0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

28
Stomatal density and stomatal index as indicators of paleoatmospheric CO 2 concentration D.L. Royer * Yale University Department of Geology and Geophysics, P.O. Box 208109, New Haven, CT 06520-8109, USA Received 9 February 2000; received in revised form 24 August 2000; accepted for publication 26 September 2000 Abstract A growing number of studies use the plant species-speci®c inverse relationship between atmospheric CO 2 concentration and stomatal density (SD) or stomatal index (SI) as a proxy for paleo-CO 2 levels. A total of 285 previously published SD and 145 SI responses to variable CO 2 concentrations from a pool of 176 C 3 plant species are analyzed here to test the reliability of this method. The percentage of responses inversely responding to CO 2 rises from 40 and 36% (for SD and SI, respectively) in experimental studies to 88 and 94% (for SD and SI, respectively) in fossil studies. The inconsistent experimental responses verify previous concerns involving this method, however the high percentage of fossil responses showing an inverse relation- ship clearly validates the method when applied over time scales of similar length. Furthermore, for all groups of observations, a positive relationship between CO 2 and SD/SI is found in only #12% of cases. Thus, CO 2 appears to inversely affect stomatal initiation, although the mechanism may involve genetic adaptation and therefore is often not clearly expressed under short CO 2 exposure times. Experimental responses of SD and SI based on open-top chambers (OTCs) inversely relate to CO 2 less often than greenhouse- based responses (P , 0.01 for both SD and SI), and should be avoided when experimental responses are required for CO 2 reconstructions. In the combined data set, hypostomatous species follow the inverse relationship more often than amphisto- matous species (56 vs. 44% for SD; 69 vs. 32% for SI; P , 0:03 for both comparisons). Both the SD and SI of fossil responses are equally likely to inversely relate to CO 2 when exposed to elevated versus subambient CO 2 concentrations (relative to today). This result casts doubt on previous claims that stomata cannot respond to CO 2 concentrations above present-day levels. Although the proportion of SD and SI responses inversely relating to CO 2 are similar, SD is more strongly affected by various environmental stresses, and thus SI-based CO 2 reconstructions are probably more accurate. q 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. Keywords: carbon dioxide; stomatal frequency; paleoatmosphere; paleoclimatology; leaf anatomy; cuticles 1. Introduction The increase in atmospheric CO 2 concentration since industrialization (Friedli et al., 1986; Keeling et al., 1995) and the predicted continued increase into the near future (Houghton et al., 1995) forces the need to understand how the biosphere operates under elevated (relative to pre-industrial) CO 2 levels. The geologic record affords a wealth of such informa- tion. Fundamental to the use of the geologic record, however, is a reliable estimate of CO 2 concentration throughout the intervals of interest. The results of a computer-based model for the Phanerozoic (Berner, 1994; see Fig. 1), based on rates of Ca±Mg silicate weathering and burial as carbonates, weathering and Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 114 (2001) 1±28 0034-6667/01/$ - see front matter q 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. PII: S0034-6667(00)00074-9 www.elsevier.nl/locate/revpalbo * Fax: 11-203-432-3134. E-mail address: [email protected] (D.L. Royer).

Transcript of 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

Page 1: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

!"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' *"#$%"%& +)'(- %* +)'+.%"#/* #01%&(#%"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)

6787 9#,(/:

!"#$ %&'($)*'+, -$.")+/$&+ 01 2$0#03, "&4 2$0.5,*'6*7 89:9 ;0< =>?@>A7 B$C D"($&7 EF >GH=>I?@>A7 %JK

9(.(+;(' < =(>/?%/, 5@@@A /(.(+;(' +) /(;+*(' 0#/$ 5B C?D?*" 5@@@A %..(1"(' 0#/ 1?>&+.%"+#) 5E !(1"($>(/ 5@@@

!"#$%&'$

C D/#F+)D )?$>(/ #0 *"?'+(* ?*( "2( 1&%)" *1(.+(*G*1(.+H. +);(/*( /(&%"+#)*2+1 >("F(() %"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#) %)'*"#$%"%& '()*+", I!6J #/ *"#$%"%& +)'(- I!KJ %* % 1/#-, 0#/ 1%&(#G345 &(;(&*7 C "#"%& #0 5LM 1/(;+#?*&, 1?>&+*2(' !6 %)' NBM !K/(*1#)*(* "# ;%/+%>&( 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* 0/#$ % 1##& #0 NOE 3P 1&%)" *1(.+(* %/( %)%&,Q(' 2(/( "# "(*" "2( /(&+%>+&+", #0 "2+*$("2#'7 R2( 1(/.()"%D( #0 /(*1#)*(* +);(/*(&, /(*1#)'+)D "# 345 /+*(* 0/#$ B@ %)' PES I0#/ !6 %)' !KT /(*1(."+;(&,J +)(-1(/+$()"%& *"?'+(* "# LL %)' <BS I0#/ !6 %)' !KT /(*1(."+;(&,J +) 0#**+& *"?'+(*7 R2( +).#)*+*"()" (-1(/+$()"%& /(*1#)*(*;(/+0, 1/(;+#?* .#).(/)* +);#&;+)D "2+* $("2#'T 2#F(;(/ "2( 2+D2 1(/.()"%D( #0 0#**+& /(*1#)*(* *2#F+)D %) +);(/*( /(&%"+#)G*2+1 .&(%/&, ;%&+'%"(* "2( $("2#' F2() %11&+(' #;(/ "+$( *.%&(* #0 *+$+&%/ &()D"27 =?/"2(/$#/(T 0#/ %&& D/#?1* #0 #>*(/;%"+#)*T %1#*+"+;( /(&%"+#)*2+1 >("F(() 345 %)' !6U!K +* 0#?)' +) #)&, !N5S #0 .%*(*7 R2?*T 345 %11(%/* "# +);(/*(&, %00(." *"#$%"%&+)+"+%"+#)T %&"2#?D2 "2( $(.2%)+*$ $%, +);#&;( D()("+. %'%1"%"+#) %)' "2(/(0#/( +* #0"() )#" .&(%/&, (-1/(**(' ?)'(/ *2#/" 345(-1#*?/( "+$(*7V-1(/+$()"%& /(*1#)*(* #0 !6 %)' !K >%*(' #) #1()G"#1 .2%$>(/* I4R3*J +);(/*(&, /(&%"( "# 345 &(** #0"() "2%) D/(()2#?*(G

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

L$,C0)4*[ .%/>#) '+#-+'(A *"#$%"%& 0/(W?().,A 1%&(#%"$#*12(/(A 1%&(#.&+$%"#&#D,A &(%0 %)%"#$,A .?"+.&(*

() *+$%,-.'$/,+

R2( +)./(%*( +) %"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*+).( +)'?*"/+%&+Q%"+#) I=/+('&+ (" %&7T N<LEA \((&+)D(" %&7T N<<MJ %)' "2( 1/('+."(' .#)"+)?(' +)./(%*(+)"# "2( )(%/ 0?"?/( I]#?D2"#) (" %&7T N<<MJ 0#/.(*

"2( )((' "# ?)'(/*"%)' 2#F "2( >+#*12(/( #1(/%"(*?)'(/ (&(;%"(' I/(&%"+;( "# 1/(G+)'?*"/+%&J 345 &(;(&*7R2( D(#&#D+. /(.#/' %00#/'* % F(%&"2 #0 *?.2 +)0#/$%G"+#)7 =?)'%$()"%& "# "2( ?*( #0 "2( D(#&#D+. /(.#/'T2#F(;(/T +* % /(&+%>&( (*"+$%"( #0 345 .#).()"/%"+#)"2/#?D2#?" "2( +)"(/;%&* #0 +)"(/(*"7 R2( /(*?&"* #0 %.#$1?"(/G>%*(' $#'(& 0#/ "2( ^2%)(/#Q#+. IX(/)(/TN<<BA *(( =+D7 NJT >%*(' #) /%"(* #0 3%_`D *+&+.%"(F(%"2(/+)D %)' >?/+%& %* .%/>#)%"(*T F(%"2(/+)D %)'

9(;+(F #0 ^%&%(#>#"%), %)' ^%&,)#&#D, NNB I5@@NJ N_5L

@@PBGEEEOU@NUa G *(( 0/#)" $%""(/ ! 5@@N V&*(;+(/ !.+().( X7Z7 C&& /+D2"* /(*(/;('7^KK[ !@@PBGEEEOI@@J@@@OBG<

FFF7(&*(;+(/7)&U&#.%"(U/(;1%&>#

: =%-[ #NG5@PGBP5GPNPB7MI/"'# "44)$**N '%)%7/#,(/b,%&(7('? I6787 9#,(/J7

Page 2: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

>?/+%& #0 #/D%)+. .%/>#)T 345 '(D%**+)DT ;%*.?&%/ &%)'1&%)" (;#&?"+#)T %)' *#&%/ /%'+%"+#)T 2%;( D%+)('.#)*+'(/%>&( ?*( I(7D7 9("%&&%.YT N<<OA \?$1 (" %&7TN<<<J7 ^/#-, '%"% %/( *"+&& ./?.+%&T 2#F(;(/T 0#/ >#"2"(*"+)D %)' /(H)+)D "2+* $#'(&7 3?//()"&, ?*(' 1/#-+(*+).&?'( ! NP3 0/#$ 1('#D()+. .%/>#)%"(* I3(/&+)DTN<<NT N<<5A `#/% (" %&7T N<<NT N<<EA VY%/" (" %&7TN<<<JT ! NP3 0/#$ "/%.( .%/>#)%"(* .#)"%+)(' F+"2+)D#("2+"( Ic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

*1(.+H. +);(/*( /(&%"+#)*2+1 >("F(() %"$#*12(/+.345 .#).()"/%"+#) %)' *"#$%"%& '()*+", %)'U#/ *"#$%G"%& +)'(-7 3#).(/)* 2%;( >(() /%+*(' /(D%/'+)D "2+*$("2#'d* /(&+%>+&+", I\#e/)(/T N<LLA ^##&( (" %&7TN<<EJT %)' +" +* "2( 1?/1#*( #0 "2+* 1%1(/ "# %''/(**"2(*( .#).(/)* ;+% %) (-"()*+;( %)%&,*+* #0 "2( &+"(/%G"?/(7 C)%&,*+* +).&?'(* *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* 0/#$ 0#**+&#>*(/;%"+#)* %* F(&& %* *2#/"G"(/$ I(-1(/+$()"%&T)%"?/%& 345 *1/+)D*T %&"+"?'+)%& "/%)*(."*T %)'2(/>%/+%J #>*(/;%"+#)*T %* /(*1#)*(* 0/#$ "2( &%""(/.%"(D#/, %/( #0"() ?*(' "# D()(/%"( *"%)'%/' .?/;(*0#/ (*"+$%"+)D 345 0/#$ 0#**+& #>*(/;%"+#)* I;%) '(/X?/D2 (" %&7T N<<PA X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<MA \?e/*.2)(/TN<<EA \?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7T N<<EA 9?)'D/() %)' X((/&+)DT

N<<<A f%D)(/ (" %&7T N<<<J7 !1(.+H.%&&,T "2( ?"+&+", #0*"#$%"%& +)'+.(* F+&& >( (-%$+)('T %) %11/#%.2 )#"%)%&,Q(' +) 1/(;+#?* /(;+(F* IX((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/TN<<5T N<<BA f##'F%/' %)' \(&&,T N<<MJ7

0) 12'3&+/#4 ',+$%,55/+6 #$,4&$&5 -2+#/$7

!"#$%"% %/( 1#/(* #) &(%0 *?/0%.(* "2/#?D2 F2+.21&%)"* (-.2%)D( 345T F%"(/ ;%1#/T %)' #"2(/ .#)*"+G"?()"* F+"2 "2( %"$#*12(/(7 R2(, 0#/$ (%/&, +) &(%0'(;(&#1$()"T %)' ",1+.%&&, $%"?/( >, "2( "+$( "2( &(%0/(%.2(* N@_E@S #0 +"* H)%& &(%0 *+Q( IR+.2%gT N<L5J7R2?*T "2( "+$+)D 0#/ "2( $(.2%)+*$I*J #0 *"#$%"%&+)+"+%"+#) &+(* (%/&, +) &(%0 #)"#D(), Ih%, %)' ]?/'TN<OMA !.2#.2 (" %&7T N<L@J7 3?//()"&,T )# $(.2%)+*$#/ .#$>+)%"+#) #0 $(.2%)+*$* %'(W?%"(&, (-1&%+)*"2( (-1/(**+#) #0 *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#)T %&"2#?D2 D()("+.F#/Y $%, 1/#;+'( +)*+D2"* +) "2( )(%/ 0?"?/( I(7D7X(/D(/ %)' C&"$%))T 5@@@J7 ^/#1#*(' $(.2%)+*$*+).&?'( +//%'+%).( Ih%, %)' ]?/'T N<OMA !.2#.2 ("%&7T N<L@JT 2?$+'+", I!%&+*>?/,T N<5OJT %)' .345If##'F%/'T N<LEA X((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<5Af##'F%/' %)' \(&&,T N<<MA X((/&+)D %)' f##'F%/'TN<<EJ7C .#$$#) "2(#/, 0#/ F2, 345 *2#?&' I1%/"+%&&,J

.#)"/#& *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#) +* %* 0#&&#F* I(7D7 f##'GF%/'T N<LOJ7 f%"(/ ;%1#/ %)' 345 .#)*"+"?"( "2( "F#$%+) i?-(* %./#** "2( &(%0 (1+'(/$+*7 K" +* D()(/%&&,%';%)"%D(#?* 0#/ 1&%)"* "# .#)*(/;( F%"(/ &#** F2+&($%-+$+Q+)D 345 ?1"%Y(T "F# ",1+.%&&, %)"+"2("+.%&1/#.(**(*7 C* 345 /+*(* 0#/ % D+;() F%"(/ >?'D("T0#/ (-%$1&(T % 1&%)" .%) j%00#/'d "# /('?.( +"* *"#$%"%&.#)'?."%).( F+"2#?" *?00(/+)D % /('?."+#) +) .%/>#)%**+$+&%"+#) /%"(*7 RF# $%+) 1%"2F%,* '/+;+)D "2+*/(*1#)*( %/( *$%&&(/ *"#$%"%& 1#/(* IX(""%/+)+ (" %&7TN<<LJ %)' % /('?."+#) +) *"#$%"%& )?$>(/*

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?5

=+D7 N7 C"$#*12(/+. 345 ;(/*?* "+$( 0#/ "2( ^2%)(/#Q#+.7 9345! /%"+# #0 $%** #0 1%&(#G345 "# "+$(G%;(/%D(' 1/(G+)'?*"/+%& ;%&?(I5P@ 11$ZT "2( $(%) 345 #;(/ %" &(%*" "2( &%*" B@@ Y7,7 I^("+" (" %&7T N<<<JJ7 R2( .()"(/&+)( k#+)+)D H&&(' .+/.&(* IN@ $7,7 "+$( *"(1*J /(1/(*()"*"2( >(*" (*"+$%"( 0/#$ "2( $#'(& #0 X(/)(/ IN<<BT N<<LJ7 R2( "F# *"/%''&+)D &+)(* /(1/(*()" (//#/ (*"+$%"(* >%*(' #) *()*+"+;+", %)%&,*(*7 X#-(*+) I%J /(1/(*()" <N )#)G*"#$%"%&G>%*(' 1/#-, (*"+$%"(* #0 ;%/,+)D 9345 /(*#&?"+#) I'%"% 0/#$ !?.2(.Y, (" %&7T N<LLA ^&%""T N<L<A 3(/&+)DT N<<NTN<<5A =/(($%) %)' ]%,(*T N<<5A \#.2 (" %&7T N<<5A `?.2(Q (" %&7T N<<PA !+)2% %)' !"#""T N<<BA C)'/(F* (" %&7T N<<MA h2#*2 (" %&7T N<<MA `#/%(" %&7T N<<EA c%11 %)' ^#"2*T N<<EA VY%/" (" %&7T N<<<A V&+.Y (" %&7T N<<<A 8((T N<<<A 8(( %)' ]+*%'%T N<<<A ^%D%)+ (" %&7T N<<<%T N<<<>A ^(%/*#)%)' ^%&$(/T N<<<J7 R2( 2(%;, &+)( +) I>J +* % H;(G1#+)" /?))+)D %;(/%D( #0 "2( $(%) 9345 #0 (;(/, >#- +) I%J7 R2+* %11/#%.2 *$##"2(* *2#/"G"(/$ 345 i?."?%"+#)* %)' +* $#/( '+/(."&, .#$1%/%>&( F+"2 "2( $#'(& #0 X(/)(/ IN<<BT N<<LJ7 R2( '%*2(' &+)( +) I>J +* % H;(G1#+)" /?))+)D%;(/%D( +).#/1#/%"+)D % /(.%&.?&%"+#) #0 VY%/" (" %&7 IN<<<J '%"% '?/+)D "2( &%"( 3%/>#)+0(/#?* %)' (%/&, ^(/$+%) ?*+)D "2( $%/+)( .%/>#)%"(! NP3 '%"% #0 ^#11 (" %&7 IN<LEJ I*(( "(-" 0#/ '("%+&*J7

Page 3: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? P

Page 4: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

If##'F%/'T N<LOJ7 3#);(/*(&,T % '/#1 +) 345/(W?+/(* %) +)./(%*( +) *"#$%"%& .#)'?."%).( "# $%+)G"%+) %**+$+&%"+#) /%"(*T >?" %" "2( .#*" #0 +)./(%*('F%"(/ &#**7

=9@9 J+0/"+"# '&4$<

!"#$%"%& '()*+", I!6J +* % 0?)."+#) #0 >#"2 "2()?$>(/ #0 *"#$%"% 1&?* "2( *+Q( #0 "2( (1+'(/$%&.(&&*7 R2?*T !6 +* %00(."(' >#"2 >, "2( +)+"+%"+#) #0*"#$%"% %)' "2( (-1%)*+#) #0 (1+'(/$%& .(&&*7 R2+*(-1%)*+#) +* % 0?)."+#) #0 $%), ;%/+%>&(* I(7D7 &+D2"T"($1(/%"?/(T F%"(/ *"%"?*T 1#*+"+#) #0 &(%0 #) ./#F)T%)' +)"/%G&(%0 1#*+"+#)JT %)' .%) #;(/1/+)" "2( *+D)%&/(i(."+;( #0 *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#)7 C* +" "?/)* #?"T 3451&%,* % *"/#)D(/ /#&( +) *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#) "2%) +)(1+'(/$%& .(&& (-1%)*+#) I"2+* +* '+*.?**(' +) '("%+&>(&#FJ7 !%&+*>?/, IN<5OJ +)"/#'?.(' "2( .#).(1" #0*"#$%"%& +)'(- I!KJT F2+.2 )#/$%&+Q(* 0#/ "2( (00(."*#0 "2+* (-1%)*+#) I+7(7 '()*+", #0 (1+'(/$%& .(&&*J7 K" +*'(H)(' %*[

!K"S# ! *"#$%"%& '()*+",

*"#$%"%& '()*+",# (1+'(/$%& .(&& '()*+",

! N@@

F2(/( *"#$%"% .#)*+*" #0 "2( *"#$%"%& 1#/( %)' "F#i%)Y+)D D?%/' .(&&*7

=9=9 ES .#"&+*

R2( 0?)'%$()"%& 12#"#*,)"2("+. '+00(/().(*>("F(() 3P %)' 3B 1&%)"* 2%;( .#)*(W?().(* 0#/*"#$%"%&G>%*(' 345 /(.#)*"/?."+#)*7 3%/>#) +) 3P1&%)"* +* H-(' F+"2+) "2( *1#)D, %)' 1%&+*%'($(*#12,&& F2(/( 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* I6'J %/(%11/#-+$%"(&, O@S #0 "2( %"$#*12(/+. ;%&?(7 C*%"$#*12(/+. 345 i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

%)' *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#) '+*.?**(' %>#;(T "2%" (;()$#'(/%"( .2%)D(* +) %"$#*12(/+. 345 2%;( &+""&( +)i?G().( #) *"#$%"%& 1#/( %/(% %)'T >, (-"()*+#)T !6 %)' !KI9%;() %)' 9%$*'()T N<LLJ7 40 "2( )+)( /(*1#)*(*'(/+;(' 0/#$ 3B 1&%)"* '#.?$()"(' 2(/(T #)&, #)(+);(/*(&, /(*1#)'* "# 345 I*(( C11()'+- CNJ7 R2+*$%/Y(' +)*()*+"+;+", +) 3B 1&%)"* &()'* +)'+/(." *?11#/"0#/ "2( 1/#1#*(' $(.2%)+*$7 X(.%?*( #0 "2( %>#;(12,*+#&#D+.%& /(%*#)*T )#)( #0 "2( %)%&,*(* .#)*+'(/('2(/( +).&?'( /(*1#)*(* 0/#$ 3B 1&%)"*7

8) 9$,4&$&5 -2+#/$7 &+- #$,4&$&5 /+-2: &# ;<0

/+-/'&$,%#

C '%"%>%*( .#)*+*"+)D #0 5LM !6 /(*1#)*(* %)' NBM!K /(*1#)*(* "# ;%/+%>&( 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* F%*.#$1+&(' "# (&?.+'%"( *%&+()" 1%""(/)* IC11()'+.(*CN_PJ7 NOE *1(.+(* %/( /(1/(*()"('7 R2+* '%"%>%*( +*%) (-1%)*+#) #0 1/(;+#?* /(;+(F* IX((/&+)D %)' 32%&G#)(/T N<<BA f##'F%/' %)' \(&&,T N<<MJ %)' +).&?'(*T0#/ "2( H/*" "+$(T *"#$%"%& +)'+.(*7V%.2 /(*1#)*( F%* H/*" 1&%.(' +) #)( #0 "2/(( .%"(G

D#/+(*[ (-1(/+$()"%&T *?>0#**+&T %)' 0#**+&7 V-1(/+G$()"%& /(*1#)*(* *"($ 0/#$ (-1(/+$()"%&&,.#)"/#&&(' 345 ();+/#)$()"*T ",1+.%&&, +) D/(()G2#?*(*T F2+.2 &%*" 0/#$ NB '%,* "# H;( ,(%/* +) &()D"27=#/ *"?'+(* "2%" $(%*?/(' !6 %)'U#/ !K %" *(;(/%&'+00(/()" "+$(* %)'U#/ 345 &(;(&*T ",1+.%&&, #)&, "2(/(*1#)*( .#//(*1#)'+)D "# "2( &#)D(*" (-1#*?/( "+$(%)' 2+D2(*" 345 &(;(& F%* ?*('7 `#*" *?>0#**+&/(*1#)*(* *"($ 0/#$ '%"(' 2(/>%/+?$ *1(.+$()*I0/#$ "2( &%*" 5B@ ,(%/*JT F2(/( .#//(*1#)'+)D 345.#).()"/%"+#)* %/( Y)#F) 0/#$ +.( .#/( '%"% Il(0"(& ("%&7T N<LMA =/+('&+ (" %&7T N<LEJ7 6%"% 0/#$ %&"+"?'+)%&"/%)*(."* %)' )%"?/%& 345 *1/+)D* %/( %&*# 1&%.(' +)"2( *?>0#**+& .%"(D#/,T %* "2+* .%"(D#/, /(1/(*()"* "2(.&#*(*" $%".2 +) "(/$* #0 345 (-1#*?/( "+$(7 =+)%&&,T0#**+& /(*1#)*(* .#)*+*" #0 F(&&G'%"(' 0#**+& $%"(/+%&7`("2#'* 0#/ #>"%+)+)D /(0(/().( 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*0#/ "2( 0#**+& /(*1#)*(* %/( '+*.?**(' >(&#F7V%.2 /(*1#)*( F%* %**+D)(' %* (+"2(/ +)./(%*+)D

