Product management in an era of disruptive innovation

Post on 08-May-2015

501 views 4 download

description

[Made at SP Jain, Mumbai. Aug 2012] We live in an era of massive disruptive innovation. More than at any other time in history of industry, we are witness to the massive upheaval of established incumbents – and their replacement by aggressive upstarts. Depending on your point of view this sea change provides massive opportunity – or a terrifying existential threat. This new reality places substantial burdens on managers. Historical tools of product management are obsolete – and there is an attendant critical need for new practices. Product management doctrine was based on a core principle best described as “Big up-front design”. The assumption was of a predictable future that could be analyzed – and planned for. Emphasis in this paradigm was on executing according to the plan. However, an analysis of the historical success rates for new business innovation has demonstrated that this process has been, at best, an abysmal failure. New practices have emerged to enable product managers to adjust to a world of uncertainty. These are based on the premise of fast response to change rather than big up-front planning. They are predicated on documenting business models and conducting focused experiments to validate key assumptions. New practices and concepts have emerged: Customer Development, Business Model Canvas, Lean Startup, and Minimum Viable Product. In this presentation, we introduce these new concepts – and describe how they can be integrated into new practices of product management that are effective in dynamic and disruptive environments. We provide an overview of the structure and application of these practices and their associated tools.

Transcript of Product management in an era of disruptive innovation

Product Managementin the era of

Disruptive Innovation

Krishnan & Nag at SP Jain, Aug ‘12

The product manager is the product’s CEO

ProductManagementR&D

Sales (+ Marketing)Markets + Customers

Executives

The product manager is the product’s CEO

ProductManagementR&D

Sales (+ Marketing)Markets + Customers

Executives

budgets staff

targets

strategy forecastscommitmentscompetitive intelligence

segmentation, messagespricing, roadmap, demos

market feedback

product

MRD, roadmap, priorities, personas

Source: Rich Mironov

Once upon a time in Product Management land…

Product Management (‘70s-’00s)

Develop conceptGet funding

Build product Alpha / beta test

Customer Shipment

Write business plan

Build the product Test / fix Ship / fix

Planning / collateral PR / plan launch Launch / Demand gen.

Initial sales rep Build sales team / selling

Build product and offering

Alpha testMarket test

Big-BangLaunch after

3-5 years

Cautionary tale

Source: Steve Blank

1987: Iridium founded

1990: Spun out

of Motorola

1997:Launch

1998:Bankrupt

$5.2b investment15 rockets

72 satellites

1987: Iridium founded

1990: Spun out

of Motorola

1997:Launch

1998:Bankrupt

$5.2b investment15 rockets

72 satellites

Target price: $7/minTarget users: 42million

Viable price: $0.5/minActual users: 30,000

Develop conceptGet funding

Build product Alpha / beta test

Customer Shipment

Build product and offering

Alpha testMarket test

Unbridled enthusiasm

Rude awakening

False sense of security

Resettingexpectations

Predictable disaster

“Big Up Front Design”

Big-BangLaunch after

3-5 years

Disruptive change is becoming commonplace

Dramatic change of fortunes

Source: Innosight – “Creative destruction whips through Corporate America”

Source: Innosight – “Creative destruction whips through Corporate America”

Agony and Ecstasy

Launched: 2007$22b / qtr

Founded: 1975$17b / qtr

Reasons for increasing pace of disruptive change

90-95% of new ventures fail to meet projections

The old ways of Product Management aren’t working

Adaptive Product Management

Limited planning, more experimentation and exploration

Develop conceptGet funding

Build product Alpha / beta test

Customer Shipment

Build product and offering

Alpha testMarket test

BUFD

Front-end planning & design

Back-end execution

Big-BangLaunch after

3-5 years

Existing market New marketE

xist

ing

p

rod

uct

New

p

rod

uct

Highest success rate

Lowest success rate

When does BUFD work?

BUFD is unlikely to work for…

Start-up companies

New products in established companies

Major new features/markets for established products

Visionaries

Steve BlankCustomer Development

Martin FowlerAgile Methods

2 stages of Customer Development

Search Scale

Source: Steve Blank

Focus on Experimentation

Focus on Execution

Iterative model – with checkpoints

Customer

discovery

Customer

validation

Customer

creation

Business

expansion

Pivot / Course correct

Search Scale

Source: Steve Blank

Search Principle # 1: Business Model Canvas

VALUE

PROPOSITION

CHANNELS

CUSTOMER

RELATIONSHIPS

CUSTOMERSEGMENTS

REVENUE STREAMS COST STRUCTURE

KEY

PARTNERS

KEY

RESOURCES

KEY

ACTIVITIES

Source: “Business Model Generation”, Osterwalder & Pigneur

iTunes market place

Search Principle #2: Minimum Viable Product

Minimum

Viable

Too-basic products no one wants

Incumbentproducts

Minimum + ViableFertile area for new

products

Source: Start-up Chronicles

• Demonstrate value• Gather feedback

If you’re building an Excel competitor, what’s the MVP?

Minimum Viable ?

Minimum Viable ?

Minimum Viable Product for Google Docs

Value prop

Learn

Ideas

Build

OfferingMeasure

Data

Minimise the total time through the

loop

Search Principle #3: Focus on exploration

How it all fits together

Agile software development

Predictive (BUFD) | Adaptive

If da Vinci was an adaptive painter…

Source: A Series of Tubes

Questions? Comments?

knataraj@thoughtworks.com nag@thoughtworks.com