Post on 29-Jan-2021
Results from B-Physics (LHCb, BELLE)
Valery Pugatch Kiev Institute for Nuclear Research, NASU
On behalf of the LHCb Collaboration
“Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
Uppsala, Sweden, 16-18 September 2014.
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
1
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 2
OUTLINE
• Introduction
• LHCb and BELLE: B - factories
• B - spectroscopy, decays, lifetimes
• CP symmetry
• Rare decays • Search for NP (multi-quark systems, lepton number violation,
charged Higgs boson, …)
• Summary and outlook
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 3
Introduction LHC : new events at up to 1013 еV energy in 35 /fb data (Run1). Precision measurements – the way to search for New Physics.
This talk: 1. LHCb ( BELLE ) precision measurements for the NP search :
– B - spectroscopy – CP symmetry – Rare decays
2. Search for NP: - multi-quark systems, lepton number violation, - charged Higgs boson search at B-factories
3. Future studies
CERN. 4th July 2012. The first Higgs boson ! Charged Higgs bosons ? New Physics (?) - super-partners in loops, … ?
New Physics & Higgs at B-factories.
Study B-decays to predictable final states - for instance, with τ – leptons, through tree-level processes evolving via b ->sq~q, b-> sγ, … (with Higgs)
Measure & compare with SM predictions: o Differential cross-sections o branching ratios o forward-backward asymmetries, o isospin asymmetries, … -> to exclude uncertainties
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
4
New Physics & Higgs at B-factories. Requirements to the experimental setups.
Beauty Identification at LHCb
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
5
Flavor tagging
Bs identification
• Efficient trigger selecting B-hadrons decay products • Excellent separation of secondary vertex allows to study Bs oscillations with minimal time quantization of 40 fs. • Background suppression:
o due to high invariant mass-resolution (~14 MeV/c2) o Perfect particles identification o Magnetic field flipping up-and-down (artificial asymmetries removal)
New Physics & Higgs at B-factories. Requirements to the experimental setups.
B -> τ ν & BELLE:
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
6
Tracks, Vertices, ID, Momentum and Energy, Triggering, Event reconstruction efficiency , Background suppression etc.,
Example:
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 7
The LHCb experiment
The LHCb detector – forward spectrometer with excellent characterisitics suitable for B-physics stuides: • Acceptance 2 < η < 5
• Momentum resolution about 0.5 %
• Track reconstruction efficiency > 96 % • Impact parameter resolution: ~ 20 μm • • Decay time resolution: ~45 fs • • Invariant mass resolution:
– ~(10-20) MeV/c2
• Ring-Imaging Cherenkov Detectors and
Muon system - particle identification (ID efficiency > 90%)
LHCb: The Large Hadron Collider Beauty
Experiment for Precise Measurements
of CP-Violation and Rare Decays
Integrated luminosity
2010: 37 pb-1
2011: 1.0 fb-1 @ 7 TeV
2012: 2 fb-1 @ 8 TeV
p p
RMS
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 8
LHCb . B-factory: proton-proton collisons
1011 protons per bunch collided at 7 and 8 TeV in 2011 and 2012
delivering luminosity at IP-8 (LHCb)
(2-4) times 1032 cm -2 *s-1
In each p-p collision about 1500 charged
particles are produced:
Challenging radiation load on detectors
Multi-level triggering for preselection of
Beauty and Charm events in LHCb
Integrated cross-sections
B+ ~39 µb
B0 ~38 µb
Bs ~10 µb
Uncertainty ~ 10 % LHCb-Paper-2013-004
New Physics may modify measured features
of CP-violation and
Rare decays
via its contribution in loop diagrams
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
9
BELLE. B-factory: electron-positron collisons
KEKB. BELLE detector. (e +e - ) collisions at Y (4S) resonance. Clean samples of B-mesons.
Data set - 711 fb-1 (total 1 000 fb-1 )– (1999-2010)
Upgraded (2016) Belle II will run at 8.0 x 1035cm -2s-1 (40 times higher than at KEKB).
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 10
Spectroscopy - a perfect tool for searching “NEW”.
LHCb Spectroscopy High energy of collisions at LHC:
production rates by many orders of magnitude higher
in comparison with lepton B-factories.
All b-hadron species (but top-quark containing) were identified.
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 11
Spectroscopy - a perfect tool
for searching “NEW”.
Heavy flavour spectroscopy. Excited states of Λb
Excited states are known for the Λ and Λc .
Two excited states of Λb (at 5911.95 and 5919.76 MeV/c2 ) were
observed for the first time in the Λb0 π+π- mass- spectrum.
Uncertaintes are less than 1 MeV/2c. Discrepancies with theories reach 20 – 30 MeV/c2
Λb reconstructed
in the Λc+π- invariant mass
spectrum.
