷�çZè²ñ�öíjï�òXù6óvî¡ç!ø�è&é ò+ñ�ú�îDï&î¡õ�ìfîDï ë&ô2í�ózó±÷�ç�êvèHñ�ö � �Äí�ç�õcêzë�ò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è�î¡õ�í�ë�è&é!î�ç!ñ�ï�ô ñ�öÇè&é!îò+ñZñ�ï�õÄêµç�íjè�î�õ!îDï\êvú_íjè&êµú�îOö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ ç &

� � � � � ����' � � � ���

> �

Page 22: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

��é!îyòD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&îyöB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç%ôKî¡í�ë&÷!ï&î¡ë è&é!îHç!ñ�ï\ô2í�óZò+ñ ô2ì)ñ ç�î¡ç/èÇñ�ö�í�òDò+î¡óµîDï�íjè&êvñ ç�ï&î¡óµí_ùè&êvú�îHè�ñJë�ìfîDî¡õ � í�ç�õKêµçZú�ñ óvú�î¡ëÇè&é!î�ë&î¡ò+ñ ç�õKõ!îDï�êvújíjè&êvú�î¡ëÇñ�ö)è&é!îHò+ñZñ�ï\õ�êµç�íjè�îyö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë� � � � "%$ �Äì�íjø�î )#> � &

� � � � ����' � � � ��� � � ���

����' � � � ���

$ � �

( îDï&î � � � � êµë�í~ç!ñ�ï\ô2í�ó�ú�î¡ò+è�ñ�ï<è�ñ�è&é!î òD÷!ï&ú�îÔíjè��\þ �!ñ�ïÚí�ìÄóµí�ç!îcòD÷�ï&ú�î�� è&é!îòD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&î²íjè�í%ìfñ êµçZèÃêµëÃí�óµë�ñ%ø êvú�î¡ç�üZý2è&é�îOêµçZú�îDï�ë�îOï�í�õ�êz÷�ë�ñ�ö±è&é�îOòDêvï\òDóvî��Zè&í�ç�ø�î¡ç/èè�ñKè&é!îOòD÷�ï&ú�î�íjè�è&éÄíjè�ìfñ êµçZè �.è&é�íjèHô2íjè&ò�é!î¡ë�è&é!î�òD÷!ï&ú�îOè�ñ2ë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õ�ñ�ï�õ!îDï � ñ�ï�ôKñ�ï&îë&êµôKìÄóµý��Äè&é�íjèOûÄè&ëOë&ç.÷!ø óvý<êµçZè�ñ è&é�î%òD÷!ï�ú�î%íjè²è&é�íjèOìfñ êµç/è � þ;�OëOòDí�ç üfî�ë&îDî¡ç ölï&ñ ôè&é!î¡êvïÇölñ�ï\ô�÷�ózíjî�è&é�îyë&ì)îDî¡õKí�çÄõ%òD÷�ï&ú_íjè&÷�ï&îyñ�ö�íOìÄíjï�í�ôKîDè�ï\ê��Dî¡õKòD÷!ï&ú�îHíjï&î�êµçZújíjï�êµí�çZè÷�ç�õ!îDïJï\êvø êµõ üfñ.õ�ýcè�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç�ë � óµñ.òDíjè&êvñ ç~ë&é�êvöBè&ë�í�ç�õgï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç�ë � þ � é�íjè�êµëç!ñ�è%ë&ñ íjì�ì�íjï&î¡ç/è�ölï�ñ ô � � êµë�è&é�íjè�è&é�î�òD÷!ï�ú_íjè&÷!ï�î�ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç~êµë�êzç�õ!îDìfî¡ç�õ!î¡çZè�ñ�öè&é!î ìÄíjï\í�ôKîDè�ï�ê��¡íjè&êvñ ç�ñ�öEè&é!î òD÷!ï�ú�î ' �.è&é�êµë�êzë�ç!ñ�èËè�ï\÷!î�öBñ�ïËè&é!îOë�ìfîDî¡õKöB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç2êµçø�î¡ç!îDï�í�óÎþ ��é�êµëEêzç/újíjï�êµí�ç�ò+îÃêµë±òDóvî¡íjï�óµýOí>õ!î¡ë&êvï�íjü�óvîÇölî¡íjè&÷!ï�îËöBñ�ïí�òDí�ç�õÄêµõ�íjè�î�ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çölñ�ï%è&êµôKî ð�íjï&ì�êµç!ø!þ �!ñ�ï%î��?í�ôKì�óvî��Çñ ç!î òDí�ç~ï&îDìÄíjï�í�ô2îDè�ï�ê��Dî í�ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é~òD÷�ï&ú�î�è�ñé�í¡ú�î %*� � � ����Së�ìfîDî¡õ �)í�óµè&é!ñ ÷!ø é è&é!î�ë&é�íjìfî¡ë�ñ�ö�è&é�î%òD÷!ï�ú�î¡ë>ð�ñ ÷�óµõ�üfî�êµõ�î¡ç/è&êµòDí�ó �è&é!î¡êvï ë�ìfîDî¡õ¾ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çÄëyðÃñ ÷�ózõ¾ü)îJ÷Äë�î¡óvî¡ë&ëHöBñ�ï�è&é!î�ì�÷!ï&ìfñ ë�î²ñ�öè&êzôKî+ù�ð�íjï�ìÄêµç!ø!þ

� î��?è�ð�î2êµçZè�ï&ñ?õ�÷�ò+î2ë&òDí�óvî2êzçÔí�õ�õ�êvè&êvñ ç è�ñcè&é!îKï�êvø êµõ!ù�ü)ñ?õ!ý<è�ï\í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ ç�ë¡þ3?÷!ì�ìfñ ë�î¾è&é!î¡ç�è&éÄíjè�ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î > êµëKë&êµô2ìÄóvýgí ë�òDí�óvî¡õ �Ëï�ñ�è&íjè�î¡õ í�ç�õ è�ï\í�ç�ë&óµíjè�î¡õú�îDï�ë&êvñ çÚñ�öSë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î � �ÄíjèOóvî¡í�ë�èHñ�ú�îDï²í2ë&ô�í�óµófë�îDø ôKî¡çZè ñ�öÇî¡í�ò�éEþ

� � ��� � � ' ��� ��� ��� � � � ' ��� � �! � " �

ð é!îDï&î� êµëyñ�ï&è&é�ñ�ø�ñ ç�í�óÎþ �>ñ�è�î�è&é�íjè�� � í�ç�õ õ!ñ2ç�ñ�è õ!îDìfî¡ç�õ�ñ ç � þæ¨è êµëKî¡í�ë�ý�è�ñgò\é!î¡ò�<�è&éÄíjè�üfñ�è&é�è&é!î¡êvï ë�ìfîDî¡õsí�ç�õsòD÷!ï�ú_íjè&÷!ï�îÚöB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç�ë2íjï&î

ì�ï&ñ�ìfñ�ï&è&êvñ ç�í�ó����� ��� � � � ����� ��� �� � � ��� � � � � � ��� ��� � � ��� �

� ñQð �)êµöÇêzç�ë�è�î¡í�õÚñ�öSñ�üÄë&îDï&ú.êzç!ø2è&é!î � � í�ë>í�öB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ çÚñ�ö � �Äð�î�ñ�üÄë�îDï�ú�î � � � � �� � ��� � � � � $ � � � � � > ��è&é!î¡çÚöBï&ñ ôÙè&é!î�íjüfñQú�î

��� � � � � � � ��� � � �� ��� � � ��� �

êvö � � � � � � � � � � � þ²æ7ç ñ�è&é!îDï²ð�ñ�ï�õ�ëOè&é!î�òD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&î¡ë²íjè²è&é!î%è6ð�ñ<ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êzç!øì)ñ êzç/è&ëOñ ç è&é!îKë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ëOï&î¡ô2í�êµç è&é!îKë&í�ô2î � ÷�ìÔè�ñ�è&é�î%ö�í�ò+è�ñ�ï�� � �:õ!î¡ë�ìÄêµè�î�è&é!îöBí�ò+èKè&é�íjèKè&é�îDý~é�í�ú�îÚü)îDî¡ç�ìÄíjï\í�ôKîDè�ï�ê��Dî¡õ�õ�ê1))îDï&î¡çZè&óvý�þÔæ7èKí�óµë�ñÔë�îDî¡ô2ëKêµçZè&÷�êvè&êµú�îè&é�íjè �>êvö�ð�î <.ç!ñQð��sí�çÄõ êvö � êzë�ç!ñ ç?ù6ò+ñ çÄë�è&í�ç/è �>ðÃî ë&é!ñ ÷Äóµõsüfî�íjü�óvîcè�ñ�ë�ñ óvú�î

>#>

Page 23: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

� ��� � ' �� � � � �� �=� ölñ�ï �� Oø êvú�î¡çÚí�ç/ý ú_í�óz÷!î²ñ�ö ���¡þ ��é�êµëÃñ�ìfîDï�íjè&êvñ ç¾ñ�öë&ñ óvú.êzç!ø%ë�÷�ò�éî��Z÷�íjè&êµñ ç�ë�öBñ�ï�í�óµó�újí�óµ÷!î¡ë�ñ�ö � ��ü.ý ô2íjè&ò\é�êµç!ø�ú_í�óµ÷�î¡ë�ñ�ö�í�ò+ñ ô2ôKñ ç~öB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ çgêµëè&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç!ø!þ

�>ëHô2î¡ç/è&êvñ ç�î¡õ�è&é!î�ë�ìfîDî¡õ öB÷Äç�ò+è&êvñ ç�õ!ñZî¡ëyç!ñ�èHêµç�ø�î¡ç!îDï�í�óEé�í�ú�î²è&é�êµëÃìÄíjï�í�ôKîDè#ùï�ê��¡íjè&êvñ ç<êzç/újíjï�êµí�ç�ò+î��

� � � � � � � ����' � ��� � � �=� ���

������ � � ��

���

� � � � � � � � ����' � � � � �=� ���

������ � � ��

���

� ��> �

� êµø ÷!ï&î " & ��� ��� � � � 3?÷�ï&î¡ë&é �²ñ�ý í�ó � ë ����������� ��� � �*� �� ��� � �% � � � ���� �� ���� � � �������� � ��� �� � � %�� � � �9 � � ������� � � � � ��� ����������� ����� �� � � ,� ��� ��� � ��� � � %�� � � �9 ��� � � �� �!� � ��� ����������� � � � � ��%�� � ����� )� � � � � � ��� ������ � %�� � � �9 ���#� � � � *%��� � � � � ��%�� � ��� # )� � � � ���� � �� ���, �� � � � � �������� ��, ��� � %� ��� ��� ��� � �:�� ���� � � � ������ ��� ���8�7�����&� � � � � ���� ��� � ���� � �#� ������� �%*� �� �#� � ��� � �����6%7� -, ����� � � �% � � � ���� ����������� ���

( ñQðÃîDú�îDï �î¡ôKì�êvï�êµòDí�óîDú.êzõ!î¡ç�ò+î��±í�ë�î��!é�êvüÄêµè�î¡õ�êµç�ûÄø ÷�ï&î /��:ë&÷!ø�ø�î¡ë�è&ë²è&éÄíjè�ölñ�ï

> .

