Post on 12-Jul-2015
Systematic Design of Virtual Character-based
SimulationsTwo Case Studies from the Pharmaceutical Industry
Presenters
• Juan Leon, Ph.D.Night Kitchen Media
• Greg SapnarBristol-Myers Squibb
• Tomás RamírezBristol-Myers Squibb
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Today, we can use virtual characters almost anywhere.
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
How do we get the most value from these virtual characters—or VCs?
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
The more accessible the VC technology the more likely its misuse.
• Easy creation = unnecessary proliferation
• Characters can overwhelm the content
• Characters do not properly represent the role they are depicting
• Technology behind the characters drives design and development
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
So…our design practices must better exploit the new “reality”.
• “Hire” a virtual character based on the learning need
• Clearly define the role of the character in the training program
• Don’t be seduced by the lure of the “WOW”
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
First, let’s make VCs better both as graphics and as people.
Virtual Characters are effective and economical when well designed….
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
We’re encountering many types of VCs in a range of situations…
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
…Each at Differing Levels of Sophistication
Visual Representation
Be
ha
vio
rS
tati
c(s
imp
le)
Dy
na
mic
(co
mp
lex)
Biological Realism(complex)
Graphical Abstraction(simple)
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
VCs support more natural learning for the human student.
• Instructional technology inside the delivery medium is doubling in advancement every 6 months
• The biological technology of the basic learner is basically the samethat hunted Mastodons
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
VCs work in part by conveying powerful
non-linguistic messages.Human Communication
7%
38%55%
Verbal (words)
Vocal (volume,pitch,rhythm, etc)
Body Movement
non-linguisticcommunication
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
VCs reach the affective domain, and they have practical advantages.
Proximity& Gaze
Expression& Gesture
Orientation& Posture
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Think more of multi-use “puppets” than expensive custom animations.
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Expressive and practical VCs contribute to a systematic solution following
• Focus on results • Utilize partnerships • Be systematic in: Assessment of need• Be systematic in: Design of solution
HPT Standards
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Our job aid can help you select the proper VC to achieve your learning goals.
(Clark-Lyons)
5. Principles of Psychological Instructional Events
4. Identify Communication Function Need
3. Design Visual Approach
1. Define Goals
• Why use a VC?
• When to use a VC.
• What VC to use?
• How to use that VC?
2. Define context
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
I should have had a VC!
• Users are getting lost in the content
• Users can’t visualize how the task will look when it is performed
• Users are under-motivated or under invested in the material
• Users fail to see the connection between themselves and the content
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
When should I use a VC?
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
What type of VC should I use?
Virtual Characters are Graphics…
…and the rules for using graphics for learning must be followed
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Like other graphics, VCs can have specific communicative functions.
Decorative
OrganizationalInterpretive
Representational
Mnemonic
Relational
Transformational
Clark/Lyons
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
VCs can also support psychological processes of learning.
Build mental models
Support attention
Support motivation
Support transfer
Minimize cognitive load
Activate prior
knowledge
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
• Build mental models and support far transfer of learning.
• Complementary Modalities
• Cognitive rehearsal
VCs can manage cognitive load
But…how do we motivate without falling into “edutainment”?
Virtual Characters are Regarded as Human…
…and the rules for interacting with humans must be followed
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
In the Reeves-Nass model VCs are engaging human beings.
People respond socially and naturally to media even though they believe it is not reasonable to do so, and even though they don’t think that these responses characterize themselves….
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
We value VCs as specialists and we transfer stereotypes, i.e. gender
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Polite dialogue has: - quality - quantity - relevance - clarity
We attribute personality to virtual characters and expect politeness.
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
We all like to be flattered.
How am I doing?
How is he doing?
Virtual Characters work well for modeling behavior and decision making….
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
The situation:Donovan reviews policies and demonstrates procedures to comply with regulatory requirements. As he learns along the process, he discusses his actions with his management and with regulatory compliance personnel.
Case Study 1: Donovan models behavior in Samples Management Process
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Case Study 1: Donovan models behavior in Samples Management Process
Storing Samples
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Case Study 1: Donovan models behavior in Samples Management Process
Expiring Product
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Which psychological functions were at play during the previous scenes?
Build mental models
Support attention
Support motivation
Support transfer
Minimize cognitive load
Activate prior
knowledge
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Which social functions did you find at play?
• Reverence for a specialist
• Gender distinction
• Conversational politeness
• Flattery
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Case Study 2: Use of a Virtual Character as a decision-maker.
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
How would you handle the instructional challenge?
The challenge:By using a case study scenario, we need to model an invisible decision-making process; in this example, the diagnosis and treatment of a complex mental disorder.
Using your VC Matrix tool, identify the instructional behaviors demonstrated by the characters in the following examples.
What roles are played by Dr. Jennings and Dr. Andrews?
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Here’s what we did….
What conclusions can we draw today about using Virtual Characters?
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
First, let’s make VCs better both as graphics and as people.
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Lessons Learned in Using VCs
• We’ve realized Time, Cost, and Logistical Advantages
• Use when you cannot put the learner in the situation where he’d be performing the job task - safety, legal, or regulatory concerns
• Beware of “seductive augmentation”
• Well used for modeling behavior and decision-making.
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Our job aid shows you when and how to use VCs effectively.
• When to use a VC.
• What VC to use?
• How to use that VC?
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
• Don’t equate liking to learning
• Attract, don’t distract
• Beware of “seductive augmentation”
• Balance attraction to motion with visual rests
What we’ve learned when designing VCs as graphics?
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
Expect to see VCs as the human face of intelligent systems.
Possibilities for the future:
• Personalized virtual characters
• EPSS: Putting a Human Face on Expert Systems
• Holographic virtual characters
Presenters
• Juan Leon, Ph.D.Night Kitchen Media
• Greg SapnarBristol-Myers Squibb
• Tomás RamírezBristol-Myers Squibb
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
1. VCs can demonstrate alternative consequences for desired and undesired behavior
2. Learners will grow impatient with a characters that seem unintelligent
3. VC’s dialogue is as important as its visual elements
4. Use VCs in scenario-based inquiry
5. Use VCs as natural attention getters and models of behavior
6. Use VCs to reduce cognitive load by feeding natural processing
7. VCs allow us to exemplify (and illustrate) thought processes
8. VCs can prompt cooperation
What we’ve learned about using VCs for modeling behavior and decision-making.
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
What we’ve learned when employing each type of VC?GUIDES | MODELS | INTERACTIVE AGENTS
Virtual characters should:
• reflect the variety of people within your organization/audience
• not be used as talking heads
• be used when otherwise, you cannot put the learner in the situation where he’d be performing the job task - safety, legal, or regulatory concerns
• demonstrate multiple scenarios for the learner
• build familiarity ( shelf life & background )
• show expertise
Copyright 2005 / Night Kitchen Media
What have we seen as advantages in using VCs in training initiatives?
Time, Cost, and Logistical Advantages• are always available
• can operate in virtual locations
• can look however you want them to look
• easier to deploy
• more consistent than actors
• require fewer resources to produce
• more flexible to manipulate/repurpose
• can translate across cultures (if designed and used correctly)
GUIDES | MODELS | INTERACTIVE AGENTS