Restoration Preservation Masonry, Inc. V. Grove Europe, Ltd.

Post on 18-Dec-2015

218 views 1 download

Tags:

Transcript of Restoration Preservation Masonry, Inc. V. Grove Europe, Ltd.

Restoration Preservation Masonry, Inc. V.

Grove Europe, Ltd.

Accident Site - Longwood Towers20 Chapel Street, Brookline, MA

Building B

Accident Site - Longwood Towers20 Chapel Street, Brookline, MA

Building B

Accident work area in southeast corner

Building B

Accident work area in southeast corner

Building B

Accident work area in southeast corner

Accident work area in southeast corner - Perspective View

Construction project involved removal of bricks and bull-nose water stone because of water infiltration and leakage issues.

Work area is approx.80’ above the ground

80 feet

Southeast corner perspective

Work area

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

Access Satellite scaffolding set-upChassis assembly

Main platform

Outriggers

Mast goes up in sections

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

Mast attached to building with wall ties

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

platform extension 1

platform extension 4

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

platform extension 5

platform extension 2

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

platform extension 3

platform extension 6

Cantilever extensions (5)

cantilever extensions (5)

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

Cantilever extensions - left side

Three different cantilever extension designs used on left side

Three different cantilever extension designs

7’ 8.75”

4’ 11.4”

8’ 2.2”

sliding extensions

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

Planks set on top of cantilever extensions

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

plywood sheets set on top of planks

Planks and plywood

Planks and plywood

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

Guard railings

Guard railings

Access Satellite scaffolding set-up

Scaffolding rides up mast

Scaffolding rides up mast

Scaffolding rides up mast

Scaffolding rides up mast

View from below

View from above

wall ties

View from above

View from above

View from above

Area represented by scale model

Accident Sequence

Areas where bull-nose water stone was previously removed

Pieces are cut from bull-nose water stone

approx. 5 feetfrom top ofwall to plywood

Cut stone is moved to platform extension #1

Scaffolding collapses

Post-accident photos

Right side of Access Satellite platform post-accident

platform extensions 4, 5 & 6

main platform

Cantilever extensions covered with planks and plywood

mast

Post-accident photo

Post-accident photo

Post-accident photo

Post-accident photo

END