S1 - Poised between Utopia and Dystopia: Educating for a Better World

Post on 06-Mar-2016

212 views 0 download

Tags:

description

This session will engage participants in an exploration of what might constitute a ‘better world’ in the context of an IB education, and will encourage a critical examination of the future directions of education in each of our schools that might contribute towards such a world.

Transcript of S1 - Poised between Utopia and Dystopia: Educating for a Better World

What  Does  it  Mean  to  be  Educated?    

Dr.  Malcolm  Pritchard  The  ISF  Academy  –  Hong  Kong  

Tyson  &  Ting*ng  

Predic*ng  the  Future?  

"Everything  that  can  be  invented,  has  been  invented."  -­‐  Charles  H.  Duell,  Commissioner,  US  Office  of  Patents,  1899.  

"All  saved  from  Titanic  aCer  collision."  -­‐  New  York  Evening  Sun,  April  15  1912  

"Brain  work  will  cause  women  to  go  bald,  while  increasing  their  masculinity."  -­‐  Professor  Hans  Friedenthal,  University  of  Berlin,  1914.  

"Who  wants  to  hear  actors  talk?"  -­‐  H.M.  Warner,  Warner  Brothers,  1927  

"No  maKer  what  happens,  the  U.S.  Navy  is  not  going  to  be  caught  napping."  -­‐  U.S.  Secretary  of  Navy,  December  4,  1941  

“Computers  in  the  future  may  have  only  1,000  vacuum  tubes  and  perhaps  only  weigh  1.5  tons."  -­‐  Popular  Mechanics,  forecasRng  the  relentless  march  of  science,  1949  

"I  think  there's  a  world  market  for  about  five  computers."  -­‐  Thomas  J.  Watson,  chairman  of  the  board  of  IBM.  

"There  is  no  reason  anyone  would  want  a  computer  in  their  home."  -­‐  Ken  Olson,  president  of  Digital  Equipment  Corp.  1977  

“The  Japanese  auto  industry  isn't  likely  to  carve  out  a  big  slice  of  the  US  market."  -­‐  Business  Week,  August  2,  1968  

"640K  ought  to  be  enough  (computer  memory)  for  anybody."  -­‐  Bill  Gates,  1981.  

The  Guardian:  'Web  2.0'  declared  millionth  word  in  English  language  

Neologism  created  every  98  minutes,  says  language  monitor  

h5p://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/jun/10/english-­‐million-­‐word-­‐milestone  

Apple  iTunes  is  the  largest  music  retailer  in  USA  and  has  sold  more  than  10  billion  legal  songs  as  of  Feb  2010        Amazon  now  sells  105  e-­‐books  for  every  100  printed  books  it  sells        Nealix  is  a  movie  streaming  company  and  accounts  for  25%  of  North  American  Internet  traffic        Facebook  is  the  largest  photo  sharing  website  in  the  world:100  million  photos  uploaded  per  day  /  6  billion  photos  uploaded  each  month  

Facebook  ‘Friend’  Map  of  the  World  

h5p://www.artdiamondblog.com/archives/2011/01/    

Nearly  800  million  ac*ve  users    50%  of  our  ac*ve  users  log  on  to  Facebook  in  any  given  day    Average  user  has  130  friends    People  spend  over  700  billion  minutes  per  month  on  Facebook    Facebook  is  the  largest  photo  sharing  website  in  the  world:100  million  photos  uploaded  per  day  /  6  billion  photos  uploaded  each  month    

Amazon  now  has  1,000,000  digital  *tles  on  Kindle.    

Visualiza*on  of  Trending  Topic  Clouds  

Moore’s  Law  

Lockheed  Mar*n  Bets  Big  on  Quantum  Compu*ng  

 By  Keir  Thomas,  PCWorld        May  28,  2011  

Nature  Nanotechnology:  A  single-­‐atom  transistor  

Researchers  recently  completed  an  inventory  of  the  world's  technological  capacity  (Feb,  2011).    In  2000,  three-­‐quarters  of  the  world's  informa*on  was  s*ll  in  analog  form.      By  2007,  all  but  6  percent  had  been  preserved  digitally    The  dpping  point  came  in  2002  

h5p://www.technewsdaily.com/humanitys-­‐shie-­‐from-­‐analog-­‐to-­‐digital-­‐nearly-­‐complete-­‐2145/  

Analog  Humanity  in  a  Digital  World  

Informa*on  Processing  Power  

We  achieve  one  Human  Brain  capability  (2  X  1016  cps)  for  $1,000  in  2023.    We  achieve  one  Human  Brain  capability  (2  X  1016  cps)  for  one  cent  in  2037.    We  achieve  one  Human  Race  capability  (2  X  1026  cps)  for  $1,000  in  2049.    We  achieve  one  Human  Race  capability  (2  X  1026  cps)  for  one  cent  in  2059.  

