Post on 13-Oct-2020
SMUNC Historical Security Council (HSC)
Background Guide –
Yalta Conference4-11 February 1945
Letter from the Chair
Dear delegates,
Welcome to the HSC Yalta Conference committee! My name is Jessica Lee and I will
be your Crisis Director throughout the day of the conference. We have plenty of exciting
issues prepared for you and we cannot wait to see you there!
To begin, here’s a little about myself. I am a Grade 9 student in SUIS Gubei Campus,
currently taking First Language English & Chinese, Second Language German, Coordinated
Science, Business, and History for my IGCSEs. As one of the active students in my school, I
help organise parties, charity events, and I am currently the team captain of the school touch
rugby team. In my spare time, I find myself enjoying oil painting, however nothing can be
compared to my passion for TV series.
I have a huge fervency towards History and participating in the HSC committee adds
a bonus to the knowledge I have in History. As I understand the function of HSC and have a
great passion for it, I believe under the management from Erin and myself, this will be
nothing else but an extraordinary committee.
This is my second MUN conference, my first being ILMUNC China IV in October
this year. As soon as I discovered my interest in MUN, I decided take the role as chair of
SMUNC. I look forward to participate in the discussion with every one of you. I believe this
committee would be amazing with your insightful contribution.
Jessica Lee
1
Letter from the Chair
Dear delegates,
Welcome to SMUNC! It is my distinct pleasure to introduce you to the Historical
Security Council at the very first session of SUIS Gubei Model United Nations. My name is
Erin Um and I will be your chair for this dynamic paced committee, which I can assure you is
one of the most exciting and challenging committees in MUN.
I am currently in grade 10 at Shanghai United International School studying business,
geography and additional maths. I'm originally from Korea, but I have been fortunate enough
to have extensive experience abroad at my early age, also to spend half of my life in Shanghai
and more than half of my school years here at SUIS. Outside of school, I find myself
enjoying reading, watching TV shows or just spending time with friends very much. At
school, my interests fall under MUN. My involvement in MUN started recently through
joining our school's MUN club at the beginning of this year and attending ILMUNC CHINA
2014. At the conference, the best committee I could have possibly been in was brought
forward to me along with the best chairs I could ask for, the HSC, and thus had a very
memorable experience. Along with your Crisis director, Jessica Lee, we hope we can share
the thrilling experience we had through this conference.
Our committee will be competitive and intense as there will be constant volatile crisis
occurring that each of you will have respond to by taking diplomatic actions; actions that may
be followed by significant repercussions. I am very excited to facilitate interesting
discussions in HSC where we would like to see you actively engage in. In the meantime, if
you have any questions prior to conference, please don't hesitate in contacting me at
suis.gubei.mun.director@gmail.com .
I look forward to seeing you guys in December and get to know you all!
Erin Um
2
Historical Background
The Seeds of War
The Yalta Conference, which is the topic of HSC, is not the first time a conference
was held to discuss what was to be done with the postwar world. To make the decision at
Yalta, delegates must go back and examine the mistakes made at the Paris Peace Conference
in 1919 after the First World War.
In 1919, Woodrow Wilson (president of the USA), Georges Clemenceau (French
Prime Minister), and David Lloyd George (British Prime Minister), issued the Treaty of
Versailles, which was signed by the ‘November Criminals’ as the German people called
them. The terms of the treaty were a huge blow to the people of Germany, who called it a
‘diktat’, which meant dictated peace. They were forced to accept ‘War Guilt’, reduce their
army to 100,000 men, the loss of their important industrial areas such as the Saar, the
Sudetenland and the Polish Corridor which split their country apart, and pay 6,600 million
pounds in reparations. The German public could not accept the ‘War Guilt’ clause. Count
Brockdorff-Rantzan, the head of German delegates in Versailles said, “…We do strongly
deny that Germany, whose people felt they were fighting a war of defense, should be forced to
accept sole responsibility.” Being blamed for starting a defensive war also led great hatred
toward the Allies who forced them to accept the blame. Also, the aftermath of the Great War
crippled Germany’s economy; the reparations term furthermore caused mass poverty with
mass unemployment and hyperinflation. This made the German people angry because the
Allies had forced them to pay for a war they did not believe they started when they barely had
money for themselves. Princess Bleucher, an English woman married to a member of the
German royal family wrote in 1920: Over and Over I hear the same refrain “We shall hate
our conquerors with a hatred that will only cease when the day of our revenge comes.” This
desire in Germany unified them, they may not have believed in everything Hitler did, but
they believed in one thing, like the Deutsche Zeitung (German news) said the day the treaty
was signed: “Do not forget it! The German people will, with unceasing labour, press forward
to reconquer the place among the nations to which it is entitled.”