"8 " @!@M#" '(./(%*+)D "8 " @!@M#" #/ /($%+)+)D "2(*%$( "8 $ @!@M# /(&%"+;( "# .#)"/#&*7 f2(/( 8G;%&?(*F(/( )#" /(1#/"('T % "(*" 0#/ #;(/&%11+)D *"%)'%/''(;+%"+#)* F%* ?*('T F2+.2 ",1+.%&&, ,+(&'* % .#)*(/G;%"+;( (*"+$%"( 0#/ *"%"+*"+.%& *+D)+H.%).( I/(&%"+;( "#"2( " ! @!@M &(;(&J7

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?B

Page 5: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

W9@9 M<.$)'/$&+"# )$*.0&*$*

N5O !6 %)' OB !K /(*1#)*(* 0/#$ % 1##& #0 EL*1(.+(* %/( /(1/(*()"(' 2(/(7 =#/ !6T B@S #0 "2((-1(/+$()"%& /(*1#)*(* +);(/*(&, /(*1#)' I%" "2( " !@!@M &(;(&J "# 345A "2( 1/#1#/"+#) 0#/ *"#$%"%& +)'+.(*+* *+$+&%/ IPESJ IR%>&( NJ7^&%)"* (-1#*(' "# *?>%$>+()" 345 %/( $#/( &+Y(&,

"# +);(/*(&, /(*1#)' "2%) 1&%)"* (-1#*(' "# (&(;%"('345 0#/ >#"2 !6 IM@ ;*7 P<SA 8 ! @!PEJ %)' !K IL< ;*75<SA 8 " @!@@N#! R2(*( /(*?&"* *?11#/" 1/(;+#?*.&%+$* "2%" 1&%)"* $#/( *"/#)D&, (-1/(** "2(345_!6U!K +);(/*( /(&%"+#)*2+1 F2() (-1#*(' "#*?>%$>+()" ;(/*?* (&(;%"(' 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*If##'F%/'T N<LOA f##'F%/' %)' X%QQ%QT N<LLAX((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<P%A \?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7TN<<OJ7 C .#$$#) (-1&%)%"+#) 0#/ "2+* 345 j.(+&+)Dd12()#$()#) +* "2%" 1&%)"* "#'%, 2%;( )#" (-1(/+().('(&(;%"(' 345 &(;(&* IPM@# 11$ZJ 0#/ %" &(%*" "2(()"+/( m?%"(/)%/, %)' 1#**+>&, &#)D(/ I^%D%)+ (" %&7T

N<<<%A ^(%/*#) %)' ^%&$(/T N<<<J7 R2?*T 0#/ *2#/""+$( *.%&(* F2(/( #)&, 1&%)" 1&%*"+.+", +* "(*"('T 1&%)"*/(*1#)' $#/( 0%;#/%>&, "# 345 .#)'+"+#)* F2+.2 "2(,$#*" /(.()"&, (-1(/+().('T )%$(&, *?>%$>+()".#).()"/%"+#)* If##'F%/'T N<LLA X((/&+)D %)' 32%&G#)(/T N<<P%J7 R2( +$1&+.%"+#) 0#/ *"#$%"%&G>%*(' 345/(.#)*"/?."+#)* +* "2%" (-1(/+$()"%& (;+'().( >%*('#) (&(;%"(' 345 "/(%"$()"* $%, )#" /(i(." "2( /(&+%G>+&+", #0 "2( $("2#'7 4;(/ LMS #0 "2( (-1(/+$()"%&/(*1#)*(* %)%&,Q(' 2(/( *"($ 0/#$ (&(;%"(' 345"/(%"$()"*7 C)#"2(/ /(&%"(' .#).(/) /%+*(' F+"2(-1(/+$()"%& /(*?&"* +* "2%" 345 +* *2+0"(' +) #)(*"(1 +) .#)"/%*" "# "2( *$##"2(/T &#)D(/G"(/$ "/()' +))%"?/( IX((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<5A \?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7TN<<OJ7C) %&"(/)%"+;( (-1&%)%"+#) 0#/ "2( 345 .(+&+)D +*

"2%" F2+&( 345 +* &+$+"+)D 0#/ 12#"#*,)"2(*+* %" 345.#).()"/%"+#)* >(&#F 1/(*()"G'%, &(;(&*T +" +* )#"&+$+"+)D %" (&(;%"(' &(;(&*7 R2(/(0#/(T 0#/ (-%$1&(T+0 345 '(./(%*(* +) % *?>%$>+()" 345 /(D+$(

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? M

R%>&( N!"%"+*"+.%& *?$$%/, #0 *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* "# .2%)D+)D 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*

V-1(/+$()"%& !?>0#**+& =#**+& 3#$>+)('

!6% !K> !6 !K !6 !K !6 !K

S. I&J S I&J S I&J S I&J S I&J S I&J S I&J S I&J

R#"%& B@ IN5OJ PE IOBJ M@ INPPJ PB IPMJ LL I5MJ <B IPEJ B< I5LMJ M@ INBMJV&(;%"(' 345

' P< IN@<J 5< IEMJ _ _ _ _ N@@ INPJ <E I5BJ BM I5P5J BN INNEJ!?>%$>+()" 345 M@ INLJ L< I<J _ _ _ _ L< I<J L< I<J OM IB@J LL I5MJ411#*+"( /(*1#)*(( < IN5OJ B IOBJ NN INPPJ < IPMJ N5 I5MJ P IPEJ NN I5LMJ M INBMJ],1#*"#$%"#?*0 M< I5OJ EM INOJ M@ IL@J PL I5BJ _ _ _ _ ME IN5NJ E< IO@JC$12+*"#$%"#?*D PE I<@J 5O IMMJ B< IB<J 5M ILJ _ _ _ _ BB INB<J P5 IONJC>%-+%& B@ IBMJ 5B I5<J BN I55J _ _ _ _ _ _ BN IELJ 5N IPPJC'%-+%& 5< IB5J PN I5EJ MM I55J _ _ _ _ _ _ PL IEMJ PP IP@J

V-1(/+$()"* ?*+)D 4R3*2 NP IPNJ NP I5BJ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _V-1(/+$()"* ?*+)D D/(()2#?*(* BL I<MJ BL IM@J _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _](/>%/+?$ *"?'+(* #)&, _ k _ _ _ MO I<PJ L< I<J _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _9(1(%"(' *1(.+(*+ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ MO I5LJ MM INNJ

% !"#$%"%& '()*+",7> !"#$%"%& +)'(-7. ^(/.()"%D( #0 /(*1#)*(* +);(/*(&, .#//(&%"+)D F+"2 3457' 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* %/( 2+D2(/ "2%) .#)"/#&*7( ^(/.()"%D( #0 /(*1#)*(* 1#*+"+;(&, .#//(&%"+)D F+"2 34570 8(%;(* F+"2 *"#$%"% #)&, #) %>%-+%& I&#F(/J *+'(7D 8(%;(* F+"2 *"#$%"% #) >#"2 *?/0%.(*72 4R3! #1()G"#1 .2%$>(/A ",1+.%&&, .#)(G*2%1(' F+"2 %) #1() "#17+ =#/ *1(.+(* F+"2 $?&"+1&( /(*1#)*(* F+"2 %N +);(/*(&, .#//(&%"+)D F+"2 345T 1(/.()"%D( "2%" .#)*+*"()"&, +);(/*(&, .#//(&%"(7k l#" %11&+.%>&( #/ *%$1&( *+Q( "## *$%&& 0#/ $(%)+)D0?& .#$1%/+*#)7

Page 6: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

IF2(/( 345 +* &+$+"+)D 0#/ 12#"#*,)"2(*+*JT %$(.2%)+*$ (-+*"* "# +)./(%*( *"#$%"%& 1#/( %/(%%)'T >, (-"()*+#)T 345 ?1"%Y(7 R2( *%$( $%,)#" >( "/?( %" (&(;%"(' 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* +0345 +* )#" &+$+"+)D 0#/ 12#"#*,)"2(*+* ?)'(/*?.2 .#)'+"+#)* If%D)(/ (" %&7T N<<EA \?e/*.2)(/(" %&7T N<<LJ7 V$1+/+.%& '%"% '# )#" *"/#)D&,*?11#/" "2+* %&"(/)%"+;( 2,1#"2(*+*7 f2+&( %**+$+G&%"+#) /%"(* D()(/%&&, '(./(%*( %" *?>%$>+()" 345

&(;(&* I^#&&(, (" %&7T N<<5A 9#>+)*#)T N<<BJT "2(,%&*# ",1+.%&&, +)./(%*( +) /(*1#)*( "# 345 .#).()G"/%"+#)* #0 %" &(%*" O@@ 11$Z I8#)D (" %&7T N<<EA3?/"+* %)' f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

.#)'?."(' +) (+"2(/ ().&#*(' D/(()2#?*(* #/#1()G"#1 .2%$>(/* I4R3*J7 `#*" 4R3* 2%;(&(** .#)"/#& #;(/ 2?$+'+", %)' "($1(/%"?/(7!+D)+H.%)" j.2%$>(/ (00(."*d 2%;( >(() '("(."('0#/ *"#$%"%& 1%/%$("(/* I\)%11 (" %&7T N<<BAC11&( (" %&7T 5@@@JT %)' /(*?&"* D()(/%"(' 2(/(*?11#/" *?.2 .&%+$*7 ^&%)"* +) 4R3* +);(/*(&,/(*1#)' "# 345 +) 0%/ 0(F(/ .%*(* "2%) D/(()2#?*(D/#F) 1&%)"* 0#/ >#"2 !6 INP ;*7 BLSA 8 " @!@@N#%)' !K INP ;*7 BLSA 8 " @!@N#! R2?*T +" %11(%/*4R3* +)"/#'?.( .#)0#?)'+)D 0%."#/* %)' *2#?&' >(%;#+'(' +) !6U!K F#/Y7C&"2#?D2 "2( 1/#1#/"+#) #0 (-1(/+$()"%& /(*1#)*(*

+);(/*(&, /(*1#)'+)D "# 345 $%, %11(%/ &#F IB@ %)'PES 0#/ !6 %)' !KT /(*1(."+;(&,JT +) 1%/" 0/#$ "2(0%."#/* '+*.?**(' %>#;(T +" +* +$1#/"%)" "# )#"( "2%""2( 1(/.()"%D( #0 /(*1#)*(* *2#F+)D % 1#*+"+;( /(&%G"+#)*2+1 "8 " @!@M# +* ;(/, &#F I< %)' BS 0#/ !6 %)'!KT /(*1(."+;(&,J7 R2?*T "2( ;%*" $%k#/+", #0 1&%)"*(+"2(/ /(*1#)' +);(/*(&, "# (-1(/+$()"%& (-1#*?/( "#345 #/ '# )#" /(*1#)' %" %&&7

W9=9 JXR10**'# )$*.0&*$*

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k#/+", #0 1&%)"* IMO %)' L<S 0#/ !6 %)' !KT /(*1(.G"+;(&,J /(*1#)'(' F+"2 *+D)+H.%)" '(./(%*(* +) !6%)'U#/ !K7 C" 2+D2(/ 345 &(;(&*T 2#F(;(/T %*(-1/(**(' )(%/ )%"?/%& 345 *1/+)D*T % *$%&&(/ 1/#1#/G"+#) #0 1&%)"* /(*1#)'(' F+"2 &#F(/ !6 IP@SA & ! P@#%)'U#/ !K INESA & ! 5M#! K0T #) "2( #"2(/ 2%)'T .?//()"345 .#).()"/%"+#)* '# &0+ /(1/(*()" % "/?( D()("+..(+&+)D 0#/ 1&%)"*T "2%) "2(*( '%"% *2#F "2%" "2( $%k#/G+", #0 1&%)"* .%))#" %'%1" "# 345 &(;(&* %>#;( "#'%,d*F+"2+) "2( *1(.+%& /(*+'().( "+$( )(%/ )%"?/%& 345*1/+)D* IN@5_N@P ,(%/*nJ7K) %..#/'%).( F+"2 "2( (-1(/+$()"%& /(*1#)*(*T %

;(/, *$%&& 1/#1#/"+#) #0 "2( *?>0#**+& #>*(/;%"+#)*1#*+"+;(&, /(*1#)' "# 345 INN %)' <S 0#/ !6 %)'!KT /(*1(."+;(&,J7 `#*" 1&%)"* (+"2(/ +);(/*(&, /(*1#)'"# 345 #/ '# )#" /(*1#)' %" %&&7 K0 345 (-(/"* %),+)i?().( #) *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#)T +" $?*" >( #0 %)+);(/*( >(2%;+#/7

W9W9 Y0**'# )$*.0&*$*

5M !6 %)' PE !K /(*1#)*(* 0/#$ % 1##& #0 5L*1(.+(* %/( /(1/(*()"(' 2(/(7 =#/ !6T LLS #0 "2(#>*(/;%"+#)* *2#F %) +);(/*( /(&%"+#)*2+1 I%" "2( " !

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?E

Page 7: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

@!@M &(;(&J "# 345A 0#/ !KT "2( 1/#1#/"+#) +* <BSIR%>&( NJ7 4)&, N5 %)' PS #0 "2( #>*(/;%"+#)* 1#*+G"+;(&, /(*1#)' "# 345 0#/ !6 %)' !KT /(*1(."+;(&,7R2?*T "2( /#>?*")(** #0 "2( !6U!K $("2#' +$1/#;(*F+"2 +)./(%*(' 345 (-1#*?/( "+$( I=+D7 5JT *?11#/"+)D(%/&+(/ 2,1#"2(*(* IX((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<5TN<<P%J7m?%&+"%"+;(&,T "2( "/%)*+"+#) >("F(() '#$+)%).( #0

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

*2#F+)D %) +);(/*( /(&%"+#)*2+1 "# 345 %* % 0?)."+#)#0 (-1#*?/( "+$( .#$(* %" "2( (-1()*( #0 +)*()*+"+;(/(*1#)*(* I=+D7 5J *?11#/"* "2+* %**?$1"+#)7 N@5 "# N@P

,(%/* +* *&+D2"&, &#)D(/ "2%) 1/(;+#?* (*"+$%"(*IX((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<P%JT %)' *2#?&' D+;(/+*( "# *#$( .%?"+#) +) ?*+)D (-1(/+$()"%& %)' *?>G0#**+& /(*1#)*(* +) 1%&(#G345 /(.#)*"/?."+#)* I+7(7.#$1%/+)D /(*1#)*(* '?( $%+)&, "# 1&%*"+.+", ;(/*?*D()("+. %'%1"%"+#)J7R2( 0#**+& '%"% .%*" '#?>" #) "2( )#"+#) "2%" *"#$%"%

.%))#" /(*1#)' "# 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* %>#;( 1/(*()"G'%, &(;(&*7 R2( 1/#1#/"+#) #0 0#**+& /(*1#)*(* *2#F+)D%) +);(/*( /(&%"+#)*2+1 >%*(' #) *?>%$>+()" 345(-1#*?/( %/( )(%/&, (W?%& "# "2#*( 0#**+& #>*(/;%"+#)*>%*(' #) (&(;%"(' 345 (-1#*?/( 0#/ >#"2 !6 IL< %)'N@@ST /(*1(."+;(&,J %)' !K IL< %)' <EST /(*1(.G"+;(&,JT %&"2#?D2 *%$1&( *+Q(* %/( 0%+/&, *$%&&IR%>&( NJ7 !#$( D/#?1* #0 1&%)"* /(*1#)' "# 345&(;(&* #0 %" &(%*" 5O@@ 11$Z I`.V&F%+) %)' 32%&G#)(/T N<<MA C11()'+- 3J7 R2+* /(*?&" '#(* )#"'+*.#?)"T 2#F(;(/T "2%" *"#$%"%& 1%/%$("(/* $%, >(&(** *$&*'+'($ %" (&(;%"(' "2%) %" *?>%$>+()" I/(&%"+;("# "#'%,J 345 &(;(&*7 R2( 345 .(+&+)D #>*(/;(' +)(-1(/+$()"%& /(*1#)*(* "2(/(0#/( %11(%/ "# *"($0/#$ "2( *2#/"G"(/$ +)%>+&+", #0 1&%)"* "# /(*1#)' "#(&(;%"(' 345T )#" % &#)DG"(/$ D()("+. &+$+"7 K)"(/(*"G+)D&,T f##'F%/' IN<LLJ )#"(' "2%" 1&%)"* F+"2 *2#/"D()(/%"+#) "+$(* I(7D7 %))?%&*J %/( #0"() .%1%>&( #0'(./(%*+)D "2(+/ *"#$%"%& '()*+"+(* F2() (-1(/+$()G"%&&, (-1#*(' "# (&(;%"(' 345 &(;(&* I0#/ %N ,(%/JT1/#>%>&, >(.%?*( #0 "2(+/ W?+.Y(/ D()("+. %'%1"%"+#)/%"(* If##'F%/'T N<LLJ7 R2+* *?DD(*"* "2%" "2( (-1#G*?/( "+$( /(W?+/(' "# $+"+D%"( "2( 345 .(+&+)D $%, )#">( $?.2 >(,#)' ",1+.%& (-1(/+$()"%& (-1#*?/( "+$(*T%)' +) 0%." $%, )#" (-+*" %" %&& 0#/ *#$( 1&%)"*73%?"+#) +* ?/D(' F+"2 /(D%/' "# *(;(/%& 0(%"?/(*

.#).(/)+)D "2( 0#**+& /(*1#)*(*7 =+/*"T +) *(;(/%&*"?'+(* *"#$%"%& .#$1%/+*#)* >("F(() 0#**+& %)'$#'(/) 1&%)"* F(/( $%'( F+"2 "F# *(1%/%"( >?" (.#&#GD+.%&&, (W?+;%&()" *("* #0 *1(.+(* I`.V&F%+) %)'32%&#)(/T N<<MT N<<EA `.V&F%+)T N<<LA `.V&F%+)(" %&7T N<<<J7 K) %''+"+#) "# "2( &#)DG"(/$ +)i?().(#0 345 #) !6 %)' !K 0#/ % D+;() *1(.+(*T +" 2%* %&*#>(() *2#F)T 0#/ (-%$1&(T "2%" 2+D2 345 *(&(."* 0#/D/#?1* #0 1&%)"* F+"2 &#F(/ $(%) *"#$%"%& '()*+"+(*U+)'+.(* IX((/&+)DT N<<EA X((/&+)D %)' f##'F%/'TN<<OJ I=+D7 PJ7 R2?*T +" +* )#" 1%/"+.?&%/&, *?/1/+*+)D"2%" *"#$%"%& '()*+"+(* %)' +)'+.(* 0/#$ "+$(* #0 2+D2

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? O

=+D7 57 R2( 1(/.()"%D( #0 /(*1#)*(* 0#/ I%J !6 %)' I>J !K "2%"+);(/*(&, /(&%"( "# 345 Ij+);(/*(dJT *2#F )# *+D)+H.%)" .2%)D( "#345 Ij+)*()*+"+;(dJT #/ /(*1#)' 1#*+"+;(&, "# 345 Ij1#*+"+;(dJ +) (%.2#0 "2/(( .%"(D#/+(*7 l#"( "2%" #)&, 2(/>%/+?$ /(*1#)*(* .#$1#*( "2(*?>0#**+& .%"(D#/,7

Page 8: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

345 %/( &#F(/ "2%) 0#/ (.#&#D+.%&&, (W?+;%&()"$#'(/) *1(.+(*7 K'(%&&,T "2(*( "F# (00(."* *2#?&' >(Y(1" *(1%/%"(7!(.#)'T (*"+$%"(* #0 345 0#/ "2( 0#**+& /(*1#)*(*

%/( +);%/+%>&, )#" %* %..?/%"( %* "2#*( (*"+$%"(* 0#/(-1(/+$()"%& %)' *?>0#**+& /(*1#)*(*7 K.( .#/( '(/+;(''%"% %/( ?*(' 0#/ "2( &%*" NM@ Y7,7T %)' "2( $#'(& #0X(/)(/ IN<<BJ #/ #"2(/ 1/#-, '%"% %/( $#*" #0"() ?*('0#/ 1/(G+.( .#/( /(*1#)*(*7 K) 1%/"+.?&%/T (*"+$%"(*0/#$ X(/)(/d* .?/;( %/( 2+D2&, %11/#-+$%"( '?( "#+"* *+Q%>&( (//#/ ();(&#1( %)' .#%/*( N@ $7,7 "+$(/(*#&?"+#) I*(( =+D7 NJA >/+(0 >?" &%/D( 345 (-.?/*+#)*'+*.(/)%>&( F+"2 "2( ;%/+#?* 1/#-, $("2#'* %/( 1/#>G%>&, "## "($1#/%&&, .#)*"/%+)(' "# +)i?().( X(/)(/d*$#'(& I`#)"%)o(Q (" %&7T N<<<J7 K) .%*(* F2(/( (-1(/+G$()"%& %)' *?>0#**+& /(*1#)*(* %/( ?*(' "# D()(/%"( %*"%)'%/' .?/;( ?1#) F2+.2 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* %/('+/(."&, .%&.?&%"(' 0/#$ 0#**+& /(*1#)*(*T +.( .#/('%"% IX((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<MA f%D)(/ (" %&7T N<<<A9?)'D/() %)' X((/&+)DT N<<<J #/ "2( 1/(*().( #0"($1(/%"?/( (-.?/*+#)* I;%) '(/ X?/D2 (" %&7T N<<PA\?e/*.2)(/T N<<EA \?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7T N<<EJ %/( ?*(' "#.#//#>#/%"( "2( *"#$%"%&G>%*(' (*"+$%"(*7

W9S9 E0/R'&$4 4"+" *$+

X%*(' #) "2( .#$>+)%"+#) #0 "2( %>#;( "2/(( .%"(GD#/+(*T >#"2 !6 %)' !K +);(/*(&, .#//(&%"( F+"2 345.%7 M@S #0 "2( "+$( I& ! 5LM %)' NBMT /(*1(."+;(&,JIR%>&( NJ7 Z(/, /%/(&, '# "2( /(*1#)*(* 1#*+"+;(&,.#//(&%"( F+"2 345 INN %)' MS 0#/ !6 %)' !KT /(*1(.G"+;(&,J7 =#/ *1(.+(* "2%" 2%;( >(() %)%&,Q(' /(1(%"G('&, >, '+00(/()" /(*(%/.2(/*T "2#*( "2%" +);(/*(&,/(*1#)' "# 345 "()' %&F%,* "# /(*1#)' +) *?.2 %F%, IMOS "& ! 5L# %)' MMS "& ! NN# 0#/ !6 %)'!KT /(*1(."+;(&,J7 f##'F%/' %)' \(&&, IN<<MJ/(1#/"(' % *+$+&%/ >(2%;+#/T F2(/( OES #0 "2(+/ *()*+G"+;( *1(.+(* .#)*+*"()"&, /(*1#)'('7R2?*T %&"2#?D2 /(*1#)*( "+$(* '+00(/ I*(( %>#;( %)'

=+D7 5JT 345 +* 2+D2&, )(D%"+;(&, .#//(&%"(' F+"2 *"#$%G"%& +)+"+%"+#)7 C *.%""(/1&#" #0 %&& '%"% *2#F* %) #;(/%&&+);(/*( /(&%"+#)*2+1 >("F(() !6U!K %)' 345 I=+D7 B%J7C&"2#?D2 "2( #;(/%&& /(D/(**+#) +* )#" /#>?*" ")5 ! @!5E!& ! B5@#" "2+* 1/+).+1%&&, *"($* 0/#$ (W?+;#.%& (-1(/+G$()"%& %)' )%"?/%& 345 *1/+)D '%"%7 R2( 0#**+& '%"%TF2() /(D/(**(' +)'(1()'()"&,T ,+(&' %) )5 #0 @7EL"& ! M<# I=+D7 B>J7 h+;() "2( *1(.+(*G*1(.+H. %)'

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?L

=+D7 P7 !6 ;(/*?* "+$( 0#/ "2( ^2%)(/#Q#+.7 9('/%F) 0/#$ X((/&+)D %)' f##'F%/' IN<<OJT F+"2 %''+"+#)%& '%"% 1&#""(' 0/#$ `.V&F%+) %)'32%&#)(/ IN<<EJT V'F%/'* (" %&7 IN<<LJT `.V&F%+) IN<<LJT 3&(%& (" %&7 IN<<<J %)' `.V&F%+) (" %&7 IN<<<J7 9(D/(**+#) +* % "2+/' #/'(/1#&,)#$+%& ")5 ! @!MO! & ! NP5#! 3#$1%/( "/()' F+"2 =+D7 N7

=+D7 B7 I%J !.%""(/1&#" #0 %&& '%"% ")5 ! @!5E! & ! B5@# *2#F+)D "2( .?>( /##" "/%)*0#/$ #0 1(/.()"%D( .2%)D( +) !6 %)' !K +) /(*1#)*( "#1(/.()"%D( .2%)D( +) %"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)7 9(*1#)*(* +) W?%'/%)"* KK %)' KZ +);(/*(&, /(&%"( "# 345 F2+&( /(*1#)*(* +) W?%'/%)"* K%)' KKK 1#*+"+;(&, /(&%"(7 I>J !+$+&%/ *.%""(/1&#" 0#/ 0#**+& '%"% #)&,7 9(D/(**+#) (W?%"+#) #0 ?)"/%)*0#/$(' '%"%[ , ! NN5!BP(-1"&@!@@5E<#&N@@! ")5 ! @!EL! & ! M<#!