Informadon  Overload  

•  1962:  first  internet  connec*on  •  1995:  16  million  users  •  1998:  26  million  urls  •  1999:  12  exabytes  =  all  human  informa*on  •  2008:  1.47  billion  users  •  2009:  226  million  websites  •  2009:  1  trillion  urls  •  2011:  Internet  size  =  800  exabytes  (800,000,000,000,000,000,000  bytes)  

•  2011:  only  10%  of  internet  data  is  reliable  or  unique    

“the  ever  acceleraRng  progress  of  technology…gives  the  appearance  of  approaching  some  essenRal  singularity  in  the  history  of  the  race  beyond  which  human  affairs,  as  we  know  them,  

could  not  conRnue.”    

John  Von  Neumann,  mathema*cian,  inventor    h5p://www.kurzweilai.net/the-­‐law-­‐of-­‐accelera*ng-­‐returns    

The  Approaching  Singularity  

Utopia-­‐Bound:  The  Roadblocks  

•  Linear  thinking  •  Incrementalism  •  Failing  to  recognize  the  ‘*pping  point’  •  Uniformitarianism  •  Ignoring  paradigm  ‘shies’  •  Single-­‐loop  problem  solving  •  Groundless  op*mism  (Pollyanna  Syndrome)  •  “Wicked  Problems”  

Caveat:  Beware  of  SIMPLE  Solu*ons  

“In  the  varied  topography  of  professional  prac*ce,  there  is  a  high,  hard  ground  overlooking  a  swamp.  On  the  hard  ground,  manageable  problems  lend  themselves  to  solu*on  through  the  applica*on  of  research-­‐based  theory  and  techniques.  In  the  swampy  lowlands,  messy,  confusing  problems  defy  technical  solu*ons…in  the  swamp  lie  the  problems  of  greatest  human  concern.”    

       Donald  Schöen:  Educa*ng  the  Reflec*ve  Prac**oner  

Terrorism  Transporta*on  routes  Affordable  healthcare  Sustainable  development  Alterna*ve  affordable  ‘commodity’  energy  Social  security  for  humankind  World  hunger  Global  warming  Environmental  planning  Military  spending    Business  design  challenges  Complex  soeware  development  

Source:  h5p://www.engineeringchallenges.org/cms/8996.aspx  

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

Uni

ted

Sta

tes

Mex

ico

New

Zea

land

Sco

tland

Aus

tralia

Rus

sian

Fed

erat

ion

Ger

man

y

Por

tuga

l

Net

herla

nds

Irela

nd

Eng

land

Spa

in

Bel

gium

(Fl.)

Slo

veni

a

Icel

and

Bel

gium

(Fr.)

Nor

way

Den

mar

k

Fran

ce

Cze

ch R

epub

lic

Luxe

mbo

urg

Est

onia

Kor

ea

Hun

gary

Aus

tria

Japa

n

Italy

Isra

el

Finl

and

Pol

and

Gre

ece

Hours per year

Chart D4.2. Number of teaching hours per year, by level of education (2008)

Net contact time in hours per year in public institutions

Countries are ranked in descending order of the number of teaching hours per year in lower secondary education. Source: OECD. Table D4.1. See Annex 3 for notes (www.oecd.org/edu/eag2010).

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700

Korea Finland Canada New Zealand Japan Australia Netherlands Belgium Norway Estonia Switzerland Iceland Poland United States Germany Sweden France Ireland Denmark Hungary United Kingdom OECD average Portugal Italy Slovenia Spain Czech Republic Slovak Republic Israel Luxembourg Austria Russian Federation Chile Mexico Brazil

Mean score

PISA performance in reading (2009)

0 25000 50000 75000 100000 125000 150000

Educational Expenditure

0

10

20

30

40

Chi

na

Chi

le

Kor

ea

Japa

n

Isra

el

Indo

nesi

a

Arg

entin

a1

Turk

ey

Bra

zil

Uni

ted

Kin

gdom

Irela

nd2

Aus

tralia

Uni

ted

Sta

tes

Fran

ce

Ger

man

y3

Spa

in

Hun

gary

Por

tuga

l

Bel

gium

(Fr.)

Cze

ch R

epub

lic

Mex

ico

Finl

and

Sw

itzer

land

2

Den

mar

k

Aus

tria

Italy

Pol

and

Slo

veni

a

Slo

vak

Rep

ublic

Est

onia

Icel

and

Gre

ece

Rus

sian

Fed

erat

ion

Luxe

mbo

urg

Number of students per classroom

Chart D2.1. Average class size in primary education (2000, 2009)

2009 2000

1. Year of reference 2008 instead of 2009. 2. Public institutions only. 3. Years of reference 2001 and 2009. Countries are ranked in descending order of average class size in primary education in 2009. Source: OECD. Argentina, China, Indonesia: UNESCO Institute for Statistics (World Education Indicators Programme). 2009 data: Table D2.1. 2000 data: Table D2.4 on line. See Annex 3 for notes (www.oecd.org/edu/eag2011).