Page 24: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î¡ë �Zì�íjï�í�ôKîDè�ï�ê��Dî¡õ�ü.ý2ð�ï�êµè&êµç!øJè&êµô2î��.ë�ìfîDî¡õ�í�ç�õ¾òD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&î²íjï&î²êµç/ú�îDï\ë�î¡óvýï&î¡óµíjè�î¡õ � òD÷!ï�ú_íjè&÷!ï�î é�í�ëÚísë&êvø ç � ð é�êzò�é�í�òDò+ñ ÷�çZè&ë<öBñ�ïÚè&é!î ë�ý?ô2ôKîDè�ï�êzò�ì�í�êvïÚñ�öï&î¡óµíjè&êvñ ç�ë�é�êvìÄëOð êvè&éÔë&ì)îDî¡õÔêzç ûÄø ÷!ï&î / � þ � é�êµë²ô2í <�î¡ë�êzç/è&÷�êµè&êvú�îKë�î¡ç�ë�î#&Jð�î2ç!îDî¡õè�ñ2ë&óvñ�ð õ�ñ�ð ç�è�ñKè&÷!ï�ç¾ë&éÄíjï&ìÚò+ñ�ï�ç!îDï�ëDþ �Ãíjï�óµêvîDï�ð�îJë&÷!ø�ø�î¡ë�è�î¡õÚè&éÄíjè�è&é�î²í�ò+è&êµñ çÚñ�öë&êvø ç�êµç�ø�êµë²ü�í�óµóµêµë�è&êzò�êµçÔç�íjè&÷�ï&î��:í�ç�õ ð�î2òDí�çÔìÄ÷�ë�é�è&éÄêµë�íjï&ø ÷�ôKî¡çZèJíÚüÄêµè>ö�÷!ï&è&é!îDïé!îDï&î�þ � é�î¡ç ð�î ë�ð êzç!ø<í<ð�î¡êvø éZè�è&êvî¡õgè�ñcè&é!î î¡ç�õ ñ�öHícë&è�ï�êµç!ø<êµç~í<òDêvï�òDóµî��è&é!îç!ñ�ï�ô2í�ó�í�òDò+î¡óµîDï�íjè&êvñ ç êµë2ò+ñ ç�ë�è&í�çZè¾í�ç�õsêµëKìÄï&ñ�ìfñ�ï&è&êvñ ç�í�óyè�ñ~è&é!îcò+ñ ç�ë�è&í�çZè�öBñ�ï�ò+îðÃî ç!îDî¡õ è�ñ�î��?îDï&èÚêµç ô2í�êµçZè&í�êµç�êµç!ø~è&é!îÔôKñ�è&êvñ çEþ �Ãý í�ç�í�óvñ�ø�ý��²êvöJð�î î��.îDï&è<íç!î¡íjï�óvý ò+ñ ç�ë�è&í�çZèJöBñ�ï�ò+î � ç!ñ�ï�ô�í�óÇè�ñ<è&é!î�òD÷!ï�ú�î � ð é!î¡çÔð�î2ë�ð�îDîDìgñ ÷!è�è&é!î2íjï\òKñ�öí�óµîDè�è�îDï �>è&é�î ç�ñ�ï�ô2í�ó²í�òDò+î¡óvîDï�íjè&êvñ ç ð>êµóµó�üfî ò+ñ ç�ë�è&í�çZèDþ �y÷!è¾öBï&ñ ô � � ðÃîÔë�îDîè&é�íjèJë&êµç�ò+î�è&é!îKç.÷�ôKîDï�íjè�ñ�ï�êµëOì�ï&î¡òDêµë�î¡óµý<è&é�êµë²ç!ñ�ï�ô�í�ó í�òDò+î¡óµîDï�íjè&êvñ ç �è&é�êµë²êµôKìÄózêvî¡ë��� � � ��� � � �

� � � � þ ��é�êµëHíjï&ø ÷ÄôKî¡ç/è>êµëyì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè�î¡õ<êµçcôKñ�ï&îJõ!îDè&í�êµó:êµç � � " � $�þÿOöÇò+ñ ÷!ï�ë�î�ï&î¡í�óEë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ëHõ�ñ2ç!ñ�èHüfî¡é�í¡ú�îJî��!í�ò+è&óvý¾êµç¾è&é!îJô2í�çÄç!îDï�êµõ!î¡í�óµê �Dî¡õ

é!îDï&î�þ²ÿ�÷!ïOô2ñ.õ!î¡ó � > � í�óµóvñ�ð>ë ñ�è&é!îDï²õ!îDöBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ çÄë üfî¡ë&êµõ�î¡ë�ï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç í�ç�õ�ø óvñ�üÄí�óë&òDí�óµêµç!ø��Hí�ç�õ í�óµóvñQð ë2è&é!î¡ô è�ñgújíjï&ý ð êvè&é � í�ë ð�î¡óµóÎþ ÿ²÷!ï ô2ñ.õ!î¡ó í�óµë�ñ~í�ózóvñ�ð ëölñ�ï�îDï&ï�ñ�ï�ë�� � ��� � ð é�êµò\écð�îKêvø ç!ñ�ï&î¡õ é!îDï�î��fí�çÄõ�è&é�î�ò+ñ çÄë�è&í�ç/èJí�òDò+î¡óµîDï�íjè&êvñ çÔò+ñ ç?ùò+îDì�è�ð êµóµóíjè�ôKñ ë�è²üfî�óµñ.òDí�óµóµýÚè�ï�÷!î�þ��!ñ�ï�è&÷�ç�íjè�î¡óvý��Eè&é!î�è&êµô2î+ù�ð�íjï&ì�êµç!ø¾í�óvø�ñ�ï�êvè&é�ôñ�ì)îDï\íjè�î¡ë êµçÚí2óµñ.òDí�óEö�í�ë&é�êµñ çÚí�ëHðÃî¡ózóÎþ

��� � � � ��� � �� � ��� �

3?÷!ì�ìfñ ë�î²ð�î�é�í¡ú�î�è6ð�ñ ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ë � òD÷!ï�ú�î¡ë � � � � � � � � � ��� � � �=� � � � � � � � � � �=�

ð é!îDï&î>ü)ñ�è&é � ��í�ç�õ �� �íjï&îOìÄíjï�í�ôKîDè�ï\ê��Dî¡õ�ü.ý � þ0�Ôî²ð êzë&éKè�ñKêµõ!î¡çZè&êvöBý ��ô2íjè&ò\é?ùêµç!ø¾ìfñ êµç/è&ë ��ñ ç üfñ�è&é ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î¡ë �±êÎþ î�þ��EìÄí�êµï�ëOñ�öËìfñ êµçZè&ë>ð>êvè&é è&é!îKë&í�ôKî � ù�újí�óµ÷!î�þ�Ôî%ç!îDî¡õ�è�ñ õ�ñ�è&é�êµë�ñ ç�í�ï&î¡í�ë�ñ ç�íjüÄóµý/ùÎû�ç�îJø�ï�êµõÚñ�ö � ù�ú_í�óz÷!î¡ë ��ç�ñ�è �&÷�ë�è�öBñ�ï>í�ölîDðêµë�ñ óµíjè�î¡õ ��í�ç�ò�é!ñ�ï&ù�ì)ñ êzç/è&ë �cñ�ï ��óµí�çÄõ�ô2íjï�<?ë �?þ � é�êµëJí�ôKñ ÷Äç/è&ë�è�ñcî¡ë�è&êµô�íjè&êµç!ø<è&é!îè&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç!øÔö�÷�ç�ò+è&êµñ ç�ë ��� ��� � í�ç�õ � ��� � þ ��é�êµë�ð êzóµóyñ ç�óvý�üfî<ìfñ ë&ë&êvüÄóµî¾êµö>è&é!îè6ð�ñ òD÷!ï&ú�î¡ë � �Hí�çÄõ �� ��í�óvè&é!ñ ÷!ø é<õÄê*))îDï�î¡ç/è ��ë&éÄíjï&îJë�ñ ôKî�êzç/è�ï�êzç�ë&êµòOò�é�íjï\í�ò+è�îDï�êµë#ùè&êµòKè&é�íjèJújíjï�êvî¡ë�êµçÔìÄíjï�í�ózóvî¡óSí�óvñ ç!øÚè&é!î¡êµïJï&î¡ë�ìfî¡ò+è&êvú�î2ì�íjè&é�ë �:è&éÄíjè�òDí�çgë�îDï�ú�î í�ë�íüÄí�ë&êµëOöBñ�ï²ô�íjè&ò�é�êµç�ø!þJæ7ç è&é!î�ì�ï�îDú.êvñ ÷Äë>ë�î¡ò+è&êµñ ç ðÃîKíjï&ø ÷!î¡õ è&é�íjè�ë�ìfîDî¡õ í�ç�õ òD÷!ï�ùú_íjè&÷!ï�î2íjï&î�ë&÷�ò\é ò�éÄíjï�í�ò+è�îDï�êµë�è&êzòDë �:ø êvú�î¡ç è&é!î2ë�ñ�ï&è&ë�ñ�öyõ�ê*)fîDï&î¡ç�ò+î¡ë²ð�î�í�çZè&êµòDêvìÄíjè�îü)îDè¨ðÃîDî¡ç<è&é!î&� � þ�( ñQðÃîDú�îDï ��í�çÚí�õ�õ�êvè&êvñ çÄí�óÄï&î��.÷�êvï�î¡ôKî¡ç/èyêµëÃè&é�íjèHè&é�êµë�ò�éÄíjï�í�ò+è�îDï�ùêµë�è&êµòyë&é!ñ ÷Äóµõ�üfîHêµçZú_íjï\êµí�ç/è è�ñ�è&é!îyìÄíjï�í�ô2îDè�ï�ê��¡íjè&êvñ ç �Zë�ñ�êvèSòDí�çKüfî�ò+ñ ôKì�÷!è�î¡õ2÷�ë&êzç!øè&é!î � ï�íjè&é!îDïSè&é�í�ç�è&é�î � � ï�îDì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&íjè&êvñ çEþ0�Oóvè&é!ñ ÷!ø éKë�ìfîDî¡õ%ö�í�êµóµëÇêµç%ø�î¡ç!îDï�í�ó!êµçè&é�êµëSï&îDø íjï\õKð é�êµóµî�òD÷!ï�ú_íjè&÷!ï�î õ!ñ.î¡ë�ç!ñ�è �/ð�î íjï&ø ÷�î¡õKè&é�íjè�öBñ�ïËë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î¡ë

