Post on 12-Apr-2017
Dementia and Criminal Justice 1
“In the aftermath of this mental health service and policy shortfall, this is an aging, mental health, and criminal justice crisis that is too large to ignore… It is too costly and inhumane to do nothing about this social problem.”Maschi, T. et al. (2012). Forget me not: Dementia in prison. The Gerontologist, Vol. 0, No. 0, 1—11
Forget me not….
The Impact of Dementiaon the Criminal Justice System
Presenter: Sharon J. Kernen, Ph.D.Comprehensive Forensic & Clinical Neuropsychology Assessments
Dementia and Criminal Justice 3
The cost of increasing dementia Statistics Definition of dementia Cognitive domains: What is lost? Myths Epidemiology Risk factors Variations
Overview
Dementia and Criminal Justice 4
DSM-5 terminology Diagnostic criteria Roles of law enforcement, prosecutors,
defense counsels, and judges Competency to Stand Trial Overflowing prisons Challenges facing prisons Activities of daily living in prison
Cont.
Dementia and Criminal Justice 5
Some favorite beings
Dementia and Criminal Justice
What’s her name again?◦UNM Grad◦Forensic, clinical, and geriatric
neuropsychology◦Seven years in Second Judicial District◦Past history as certified personal trainer,
program manager, and aerobics director working with “Mature Adults”◦Wife, mom and nana, and head dog wrangler
Background:
Dementia and Criminal Justice 7
Yep! There you go…
Dementia and Criminal Justice 8
THE IMPACT
Dementia and Criminal Justice 9
36 million with dementia globally Triple that number in 2050 Approximately affects one in 20 over age 65 and
one-fifth of people over 80 90% eventually require full-time nursing care Average life span: six years post-diagnosis Dementia rate among older prisoners largely
undetermined but estimated at 40,000 in U.S. with increase of ¼ million by 2050.
Where are we going?
Dementia and Criminal Justice 10
Estimated public spending is upward of 202 billion dollars, likely much more costly than care in the community
In 2010 worldwide cost of dementia care in general population estimated at $604 billion. In the U.S. estimated at $157 billion to $215 billion
Annual cost to house older adults in prison is $70,000, 3 times estimated comparable costs for younger inmates
Cost:$$$$$$$
Dementia and Criminal Justice 11
Defined broadly: a syndrome of acquired intellectual impairment produced by brain dysfunction. Often called, “a cruel and unusual disease.”◦Phillipe Pinel used it to refer to intellectual
deterioration and idiocy◦Others called it “senility◦Dementia praecox: Schizophrenia
Dementia is………..
Dementia and Criminal Justice 12
“Dementia” is a loss of mental functions not due to delirium. It comprises of 3 or more deficit areas:◦Memory◦Language◦Perception◦Praxis◦Calculations◦Semantic knowledge◦Executive function◦Personality◦Social behavior◦Emotional awareness or expressionDocumented by mental status assessments
Dementia and Criminal Justice 14
Dementia Myths A global impairment Must impair memory A behavioral disorder Inevitable with aging Cannot have an acute onset An untreatable disorder
Dementia and Criminal Justice 15
Single greatest predictor: Longer lifespan After onset of dementia: 5 to 6 years World Health Organization: 35.6 million
globally will triple by 2050 No quality data on number of prisoners with
dementia
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Dementia and Criminal Justice 16
Alzheimer’s: Most Prevalent
Dementia and Criminal Justice 17
From:Mendez, M. & Cummings,J. (2003). Dementia:A Clinical Approach. Third Edition, p. 9
Overlapping nature of AD
ADFTD
DLBVascular
Dementia and Criminal Justice 18
RISKY BUSINESS
Dementia and Criminal Justice 19
Types of Dementia: Variations
Dementia and Criminal Justice 20
Cortical◦Alzheimer’s◦Frontotemporal◦Asymmetric cortical atrophiesFrontal-subcorticalDementia with Lewy BodiesParkinson’s DiseaseHuntington’s DiseaseProgressive Supranuclear PalsyVascular DementiaCreutz-Jacob…….etc.
Cortical vs. Subcortical
Dementia and Criminal Justice 21
Mild/Major Neurocognitive Disorder due to…..page 602◦Alzheimer’s Disease◦With Lewy Bodies◦Vascular◦Traumatic Brain Injury◦HIV Infection◦Prion Disease◦Parkinson’s Disease◦Huntington’s Disease◦Another medical condition◦Multiple etiologies◦Unspecified
DSM-5: Diagnostic Terminology
Note: The word “dementia”
is never used.
Dementia and Criminal Justice 22
Beyond renaming it “cognitive decline,” you must specify “possible” or “probable” and include the ICD code for due to…..