The  Learning  Process:  Knowledge  construc*on  and  the  Ques8on  

“…all  knowledge  is  in  response  to  a  quesRon.  If  there  were  no  quesRon,  there  would  be  no  scienRfic  knowledge.  Nothing  proceeds  from  itself.  Nothing  is  given.  All  is  constructed.”    Gaston  Bachelard,  The  FormaRon  of  the  ScienRfic  Mind,  1938  

Construc*ng  Knowledge  

•  Ques*ons  •  Inquiry  •  Filtering  skills  •  Discernment  •  Interpreta*on  •  Comparisons  •  Insight  •  Analysis  •  Conclusions  

Informa*on  is  increasingly  structured  in  hyperlinked  tree  structures  

From  Linearity  to  Non-­‐linearity  

Wisdom  Values  Virtues  

Vision  

Informa*on  Processing  and  Storage:  

Cogni*on,  Literacy,  Memory  

Data  Senses:  Seeing,  Hearing,  Touching,  Smelling,  

Tas*ng,  Feeling  

Adapted  from  Russell  Ackoff,  From  Data  to  Wisdom  (1989)  

Ac*on-­‐result  

Reframe-­‐ac*on-­‐result  

Intuit-­‐ac*on-­‐result  

Single  Loop  Learning  

Double  Loop  Learning  

Triple  Loop  Learning  Imagine  Create  Transform  Transcend  

Revise  Reflect  Reframe  Re-­‐theorize    

Observe  Induce  Adjust  Control    

EXPERIENTIAL  LEARNING  &  RISK  PHYSICAL  –  SOCIAL  –  CULTURAL  –  

INTELLECTUAL  

Loyalty  Respect  

Compassion  Love  

E*que5e  Jus*ce  

Harmony  Balance  

Balanced  Caring  

Communicators  Inquirers  

Knowledgeable  Open-­‐minded  Principled  Reflec*ve  Risk-­‐takers  Thinkers  

 

Schools  of  the  Past  

Persevere,  sustain,  reflect,  revere,  maintain,  conser5e,  sustain,  endure,  admire,  venerate,  respect,  hold,  honour  

Traditions,  cult9re,  histor:,  habits,  iner<ia,  conventions,  heritage,  inheritance,  conser5ation    

Schools  of  the  Present  

Manage,  operate,  reconcile,  compromise,  align  harmonize,  measure,  control,  implement,  resolve,  ra*onalize,  stage,  produce    Status  quo,  tension,  balance,  cau*on,  goals,  accountability,  performance  indicators,  strategy,  plan,  goals,  resource,  policy,  prac*ce,  responsibility,  current  

Schools of the Future Wish, desire, dream, launch, risk, invent, create, inspire, initiate, transform, transcend, envisage, anticipate, experiment, Future, hope, aspiration, vision, plan, progress, development, innovation, potential, talent, prospective, proposal, paradigm shift

Educadonal  Essendals  in  the  21st  Century  

•  Virtues,  Values,  Vision:  seeing  truly,  applied  ethics,  crea*vity,  responsibility,    

•  Cultural  skills:  respect,  values,  ethics,  behaviour,  standards,  tradi*ons,  self-­‐restraint,  memory  

•  Experiendal  risk-­‐taking:  innova*on,  crea*vity,  inven*on,  trial  and  error,  mistakes,  recovery,  reflec*on,  support,  scaffolding,  resilience    

•  Communicadon  skills:  social  interac*on  through  speaking,  deba*ng,  convincing,  listening,  nego*a*ng,  compromising,  sharing,  harmonizing  

•  Knowledge  mastery:  literacy,  numeracy,  logic,  cri*cal  thinking  

•  Physical  culture:  health,  fitness,  endurance,  exper*se,  courage,  mastery,  compe**on,  grace,  concession  

Learning  for  the  Truly  Educated  

•  Wisdom:  Vision,  virtues,  values  

•  Culture:  Mul*lingual  &  mul*cultural    •  Experience:  courage  and  resilience  from  The  Swamp  

•  Knowledge:  constructed  from  our  Quesdons      

Where  is  the  Life  we  have  lost  in  living?    Where  is  the  wisdom  we  have  lost  in  knowledge?    Where  is  the  knowledge  we  have  lost  in  inforCation?    T.S.  Eliot,  “The  Rock”  (1934)