3
Furthermore, the Treaty also stripped Germany of its eastern territories such as the
Polish Corridor and West Prussia, which were mainly German populated, Which, in turn,
would have given Germany its justification to reclaim those territories in war. Sir Michael
Howard of Yale University said, “Hitler or no Hitler, they would have wanted to reverse the
judgment which they regarded as a totally unfair one; and above all, restore their frontiers in
Eastern Europe which they felt had been taken away quite unjustly.” The Treaty of Versailles
left Germany wanting to reverse its terms and take revenge on those that forced them to
accept it, which eventually led to the Second World War.
The League of Nations
The League of Nations was the predecessor of the United Nations, when discussing
and planning the UN at Yalta, the delegate must be aware of the reasons why the League
failed to prevent the Second World War.
The failures of the League of Nations made it easier for Nazi Germany to grow
powerful and achieve its objectives. In 1931-32, the League allowed Japan to take over
Manchuria and in 1935-36 Italy to take over Abyssinia while Hitler watched. This gave Hitler
the idea the he could do the same without opposition. If the League had allowed Japan and
Italy to commit blatant aggression with no consequence, why shouldn't they let Hitler?
Historian JR Western said, “The crises of 1935-6 were fatal to the League…it began the
emotional preparation among the democracies for the Second World War.”
Appeasement & the Nazi-Soviet Pact
The policy of appeasement was another cause of the outbreak of the Second World
War. At Yalta, the Western Allies would be determined not the repeat the mistake of
appeasing dictators as they had done with Adolf Hitler of Nazi Germany, as this led to him
continuously getting what he wanted and eventually led to the outbreak of war. This would
4
change their attitude towards Joseph Stalin, the dictator of the USSR. The Nazi-Soviet Pact
was also a good example of how relations between the Soviet Union and the West were.
The Nazi-Soviet Pact of 1939 was a world shocking agreement that resulted in
Germany’s invasion of Poland, both invasions soon led to full scale war across Europe. The
Nazi-Soviet Pact was a non-aggression pact signed by Stalin and Hitler as well as a secret
agreement to divide Poland between them. This pact between these ideological arch enemies
caused the Second World War because Hitler was unwilling to risk war over Poland unless he
could avoid the possibility a two-front war which was one of the reasons for Germany’s
defeat in the First World War. With the Nazi-Soviet Pact signed that he knew that Germany
was safe from a war on the Eastern Front (at least at the time being), which allowed him to
start a war without worrying about the Eastern Front.
The World at War
5
The Second World War was a global war generally said to have lasted from 1939 to
1945, though conflicts had began in Asia and other regions prior to 1939. It was the deadliest
conflict ever with an estimate of around 50 to 85 million fatalities. Over 30 countries were
involved and they split into the Allies and the Axis. The Allied powers included the United
States of America, the United Kingdom and the British Commonwealth, France, China,
Poland, and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. The Axis powers emerged from the
Anti-Comintern Pact between Nazi Germany and Japan and the ‘Rome-Berlin Axis’, which
led to the Tripartite Pact between Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy, and Imperial Japan.
In the first couple of years, the Axis powers were victorious whilst the Allies suffered
defeat after defeat in all corners of the world. The war began in Europe on the 1st September
1939 when Germany invaded Poland. Poland soon fell as the Soviets invaded from the east.
After the fall of Poland, Britain and France declared war on Germany. On the 10th May 1940,
Germany attacked through Belgium and the Netherlands, which quickly fell to Wehrmacht’s
Blitzkrieg tactics. France fell after six weeks and the British were forced to evacuate
mainland Europe from Dunkirk. In 1941, Hitler launched Operation Barbarossa. 3 million
soldiers poured over the border into the USSR. In the first three months, the Soviets lost their
entire air and tank force and suffered 4 million casualties. By September 1941, the Germans
had laid siege to Leningrad and almost reached Moscow. In the Far East, Japan had already
launched a full-scale invasion of China in 1937, and on the 7th December 1941, Japan
bombed the American naval base in Pearl Harbour. By 1942, the Japanese forces had reached
Burma and were advancing into India, and in the south their submarines attacked Sydney.
American, British and Commonwealth forces were retreating everywhere.
The Atlantic Charter
The Atlantic Charter was a pivotal policy statement issued on 4th August 1941 that
defined the Allied goals for the post-war world. It was drafted by British Prime Minister
Winston Churchill and President Franklin D. Roosevelt, and later agreed to by all the Allies.
The Charter stated the ideal goals of the war: no territorial aggrandizement; no territorial
changes made against the wishes of the people; restoration of self-government to those
6
deprived of it; reduction of trade restrictions; global cooperation to secure better economic
and social conditions for all; freedom from fear and want; freedom of the seas; and
abandonment of the use of force, as well as disarmament of aggressor nations. In the
‘Declaration by United Nations’ of 1 January 1942, the Allies of World War II pledged
adherence to this charter's principles.
The Casablanca Conference
The Casablanca Conference was held on 14-24 January 1943 in Casablanca,
Morocco, between British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, American President Franklin
D. Roosevelt, and Generals Charles de Gaulle and Henri Giraud, representing the French
resistance forces. Soviet leader Joseph Stalin didn’t attend, as he believed the on-going battle
in Stalingrad needed his presence. The Casablanca Declaration announced the Allied powers
would not accept anything less than the unconditional surrender of the Axis powers.