Phys.Rev.Lett.109(2012)172003
Spectroscopy - a perfect tool in searching for “NEW”. Heavy flavour spectroscopy.
χb radiative decays
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
12
Signals: χb1 – ‘green’, χb2 – ‘magenta’
ϒ (
3S)
ϒ(2
S)
ϒ(1
S) LHCb. ( 7 & 8 ) TeV @ 3 fb-1.
Reconstruction of χb -> ϒγ : (di-muon (ϒ) + photon ) candidates
The observation of the radiative transition of χb(3P) meson to ϒ (3S)
-> the most precise value of the mass χb1 (3P)
LHCb-PAPER-2014-031
Spectroscopy and products angular distributions. A perfect tool for searching “NEW”.
Z (4430) – four-quarks resonant state
Z(3900) (BELLE, PRL 110 (2013) 252002 Z(4430) - First observed by BELLE (Phys.Rev. D88:074026)
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
13
LHCb – Confirmed (PRL, 112, 222002 (2014) The same decay studied: B0 -> K+π-ψ (2S) JP = 1+ assigned
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 14
Measurement of Lifetime – a tool to identify “KNOWN” and “NEW”
Lifetime: B-meson and Λb- baryon
• HQE- theory [NPB, 483, 339, 1997] : Heavy b-quark determines the lifetime: equal for two b-species.
• The role of the third particle might be essential !
• Nuclear Physics – the Coulomb field of the 3d particle modifies the observed width of the two-body short-lived resonance.
LHCb result:
τ(Λb) = 1.482±0.018±0.012 ps
τ(Λb)/τ(B0) = 0.976±0.012±0.006
Confirmation of the HQE –theory.
Bs oscillation frequency
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 15
Tagged flavor evolution measurements with an accuracy of 45 fs.
Results for the Bs -mesons decays into D-sπ
+ and D+sπ- .
The extracted frequency of oscillations
Δms = 17.768 ± 0.023 ± 0.006 ps-1
Evolution of Events in Time – signature for “NEW”
Evolution of Events in Time – signature for “NEW”
B0 oscillations
observed in D+π- and J/ψK*0 decays
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
16
The most precise measurement
of the oscillation frequency for B0 mesons.
Combined for two decay channels
Δmd = 0.5156 ± 0.0051 ± 0.0033 ps-1
LHCb-PAPER-2013-006 arXiv.1304.4741
PLB.719(2013)318
Neutral Bs and Bd mixing frequences
measured using semileptonic decays
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
17
LHCb measures flavor evolution (mixing) with an accuracy of 45 fs due to VELO
displaced vertex reconstruction with an accuracy of few tens µm.
Characteristic features of mixing: mass difference Δm (related to the frequency of
mixing), width difference ΔГ, phase between the decay and mixing amplitudes Φs .
Phys. Lett. B 723 (2013) 33-43
Evolution of Events in Time – signature for “NEW”
http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Lett.+B&volume=723&year=2013&page=33http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Lett.+B&volume=723&year=2013&page=33http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Lett.+B&volume=723&year=2013&page=33http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Lett.+B&volume=723&year=2013&page=33http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Lett.+B&volume=723&year=2013&page=33http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Lett.+B&volume=723&year=2013&page=33http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Lett.+B&volume=723&year=2013&page=33
Measuring asymmetries - restrict the systematic errors in search for “NEW”
CP symmetry violation
CP Violation (CPV) – potential source of New Physics – SM expectations are significantly lower than needed to explain baryon asymmetry in the Universe.
Three ways for CP violation:
Direct - in decay
Indirect - in mixing
Interference of the above two processes.
B – mesons
mixing (oscillations)
Mixing may proceed also via loop diagrams
involving heavy particles – New Physics.
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
18
Measuring asymmetries - restrict the systematic errors in search for “NEW”
CP Violation in Beauty Direct Decays
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
19
Asymmetries were derived from measured data for decays of neutral Bd as well as Bs mesons (to get rid out of systematic errors)
Within SM expectations
First observation of CP violation
in the decays of B0s mesons
ACP(B0s→K
-π+) = +0.27 ± 0.04 ± 0.01
ACP(B0→K+π-) = -0.080 ± 0.007 ± 0.003
The most precise measurement.
Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 (2013) 221601
http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=110&year=2013&page=221601http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=110&year=2013&page=221601http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=110&year=2013&page=221601http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=110&year=2013&page=221601http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=110&year=2013&page=221601
Measuring asymmetries - restrict the systematic errors in search for “NEW”
CP Violation in Bs Mixing
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
20
Time dependent decay studies for measuring CP violating parameters in Bs mixing: Bs J/Ψ Κ
+Κ – and Bs J/Ψ π
+π-
CP violating phase Φs may include new physics …
Combined for two
processes results are
compatible with SM. (Phys.Lett. B736 (2014) 186) – Update for 3 fb-1
Фs = (70 +/- 68 +/- 8 ) mrad
Measuring asymmetries - restrict the systematic errors in search for “NEW”
CP Violation in Bs Mixing
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
21
CKM2014 Vienna, 8 -12th September 2014
Measuring asymmetries - restrict the systematic errors in search for “NEW”
CP Violation
in three-body charmless B decays.