> /

Page 25: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

� ìÄíjï�í�ô2îDè�ï�ê��Dî¡õ2ü.ý�è&êµôKî��?òD÷!ï&újíjè&÷!ï&î êzë�íjì�ì�ï&ñ �?êzô2íjè�î¡óvýKêµçZú�îDï�ë�î¡óvý%ì�ï&ñ�ìfñ�ï&è&êvñ çÄí�óè�ñ�è&é!î�ë �Z÷�íjï�îJñ�öSë�ìfîDî¡õEþ ��éÄêµëHôKî¡í�ç�ë è&é�íjè>ë�ìfîDî¡õ<êzë�í�óµë�ñ2î¡ózêvø êvüÄóvî�í�ë>íKüÄí�ë&êµë�ölñ�ïô2íjè&ò�é�êzç!ø��/í�ç�õKë&êzç�ò+îHêvèSêµëÇôKñ�ï&îHï&î¡óµêzíjüÄóvýJò+ñ ôKìÄ÷�è�î¡õ �/êvèÇêµëÇè&é!î�ôKî¡í�ë�÷!ï&îyðÃî�ò\é!ñ ë�î�þ

�� � � ��� � ����� � ��� � � � � ��� � �� � ��� �

�>ý?ç�í�ô2êzò�è&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç�ø � � � � � êµë�í2õ�ý.ç�í�ô�êµò²ì�ï&ñ�ø�ï�í�ô�ô2êµç!ø2ôKîDè&é�ñ.õ�÷�ë�î¡õÚè�ññ�ü�è&í�êµçÚí�ç!ñ ç�óµêzç!î¡íjï � -�"����� � ��� �fè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ ç�üfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç¾è6ð�ñ���ù6õÄêµôKî¡ç�ë&êµñ ç�í�ó �è&êµôKî+ù�újíjï&ý.êzç!ø�ë&êvø ç�í�óµë � �,3 #.%$ � þ ��é!îyè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êµñ çKò+ñ ç�ë&êµë�è&ë�ñ�ö)óvñ?òDí�ó!ë�è�ï&îDè&ò\é�êµç!øñ�ïJò+ñ ôKì�ï&î¡ë&ë�êvñ çcñ�öÃè&é!î�è&êµôKî+ù6í �!êµëOñ�öËî¡êvè&é�îDï²ë�êvø ç�í�óï&î¡óµíjè&êvú�î�è�ñ¾è&é!î�è&êµôKî+ù6í �!êµëOñ�öè&é!î�ñ�è&é�îDï¡þ ��é!î�í�êzô ñ�ö�è&é�î¡ë�î%óµñ.òDí�ó í�õ��&÷�ë�è&ôKî¡çZè&ë²êµë è&é�î%ô2êzç�êµô2ê��¡íjè&êµñ çÚñ�öËë�ñ ôKîø óvñ�üÄí�óÄô2î¡í�ë&÷!ï&î ÷Äë�î¡õKè�ñ �.÷�í�çZè&êvöBý�è&é!î>õ�ê*)fîDï&î¡ç�ò+îHüfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç�è&é�î�è6ð�ñ%ë�êvø ç�í�óµë � ë�÷�ò�éí�ëyè&é!î�óvî¡í�ë�è#ù6ë��.÷�íjï&î¡õ¾îDï&ï�ñ�ïyë�÷�ô2ôKî¡õ ñ�ú�îDï�è&é�îOè�ï\í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ ç�ìÄíjè&éÚêµç è&é!î�òDí�ë�îñ�ö:õ�êµë&ò+ï�îDè�î è&êµôKî²÷�ç�êµè&ëDþ � é!î è�ï�í�çÄë�ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç ìÄíjè&é �.ð é�êµò\é êµëÃë&êµôKì�óvýKí�ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+îñ�öËñ�ï�õ!îDï�î¡õcìÄí�êµï�ë ñ�öÃò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êzç!ø2è&êµôKî�êµç�ë&è&í�ç�ò+î¡ë>êzçcè&é!î%è6ð�ñÚö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ë ��ô2í�ýî¡í�ë&êµóvý üfîcõ!îDè�îDï�ô�êµç!î¡õsêµç í õ!ý?ç�í�ô2êµòÚö�í�ë&é�êµñ çsë�ñ è&é�íjè è&é!îcø óµñ�üÄí�ó ôKî¡í�ë�÷!ï&îcêµëô2êµç�êµô�ê��Dî¡õEþ

æ7çcë�ìfîDî¡ò�éÚï&î¡ò+ñ�ø çÄêvè&êvñ çÚí�ë�ý?ô2ôKîDè�ï�êzò � � � é�í�ë�ü)îDî¡ç¾è&é�îJôKîDè&é!ñ?õÚñ�ö ò\é!ñ êµò+î�è&é!î�ðÃñ�ï\õ � ��� � � �� ��%>êµç�è&é�êµëHò+ñ çZè�î��.è>ôKî¡í�ç�ëyè&é�íjèHñ ç!îJë�êvø ç�í�ófêµëyüfî¡êµç!ø%ð�íjï�ì)î¡õè�ñ ûÄè�ígì�ï&î¡õ!îDè�îDï\ô2êµç!î¡õ�ï�îDölîDï&î¡çÄò+îcë&êvø ç�í�ó�þ (>ñ�ð�îDú�îDï ��ð�î�é�í�ú�î�ò\é!ñ ë�î¡ç è�ñ~÷�ë�îë�ý.ô�ôKîDè�ï�êµò � ��� öBñ�ï�ñ ÷!ï�ðÃñ�ï�<)þ 3.ý?ô2ôKîDè�ï�êzò � ��� í�ózóvñ�ð ë%öBñ�ïKë&êµô%÷�óvè&í�ç!îDñ ÷�ëë�è�ï&îDè&ò�éÄêµç!ø�í�çÄõ ò+ñ ôKìÄï&î¡ë&ë&êvñ ç�ñ�öEè&é!î è¨ðÃñKë&êµø ç�í�óµëSüfî¡êµç!ø�ò+ñ ôKìÄíjï&î¡õ �.è&é!î²ô2íjì�ìÄêzç!øñ�ü�è&í�êµç!î¡õ<ô�í¡ý¾üfîJíjì�ìÄóµêvî¡õ¾è�ñ�î¡êvè&é!îDï ë&êµø ç�í�óEí�ç�õÚï&î¡ë�÷�óvè�êµçÚíKø�ñ.ñ?õ<ô2íjè&ò�é�è�ñ2è&é!îñ�è&é!îDï¡þ �Ôîcì�ï&îDöBîDï2è&é!î�ë�ý.ô�ôKîDè�ï�êµò<íjìÄì�ï&ñ í�ò�é üfî¡òDí�÷�ë�î<è&é�êzë2ôKîDè&é!ñ?õsõ!ñ.î¡ë�ç!ñ�èí�ë&ë&÷�ôKîOêµç�í�çZý2ø êvú�î¡ç�ò+ñ ôKìÄíjï\êµë�ñ ç è&é�íjèÃî¡êµè&é!îDï�ë�êvø ç�í�óÄêzë�è&é!î>è�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�î�þ � üfîDè�è�îDïò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+î%ô2í�ý í�ózë�ñ üfî�í�ò�é�êµîDú�î¡õ õ�÷!î%è�ñ¾è&é!î�öBí�ò+è²è&é�íjè�üfñ�è&é ë&êvø ç�í�óµë²íjï&îü)î¡êzç!øKë&êµô%÷�óvè&í�ç!îDñ ÷�ë�óvý�í�õ��&÷�ë�è�î¡õÚè�ñ2ûÄèHî¡í�ò�é�ñ�è&é!îDï>êzç¾è&é!îJë�ý?ô2ôKîDè�ï�êµò�òDí�ë&î�þ