American President Roosevelt brought the term forward, and in February 12, 1943 he said the
following: “we mean no harm to the common people of the Axis nations. But we do mean to
impose punishment and retribution upon their guilty, barbaric leaders”.
However, many historians believe that behind the scenes, the United States and
Britain were not in complete agreement about seeing the war fought until Germany were
destroyed. According to some historians, German resistance forces and anti-Nazi government
officials were working with the British intelligence to remove Hitler from power and instead
negotiate a peace treaty with the Allies. However, Roosevelt was not interested and proposed
unconditional surrender. Former U.S. ambassador Charles Bohlen believe that Roosevelt
introduced the term to keep Soviet Union fighting with Germany in the east, therefore
diminishing valuable German munitions and troops and also “to prevent Stalin from
negotiating a separate peace with Nazi regime”.
There was also disagreement between how the Allies were to invade mainland
Europe. Stalin was pressing the Western Allies to open a new front in France to take pressure
off the Russians. Roosevelt, with advice from General George Marshall, proposed a cross-
7
channel invasion of France. However, Churchill favoured an Allied invasion of Sicily. The
British thought that by attacking Italy, German reserves would be drawn in Italy were poor
transportation would decrease their mobility. Also, this meant when the Allies eventually
crossed the channel, the Germans would be weakened by many more months of fighting the
Russians. Roosevelt, on the other hand, was mainly focused on the Pacific war. He blamed
the British for not participating enough in the Pacific war. The two leaders made a
compromise. Roosevelt agreed to Churchill’s strategy for Europe, while Churchill promised
to put more British troops and resources to the Pacific war.
At the Casablanca conference the United States and Britain disagreed on many issues.
The USA-Britain relationship was the strongest compared to any relationships either country
had with the USSR. However, they didn’t agree upon that much and they both needed to gain
something from an agreement. Another factor that is clear is that the United Kingdom even
when they were allied with the Soviet Union, still considered the Soviet Union and
communism to be a major threat.
The Cairo Conference
The Cairo Conference was held on 22-26 November 1943 in Cairo, Egypt. The Cairo
Conference was about the position against Japan during World War II and what to do with
post-war Asia. Participants in the Conference were President Franklin D. Roosevelt, Prime
Minister Winston Churchill, and Generalissimo Chiang-Kai-shek of the Republic of China.
Joseph Stalin did not participate, as he was not interested in causing unnecessary friction and
tension between the Soviet Union and Japan, especially considering that Chiang Kai-shek
was attending the Cairo Conference. The Allies issued the Cairo Declaration was declared on
27th November 1943:
“The Three Great Allies are fighting this war to restrain and punish the aggression of
Japan. They covet no gain for themselves and have no thought of territorial expansion. It is
their purpose that Japan shall be stripped of all the islands in the Pacific which she has
seized or occupied since the beginning of the first World War in 1914, and that all the
8
territories Japan has stolen from the Chinese, such as Manchuria, Formosa, and The
Pescadores, shall be restored to the Republic of China. Japan will also be expelled from all
other territories which she has taken by violence and greed. The aforesaid three great
powers, mindful of the enslavement of the people of Korea, are determined that in due course
Korea shall become free and independent.
With these objects in view the three Allies, in harmony with those of the United
Nations at war with Japan, will continue to persevere in the serious and prolonged
operations necessary to procure the unconditional surrender of Japan.”
The Tehran Conference
The first conference between the Big Three – Britain, the USA, and the USSR, was
held in Tehran, Iran in November 1943. The leaders present were American President
Roosevelt, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin, the leader of the
USSR. At the time of the conference, the Red Army had defeated the Germans and captured
300,000 prisoners at Stalingrad and was now pushing the Germans into retreat. The British
and Americans had expelled Germans from North Africa and invaded Fascist Italy. However,
the USA and Britain have yet to open a second front in Western Europe to the frustration of
Stalin, who had been demanding an invasion of France for some time already. In the pacific,
the war against Japan had entered the brutal ‘island hoping’ phase.
At Tehran, the Allies had very different views and failed to come to a decision about
what to do with Germany after the fall of the Nazis. This difference was because of different
wartime experiences with Germany, the fear of repeating the mistakes of the Treaty of
Versailles, and their different ideologies. However, they confirmed again that they would not
accept any terms asides from the unconditional surrender of Nazi Germany and agreed that
they needed to weaken postwar Germany. There were also major disagreements about Poland
and Eastern Europe. Stalin wanted to keep the territories in had annexed in 1939, which
included the Baltic States and parts of Finland, and Poland. Especially Poland, which Stalin
saw as a traditional pathway armies invading Russia. The USA and Britain reluctantly agreed
though this was against the 1941 ‘Atlantic Charter’ agreement. Another disagreement was
Japan. The USA wanted the USSR to entre the war against Japan and open a second front in
9
the Pacific war like Stalin wanted them to do in France. However the USSR was wanted to
avoid a war with the Axis in both the west and east of the country. They had also signed a
Neutrality Pact with Japan, which meant going to war in the east would violate the terms.