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
22
The first evidence of inclusive CP asymmetry in charmless three-body B± decays.
ACP = +0.025 ± 0.004 ± 0.004 ± 0.007,
2.8 σ
B±→K±π+π- B±→K±K+K-
ACP = -0.036 ± 0.004 ± 0.002 ± 0.007,
4.3 σ
Phys. Rev. Lett. 111 (2013) 101801
LHCb-Paper-2014-044:
From 1 to 3 fb-1 asymmetries are confirmed.
http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=111&year=2013&page=101801http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=111&year=2013&page=101801http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=111&year=2013&page=101801http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=111&year=2013&page=101801http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=Phys.+Rev.+Lett.&volume=111&year=2013&page=101801
The B±→DK and B±→Dπ decays were analyzed :
D decays: KK, ππ, K0Sππ, K0SKK or Kπππ.
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
23
Example: γ = (71.1+16.6-15.7)° for
B±→DK decay (68% CL).
LHCB-PAPER-2013-020.
PLB, 726, 151 (2013)
LHCb (CKM2014, Vienna). LHCb-CONF-2014-004 Updated LHCb combined measurements
γ = (72.9 +9.2 – 9.9 )0
CKM angles in the Unitarity Triangle.
φ3 (γ) from B±→Dh± decays
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
24
CKM angles in the Unitarity Triangle. Angle φ1 (β)
BELLE
CKM angles in the Unitarity Triangle.
Angle φ2 (α) . B0 -> π +π_
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
25
Global fit: φ2 (α), φ2 (γ)
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 26
Rare decays B0s→µ
+µ- and B0→µ+µ- Standard Model - FCNC and helicity suppressed processes with pure leptonic final states , PRL 112 101801 (2014) :
Br (B0s→µ+µ-) = (3.65 ± 0.23) × 10-9
Br (B0→µ+µ-) = (1.1 ± 0.10) × 10-10
-> If in experiment different – evidence for New Physics.
26
Results: 1. B0s → µ+µ-
First observation LHCb (PRL 111, 101805 (2013)) Combined LHCb & CMS (2014)
(preliminary) (2.9 +/- 0.7) x 10-9
2. B0 → µ+µ-
New Physics - the next digit of data accuracy ?
Results consistent with the SM
CMS PAS BPH-13-007 LHCb-CONF-2013-012
Rare decays. Angular Distributions
B0→K+ π-μ+μ- .
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
27
B0→K+ π-μ+μ- - FCNC process via
loop diagram in SM. - Possibility of modification of angular
distributions due to contribution of new
particles.
In total, P1-8 parameters determining
angular distribution of final state
products have been measured.
The P5' observable is shown as a function
of the μ+μ- invariant mass squared q2.
3.7σ deviation of data above
the Standard Model prediction
is observed at 4.3 < q2 < 8.68 GeV2/c4.
JHEP 08 (2013) 131
http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=J.+High+Energy+Phys.&volume=08&year=2013&page=131http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=J.+High+Energy+Phys.&volume=08&year=2013&page=131http://cds.cern.ch/ejournals.py?publication=J.+High+Energy+Phys.&volume=08&year=2013&page=131
Higgs boson searches at B-factories.
Some ways how it might proceed with Higgs-bosons to observable final states.
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
28
Higgs boson searches at B-factories.
B -> τν (BELLE & BABAR) B-decays with heavy τ–lepton in final state may evolve with additional decay modes not present with light leptons : NP contribution might occur through tree processes
Branching ratios change
• Predicition: Minimal extension of the SM with two Higgs doublet – 2HDM
Br(B->τν) = (1.11 +/- 0.28) X 10-4 • Experimental results : BELLE (PRL 110, 131801 (2013) BaBaR (arXiv:1207.0698 (2012)
averaged over hadronic and semileptonic tagging: Br(B->τν) = (1.15 +/- 0.23) X 10-4
Consistent with Standard Model
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
29
Higgs boson searches at B-factories.
B -> D*τν Ratios (R) are considered : R = Br(B->D*τν) /Br(D->D*lν) – to exclude experimental and theoretical uncertainties R (D) = Br(B->Dτν) /Br(D->Dlν) =
0.430 +/- 0.091 R (D*) = Br(B->D*τν) /Br(D*->Dlν) =
0.405 +/- 0.047 (BELLE – KEK–FF2013)
Deviations from the SM theory:
R (D) : 1.4 σ; R (D*) – 3.0 σ
(S. Feiter et al., PRD 85 094025 (2012)
R- dependence on the SM parameters Y. Sakai, R. Watanabe, M. Tanaka. PRD 87, 034028 (2013)
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
30
Search for NP.
