THE NEW BRAZIL: ACHIEVEMENTS AND CHALLENGES

Post on 30-Dec-2015

29 views 0 download

description

THE NEW BRAZIL: ACHIEVEMENTS AND CHALLENGES. Edmar Bacha Brazil Seminar. Columbia University September 10th, 2014. BRAZIL’S ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE MID 1990s. Inflation stabilization Income gains of poor families Declining unemployment rates Lower real interest rates - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of THE NEW BRAZIL: ACHIEVEMENTS AND CHALLENGES

THE NEW BRAZIL: ACHIEVEMENTS AND CHALLENGES

Edmar BachaBrazil Seminar. Columbia University

September 10th, 2014

2

BRAZIL’S ACHIEVEMENTS SINCE MID 1990s

• Inflation stabilization • Income gains of poor families• Declining unemployment rates• Lower real interest rates• From external debtor to external creditor

8/21/2014

3

INFLATION BEFORE AND AFTER THE REAL PLAN, 1979-94 AND 1994-2009

8/21/2014 3

4

INCOME DISTRIBUTION IMPROVED AFTER STABILIZATION, 1995-2012

8/21/2014

Yearly

Cumulative

5

UNEMPLOYMENT IS THE LOWEST IN THE SERIES, 2002-2014

8/21/2014

6

REAL INTEREST RATES ARE LOWER THAN IN THE PAST, 1996-2014

8/21/2014

7

BRAZIL: A NET CREDITOR TO ABROAD(GROSS AND NET EXTERNAL DEBT AS A RATIO TO EXPORTS, 1970-2014)

8/21/2014

8

STRUCTURAL CHALLENGES

• Low growth syndrome• Unfavorable growth-inflation mix• Too high prices• Heavy tax burden• Very expensive social security • Low investment rate• Insufficient infrastructure• Poor education• Closed economy

8/21/2014

9

LOW GDP GROWTH RATES SINCE THE EARLY 1980s

8/21/2014

10

INFLATION-GROWTH MIX IS UNFAVORABLE (2011-14*)

8/21/2014

11

THE MOST EXPENSIVE COUNTRY AMONG THE BRICS

8/21/2014

12

TAX BURDEN IS HEAVY(OECD AND EMERGING MARKETS, 2013)

8/21/2014

13

SOCIAL SECURITY IS A BIG PROBLEM(OECD data for 2005)

8/21/2014

14

INVESTMENT RATE IS LOW AND BNDES OFFERS LITTLE HELP

8/21/2014

15

INFRASTRUCTURE LAGS

8/21/2014

16

EDUCATIONAL LEVELS ARE POOR(PISA 2012 RANKINGS & GRADES, SELECTED COUNTRIES)

8/21/2014

17

ONE OF THE MOST CLOSED COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD• Big economies, big

exporters: – US (1/2), China (2/1), Japan

(3/5), Germany (4/3), France (5/6), UK (6/4)

• Brazil: 7th largest economy in the world, but only the 22nd largest exporter

• Brazil’s GDP, 3.3% of world. Brazil’s exports, 1.3% of world.

• Ratio imports/GDP Brazil: 13%– Lowest value among the 176

countries considered by the World Bank.

• Paradox: Brazil the 4th most preferred destination for foreign direct investment

• Open capital account, closed current account: recipe for impoverishing growth

8/21/2014

18

CURRENT INDUSTRIAL POLICY: MORE PROTECTIONISM

• Response to deindustrialization and external deficits:– Discriminatory manipulation of taxes and import tariffs– Overambitious local content policy– Indiscriminate Buy Brazilian act with 25% preference

margin– Inadequate ‘national champions’ policy by BNDES

8/21/2014

Result is less competitiveness and lower productivity

19

•Reduction of ‘Brazil cost’ (tax, bureaucracy, logistics)

1

•International trade agreements

2

•Replacing high tariffs by a more devalued exchange rate

3

ALTERNATIVE INDUSTRIAL POLICY: INTEGRATION TO INTERNATIONAL PRODUCTIVE CHAINS

8/21/2014

Three Pillars

20

CONCLUSIONS

8/21/2014

Brazil has come a long a way since the mid-1990s

But it needs more savings and investment, better education, and a reduction in the “Brazil cost” of doing business

Opening up to the world would work as a catalyst for the adoption of the reforms that Brazil needs to raise its GDP growth rates

21

THANK YOU

8/21/2014

22

SOURCES FOR THE SLIDES

• S3: Miriam Leitão, Saga Brasileira: A Longa Luta de um Povo por sua Moeda. Record, 2011: 260-261.

• S4: Secretaria de Assuntos Estratégicos (SAE).• S5-S7: MacroEconomic Research Banco Itaú BBA. • S9: Edmar Bacha and Regis Bonelli, “Accounting for the rise and fall of Brazil’s Post-WW-II GDP

growth”, July 2012. Available at: www.iepecdg.com.br. Updated in July 2014 by Regis Bonelli.• S10: The Economist. • S11: IMF apud José Roberto Afonso and Kleber Castro.• S12: Paulo Tafner and Fabio Giambiagi, “Previdência social: uma agenda de reformas”. PPT.

October 2010.• S13: Armando Castelar, ”Desempenho Recente e Perspectivas de Crescimento da Economia

Brasileira”. Presentation to the Seminar: Whither Latin America? Rio de Janeiro: Vargas Foundation, August 9-10, 2012. Updated in July 2014 by Luísa de Azevedo Senra Soares.

• S14: World Economic Forum, apud Financial Times.• S15: OECD, PISA.

8/21/2014