Post on 31-May-2018
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
1/15
Trip Adler Biological Sciences 54Final Writing Project5/6/04
PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated andSubsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of
Isolated Fibroblasts with PDGF in Culture
Trip Adler, Mei Rosa Ng, Robin Kachka, Benigno Varela, Danielle Andrews-Lovell,Kedar Gumaste, Kimmie Keefe, Laura Hellett, Laura Perretta, Stephanie Wang
Abstract
Extracellular signaling is a process in which a molecule outside of a cell binds
to a transmembrane receptor to activate a signaling pathway. One particular
example of this is PDGF (platelet-derived growth factor) binding to a RTK (receptor
tyrosine kinase) to activate the Ras-ERK kinase pathway in fibroblasts. After
choosing an antibody that binds to fibroblasts, using it to purify a culture of this cell
type, and then checking the efficiency of the sort using microscopy, we used the pure
culture to study the PDGF-activated pathway. We stimulated the culture with
PDGF, and took samples of unstimulated cells, cells thirty minutes after stimulation,
and cells two hours after stimulation. A western blot was used to observe the
relative amounts of PDGFR, Raf, and ERK, in their unphosphorylated and
phosphorylated states, at the three different times. It was found that all three
proteins are initially unphosphorylated, phosphorylated thirty minutes after
stimulation, and less phosphorylated two hours after stimulation. This is consistent
with what would be expected in an RTK-controlled Ras-ERK kinase pathway that is
activated by PDGF. The protein players are initially phosphorylated in the
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
2/15
pathway, but are later dephosphorylated to stop signal transmission.
Introduction
Extracellular signaling is one of the fundamental biological processes that allows
life on earth to be possible. It is this process that allows cells to respond to their external
environments. Understanding the mechanisms of signaling not only allows us to have a
better understanding of cells and the way they interact with their surroundings, but many
useful applications can result. To increase our understanding of signaling, we studied this
process in a pure culture of fibroblasts that we isolated. By stimulating the cells with
PDGF and taking samples after different amounts of time, we observed the changing
levels of phosphorylated and unphosphorylated signaling proteins. Our results are
consistent with what we would expect for the Ras-ERK pathway controlled by RTK
(receptor tyrosine kinase) transmembrane protein.
To better understand the signaling pathway that takes place when fibroblasts are
stimulated by PDGF, we started out by isolating a pure culture of fibroblasts. This first
involved selecting the antibody to be used in this process. Immunofluorescence and
brightfield microscopy were used to observe how different antibodies stain skin tissue
samples. We found out that anti-PDGFR (platelet-derived growth factor receptor) was
specific to fibroblasts. We then used this antibody in an antibody-based cell sort, and
observed the effectiveness of the sort using phase contrast microscopy. Fluorescencemicroscopy was then used to further probe the efficiency of the sort. After this we had a
pure culture of fibroblasts for use in the final experiment. The fibroblasts were
stimulated with PDGF, and samples were taken of unstimulated cells, cells thirty minutes
2
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
3/15
after stimulation, and cells two hours after stimulation. The samples were run on a gel
and a western blot was done using antibodies against PDGFR, Raf, and ERK, in their
phosphorylated and unphosphorylated forms. It was found that these three proteins tend
to be unphosphorylated before stimulation, phosphorylated thirty minutes after
stimulation, and less are phosphorylated two hours after stimulation. This fits the current
understanding of the RTK-controlled Ras-ERK pathway, in which all of these proteins
are initially phosphorylated, but are later dephosphorylated to stop signal transmission.
Materials and Methods
Immunohistochemistry and Brightfield Microscopy : Five skin samples from
pigs were sectioned, fixed, and treated with a peroxide block. While one of the samples
was not treated with a primary antibody, the other four were treated with anti-EGFR
(epidermal growth factor receptor), anti-PDGFR (platelet-derived growth factor
receptor), anti-Cytokeratin, or anti-Collagen antibodies. The samples were then
incubated with a secondary antibody, which was linked to biotin. This in turn was bound
to a fusion protein of streptavidin linked to HRP (horse radish peroxidase) enzyme. After
this the HRP substrate was added, which results in a red precipitate, and the nuclei were
stained blue with hematoxylin. Lastly, mounting media was added directly to the sample
area. Brightfield microscopy was used to observe these prepared slides at 40X
magnification.Cell Sorting and Phase Contrast Microscopy : Intact skin tissue was treated
with trypsin and then homogenized to create a cell suspension. This was inserted into an
opticell with growth media. Trypsin/EDTA solution was used to remove cells from the
3
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
4/15
membrane. The cells were centrifuged at 2,500 rpm for ten minutes. The pellet was
resuspended in DMEM/PBS solution. To isolate fibroblasts, anti-PDGFR antibodies
were added as a primary antibody. This suspension was then injected into a new opticell,
before adding secondary antibody bound to magnetic beads. A magnet was used to hold
these beads and the cells bound to them in place, while the unattached cells were
removed. Growth media was then added so the cells could continue to grow. This entire
process starting after the initial addition of trypsin and the homogenization was done
twice. Before and after the sort, a phase-contrast image was taken of the cell culture.