�Oý.ç�í�ô�êµò�è&êzôKî�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç�ø�é�í�ë%í�óvï&î¡í�õ!ýÔüfîDî¡ç�÷�ë�î¡õ�êµçgí óµêµô�êvè�î¡õgòDíjìÄí�òDêµè6ýgêµçë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î2ú�îDï�ê®û�òDíjè&êµñ ç ë�ý?ë�è�î¡ô2ë � � ( � %$yí�ç�õ�� ��� $ � �Çè�ñ�ô2íjè&ò\égè&é�î � � � � í�ç�õ � � � ë�êvø ç�í�óµëDþ ��é!îcï�î¡ë&÷�óvè&ë�ñ�ö�è&é!î¡ë�î í�óvø�ñ�ï�êvè&é�ô�ë�ð�îDï&î�óµî¡ë&ë�è&éÄí�ç ë&íjè&êzë�öBí�ò+è�ñ�ï�ý� ë�îDî � �!3 #"%$ � �Jõ�÷!î è�ñ�è&é!îÔö�í�ò+è<è&é�íjè<è&é!î � � � � í�çÄõ � � � ï&îDì�ï�î¡ë�î¡ç/è&íjè&êµñ ç�ñ�öè&é!î2ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&îKêµë�ç!ñ�èJêµçZú_íjï\êµí�ç/è�÷�çÄõ!îDï²ï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç í�ç�õÔë�òDí�óµêµç!ø!þ ( î¡çÄò+î��±è&é!îKè&êµôKîð�íjï&ì�êµç!ø¾í�óvø�ñ�ï�êvè&é�ô ð�ñ ÷�óµõ è�ï&ý�è�ñ<ò+ñ ôKìfî¡ç�ë&íjè�îKöBñ�ï²õ�îDú.êµíjè&êµñ ç�ë²êµç ï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç í�ç�õë&òDí�óµêµç!ø�üZý<ë&÷ÄòDò+î¡ë&ë&êvú�î%ôKñ.õÄê®û�òDíjè&êvñ ç�ë êµç<è&é!î�è&êµôKî�í �!êµëDþ��Ôî%ñ ç�è&é!î�ñ�è&é!îDï²é�í�ç�õ÷�ë�î è&é!îÔë�ìfîDî¡õ ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç ñ�öJè&é!îÔë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î��êvè¾òDí�ç ü)î ò+ñ ôKìÄ÷�è�î¡õ êzç í�ë�è&íjüÄóvîöBí�ë&éÄêvñ ç �?êµëÃêzç/újíjï�êµí�çZèÃ÷�çÄõ!îDïËï&ñ�è&íjè&êµñ ç ��í�ç�õ î��Z÷�êµú_íjï�êzí�ç/èÃè�ñ%ø óµñ�üÄí�ó�ë�òDí�óµêµç!ø!þ 3?êµçÄò+îè&é!î è&êµô2î+ù�ð�íjï&ì�êµç!ø�í�óvø�ñ�ï\êvè&é�ô í�ózóvñ�ð ëËölñ�ïyë&óvñQð óvý�újíjï&ý.êzç!ø�ë&òDí�óvîOõ�ê*)fîDï&î¡ç�ò+î¡ëÃêµç2è&é!îë&êvø ç�í�óµë �!è&é!îJë&òDí�óvîJî��.÷�êvújíjï�êµí�çÄò+î²êzë�ç!ñ�è�í�çcêzë&ë&÷!î�þ

> �

Page 26: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

������ ��� �� � � ���

��é!î è6ð�ñsë�ìfîDî¡õ ë�êvø ç�í�óµë�íjï&î îDú_í�óµ÷Äíjè�î¡õ ñ ç í�ø�ï�êzõ ñ�ö�è&êµôKî ì)ñ êzç/è&ë � ðÃî ÷Äë�î íø�ï�êµõ ð êvè&é ï&î¡ë�ñ óµ÷!è&êµñ ç ñ ç!î�ûÄöBè&é è&éÄíjè�ñ�ö�è&é!î�ñ�ï\êvø êµç�í�ó>õ�íjè&í � þ ��é�êµë ï&î¡ë&÷Äóvè&ë�êµçè6ð�ñ¾ë&î��Z÷!î¡çÄò+î¡ë � � � í�ç�õ � � �fñ�ö�óvî¡ç!ø�è&éÄë�� �>í�çÄõ�� _þ��Ãý.ìÄêµòDí�óµóvý¾è&é!î�ç.÷�ô�üfîDï�ë ñ�öë&í�ôKìÄóvî¡õ<ì)ñ êzç/è&ë�� � íjï&îJð êvè&éÄêµç � � % ñ�öÇî¡í�ò�é�ñ�è&é!îDï¡þ ��é!î�ø�ñ í�ó±ñ�öÇè&é!î�í�óvø�ñ�ï�êvè&é�ôêµëHè�ñ2û)ç�õ<í2ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î+ù6ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î%ô2íjì�ìÄêzç!ø�ü)îDè¨ðÃîDî¡ç�è&é!îJè¨ðÃñ�ë&êvø ç�í�ózëDþ �Ôîõ!î¡ç!ñ�è�îJè&é�êzë�ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�î¡ç�ò+î+ù6ô2íjì�ìÄêzç!ø�ü.ý¾í2ë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+îJñ�ö ñ�ï�õ!îDï&î¡õ<ìÄí�êvï�ë � � ��� � þ

��é!î�ë�ý.ô�ôKîDè�ï�êµò � ��� í�óµø�ñ�ï�êvè&é�ô ð>é�êµò�égðÃî�÷�ë�î�êzë�í<ü�í�ë&êµòKñ ç!î�þ ��êvú�î¡ç~íò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+î � ��� � � ü)îDè¨ðÃîDî¡ç � � � í�ç�õ � � �!í�óµóvñ�ðyíjüÄóvî>öB÷�è&÷!ï&î>ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ëêµç�òDóµ÷�õ�î�è&é�ñ ë�î üfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç � ��� �� �Ãí�ç�õ � � � � ����� �� �Ëí�ç�õ � � �� � �Zí�ç�õ������ � í�ç�õ � � �� �+þ�>ëyí%ø óvñ�üÄí�ó)ò+ñ ç�ë�è�ï�í�êzç/è�ðÃîOî¡ç!öBñ�ï�ò+î²è&é!î²ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+î üfîDè6ð�îDî¡çÚë�î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+îOú_í�ó®ù÷!î¡ë � � � � � í�ç�õ � � � � � � þ ��é!îÚõ!î¡ë&êµï&î¡õ�ñ�ú�îDï�í�óµó ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡çÄò+î¾êzë%õ�îDè�îDï�ô2êµç!î¡õ÷�ë&êµç!ø�õ!ý.çÄí�ô2êµò�ì�ï&ñ�ø�ï\í�ô2ô2êµç!øcè�ñ ô2êzç�êµô2ê��Dî�è&é!î è�ñ�è&í�ó�ðÃî¡êvø éZè�î¡õ�óvî¡í�ë�è#ù6ë��.÷�íjï&î¡õîDï&ï&ñ�ï�üfîDè¨ðÃîDî¡ç~è&é!î ë&ì)îDî¡õgë&êvø ç�í�óSñQú�îDï�è&é!î ò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+îKìÄíjè&é � í�óµóµñ�ð êµç�øÚölñ�ïóvñ.òDí�óSë�òDí�óvîKí�õ���÷Äë�è&ôKî¡çZèDþ �Ãí�ò�éÔìÄí�êµï � � � � � è&é!îDï�îDölñ�ï&î2éÄí�ë�íÚë&òDí�óvî¡õÔë��.÷�íjï&î¡õ õ�êµë�ùè&í�ç�ò+îKí�ë&ë�ñ?òDêµíjè�î¡õ ð êvè&é êvè �fí�ç�õ è&é!î¡ë�î�íjï&îKë&êµôKìÄóµý¾í�õÄõ!î¡õcñQú�îDï�è&é!î�ìÄíjè&éEþ ��é!î¡ë�îë��Z÷Äíjï&î¡õ<õ�êµë&è&í�ç�ò+î¡ë�êµç¾ñ ÷!ï>òDí�ë�î�íjï&î�ë�êµôKìÄóvý � ��� � � � � � í�õ��&÷�ë�è�î¡õÚêzç¾è6ð�ñ�ðyí¡ý?ë�&

' ��é�î�õ�êµë�è&í�çÄò+î¡ë�í�ë&ë�ñ?òDêµíjè�î¡õ~ð êvè&é ò+ñ�ï�ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ!î¡ç�ò+î¡ë�ñ�öyè&é!î�öBñ�ï�ô � ��� � � � �ñ�ï � ��� � � � � íjï&îÔð�î¡êvø éZè�î¡õ�ü.ý í ö�í�ò+è�ñ�ï � $ � �²ð é�êzóvî�è&é�ñ ë�îÔñ�ö�è&é�îÔölñ�ï�ô� � � � � � � � � íjï&î�ç�ñ�è � õ�÷�ï�êµç!ø¾è&é!î�ò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è&íjè&êvñ çgñ�öyè&é!î2ð�î¡êvø é/è�î¡õ~óvî¡í�ë�è#ùë��.÷�íjï&î¡õ îDï&ï&ñ�ï¡þ � é�êµë²ð�î¡êvø é/è&êzç!øÚø ÷�íjï�í�çZè�îDî¡ë�è&éÄíjè�ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�î¡ç�ò+îKìÄíjè&é�ëð éÄêµò�é�è�ï�í�ú�îDï�ë�î<ï&ñ ÷�è�î¡ëKë&÷�ò�é�í�ë � ��� � ��� � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � ñ�ï� ��� � � � � ��� � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � ð êzóµófç!ñ�è�üfî�ìfî¡ç�í�óµê��Dî¡õ¾ï&î¡ózíjè&êvú�îJè�ñ2è&é!îõ�êµï&î¡ò+èyìÄíjè&é � ��� � � � � ��� � � � � � � � ë�îDî � � #.%$ � þ

' ��é�î�ë�ìfîDî¡õ ë�êvø ç�í�óµë íjï&î êzç�êvè&êµí�óµóµý~ë&òDí�óvî¡õ è�ñ óµêvîcêzç � � � � � þ:��÷!ï�è&é!îDï�ôKñ�ï&î��íÚóvñ?òDí�ó ï&î¡ë&òDí�óµêzç!ø¾è&í <�î¡ëJìÄóµí�ò+îKüfîDöBñ�ï&îKõ�êµë�è&í�çÄò+î¡ë�íjï&î2ò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è�î¡õ &²êzç î5))î¡ò+èñ ç!î�î¡çZè&êvï&îKë�ìfîDî¡õÔòD÷!ï&ú�î2êzëOë�òDí�óvî¡õÔë�ñÚè&é�íjè�è&é!î¡êµï²óµñ.òDí�óSôKî¡í�çÄë � ò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è�î¡õñQú�îDï í�ð êµç�õ�ñ�ð�íjï&ñ ÷�ç�õ¾è&é�î�è&íjï&ø�îDè�ìfñ êµçZè&ë � ò+ñ êzç�òDêµõ!î��?üfîDölñ�ï�î�è&é!î�õ�êµë�è&í�ç�ò+îüfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç<è&é�îJë�ìfîDî¡õ�ë�êµç �.÷!î¡ë�è&êvñ çÚêzë�ò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è�î¡õ±þ