Page 603 and 604 will help with that.
Confused yet?
Dementia and Criminal Justice 23
Probable Alzheimer’s Disease: diagnosed if there is evidence of a causative Alzheimer’s disease genetic mutation from either genetic testing or family history
Possible Alzheimer’s Disease: diagnosed if there is no evidence of causative Alzheimer’s disease genetic mutation or family history and all three of the following are present:
DSM-5 Definitions – p. 611
Dementia and Criminal Justice 24
(1) Clear evidence of decline in memory and learning
(2) Steadily progressive, gradual decline in cognition, without extended plateaus
(3) No evidence of mixed etiology (i.e., absence of other neurodegenerative of cerebrovascular disease or another neurological or systemic disease or condition likely contributing to cognitive decline
DSM-5 cont.—p. 611
Dementia and Criminal Justice 25
If it were only this simple…..
Dementia and Criminal Justice 26
Executive function has evolved to broadly describe an array of loosely defined control processes responsible for planning, coordinating, sequencing, and monitoring other cognitive skills, enabling goal-directed and future-oriented behavior. Some also place extremely functional activities such as attention, visuospatial function, reasoning, and planning among the tasks to be under the guidance of executive function. In other words, executive function may be described by several related but dissociable processes, including divided attention, updating and monitoring, task shifting, response inhibition, and visuospatial function or the perception of the surrounding world.
What is Executive Function?
Dementia and Criminal Justice 27
Neuropsychological Evaluation, usually on a yearly basis with the first assessment used as a baseline
An initial baseline MRI and repeated when neuropsychological evaluation shows cognitive decline
Tracking Progression
Dementia and Criminal Justice 28
Also includes Early symptoms ofexecutive dysfunc-tion rather than memory
DLB
• Fluctuating cognition• Visual hallucinations• ParkinsonismDSM-5—p.618
Dementia and Criminal Justice 29
Recent memory that affects daily life Difficulty performing regular tasks Problems with language Disorientation of time and space Decreased or poor judgment Problems with complex tasks Misplacing things Changes in mood and behavior Relating to others Loss of initiative
Warning Signs
Dementia and Criminal Justice 30
Dementia and Criminal Justice 31
Dementia and Criminal Justice 32
What happens between early and late stage dementia? Trouble with a capital T Delusions Hallucinations Wandering Physical and verbal aggression Sexually inappropriate Paranoia Sundowning Depression
Dementia and Criminal Justice 33
Dementia and Criminal Justice 34
Aggression, sexual or physical often concludes with interaction with the
police. Police training needs to include more information about behaviors that might be dementia rather than criminal.Criminalization of theSymptoms
Role of Law Enforcement
Dementia and Criminal Justice 35
Deserving of the same treatment given to those with a mental
disorder:a psychiatric evaluation and pharmaceuticalintervention.
Rather than jail…
Dementia and Criminal Justice 36
High rates of various mental health disorders contribute to increased risk for dementia
Premature aging Adverse environment (exceptional stresses) Traumatic brain injury Chronic substance abuse Medication side effects Historically poor diets
Additional Risk Factors for Inmates
Dementia and Criminal Justice 37
Vitamin deficiencies Exposure to violence Inadequate service provision Purpose is punishment Poor quality of life Lower educational status
Cont.
Dementia and Criminal Justice 38
Awareness of the need to raise competency Usually not difficult to get a judge to issue such an
order Try to get them released from jail. If there is no
family to take them in, this may be difficult. When dementia is suspected, considering asking
for approval for an LSR to evaluate with a comprehensive neuropsychological assessment.
Defense Counsel
Dementia and Criminal Justice 39
Need for specialized training on needs and problems present in an elderly defendant
An appreciation of the potential conditions and limitations
Awareness that their impairment may not be obvious Determination of whether the client’s medical
conditions will interfere with physical competence or will stresses of trial exacerbate illnesses and take preventative measures
Defending the Elderly
Dementia and Criminal Justice 40
Presence of dementia may be relevant to conduct during investigation
Confession, consent to search, understanding of Miranda Waiver
Find a way to inform the jury as to why the defendant cannot take the stand
Seek access to prosecution witness’ medical records Be alert to possibility of suicidal ideation Use life expectancy tables and stages of dementia to
demonstrate the relationship of a sentence A sentence of 10 years may equal a life sentence Extremely low rate of recidivism among elderly
Dementia and Criminal Justice 41
Become aware and educated about what constitutes dementia
Other than the case of a habitual offender or violent behavior and if the dementia is well documented by the examiner, first consider stipulating to the diagnosis
Prisoners with dementia often do not remember why they are in prison or how long they have been there.