On the positive side, although all three of the leaders arrived with differing objectives,
they managed to come to some agreements. The USA and Britain agreed to the opening of a
second front against Nazi Germany by the Western Allies. The conference also addressed
relations between the Allies and Turkey, operations in Yugoslavia and against Japan as well
as the envisaged post-war settlement. The Tehran Conferences resulted in the decisions:
1. The Yugoslav Partisans will be supported by Allied supplies and equipment.
2. It would be desirable if Turkey should join the war with the Allies.
3. If Turkey should be at war with Germany, and as a result Bulgaria declares war on
Turkey, the Soviet Union would immediately be at war with Bulgaria.
4. The cross-channel invasion of France would be launched in May 1944.
At Tehran, Roosevelt and Stalin seemed to get along reasonably well. Roosevelt was
an idealist and on his return to the USA he publicly said in a radio broadcast, “I got along
fine with Marshal Stalin…I believe that we are going to get along very well with him and the
Russian people…” Churchill on the other hand did not trust Stalin, and Stalin constantly
teased Churchill at Tehran. For example, Stalin proposed executing 50,000–100,000 German
officers so that Germany could not plan another war. Churchill was outraged and denounced
“the cold blooded execution of soldiers who fought for their country.” He stormed out of the
room, but was brought back in by Stalin who said he was joking. Churchill was glad Stalin
had relented, but thought Stalin was testing the waters. Roosevelt hoped to be the mediator
between Stalin and Churchill. He also seemed to believe that the British Imperialism and the
desire of other Europeans to reclaim and expanded their empires as they have done after the
First World War as a more serious problem than the growing Soviet strength. Roosevelt said
to Stanisław Mikołajczyk, the leader of the Polish government-in-exile, “…one thing I am
certain, Stalin is not an imperialist.”
10
Current Situation
Yalta Conference 1945
It is the 4th February 1945; the War is almost over. It is clear that it wouldn’t be long
before the fall of Nazi Germany, so the Allies will meet once again to discuss what was to be
done with Europe and the world after Germany’s surrender, this time at Yalta, in southern
Ukraine.
The Axis powers are retreating in all areas of the world. Germany was now on the
verge of defeat. A second front in Normandy had finally been opened in 1944. The Red Army
had driven the Germans out of Eastern Europe, entering Warsaw, the capital of Poland on the
17th January, and was ready to invade Germany itself. The Americans and British had
liberated France and Belgium, and were now ready to attack Germany from the west. As the
Red Army, the came across Nazi concentration and death camps and the horrors were
revealed to the public. Japan was still fighting in the East, but the USA, Britain, and Australia
were pushing them back to their homeland.
The war had changed the balance of power in the world. In 1945, the ‘Old Powers’
that had been an important influence in international affairs in the 1930s, that is Britain and
France, had been demoted by the war to second rank powers because of their inability to
defeat Germany. France had been smashed and occupied and was only just liberated.
Britain’s economy had been exhausted and had to depend on the world’s richest country – the
USA to support it throughout the war. However, compared to the French, the British were
still relatively powerful, with a strong navy and the support of the Commonwealth. The
USSR and the USA emerge from the war as the world’s two superpowers. The USSR and the
USA were the only countries large enough, rich enough, and strong enough to exercise real
international influence and leadership, and thus they will be the main powers at Yalta, closely
followed by Britain ,whilst the other countries will have far less influence.
11
Despite their wartime alliance, the USA, Britain, and the USSR (the Big Three) had
many differences. Ideologically, they were completely different. The USA and Britain were
democratic capitalist countries whereas the USSR was a one-party Communist state. Before
the war, America experienced a period known as ‘The Red Scare’, red being the colour of the
Communists. Opinion polls before the war showed that Americans trusted Communists less
than Nazis. Britain shared a similar distaste for Communism, especially their current leader
Winston Churchill, who was a member of the right-winged Conservative party. Fear of
Communism was one of the reasons why the British appeased Hitler before the war; they
wanted a strong, right-winged Germany to be a buffer against Communism. The Soviets also
wouldn’t have forgotten that during the Russian Civil War, the British and the Americans had
intervened and fought against the Communists, who were named the Bolsheviks at that time.
As the war is coming to an end, differences and distrust between the USSR and the Western
Allies had started to emerge again.
The Grand Alliance was formed when the Nazis launched Operation Barbarossa on
the USSR, both Churchill and Roosevelt gave aid to the Soviet Union. However, this did not
change how the USSR and Communism was seen in the West, especially in Britain. Whilst
Roosevelt and Stalin got on relatively well, there was a mutual suspicion between Churchill
and Stalin. During the war, Stalin had been frustrated that the Western Allies delayed the
opening of a new front in Europe many times. The Red Army was taking on 85% of
Wehrmacht’s troops and Stalin wanted a new front in France to take pressure off the
Russians. Stalin became suspicious that they were deliberately delaying the attack in hope of
seeing the USSR permanently weakened by the relentless German war machine.