Cell Counting : Before the second cell sort, 500l of suspension was removed
for a cell count. First, 100l of trypan blue was added to the suspension. 10l of this
was transferred to one chamber of the hemocytometer, where the numbers of white and
blue cells were counted. Each 1 mm2 section of the hemocytometer represented a total
volume of 1x10-4 ml. By counting the average number of white cells per 1 mm2 section,
an estimate of the number of living cells per ml could be calculated.
Immunofluorescense and Fluorescence Microscopy : The opticell was cut open
and the cells were fixed with methanol. After blocking with PBS/1%BSA and staining
the nuclei blue, a mixture of rabbit anti-PDGFR and goat anti-EGFR primary antibodies
was added. The secondary antibody mixture was then added, which consisted of anti-
rabbit antibodies conjugated to Fluor488, which appears green in fluorescence
microscopy, and anti-goat conjugated to Fluor546, which appears red. These cells werethen observed by fluorescence microscopy at 40X magnification.
Gel Electrophoresis : Using the pure cultures of fibroblasts, some were
stimulated by PDGF, and of these some were collected, washed and stored as cell pellets
4
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
5/15
after thirty minutes, while others were collected after two hours. Some cells were also
left unstimulated. These three different samples were resuspended and added to SDS-
PAGE (sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis) loading dye, and this
was loaded into a 12% acrylamide gel. There were four groups of four lanes, and each
group consisted of Precision Plus Protein standards marker in lane 1, unstimulated extract
in lane 2, extract taken thirty minutes after stimulation in lane 3, and extract taken two
hours after stimulation in lane 4. The gel was run for fifty minutes at 150 V.
Western Blotting : When the gel was done running, it was placed in CAPS
electroblotting buffer. A sandwich was prepared and the gel box was filled with CAPS buffer. The transfer was run at .200 amps for forty-five minutes, and then the membrane
was placed in a blocking solution of BSA(2%)/TBS-Tween. There were four primary
antibody solutions used: 1) rabbit anti-PDGFR , 2) rabbit anti-p-PDGFR (anti-
phosphorylated-PDGFR ), 3) rabbit anti-Raf-1 and mouse anti-p-Raf-1, and 4) rabbit
anti-ERK1/2, and mouse anti-p-ERK1/2. These antibodies were diluted to 1/1000 in
BSA(2%)/TBS-Tween solution and added to the membranes. The secondary antibodies
were anti-rabbit, which were conjugated to fluorophores that appeared green when
scanned, and anti-mouse, which were conjugated to fluorophores that appeared red. A
total of four western blot membranes were scanned.
Results
We first determined that anti-PDGFR (platelet-derived growth factor receptor)
antibody is good for isolating fibroblasts. To do this, five skin samples from research
pigs were observed using brightfield microscopy ( Figure 1 ). The nuclei in the samples
5
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
6/15
were stained blue with hematoxylin, and in each sample a different cell type was stained
red using different primary antibodies and secondary antibodies conjugated to the HRP
(horse radish peroxidase) enzyme. In each image the dermis, epidermis, and components
of these two tissue types are visible. Figure 1a is the negative control, because the
primary antibody did not specifically bind to any proteins in the skin. This is apparent
because only one color of staining is present and it is staining the nuclei.
The staining in the second image was done with anti-EGFR (epidermal growth
factor receptor) antibody ( Figure 1b ). This is obvious because the red staining is
localized to the epidermis, and is concentrated in the basal layer, where actual growthtakes place. Figure 1c was stained with anti-Cytokeratin antibody, and it is the dark red
staining in the outer layer of the epidermis is what explains this. In Figure 1d the dermis
was stained with anti-Collagen antibody. Because collagen makes up most of the dermis,
it makes sense that the red color is spread out throughout this tissue layer. Finally, Figure
1e was stained with anti-PDGFR antibodies. Because this stains fibroblasts, it can be
seen concentrated near the fibroblasts in the dermis and near the inner layer of the
epidermis. Therefore, we determined that anti-PDGFR antibody is the antibody best
suited for use in the isolation of fibroblasts from intact skin tissue.
(a) (b)
6
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
7/15
(c) (d)
(e) Figure 1 . Brightfield Microscopy of Skin Cells . The distinction between the dermis,epidermis, and components of these tissues is clear. In each image, cell nuclei are stainedin blue and a different protein is stained in red using a different primary antibody. (a) Negative control. The antibody used did not recognize any proteins in the skin. (b)Staining of epidermis using anti-EGFR antibodies. (c) Staining of Keratinocytes withanti-Cytokeratin antibodies. (d) Staining of dermis with anti-Collagen antibodies. (e)Staining of fibroblasts with anti-PDGFR antibodies.