Page 9: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? <

Page 10: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

1/#>%>&( $?&"+G$(.2%)+*"+. )%"?/( #0 "2( /(&%"+#)*2+1T"2+* /(D/(**+#) +* *?/1/+*+)D&, /#>?*"73?/+#?*&,T >%*(' *#&(&, #) "2( .#$>+)(' /(*?&"*T +"

%11(%/* !6 +* (W?%&&, /(&+%>&( %* !K %* % 345 +)'+.%"#/IR%>&( NJ7 R2( +$1&+.%"+#)* %/( "($1"+)DT %* (1+'(/$%&.(&&* %/( #0"() '+0H.?&" "# /(*#&;( +) 0#**+& $%"(/+%&IX((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<NA `.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/TN<<EJ7 R2+* +**?( +* '+*.?**(' +) "2( *(."+#) >(&#F7`#*" ;%*.?&%/ &%)' 1&%)"* 2%;( *"#$%"% #) (+"2(/

>#"2 *?/0%.(* I%$12+*"#$%"#?*J #/ #)&, "2( %>%-+%&I&#F(/J *?/0%.( I2,1#*"#$%"#?*J7 f##'F%/' %)'\(&&, IN<<MJ /(1#/"(' )# *"/#)D '+00(/().(* +)/(*1#)*(* >("F(() "2( "F# &(%0 ",1(*T %&"2#?D2 +)(-1(/+$()"%& /(*1#)*(* %$12+*"#$%"#?* *1(.+(*%11(%/(' $#/( &+Y(&, "# +);(/*(&, /(&%"( "# 34579(*?&"* 2(/( +)'+.%"( 2,1#*"#$%"#?* *1(.+(* $#/(#0"() +);(/*(&, /(*1#)' "# 345 0#/ >#"2 !6 IME ;*7BBSA 8 " @!@P# %)' !K IE< ;*7 P5SA 8 " @!@@N#! =#/%$12+*"#$%"#?* *1(.+(*T )(+"2(/ "2( %>%-+%& )#/ %'%-G+%& I?11(/J *?/0%.( ,+(&' *"%"+*"+.%&&, '+00(/()"/(*1#)*(* IR%>&( NJ7

=) >,$2+$/&5 ',+?,.+-/+6 ?&'$,%#

345 +* &+Y(&, )#" "2( *#&( 0%."#/ '("(/$+)+)D *"#$%G"%& '()*+", %)' *"#$%"%& +)'(-7 C* '+*.?**(' %>#;(T!6 +* *()*+"+;( "# >#"2 *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#) %)' (1+'(/G$%& .(&& (-1%)*+#)T F2+&( !K +* *()*+"+;( #)&, "#*"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#)7 R2( +)i?().( #0 )%"?/%& ;%/+%>+&G+",T F%"(/ *"/(**T +//%'+%).(T "($1(/%"?/( %)' #"2(/0%."#/* #) *"#$%"%& 1%/%$("(/* %/( >/+(i, '+*.?**('>(&#F7 `#/( "2#/#?D2 /(;+(F* %/( D+;() >, !%&+*>?/,IN<5OJT R+.2%g IN<L5J %)' f##'F%/' %)' \(&&,IN<<MJ7

S9@9 B"+X)"# (")'"R'#'+,

K) D()(/%&T *"#$%"%& '()*+", +)./(%*(* 0/#$ &(%0>%*( "# "+1 I!%&+*>?/,T N<5OA !2%/$% %)' 6?))TN<ELT N<E<A R+.2%gT N<L5A !$+"2 (" %&7T N<L<A =(//+*(" %&7T N<<EA p%..2+)+ (" %&7T N<<OA !"%).%"# (" %&7TN<<<J7 !6 %&*# #0"() +)./(%*(* 0/#$ &(%0 $+'/+> "#

$%/D+) I!%&+*>?/,T N<5OA !2%/$% %)' 6?))T N<ELA!$+"2 (" %&7T N<L<JT %&"2#?D2 *#$("+$(* "2( '+00(/G().(* %/( )#" *+D)+H.%)" I!2%/$% %)' 6?))T N<E<AR+.2%g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

'+*"%& /(D+#)* #0 "2( 1&%)" I!%&+*>?/,T N<5OA h%, %)']?/'T N<OMA R+.2%gT N<L5A 4>(/>%?(/ %)' !"/%+)T N<LEAp%..2+)+ (" %&7T N<<OJT 1/+$%/+&, %* % .#)*(W?().( #0'(./(%*(' F%"(/ 1#"()"+%&7 6(./(%*(' F%"(/ 1#"()"+%&*"+$?&%"(* -(/#12,"+. "/%+"*T F2+.2 +).&?'( *$%&&(/(1+'(/$%& .(&&*T F2+.2 +) "?/) 1/#$#"( .&#*(/ 1%.Y+)D#0 *"#$%"%T %)' "2?* +)./(%*(' !67 8+""&( (00(." +*/(1#/"(' 0#/ !K I9#F*#)T N<BEJT %&"2#?D2 (;(/D/(()*1(.+(* $%, (-2+>+" % *+D)+H.%)" D/%'+()" I\?e/*.2)(/Tf7`7T 1(/*#)%& .#$$?)+.%"+#)T 5@@@J7 3#)i%"(' F+"2"2+* "/()' %/( "2( '+00(/().(* >("F(() *?) %)' *2%'(&(%;(*7 CD%+)T !6 +* .#)*+*"()"&, 2+D2(/ +) *?) &(%;(*F2+&( !K ;%&?(* /($%+) .#)*(/;%"+;( I!%&+*>?/,T N<5OA^##&( (" %&7T N<<EA\?e/*.2)(/T N<<OAf%D)(/T N<<LJF+"2"2( (-.(1"+#) #0 "2( *"?', #0 ^##&( (" %&7 IN<<EJT F2#0#?)' % *$%&& OS '(.&+)( +) !K 0#/ *2%'( ;(/*?* *?)&(%;(*7 =#/ 0#**+& *"?'+(*T *+).( *?) &(%;(* +) %&&#.2"2#G)#?* %**($>&%D(* %/( 1/(0(/()"+%&&, 1/(*(/;(' I!1+.(/TN<LNJT "2+* +**?( +* #0"() )#" % .#).(/) (;() 0#/ !6G>%*(' F#/Y7 =#/ (-%$1&(T \?e/*.2)(/ IN<<OJ #>*(/;('"2%" <@S #0 2+* `+#.()( ZX$)6X* .*$X406"*+"&$"&(%;(* F(/( *?) $#/12#",1(*7

S9=9 ["+$) *+)$**

K) D()(/%&T F%"(/ *"/(** .#//(&%"(* F+"2 +)./(%*('!6 I!%&+*>?/,T N<5OA !2%/$% %)' 6?))T N<ELT N<E<AR+.2%gT N<L5A C>/%$*T N<<BA V*"+%/"( (" %&7T N<<BA

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?N@

=+D7 M7 I%J 345 /(&%"+;( "# %$>+()" .#).()"/%"+#)* 0#/ 0#?/ 2(+D2"* F+"2+) % "/(( .%)#1, +) N<<E7 3%)#1, 2(+D2" +* .%7 5B $7 4/'+)%"( /(1/(*()"**(;() '%, /?))+)D %;(/%D( #0 '%+&, %;(/%D(* #0 2#?/&, $(%*?/($()"* %" (%.2 2(+D2" I& ! MPNN 0#/ (%.2 2(+D2"J7 `(%*?/($()"* %" 5<7@ $ 2(+D2""%Y() %* %$>+()" ;%&?( I$(%) 0#/ "+$( +)"(/;%& %" "2+* 2(+D2"! PO@ 11$ZJ7 I>J 6+?/)%& "/()' #0 345 /(&%"+;( "# %$>+()" .#).()"/%"+#)* I'%"%0/#$ < C1/+&_NP q?&, N<<EJ7 4/'+)%"( /(1/(*()"* $(%) 0#/ (%.2 2#?/ %" (%.2 2(+D2" I& ! NPLL 0#/ (%.2 2(+D2"J7 !"%)'%/' (//#/* %11/#-+$%"(*+Q( #0 *,$>#&*7 9%F '%"% ?*(' F+"2 1(/$+**+#) #0 !7 f#0*,7

Page 11: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? NN

Page 12: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

3&+00#/' (" %&7T N<<MA ](.Y()>(/D(/ (" %&7T N<<LA^%e%eYY#e)() (" %&7T N<<LJ7 !#$( *"?'+(*T 2#F(;(/T/(1#/" )# /(*1#)*( IV*"+%/"( (" %&7T N<<BA 6+-#) ("%&7T N<<MA ^/+".2%/' (" %&7T N<<LA 3()"/+""# (" %&7TN<<<J7 l# *"?'+(* /(1#/" % '(./(%*(7 !K .#)*+*"()"&,%11(%/* +)*()*+"+;( "# F%"(/ *"/(** I!%&+*>?/,T N<5OA!2%/$% %)' 6?))T N<ELT N<E<A V*"+%/"( (" %&7T N<<BA3&+00#/' (" %&7T N<<MJ7!%&+*>?/, IN<5OJ 1/#1#*(' 2?$+'+", %* % $(.2%)G

+*$ 0#/ .#)"/#&&+)D *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#)T %)' "2?* !K7K)./(%*(' 2?$+'+", *&+D2"&, +)./(%*(' !K I8$ @7@MJ0#/ J6'##" &X+"&*T 2#F(;(/T R+.2%g IN<L5J .#).&?'('"2%" 2?$+'+", $%, %."?%&&, /('?.( *"#$%"%& +)'(-7!2%/$% %)' 6?)) IN<ELT N<E<J 0#?)' )# (00(."7R2?*T "2( .?//()" '%"% %/( (W?+;#.%&7

S9W9 \))"4'"&6$

l#" *?/1/+*+)D&,T &+D2" +)"()*+", ?*?%&&, 1#*+"+;(&,.#//(&%"(* F+"2 !6 I!2%/$% %)' 6?))T N<ELT N<E<Ah%, %)' ]?/'T N<OMA R+.2%gT N<L5A 4>(/>%?(/ %)'!"/%+)T N<LEA !#&%g/#;%g %)' ^#*1rg*s+&#;%gT N<LLA !"(F%/"%)' ]#''+)#""T N<<PA C*2"#) %)' X(/&,)T N<<BA=?/?Y%F%T N<<OA p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

*"/#)D&, %00(."* >#"2 !6 %)' !K I!.2#.2 (" %&7T N<L@Ap%..2+)+ (" %&7T N<<OJ7 !.2#.2 (" %&7 IN<L@J #>*(/;('"2%" (;() #)( '%, #0 &#F +//%'+%).( &(;(&* '?/+)D "2(./+"+.%& 1(/+#' #0 *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#) .#?&' %00(." !6%)' !K7 h+;() "2%" !K +* ",1+.%&&, .#)*(/;%"+;( +)'(.+'?#?* *1(.+(* F+"2+) % D+;() ./#F)T +" +* 1#**+>&("2( (00(."* #0 12#"#1(/+#' #) !K #>*(/;(' +) (-1(/+G$()"* %/( $+)+$%& +) )%"?/(7

S9S9 F$/.$)"+X)$

R($1(/%"?/( %11(%/* 1#*+"+;(&, .#//(&%"(' F+"2 !6I=(//+* (" %&7T N<<EA 9('', (" %&7T N<<LA f%D)(/T N<<LA>?" *(( C11&( (" %&7T 5@@@JT % &+Y(&, .#)*(W?().( #0

()2%).(' F%"(/ *"/(**7 R($1(/%"?/( $%, %&*# %00(." !KI=(//+* (" %&7T N<<EA f%D)(/T N<<LJT *?DD(*"+)D %)+)i?().( #) *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#)7 9('', (" %&7 IN<<LJT2#F(;(/T 0#?)' )# /(*1#)*(7 R2( +)i?().( #0"($1(/%"?/( #) *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#) $%, >( +).#)*(GW?()"+%&T "2#?D2T %* $#*" 1&%)"* 1%/"+%&&, )#/$%&+Q(0#/ i?."?%"+)D "($1(/%"?/(* >, %'k?*"+)D "2( "+$+)D#0 &(%0 '(;(&#1$()"T %)' *# "2( "($1(/%"?/( %" F2+.2*"#$%"% 0#/$ /($%+)* 0%+/&, .#)*"%)" If%D)(/T N<<LJ7

S9H9 E"&0., E:= 3)"4'$&+

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`%**%.2?*(""*Tt!CT .#)*+*"* #0 $+-(' 2%/'F##'* %)' .#)+0(/*7 C**2#F) +) =+D7 M%T %>#;( B7M $T F2(/( "2( >?&Y #0&(%;(* 0/#$ $%"?/( "/((* 0#/$T .%)#1, 345 &(;(&*%/( ;+/"?%&&, +)'+*"+)D?+*2%>&( 0/#$ %$>+()" &(;(&*7=?/"2(/$#/(T %&& '(;+%"+#)* '+$+)+*2 '?/+)D "2($+''&( #0 "2( '%, I=+D7 M>JT % 1(/+#' F2() .(&& /(*1+/%G"+#) %)' '+;+*+#) +* 2+D2(*"7 R2?*T 345 D/%'+()"*F+"2+) .%)#1+(* %/( &+Y(&, )#" *"/#)D ()#?D2 "# +)i?G().( *"#$%"%& +)+"+%"+#) /%"(*7

S9G9 8"#$0+"<0&0/,

^%&(#>#"%)+.%& *1(.+(* +'()"+H.%"+#) ;+% $#/12#&#GD+.%& .#$1%/+*#) F+"2 $#'(/) /(1/(*()"%"+;(* +* #0"()"()?#?*T 1%/"+.?&%/&, F+"2 1/(Gl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

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?N5

Page 13: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

>(2%;+#/* "2/#?D2 "+$(7 R2+*T +) "?/)T .#?&' %00(."1%&(#G345 /(.#)*"/?."+#)*7 4)( F%, "# .+/.?$;()""2+* 1/#>&($ +* "2/#?D2 "2( *"?', #0 "2( *1(.+(*d.&#*(*" (-"%)" *+*"(/ D/#?1 I(7D7 '( m?(+/#Q %)'h%?"2+(/T N<<@J7 K0 "2( *"#$%"% +) >#"2 (-"%)" *1(.+(**2#F % *+$+&%/ /(*1#)*( "# 345T "2() +" .%) >(%**?$(' "2%" "2+* *"#$%"%& >(2%;+#/ +) >#"2 *1(.+(*+* .#)*(/;%"+;( +) "+$( >%.Y "# %" &(%*" F2() "2(*1(.+(* >/%).2('7

S9]9 :+5$) .0+$&+'"# 60&10X&4'&3 1"6+0)*

R2/#?D2 "2( .#$1%/+*#) #0 N@@ *1(.+(*T )(+"2(/D/#F"2 0#/$ IF##'+)(** ;*7 )#)GF##'+)(**A "/((*;*7 *2/?>*JT 2%>+"%" I.##& ;*7 F%/$JT )#/ "%-#)#$+./(&%"(')(** *"/#)D&, .#//(&%"(' F+"2 !6 If##'F%/'%)' \(&&,T N<<MJ7 ]%>+"%" 2%* %&*# >(() 0#?)' )#" "#%00(." !K I9#F*#)T N<BEJ7 C)%&,*+* #0 "2( '%"% *("1/(*()"(' 2(/( *2#F* "2%" 0#/ D()(/% /(1/(*()"(' >,$N *1(.+(*T #)&, N<S "& ! NE# %)' NBS "& ! O# #0"2(*( D()(/% /(*1#)' +) % .#)*+*"()" 0%*2+#) "# 345I+7(7 1#*+"+;(T )(D%"+;(T #/ +)*()*+"+;(J 0#/ !6 %)' !KT/(*1(."+;(&,7 R2(*( /(*?&"* 1/#;+'( 0?/"2(/ *?11#/" 0#/"2( "%-#)#$+. +)'(1()'().( #0 *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* "#3457C) +)./(%*( +) 1&#+', &(;(& +* %**#.+%"(' F+"2 &#F(/

!6 I9#F*#)T N<BEA `+*2/%T N<<OJ7 l# .&(%/ "/()' +*0#?)' +) !K I>%*(' #) "F# *"?'+(*JT F+"2 9#F*#)IN<BEJ /(1#/"+)D % '(./(%*( %)' `+*2/% IN<<OJ )#.2%)D(7 h+;() "2( F+'(*1/(%' ;%/+%>+&+", #0 1&#+',&(;(&* +) "2( 0#**+& /(.#/' I`%*"(/*#)T N<<BJT "2+*$%, 2%;( +$1#/"%)" .#)*(W?().(* 0#/ *"#$%"%&G>%*(' 345 /(.#)*"/?."+#)*7V&(;%"(' &(;(&* #0 #Q#)( +)./(%*( !6 +) ;$+X#"

.$&4X#" I=/(, (" %&7T N<<EA ^%e%eYY#e)() (" %&7T N<<LJTY)"<'&X* $<6$#*'0) If+&"*2+/( (" %&7T N<<EJ %)' :#$"$X)0."$" I`+))#..+ (" %&7T N<<<J7 V00(."* #) !K F(/()#" /(1#/"('7C&"2#?D2 &%/D(&, ?)"(*"('T %"$#*12(/+. #-,D()

$%, +)i?().( !6 %)' !K7 V&(;%"(' 45U345 /%"+#*+)./(%*( 12#"#/(*1+/%"+#) +) 3P 1&%)"*T *?11/(**+)D345 %**+$+&%"+#) /%"(*7 4)( 1%"2F%, "# $('+%"( "2+*'(.&+)( +* +)./(%*+)D !6 %)'U#/ !K7 V-1(/+$()"%& F#/Y#) D$4$)" 5$#'< %)' ;$+X#" .XR$*6$&* *2#F *&+D2"&,2+D2(/ *"#$%"%& +)'+.(* +) % PMS ;(/*?* 5NS 45 %"$#G*12(/( IX((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<L>J7 K0 .#//(."T "2+* 0%."#/$%, >( 1%/"+.?&%/&, +$1#/"%)" '?/+)D "2( 3%/>#)+0(/G#?* %)' (%/&, ^(/$+%) F2() 45 .#).()"/%"+#)* %/(

$#'(&(' "# (-.((' P@S IX(/)(/ %)' 3%)H(&'T N<L<AX(/)(/ (" %&7T 5@@@J7

@) 9.44&%7

X%*(' #) "2( '%"% 1/(*()"(' 2(/(T )(%/&, %&& *1(.+(*%11(%/ /(*1#)*+;( #) "2( "+$( *.%&(* +)2(/()" +) $#*"0#**+& 345 /(.#)*"/?."+#)* I$N@

5 ,(%/*J I=+D7 5AR%>&( NJ7 4)&, B@_M@S #0 *1(.+(* %/( /(*1#)*+;(#;(/ "2( "+$( *.%&(* #0 (-1(/+$()"%& %)' *?>0#**+&*"?'+(* I!N@&5_N@5 ,(%/*JT %)' *# "2#*( .#)'?."+)D*"?'+(* /(W?+/+)D *?.2 /(*1#)*(* $?*" "%Y( .%/( +).2##*+)D *()*+"+;( *1(.+(* IC11()'+.(* C %)' XJ7C)#"2(/ 1#"()"+%& F(%Y)(** +) ?"+&+Q+)D (-1(/+$()"%&%)' *?>0#**+& /(*1#)*(* +* "2%" "2(, %/( $#/( /(i(."+;(#0 1&%*"+.+", F+"2+) D+;() D()( 1##&*T %)' $%, '+*1&%,'+00(/()" >(2%;+#/* "2%) "2(+/ /(*1(."+;( 0#**+&/(*1#)*(* IF2+.2 %/( $#/( /(i(."+;( #0 D()("+. %'%1G"%"+#)J7!6 %)' !K %/( >#"2 (W?%&&, &+Y(&, "# +);(/*(&, /(&%"(