12
Key Issues to Consider
Germany
It was clear that Germany would soon be taken over from both east and west. The Big
Three will need to decide what was to happen to post-war Germany. This is the second time
Germany had been the main aggressor in a World War and they left huge amounts of
destruction in Europe. The Allies will have to make decision about punishments and
reparations, which would mainly be paid to the Soviet Union because it had suffered the
worst in the war, with more than 20 million casualties. Joseph Stalin, leader of the USSR, is
therefore concerned about the future security of the USSR and so wants to cripple Germany,
perhaps splitting it up into smaller nations like the French President wanted in 1919, and
extract heavy reparations that were mainly given to the USSR. However, when making
decisions for Germany, the Allies must remember and consider the mistakes of the Treaty of
Versailles at the end of the First World War. The harsh Treaty of Versailles led to the rise of
Nazi Germany and German aggression during the Second World War. How Germany was to
be punished and what was to be done to its territory will be one of the main topics at Yalta.
Also, as the Allies closed in on Germany, they discovered concentration and death
camps that the retreating Germans hastily tried to destroy. The Nazis and their collaborators
committed horrifying atrocities in the war. The Holocaust was the largest genocide of the 20th
century in which approximately 6 million Jews were killed under the command of Hitler and
the Nazi. This genocide was part of a broader aggregate of oppression and killings of various
ethnic and political groups in Europe by the Nazis. Non-Jewish victims include Gypsies,
Poles, communists, homosexuals, Soviet POWs, and the mentally and physically disabled.
The survivors of the Holocaust found themselves far away from their homes as they had been
transported to camps. The Allies therefore need to decide on how to get the dislocated people
back home. Many of the war criminals responsible for the genocide were fleeing Europe in
fear of Allied punishments. The war criminals had ended up in far away countries, many in
South American countries like Argentina, and so needed to be brought to justice. Many
people were horrified by the war crimes committed by the Germans, especially the Holocaust
13
and on the Eastern Front where the Germans fought a ‘war of extermination’ and completely
ignored the rules of warfare.
Poland & Eastern Europe
By February 1945, most of Eastern Europe had been liberated and occupied by the
Red Army, which meant that the Soviet Union is effectively in control. The status of Poland
is one of many disagreements. Throughout history, Poland had served as a historical corridor
for forces attempting to invade Russia. Stalin, concerned about the future security of the
USSR, therefore wanted Poland and other Eastern European countries such as Finland and
Romania, which previously had governments hostile to the USSR, to be under the ‘Soviet
sphere of influence’ and have governments loyal and friendly to the USSR. On 1st of January
1945, Stalin had installed the Soviet sponsored Provisional Government of Republic of
Poland (RTRP) in the Polish territories under the occupation of the Red Army. This caused
protests from the Polish government-in-exile in London, who claimed that the Soviet Union
had “taken over the sovereign political rights of the Polish nation.” The Polish government-
in-exile was formed in the aftermath of the annexation of Poland by the USSR and Nazi
Germany in 1939, and fought with the Allies in Europe, Africa, and the Middle East during
the Second World War. The governments of the United States and Great Britain, who
supported the Polish government in exile, also issued formal protest.
The Polish government-in-exile was not recognized by the Soviet Union and the
RTRP, the self-proclaimed legitimate government of Poland. Winston Churchill, aware of the
Soviet one-party system and a strong supporter of the Polish government-in-exile, wanted
free elections and democratic governments in Eastern and Central Europe, especially Poland.
However, Joseph Stalin conveyed his intention to the Western Allies that Eastern Europe was
under the control of the Soviet Union and that he intended for it to remain that way.
In addition, the Soviet Union wanted to keep the territory of eastern Poland they had
already annexed in 1939. This was agreed at Tehran but the borders were decided yet. Even
though Poland was to be compensated with German territory, the Western Allies were still
extremely unhappy about it. Also, the territory that the USSR intended to keep had million of
14
Poles living there. Stanisław Mikołajczyk, the leader of the Polish government-in-exile,
would not compromise on the question of Poland's sovereignty over her pre-war territories
and insisted on stopping Stalin from setting up a Communist government in post-war Poland.
Greece
After the Germans left, there were two rival groups in Greece that wanted to rule the
country. The Communists wanted to turn it into a Soviet republic while the Monarchists
wanted the return of the King of Greece. If it became a Soviet republic, Greece would be
likely to come under the influence and control of the USSR. However, Greece was vital to
Britain, because it gave the Royal Navy control of the Mediterranean Sea, and thus, control of
the Suez Canal. This meant that Greece would be one of Britain’s priorities as the Suez Canal
was an essential waterway for Britain because it was the shortest route for ships to get to and
from Britain and its Commonwealth countries such as India and Australia, where it got most
of its essential resources. The only other route is to sail around Africa, which would delay the
ships for months. For the USSR and USA, Greece was of a lesser importance, as they did not
rely on the Suez Canal or have interests in the Mediterranean.