When treatment becomes punishment Beware of criminalizing the symptom: Offenses
committed in old age are often expressions of the onset of dementia. Pathological shifts can weaken inhibitions, resulting in instances of violence and deviant sexual behavior.
Role of Prosecution
Dementia and Criminal Justice 42
Some prosecutors have taken the media stance to heart and feel that anyone who has been arrested must be prosecuted
Prosecutors also need to be aware of what dementia is and that it is irreversible and that the defendant’s actions have been the result of delusional thinking.
Attitude of being tough on crime (any crime) and prison is the only appropriate
punishment
Yes, sometimes justice is blind
Dementia and Criminal Justice 43
Due to its increasing prevalence, judges need to recognize the symptoms and have an understanding of dementia. They need to opine accordingly when competency is
raised and dementia is documented anddiagnosed.
Role of the Judge
Dementia and Criminal Justice 44
Judges should have an understanding of “criminalizing the symptom”
True for any mental illness, not just dementia An understanding of dementia and its irreversibility and
progressive nature With such an understanding, someone with dementia
would never be sentenced to prison for a non-violent crime
Judges also allow themselves to be driven by media opinion and societal bias
The public traditionally believes that any sentence other than prison is too lenient for serious offenders…many retail stores have a policy that anyone caught shoplifting should go to jail
Dementia and Criminal Justice 45
Moreover some view mental illness as volitional and perhaps a deliberate attempt to avoid punishment
The public’s intolerance of perpetrators, whether mentally ill or not, is demonstrated by a desire for more restrictive detention laws
The statute for mens rea or diminished capacity attenuates some harsh punishments. New Mexico does have such a law.
Innocent until proven guilty does not hold true
The Halls of Justice
Dementia and Criminal Justice 46
New Mexico Criteria for Determining Competence to Stand Trial
The Client must have a factual understanding of the charges and legal proceedings, (2) The Client must also have a rational understanding of the charges and legal proceedings, and (3) The Client must have the ability to assist his or her attorney [State v. Rotherham, 122 N.M. 246, 252, (1996)].
COMPETENCY STATUTE IN NM
Dementia and Criminal Justice 47
Trial DeficitsFailure to understand MirandaLegal chargesPotential penaltiesRoles of court officersPleasPlea bargainingInability to rationally assist attorneyBe self-protective
Geriatric Competency to Stand Trial
Dementia and Criminal Justice 48
Appropriate courtroom behaviorBased on 30 studies average rate of
incompetence is 30% of those evaluatedAverages based on young defendants with
psychiatric disordersLiterature shows that those over 60, 30%
had dementia, 25% psychosis, and 38% personality disorder and 50% deemed incompetent, due to organic impairment
Very little research on geriatric defendants
Dementia and Criminal Justice 49
Study: Geriatric C to ST CST Group IST Group % % p ValueMemory impairment 22.2 95.2 <0.0001Impaired abstraction 25.0 85.7 <0.0001Impaired concentration 27.8 71.4 <0.0001Impaired calculation 19.4 61.9 <0.001Thought process abnormality 5.6 47.6 <0.001Hallucination s 8.3 14.3 <0.74,NSDelusions 11.0 14.3 <1.0, NS
From: Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law: 2002
Dementia and Criminal Justice 50
Prisons Overflowing
Dementia and Criminal Justice 51
The worldwide growth of prison populations has been spearheaded by the U.S. since the 1980s with “tough-on-crime” criminal justice policies
Stricter sentencing laws and longer mandatory prison terms set the upward trend of mass incarceration
In terms of the elderly a more compassionate stance is taking hold, such as the U.S. Compassionate Release Laws and moving away from overly punitive policies that affect older adults.
Other countries have begun to follow suit
Impact of Policy
Dementia and Criminal Justice 52
Challenges faced by prisons….
Dementia and Criminal Justice 53
Dementia is a hidden problem that may show in early stages as depression, aggression, and anxiety and they go unnoticed
Prison systems too large to devote the time to diagnose early dementia effectively
Highly regimented nature of prison life determines that mental health issues are easily missed or ignored
Older offenders reluctant to seek attention or report changes in mood, as many have been raised with a more stoic attitude and are therefore non-medicated
Mental health services directed toward younger more vocal inmates
Dementia and Criminal Justice 54
Lack of comprehensive screening policies for dementia
Medical screenings are performed but they are not designed to detect issues associated with aging, i.e., cognitive impairment
Healthcare practitioners in the community also lack proper tools and disregard standardized scoring
Identifying dementia further encumbered by deficiencies in staff training and health care
Unawareness of need to conduct regular mental health checks on older prisoners whose symptoms may fluctuate
Dementia and Criminal Justice 55
Repeated requests for healthcare units to train and oversee the delivery of care for older detainees have gone unheeded
COs are in best position to notice changes in mood or behavior but lack required skills
Improved communication between security and mental health staff, including officer observations in functional evaluations is a need
Aims of incarceration, whether punitive or rehabilitative hold little meaning for the inmate with dementia.