"# 3457 !6T 2#F(;(/T +* *()*+"+;( "# 0%."#/* %00(."+)D.(&& (-1%)*+#) *?.2 %* F%"(/ *"/(**T "($1(/%"?/(T %)'+//%'+%"+#)7 !KT +) .#)"/%*"T +* *()*+"+;( #)&, "# 0%."#/*%00(."+)D .(&& +)+"+%"+#)T #0 F2+.2 345 %11(%/* "# >(#)( 0%."#/7 R2?*T (;() +0 !6 %)' !K *2#F *+$+&%//(*1#)*(* 0#/ % D+;() *1(.+(* I(7D7 >#"2 1#*+"+;( #/)(D%"+;(JT !K *2#?&' ,+(&' $#/( %..?/%"( 345(*"+$%"(*7

H9@9 K..#'6"+'0&* 01 /$+504

C&"2#?D2 (-1(/+$()"%& F#/Y 2%* >(() .%//+(' #?"0#/ $%), ,(%/*T f##'F%/' IN<LOJ F%* "2( H/*" "#'#.?$()" "2( +);(/*( 345_!6U!K /(&%"+#)*2+1 #;(/&#)D(/ "+$( *.%&(* I5@@ ,(%/*J7 X((/&+)D (" %&7 IN<<NTN<<PJ (-"()'(' "2( %11&+.%>+&+", #0 "2( $("2#' "#NB@ Y7,7 F+"2 J"#'< 5$)R"6$"T F2(/( *"#$%"%& '()*+G"+(* *2#F(' % D()(/%& +);(/*( /(&%"+#)*2+1 F+"2 +.(.#/( /(.#)*"/?."(' 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*7 R2+* $("2#'2%* %&*# 1/#;() *?..(**0?& F+"2 <75 Y% J"#'< 6'&$)$"I`.V&F%+) (" %&7T N<<MJT NP Y% ;$+X#" &"&" IX((/&+)DTN<<PJT %)' 5L Y% 8'&X* ^$<'#'* I;%) '( f%"(/ (" %&7TN<<BJ7f2+&( "2( %>#;( *"?'+(* ;%&+'%"( "2( /(&%"+#)*2+1

#;(/ "+$( *.%&(* ?*(0?& 0#/ 0#**+& *"?'+(*T "2(, '# )#"D()(/%"( +)'(1()'()" (*"+$%"(* #0 1%&(#G3457 =#/"2+*T 0#**+& /(*1#)*(* $?*" >( H""(' "# % *"%)'%/'.?/;( >%*(' #) (-1(/+$()"%&T *?>0#**+&T %)' 0#**+&

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? NP

Page 14: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

/(*1#)*(* I0/#$ "2( &%*" B@@ Y7,7T 0#/ F2+.2 +.( .#/('%"% (-+*"A (7D7 ^("+" (" %&7T N<<<J #0 "2( *"/$ *1(.+(*7R2+* %11/#%.2 2%* >(() *?..(**0?& +) "2( ]#&#.()(F+"2 J"#'< 5$)R"6$" IX((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<P%AX((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<MA 9?)'D/() %)' X((/&+)DT N<<<J%)' ;$+X#" .XR$*6$&* %)' ;9 .$&4X#" If%D)(/ (" %&7TN<<<JT %)' +) "2( `+#.()( F+"2 ZX$)6X* .$+)"$" %)';$+X#" *XR.XR$*6$&* I;%) '(/ X?/D2 (" %&7T N<<PA\?e/*.2)(/T N<<EA \?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7T N<<EJ7 f2+&( "2+*%11/#%.2 1/#'?.(* "2( $#*" %..?/%"( 345 /(.#)*"/?.G"+#)*T +" +* &+$+"(' >, +"* /(W?+/($()" "# .#$1%/( +'()G"+.%& *1(.+(* I#/ 2+D2&, *+$+&%/ *1(.+(* F+"2+) % D()?*Af%D)(/ (" %&7T N<<<J7 R2(/( %/(T 2#F(;(/T *+)D&(*1(.+(* *1%))+)D $#*" #/ %&& #0 "2( &%"( 3/("%.(#?*%)' R(/"+%/, I(7D7 2'&_30 "4'"&+0'4$*UR'#0R"T *(;(/%&$($>(/* #0 R%-#'+%.(%(JT %)' *# 345 (*"+$%"(* 0#/"2+* +)"(/;%& %/( 1#**+>&(74)( .&(%/ %';%)"%D( #0 "2( *"#$%"%& $("2#' #;(/

#"2(/ 1/#-+(* %)' $#'(&* +* +"* 2+D2 "($1#/%& /(*#&?G"+#)7 R2( "($1#/%& /(*#&?"+#) #0 &%"( m?%"(/)%/, 0#**+&$%"(/+%& #0"() (-.(('* "2%" #0 +.( .#/(* IX((/&+)D ("%&7T N<<MA f%D)(/ (" %&7T N<<<JT %)' *+$+&%/ 2+D2 /(*#G&?"+#) '%"% 2%;( >(() ?*(' "# '#.?$()" 345 (-.?/G*+#)* %./#** "2( C&&(/u'Uc#?)D(/ 6/,%* IX((/&+)D ("%&7T N<<MJ %)' R/+%**+.Uq?/%**+. I`.V&F%+) (" %&7TN<<<J >#?)'%/+(*7 C)#"2(/ %';%)"%D( #;(/ #"2(/1/#-+(* %)' $#'(&* +* +"* 2+D2(/ &(;(& #0 1/(.+*+#)I.#$1%/( =+D7 N% F+"2 =+D7 EJ7V*"+$%"+)D 1/(G3/("%.(#?* 345 &(;(&* 1/#;(* $#/(

'+0H.?&"7 `.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/ IN<<MJ '(;(&#1(' %"(.2)+W?( .#$1%/+)D /(*1#)*(* #0 0#**+& *1(.+(* "#"2#*( #0 "2(+/ l(%/(*" 8+;+)D VW?+;%&()"* Il8V*J7l8V* %/( '(H)(' (.#&#D+.%&&,T )#" "%-#)#$+.%&&,T%)' /(1/(*()" "2( (.#&#D+.%&&, .&#*(*" &+;+)D %)%&#D"# "2( 0#**+& *1(.+(*7 !K /%"+#* #0 "2( 0#**+&*[l8V*F(/( .%&.?&%"('T %)' +) #/'(/ "# (*"+$%"( 345 "2(

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?NB

=+D7 E7 V*"+$%"(* #0 345 0#/ "2( 6(;#)+%)T 3%/>#)+0(/#?*_^(/$+%)T R/+%**+.T q?/%**+.T %)' V#.()( I?)$%/Y(' >#-(*J .%&.?&%"(' 0/#$ "2(*"#$%"%& /%"+# "(.2)+W?( #0 `.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/ IN<<MJ *?1(/+$1#*(' #;(/ "2( 345 .?/;( %)' .#//(*1#)'+)D (//#/ ();(&#1( #0 X(/)(/IN<<BT N<<LJ7 !"#$%"%& /%"+# *.%&( .%&+>/%"(' "# 9345 *.%&( ?*+)D % N[N .#//(*1#)'().(A "2+* +* "2( j9(.()" *"%)'%/'d #0 `.V&F%+) IN<<LJ7 9345%)' *"#$%"%& /%"+# '(H)(' +) =+D7 N %)' "(-"T /(*1(."+;(&,7 6%"% 0/#$ `.V&F%+) IN<<LJ %)' `.V&F%+) (" %&7 IN<<<J7 V*"+$%"(* #0 345 0#/ "2(`+#.()( Iv;wJ .%&.?&%"(' 0/#$ % 2(/>%/+%G>%*(' "/%+)+)D *("7 6%"% 0/#$ ;%) '(/ X?/D2 (" %&7 IN<<PJ %)' \?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7 IN<<EJ7

Page 15: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

3%/>#)+0(/#?*[l8V *"#$%"%& /%"+# F%* )#/$%&+Q(' "#"2( ^2%)(/#Q#+. 345 .?/;( #0 X(/)(/ IN<<BJT F+"2 "2(/($%+)'(/ #0 "2( /%"+#* *.%&(' %..#/'+)D&, +) % &+)(%/0%*2+#)7 h+;() "2%" "2+* $("2#' %**?$(* % &+)(%//(*1#)*( %)' +* )#" % "/?( +)'(1()'()" 345 +)'+.%"#/T/(.#)*"/?."(' 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* 0/#$ "2( 6(;#)+%)T3%/>#)+0(/#?*T ^(/$+%)T %)' q?/%**+. %&& $%".2('X(/)(/d* ;%&?(* /($%/Y%>&, F(&& I`.V&F%+) %)'32%&#)(/T N<<MT N<<EJ7 8%"(/ I`.V&F%+)T N<<LJT +)#/'(/ "# /('?.( "2( $("2#'d* '(1()'().( #) X(/)(/IN<<BJT '%"% I+).&?'+)D )(F $%"(/+%& 0/#$ "2( V#.()(JF(/( 1&#""(' %**?$+)D % N[N .#//(*1#)'().(>("F(() *"#$%"%& /%"+#* %)' 9345 I9345! /%"+##0 $%** #0 1%&(#G345 "# 1/(G+)'?*"/+%& ;%&?(A *((=+D7 NJ7 t*+)D "2+* $#/( +)'(1()'()" "(.2)+W?(T %&&>?" "2( 6(;#)+%) $%"(/+%& %D/((' F(&& F+"2 "2( (*"+G$%"(* #0 X(/)(/ IN<<BJ7 9(.()" .2%)D(* +) X(/)(/d*$#'(&T 2#F(;(/T 2%;( 1?*2(' >%.Y "2( *2%/1 '/#1 +)^%&(#Q#+. 345 !B@ $7,7 IX(/)(/T N<<LJT /(*?&"+)D +).&#*(/ %D/(($()" >("F(() "2( "F# $("2#'* 0#/ "2(6(;#)+%) I=+D7 EJ7R2(/( +* D/#F+)D +)"(/(*" +) W?%)"+0,+)D R(/"+%/,

345 .#).()"/%"+#)* I3(/&+)D (" %&7T N<<OA ^%D%)+ ("

%&7T N<<<%T N<<<>A ^(%/*#) %)' ^%&$(/T N<<<JT 1/+$%/G+&, 0?(&(' >, "2( W?(*"+#) #0 F2("2(/ 345 %)'"($1(/%"?/( %/( .#?1&(' '?/+)D "2+* +)"(/;%&7 V*"+G$%"(* 0/#$ *"#$%"%& +)'+.(* 2%;( "2( 1#"()"+%& "#2(&1 /(*#&;( "2+* W?(*"+#)7 C* 0#/ 1/(G3/("%.(#?* (*"+G$%"(*T "2( &(** W?%)"+"%"+;( *"#$%"%& /%"+# $("2#' #0`.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/ IN<<MJ /($%+)* "2( >(*"#1"+#)7

!'A+,B52-6242+$#

K "2%)Y f7`7 \?e/*.2)(/T f7h7 32%&#)(/T 67q7X((/&+)DT 87q7 ]+.Y(,T q7 3%//#&&T %)' q737 `.V&F%+)0#/ .#)*"/?."+;( .#$$()"* #) "2( $%)?*./+1"7 K "2%)Y97C7 X(/)(/ 0#/ .#)*"/?."+;( .#$$()"* %)' 2(&1 +)'/%0"+)D =+D*7 N %)' E7 K %&*# "2%)Y 87`7 ]?DD+)* 0#/1/#;+'+)D %) %D( 0#/ 2+* `+#.()( $%"(/+%&7 K %$ D/%"(G0?& "# !7 f#0*,T X7 `?)D(/T `7 h#?&'()T %)' 37X%/0#/' 0#/ 1/#;+'+)D .%)#1, 345 '%"% 0/#$ ]%/;%/'=#/(*"7 R2+* F#/Y F%* 0?)'(' >, 64V D/%)" 6VG=h45G<MV9NBM55T % l!= h/%'?%"( 9(*(%/.2 =(&&#FG*2+1T %)' % c%&( t)+;(/*+", =(&&#F*2+17

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? NM

!CC2+-/: !(V-1(/+$()"%& *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(*

V-1(/+$()"&()D"2I'%,*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;("# .#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0 &(%0 !6 /(*1#)*( !K /(*1#)*( !#?/.(

n $ P@@S 85"*$0#X* (X#3")'* %>%-+%& ! % <S _ 4d8(%/, %)' \)(.2"T N<LN>

%'%-+%& &NB $ 5@EOS `")*'#$" ($*+'+" %>%-+%& ! % <NS _ X/+*"#F %)' 8##+T N<EL>

%'%-+%& & _$ !N@MS `")*'#$" ($*+'+" %>%-+%& ! % <<S _

%'%-+%& &NM $ N@@S 80.X#X* $X)0"/$)'6"&" _ $ PLS & h%?'+&&(x/( %)' `#?**(%?T

N<L<>

5@ $ L@S 85"*$0#X* (X#3")'* %>%-+%& & & 9%)%*+)D2( %)' R%,&#/T N<<E>

%'%-+%& & &5N $ LES F)"4$*6"&+'" I^X/'&$&*'*nJ %>%-+%& & & X#("*.2 (" %&7T N<<E>

5N % 5<S a"66'&'X/ /,)+'##X* %>%-+%& & & f##'F%/'T N<LE>

%'%-+%& ! $ MBLS ! $ B5BS$ 5<S a"66'&'X/ /,)+'##X* %>%-+%& & &

%'%-+%& & &5N % PBS K6$) .*$X40.#"+"&X* %>%-+%& ! $ 55@S ! $ N55S f##'F%/' %)' X%QQ%QT N<LL>

2$X/ X)R"&X/ %>%-+%& ! $ PNS ! $ NLS%'%-+%& ! $ 5NBS ! $ N<NS

ZX$)6X* )0RX) %>%-+%& ! $ NPNS ! $ LNSP5"/&X* 6"+5")+'6X* %>%-+%& ! $ NNOS ! $ N@@SPX/$< 6)'*.X* %>%-+%& ! $ ONS ! $ PNS

%'%-+%& ! $ NM@S ! $ B@@S

Page 16: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?NE

C11()'+- CN I60&+'&X$4J

V-1(/+$()"&()D"2I'%,*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;("# .#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0 &(%0 !6 /(*1#)*( !K /(*1#)*( !#?/.(

$ N@@S K/")"&+5X* )$+)0^$<X* %>%-+%& ! % PMS ! % 5PS%'%-+%& ! % PLS ! % 5ES

K/R)0*'" ")+$/'*''10#'" %>%-+%& ! % NNS &%'%-+%& ! % 5BS ! % 5MS

J$+")'" 1"R$)'' %>%-+%& & ! % 5NS%'%-+%& ! % 55S ! % 5NS

5N<<_PM $ <BS O0#'X/ .$)$&&$ %'%-+%& & _ 9,&( %)' !"%)&(,T N<<5>

5E $ LES O,60.$)*'6X/ $*6X#$&+X/ %>%-+%& ! % NOS & `%'*()T N<OP>

%'%-+%& ! % NBS &$ LNBS O,60.$)*'6X/ $*6X#$&+X/ %>%-+%& ! % 5PS &

%'%-+%& ! % PES &!5L $ PPS O0#'X/ +$/X#+$&+X/ %'%-+%& & _ h%, %)' ]%?.YT N<<B>

5L $ N@@S 85"*$0#X* (X#3")'* %>%-+%& & & 9%'#D&#? %)' q%/;+*T N<<5.

%'%-+%& & &!B@ $ <NS P".5"&X* )".5"&'*+)X/ %>%-+%& & & 3%*( (" %&7T N<<L>

BM $ ONS K&+5,##'* (X#&$)")'" %>%-+%& ! % P5S ! % NOS =(//+* %)' R%,&#/T N<<B>

%'%-+%& & &O0+X* 60)&'6X#"+X* %>%-+%& $ E@S &

%'%-+%& $ B@S &8#"&+"30 /$4'" %>%-+%& ! % 5@S &

%'%-+%& ! % PES ! % N5SJ"&3X'*0)R" /'&0) %>%-+%& $ NOMS $ PES

%'%-+%& $ NM@S $ 5NPSBM $ N@@S a'6'" 1"R" %>%-+%& & & 9%'#D&#? %)' q%/;+*T N<<P.

%'%-+%& & &BM $ NELS 2#,6'&$ /"< %>%-+%& $ PLS & R2#$%* %)' ]%/;(,T N<LP.

%'%-+%& & &O'bX'4"/R") *+,)"6'^X" %>%-+%& & $ P@Sc$" /",*I3BJ %>%-+%& & &

%'%-+%& & &!M@ $ ELS K&+5,##'* (X#&$)")'" %>%-+%& ! % 5PS & X/,%)" (" %&7T N<<L.

J"&3X'*0)R" /'&0) %>%-+%& & &;)0/0.*'* $)$6+" %>%-+%& & &

M@ % !P5S K($&" *"+'(" %>%-+%& & _ `%&#)( (" %&7T N<<P.

%'%-+%& & _8)0*0.'* 3#"&4X#*0 %>%-+%& & _

%'%-+%& & _J65'd"65,)'X/*60.")'X/I3BJ

%>%-+%& & _

F)'+'6X/ "$*+'(X/ %>%-+%& & _%'%-+%& & _

MB $ <PS ;0$5/$)'" 6,#'&4)'6" _ & _ f##'F%/' %)' X((/&+)DT N<<O>

ME $ N@@S E0#$X* R#X/$' %>%-+%& ! % <S ! % BS X((/&+)D %)' f##'F%/'T N<<M>

F)0."$0#X/ /"e0) %>%-+%& ! % BS ! % N@SM< $ NLES 8$#")30&'X/ 50)+0)X/ %>%-+%& & _ \(&&, (" %&7T N<<N>

%'%-+%& ! % M@S _E@ % 5<S J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' ! $ 5LS _ X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<M>

$ N@@S .#$>+)(' ! % BNS _E@ $ <PS :65)0/" #"30.X* %>%-+%& & _ 4>(/>%?(/ (" %&7T N<LM>

%'%-+%& & _EP $ NMOS 8"&'6X/ +)'6"&+5X/ %>%-+%& ! % 55S _ R+11+)D %)' `?//%,T N<<<>

8"&'6X/ "&+'40+"#$I3BJ %>%-+%& $ 5LS _

Page 17: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? NO

C11()'+- CN I60&+'&X$4J

V-1(/+$()"&()D"2I'%,*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;("# .#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0 &(%0 !6 /(*1#)*( !K /(*1#)*( !#?/.(

" EE $ N@@S 20**,.'X/ 5')*X+X/ %>%-+%& & & 9('', (" %&7T N<<L>

%'%-+%& & &O5 $ L<S O0#'X/ .$)$&&$ %>%-+%& $ ! % =(//+* (" %&7T N<<E.

L@ $ N@@S ;$+X#" .$&4X#" %>%-+%& & & f%D)(/T N<<L>

<@ $ N@@S ZX$)6X* '#$< %>%-+%& ! % 5OS _ ^%#&(""+ (" %&7T N<<O>

<@_N5@ $ N@@S K&4)0.030& 3$)")4''I3BJ %>%-+%& ! % 5LS _ \)%11 (" %&7T N<<B.

%'%-+%& $ OMS _J"#('" .'+65$)' %>%-+%& $ B@S _

%'%-+%& $ N5MS _<5 $ N@@S 80.X#X* +)'6506")." %>%-+%& & & 9%'#D&#? %)' q%/;+*T N<<@>

%'%-+%& & &<P M5S :),d" *"+'(" %>%-+%& % 5<S _ 9#F&%)'GX%$0#/' (" %&7T N<<@>

%'%-+%& % NOS _$ NOPS :),d" *"+'(" %>%-+%& & _

%'%-+%& & _N@M $ NLES 8$#")30&'X/ 50)+0)X/ %>%-+%& & _ \(&&, (" %&7T N<<N>

%'%-+%& & _NNB $ LOS K)"65'* 5,.03"$" %>%-+%& ! % N5S & 3&+00#/' (" %&7T N<<M>

%'%-+%& ! % NES ! % LSN5@ $ OMOS P5'd0.50)" /"&3#$ %>%-+%& ! % NBS _ X((/&+)DT N<<B>

O"3X&6X#")'" )"6$/0*" %>%-+%& ! % PNS _`X*" ".'6X#"+" %>%-+%& & _

%'%-+%& & _N5@ $ N@@S 80.X#X* +)'6506")." %>%-+%& ! % N<S ! % PNS 3(?&($%)* (" %&7T N<<M.

%'%-+%& & &80.X#X* 4$#+0'4$* %>%-+%& ! % 5OS ! % PES

%'%-+%& ! % PPS &N5@ $ N@@S ZX$)6X* .$+)"$" %>%-+%& ! % 5MS ! % NBS \?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7T N<<L>

N5P $ <PS 8$&+"6#$+5)" /"6)0#0R" %>%-+%& ! % OS _ 4>(/>%?(/ (" %&7T N<LM>

%'%-+%& & _N5M $ B<S F)'+'6X/ "$*+'(X/ %>%-+%& & & V*"+%/"( (" %&7T N<<B.

%'%-+%& & &NPM $ N@@S 8)X&X* "('X/ %>%-+%& & _ 3()"/+""# (" %&7T N<<<.

NM@ $ N@@S E5#0)0.5,+X/ .'6+X)"+X/ %>%-+%& ! % OS ! % 5PS X((/&+)D %)' f##'F%/'T N<<M>

D$4$)" 5$#'< %>%-+%& ! % N@S ! % 5<SD,.0$*+$* (")'$3"+" %>%-+%& ! % <S ! % ES

5NO $ N@@S `")"&+5$* 60),/R0*" %>%-+%& ! % NBS _ V%$?* (" %&7T N<<P>

!5B@ $ <LS 8'6$" *'+65$&*'* %>%-+%& & _ X%/"#) %)' q%/;+*T N<<<>

5O@ $ NNBS 8'&X* R"&_*'"&" _ & _ !"(F%/" %)' ]#''+)#""T N<<P>

P@@ $ <OS MX6"#,.+X* +$+)040&+" %>%-+%& ! % 5@S _ X(//,$%) (" %&7T N<<B>T.

!PEM $ ONS PX/$< 0R+X*'10#'X* %>%-+%& ! % LS _ ^(%/*#) (" %&7T N<<M>

%'%-+%& & _!B@@ $ N@@S P5'd0.50)" /"&3#$ %>%-+%& ! % NES & =%/)*F#/"2 (" %&7T N<<E>

!B5M $ ONS ;)0/X* $)$6+X* %>%-+%& & & 8%?>(/ %)' \#e/)(/T N<<O.

%'%-+%& & &8#"&+"30 /$4'" %>%-+%& & &

%'%-+%& & &J"&3X'*0)R" /'&0) %>%-+%& & &

MO@ $ N@@S 8)X&X* "('X/ %>%-+%& & _ C"Y+)*#) (" %&7T N<<O>

ZX$)6X* )0RX) %>%-+%& $ !NM@S _E@@ $ <OS 8'&X* ."#X*+)'* _ & _ ^/+".2%/' (" %&7T N<<L.