��é�êµë�ózíjè�è�îDï�í�õ��&÷�ë�è&ô2î¡ç/è�ï�î � î¡ò+è&ëËñ ÷�ïÃêµçZè�îDï&î¡ë�èËêzçKè&é!î ï\êµë�î¡ë�í�ç�õ�öBí�ózóµëSñ�öfè&é!î>ë&ì)îDî¡õöB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ çÚí�ë íKü�í�ë&êµëyöBñ�ï ô2íjè&ò�éÄêµç!ø���ï�íjè&é�îDï�è&é�í�çÚè&é!î�í�ò+è&÷�í�ó±óvîDú�î¡óµë íjè�è&í�êµç!î¡õEþ

�Ôîgé�í�ú�î~í�óvè�îDï&î¡õ è&é�îÔüÄí�ë&êµòÔí�óvø�ñ�ï\êvè&é�ô�üZý í�õ�õ�êzç!ø�í�õ�õ�êvè&êvñ çÄí�ó>óvñ?òDí�ó�ò+ñ ç?ùë�è�ï�í�êµçZè&ë �?ð é�êµò\é�ìÄï&ñ é�êvüÄêµè�ôKñ�ï&îOè&é�í�ç�ñ ç!î�é!ñ�ï�ê��Dñ çZè&í�óÄñ�ïHú�îDï�è&êµòDí�ófôKñ�ú�î�êµç�í%ï&ñ�ðJþ��é!î²ìÄ÷!ï&ìfñ ë�îOñ�ö:è&é�î¡ë�îJóvñ?òDí�ó)ò+ñ çÄë�è�ï�í�êµçZè&ëHêµëyè�ñKì�ï&îDú�î¡çZèyè&é!îJô2íjì�ì�êµç!ø�ñ�öÇí�ë&êµç!ø óµîè&êµôKî²êµç�ë�è&í�çZè�êzç2ñ ç!î�ë&êvø çÄí�ó�è�ñKô2í�çZý2è&êµôKî²êµç�ë�è&í�çZè&ë�êµç�è&é�î>ñ�è&é!îDïHë&êµø ç�í�óÎþÇæ7ç ìÄíjï�ùè&êµòD÷�óµíjï �jé�í�ú.êµç�ø è&é!î¡ë�î�ï&î¡ë�è�ï\êµò+è&êvñ ç�ëí�óµóvñ�ð>ë:öBñ�ï ô%÷�ò\é�êµô2ì�ï&ñ�ú�î¡õ%ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè&íjè&êvñ çKí�ç�õ

> )

Page 27: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

ë&é�íjìfî2í�ç�í�óvý?ë&êµë�õ�÷�î%è�ñcè&é!î2ö�í�ò+èJè&é�íjèJè&é!î ô2íjì�ìÄêµç�ø ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çÔõ�ñZî¡ëJç�ñ�è�õ�êµë�è�ñ�ï�èè&é!î�ñ�ï�êµø êµç�í�ófö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç�ëyè�ñ è&é!î�ë&í�ô2î�õ!îDø�ï&îDî%í�ë êµç<è&é!î�òDí�ë�î�ñ�ö ðyíjï&ìÄêzç!øKð êvè&é!ñ ÷�èóvñ.òDí�ó:ò+ñ ç�ë�è�ï�í�êµçZè&ëDþ

��� � ��� � � �!� �� � � �� ����� � � ��� �( îDï&î�ð�î�ø êµú�î%ôKñ�ï�î%õ!îDè&í�êzóµë ñ ç è&é!î�ò+ñ ôKìÄ÷�è&íjè&êvñ ç�ë²êµçcë&è�îDì ) êµç ò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è&êzç!ø�è&é!îí¡ú�îDï�íjø�îKóvîDè�è�îDï¡þ ��î¡òDí�óµóEè&éÄíjè�è&é!î � �Jíjï&î � (> ô2íjè�ï�êzò+î¡ë�ï&îDì�ï�î¡ë�î¡ç/è&êzç!ø2õ�ê*)fîDï&î¡çZèú�îDï�ë&êvñ ç�ëËñ�öfè&é!î ë&í�ôKî>óvîDè�è�îDï �?í�ç�õKð êvè&éKí�ò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�î¡ç�ò+îHüfîDè6ð�îDî¡ç�î¡í�ò\é�ñ�öfè&é!î¡êvïï&ñ�ð ë¡þ ��ñ�ï<ç!ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç�í�ó²ë&êµô2ìÄóµêµòDêvè¨ý~ð�î õ!ï&ñ�ì è&é!î ë�÷!üÄë&ò+ï�êµì�è � þ �Ôî õ!î+û)ç!îcè&é!îí¡ú�îDï�íjø�î � ì�ï&î¡ë&éÄíjì)î � óµîDè�è�îDï �� è�ñ2üfî�è&é!îJô2êµç�êzô2ê��DîDïyñ�ö

��� � ����� � � � � �� ��

� � . �

ñ�ú�îDï ���� � Jí�ç�õ � � þ!�Ôî%é�í¡ú�î�ñ ô2êvè�è�î¡õ�è&é!îJè�îDï�ô�ë � � ��ë�êµç�ò+îJè&é!îDýÚíjï&î�è�ï�êvú?êµí�óµóvýî¡ë�è&êµô2íjè�î¡õ<í�ë " %$� ÷�ë&êµç�ø�è&é!îJò+î¡çZè�ï&ñ êµõ¾ñ�ö � � ölñ�ï � þ ��é!î�ë�è&í�ç�õÄíjï�õ�ì�ï�í�ò+è&êµò+îJêµçë&é�íjìfîKí�ç�í�óvý?ë&êµë � �,� � �%$ � êµëOè�ñcí�óµóvñQð�íjè�ôKñ ë�èJë&êzô2êµóµíjï�êµè6ýÚè�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç�ë���� �ï�íjè&é!îDïËè&éÄí�çKø�î¡ç!îDï�í�ó�ç!ñ ç?ù6ë&êµç�ø ÷�óµíjïÇè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êµñ ç�ë � � �/ð>é!îDï&î�� � íjï�î�ñ�ï&è&é!ñ�ø�ñjùç�í�ó?ï&ñ�è&íjè&êvñ çKô2íjè�ï\êµò+î¡ëDþ0�!ñ�ï�òDêµç�ø�è&é!î � � è�ñ�ü)îHë&êzô2êµóµíjï�êµè6ý²è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êµñ ç�ëSë�îDî¡ô2ëè�ñZñ2ï�î¡ë�è�ï�êµò+è&êvú�î���ë&êµç�ò+î�í�ç<êµçÄõ�êvú?êµõ�÷�í�ó�ô2í¡ýÚç!ñ�èHñ ç�óµý ë&êvø ç<üÄêvø�ø�îDï�ñ�ï ë�ô2í�óµóvîDï �?üÄ÷�èô2í¡ý�í�óµë�ñ�ë �Z÷�í�ë�é�ñ�ïHë�è�ï&îDè&ò\éÚé�êµëÃë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�þ �OóµóvñQð êµç!ø%é�êµô è�ñ%í�óvè�îDïyè&é!î²ë&é!î¡íjïHí�ëðÃî¡óµóÄë�îDî¡ô2ë�è�ñ%òDí�óµó�öBñ�ïË÷�ç�ï&î¡ë�è�ï�êµò+è�î¡õ � � þ0�>óvè&é�ñ ÷!ø é2êvè�ð�ñ ÷�óµõKë&îDî¡ô ôKñ�ï�î ç�íjè&÷!ï�í�óè�ñ�é�í�ú�î%íjìÄìÄóµêvî¡õ¾è&é!î�è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êµñ ç � � è�ñ �� ï�íjè&é!îDï>è&é�í�ç � � è�ñ(� � �)êµç <�îDîDì!ùêµç!øKð êvè&é<ñ ÷!ï ôKñ?õ!î¡ó �!è&é!î�ölñ�ï�ô ðÃî�é�í¡ú�î%ò�é!ñ ë�î¡ç í�õ�ô2êµè&ë�íKö�íjï òDóvî¡í�ç!îDïOë�ñ óµ÷!è&êvñ ç±þ�:ñ í¡ú�ñ êµõ õ!îDø�î¡ç�îDï�í�òDêvî¡ë%ðÃî�êµôKìfñ ë�î2è&é�î�ò+ñ ç�ë&è�ï�í�êµçZè �� $ �� �� �Sí�óvè&é!ñ ÷!ø é~ñ�è&é!îDïî��Z÷�êµú_í�óvî¡çZè�ò+ñ ç�ë�è�ï\í�êµç/è&ë>íjï&î�ìfñ ë&ë&êvü�óvî�þ

æ¨ö � � �� � � êµë è&é!î �>ù � õ!î¡ò+ñ ô2ì)ñ ë�êvè&êvñ çsñ�ö�è&é�î � è&é óµîDè�è�îDï �Hè&é!î¡ç êvè êµëî¡í�ë�ý~è�ñ~ë&é!ñ�ðÙè&éÄíjèKè&é!î¾ñ�ì�è&êµô2í�ó � � êµë�ø êµú�î¡ç üZý � � � ' �� $� �� í�ç�õ�é!î¡ç�ò+î� � � � �� � $� �� þ!3?ñ2íjè�è&é!î�ô2êzç�êµô%÷�ô � � . � êµë

����� � ���

� � $� ��� � �� ���

���� � � è�ï � �� $�� � �� �

� �Eè�ï � �� $ �� �� �

ð é!îDï&î �� êµë è&é!î�í�ú�îDï�íjø�îÔñ�ö�è&é!î ï&î¡ë&êµõ�÷Äí�óHì�ï&ñ���î¡ò+è&êvñ ç ñ�ì)îDï\íjè�ñ�ï�ë � � � � � � � $� � þ 3?êµç�ò+î¾î¡í�ò�é ñ�öOè&é!î � � íjï&î�ë�ý.ô�ôKîDè�ï�êµò¾í�ç�õsç�ñ ç�ç!îDø íjè&êvú�î��Hë�ñ êµë �� þ

