What was Apple thinking?

Post on 27-Jan-2015

105 views 0 download

Tags:

description

A completely subjective list of problems with the User Interface of Apple' iOS 7 mobile operating system, based on a quick recap of the fundamental design concepts of Gestalt Laws, affordances, and skeumorphism.

Transcript of What was Apple thinking?

What was Apple thinking? !

Jochen Wolters @jochenWolters

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Gestalt

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Source: Wikipedia

Gestalt !

The essence or shape of an entity’s complete form.

Image by R. C. James

Sniff, Sniff…

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Similarity

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Proximity

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Closure

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Similarity + Proximity + Closure

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

AffordanceAffordance !

A property of an object, or an environment, which allows an individual to perform an action.

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Affordance !

A property of an object, or an environment, which allows an individual to perform an action that is readily perceivable.

Source: Wikipedia

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

“Does the user perceive that clicking on that location is a meaningful, useful action to perform?”

Donald Norman

Source: http://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/affordances_and.html

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Skeuomorph

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Source: Wikipedia

Skeuomorph !

A derivative object that retains ornamental design cues to a structure that were functionallynecessary in the original.

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Rear Door Front Door

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Don’t Make Me Think! Steve Krug

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Slide inspired by Eric Reiss

OS X 10.9

Windows 8

iOS 7

“That’s a button!”

“Looks like a button.”

“Is that a button?”

Buttons

Examples

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Buttons

Tweetlogix

Notes

“ Does the user perceive that clicking on that location is a meaningful, useful action to perform?”

Donald Norman

Source: http://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/affordances_and.html

Buttons Icons

Examples

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Buttons Icons

Share Panel in Safari

“That’s a book!”

“Looks like a book.”

“Is that a book?”

“Huh?!”

Reminders

iBooks

Notes Game Center

Voice Memos

Passbook

Buttons Icons Barrel Widget

Examples

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Buttons Icons Barrel Widget

Calendar

Buttons Icons Barrel Widget Hidden Functions

Examples

Gestalt Laws | Affordances | Skeuomorphism

Buttons Icons Barrel Widget Hidden Functions

Search Field in iBooks

Podcasts

“ Does the user perceive that clicking on that location is a meaningful, useful action to perform?”

Donald Norman

Source: http://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/affordances_and.html

Gestalt Laws Affordances

Skeuomorphism

Structure Discoverability Knowledge Transfer

help create meaningful:

Donald P. Norman

The Design of Everyday Things

Questions Answers, Spirited Discussion

&

Thank you! !

Jochen Wolters @jochenWolters !

jochen@uiobservatory.com