Post on 12-Jan-2016
www.lehmanlaw.com
Edward LehmanEdward Lehman
Practising Law Institute Practising Law Institute 810 Seventh Avenue, 20th Floor 810 Seventh Avenue, 20th Floor
New York, NY 10019 New York, NY 10019
LEHMAN, LEE & XULEHMAN, LEE & XUwww.lehmanlaw.comwww.lehmanlaw.com
www.lehmanlaw.com
M&A Strategies M&A Strategies in Chinain China
www.lehmanlaw.com
Of InterestOf Interest
BizChina BizChina
Dialogue Dialogue
Discussion of new anti-monopoly law Discussion of new anti-monopoly law and impacts on M&A in Chinaand impacts on M&A in China– located at located at www.lehmanlaw.comwww.lehmanlaw.com under TV & under TV &
MediaMedia
www.lehmanlaw.com
General thoughtsGeneral thoughts
Why is common sense left at the Why is common sense left at the border?border?
Three basic rules of M&A in Three basic rules of M&A in China:China:
1.1. Due diligenceDue diligence
2.2. Due diligenceDue diligence
3.3. Due diligenceDue diligence
www.lehmanlaw.com
ContentsContents
Growth of M&AsGrowth of M&As
M&A OpportunitiesM&A Opportunities
Nature of M&As Nature of M&As
Importance of Privately Importance of Privately Owned Enterprises Owned Enterprises
Case Study – Mengniu Case Study – Mengniu Diary GroupDiary Group
Role of GovernmentRole of Government
Restrictions Restrictions
M&A Methods within M&A Methods within ChinaChina
Offshore TransactionsOffshore Transactions
Current Law on M&ACurrent Law on M&A
Practical ConsiderationsPractical Considerations
www.lehmanlaw.com
Growth of M&AsGrowth of M&As Every year since 2002 has been a record Every year since 2002 has been a record yeyear of M&A growthar of M&A growth M&A transactions rose 50% in 2004 over M&A transactions rose 50% in 2004 over preprevious year vious year HSBC USD $1.74bn acquisition of 19.9% HSBC USD $1.74bn acquisition of 19.9% stastake in Bank of Communicationske in Bank of Communications Anheuser-Busch USD $600 million acquisition Anheuser-Busch USD $600 million acquisition
of Harbin Brewery Group of Harbin Brewery Group
More M&As over traditional More M&As over traditional “Green-field” “Green-field” investmentsinvestments
www.lehmanlaw.com
From the headlinesFrom the headlines ““China is formally launching its wealth fund, China is formally launching its wealth fund,
amid market talk…what the nearly $200 billion amid market talk…what the nearly $200 billion will be used for”will be used for”
““Nasdaq won China’s approval to open a Nasdaq won China’s approval to open a Beijing representative office”Beijing representative office”
““Citic Resources was expected to buy a Citic Resources was expected to buy a majority stake in Tincy, making it China’s majority stake in Tincy, making it China’s fourth-largest oil producer”fourth-largest oil producer”
““Chinese telecom shares leapt after Chinese telecom shares leapt after government plan to audit five-major operators government plan to audit five-major operators spurred talk of sector restructuring.”spurred talk of sector restructuring.”
From the Wall Street Journal Asia (September From the Wall Street Journal Asia (September 28-30, 2007 Edition)28-30, 2007 Edition)
www.lehmanlaw.com
Opportunities Opportunities for M&Asfor M&As
Government expansion of industries Government expansion of industries for for M&A investment M&A investment
Privatization of State-owned Privatization of State-owned Enterprises Enterprises (SOEs) - approx 4,000 to (SOEs) - approx 4,000 to 5,000 each year 5,000 each year
Acquisition is the cheapest and Acquisition is the cheapest and fastest way fastest way to enter the Chinese market to enter the Chinese market
Fragmented sectors of the economy Fragmented sectors of the economy present present opportunities to consolidate and opportunities to consolidate and create create economies of scale economies of scale
www.lehmanlaw.com
Nature of M&AsNature of M&As Vast majority M&A involved Vast majority M&A involved
recently – privatization of recently – privatization of SOEsSOEs
Trend is changing to involvTrend is changing to involve e Private-owned Enterprises Private-owned Enterprises
(POEs) (POEs) POEs, especially those that POEs, especially those that
develop from SOEs, are develop from SOEs, are nnow major targets of M&As ow major targets of M&As
www.lehmanlaw.com
ImportanImportance of ce of POEsPOEs
Fast growth = attractive Fast growth = attractive investment targets investment targets
Usually capital starved, Usually capital starved, welcome cash in welcome cash in
exchange exchange for minority stake for minority stake
Low-costs, non-Low-costs, non-bureaucratic, bureaucratic, local local knowledge, effective knowledge, effective
good partners for good partners for restructuring SOEs (most restructuring SOEs (most POE POE managers come from managers come from SOEs) SOEs)