Page 18: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?NL

!CC2+-/: !0!?>0#**+& *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(*

CD( #0$%"(/+%&I,(%/*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;( "#.#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0 &(%0 !6 /(*1#)*( !K /(*1#)*( !#?/.(

y % MS J"#'< 5$)R"6$" %>%-+%& & _ X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<5%'%-+%& ! $ LPS _

y % NPS MX6"#,.+X* ."X6'^0)" .#$>+)(' ! $ 5ES _ \#e/)(/ %)' 3#.2/%)(T N<LMy % ES 2)'*$#'&'" #'++0)"#'* .#$>+)(' & _ \#e/)(/ (" %&7T N<LE

% NPS B0+501"3X* /$&d'$*'' %>%-+%& ! $ 5NS _% LS P"&X&6X#X* 3)"5"/'' .#$>+)(' & _

y % N@S a"66'&'X/ /,)+'##X* %>%-+%& % 5@S _ f##'F%/'T N<LE%'%-+%& ! $ B5MS _

y % ES B")4X* *+)'6+" %>%-+%& & _ f##'F%/' %)' X%QQ%QT N<LL%'%-+%& ! $ N<S _

b $ N<BS FX**'#"30 1")1")" %>%-+%& _ ! % EMS X((/&+)D %)' f##'F%/'T N<<Ob $ N@@S J6').X* #"6X*+)'* _ ! % N<S _ X(""%/+)+ (" %&7T N<<Ob $ N@@S K##'X/ *.5"$)06$.5"#0& %>%-+%& & _ X(""%/+)+ (" %&7T N<<L

;X<X* *$/.$)(')$&* %>%-+%& & &E0&(0#(X#X* ")($&*'* %>%-+%& & $ 5ESE0&(0#(X#X* 6"&+"R)'6" %>%-+%& & &E0&,d" 6"&"4$&*'* %>%-+%& ! % 5ES $ 5NSY)"<'&X* 0)&X* %>%-+%& ! % PMS &2$)"&'X/ /0##$ %>%-+%& & &

C11()'+- CN I60&+'&X$4J

V-1(/+$()"&()D"2I'%,*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;("# .#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0 &(%0 !6 /(*1#)*( !K /(*1#)*( !#?/.(

!OP@ $ N@@S 8'6$" "R'$* _ & _ 6+-#) (" %&7T N<<M.

ZX$)6X* )XR)" %>%-+%& $ LS _OP@ $ E@S FX**'#"30 1")1")" %>%-+%& _ ! % 5ES X((/&+)D %)' f##'F%/'T N<<O>

OM@ $ <OS `"&3'1$)" '&4'6" %>%-+%& ! % NOS _ h##'0(&&#F (" %&7T N<<O>

!LB@ $ <<S J6').X* 0#&$,' _ & _ 6/%Y(T N<<5.

P ,(%/* $ E@S 8'&X* *,#($*+)'* %>%-+%& ! % NES _ X((/&+)DT N<<O>

%'%-+%& ! % NLS _P ,(%/* $ E@S 2'&_30 R'#0R" %>%-+%& ! % 5@S ! % OS X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<L%>

NNMM $ M@S 8*$X40+*X3" /$&d'$*'' %>%-+%& & _ C11&( (" %&7T 5@@@>

!M ,(%/* $ !L5S E'+)X* "X)"&+'X/ %>%-+%& & & V*"+%/"( (" %&7T N<<B.

`("%G%)%&,*+*

BP *1(.+(* IE@S *2#F(' !6/('?."+#)*J

! %I<7@! P7PS*7(7J

_ f##'F%/' %)' \(&&,T N<<M

! /(*1#)*( +);(/*(&, /(&%"(* "8 " @!@M# "# 345 .#).()"/%"+#)7& )# *+D)+H.%)" .2%)D( "8 $ @!@M#7_ )#" /(1#/"('7% R,1+.%&&, >("F(() PB@ %)' PE@ 11$Z7> ^&%)"* D/#F) +) ().&#*(' D/(()2#?*(* #/ .2%$>(/*7. ^&%)"* D/#F) +) #1()G"#1 .2%$>(/* I4R3*J7

Page 19: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? N<

C11()'+- C5 I60&+'&X$4J

CD( #0$%"(/+%&I,(%/*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;( "#.#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0 &(%0 !6 /(*1#)*( !K /(*1#)*( !#?/.(

2#0RX#")'" .X&6+"+" %>%-+%& & &%'%-+%& & &

D,.$)'6X/ .$)10)"+X/ %>%-+%& & &8#"&+"30 #"&6$0#"+" %>%-+%& & &

%'%-+%& & &80+$&+'##" )$.+"&* %>%-+%& & &8X#'6")'" *'6X#" %>%-+%& & &PX*6X* "6X#$"+X* %>%-+%& & _J6"R'0*" 60#X/R")'" %>%-+%& & &J'#$&$ (X#3")'* %>%-+%& & &J+"65,* )$6+" %>%-+%& ! % NNS &F)'10#'X/ .)"+$&*$ %>%-+%& & &

b $ !NP@S ;"X5'&'" /X#+'&$)('" %>%-+%& $ E5S $ BNS =(/)%g)'(Q (" %&7T N<<L%'%-+%& ! % ONS ! % OPS

J."+5'.5,#X/ 6"&&'10#'X/ %>%-+%& & &%'%-+%& ! % O5S ! % LMS

b $ B@S ZX$)6X* .XR$*6$&* %>%-+%& & & `+D&+(""% %)' 9%*.+T N<<Pb $ MNMS K)RX+X* X&$40 %>%-+%& ! % 5<S ! % 5@S q#)(* (" %&7T N<<Mb $ NNBS ZX$)6X* '#$< %>%-+%& ! % 5ES _ ^%#&(""+ (" %&7T N<<Lb $ M@S ;0$5/$)'" 6,#'&4$)'6" %>%-+%& & _ f##'F%/' %)' X((/&+)DT N<<Ob $ !ONS 85)"3/'+$* "X*+)"#'* %>%-+%& & _ ;%) h%/'+)D() (" %&7T N<<O

%'%-+%& ! % BMS _PO $ NMS> `$+"*$bX0'" 3#,.+0*+)0R0'4$* %>%-+%& & ! % NOS 6787 9#,(/T ?)1?>&+*2(' '%"%BP $ NMS> ;$+X#" .$&4X#" %>%-+%& ! % P@S ! % P5S f%D)(/ (" %&7T N<<EO@ $ NLS. K6$) 6"/.$*+)$ %>%-+%& & _ X((/&+)D %)' \(&&,T N<<O

K6$) .*$X40.#"+"&X* %>%-+%& & _K##'")'" .$+'0#"+" %>%-+%& $ 55S _K##'X/ X)*'&X/ %>%-+%& & _K#&X* 3#X+'&0*" %>%-+%& $ NP5S _K&$/0&$ &$/0)0*" %>%-+%& & _K)X/ /"6X#"+X/ %>%-+%& ! % ENS _

%'%-+%& ! % L@S _;$+X#" .$&4X#" %>%-+%& ! % P<S _;$+X#" .$&4X#" %>%-+%& ! % BPS _;$+X#" .XR$*6$&* %>%-+%& ! % MES _E").'&X* R$+X#X* %>%-+%& $ NPS _E"*+"&$" *"+'(" %>%-+%& ! % 5BS _E5"/"$&$)'0& "&3X*+'10#'X/ %>%-+%& & _E')6"$" #X+$+'"&" %>%-+%& ! % 5MS _E')*'X/ ."#X*+)$ %>%-+%& ! % 55S _E0)&X* *"&3X'&$" %>%-+%& ! % NES _E0),#X* "($##"&" %>%-+%& ! % M@S _E)"+"$3X* /0&03,&" %>%-+%& ! % PES _-'.*"6X* 1X##0&X/ %>%-+%& $ MBS _

%'%-+%& $ MM@S _M.'#0R'X/ /0&+"&X/ %>%-+%& ! % 5LS _

%'%-+%& & _Y"3X* *,#("+'6" %>%-+%& $ PPS _Y"3X* *,#("+'6" %>%-+%& & _Y)"<'&X* $<6$#*'0) %>%-+%& $ P<S _2$)"&'X/ 4'**$6+X/ %>%-+%& & _2$)"&'X/ )0R$)+'"&X/ %>%-+%& ! % MLS _

%'%-+%& $ _2$X/ )XR"&X/ %>%-+%& ! % 5NS _

%'%-+%& & _2#$650/" 5$4$)"6$" %>%-+%& ! % 5PS _D$4$)" 5$#'< %>%-+%& $ N@NS _

Page 20: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?5@

C11()'+- C5 I60&+'&X$4J

CD( #0$%"(/+%&I,(%/*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;( "#.#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0 &(%0 !6 /(*1#)*( !K /(*1#)*( !#?/.(

D$)"6#$X/ *.50&4,#'X/ %>%-+%& ! % NBS _%'%-+%& & _

D,"6'&+50'4$* &0&I*6)'.+" %>%-+%& $ MES _%'%-+%& & _

D,.$)'6X/ 5')*X+X/ %>%-+%& ! % NNS _D,.$)'6X/ .$)10)"+X/ %>%-+%& ! % MES _\#$< "bX'10#'X/ %>%-+%& $ PNS _O"/'"*+)X/ 3"#$0R40#0& %>%-+%& & _O"+5,)X* .)"+$&*'* %>%-+%& & _

%'%-+%& ! % PLS _O'3X*+)X/ (X#3")$ %>%-+%& ! % EOS _O0&'6$)" .$)'6#,/$&X/ %>%-+%& ! % 5OS _OXdX#" *,#("+'6" %>%-+%& ! % BBS _O,*'/"65'" &X//X#")'" %>%-+%& ! % MES _

%'%-+%& ! % EOS _`$)6X)'"#'* .$)$&&'* %>%-+%& ! % NOS _:<"#'* "6$+0*$##" %>%-+%& & _80.X#X* &'3)" %>%-+%& $ BES _8)'/X#" (X#3")'* %>%-+%& ! % NBS _8)X&$##" (X#3")'* %>%-+%& ! % BOS _

%'%-+%& ! % MMS _8)X&X* "('X/ %>%-+%& ! % 5@S _8+$)'4'X/ "bX'#'&X/ %>%-+%& & _ZX$)6X* .$+)"$" %>%-+%& ! % NBS _ZX$)6X* )0RX) %>%-+%& & _P"&X&6X#X* f6")'" %>%-+%& ! % 5NS _

%'%-+%& & _P0*" 6"&'&" %>%-+%& ! % 5LS _J"/RX6X* &'3)"I*?)J %>%-+%& & _*"/RX6X* &'3)"I*2%'(J %>%-+%& & _J6)0.5X#")'" &040*" %>%-+%& ! % NLS _J'#$&$ 4'0'6" %>%-+%& $ B<S _

%'%-+%& ! % _J0)RX* "X6X.")'" %>%-+%& & _J+$##")'" 50#0*+$" %>%-+%& ! % 5LS _F"<X* R"66"+" %>%-+%& & _F'#'" 60)4"+" %>%-+%& ! % PBS _%#/X* 3#"R)" %>%-+%& & _a"66'&'X/ /,)+'##X* %>%-+%& & _

%'%-+%& & _a'6'" 6)"66" %>%-+%& ! % MOS _

%'%-+%& ! % 5@S _a'6'" *$.'X/ %>%-+%& ! % BPS _a'0#" 040)"+" %>%-+%& & _

<N $ 5@S. ;$+X#" &"&" %>%-+%& ! % 5<S _ X((/&+)DT N<<P<L $ 5BS. J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' _ ! % 5NS 9?)'D/() %)' X((/&+)DT N<<<NN@ $ 5MS. ;$+X#" .XR$*6$&* %>%-+%& ! % BMS ! % PMS \?e/*.2)(/T N<<ENNL $ 5BS. ZX$)6X* .$+)"$" %>%-+%& _ ! % PBS ;%) '(/ X?/D2 (" %&7T N<<PN5E $ NBS. J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' ! % 55S _ X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<P!N5O $ 5BS. J"#'< 6'&$)$" %>%-+%& ! % 55S ! % NOS `.V&F%+) (" %&7T N<<MNBB $ 5PS. J"#*0#" _"#'I3BJ %>%-+%& _ & 9%;() %)' 9%$*'()T N<LLNBB $ 5OS. 2'&_30 R'#0R" %>%-+%& & ! % BBS 6787 9#,(/T ?)1?>&+*2(' '%"%NM@ $ NBS. J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' ! % 5ES _ X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<MNMN $ 5OS. ZX$)6X* )0RX) %>%-+%& ! % 5PS _ X((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<P>NOP $ 5MS. :#$" $X)0."$" %>%-+%& ! % 5BS _ X((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<P.NLN $ 5ES. Y"3X* *,#("+'6" %>%-+%& ! % BPS _ ^%#&(""+ %)' h(&&+)+T N<<P

ZX$)6X* '#$< %>%-+%& ! % 5LS _

Page 21: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? 5N

!CC2+-/: !8=#**+& *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(*

CD( #0$%"(/+%&I,(%/*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;( "#.#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0&(%0

!6/(*1#)*(

!K/(*1#)*(

!#?/.(

<@@@ % 5MS>T. J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' _ ! $ MMS 9?)'D/() %)' X((/&+)DT N<<<<N<@ % 5OS> J"#'< 6'&$)$" %>%-+%& ! $ MOS ! $ P5S `.V&F%+) (" %&7T N<<M<L@@ $ 5@S'Tk ;$+X#" .XR$*6$&*7

;9 .$&4X#"%>%-+%& _ ! % P5S

I$(%)Jf%D)(/ (" %&7T N<<<

N@OM@IC&&(/u'Uc7 6/,%*J

% 5MS.TY J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' ! $ 5OS _ X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<M

NNM@@ % 5BS> J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' % BES & X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<5NP@@@ % 5<S> ;$+X#" &"&" %>%-+%& ! $ E@S _ X((/&+)DT N<<PNEM@@ % BOS> J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' ! $ MBS ! $ 5MS X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<P5L@@@ % BES> 8'&X* ^$<'#'* _ ! $ PNS _ ;%) '( f%"(/ (" %&7T N<<BNB@T@@@ % BOS> J"#'< 5$)R"6$" .#$>+)(' ! $ OPS ! $ P<S X((/&+)D (" %&7T N<<P57M $7,7 $ BS( ZX$)6X* .$+)"$" %>%-+%& _ ! % N@S ;%) '(/ X?/D2 (" %&7T N<<PA

\?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7T N<<E

C11()'+- C5 I60&+'&X$4J

CD( #0$%"(/+%&I,(%/*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;( "#.#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0 &(%0 !6 /(*1#)*( !K /(*1#)*( !#?/.(

N<@ $ 5OS. ZX$)6X* .$+)"$" %>%-+%& ! % B@S ! % PNS \?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7T N<<E5@@ $ 5BS. K6$) .*$X40.#"+"&X*7

E").'&X* R$+X#X*7 Y"3X**,#("+'6"7 80.X#X* &'3)"7ZX$)6X* .$+)"$"7 Z9 )0RX)7P5"/&X* 6"+5")+'6X*7 F'#'"60)4"+"

%>%-+%& ! % B@SI$(%)J

_ f##'F%/'T N<LO

5B@ $ 5MS. K#&X* 3#X+'&0*"7 K/")"&+5X*6"X4"+X*7 ;$+X#" .$&4X#"7;X<X* *$/.$)(')$&*7E$)"+0&'" *'#'bX"7 E,&040&4"6+,#0&7 2$&+'"&" "#.'&"7D$##$R0)X* 10$+'4X*7 gX&'.$)X*60//X&'*7 8"."($) "#.'&X/78'&X* .'&$"7 89 X&6'&"+"78'*+"6'" #$&+'*6X*7P50404$&4)0& 1$))X3'&$X/

.#$>+)(' ! % NOSI$(%)J

& I$(%)J ^()o?(&%* %)' `%"%$%&%T N<<@

PPNL $ 55S' :#$" $X)0."$" %>%-+%& ! % PPS _ X((/&+)D %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<P.

! /(*1#)*( +);(/*(&, /(&%"(* "8 " @!@M# "# 345 .#).()"/%"+#)7& )# *+D)+H.%)" .2%)D( "8 $ @!@M#7_ )#" /(1#/"('7y '%"% 0/#$ %) %&"+"?'+)%& *"?',A "2?*T "2( j%D(d +* 2#F(;(/ &#)D "2( 1#1?&%"+#) 2%* (-+*"(' %" "2( *%$1&(' %&"+"?'(*7b '%"% 0/#$ % )%"?/%& 345 *1/+)D %/(%A "2?*T "2( j%D(d +* 2#F(;(/ &#)D "2( 1#1?&%"+#) 2%* (-+*"(' %" "2( &#.%"+#)T %**?$+)D .#)*"%)" 345($+**+#)*7% R,1+.%&&, >("F(() PB@ %)' PE@ 11$ZA 0#/ 2(/>%/+?$ *"?'+(*T .#)"/#& .#//(*1#)'* F+"2 #&'(*" $%"(/+%&7> =/#$ '+/(." $(%*?/($()"* 0/#$ `%?)% 8#% 4>*(/;%"#/,T ]%F%++ %)' !#?"2 ^#&( I\((&+)D (" %&7T N<<MJ7. =/#$ !+1&( !"%"+#) +.( .#/( Il(0"(& (" %&7T N<LMA =/+('&+ (" %&7T N<LEJ7' =/#$ R%,&#/ 6#$( +.( .#/( IK)'(/$?e2&( (" %&7T N<<<J7

Page 22: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?55

C11()'+- CP I60&+'&X$4J

CD( #0$%"(/+%&I,(%/*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;( "#.#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0&(%0

!6/(*1#)*(

!K/(*1#)*(

!#?/.(

E7M $7,7 % 5@S( ZX$)6X* .$+)"$" %>%-+%& _ ! $ MMS ;%) '(/ X?/D2 (" %&7T N<<PA\?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7T N<<E

% 5BS(T& Y"3X* "++$&X"+" %>%-+%& _ ! $ BNSE7M $7,7 % 5@S' ;$+X#" *XR.XR$*6$&* %>%-+%& ! $ O5S ! $ BMS \?e/*.2)(/T N<<EN@ $7,7 $ BS( ZX$)6X* .$+)"$" %>%-+%& _ ! % <S ;%) '(/ X?/D2 (" %&7T N<<PA

\?e/*.2)(/ (" %&7T N<<EN@ $7,7 & ' ;$+X#" *XR.XR$*6$&* %>%-+%& ! & ! & \?e/*.2)(/T N<<ENM7M $7,7 $ 0 E5"/"$6,.")'* #'&3X"$10#'"7

EX&&'&35"/'" 65"&$,'7`$+"*$bX0'" 066'4$&+"#'*78'&X* 5")&$,"&"7 8'&X* *197F"<04'X/ 4XR'X/

.#$>+)(' ! % I$(%)J _ ]?DD+)*T N<LM

BB_M@ $7,7I`7 V#.()(J

$ BPSD O'&4$)" 6'&&"/0/'10#'"7O'&4$)" *17)

%>%-+%& ! % PESI$(%)J

! % BOSI$(%)J

`.V&F%+)T N<<L

O'+*$" R0X)&$&*'*7O9 $4C")4*''7 O9 5')*X+")

%>%-+%& ! % 5OSI$(%)J

! % PLSI$(%)J

NE@_NLM $7,7I`7 q?/%**+.J

$ NB<SD ;)"65,.5,##X/ 6)X6'*) %>%-+%& ! % MBS ! % P<S `.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<E

;9 /"/'##")$) %>%-+%& ! % P<S ! % M5S2'&_30 5X++0&'') %>%-+%& ! % P5S _

NE@_NLM $7,7I`7 q?/%**+.J

$ NB<SD ;"$')" 1X)6"+") %>%-+%& ! % BBS _ `.V&F%+)T N<<L

%'%-+%& ! % EOS _E+$&'* $<'#'*7 E9 _"&$5")"'7E9 *X#6'6"X#'*)

%>%-+%& ! % BESI$(%)J

$ NBSI$(%)J

8"3'0.5,##X/ _X))''789 /"6X#0*X/7 89 0)4'&"+X/)

%>%-+%& ! % PESI$(%)J

! % P<SI$(%)J

!5@M $7,7I8%"(*" R/+%**+.J

$ E<S2 ;"$')" R0$33'#4'"&") %>%-+%& _ ! % BBS `.V&F%+) (" %&7T N<<<

;9 /'&X+") %>%-+%& _ ! % B<S;9 ."X6'.")+'"+") %>%-+%& _ ! % 5MS;"$')" *17) %>%-+%& _ ! % PESE+$&'* /'&X+"7 E9 &'#**0&'') %>%-+%& _ ! % BPS

I$(%)JE9 &'#**0&'') %>%-+%& _ ! % 5NS2'&_30 "60*/'6") %>%-+%& _ ! % 5ES29 0R0("+X*) %>%-+%& _ ! % MOS

!5@M $7,7IV%/&+(*" q?/%**+.J

$ MEOS2 ;"$')" #0&3'10#'") %>%-+%& _ ! % E@S

;9 *.$6+"R'#'*) %>%-+%& _ ! % ONSB'#**0&'" .0#,/0).5") %>%-+%& _ ! % O@SJ+$&0.+$)'* 4'&0*"X)$&*'*) %>%-+%& _ ! % NNS

5LM_5<@ $7,7IV7 ^(/$+%)J

& D O$R"65'" 1)0&40*") %>%-+%& $ N5@S ! & `.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<M

5<@_P@P $7,7I87 ^())7J

$ & B$X)0.+$)'* 0("+" %>%-+%& ! % B@S ! % 5OS 3&(%& (" %&7T N<<<

PN@ $7,7 I87 ^())7J & D JC'##'&3+0&'" 4$&+'6X#"+") %>%-+%& $ BE@S ! & `.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<MPLL_POP $7,7I`7 6(;#)+%)J

% ENSDT$ -)$."&0.5,6X* *.'&"$10)/'* _ ! $ B5S ! $ PLS V'F%/'* (" %&7T N<<L

Page 23: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

D2?2%2+'2#

C>/%$*T `767T N<<B7 h()#",1+. %)' 12()#",1+. ;%/+%"+#) %* *"/(**%'%1"%"+#)* +) "($1(/%"( "/(( *1(.+(*[ % /(;+(F #0 *(;(/%& .%*(*"?'+(*7 R/(( ^2,*+#&7 NBT LPP_LB57

C)'/(F*T q7V7T R%)'#)T !7\7T 6())+*T ^7=7T N<<M7 3#).()"/%"+#)* #0.%/>#) '+#-+'( +) "2( 8%"( 3/("%.(#?* %"$#*12(/(7 q7 h(#&7 !#.78#)'#) NM5T N_P7

C11&(T `7V7T 4&*Q,YT 67`7T 4/$/#'T 67^7T 8(F+*T q7T !#?"2F#/"2T67T R+)D(,T 67R7T 5@@@7 `#/12#&#D, %)' *"#$%"%& 0?)."+#) #06#?D&%* H/ )(('&(* (-1#*(' "# .&+$%"( .2%)D([ (&(;%"(' 345%)' "($1(/%"?/(7 K)"7 q7 ^&%)" !.+7 NENT N5O_NP57