> �

Page 28: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

� ñQð ô2êµç�êµô�ê��¡êµç!ø�è�ï � �� $ �� �� � ë&÷�ü �#î¡ò+è�è�ñ �� $ �� � �Oêµë�í�ð�î¡óµó <.ç�ñ�ð ç�î¡êvø�î¡çZú�î¡ò+è�ñ�ïì�ï&ñ�üÄóvî¡ô ��ð êvè&é�ë�ñ óµ÷!è&êvñ ç �� ü)î¡êzç!ø2í2üÄí�ë�êµë�öBñ�ï è&é!î�î¡êvø�î¡ç�ë�ì�í�ò+î%ò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êµç!ø�è�ñè&é!î2è6ð�ñ�ë�ô2í�óµóvî¡ë�è²î¡êvø�î¡çZújí�óµ÷!î¡ëJñ�ö �� þ 3?êµçÄò+îKî¡í�ò�é ñ�öyè&é!î�ì�ï&ñ���î¡ò+è&êvñ çÔñ�ìfîDï�íjè�ñ�ï�ë � $� éÄí�ë2î¡êvø�î¡çZú_í�óz÷!î¡ëKñ�ö �DîDï&ñ ñ�ï ñ ç!î��yè&é!î¡êvï2í¡ú�îDï\íjø�î �� é�í�ëKî¡êvø�î¡çZújí�óµ÷!î¡ë2êµç� � � � $ �:í�ç�õ�è&éZ÷�ëOè&é!î�ë�ñ óµ÷�è&êvñ çcí�óµë&ñ�ò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�ë>è�ñ�è&é�î�è¨ðÃñ ��� �� ���î¡êµø�î¡ç/újí�óµ÷!î¡ëñ�ö ��2þ

�Çêvø ÷!ï&î ��� ë&é!ñQð ë±è&é!îÃè�î¡ôKìÄóµíjè�îËî¡ë�è&êµô2íjè�î¡õ%êµç²è&é�êµë:öBí�ë�é�êvñ ç�öBï&ñ ô ûÄú�îÃñ�ö "� ��*�� ����� � � ��ë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î¡ëDþ

� êµø ÷!ï&î ��� & ��� ����� � �� � �*� � � � ���� �� ��� � ���� � ������������� ����� ����� � � 3?÷!ï&î¡ë�é�Oñ�ý í�ó���� � � � � � ,� � � � � � ����������� ��� ��� ��������������� � ������� ��� ����� � �����&%� �� �:� � � ��� � �&%��$����� �*� � �� %� ���� �235 �� ��", � � � ����,�� �7��� � �� ��, �� ������ ���7% �������� ���, � � �� ��� ��� �:�� � � �� �� ��� � � �*� � � %*� ��� � � ���� � �� � � ��� � �:�&������ ��� 2� � ��� �� ��� �� � � ���

3.ñ ôKî�í�õÄõ�êvè&êvñ ç�í�ó)öBî¡íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë ñ�öè&é�êzë�íjì�ì�ï&ñ í�ò\é<íjï&îJð�ñ�ï&è&é<ç�ñ�è&êµç!ø &' ÿ²÷�ï�ì�ï&ñ�ü�óvî¡ô é�í�ë%í òDóvñ ë�î¡õ~ölñ�ï�ô ë�ñ óµ÷�è&êvñ ç ��é�í�õgðÃî¾÷�ë�î¡õ~è&é!î¾ë&êµô2êµózíjï�êvè6ý

>

Page 29: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

è�ï�í�çÄë�ölñ�ï\ô2íjè&êvñ ç�ë ��í�ç�êµè�îDï�íjè&êvú�îÚë�ñ óµ÷!è&êµñ çgð�ñ ÷�óµõ é�í�ú�îÚü)îDî¡ç�ï&î��.÷�êvï�î¡õ � í�ó®ùè&é!ñ ÷�ø é<í�õ�ô2êvè�è�î¡õÄóvý�î¡êvø�î¡çÄõ!î¡ò+ñ ôKìfñ ë&êvè&êvñ çÄëHíjï&îJêvè�îDï�íjè&êvú�î � þ

' ��é�î�ë�ñ óµ÷�è&êvñ ç �� êzë>í�ô2íjè�ï�ê�� �Eí�ç�õ�ï&îDì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè&ëOè&é!î�í¡ú�îDï�íjø�î2óvîDè�è�îDïJíjèOè&êµôKîìfñ êµçZè&ëJêµôKì�óµêµòDêvèOölñ�ï%î¡í�ò�é~ï&ñQð ñ�öyè&é!î�êµç�õ�êvú?êµõ�÷Äí�óóvîDè�è�îDï\ë � �jþ¾æ7çgì�ï�í�ò+è&êµò+îð�î%ç�îDî¡õ�è�ñÚï�îDì�ï&î¡ë�î¡çZè>è&é�î%óvîDè�è�îDïJí�ë�í ö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ çEþ ��ë�êµôKìÄóvî%ë�ñ óµ÷!è&êµñ ç<è&é�íjèð�î�é�í�ú�îKí�õ!ñ�ì�è�î¡õ êµë�è�ñ¾ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&écè&é�î�í¡ú�îDï\íjø�î2÷�ë&êµç!ø�è&é!î�òD÷!ü�êµòJë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�êµç�øë�ì�óµêµç!î²ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é!îDï¡þ

' �Oóvè&é!ñ ÷!ø écî¡í�ò�é ñ�ö�è&é�î�êµç�õÄêvú.êzõ�÷�í�ófë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î¡ë>êzë ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é �EêvèOô2í¡ýcéÄíjì�ìfî¡çè&é�íjè%è&é!îÚí�� ç!î¾êµçZú_íjï\êµí�ç/è�í¡ú�îDï\íjø�îcêµë%ç!ñ�è%í�ëKë�ôKñZñ�è&é±þ ÿ�ç!î�òDí�ç êµô2ì)ñ ë&îí ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é�ç!î¡ë�ë ìfî¡ç�í�óµè6ýsñ ç è&é!îÔò+ï�êvè�îDï\êvñ ç � � . � �²ü.ý í�õ�õ�êzç!ø�í �.÷�í�õ!ï�íjè&êzòï&ñ ÷�ø é�ç!î¡ë&ë>ìfî¡ç�í�óvè6ýÚñ�öËè&é!î�öBñ�ï�ô � è�ï �� $�� ��>þ � ç�íjè&÷!ï�í�ó òDí�ç�õ�êµõÄíjè�î�öBñ�ï �êµë�è&é!î>êµçZè�îDø�ï�íjè�î¡õ �?ë�î¡ò+ñ ç�õ!ù6ë��Z÷Äíjï&î¡õ?ù6õ!îDï�êµú_íjè&êvú�î>ô2íjè�ï�ê��Kò+ñ�ï&ï&î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õÄêµç!ø�è�ñ�íë&ô2ñZñ�è&é�êzç!ø�ë�ìÄóµêµç�î�þ:æ#ç�è&é�êµëSòDí�ë�î�è&é�î ë�ñ óµ÷!è&êµñ ç%êzë�í²üÄí�ë&êµëÇöBñ�ï�è&é!îHî¡êµø�î¡ç�ë�ìÄí�ò+îò+ñ�ï&ï�î¡ë�ìfñ ç�õ�êµç!ø è�ñOè&é�î�è¨ðÃñJë�ô2í�óµóvî¡ë�èî¡êvø�î¡çZú_í�óµ÷�î¡ëÇñ�ö ���� � ��� þæ#ç%ì�ï�í�ò+è&êµò+îñ ÷!ïÚ÷�çÄò+ñ ç�ë�è�ï�í�êµç�î¡õ ë�ñ óz÷!è&êvñ ç�ë�íjï&î ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&é î¡ç!ñ ÷!ø é�ç!ñ�è¾è�ñ�ï&î��.÷�êvï�îcè&é�êµëí�õ�õÄêvè&êvñ ç�í�ó±ò+ñ çÄë�è�ï�í�êµçZèDþ�ÿOö�ò+ñ ÷!ï�ë�î%è&é!î�ë&êµôKì�óvîDï üÄ÷�è>óvî¡ë&ë>î¡óvîDø í�çZè�ë�ñ óµ÷!è&êvñ çêµëyè�ñ�ñ ç�ò+î�íjø í�êµç�ë&ôKñ.ñ�è&éÚè&é!îJò+ñ óµ÷�ô�ç�ëyñ�ö �� þ

' �Oóvè&é!ñ ÷!ø ésñ ÷!ï í�ú�îDï�íjø�î ï&î��Z÷Äêvï&î¡ë2í�ç î¡êvø�î¡ç�õ!î¡ò+ñ ôKìfñ ë&êµè&êvñ ç�ñ�öJí�ç � ( �ô2íjè�ï\ê�� ��è&é!î�ìÄï&ñ�üÄóvî¡ô óvî¡ç�õ�ë�êµè&ë�î¡óvöSç�íjè&÷!ï�í�ózóvý¾è�ñ�í ë&êµôKìÄózê®ûÄî¡õÚêvè�îDï�íjè&êµú�î�ë�ñjùóµ÷�è&êvñ çEþ æ¨è�îDï�íjè&êµú�îJí�óvø�ñ�ï�êvè&é�ô�ëÃöBñ�ïyû�ç�õÄêµç!ø�î¡êµø�î¡ç?ù6ë&÷!üÄë&ìÄí�ò+î¡ëyñ�öí�ç¾ñ�ìfîDï�íjè�ñ�ï� ô2íjè�ï\ê�� � è6ý.ìÄêµòDí�óµóµýÔñ�ì)îDï\íjè�î ü.ý ï&îDìfî¡íjè�î¡õ�óvý íjìÄìÄóvý?êµç!øÚè&é!î¾ô2íjè�ï�ê�� è�ñ è&é!îòD÷!ï�ï&î¡ç/è ø ÷!î¡ë&ë �)ölñ ózóvñ�ð�î¡õcü.ý<í ï&î¡ç!ñ�ï�ô2í�ózê��¡íjè&êvñ ç � �,�Oú��� #.%$ � þ �Oóvè&é!ñ ÷�ø é ��êµë � ( � ��êµè êµëHè&é!î%ë&÷�ôÙñ�öSìÄï&ñ��#î¡ò+è&êµñ ç<ñ�ìfîDï�íjè�ñ�ï�ë � ñ ç/è�ñ¾í > ù6õ�êzôKî¡ç�ë&êvñ çÄí�óë�ì�í�ò+î � �.í�ç�õ�è&éZ÷Äë�î¡í�ò�é�òDí�ç ü)î>íjì�ìÄóµêvî¡õKêzç�� � � � ñ�ì)îDï\íjè&êvñ ç�ëDþ ��é!î ë�í�ôKî>êµëè�ï�÷�î�öBñ�ï²è&é!îKò+ñ ç�ë�è�ï�í�êµç�î¡õcì�ï�ñ�üÄóvî¡ô ñ ÷!è&óµêµç!î¡õ êµç�è&é!î�ì�ï&îDú?êvñ ÷�ëOêvè�î¡ô �Eë&êµçÄò+î� êµë:ò+ñ ôKìfñ ë�î¡õ%ñ�ö�ü�í�ç�õ!î¡õ�ô�íjè�ï�êµò+î¡ëDþ�ÿ²÷!ïÇêµôKìÄóµî¡ôKî¡ç/è&íjè&êµñ ç�÷�ë�î¡ëè&é�êµëè�ï�êµò <í�ç�õ¾ï�î¡ë&÷�óvè&ë�êzçÚíKõ!ï�í�ô2íjè&êµò�ë&ì)îDî¡õÄ÷!ì<êµçÚò+ñ ôKìÄ÷�è&íjè&êvñ çÚè&êµôKî�þ

