Post on 14-Oct-2020
Biosolids Dryer Technology Types, Product Types and
Market Value
By Todd O. Williams, PE, BCEE
VWEA Education Seminar
Collaborative Biosolids: Fuel for Thought
Richmond, Virginia
May 11, 2017
2 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Biosolids Dryer Technology Types, Product Types and Market Value
Acknowledgements:
Brian Owsenek, UOSA
Rodney Lloyd, Leesburg
Tim Gallagher, CH2M
Tim Bauer, CH2M
Peter Burrowes, CH2M
Ron Alexander, Alexander Associates
3 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Outline
• Drying Technologies Overview
• Product Marketing Issues
• Virginia Case Studies
• Summary
4 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Why Dry Biosolids?
•Mass & Volume reduction
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
Percent of Solids Dried (2030 Basis)
No
. o
f T
rucks
/Day
Trucks for Hauling
Trucks for Hauling Cake(No./Day)
Trucks for Hauling DryProduct (No./Day)
5 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Why Dry Biosolids?
•Produces a Class A product (under Part 503 rules)– unrestricted use
– flexible usages• commercial fertilizer blend (prepared)
• fertilizer amendment (direct land application)
• fuel – cement kilns
•Can be stored easily (well, sort of….)
6 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Drying Technologies
• Rotary Drums (Direct)– Jones Island, WI; UOSA, VA;
Changi, Singapore; Louisville,
KY; Corona, CA; Bonita
Springs, FL; Leesburg, VA; Blue
Lake, MN; Stamford, CT;
Philadelphia, PA
– Advantages• Product quality
• High capacity
• Operating experience
– Disadvantages• High cost
• High safety provisions
• Complexity, O&M
7 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Typical Direct Drum Dryer
8 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Drying Technologies
• Belt Dryers (Direct)– Kenosha, WI– Low temperature air is used to
heat, absorb moisture• recycle optional• heated by furnace or heat
exchanger
– Advantages• Product quality (moderate)
• Safety (lower temp & low dust)
• Waste heat provisions
• Can use waste heat from CHP
– Disadvantages• Large footprint vs capacity
• Moderate complexity, O&M
10 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Drying Technologies
• Paddle & Screw (Indirect)– Wilsonville, OR; Wilmington, DE– hot oil or steam are used to
heat hollow paddles and shaft• recycle not typical• variable speed rotors• dryers are horizontal single-pass
– Advantages• Good for smaller plants
• Lower complexity
– Disadvantages• Product quality
• Sludge quality adaptability
– Neutral• Safety
12 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Drying Technologies
• Continuous Batch (Indirect) – Fayetteville, AR
– Hot oil is used to heat rotor• Recycle not typical
• Mixing augers and drum
• Fill – Dry – Discharge cycle
– Advantages• Good for smaller plants
• Lower complexity
– Disadvantages• Product quality
– Neutral• Batch operation
• Safety
13 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Drying Technologies
End of batch – ready for unloading
Drying
• Solar Drying – Lincoln, Rio Vista, Salida
CA; Kent County, MD
– Sun and forced ventilation
used• Climatic sensors control
airflow and mole
– Advantages• Good for smaller plants
• Lower complexity
– Disadvantages• Large space required
– Neutral• Batch operation
• Safety
– Can be used in tandem with
thermal dryers to reduce
energy use by half
Chamber filling
14 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Drying Technologies– …..and others
• Thin film (Green Bay, WI)
15 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Drying Technologies
– …..and others• Fluid Bed
• Tray
• Flash
• Electric
• Etc.
Dryer Types
(2011)
Number of
Facilities
USA Canada
Drum 38 6
Belt 7
Indirect 78 1
Solar 15
Total 138 7
16 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Product Marketing and Quality and End Use Issues
• Seasonality of Production and Use– Especially apparent in northern
climates– Storage in winter is an issue
• Pellet Quality– Big difference in product uniformity
• Direct dryers• Indirect dryers
– Hardness– Dust– Size– Uniformity
– Contaminants (Metals, Fiber, Plastics)– Odors
• Digested or not
• Nutrient Content (N-P-K)– Generally N = 5 to 6– Generally P = 3 to 8– Generally K = 0
17 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Product Marketing and Quality and End Use Issues
• Fertilizer Blenders– Require High Degree of Uniformity and will pay top $
• Agricultural Users– Do not require uniformity and will pay much less, if at all
• Soil Blenders?– Are they really interested in the products and willing to pay?
18 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
WEF RBC Conducted a Survey in 2016 and Published a Fact Sheet of Operating Dryer Facilities in 2017
19 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
WEF Survey/Fact Sheet Highlights
• Virtually all dryer facilities sell
granulated product
• Half of respondents sell product for
$1-$20/ton
• One third of respondents sell
product for greater than $20/ton
• Most (>75%) market product in bulk
only
20 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Recent Survey Results from Several California Dryer Facilities (Corona, Encina, Sacramento, Ventura)
• Only high quality pellets can be sold
for substantial price.
• High quality pellets are being sold in
relatively small quantities to golf
courses and nurseries for $100 -
$120/ton in super-sacks
• High quality pellets are sold in bulk to
landscapers, nurseries and
greenhouses range from $40 - $85/ton
• Bulk sales to fertilizer blenders and
brokers in the $20 - $40/ton range
• Bulk sales to farmers/agriculture value
between $12 - $17/ton and used
mainly to prevent on site storage
21 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Case Study – UOSA, Virginia
• Berlie/Swiss Combi (3265) installed in 2004
• Andritz DDS 40 installed in 2014
• Operate 24/5
• Process digested primary blended with undigested WAS
• Process about 6,000 DT/Year
• N-P-K = 5-3-0
• Market product by third party
• 50/50 share in product revenues
• Sold in bulk only
• Wintertime, mostly agriculture at $20/T
• Summer to fertilizer blenders at $40/T
• After $15/T Admin fee, net +$5/T when sold to blenders, net -$5/T when sold to ag/farmers
22 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Case Study – Leesburg, Virginia
• Andritz DDS 20 installed in 2002
• Operate 2 shifts, 5 days per week
(5 am- 10 pm)
• Process digested primary blended
with undigested WAS
• Process about 1,000 DT/Year
• N-P-K = 6-3-0
• Market product themselves
• Giveaway in bags to residents
• Sold in bulk and in bags
• Published information on website
23 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Leesburg TLC Product Sales in 2016
Tons # bags Revenue
(including
delivery)
Net Revenue
($/ton)
Net Revenue
($/bag)
% product
distributed
50 lb bags sold 108 4320 $26,400 $244.44 $6.11 10.6%
Bulk sold 575 $41,713 $72.54 56.5%
50 lb bags giveaway 84 3360 8.3%
Bulk giveaway 251 24.6%
Total 1018 7680 $68,113 $66.91 100.0%
24 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Summary Thoughts
• There are many drier types that create many different product types– Understand your objectives– Know what the local market is
• Before selecting a technology!
• Higher quality uniform products are sold at higher prices
• Markets are generally good for dried products
• Brokers have capacity to move product quickly and efficiently but will pay significantly less for product
• Utilities that market their own product require dedicated staff, but reap higher profits on product sales
• Build flexibility into your program!
25 2015_WWGST_RRR_PPT_Template_01.pptx
Biosolids Dryer Technology Types, Product Types and Market Value
QUESTIONS?
Todd O. Williams, PE, BCEE
todd.williams@ch2m.com