C*2"#)T ^7`7!7T X(/&,)T h7^7T N<<B7 C .#$1%/+*#) #0 &(%0 12,*+#&G#D, %)' %)%"#$, #0 m?(/.?* I*(."+#) M),+5)0R"#"&X* z =%D%G.(%(J *1(.+(* +) '+00(/()" &+D2" ();+/#)$()"*7 C$7 q7 X#"7 LNTML<_M<O7

C"Y+)*#)T 37q7T R%,&#/T q7`7T f+&Y+)*T 67T X(*0#/'T 97R7T N<<O7V00(."* #0 (&(;%"(' 345 #) .2&#/#1&%*" .#$1#)()"*T D%*(-.2%)D( %)' D/#F"2 #0 #%Y %)' .2(//,7 R/(( ^2,*+#&7 NOTPN<_P5M7

X%/)#&%T q7`7T 9%,)%?'T 67T \#/#"Y(;+.2T c7!7T 8#/+?*T 37T N<LO7Z#*"#Y +.( .#/( 1/#;+'(* NE@T@@@G,(%/ /(.#/' #0 %"$#*12(/+.3457 l%"?/( P5<T B@L_BNB7

X((/&+)DT 67q7T N<<P7 32%)D(* +) "2( *"#$%"%& '()*+", #0 ;$+X#" &"&"&(%;(* +) /(*1#)*( "# +)./(%*(* +) %"$#*12(/+. .%/>#) '+#-+'(.#).()"/%"+#) *+).( "2( &%"(GD&%.+%&7 !1(.7 ^%17 ^%&%(#)"#&7 B<TNLN_NLO7

X((/&+)DT 67q7T N<<B7 ^%&%(#G(.#12,*+#&#D+.%& *"?'+(* #) 3/("%.(#?*

%)' R(/"+%/, 0#**+& i#/%*7 K)[ X#?&"(/T `737T =+*2(/T ]737 IV'*7JT

3()#Q#+. ^&%)"* %)' 3&+$%"(* #0 "2( C/."+.7 !1/+)D(/T X(/&+)T

117 5P_PP7X((/&+)DT 67q7T N<<E7 ^%&%(#G(.#12,*+#&#D+.%& 1(/*1(."+;(* #) 1&%)"

/(*1#)*(* "# D&#>%& .2%)D(7 R/()'* V.#&7 V;#&7 NNT 5@_5P7X((/&+)DT 67q7T N<<O7 3%/>#) +*#"#1( '+*./+$+)%"+#) %)' *"#$%"%&

/(*1#)*(* #0 $%"?/( 8'&X* *,#($*+)'* 87 "/((* (-1#*(' +) *+"? 0#/

"2/(( ,(%/* "# (&(;%"(' 345 %)' "($1(/%"?/(7 C."% {.#&7 NLT

E<O_ON57X((/&+)DT 67q7T X+/Y*T ]7]7T f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<<M7 9%1+' &%"(G

D&%.+%& %"$#*12(/+. 345 .2%)D(* /(.#)*"/?."(' 0/#$ "2( *"#$%G

"%& '()*+", /(.#/' #0 0#**+& &(%;(*7 q7 m?%"7 !.+7 N@T PO<_PLB7X((/&+)DT 67q7T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T N<<57 !"#$%"%& '()*+", %* %) +)'+G

.%"#/ #0 %"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)7 ]#&#.()( 5T ON_OL7X((/&+)DT 67q7T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T N<<P%7 V;#&?"+#)%/, /(*1#)*(* #0

*"#$%"%& '()*+", "# D&#>%& 345 .2%)D(7 X+#&7 q7 8+))(%) !#.7 BLT

PBP_PMP7X((/&+)DT 67q7T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T N<<P>7 R2( +$1%." #0 %"$#*12(/+.

345 %)' "($1(/%"?/( .2%)D( #) *"#$%"%& '()*+",[ #>*(/;%"+#)*

0/#$ ZX$)6X* )0RX) &%$$%* &(%;(*7 C))7 X#"7 ONT 5PN_5PM7X((/&+)DT 67q7T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T N<<P.7 !"#$%"%& '()*+", /(*1#)*(*

#0 VD,1"+%) :#$" $X)0."$" 87 &(%;(* "# 345 .2%)D( *+).( NP5O

X37 C))7 X#"7 ONT BPN_BPM7X((/&+)DT 67q7T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T N<<B7 C"$#*12(/+. 345 .2%)D(*

*+).( "2( &%*" D&%.+%& $%-+$?$[ (;+'().( 0/#$ "2( *"#$%"%&

'()*+", /(.#/' #0 0#**+& &(%;(*7 9(;7 ^%&%(#>#"7 ^%&,)#&7 LNT

NN_NO7X((/&+)DT 67q7T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T ]?)"&(,T X7T ^(%/*#)T q7C7T R##&(,T

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? 5P

C11()'+- CP I60&+'&X$4J

CD( #0$%"(/+%&I,(%/*J

345 &(;(&*I/(&%"+;( "#.#)"/#&*%J

!1(.+(* ?*(' !+'( #0&(%0

!6/(*1#)*(

!K/(*1#)*(

!#?/.(

P<@_B@P $7,7IV7 6(;#)+%)J

$ EMOSD K3#"0.5,+0& /"e0)) .#$>+)(' ! % <<S ! % LBS `.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<M

J"C40&'" 0)&"+") .#$>+)(' ! % <LS ! % OLS

! /(*1#)*( +);(/*(&, /(&%"(* "8 " @!@M# "# 345 .#).()"/%"+#)7& )# *+D)+H.%)" .2%)D( "8 $ @!@M#7_ )#" /(1#/"('7% R,1+.%&&, >("F(() PB@ %)' PE@ 11$Z7> =/#$ Z#*"#Y IX%/)#&% (" %&7T N<LOJ %)' R%,&#/ 6#$( IK)'(/$?e2&( (" %&7T N<<<J +.( .#/(*7. =/#$ *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*( #0 /(.()" J"#'< 5$)R"6$"T F2(/( 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* %/( Y)#F)A ;%&?(* $%".2 +.( .#/( '%"% I/(0(/ "%>&( 0##")#"( <J7' =/#$ *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* #0 /(.()" ;$+X#" .XR$*6$&* %)' ;$+X#" .$&4X#"T F2(/( 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* %/( Y)#F)7( =/#$ *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*( #0 /(.()" ZX$)6X* .$+)"$"T F2(/( 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* %/( Y)#F)A ;%&?(* .#//(&%"( F+"2 "($1(/%"?/( .?/;(70 =/#$ =/(($%) %)' ]%,(*T N<<5A 3(/&+)D (" %&7T N<<O I.707 ^%D%)+ (" %&7T N<<<%J7D =/#$ j>(*" (*"+$%"(d #0 X(/)(/ IN<<BT N<<LJ72 =/#$ *"#$%"%& /%"+#* I`.V&F%+) %)' 32%&#)(/T N<<MT N<<EA `.V&F%+)T N<<LJ7k R2( .#)"/#& D/#?1 +* 1/+#/ "# "2( 345 *1+Y( I5E@ 11$Z 345 I/(0(/ "%>&( 0##")#"( NNJJ7Y R2( .#)"/#& D/#?1 +* "2( &%"( C&&(/u' $%"(/+%&T 1/+#/ "# 345 '/#1 I5OP 11$Z 345 I/(0(/ "%>&( 0##")#"(

N@JJ7& R2( .#)"/#& D/#?1 +* "2( N@ `% $%"(/+%& IPO@ 11$Z 345 I/(0(/ "%>&( 0##")#"( N5JJ7$ R2( .#)"/#& D/#?1 +* "2( PLL `% $%"(/+%& I5E@@ 11$Z 345 I/(0(/ "%>&( 0##")#"( NBJJ7) !"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* .#$1%/(' F+"2 .#//(*1#)'+)D l(%/(*" 8+;+)D VW?+;%&()"* Il8V*JA $("2#' '(*./+>(' +) "(-"7

Page 24: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

`7q7T N<<N7 R/%.Y+)D *"#$%"%& '()*+"+(* "2/#?D2 % D&%.+%& .,.&([

"2(+/ *+D)+H.%).( 0#/ 1/('+."+)D "2( /(*1#)*( #0 1&%)"* "#

.2%)D+)D %"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*7 h&#>%& V.#&7

X+#D(#D/7 8(""7 NT NPE_NB57X((/&+)DT 67q7T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T ]?)"&(,T X7T ^(%/*#)T q7C7T R##&(,T

`7q7T N<<P7 !"#$%"%& '()*+", /(*1#)'* "# "2( D&%.+%& .,.&( #0

();+/#)$()"%& .2%)D(7 ^/#.7 97 !#.7 8#)'#) X5MNT NPP_NPL7X((/&+)DT 67q7T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T ]?)"&(,T X7T ^(%/*#)T q7C7T R##&(,T

`7q7T f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<<57 Z%/+%"+#)* +) "2( *"#$%"%& '()*+",

#0 J"#'< 5$)R"6$" 87 ?)'(/ "2( .2%)D+)D %"$#*12(/+. 345.#).()"/%"+#)* #0 &%"(G %)' 1#*"GD&%.+%& "+$(7 ^2+&#*7 R/%)*7 97

!#.7 8#)'#) XPPET 5NM_55B7X((/&+)DT 67q7T \(&&,T 37\7T N<<O7 !"#$%"%& '()*+", /(*1#)*(* #0

"($1(/%"( F##'&%)' 1&%)"* #;(/ "2( 1%*" *(;() '(.%'(* #0

345 +)./(%*([ % .#$1%/+*#) #0 !%&+*>?/, IN<5OJ F+"2 .#)"($G

1#/%/, '%"%7 C$7 q7 X#"7 LBT NMO5_NMLP7X((/&+)DT 67q7T `.V&F%+)T q737T 4*>#/)(T 37^7T N<<L%7 !"#$%"%&

/(*1#)*(* #0 "2( &+;+)D 0#**+& 2'&_30 R'#0R" 87 "# .2%)D(* +)

%"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*7 q7 V-17 X#"7 B<T NE@P_NE@O7X((/&+)DT 67q7T f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<<M7 !"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* #0 ;%/+(G

D%"(' &(%;(* "# 345 ()/+.2$()"7 C))7 X#"7 OMT M@O_MNN7X((/&+)DT 67q7T f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<<E7 ^%&%(#G(.#12,*+#&#D+.%&

1(/*1(."+;(* #) 1&%)" /(*1#)*(* "# D&#>%& .2%)D(7 R/()'* V.#&7

V;#&7 NNT 5@_5P7X((/&+)DT 67q7T f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<<O7 32%)D(* +) &%)' 1&%)" 0?).G

"+#) #;(/ "2( ^2%)(/#Q#+.[ /(.#)*"/?."+#)* >%*(' #) "2( 0#**+&

/(.#/'7 X#"7 q7 8+))7 !#.7 N5BT NPO_NMP7X((/&+)DT 67q7T f##'F%/'T =7K7T 8#$%*T `797T f+&&*T `7C7T m?+.YT

f7^7T Z%&'(*T ^7q7T N<<L>7 R2( +)i?().( #0 3%/>#)+0(/#?*

1%&%(#%"$#*12(/(* #) 1&%)" 0?)."+#)[ %) (-1(/+$()"%& %)'

$#'(&&+)D %**(**$()"7 ^2+&#*7 R/%)*7 97 !#.7 8#)'#) XPMPT

NPN_NB@7X(/D(/T 67T C&"$%))T R7T 5@@@7 C *?>"+&+*+)G&+Y( *(/+)( 1/#"(%*(

+);#&;(' +) "2( /(D?&%"+#) #0 *"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' '+*"/+>?"+#)

+) K)"R'40.*'* +5"#'"&"7 h()(* 6(;7 NBT NNN<_NNPN7X(/)(/T 97C7T N<<B7 h(#.%/> KK[ % /(;+*(' $#'(& #0 %"$#*12(/+. 345

#;(/ ^2%)(/#Q#+. "+$(7 C$7 q7 !.+7 5<BT ME_<N7X(/)(/T 97C7T N<<L7 !()*+"+;+", #0 ^2%)(/#Q#+. %"$#*12(/+. 345 "#

1%&(#D(#D/%12+.%&&, +)'?.(' .2%)D(* +) &%)' "($1(/%"?/( %)'

/?)#007 K)[ 3/#F&(,T R7q7T X?/Y(T \737 IV'*7JT R(."#)+. X#?)'G

%/, 3#)'+"+#)* 0#/ 3&+$%"( 9(.#)*"/?."+#)*7 4-0#/' t)+;(/*+",

^/(**T l(F c#/YT 117 5MN_5E@7X(/)(/T 97C7T 3%)H(&'T 67T N<L<7 C )(F $#'(& 0#/ %"$#*12(/+.

#-,D() #;(/ ^2%)(/#Q#+. "+$(7 C$7 q7 !.+7 5L<T PPP_PEN7X(/)(/T 97C7T ^("*.2T !7R7T 8%Y(T q7C7T X((/&+)DT 67q7T ^#11T X7l7T

8%)(T 97!7T 8%F*T V7C7T f(*"&(,T `7X7T 3%**%/T l7T f##'F%/'T

=7K7T m?+.YT f7^7T 5@@@7 K*#"#1( 0/%."+#)%"+#) %)' %"$#*12(/+.

#-,D()[ +$1&+.%"+#)* 0#/ ^2%)(/#Q#+. 45 (;#&?"+#)7 !.+().(

5LOT NEP@_NEPP7X(//,$%)T 37C7T V%$?*T 67T 6?00T h7C7T N<<B7 !"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(*

"# % /%)D( #0 ;%/+%>&(* +) "/(( *1(.+(* D/#F) F+"2 345 ()/+.2G

$()"7 q7 V-17 X#"7 BMT MP<_MBE7X(""%/+)+T K7T `+D&+(""%T =7T 9%*.2+T C7T N<<O7 !"?',+)D $#/12#G

12,*+#&#D+.%& /(*1#)*(* #0 !.+/1?* &%.?*"/+* 0/#$ )%"?/%&&,

345G()/+.2(' ();+/#)$()"*7 K)[ 9%*.2+T C7T `+D&+(""%T =7T

R#D)(""+T 97T ;%) h%/'+)D()T ^797 IV'*7JT ^&%)" 9(*1#)*(* "#

V&(;%"(' 3453%$>/+'D( t)+;(/*+", ^/(**T 3%$>/+'D(T 117NPB_NBO7

X(""%/+)+T K7T Z%..%/+T =7^7T `+D&+(""%T =7T N<<L7 V&(;%"(' 345.#).()"/%"+#)* %)' *"#$%"%& '()*+",[ #>*(/;%"+#)* 0/#$ NO

1&%)" *1(.+(* D/#F+)D +) % 345 *1/+)D +) .()"/%& K"%&,7 h&#>%&32%)D( X+#&7 BT NO_557

X#("*.2T q7T 32+)T q7T 8+)DT `7T 3/#-'%&(T q7T N<<E7 V&(;%"(' .%/>#)'+#-+'( %00(."* "2( 1%""(/)+)D #0 *?>*+'+%/, .(&&* +) F)"4$*6"&+'"

*"#$%"%& .#$1&(-(*7 q7 V-17 X#"7 BOT <5M_<PN7X/+*"#FT q7`7T 8##+T C7G!7T N<EL7 V00(."* #0 .%/>#) '+#-+'( #) "2(

D/#F"2 %)' $#/12#D()(*+* #0 `")*'#$"7 C$7 q7 X#"7 MMT LLB_LL<7

X/,%)"T q7T R%,&#/T h7T =/(2)(/T `7T N<<L7 ^2#"#*,)"2("+. %..&+$%G

"+#) "# (&(;%"(' 345 +* $#'+H(' >, *#?/.([*+)Y >%&%).( +) "2/((.#$1#)()" *1(.+(* #0 .2%&Y D/%**&%)' *F%/'* D/#F) +) % 0/(( %+/.%/>#) '+#-+'( ()/+.2$()" I=C3VJ (-1(/+$()"7 ^&%)"T 3(&&

V);+/#)7 5NT NM<_NEL7;%) '(/ X?/D2T q7T Z+**.2(/T ]7T 6+&.2(/T 6787T \?e/*.2)(/T f7`7T

N<<P7 ^%&(#%"$#*12(/+. *+D)%"?/(* +) l(#D()( 0#**+& &(%;(*7!.+().( 5E@T NOLL_NO<@7

3%*(T C787T 3?/"+*T ^7!7T !)#FT C7C7T N<<L7 ](/+"%>&( ;%/+%"+#) +)

*"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* "# (&(;%"(' 345 +) F+&' /%'+*2T P".5"&X*)".5"&'*+)X/ IX/%**+.%.(%(J7 C$7 q7 X#"7 LMT 5MP_5ML7

3()"/+""#T `7T `%#)%)+T =7T 8((T ]7!7q7T q%/;+*T ^7h7T N<<<7 K)"(/%.G"+;( (00(."* #0 (&(;%"(' |345} %)' '/#?D2" #) .2(//, I8)X&X*

"('X/J *(('&+)D*7 KK7 ^2#"#*,)"2("+. .%1%.+", %)' F%"(/ /(&%G"+#)*7 l(F ^2,"#&7 NBNT NBN_NMP7

3(/&+)DT R7V7T N<<N7 3%/>#) '+#-+'( +) "2( %"$#*12(/([ (;+'().(0/#$ 3()#Q#+. %)' `(*#Q#+. 1%&(#*#&*7 C$7 q7 !.+7 5<NT POO_

B@@73(/&+)DT R7V7T N<<57 t*( #0 .%/>#) +*#"#1(* +) 1%&(#*#&* %* %) +)'+G

.%"#/ #0 "2( ^I345J #0 "2( 1%&(#%"$#*12(/(7 h&#>%& X+#D(#G

.2($7 3,.&(* ET P@O_PNB73(/&+)DT R7V7T ]%//+*T q7`7T `%.=%''()T X7q7T 8(%Y(,T `7h7T m?%'(T

q7T V+*()$%))T Z7T V2&(/+)D(/T q797T N<<O7 h&#>%& ;(D("%"+#)

.2%)D( "2/#?D2 "2( `+#.()(U^&+#.()( >#?)'%/,7 l%"?/( PL<TNMP_NML7

3(?&($%)*T 97T ;%) ^/%("T 87T q+%)DT ~7l7T N<<M7 V00(."* #0 345()/+.2$()"T &(%0 1#*+"+#) %)' .&#)( #) *"#$%"%& +)'(- %)'

(1+'(/$%& .(&& '()*+", +) 1#1&%/ I80.X#X*J7 l(F ^2,"#&7 NPNT<<_N@O7

3&(%&T 37q7T q%$(*T 97`7T p#'/#FT V787T N<<<7 Z%/+%"+#) +) *"#$%"%&'()*+", +) "2( 8%"( 3%/>#)+0(/#?* D,$)#*1(/$ 0/#)' B$X)0.I

+$)'* 0("+"7 ^%&%+#* NBT NL@_NLM73&+00#/'T !737T X&%.YT 3797T 9#>(/"*T q7C7T !"/#)%.2T K7`7T !+)D&("#)G

q#)(*T ^797T `#2%$('T C767T CQ%$GC&+T !7l7T N<<M7 R2( (00(."

#0 (&(;%"(' %"$#*12(/+. 345 %)' '/#?D2" #) *"#$%"%& 0/(W?().,+) D/#?)')?" IK)"65'* 5,.03"$" I87JJ7 q7 V-17 X#"7 BET LBO_LM57

3?/"+*T ^7!7T f%)DT ~7T N<<L7 C $("%G%)%&,*+* #0 (&(;%"(' 345(00(."* #) F##', 1&%)" $%**T 0#/$T %)' 12,*+#&#D,7 4(.#&#D+%

NNPT 5<<_PNP76+-#)T `7T 8( R2+(.T 67T h%//(.T q7G^7T N<<M7 R2( D/#F"2 %)' D%*

(-.2%)D( /(*1#)*( #0 *#+&G1&%)"(' l#/F%, *1/?.( |8'6$" "R'$*I87J \%/*"7} %)' /(' #%Y IZX$)6X* )XR)" 87J (-1#*(' "# (&(;%"('

345 %)' "# )%"?/%&&, #..?//+)D '/#?D2"7 l(F ^2,"#&7 N5<T 5EM_5OP7

6/%Y(T X7h7T N<<57 C H(&' *"?', #0 "2( (00(."* #0 (&(;%"(' 345 #)

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?5B

Page 25: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

(.#*,*"($ 1/#.(**(* +) % 32(*%1(%Y( X%, f("&%)'7 C?*"7 q7X#"7 B@T MO<_M<M7

V%$?*T 67T X(//,$%)T 37C7T 6?00T h7C7T N<<P7 C**+$+&%"+#)T *"#$%G"%& .#)'?."%).(T *1(.+H. &(%0 %/(% %)' .2&#/#12,&& /(*1#)*(* "#

(&(;%"(' 345 #0`")"&+5$* 60),/R0*"T % "/#1+.%& $#)*##) /%+)0#/(*" *1(.+(*7 C?*"7 q7 ^&%)" ^2,*+#&7 5@T OBN_OMM7

V'F%/'*T 67T \(/1T ]7T ]%**T ]7T N<<L7 !"#$%"% +) (%/&, &%)' 1&%)"*[%) %)%"#$+.%& %)' (.#12,*+#&#D+.%& %11/#%.27 q7 V-17 X#"7 B<T

5MM_5OL7V2&(/+)D(/T q797T 3(/&+)DT R7V7T N<<M7 C"$#*12(/+. 345 %)' "2( /%"+#

#0 +)"(/.(&&?&%/ "# %$>+()" 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* +) 1&%)"*7 ^&%)"^2,*+#&7 NMT N@M_NNN7

VY%/"T 6767T 3(/&+)DT R7V7T `#)"%)o(QT K7^7T R%>#/T l7q7T N<<<7 C B@@

$+&&+#) ,(%/ .%/>#) +*#"#1( /(.#/' #0 1('#D()+. .%/>#)%"([+$1&+.%"+#)* 0#/ 1%&(#%"$#*12(/+. .%/>#) '+#-+'(7 C$7 q7 !.+75<<T L@M_L5O7

V&+.YT q7`7T `#/%T 37K7T 6/+(*(T !7h7T N<<<7 V&(;%"(' %"$#*12(/+.