““Guanxi” (Relationship) Guanxi” (Relationship) with with SOEs SOEs
www.lehmanlaw.com
Case Study: Mengniu Case Study: Mengniu Dairy GroupDairy Group
www.lehmanlaw.com
Case Study in POEs: Case Study in POEs: Mengniu Dairy GroupMengniu Dairy Group
Second largest producer of milk, yogurt, ice Second largest producer of milk, yogurt, ice cream cream
Niu Genshen, former vice-president at state-Niu Genshen, former vice-president at state-owned Yili Dairy, founded Mengniu after owned Yili Dairy, founded Mengniu after leavileavi
ng the companyng the company Borrowed $1million to establish Mengniu Diary Borrowed $1million to establish Mengniu Diary
Group Group After 7 years, Mengniu rapidly closing-in on After 7 years, Mengniu rapidly closing-in on
Yili Dairy Yili Dairy Mengniu’s annual revenue was $1.3bn, while Mengniu’s annual revenue was $1.3bn, while
Yili’s Yili’s annual revenue was $1.5bn (2005)annual revenue was $1.5bn (2005)
www.lehmanlaw.com
Role of Role of Government in Government in
M&AsM&As Government approval required for Government approval required for
M&A M&A transactions transactions
Includes: Includes:
I.I. Ministry of Commerce Ministry of Commerce (MOFCOM)(MOFCOM) - - principle principle foreign investment examination foreign investment examination and approval and approval authority, entitled to authority, entitled to supervise and approve supervise and approve M&A M&A transactions transactions
www.lehmanlaw.com
Role of Role of Government in Government in
M&AsM&AsII.II. State Development and Reform Commission State Development and Reform Commission
(SDRC)(SDRC) is responsible for both approving foreign is responsible for both approving foreign investment project application and supervising investment project application and supervising restructuring of state-owned enterprisesrestructuring of state-owned enterprises
III.III. State-Owned Assets Supervision and State-Owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission Administration Commission (SASAC)(SASAC) comes into comes into picture if the target enterprise is state-ownedpicture if the target enterprise is state-owned
IV.IV. China Securities Regulatory Commission China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC)(CSRC) – if is listed on China’s stock market– if is listed on China’s stock market
V.V. Other industry-specific regulators, e.g. Other industry-specific regulators, e.g. if the if the target is a Chinese bank, the approval of China target is a Chinese bank, the approval of China Banking Regulatory Commission Banking Regulatory Commission (CBRC)(CBRC) will be will be required required
www.lehmanlaw.com
RestrictionsRestrictions Catalogue for the Guidance of Catalogue for the Guidance of
Foreign Investment Foreign Investment (CATALOGUE)(CATALOGUE)
Classifies investment projects Classifies investment projects by by sector as “sector as “encouragedencouraged,” ,” ““permittedpermitted,” “,” “restrictedrestricted,” or ,” or ““prohibitedprohibited” ”
Majority Chinese Majority Chinese shareholding shareholding mandated in mandated in several restricted several restricted sectors sectors
Other sectors prohibit 100% Other sectors prohibit 100% foreign shareholding foreign shareholding
www.lehmanlaw.com
M&A Methods M&A Methods within Chinawithin China
Equity Equity TransactionTransaction
Asset PurchaseAsset Purchase
Statutory Statutory Merger Merger
www.lehmanlaw.com
I.I. Equity TransactionEquity Transaction Foreign investor acquires equity in an Foreign investor acquires equity in an
existing FIE or a domestic enterprise existing FIE or a domestic enterprise from from foreign or Chinese shareholders foreign or Chinese shareholders
Requires Chinese examination and Requires Chinese examination and approval approval
If target is purely domestic, it will If target is purely domestic, it will become become an FIE after equity purchase an FIE after equity purchase
FIE must assume target’s FIE must assume target’s responsibilities responsibilities and and liabilities liabilities
All agreements subject to Chinese All agreements subject to Chinese Government’s approvalGovernment’s approval
www.lehmanlaw.com
II.II. Asset PurchaseAsset Purchase
AAcquire select assets cquire select assets
““Peel-off” unwanted assets and Peel-off” unwanted assets and liabilities liabilities
No change in equity ownershipNo change in equity ownership
Target retains all original rights and Target retains all original rights and liabilities liabilities
Foreign companies not allowed to Foreign companies not allowed to directly directly operate assets without PRC operate assets without PRC presence presence