The Empire of Japan
The war against Japan was costing USA and Britain massive casualties. However the
USSR was not in the war with Japan, and its entrance would make take pressure of the British
and American forces. Therefore, the USA had been pressuring the USSR to join the war
against Japan for sometime already. However, going to war with Japan would mean a double
fronted war for the USSR, which they did not want to risk. Also, the Soviet Union had signed
the Soviet-Japanese Neutrality pact in 1941, which mean that going to war with Japan would
be to violate the Pact. The following picture is a part of the Neutrality pact:
15
The French and Dutch colonies in South East Asia were annexed by Japan in war. The
USA was against imperialism did not want theses territories to be returned to colonial rule,
despite the desire of the Europeans. However, the Japanese left them in destruction and it is
likely there will be problems in the aftermath of the War.
The United Nations
As a result of the failure of the League of Nation, Roosevelt is now firmly against the
policy of Isolation and will commit the USA in an new international body – the United
Nations, and the United Nation Security Council will maintain peace after the war. One of the
main reasons why the League of Nations failed to stop Japan and Italy during its the
Manchurian and Abyssinian crisis was because the League was weak – it did not have its own
army, and some of the major powers in the world (USA, USSR) were not in the League (The
USA was following the policy of Isolation and the USSR was not invited until 1934 because
it was Communist). This meant that the League lacked the international influence it could
have had. Also, the Permanent Members of the League – Britain, France, Italy, and Japan,
were too worried about their own problems at home to put effort and money into the League
of Nations. The Allies therefore needed to discuss the future Security Council and how the
United Nations would be structured to avoid the mistakes of the League of Nations.
16
Bloc Positions
USSR
By the time of the Conference, Red Army Marshal Georgy Zhukov’s forces were only
65 km from Berlin; the Soviets had completely occupied Poland, Romania, Greece, and most
of Eastern Europe with a standing army three times larger than the Allied forces in the West.
During the war, the Red Army had become the world’s strongest land force and it had played
a huge role in the war against Germany – more than 80% of Germany’s armed forces fought
on the Eastern Front. This meant that Stalin felt that he was in a strong position to dictate the
terms at Yalta. Poland was one of the main topics on the Soviet agenda. Stalin wanted to keep
the territory of Poland that the USSR annexed in 1939. Stalin had installed the Soviet
sponsored Provisional Government of Republic of Poland (RTRP) in the Polish territories
under the occupation of the Red Army, and would want to make Poland a Communist
satellite state of the USSR. The Soviet Union strongly opposed the idea of bringing back the
Polish government-in-exile, which was hostile towards the USSR. The same applies for the
rest of Eastern Europe; Stalin wished to create a ‘Soviet sphere of influence’ in the east for
the future security of the USSR as it had suffered terribly in the war.
17
Stalin wanted a large share of German reparations and territory to be for the USSR, as
the Soviet Union suffered more casualties than any other country. The USSR also wanted
Germany to become socialist and friendly to the Soviet Union, since this was not the first
time Germany had become a serious threat to the security of the USSR. Stalin also wanted
more Soviet voices to be added to the UN, and other Soviet Republics would be some of his
choices. Stalin also had interests in China where the Mao Zedong led Communist Party of
China was only keeping a temporary peace with the Republic of China. The USSR and Japan
have had interests in the Manchurian railway and Port Arthur throughout history. Port Arthur
is especially important to the USSR because its only other port in east of Russia is frozen 6
months every winter, and it was one of the reasons the Russo-Japanese war of 1905 was
fought. The USSR had been reluctant to join the war against Japan; Stalin wanted to avoid a
double fronted war and also wanted a reward of Japanese territory if the USSR was to go to
war with Japan.
USA
Before the war, America had followed the policy of Isolation – keeping out of
European and world affairs. However, the USA had learnt a lesson by the 1940s. Franklin D.
Roosevelt, President of the United States, was determined not to repeat the mistakes before
the Second World War, and the USA had also shown that it was the world’s most powerful
air force during the world and had emerged as one of the only countries that weren’t left in
destruction by the war, which meant that they had the strongest economy. Therefore the USA
will come to Yalta as one of the world’s two superpowers and attempt to exercise
international leadership. The ideology of the USA was completely different from the Soviet
Union. The USA would not approve of Stalin’s plans for Poland and Eastern Europe, and
would ask for democracy and free elections in countries liberated from Axis control.
However Franklin D. Roosevelt, the president of the USA, was considered pro-
Russian compared to most Westerners at the time. In the Tehran conference, Churchill
warned of potential domination by a Stalin dictatorship over Eastern Europe, Roosevelt
responded, “I just have a hunch that Stalin is not that kind of a man. … I think that if I give
him everything I possibly can and ask for nothing from him in return, noblesse oblige, he
18
won't try to annex anything and will work with me for a world of democracy and peace.” The
USA was suffering heavy casualties in the war against Japan, so they wanted the USSR to
join the war against Japan. Roosevelt also knew that the USSR wanted something in return to
break their pact with Japan. Roosevelt, quite like Woodrow Wilson two decades ago, is
promoting the idea of an international body, however this time the USA will be committed to
joining.