345 &(;(&* %)' (-1%)*+#) #0 (%/&, ;%*.?&%/ &%)' 1&%)"*[ *"%>&(+*#"#1( (;+'().( 0/#$ "2( X%""(/, ^#+)" =$7 IV%/&, "# `+''&(6(;#)+%)JT h%*1(g X%,T 3%)%'%7 h!C C>*"/%."* F+"2 ^/#D/%$*T

;#&7 PNT 17 CGNM<7V*"+%/"(T `7T ^()o?(&%*T q7T \+$>%&&T X7C7T K'*#T !7X7T 8%`#/"(T 9787T

^+)"(/T ^7q7T f%&&T h7f7T h%/.+%T 9787T N<<B7 V&(;%"(' 345(00(."* #) *"#$%"%& '()*+", #0 F2(%" %)' *#?/ #/%)D( "/((*7 q7

V-17 X#"7 BMT NEEM_NEEL7=%/)*F#/"2T V7q7T V&&+*#)T C7`7T h#)DT f7\7T N<<E7 V&(;%"(' 345

%&"(/* %)%"#$,T 12,*+#&#D,T D/#F"2T %)' /(1/#'?."+#) #0 /('$%)D/#;( IP5'd0.50)" /"&3#$ 87J7 4(.#&#D+% N@LT M<<_E@<7

=%/W?2%/T h767T ;#) 3%($$(/(/T !7T X(//,T q7C7T N<L@7 C >+#.2($G

+.%& $#'(& #0 12#"#*,)"2("+. 345 %**+$+&%"+#) +) &(%;(* #0 3P*1(.+(*7 ^&%)"% NB<T OL_<@7

=(/)%g)'(QT `767T ^+("(/*T C7T 6#)#*#T 37T R(Q%/%T f7T CQY?(T `7T](//(/%T 37T 9()D+0#T V7T ](//(/%T C7T N<<L7 V00(."* #0 % )%"?/%&

*#?/.( #0 ;(/, 2+D2 345 .#).()"/%"+#) #) "2( &(%0 D%* (-.2%)D(T-,&($ F%"(/ 1#"()"+%& %)' *"#$%"%& .2%/%."(/+*"+.* #0 1&%)"* #0

J."+'.5,#X/ 6"&&'10#'X/ %)' ;"X5'&'" /X#+'&$)('"7 l(F^2,"#&7 NPLT EL<_E<O7

=(//+*T 97T l+k*T K7T X(2%(D2(T R7T K$1()*T K7T N<<E7 V&(;%"(' 345 %)'"($1(/%"?/( 2%;( '+00(/()" (00(."* #) &(%0 %)%"#$, #0 1(/())+%&

/,(D/%** +) *1/+)D %)' *?$$(/7 C))7 X#"7 OLT BL<_B<O7=(//+*T 97T R%,&#/T h7T N<<B7 !"#$%"%& .2%/%."(/+*"+.* #0 0#?/ )%"+;(

2(/>* 0#&&#F+)D (-1#*?/( "# (&(;%"(' 3457 C))7 X#"7 OPT BBO_BMP7

=/(($%)T \7]7T ]%,(*T q7`7T N<<57 =/%."+#)%"+#) #0 .%/>#) +*#"#1(*>, 12,"#1&%)Y"#) %)' (*"+$%"(* #0 %).+()" 345 &(;(&*7 h&#>%&

X+#D(#.2($7 3,.&(* ET NLM_N<L7=/(,T X7T !.2(+'(DD(/T 37T h?e)"2%/'"Gh#(/DT `7!7T `%",**(YT 97T

N<<E7 R2( (00(."* #0 #Q#)( %)' )?"/+()" *?11&, #) *"#$%"%&/(*1#)*( +) >+/.2 I;$+X#" .$&4X#"J &(%;(* %* '("(/$+)(' >,

'+D+"%& +$%D(G%)%&,*+* %)' ~G/%, $+./#%)%&,*+*7 l(F ^2,"#&7NP5T NPM_NBP7

=/+('&+T ]7T 8#e"*.2(/T ]7T 4(*.2D(/T ]7T !+(D()"2%&(/T t7T !"%?00(/TX7T N<LE7 K.( .#/( /(.#/' #0 "2( NP3UN53 /%"+# #0 %"$#*12(/+. 345+) "2( 1%*" "F# .()"?/+(*7 l%"?/( P5BT 5PO_5PL7

=?/?Y%F%T C7T N<<O7 !"#$%"%& 0/(W?()., #0 ZX$)6X* /,)*'&"$10#'"D/#F) ?)'(/ '+00(/()" +//%'+%).(*7 ^2#"#*,)"2("+.% PBT N<M_N<<7

;%) h%/'+)D()T ^797T h/%.(T q7T q(00/((T 37V7T X,%/+T !7]7T `+D&+(""%T

=7T 9%*.2+T C7T X(""%/+)+T K7T N<<O7 8#)DG"(/$ (00(."* #0 ()2%).('

345G.#).()"/%"+#)* #) &(%0 D%* (-.2%)D([ /(*(%/.2 #11#/"?G

)+"+(* ?*+)D 345 *1/+)D*7 K)[ 9%*.2+T C7T `+D&+(""%T =7T R#D)(""+T

97T ;%) h%/'+)D()T ^797 IV'*7JT ^&%)" 9(*1#)*(* "# V&(;%"('

3457 3%$>/+D( t)+;(/*+", ^/(**T 3%$>/+'D(T 117 E<_LE7h%?'+&&(x/(T q7^7T `#?**(%?T `7T N<L<7 !2#/" "(/$ (00(." #0 345 #)

&(%0 '(;(&#1$()" %)' D%* (-.2%)D( #0 ,#?)D 1#1&%/* I80.X#X*

$X)"/$)'6"&" .;7 K 5NBJ7 4(.#&7 ^&%)"7 N@T <M_N@M7h%,T C7^7T ]%?.YT X7T N<<B7 C..&+$%"+#) #0 O0#'X/ +$/X#$&+X/ "#

()2%).(' .%/>#) '+#-+'( .#).()"/%"+#)7 q7 V-17 X#"7 BMT NNPP_

NNBN7h%,T C7^7T ]?/'T 97h7T N<OM7 R2( +)i?().( #0 &+D2" #) *"#$%"%&

'()*+", +) "2( "#$%"#7 l(F ^2,"#&7 OMT PO_BE7h2#*2T ^7T X2%""%.2%/,%T !7\7T q%)+T 97C7T N<<M7 ^%&%(#.&+$%"( %)'

1%&%(#;(D("%"+#) +) .()"/%& K)'+% '?/+)D "2( t11(/ 3/("%.(#?*

>%*(' #) *"%>&( +*#"#1( .#$1#*+"+#) #0 "2( 1%&%(#*#& .%/>#)%"(*7

^%&%(#D(#D/7 ^%&%(#.&+$%"#&7 ^%&%(#(.#&7 NNBT 5LM_5<E7h##'0(&&#FT q7T V%$?*T 67T 6?00T h7T N<<O7 6+?/)%& %)' *(%*#)%&

.2%)D(* +) "2( +$1%." #) 345 ()/+.2$()" #) %**+$+&%"+#)T

*"#$%"%& .#)'?."%).( %)' D/#F"2 +) % &#)DG"(/$ *"?', #0

`"&3'1$)" '&4'6" +) "2( F("_'/, "/#1+.* #0 C?*"/%&+%7 R/((

^2,*+#&7 NOT 5<N_5<<7](.Y()>(/D(/T t7T 9#DD%"QT t7T !.2?//T t7T N<<L7 V00(." #0 '/#?D2"

*"/(** #) "2( .,"#&#D+.%& *"%"?* +) P'6'&X* 60//X&'*7 q7 V-17 X#"7

B<T NLN_NL<7]#?D2"#)T q7R7T `(+/% =+&2#T 87h7T 3%&&%)'(/T X7C7T ]%//+*T l7T

\%""()>(/DT C7T `%*Y(&&T \7T N<<M7 3&+$%"( 32%)D(7 R2(

K^33 !.+()"+H. C**(**$()"7 3%$>/+'D( t)+;(/*+", ^/(**T

3%$>/+'D(7]?DD+)*T 87`7T N<LM7 3?"+.?&%/ %)%&,*(* %)' 1/(&+$+)%/, .#$1%/G

+*#)* #0 *#$( `+#.()( .#)+0(/* 0/#$ 3&%/Y+%T K'%2#7 K)[ !$+&(,T

37q7 IV'7JT 8%"( 3()#Q#+. 2+*"#/, #0 "2( ^%.+H. l#/"2F(*"7

C$(/+.%) C**#.+%"+#) 0#/ "2( C';%).($()" #0 !.+().(T !%)

=/%).+*.#T 117 NNP_NPL7K)'(/$?e2&(T C7T !"#.Y(/T R7=7T q##*T =7T =+*.2(/T ]7T !$+"2T ]7q7T

f%2&()T `7T 6(.YT X7T `%*"/#+%))+T 67T R*.2?$+T q7T X&?)+(/T

R7T `(,(/T 97T !"%?00(/T X7T N<<<7 ]#&#.()( .%/>#)G.,.&(

',)%$+.* >%*(' #) 345 "/%11(' +) +.( %" R%,&#/ 6#$(T C)"%/.G

"+.%7 l%"?/( P<LT N5N_N5E7q#)(*T `7X7T X/#F)T q737T 9%*.2+T C7T `+D&+(""%T =7T N<<M7 R2(

(00(."* #) K)RX+X* X&$40 87 #0 &#)DG"(/$ (-1#*?/( "# (&(;%"('

3457 h&#>%& 32%)D( X+#&7 NT 5<M_P@57\((&+)DT 3767T f2#/0T R7^7T f%2&()T `7T ;%) '(/ ^&+.2"T q7T N<<M7

K)"(/%))?%& (-"/($(* +) "2( /%"( #0 %"$#*12(/+. .%/>#) '+#-+'(

*+).( N<L@7 l%"?/( POMT EEE_EO@7\(&&,T 67f7T ]+.Y&()"#)T ^797T 9((Y+(T V7h7T N<<N7 ^2#"#*,)"2("+.

/(*1#)*( #0 D(/%)+?$ "# (&(;%"(' 345 %* %00(."(' >, &(%0 %D( %)'

"+$( #0 345 (-1#*?/(7 3%)7 q7 X#"7 E<T 5BL5_5BLL7\)%11T C7\7T 3#.Y(T `7T ]%$(/&,).YT V7^7T 4F()*>,T 37V7T N<<B7

V00(." #0 (&(;%"(' 345 #) *"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' '+*"/+>?"+#) +) %

3B D/%** %)' % 3B 0#/> ?)'(/ H(&' .#)'+"+#)*7 C))7 X#"7 OBT

M<M_M<<7\#.2T ^787T p%.2#*T q737T h+)D(/+.2T ^767T N<<57 3#//(&%"+#)

>("F(() +*#"#1( /(.#/'* +) $%/+)( %)' .#)"+)()"%& .%/>#) /(*(/G

;#+/* )(%/ "2( ^%&%(#.()(UV#.()( >#?)'%/,7 l%"?/( PMLT PN<_

P557

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? 5M

Page 26: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

\#e/)(/T 327T N<LL7 6#(* D&#>%& +)./(%*( #0 345 %&"(/ *"#$%"%&

'()*+",n =&#/% NLNT 5MP_5MO7\#e/)(/T 327T X%))+*"(/T ^7T `%/YT C7=7T N<LE7 C&"+"?'+)%& ;%/+%"+#)

+) *"#$%"%& .#)'?."%).(T )+"/#D() .#)"()" %)' &(%0 %)%"#$, +)

'+00(/()" 1&%)" &+0( 0#/$* +) l(F p(%&%)'7 4(.#&#D+% E<T MOO_

MLL7\#e/)(/T 327T 3#.2/%)(T ^7`7T N<LM7 !"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* %)' F%"(/

/(&%"+#)* #0 MX6"#,.+X* ."X6'^0)" +) *?$$(/ %&#)D %) (&(;%G

"+#)%& D/%'+()"7 4(.#&#D+% EET BBP_BMM7\?$1T 8797T C/"2?/T `7C7T ^%"QY#F*Y,T `7V7T h+>>*T `7R7T ^+)Y?*T

67!7T !2((2%)T ^7`7T N<<<7 C F(%"2(/+)D 2,1#"2(*+* 0#/ D&%.+%G

"+#) %" 2+D2 %"$#*12(/+. 1345 '?/+)D "2( 8%"( 4/'#;+.+%)7

^%&%(#D(#D/7T ^%&%(#.&+$%"#&7T ^%&%(#(.#&7 NM5T NOP_NLO7\?e/*.2)(/T f7`7T N<<E7 8(%0 *"#$%"% %* >+#*()*#/* #0 1%&(#%"$#G

*12(/+. 345 &(;(&*7 8^^ 3#)"/+>7 !(/+(* MT N_NMP7\?e/*.2)(/T f7`7T N<<O7 R2( %)%"#$+.%& '+;(/*+", #0 /(.()" %)'

0#**+& &(%;(* #0 "2( '?/$%*" #%Y IZX$)6X* .$+)"$" 8+(>&(+)UZ9

.*$X406"*+"&$" h#(11(/"J z +$1&+.%"+#)* 0#/ "2(+/ ?*( %*

>+#*()*#/* #0 1%&%(#%"$#*12(/+. 345 &(;(&*7 9(;7 ^%&%(#>#"7

^%&,)#&7 <ET N_P@7\?e/*.2)(/T f7`7T !"?&()T K7T f%D)(/T =7T \?+1(/T ^7q737T N<<L7

3#$1%/+*#) #0 1%&%(#>#"%)+.%& #>*(/;%"+#)* F+"2 (-1(/+$()"%&

'%"% #) "2( &(%0 %)%"#$, #0 '?/$%*" #%Y |ZX$)6X* .$+)"$"

I=%D%.(%(J} +) /(*1#)*( "# ();+/#)$()"%& .2%)D(7 C))7 X#"7

LNT EMO_EEB7\?e/*.2)(/T f7`7T ;%) '(/ X?/D2T q7T Z+**.2(/T ]7T 6+&.2(/T 6787T

N<<E7 4%Y &(%;(* %* >+#*()*#/* #0 &%"( l(#D()( %)' (%/&, ^&(+*G

"#.()( 1%&(#%"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*7 `%/7 `+./#1%G

&(#)"#&7 5OT 5<<_PN57\?e/*.2)(/T f7`7T f%D)(/T =7T Z+**.2(/T V7]7T Z+**.2(/T ]7T N<<O7

^/('+."+)D "2( /(*1#)*( #0 &(%0 *"#$%"%& 0/(W?()., "# % 0?"?/(

345G()/+.2(' %"$#*12(/([ .#)*"/%+)"* 0/#$ 2+*"#/+.%& #>*(/;%G

"+#)*7 h(#&7 9?)'*.27 LET MN5_MNO78%$>(/*T ]7T 32%1+)T =7!7T ^#)*T R787T N<<L7 ^&%)" ^2,*+#&#D+.%&

V.#&#D,7 !1/+)D(/T l(F c#/Y78%?>(/T f7T \#e/)(/T 327T N<<O7 K) *+"? *"#$%"%& /(*1#)*(* "# &#)DG

"(/$ 345 ()/+.2$()" +) .%&.%/(#?* D/%**&%)' 1&%)"*7 C."% {.#&7

NLT 55N_55<78((T c7K7T N<<<7 !"%>&( +*#"#1+. .#$1#*+"+#) #0 .%&.+. 1%&(#*#&* #0

"2( V%/&, 3/("%.(#?* ]%*%)'#)D =#/$%"+#)T *#?"2(%*"(/)

\#/(%7 ^%&%(#D(#D/7 ^%&%(#.&+$%"#&7 ^%&%(#(.#&7 NM@T N5P_NPP78((T c7K7T ]+*%'%T \7T N<<<7 !"%>&( +*#"#1+. .#$1#*+"+#) #0 1('#G

D()+. .%/>#)%"(* #0 "2( V%/&, 3/("%.(#?* !2+$#)#*(Y+

!?>D/#?1T F(*"(/) ]#)*2?T q%1%)7 ^%&%(#D(#D/7 ^%&%(#.&+$%G

"#&7 ^%&%(#(.#&7 NMPT N5O_NPL78#)DT !7^7T 4*>#/)(T 37^7T ]?$12/+(*T !7f7T N<<E7 ^2#"#*,)"2(*+*T

/+*+)D %"$#*12(/+. .%/>#) '+#-+'( .#).()"/%"+#) %)' .&+$%"(

.2%)D(7 K)[ X/(,$(,(/T C7K7T ]%&&T 6747T `(&+&&#T q7`7T C� D/()T

h7K7 IV'*7JT h&#>%& 32%)D([ V00(."* #) 3#)+0(/#?* =#/(*"* %)'

h/%**&%)'*7 f+&(,T l(F c#/YT 117 N5N_NM<7`%'*()T V7T N<OP7 V00(." #0 345G.#).()"/%"+#) #) "2( $#/12#&#D+G

.%&T 2+*"#&#D+.%& %)' .,"#&#D+.%& .2%)D(* +) "#$%"# 1&%)"*7 C."%

CD/+.7 !.%)'7 5PT 5BN_5BE7`%&#)(T !797T `%,(?-T ]7!7T q#2)*#)T ]7X7T ^#&&(,T ]7f7T N<<P7

!"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' %1(/"?/( &()D"2 +) 0#?/ 1&%)" *1(.+(* D/#F)

%./#** % *?>%$>+()" 345 D/%'+()"7 C$7 q7 X#"7 L@T NBNP_NBNL7

`%*"(/*#)T q7T N<<B7 !"#$%"%& *+Q( +) 0#**+& 1&%)"*[ (;+'().( 0#/1#&,1&#+', +) $%k#/+", #0 %)D+#*1(/$*7 !.+().( 5EBT B5N_B5B7

`.V&F%+)T q737T N<<L7 6# 0#**+& 1&%)"* *+D)%& 1%&%(#%"$#*12(/+.345 .#).()"/%"+#) +) "2( D(#&#D+.%& 1%*"n ^2+&#*7 R/%)*7 97

!#.7 8#)'#) X PMPT LP_<E7`.V&F%+)T q737T X((/&+)DT 67q7T f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<<<7 =#**+& 1&%)"*

%)' D&#>%& F%/$+)D %" "2( R/+%**+._q?/%**+. >#?)'%/,7 !.+().(

5LMT NPLE_NP<@7`.V&F%+)T q737T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T N<<M7 !"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' +)'(-

#0 0#**+& 1&%)"* "/%.Y %"$#*12(/+. .%/>#) '+#-+'( +) "2( ^%&%(#GQ#+.7 C))7 X#"7 OET PL<_P<M7

`.V&F%+)T q737T 32%&#)(/T f7h7T N<<E7 R2( 0#**+& .?"+.&( %* % *Y(&(G

"%& /(.#/' #0 ();+/#)$()"%& .2%)D(7 ^%&%+#* NNT POE_PLL7`.V&F%+)T q7T `+".2(&&T =7q7h7T q#)(*T `7X7T N<<M7 9(&%"+#)*2+1 #0

*"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' +)'(- #0 !%&+- .+)(/(% "# %"$#*12(/+..%/>#) '+#-+'( .#).()"/%"+#)* +) "2( ]#&#.()(7 ]#&#.()( MT

5NE_5N<7`+D&+(""%T =7T 9%*.2+T C7T N<<P7 !"?',+)D "2( (00(." #0 (&(;%"(' 345

+) "2( #1() +) % )%"?/%&&, ()/+.2(' ();+/#)$()" +) .()"/%& K"%&,7

Z(D("%"+# N@BUN@MT P<N_B@@7`+))#..+T C7T ^%)+.?..+T C7T !(>%*"+%)+T 87T 8#/()Q+)+T h7T Z+"%G

D&+%)#T 37T N<<<7 ^2,*+#&#D+.%& %)' $#/12#&#D+.%& /(*1#)*(*#0 #&+;( 1&%)"* "# #Q#)( (-1#*?/( '?/+)D % D/#F+)D *(%*#)7

R/(( ^2,*+#&7 N<T P<N_P<O7`+*2/%T `7\7T N<<O7 !"#$%"%& .2%/%."(/+*"+.* %" '+00(/()" 1&#+',

&(;(&* +) E011$" 87 C))7 X#"7 L@T EL<_E<57`#)"%)o(QT K7^7T R%>#/T l7q7T VY%/"T 67T 3#&&+*"(/T q7f7T N<<<7 V;#&?G

"+#) #0 ^(/$+%) %"$#*12(/+. 1345 %* '(/+;(' 0/#$ &%"(*" 3%/>#G

)+0(/#?* "2/#?D2 ^(/$+%) 1%&(#*#& .%/>#)%"(*T `+'&%)' %)'^%/%'#- X%*+)*T t7!7C7 %)' )#/"2(/) K"%&+%) C&1*7 h!C

C>*"/%."* F+"2 ^/#D/%$*T ;#&7 PNT 17 CGP5E7`#/%T 37K7T 6/+(*(T !7h7T 3#&%/?**#T 87C7T N<<E7 `+''&( %)' 8%"(

^%&(#Q#+. %"$#*12(/+. 345 &(;(&* 0/#$ *#+& .%/>#)%"( %)'

#/D%)+. $%""(/7 !.+().( 5ONT NN@M_NN@O7`#/%T 37K7T 6/+(*(T !7h7T !(%D(/T ^7h7T N<<N7 3%/>#) '+#-+'( +) "2(

^%&(#Q#+. %"$#*12(/([ (;+'().( 0/#$ .%/>#)G+*#"#1( .#$1#*+G"+#)* #0 1('#D()+. .%/>#)%"(7 h(#&#D, N<T N@NO_N@5@7

`?.2(QT ^7T ^(("(/*T 37T \(11()*T V7T Z+%()(T f7C7T N<<P7 !"%>&(

+*#"#1+. .#$1#*+"+#) #0 1%&(#*#&* +) "2( 8#F(/ Z+*%) #0 (%*"(/)X(&D+?$[ (;+'().( #0 (;%1#/%"+#) %)' *#+&GD%* 3457 32($7

h(#&7 N@ET PL<_P<E7l(0"(&T C7T `##/T V7T 4(*.2D(/T ]7T !"%?00(/T X7T N<LM7 V;+'().(

0/#$ 1#&%/ +.( .#/(* 0#/ "2( +)./(%*( +) %"$#*12(/+. 345 +)"2( 1%*" "F# .()"?/+(*7 l%"?/( PNMT BM_BO7

4>(/>%?(/T !7=7T !"/%+)T X797T N<LE7 V00(."* #0 .%)#1, 1#*+"+#) %)'

+//%'+%).( #) "2( &(%0 12,*+#&#D, %)' $#/12#&#D, #0 8$&+"6#$I+5)" /"6)0#0R" I`+$#*%.(%(J7 C$7 q7 X#"7 OPT B@<_BNE7

4>(/>%?(/T !7=7T !"/%+)T X797T =(".2(/T l7T N<LM7 V00(." #0 345G()/+.2$()" #) *(('&+)D 12,*+#&#D, %)' D/#F"2 #0 "F# "/#1+.%&

"/(( *1(.+(*7 ^2,*+#&7 ^&%)"7 EMT PM5_PME74d8(%/,T q7f7T \)(.2"T h7l7T N<LN7 V&(;%"(' 345 .#).()"/%"+#)

+)./(%*(* *"#$%"% )?$>(/* +) 85"*$0#X* (X#3")'* &(%;(*7 X#"7

h%Q7 NB5T BPL_BBN7^%e%eYY#e)()T V7T Z%2%&%T q7T ^#2k#&%T `7T ]#&#1%+)()T R7T \%e/()&%$1+T

87T N<<L7 ^2,*+#&#D+.%&T *"#$%"%& %)' ?&"/%*"/?."?/%& #Q#)(/(*1#)*(* +) >+/.2 I;$+X#" .$&4X#" 9#"27J %/( $#'+H(' >,

F%"(/ *"/(**7 ^&%)"T 3(&& V);+/#)7 5NT EON_ELB7

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?5E

Page 27: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

^%D%)+T `7T C/"2?/T `7C7T =/(($%)T \7]7T N<<<%7 `+#.()( (;#&?"+#)#0 %"$#*12(/+. .%/>#) '+#-+'(7 ^%&(#.(%)#D/%12, NBT 5OP_5<57

^%D%)+T `7T =/(($%)T \7]7T C/"2?/T `7C7T N<<<>7 8%"( `+#.()(%"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)* %)' "2( (-1%)*+#) #0 3B

D/%**(*7 !.+().( 5LMT LOE_LO<7^%#&(""+T V7T h(&&+)+T 97T N<<P7 !"#$%"%& '()*+", ;%/+%"+#) +) >((.2

%)' 2#&$ #%Y &(%;(* .#&&(."(' #;(/ "2( &%*" 5@@ ,(%/*7 C."%{.#&7 NBT NOP_NOL7

^%#&(""+T V7T `+D&+(""%T =7T 9%*.2+T C7T `%)(*T =7T h/#**#)+T ^7T N<<O7!"#$%"%& )?$>(/* +) 2#&$ #%Y IZX$)6X* '#$< 87J &(%;(* D/#F) +))%"?/%&&, %)' %/"+H.+%&&, 345G()/+.2(' ();+/#)$()"*7 K)[

9%*.2+T C7T `+D&+(""%T =7T R#D)(""+T 97T ;%) h%/'+)D()T ^797IV'*7JT ^&%)" 9(*1#)*(* "# V&(;%"(' 3457 3%$>/+'D( t)+;(/*+",

^/(**T 3%$>/+'D(T 117 N<O_5@L7^%#&(""+T V7T l#?//+*#)T h7T h%//(.T q7^7T 9%*.2+T C7T N<<L7 `#'+H.%G

"+#)* #0 "2( &(%0 *?/0%.( *"/?."?/(* #0 ZX$)6X* '#$< 87 +) #1()T)%"?/%&&, 345G()/+.2(' ();+/#)$()"*7 ^&%)"T 3(&& V);+/#)7 5NTN@ON_N@OM7

^(%/*#)T `7T 6%;+(*T f7q7T `%)*H(&'T R7C7T N<<M7 C*,$$("/+.