Lepton Flavor Violation
τ --> µ - µ + µ - (LHCb)
LHCb result (1 fb-1 @ 7 TeV, 2 fb-1 @ 8 TeV )
branching fraction of the τ --> µ - µ + µ - :
< 4.6 x 10-8 (90 % confidence level) – consistent with the SM expectation
BELLE: < 2.1 x 10-8 (90 % confidence level)
PLB 687, 139 (2010)
LHCb-PAPER-2014-052
Dashed line – SM; Solid line – observed. Yellow - 68 % CL, Green – 95 % CL
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
31
Search for NP. Lepton Flavor Violation
and Baryon Number Violation
LHCb
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
32
LHCb Search for Majorana neutrinos in B- -> π+μ-μ- BR < 4 x 10 -9 (95 % CL) (LHCb data, 3 fb-1) PRL 112, 131802 (2014)
Search for NP. Asymmetries.
Backward – Forward asymmetry in Inclusive B -> Xs l+ l- (BELLE)
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
33
Experimental data (BELLE) – The Forward-Backward Asymmetry (AFB) for the sum of 10 exclusive states (B0 , B+ ) dependence on the momentum transferred q2 . SM calculation – Red band AFB 10.2 GeV/c2
Deviation from the SM : 1.8 σ for the q2
Search for NP. Asymmetries.
• Isospin Asymmetries (AI). arXiv 1403.8044. LHCb (3 fb-1)
B -> K (*) µ+µ-
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
34
Limits on the Higgs production. LHCb
Cross-section for the production of Higgs – like boson
does not exceed 32 pb @ 95 % CL The specific model BV48:
mSUGRA with baryon number violation and parameters:
114 GeV/c2 – h0,
48 Gev/c2 – anti-X0 ,
10 ps - τ (X0)
Data analyzed: 35.8 pb-1 (LHCb –CONF-2012-014) . Further studies continue.
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
35
Limits on Higgs → ττ production. LHCb
JHEP05(2013)132 –> (1 fb-1 @ √s = 7 TeV) LHCb Limit on MSSM Higgs boson production
0.7 pb < σ x BF < 8.6 pb for 90
Limits on Higgs production. LHCb
W/Z (leptons) + H → b anti-b (jets)
-> LHCb acceptance for the 2 b’s inside the detector ≈ 5% -> LHCb acceptance for single lepton inside the detector ≈ 5% Determine limits on H → bb from the observed vs expected events
- Tools developed: jets and B-jet tagging
- Benchmark analysis made – Measurement of the central forward bb asymmetry (LHCb-
CONF-2013-001)
– Measurement of σ(bb) with inclusive final states (LHCb-CONF-2013-002)
for 2.5
Conclusions and Outlook
• Beauty Physics studies have been successfully carried out at the leptonic and hadronic B-factories. Substantial data sets with B-matter samples were accumulated and analyzed at the LHCb and BELLE experiments.
• Measurements of physics observables (new range of energy for collisions up to 8 TeV at LHC) have been performed with unprecedented accuracy (CP violation, rare decays) or for the first time (Bs->µ
+µ- , CPV in B0s , new resonances). Efforts to establish signals beyond Standard Model are being undertaken.
• Most of results obtained were in agreement with the Standard Model predictions. Some disagreements in the data space sensitive to New Physics are under studies (P5 in B
0→K*0μ+μ-, Lepton universality in B+ -> K+ l+l- , …).
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
38
Conclusions and Outlook
• LHCb will continue data taking in 2015-2017 planning the upgrade for running in 2019 at luminosity up to 2 times 1033 cm-2s -1 . BELLE II after upgrade aims to accumulate 50 000 fb-1 data set .
• New Physics must exist! It might require new tools and methods to be developed for its observation. New huge energy valley opened at LHC is certainly rich by new phenomena. There are observables which have to be discovered to study New Physics !
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged Higgs Discovery at Colliders”
39
V. Pugatch. “Prospects for Charged
Higgs Discovery at Colliders” 40
There ... New Physics ! THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION !
There are new directions for HEP studies. Energy: from 1013 еV (at LHC) to 1021 еV. Space: from 10-18 m to 1025 m (Universe) Time: from 10-24 s to 1017 s New Physics ?! It might require new tools and methods to be developed for its observation. New huge energy valley opened at LHC is certainly rich for new phenomena. There might be observables which have to be discovered to study New Physics !
Distribution of Galaxies visible in cosmic rays with E >10 19 eV). Scale: 10 24 m. The Earth diameter - ~107 m, The LHC diameter – ~104 m