Needs to establish FIE to purchase Needs to establish FIE to purchase assets assets
www.lehmanlaw.com
III.III. MergerMerger
Foreign investor must establish FIE Foreign investor must establish FIE in China in China for merger for merger
Subject to multi-step approval Subject to multi-step approval process process
Two Types: Two Types:
I.I. Merger by Absorption - absorbing Merger by Absorption - absorbing company company will remain, while absorbed will remain, while absorbed company will dissolve company will dissolve
II.II. Merger by New Establishment - combined Merger by New Establishment - combined
companies will dissolve, while new companies will dissolve, while new company is established company is established
www.lehmanlaw.com
Off-shore Off-shore TransactionTransaction
U.S. C CorporationU.S. C Corporation
↓ ↓ Acquires a Acquires a 70% stake 70% stake HK B Offshore Corporation HK B Offshore Corporation Indirectly Acquires Indirectly Acquires
AA
↓ ↓ ShareholderShareholderChina A Domestic CorporationChina A Domestic Corporation
Offshore transaction most effective
Doesn’t require approval within China unless any item (i.e. shareholders’ names) needs to be changed
www.lehmanlaw.com
Current Law on M&ACurrent Law on M&A Acquisition of Domestic Acquisition of Domestic
Enterprises by Foreign Enterprises by Foreign Investors ProvisionsInvestors Provisions
(Effective Sep 8, 2006) (Effective Sep 8, 2006) Supersedes 2003 Supersedes 2003
Tentative Provisions on Tentative Provisions on Using Foreign Using Foreign Investment to Investment to Reorganize State-Reorganize State-Owned EnterprisesOwned Enterprises
www.lehmanlaw.com
Current Law on M&ACurrent Law on M&AI.I. Share SwapsShare Swaps The shareholder of an overseas company to The shareholder of an overseas company to
use the shares it holds in the overseas use the shares it holds in the overseas company or to use the newly issued shares of company or to use the newly issued shares of the overseas company to purchase the the overseas company to purchase the shares held by the shareholder of a domestic shares held by the shareholder of a domestic enterprise or the newly issued shares of the enterprise or the newly issued shares of the domestic enterprise.domestic enterprise.
The domestic company or its shareholder The domestic company or its shareholder shall engage a PRC registered agency (e.g. a shall engage a PRC registered agency (e.g. a law firm, a CPA firm) to act as their M&A law firm, a CPA firm) to act as their M&A counsel to conduct Due Diligence. counsel to conduct Due Diligence.
www.lehmanlaw.com
Current Law on M&ACurrent Law on M&A
II.II. Offshore Special Purpose Offshore Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs)Vehicles (SPVs)
An Overseas company directly or indirectly An Overseas company directly or indirectly controlled by a PRC company or PRC controlled by a PRC company or PRC individuals for the purpose of individuals for the purpose of consummating the overseas listing of the consummating the overseas listing of the interests it actually owns in a domestic interests it actually owns in a domestic company.company.
Domestic company needs MOFCOM and Domestic company needs MOFCOM and CSRC approvalCSRC approval
After overseas listing, domestic company After overseas listing, domestic company must report to MOFCOM proceeds must report to MOFCOM proceeds repatriation plan – required to repatriate all repatriation plan – required to repatriate all foreign currency incomeforeign currency income
www.lehmanlaw.com
Current Law on M&ACurrent Law on M&A
III.III. National Economic SecurityNational Economic SecurityRequires both foreign investors and Requires both foreign investors and domestic enterprises to report domestic enterprises to report
details details of acquisition to MOFCOM if itof acquisition to MOFCOM if it
Involves China’s “key industries”Involves China’s “key industries” May affect China’s economic May affect China’s economic
securitysecurity May lead to transfer of ownership May lead to transfer of ownership
of famous Chinese trademarksof famous Chinese trademarks
www.lehmanlaw.com
Practical Practical ConsideratioConsideratio
nsns Importance of Due Importance of Due Diligence Diligence
FIE Tax Preference FIE Tax Preference I.I. 15% to 24% tax rate for FIEs; 15% to 24% tax rate for FIEs;
II.II. ““Two-plus-three” year tax holiday fTwo-plus-three” year tax holiday for FIE manufacturersor FIE manufacturers
New Unified Tax New Unified Tax SysteSystem m ( Jan 1, 2008) ( Jan 1, 2008) 25%25%
Copyright © Lehman, Lee & Xu All Rights Reserved
THANK YOUTHANK YOU
Address: 10-2 Liangmaqiao Diplomatic Compound, Beijing
Telephone: 86-10-8532-1919Fax: 86-10-8532-1999
Email: elehman@lehmanlaw.com
Website: www.lehmanlaw.com