Dementia and Criminal Justice 56
Research on the experiences of older people in prison is replete with examples of detainees
oblivious to their surroundings and mentally incapable of participating in courses required for release even in the institutions that provide compassionate release There are major operational implications for
facilities lacking knowledge, tools and resources to effectively manage, ensuring more older inmates will be left “vegetating”
Dementia and Criminal Justice 57
Culture of Victimization Aggression Violence Bullying Mocking Provoking Sexual
Dementia and Criminal Justice 58
Excessive Punishments
Dementia and Criminal Justice 59
Dementia and Criminal Justice 60
Dementia and Criminal Justice 61
Inmates with dementia: Prison Statistics
Excessive Representation of Dementia in Prisons
Dementia and Criminal Justice 62
Basic physical needs◦Grooming and personal hygiene◦Dressing◦Toileting/Continence◦Transferring◦Ambulating◦Eating
Activities of Daily Living (ADLs)Functional Skills
Dementia and Criminal Justice 63
Categorized separately from ADLs Managing finances Managing medications Appointments DrivingADLs are more preserved and impairment shows up in later stages, dependent on physical functioningIADLs performance is more sensitive to early cognitive decline
Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADLS)Complex Activities Related to Independent Living
Dementia and Criminal Justice 64
Prison Activities of Daily Living
Dementia and Criminal Justice 65
Restructure of the environment to reduce the potential for confusion and agitation◦Good lighting◦Quiet surroundings◦Contrasting colors to delineate bathrooms
and other accessibility needs◦Remove mirrors
Modifications for Impaired Prisoners
Dementia and Criminal Justice 66
◦Simple signage including pictures with words◦Handrails◦Wheelchair accessible showers◦Locked units◦Absence of rugs or carpeting with edges◦Consistent daily routines◦Hearing aids◦Eyeglasses◦Clothing: velcro and elastic designs
Dementia and Criminal Justice 67
Dropping to the floor for alarms Standing for head counts Ambulating to dining hall Hearing orders from staff Climbing up and down: top bunkStaff must be trained that inability to perform does not equal defiance but may be indication of disease
PADLs: Life in Prison with Dementia
Dementia and Criminal Justice 68
Inability to perform PADLs leaves the prisoner vulnerable to harsh punishment or segregation
Violation of facility rules may result in solitary confinement, which further compromises their physical and mental well-being
Consequences
Dementia and Criminal Justice 69
Used to be sociable, now withdrawn Some memory lapses Misplacing items Mood changes Temperamental Easily agitated Confusion
Overlooked Early Symptoms
Dementia and Criminal Justice 70
Staff training for those who see individuals frequently◦Communications◦Take their perspective seriously◦Never try to argue them out of delusions or confusion◦Non-judgmental ◦Patience, discipline, and flexibility◦No multi-step directions◦Support autonomy: keep choices simple and
manageable
SOLUTIONS
Dementia and Criminal Justice 71
May need to re-introduce self each time Make sure you have their full attention Talk slowly, use gestures, and allow time to process Try not to initiate a behavioral crisis Policy changes:◦Compassionate Release Programs◦Institute programs where other compatible
prisoners can be their gentle guide◦Do not incarcerate individuals with dementia for
non-violent crimes◦Plan for older prisoners (50+) to have regular
checkups: early detection is key
Dementia and Criminal Justice 72
Prison Nursing Care
Dementia and Criminal Justice 73
Alternative Placement Area (APA): A designated living area for inmates who have special housing designation and who meet specified mental health criteria◦Mental Health Treatment Center: only at CNMCF and from
description, this would be the only likely placement for later stages of dementia
◦Rounds: Visits by Behavioral health clinician to provide brief conversation, discussion, and receive requests for behavioral health services
◦Well-Being Checks: Designed to monitor for any mental health deterioration
Dementia or any special needs for same is not mentionedThe legal mandate for prisoner healthcare also does not
mention providing for special geriatric needs
NM PRISON POLICIES
Dementia and Criminal Justice 74
Released prisoners without family may be helplessly lost: Programs need to be in place that will help guide them appropriately
Nursing homes (in NM) will not take a convicted felon
More group homes with trained staff are a must: some will need 24/7 supervision
Financially, it will eventually be less expensive than caring for them in prison
Community Challenges…
Dementia and Criminal Justice 75
Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any further questions:
505-263-8055kershar@comcast.netdr.s.kernen@gmail.com
505-263-8055
…and as always my best regards