/(*1#)*(* #0 %'%-+%& %)' %>%-+%& *"#$%"% "# (&(;%"(' 345[+$1%."* #) "2( .#)"/#& #0 D%* (-.2%)D( >, &(%;(*7 ^&%)"T 3(&&V);+/#)7 NLT LPO_LBP7

^(%/*#)T ^7l7T ^%&$(/T `797T N<<<7 `+''&( V#.()( *(%F%"(/ 1] %)'%"$#*12(/+. .%/>#) '+#-+'( .#).()"/%"+#)*7 !.+().( 5LBT NL5B_

NL5E7^()o?(&%*T q7T `%"%$%&%T 97T N<<@7 32%)D(* +) l %)' ! &(%0 .#)"()"T

*"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' *1(.+H. &(%0 %/(% +) NB 1&%)" *1(.+(* '?/+)D"2( &%*" "2/(( .()"?/+(*7 q7 V-17 X#"7 BNT NNN<_NN5B7

^("+"T q797T q#?Q(&T q7T9%,)%?'T67TX%/Y#;Tl7K7TX%/)#&%T q7G`7TX%*+&(TK7T X()'(/T `7T 32%11(&&%QT q7T 6%;+*T `7T 6(&%,D?(T h7T 6(&$#""(T

`7T \#"&,%Y#;T Z7`7T 8(D/%)'T `7T 8+1()Y#;T Z7c7T 8#/+?*T 37T^(g1+)T 87T 9+"QT 37T !%&"Q$%)T V7T !"+(;()%/'T `7T N<<<7 3&+$%"(%)' %"$#*12(/+. 2+*"#/, #0 "2( 1%*" B5@T@@@ ,(%/* 0/#$ "2(Z#*"#Y

+.( .#/(T C)"%/."+.%7 l%"?/( P<<T B5<_BPE7^&%""T l7]7T N<L<7 8%.?*"/+)( .%/>#)%"(* %)' 1('#D()(*+*[ *('+$()G

"#&#D, %)' #/+D+) #0 1%&?*"/+)( '(1#*+"* 0/#$ "2( V%/&, 3/("%.G(#?* 9?1(&# =#/$%"+#)T f7 3%$(/#* X%*+)T l7 !1%+)7

!('+$()"#&#D, PET EEM_ELB7^#&&(,T ]7f7T q#2)*#)T ]7X7T `%/+)#T X767T `%,(?-T ]7!7T N<<P7

K)./(%*( +) 3P 1&%)" F%"(/G?*( (0H.+()., %)' >+#$%** #;(/h&%.+%& "# 1/(*()" 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*7 l%"?/( PENT EN_EB7

^#&&(,T ]7f7T q#2)*#)T ]7X7T `%,(?-T ]7!7T N<<57 h/#F"2 %)' D%*(-.2%)D( #0 #%"* IK($&" *"+'("J %)' F+&' $?*"%/' I;)"**'6"

_"R$)J %" *?>%$>+()" 345 .#).()"/%"+#)*7 K)"7 q7 ^&%)" !.+7NMPT BMP_BEN7

^##&(T K7T f(,(/*T q767X7T 8%F*#)T R7T 9%;()T q7C7T N<<E7 Z%/+%"+#)*+) *"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' +)'(-[ +$1&+.%"+#)* 0#/ 1%&%(#.&+$%"+./(.#)*"/?."+#)*7 ^&%)"T 3(&& V);+/#)7 N<T O@M_ON57

^#11T X7l7T C)'(/*#)T R7=7T !%)'>(/DT ^7C7T N<LE7 X/%.2+#1#'* %*+)'+.%"#/* #0 #/+D+)%& +*#"#1+. .#$1#*+"+#) +) *#$( ^%&(#Q#+.

&+$(*"#)(*7 X?&&7 h(#&7 !#.7 C$7 <OT N5E5_N5E<7^/+".2%/'T !7h7T `#*k+'+*T 37T ^("(/*#)T 37`7T 9?)+#)T h7X7T 9#D(/*T

]7]7T N<<L7 C)%"#$+.%& %)' $#/12#&#D+.%& %&"(/%"+#)* +) &#)DG&(%0 1+)( )(('&(* /(*?&"+)D 0/#$ D/#F"2 +) (&(;%"(' 345[ +)"(/G

%."+#)* F+"2 *#+& /(*#?/.( %;%+&%>+&+",7 K)"7 q7 ^&%)" !.+7 NM<TN@@5_N@@<7

'( m?(+/#QT \7T h%?"2+(/T q7T N<<@7 ^2,&#D(), %* % .()"/%& 1/+).+1&(

+) "%-#)#$,[ 12,&#D()("+. '(H)+"+#)* #0 "%-#) )%$(*7 !,*"7p##&7 P<T P@O_P557

9%'#D&#?T \7`7T q%/;+*T ^7h7T N<<@7 V00(."* #0 345 ()/+.2$()" #)

0#?/ 1#1&%/ .&#)(*7 KK7 8(%0 *"/?."?/( 1/#1(/"+(*7 C))7 X#"7 EMTE5O_EP57

9%'#D&#?T \7`7T q%/;+*T ^7h7T N<<57 R2( (00(."* #0 345 ()/+.2$()"%)' )?"/+()" *?11&, #) D/#F"2T $#/12#&#D, %)' %)%"#$, #0

85"*$0#X* (X#3")'* 87 *(('&+)D*7 C))7 X#"7 O@T 5BM_5ME79%'#D&#?T \7`7T q%/;+*T ^7h7T N<<P7 V00(."* #0 %"$#*12(/+. 345

()/+.2$()" #) (%/&, D/#F"2 #0 a'('" 1"R"T % 1&%)" F+"2 &%/D(

.#",&('#)*7 ^&%)"T 3(&& V);+/#)7 NET <P_<L79%2+$T `7C7T =#/'2%$T 97T N<<N7 V00(." #0 *2%'( #) &(%0 %)' .(&&

*+Q( %)' )?$>(/ #0 (1+'(/$%& .(&&* +) D%/&+. IK##'X/ *"+'(X/J7

C))7 X#"7 EOT NEO_NON79%)%*+)D2(T !7T R%,&#/T h7T N<<E7 `(.2%)+*$ 0#/ +)./(%*(' &(%0

D/#F"2 +) (&(;%"(' 3457 q7 V-17 X#"7 BOT PB<_PML79%;()T q7C7T 9%$*'()T ]7q7T N<LL7 !+$+&%/+", #0 *"#$%"%& +)'(- +)

"2( 3B 1&%)" J"#*0#" _"#' 87 +) $%"(/+%& .#&&(."(' +) NLBP %)'

N<LO[ /(&(;%).( "# .2%)D(* +) %"$#*12(/+. 345 .#)"()"7 R/%)*7

X#"7 !#.7 V'+)>7 BMT 55P_5PP79('',T \797T 9#>%)%T 9797T ]#'D(*T ]7=7T 8+?T ~7q7T `.\+)+#)T

q7`7T N<<L7 K)"(/%."+#)* #0 345 ()/+.2$()" %)' "($1(/%"?/(#) .#""#) D/#F"2 %)' &(%0 .2%/%."(/+*"+.*7 V);+/#)7 V-17 X#"7

P<T NNO_N5<79("%&&%.YT h7q7T N<<O7 V%/&, 0#/(*" *#+&* %)' "2(+/ /#&( +) 6(;#)+%)

D&#>%& .2%)D(7 !.+().( 5OET MLP_MLM79#>+)*#)T q7`7T N<<B7 !1(.?&%"+#)* #) .%/>#) '+#-+'( *"%/;%"+#)7

8%"( R(/"+%/, (;#&?"+#) #0 *"#$%"%& /(D?&%"+#) %)' i#/+*"+.$#'(/)+Q%"+#)7 ^&%)"T 3(&& V);+/#)7 NOT PBM_PMB7

9#F&%)'GX%$0#/'T C7q7T l#/'()>/#.YT 37T X%Y(/T q7R7T X#F(*T h7T

C&&()T 87]7T N<<@7 32%)D(* +) *"#$%"%& '()*+", +) /+.( D/#F)?)'(/ ;%/+#?* 345 /(D+$(* F+"2 )%"?/%& *#&%/ /%'+%"+#)7 V);+/#)7

V-17 X#"7 P@T NOM_NL@79#F*#)T q7`7T N<BE7 R2( *+D)+H.%).( #0 *"#$%"%& +)'(- %* % '+00(/G

()"+%& .2%/%."(/7 ^%/" KKK7 !"?'+(* +) "2( D()(/% K+)0."T -"+X)"T

-'3'+"#'*T 85,+0#"66" %)' +) 1#&,1&#+' &(%;(*7 m?%/"7 q7 ^2%/$7^2%/$%.(?"7 N<T NPE_NBP7

9?)'D/()T `7T X((/&+)DT 67T N<<<7 C ]#&#.()( 345 /(.#/' 0/#$ "2(

*"#$%"%& +)'(- #0 *?>G0#**+& J"#'< 5$)R"6$" 87 &(%;(* 0/#$)#/"2(/) !F('()7 ]#&#.()( <T M@<_MNP7

9,&(T h7q7C7T !"%)&(,T q7T N<<57 V00(." #0 (&(;%"(' 345 #) *"#$%"%&*+Q( %)' '+*"/+>?"+#) +) 1(/())+%& /,(D/%**7 C))7 X#"7 E<T MEP_

MEM7!%&+*>?/,T V7q7T N<5O7 4) "2( .%?*(* %)' (.#&#D+.%& *+D)+H.%).( #0

*"#$%"%& 0/(W?().,T F+"2 *1(.+%& /(0(/().( "# "2( F##'&%)'

i#/%7 ^2+&#*7 R/%)*7 97 !#.7 8#)'#) X 5NET N_EM7!.2#.2T ^7h7T p+)*#?T 37T !+>+T `7T N<L@7 6(1()'().( #0 "2( *"#$%G

"%& +)'(- #) ();+/#)$()"%& 0%."#/* '?/+)D *"#$%"%& '+00(/()"+%G

"+#) +) &(%;(* #0 a'3&" *'&$&*'* 87 K7 V00(." #0 &+D2" +)"()*+",7 q7V-17 X#"7 PNT N5NN_N5NE7

!2%/$%T h7\7T 6?))T 67X7T N<EL7 V00(." #0 ();+/#)$()" #) "2(

.?"+.?&%/ 0(%"?/(* +) L"#"&650$ 1$4*65$&_0'7 X?&&7 R#//(, X#"73&?> <MT BEB_BOP7

!2%/$%T h7\7T 6?))T 67X7T N<E<7 V);+/#)$()"%& $#'+H.%"+#)* #0

&(%0 *?/0%.( "/%+"* +) -"+X)" *+)"/0&'X/7 3%)7 q7 X#"7 BOT N5NN_N5NE7

!+)2%T C7T !"#""T 8767T N<<B7 l(F %"$#*12(/+. 1345 (*"+$%"(* 0/#$

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=? 5O

Page 28: 0 1%&(#%$#*12(/+. 34 .#).()/%+#)peter/Resources/Seminar/readings...W9@9 M

1%&(#*#&* '?/+)D "2( &%"( ^%&(#.()( U(%/&, V#.()( D&#>%& F%/$G+)D +)"(/;%&7 h&#>%& ^&%)("7 32%)D( <T 5<O_P@O7

!$+"2T !7T f(,(/*T q767X7T X(//,T f7h7T N<L<7 Z%/+%"+#) +) *"#$%"%&.2%/%."(/+*"+.* #;(/ "2( &#F(/ *?/0%.( #0 E0//$#'&" 60//X&'*&(%;(*7 ^&%)"T 3(&& V);+/#)7 N5T EMP_EM<7

!#&%g/#;%gT q7T ^#*1rg*s+&#;%gT q7T N<LL7 !"#$%"%& 0/(W?().+(* +) "2( %'%-G+%& %)' %>%-+%& (1+'(/$(* #0 1/+$%/, >(%) &(%;(* %00(."(' >,D/#F+)D +//%'+%).(*7 C."% t)+;7 3%/#&+)%( z X+#&7 PNT N@N_N@M7

!1+.(/T 97C7T N<LN7 R2( *#/"+)D %)' '(1#*+"+#) #0 %&&#.2"2#)#?*1&%)" $%"(/+%& +) % $#'(/) ();+/#)$()" %" !+&&F##' 8%Y(T !+&&GF##' ^%/YT X(/Y*2+/(T V)D&%)'7 t! h(#&7 !?/;7 ^/#07 ^%17 NNBPTN_OO7

!"%).%"#T h737T `%QQ#)+GZ+;(+/#*T !737T 8?.2+T C7V7T N<<<7 !"#$%G"%& .2%/%."(/+*"+.* +) '+00(/()" 2%>+"%" 0#/$* #0 X/%Q+&+%) *1(.+(*#0 M.'4$&4)X/ I4/.2+'%.(%(J7 l#/'7 q7 X#"7 N<T 5ON_5OM7

!"(F%/"T q767T ]#''+)#""T q7T N<<P7 ^2#"#*,)"2("+. %..&+$%"+#) "#(&(;%"(' %"$#*12(/+. .%/>#) '+#-+'( %)' tZ +//%'+%"+#) +)8'&X* R"&_*'"&"7 ^2,*+#&7 ^&%)"7 LLT B<P_M@@7

!?.2(.Y,T 97\7T ]?>(/"T q7=7T X+/)(, '( f+"T 3737T N<LL7 K*#"#1+.+$1/+)" #0 .&+$%"( %)' 2,'/#D(#.2($+*"/, #) "(//(*"/+%& *"/%"% #0"2( R/+%**+._q?/%**+. ]%/"0#/' %)' =?)', 9+0" X%*+)*7 q7 !('+G$()"7 ^("/#&7 MLT L@N_LNN7

R2#$%*T q7=7T ]%/;(,T 37l7T N<LP7 8(%0 %)%"#$, #0 0#?/ *1(.+(*D/#F) ?)'(/ .#)"+)?#?* 345 ()/+.2$()"7 X#"7 h%Q7 NBBT P@P_P@<7

R+.2%gT K7T N<L57 ^2#"#*,)"2("+. .2%/%."(/+*"+.* '?/+)D #)"#D()(*+* #0&(%;(*7 O7 !"#$%"%'()*+", %)' *+Q(*7 ^2#"#*,)"2("+.% NET POM_BON7

R+11+)DT 37T `?//%,T 6797T N<<<7 V00(."* #0 (&(;%"(' %"$#*12(/+.345 .#).()"/%"+#) #) &(%0 %)%"#$, %)' $#/12#&#D, +) 8"&'6X/*1(.+(* /(1/(*()"+)D '+00(/()" 12#"#*,)"2("+. $#'(*7 K)"7 q7 ^&%)"!.+7 NE@T N@EP_N@OP7

Z(+Q(/T q7T C&%T 67T CQ$,T \7T X/?.Y*.2()T ^7T X?2&T 67T X/?2)T =7T3%/'()T h7C7=7T 6+()(/T C7T V>)("2T !7T h#''(/+*T c7T q%*1(/T R7T\#/"(T 37T ^%F(&&(YT =7T ^#'&%2%T 47h7T !"/%?**T ]7T N<<<7LO!/ULE!/T !NP3 %)' !NL4 (;#&?"+#) #0 ^2%)(/#Q#+. *(%F%"(/732($7 h(#&7 NENT M<_LL7

f%D)(/T =7T N<<L7 R2( +)i?().( #0 ();+/#)$()" #) "2( *"#$%"%&0/(W?()., +) ;$+X#"7 8^^ 3#)"/+>7 !(/+(* <T N_N@57

f%D)(/T =7T X(&#FT 97T 6( \&(/YT ^7T 6+&.2(/T 6787T q##*"()T ]7T

\?e/*.2)(/T f7`7T Z+**.2(/T ]7T N<<E7 C )%"?/%& (-1(/+$()" #)

1&%)" %..&+$%"+#)[ &+0("+$( *"#$%"%& 0/(W?()., /(*1#)*( #0 %)

+)'+;+'?%& "/(( "# %))?%& %"$#*12(/+. 345 +)./(%*(7 ^/#.7 l%"&

C.%'7 !.+7 t!C <PT NNO@M_NNO@L7f%D)(/T =7T X#2).Y(T !7q7^7T 6+&.2(/T 6787T \?e/*.2)(/T f7`7T ;%)

h((&T X7T Z+**.2(/T ]7T N<<<7 3()"?/,G*.%&( *2+0"* +) (%/&, ]#&#G

.()( %"$#*12(/+. 345 .#).()"/%"+#)7 !.+().( 5LBT N<ON_N<OP7;%) '( f%"(/T ^7\7T 8(%;+""T !7f7T X("%).#?/"T q787T N<<B7 R/()'* +)

*"#$%"%& '()*+", %)' NP3UN53 /%"+#* #0 8'&X* ^$<'#'* )(('&(*

'?/+)D &%*" D&%.+%&_+)"(/D&%.+%& .,.&(7 !.+().( 5EBT 5P<_5BP7f+&"*2+/(T q7q7q7T f/+D2"T 37q7T 3#&&*T q7q7T 3/%+D#)T q7T t)*F#/"2T

`7]7T N<<E7 !#$( 0#&+%/ .2%/%."(/+*"+.* #0 %*2 "/((* IY)"<'&X*

$<6$#*'0)J (-1#*(' "# #Q#)( (1+*#'(*7 l(F ^2,"#&7 NPBT E5P_

EP@7f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<LE7 V.#12,*+#&#D+.%& *"?'+(* #) "2( *2/?> a"66'I

&'X/ /,)+'##X* 87 "%Y() 0/#$ % F+'( %&"+"?'+)%& /%)D(7 4(.#&#D+%

O@T ML@_MLE7f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<LO7 !"#$%"%& )?$>(/* %/( *()*+"+;( "# +)./(%*(*

+) 345 0/#$ 1/(G+)'?*"/+%& &(;(&*7 l%"?/( P5OT ENO_ENL7f##'F%/'T =7K7T N<LL7 R2( /(*1#)*(* #0 *"#$%"% "# .2%)D(* +)

%"$#*12(/+. &(;(&* #0 3457 ^&%)"* R#'%, NT NP5_NPM7f##'F%/'T =7K7T X%QQ%QT =7C7T N<LL7 R2( /(*1#)*(* #0 *"#$%G

"%& '()*+", "# 345 1%/"+%& 1/(**?/(7 q7 V-17 X#"7 P<T

NOON_NOLN7f##'F%/'T =7K7T X((/&+)DT 67q7T N<<O7 ^&%)"_345 /(*1#)*(* +) "2(

&#)D "(/$[ 1&%)"* 0/#$ 345 *1/+)D* +) =&#/+'% %)' "#$>* +)

VD,1"7 K)[ 9%*.2+T C7T `+D&+(""%T =7T R#D)(""+T 97T ;%) h%/'+)D()T

^797 IV'*7J7 ^&%)" 9(*1#)*(* "# V&(;%"(' 3457 3%$>/+'D(

t)+;(/*+", ^/(**T 3%$>/+'D(T 117 N@P_NNP7f##'F%/'T =7K7T \(&&,T 37\7T N<<M7 R2( +)i?().( #0 345 .#).()G

"/%"+#) #) *"#$%"%& '()*+",7 l(F ^2,"#&7 NPNT PNN_P5O7c%11T 37q7T ^#"2*T ]7T N<<57 C).+()" %"$#*12(/+. 345 1/(**?/(*

+)0(//(' 0/#$ )%"?/%& D#("2+"(*7 l%"?/( PMMT PB5_PBB7c%11T 37q7T ^#"2*T ]7T N<<E7 3%/>#) +*#"#1(* +) .#)"+)()"%& F(%"2G

(/+)D ();+/#)$()"* %)' ;%/+%"+#)* +) %).+()" %"$#*12(/+. 3451/(**?/(7 V%/"2 ^&%)("7 !.+7 8(""7 NPOT ON_L57

p%..2+)+T `7T `#/+)+T !7T Z+"%D&+%)#T 37T N<<O7 V00(." #0 12#"#1(/+#'

#) *#$( *"#$%"%& .2%/%."(/+*"+.* #0 +) ;+"/# .?&"?/(' 0/?+" "/((

*2##"*7 ^&%)"T 3(&&T R+**?( 4/D%) 3?&"?/( B<T N<M_5@@7

-9O9 P0,$) Q P$('$C 01 8"#"$0R0+"&, "&4 8"#,&0#03, @@S T=>>@U @V=?5L