The USA also wanted the USSR to join the war against Japan, as it was also an Axis
power that the Allies were fighting and it wasn’t fair that the USA, Britain, Australia and
other members of the Commonwealth were taking on the Japanese and Germany whilst the
USSR was only fighting Germany, even if it was playing the largest role in the European war.
Japanese resistance was fanatically fierce so Roosevelt wanted to end the war as quickly as
possible with fewer American casualties.
Britain
Britain had been significantly weakened by the war and had to rely on economic
support from the USA, which had no intention of helping Britain prop-up its empire in the
aftermath of the war. However, Britain and the USA shared a common objective of allowing
democracy and free elections in countries liberated from German control, and Churchill a
good relationship with Roosevelt. Churchill feared that Roosevelt was too pro-Russian, and
was concerned that Stalin would try to set up Communist governments in countries in Eastern
Europe. Churchill was upset that Stalin had set up a Soviet styled Provisional Government in
Poland, and supported the Polish government in exile. Churchill and Stalin had a strained
relationship. Despite making an alliance with Stalin when the Nazis invaded the USSR in
1941, Churchill displayed his dislike for the Soviet leader by saying, “If Hitler invaded Hell,
I would make at least favourable reference to the Devil in the House of Commons.” Britain’s
main interest was its empire, and the Suez Canal was important in connecting them. Churchill
had a strong desire to prevent a communist take over in Greece, and had already sent British
troops into Greece to secure British interests.
19
Republic of China
Chiang Kai-shek and his Nationalist Party currently rule the Republic of China.
Chiang Kai-shek did not want to be subordinate to either the United States or the Soviet
Union but jockeyed for room between the two and wanted to get the most out of the Soviet
Union and the Americans without taking sides. China had suffered terribly during the
Japanese invasion; the Nanking Massacre is a famous example of the atrocities of the
Japanese. China had also lost many territories such as Manchuria to Japan. Chiang Kai-shek
would want to see all Chinese territories returned to China. He was also aware of the
possibility of the Soviets supporting the Chinese Communist Party led by Mao Zedong.
Provisional Government of the Republic of Poland
The Provisional Government of the Republic of Poland (RTRP)’s was created to
succeed the previous government formed in 1944, called the Committee of National
Liberation, also known as the Lublin Committee as it was based in Lublin. After Warsaw was
liberated, the Lublin Committee was moved to Warsaw and became the RTRP. Its chair is
Edward Osóbka-Morawski. The Deputy Prime Ministers of the RTRP is Władysław
Gomułka of the Polish Workers' Party and Stanisław Janusz from People's Party. Władysław
Gomułka opposed the excessive Soviet control over Poland; however, there was nothing they
could do about it as the Red Army was in control of the country. Despite this, the RTRP has
sided with the USSR and does not recognise the Polish government-in-exile and will not
negotiate with it.
Polish government-in-exile
The Polish government-in-exile was also known as the London Poles as they were
based in London during the war. The London Poles played a very important part in organsing
the Warsaw uprising. When the Red Army reached Warsaw, Stalin ordered it to stop
advancing instead of helping the uprising. The Red Army waited until the Nazis had killed
20
200,000 Polish resistance fighters before entering Warsaw and establishing the Lublin
Committee as the RTRP. Stanisław Mikołajczyk led the Polish government-in-exile after the
previous leader died in a crash. The Polish government-in-exile’s military units had fought
for the Allies in Europe, Africa, and the Middle East. There were many Polish pilots in the
RAF in the Battle of Britain. The Polish government-in-exile did not recognise the RTRP as
legitimate leader of the USSR and strongly opposed the Soviet influence in Poland.
Provisional Government of the French Republic
The Provisional Government of the French Republic (gouvernement provisoire de la
République française or GPRF) was established in 1944 after its liberation. Charles de
Gaulle, who was the leader of the French government-in-exile and the Free French Forces
based in Britain after its fall in 1940, is the leader of the GPRF. France was aligned with
Britain and wanted a say in what to do with Germany after the fall of Hitler, as this is the
third German invasion of France.
Australia
Australia was once a British colony, but had gained independence and is now part of
the British Commonwealth. The shock of the United Kingdom's defeat in Asia in 1942 and
the threat of Japanese invasion caused Australia to turn to the USA as a new ally and
protector. Australian forces had fought against Japan and defeated them at New Guinea. At
Yalta, Australia is with Britain and the USA.
Mongolian People’s Republic
The Mongolian People’s Republic is a Soviet satellite state. During the Soviet-
Japanese war in 1939, which was before the signing of the Neutrality Pact, the Red Army
successfully defended Mongolia from Japanese invasion. Mongolia is aligned with the Soviet
21
Union and since it is geographically close to Manchuria, would be likely to participate if the
Soviet Union were to attack the Empire of Japan.