� � å �fäËã�� �få\á�Þ�Ôî<é�í¡ú�îÚè�î¡ë�è�î¡õsñ ÷!ïKôKñ.õ�î¡óÃñ ç�í ë&ô�í�óµóÃë�í�ôKìÄóvî�ñ�ö>ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë �Sè&í <�î¡çsölï&ñ ô íø�ï&ñ ÷!ì�ñ�ö è�î¡ç ò+ñ óµóvî¡íjø ÷!î¡ëKíjè ���� � �Ãî¡ózó�ózíjü)ñ�ï\íjè�ñ�ï�êvî¡ëDþ �>óvè&é�ñ ÷!ø é�è&é!î¾ï&î¡ë&÷�óvè&ëë&é!ñ ÷�óµõgüfî�ï&îDø íjï�õ�î¡õ~í�ë�ì�ï&î¡óµêzô2êµç�íjï&ý��è&é!îDý é�í�ú�î�üfîDî¡ç~ì�ï&ñ ô2êzë&êµç!ø!þ���ñ ë�è�ölñ�ï&øjùîDï�ë2ð êzóµóËüfî<õ!îDè�î¡ò+è�î¡õ ÷�ë&êzç!ø è&é!î<õ!ý?ç�í�ô2êµò¾í�ë�ìfî¡ò+è2ñ�ö²è&é!î<ôKñ?õ!î¡ó�í�óµñ ç!î � ÷�ë&êzç!øè&é!î�õ�êµë&è&í�ç�ò+î¡ëyï&îDìfñ�ï&è�î¡õÚü.ý è&é�î�è&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìÄêµç!øKï�ñ ÷!è&êµç!î�þ0�OçÚî��.ìfîDï�êµî¡ç�ò+î¡õÚë�è&íjè&êµòXùë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�öBñ�ï&ø�îDï�é�í�ëOóµêvè�è&óvî%ò+ñ ç�ò+îDï�ç ölñ�ï²è&é!î�õ!ý?ç�í�ô2êµò�í�ë�ìfî¡ò+è>ñ�öËè&é!î%ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î��

> "

Page 30: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

í�ç�õ�êµëKóµê1<�î¡óµý è�ñÔüfî�öBñ êµóvî¡õ�ð é�î¡ç�é�êµë�ë�ìfîDî¡õ�öB÷�çÄò+è&êvñ ç êµëKò+ñ ôKìÄíjï&î¡õsè�ñÔè&é�íjèKñ�öè&é!î<ñ�ð>ç!îDï2ñ�öOè&é!îcë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�þ ��é�êµë�êµë2î¡ë�ìfî¡òDêµí�óµóvý è�ï\÷!îÚð é!î¡ç�é!î<éÄí�ëKè�ñgóvî¡íjï�çè�ñÚï&îDì�ï&ñ?õ�÷�ò+î%î��.ñ�è&êzò � ñ ÷!ï�êµë�é!î¡ë �)ñ�ölè�î¡çÔêµózóvîDø êvüÄóvî��)üÄ÷!è²ò+ñ ç�ë&êzë�è�î¡ç/è�êµç è&é!î�ú?êµò+è&êµô2ëë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�þ ��é!î�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î�ñ�ö "� ��� � ����� � �:ñ ç è&é�îKñ�è&é!îDïJé�í�ç�õ �±êzë>ú�îDï�ýcîDú�î¡çí�ç�õ ç!î¡íjè&óvýgð ï�êvè�è�î¡çEþ � öBñ�ï&ø�îDï2ô2êµø é/è�õ!ñ ðÃî¡óµó�è�ñÔë&êµô2ìÄóvý ð�ï�êvè�î�è&é�êµë�ç�í�ô2î�êµçè&é!î¡êvï�ñ�ð>ç ç�íjè&÷!ï�í�óËë�è6ý?óvî��:í�ç�õ è&é!îDï&îDü.ý ô2êzô2êµò�è&é!î2ë�ìfîDî¡õÔö�÷�ç�ò+è&êvñ ç êµç�é�îDï&î¡ç/è�êµçòD÷!ï�ë&êvú�î é�í�ç�õ!ð�ï\êvè&êµç!ø!þ ��é!î2öBñ�ï&ø�îDï�êµç è&é!î î��?í�ô2ìÄóvî¡ë�÷Äë�î¡õgêµç è&é�êµëJì�íjì)îDï%õ�êµõ íï&î¡í�ë�ñ ç�íjüÄóµî��#ñ�ü �.í�ç�õ�êµçKö�í�ò+è�é�êzëSë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î ë�îDø ôKî¡çZè�î¡õ¾êµç2ô%÷�ò�é�è&é!î ë&í�ôKî>ìÄóµí�ò+î¡ëí�ë>õ�êzõÚè&é!ñ ë�î�ñ�ö�é�êµëHú?êµò+è&êµôÚþ (>ñ�ð�îDú�îDï �fè�ñ ô2êµô�êµò²üfñ�è&é<è&é!î%ë�ìfîDî¡õ<í�ç�õcë�é�íjìfîJñ�öè&é!î�ë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î¡ëyì�ï&ñQú�î¡õ<è�ñ.ñ�ô%÷�ò�é�êµç¾è&é�êµëHòDí�ë�î�þ

�Ôî�ç!îDî¡õcë�è&êµóµó)è�ñ2î��?ìfîDï�êµôKî¡çZèyð êvè&é¾ñ ÷!ï ô2ñ.õ!î¡óEêzç�ô�í�ç/ý¾ðyí¡ý?ëDþ!3.ñ ôKî�ñ�öè&é!îêvè�î¡ô2ëHñ çcñ ÷!ï�íjø�î¡ç�õ�í2íjï�î#&

' ð�îKç!îDî¡õ è�ñ�ø íjè&é�îDï�ë�è&íjè&êµë�è&êzòDë>ñ çÔí¾óvîDè�è�îDï�ü�í�ë&êµëOêµç ölñ�ï�ô�êµç!ø�ñ ÷�ïOï\÷�óvî¡ë>ölñ�ïõ�êzë&ò+ï�êµô2êzç�íjè&êvñ ç &

� 3.ñ ô2î �� � �����fé�í�ú�îËóvñ ç!ø�îDïíjï�òXù6óvî¡ç!ø�è&é�ë �_í�ç�õ #Qñ�ï:êµçZú�ñ óvú�î�ôKñ�ï&î�ï�î¡ò+ñ�ï�õ!î¡õìfñ êµçZè&ë �/è&éÄí�ç�ñ�è&é!îDï\ëDþ���é!î>ë�é!ñ�ï&è�îDïyí�ç�õ ë�êµôKìÄóvîDïËè&é!î>óvîDè�è�îDï �Zè&é!î²ôKñ�ï&îî¡í�ë�ý êvè�êµëOè�ñÚè�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô êvè�÷�ë�êµç!ø�è&é�î2í�� ç!î+ù�è�ï�í�ç�ë&ölñ�ï�ô�íjè&êvñ ç�ëDþ 3?÷�ò�éóvîDè�è�îDï\ë�íjï�î²ózê1<�î¡óvýKè�ñKíjì�ìfî¡íjïHë�è&íjüÄóvî²êµç è&é!î²è�ï�í�êµç�êµç�ø�ë�îDè �!í�ç�õ¾íjï&î�óvî¡ë&ëóµê <�î¡óvý2è�ñ�üfî�õ!îDè�î¡ò+è&íjüÄóµî�êµç¾è&é!î�öBñ�ï&ø�îDï&ý�þ

� 3.ñ ô2î�óvîDè�è�îDï�ëOð êzóµófú_íjï�ýcóµêvè�è&óvî�êµç<è&é!î%è�ï�í�êµçÄêµç!ø2ë�îDè � îDú�î¡çÔóvñ ç!ø�îDï �fóvî¡ë&ëë&êzôKìÄóvî�ñ ç!î¡ë � �Hí�ç�õ�ð>êµóµó�üfî¾ë&è�ï&ñ ç!øgòDí�ç�õÄêµõ�íjè�î¡ëKöBñ�ï�õ�êµë�ò+ï�êµô2êµçÄíjè&êvñ ç �í�óvè�îDï\ç�íjè&êvú�î¡óvý��fñ�è&é!îDï�ëOð êzóµó:é�í�ú�îKé�êvø é�ú_íjï�êzí�ç�ò+îKí�ç�õ�íjï�î�ózê1<�î¡óvýÚè�ñ¾üfîìfñ.ñ�ï�õ�êµë&ò+ï�êzô2êµç�íjè�ñ�ï�ë¡þ