South Africa
South Africa, like Australia, used to be part of the British Empire and is now a
Dominion in its Commonwealth. In 1934, the South African Party and National Party merged
to form the United Party, seeking reconciliation between Afrikaners and English-speaking
‘Whites’. In 1939 the party split over the entry of the Union into World War II as an ally of
the United Kingdom, a move that the National Party followers strongly opposed. South
Africa will side with Britain and support it in Yalta.
Yugoslavia
The Yugoslav Partisans were one of the strongest resistance groups during the Second
World War. Unlike the various nationalist militias operating in occupied Yugoslavia, the
Partisans promoted the ‘brotherhood and unity’ of Yugoslav nations, and representing the
republican, left wing, and socialist elements of the Yugoslav political spectrum. The
Communist Party of Yugoslavia (KPJ) led the coalition of political parties, factions, and
prominent individuals behind the movement. Marshal Josip Broz Titos, the leader of the
Yugoslav Partisans, was a member of the KPJ.
Being Communist, the Yugoslav Parisians are aligned with the Soviet Union and
hoped to model their future economy and government of the USSR. Marshal Titos also hoped
to see the Communists take over in Greece so it would have a Communist ally nearby. Titos
was unhappy about Churchill’s desire to bring back the King of Yugoslavia into its future
government.
22
Procedure
Unlike other committees, the Security Council has its own unique way of running and
proceeding. Here we do not have a fixed agenda, as crises might occur anytime throughout
the conference, we expect each of the delegates to make quick responses in different
circumstances. Though the final goal of the committee is still to pass resolutions according to
the crisis they might be facing, there might be certain situations where the committee may
decide to change its focus as the issues evolve. Substantive resolutions would have to be
voted on using the standard parliamentary procedure, with two-thirds of the members
agreeing.
All delegates are welcome to judge and decide on their own, there will be situations
where delegates not following the actual history may be allowed if it is sensible and realistic.
We expect each of the delegates to think wisely before making influential decisions.
Meanwhile, also take into consideration to the consequences that might arise throughout their
act.
Personal Directives
In order to go into a resolution procedure, delegates have tools to help influence world
events. Delegates may seek the Crisis Director privately to request an action towards other
countries. By using personal directives, delegates may request an action from their own
government (which will be decided whether it is approved or not by the crisis director). The
chance of the directive passing would be depended the domestic political situation as well as
how the on-going situation will be effected, etc.
For example, during the Cuban Revolution back in 1956, the Cuban government did
not have enough force to defeat the rebels, the USA, who happen to need the support of Cuba
in other places can therefore arrange a troop to help solve the crisis in Cuba. The US delegate
23
then may request from the Crisis Director on whether they can spare out a troop from their
internal army force and send them to support the Cuban government on defeating the rebels.
Communiqués
Communiqués can be addressed to either a specific individual or to the entire
institutions. There are no restrictions on the types and targets of communiqués – however, do
be aware of interception that might occur during the delivery of the message.
A delegate may speak to either a specific country, or to the whole room. The message
can either be true or a false one. With true information, delegates should put into
consideration about the consequences they might face if the information gets intercepted.
However, delegates are also welcome to give out inaccurate news to the rest in order to
benefit them or to add tension to the committee.
Press Releases
Press releases may be used to announce, pressure, or flawed decisions. Again, just
like the other tools, the domestic political situation of each nation will affect the usage of
press releases. With the correct use of press release, benefits may be brought to certain
countries whilst some other countries may be influenced negatively.
For instance, a delegate may use press release to express their current position or on
how they will react to the ongoing event. By using press releases, other delegates may get a
better idea on each other’s thoughts and ideas. Also, by releasing erroneous news may benefit
a country (or more) in certain ways.
24
Bibliography
Walsh, Ben. GCSE modern world history second edition, London: Hodder & Stoughton
Limited, an Hachette UK company, 2001.
Sir Michael Howard, Yale University
C.Perter Chen, World War 2 Data Base. ww2db.com
Adolf Hitler. Mein Kampf
History10paper2.wikispace.com
AJP Taylor. The Origins of the Second World War
Csoban Göcze. Treaty of Versailles (1919)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov–Ribbentrop_Pact
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet–Japanese_Neutrality_Pact
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
Eastern_Front_(World_War_II)#Operation_Barbarossa:_Summer_1941
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Provisional_Government_of_the_Republic_of_Poland
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanisław_Mikołajczyk
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polish_government-in-exile#Wartime_history
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yalta_Conference#Key_points
http://www.ilmunc-china.com/Bgs/UNSC.pdf
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_War_II_Casualties2.svg
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tehran_Conference#Proceedings_of_the_Conference
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiang_Kai-shek
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Provisional_Government_of_the_French_Republic
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_de_Gaulle
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongolia#Modern_history
Thomas, Jo. Rogers, Kelly. History, 20th Century World, The Cold War
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_Federal_Republic_of_Yugoslavia#World_War_II
25