� ��é�î > ( > è�ï�í�ç�ë�öBñ�ï�ô2íjè&êvñ ç�ô�íjè�ï�êµò+î¡ë2ò+ñ çZè&í�êµç í�õÄõ�êvè&êvñ ç�í�óyêµç�ölñ�ï�ô�í_ùè&êvñ ç¾íjüfñ ÷!è�è&é!î²ú_íjï\êµíjüÄêµóµêµè6ýKêµç�î¡í�ò�é<ë�êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î�þ���é�îDý�òDí�ç¾üfî>ö�÷!ï&è&é!îDïõ!î¡ò+ñ ô2ì)ñ ë&î¡õ�êµçZè�ñ�ï�ñ�è&íjè&êvñ ç �Eë&òDí�óvî�í�ç�õ ë&é!î¡íjïOöBí�ò+è�ñ�ï�ë �fí�çÄõ�í�ç�í�óµý �Dî¡õë�îDì�íjï�íjè�î¡óvý�þ

' �Ôî íjï&î òD÷!ï&ï&î¡çZè&óvý î��.ì�óvñ�ï�êµç!ø~í�óvè�îDï�ç�íjè&êvú�î è&êµôKî+ù�ðyíjï&ìÄêzç!øgë&ò\é!î¡ôKî¡ë ��î¡ë&ì)î+ùòDêµí�ózóvý�òDí�ç�õ�êzõ�íjè�î¡ëHè&é�íjè òDí�çcüfîJò+ñ ôKìÄ÷!è�î¡õ<ô2ñ�ï&îJî5� òDêvî¡çZè&óvý�þ

' �Ôî�ìÄóµí�ç~è�ñ�î��?îDï�òDêµë&î è&é!î¾ôKñ?õ!î¡óÃñ ç~í óµíjï&ø�î¾õ�íjè&íjüÄí�ë�î¾ñ�ö�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë �Sêµçñ�ï�õ�îDïHè�ñ�îDújí�óµ÷�íjè�î�êvè&ëyìfîDï&öBñ�ï�ô2í�çÄò+î�ð êvè&éÚë�ñ ôKî�ò+ñ ç?û�õ!î¡ç�ò+î�þ

� å�� �Xå�á �²à���� ����,+ #. $ (�þ ��þ�+yï�íjüfî�í�ç�õ��þ�3)þSÿ�ë�è�ï&î¡ô � �=�>÷!è�ñ ô�íjè&êµòÚë&êvø ç�íjè&÷�ï&î ú�îDï\ê®û�òDíjè&êvñ ç

. �

Page 31: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

÷�ë�êµç!ø�í è&é!ï&îDî+ù6í �!êµë#ù�öBñ�ï�ò+î+ù6ë�î¡ç�ë�êvè&êvú�î%ì)î¡ç � ��������� � �� ���9 � ������� �� �� � ����- ����%���� ���� � � ��� � ������� � "# #..þ

�,�Oú � #. $ �%þ �Oñ óz÷!ü � +OþËújí�ç �:ñ í�ç ��� ���� ����� � ��� ��� ������� ��� ��ñ é�ç�ë ( ñ�ì <?êµç�ë.Oç�êvú)þ0��ï&î¡ë&ë � ��í�óµè&êµôKñ�ï&î�� � � � � "# #..þ

� ( � $ �~þ (>í�çÄí�ç � ��þ �~þ ( îDï&ü�ë�è�í�çÄõ ��þ �gþ �J÷!ï�è �Dü)îDï�ø�� �=�Çêµç�êµè�îOë�è&íjè�î�ô2í�ò\é�êµç!îõ!î¡òDêzë&êvñ ç¾ì�ï&ñ?ò+î¡õ�÷!ï�îJôKñ.õ�î¡ófölñ�ïOë&êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î�ú�îDï�ê®û�òDíjè&êvñ ç � ������� ���%��#� � � ��%����� ����� � � �:�� �������� ���� �� � � "�� .þ

� � " � $6� þ�� î¡ózë�ñ çcí�ç�õ ��þ �Jêzë&é!ñ ç � ��.Oë�î�ñ�ö �Oý?ç�í�ô2êµò ��î¡íjè&÷!ï&î¡ë>ölñ�ï 3?êvø ç�íjè&÷!ï�î� î¡ò+ñ�ø ç�êvè&êvñ ç � � ���� � ��î¡óµó �íjüÄë �î¡ò�é�ç�êzòDí�ó �cî¡ô2ñ�ï�í�ç�õ�÷�ô � � "#" � þ

� � #" $ �Jþ!�Ëóµí�ôKñ çÄõ!ñ ç í�ç�õ �%þ �±ñ�ï&îDè�è�î�� �=�O÷!è�ñ ô2íjè&êzò�ë&êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î<ú�îDï\ê®û�òDíjè&êvñ çí�ç�õ<ð�ï�êvè�îDï êzõ!î¡ç/è&êvû�òDíjè&êvñ ç�ù � é!îJë�è&íjè�î�ñ�öSè&é�î�íjï&è � �"! ��� ���-$# *%*���& � ������ �%����:�� � &� ��� � ���&������ � � � "# #".þ

� � > $ ��þ �Jþ �>íjüÄêµç!îDï���þ ��þ � ñ ë�î¡çZü)îDï�ø �!þ �%þ � êµóvìfñ ç2í�çÄõ ��þ �~þ 7fí�ôKìÄêµç � �=�üfñ.ñ�è&ë�è�ï�íjì�ìÄêzç!øKè�ï�í�êµç�êzç!øKè�î¡ò�é�çÄê �Z÷�î�öBñ�ï ñ�ü�è&í�êµçÄêµç!ø�õ!î¡ô�êµë�ý?óµóµíjüÄóvî²ï&îDöBîDï&î¡ç�ò+îìÄíjè�è�îDï\ç�ë � �' � � %���� � ��� ��%�� � �8�(� � (� �.�� �/÷�ç!î � "# >

� � �� $ ��þ��Ãóµí�ôKñ ç�õ!ñ ç � � � é�íjè�õ!ñ.î¡ëÇõ�ê*)fîDï&î¡çZè&êµí�ó/ø�îDñ ô2îDè�ï&ý�è�î¡ózó.÷Äë íjüfñ ÷!èÇé�í�ç�õ!ùð�ï\êvè&êµç!ø%ø�î¡ç!îDï�íjè&êvñ ç � �"! 2�7% �) �*�� ��� � ��� � �� � �� � � � ���� � � �+� � � �� ����� � ����� ��% ��� � � � �� ������,�$����� � � � � "# ��Zþ

� � 3 " � $ �!þ � êµò+î��)í�ç�õ �>þ 3?êµóvú�îDï\ô2í�ç � � �Ãë�è&êµô2íjè&êµç�ø2è&é!î��cî¡í�ç í�ç�õ +�ñ�újíjï�êµí�ç�ò+î3.è�ï\÷�ò+è&÷!ï&î � ñ ç!ì�íjï�í�ôKîDè�ï�êµòDí�ózóvý<ð é!î¡ç�è&é!î��²íjè&íÚíjï&î +y÷!ï&ú�î¡ë � �-'�# � .� � ������ �� �

�,3 > $ %þ 3?íjè�ñ í�ç�õ �Kþ���ñ�ø ÷!ï&î�� ��ÿ²ç?ù6óµêzç!îcë&êvø çÄíjè&÷!ï&î ú�îDï�ê®û�òDíjè&êvñ ç üÄí�ë�î¡õ ñ çë&éÄíjì)î��SôKñ�è&êµñ ç�í�çÄõ~é�í�çÄõ!ð�ï�êvè&êzç!øÚì�ï&î¡ë&ë�÷!ï&î � ��! 2�7%��/ ���0�� ���1� �� � � ��! ��� ���-2# �%���� � ������ �3%�� ���� � ���54� 6 �74� & �,� �# ��%�� � � "# > þ

�,3 #. $��%þ 3?í�ç <�ñ )Úí�ç�õ ��þ �>þ �Jï�÷�ë=<jí�ó.î¡õ�êvè�ñ�ï�ë � � � êµôKî � íjï&ìÄë � 3.è�ï�êµç�ø �Ãõ�êvè&ë � í�ç�õ� í�ò+ï&ñ ôKñ óvî¡òD÷Äóvî¡ë�& ��é!î ��é!îDñ�ï�ý í�ç�õ ��ï\í�ò+è&êµò+î�ñ�ö 3.î��.÷!î¡ç�ò+î�+�ñ ô2ìÄíjï�êµë�ñ ç � �� � � � ���� � � ���� ��8! �"��� � ��� �� �0� � ��� ����*�� % ��� � � � �9 �� ���6 �� � � "# #..þ

� � " � $��%þ � í�éZüÄí � ���� �� � �# % ����� � � � $: ��� ��, ��������� � � ��� � ��+ � � 3Zù �;3 �� îDø êvñ ç�í�ó6+�ñ ç�ölîDï&î¡çÄò+î 3.îDï�êvî¡ë � 3?æ � � � �Ãé�êµóµí�õ�î¡óvìÄé�êµí?þ

� ���� $ �gþ Ëí�ë&÷�íjï\íÚí�ç�õ �gþÿ;<_í � � 3?êµø ç�íjè&÷!ï&î%ú�îDï�ê®û�òDíjè&êµñ ç î��.ìfîDï�êµô2î¡ç/èOüÄí�ë�î¡õñ ç~ç!ñ ç?ù6óµêµç�î¡íjï�è&êµôKî�í�óµêµø ç�ôKî¡çZè � �;������� � �� ���� "� ��� � �1� �&���- ����%�����.��� ��� �� �9 �7 �6 � � "����Zþ

. �

Page 32: hastie/Papers/signature.pdf ·

�,798- #� $ �Kþ!� þ�7fêzô2ôKîDï�ô2í�çÄçsí�ç�õ +²þ ��þ�8�íjï�í�õ!ý�� �=(Oí�ç�õ!ð ï�êvè�îDï�ú�îDï\ê®û�òDíjè&êvñ çöBï&ñ ô ñ ç�î+ù�üÄêvè��.÷�í�çZè&ê��Dî¡õ � ì�ï&î¡ë&ë&÷�ï&îKìÄíjè�è�îDï�ç�ë � �+! ��� ���-5# *%*���& � ������ � ��4���� �) 9� � � � "# #�.þ

. >