Once it was determined that anti-PDGFR antibodies bind to the cell surface of
fibroblasts, these antibodies were used to isolate fibroblasts from skin tissue. After
degrading the connective tissue of the dermis, the resulting culture of cells was
photographed using phase contrast microscopy ( Figure 2 a). In this mixture, the
fibroblasts were the smaller cells with pointy edges, and the other skin cells could easily
be distinguished by their different sizes and shapes. Using anti-PDGFR as a primary
7
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
8/15
antibody specific to fibroblasts and a secondary antibody bound to a magnetic bead, the
fibroblasts were separated from the other cells by magnetic sorting. The resulting culture
of pure fibroblasts is shown in Figure 2b . A hemocytometer was used to count that there
were about 3.50x106 healthy cells per milliliter of solution. The healthy cells were
distinguished from the unhealthy ones using trypan blue. Roughly 87% of the counted
cells were white, which indicates that they were healthy.
To further probe the efficiency of the cell sort, immunofluorescence was used.
The nuclei were stained blue with DAPI, while a mixture of rabbit anti-PDGFR and goat
(a) (b) Figure 2 . Phase Contrast Images of Skin Cell Culture Before and After Cell Sort .(a) Before a cell sort that selects for fibroblasts, it can be seen that there are severaldifferent types of cells. The smaller ones with pointy edges are fibroblasts, while thecells of other sizes and shapes are other skin cells. (b) After the cell sort, the only type of cells present is fibroblasts.anti-EGFR antibodies, which are specific for fibroblasts and epithelial cells, respectively,
were added. Secondary antibodies conjugated to Fluor488 and Fluor546 stained the
fibroblast membranes green and the epithelial membranes red, respectively. As a
negative control, this process was first done to a culture of pure epithelial cells. Figure
3a shows this result, with the nuclei blue and all the membranes red. In contrast, Figure
3b shows the immunofluorescence image after the cell sort. In this case, there are no
epithelial cells present. Instead, all the nuclei are surrounded by green membranes, which
8
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
9/15
indicates that these are all fibroblasts. In addition, the membranes have a shape that is
characteristic of fibroblasts, in which there are spiky points. Therefore, the lack of
epithelial cells suggests that this is a fairly pure culture of fibroblast cells that is ready for
use in another experiment.
(a) (b) Figure 3 . Immunofluorescence Images of Epithelial Cells and Skin Cell CultureAfter Cell Sort . The cell nuclei were stained blue with DAPI. The membranes werestained using a mixture of anti-PDGFR and anti-EGFR antibodies, and secondaryantibodies conjugated to Fluor488 and Fluor546 made fibroblasts appear green andepithelial cells appear red, respectively. (a) As a negative control, a pure culture of
epithelial cells was used in immunofluorescence microscopy. It can be seen that there areonly cells with red membranes present, which are epithelial cells. (b) After the cell sort,only fibroblasts, with membranes that are stained green, are present.
After verifying by immunofluorescence that the culture of cells was only
composed of fibroblasts, this pure culture was used in further experimentation. First, cell
extracts were taken before the cells were treated in any way. Then the fibroblasts were
stimulated with PDGF, and cells were collected thirty minutes and two hours after
stimulation. Four different SDS-PAGE gels were loaded with marker in lane 1, extract
before stimulation in lane 2, extract thirty minutes after stimulation in lane 3, and extract
two hours after stimulation in lane 4 ( Figure 4 ). Western blots were done such that each
9
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
10/15
set of extracts was stained with a different primary antibody.
Figure 4a shows staining with anti-PDGFR antibody. It can be seen that before
stimulation, there is a strong green band, which indicates the presence of
unphosphorylated PDGFR. However, after thirty minutes, this band gets weaker,
indicating the disappearance of this protein, and then after two hours, the band gets
stronger again. Meanwhile, in Figure 4b , which shows staining with anti-p-PDGFR
(phosphorylated-PDGFR) antibody, the band is weak at first and gets stronger after thirty
minutes, indicating that more p-PDGFR is accumulating, but then it weakens again after
two hours. Figure 4c shows a similar pattern when staining is with anti-Raf antibody. Itillustrates the presence of Raf at first, its initial disappearance after stimulation with
PDGF, and then reappearance a little later. When Raf disappears, Figure 4d shows that p-
Raf begins to appear, and when Raf appears, p-Raf disappears. The merge shows that
both Raf and p-Raf are present after the initial stimulation, but more Raf returns at the
two-hour mark. Figure 4f shows that ERK is present the whole time but especially before
stimulation and two hours after stimulation. After stimulation, the amount p-ERK
initially increases ( Figure 4g). This is clarified in Figure 4h, which shows the merge.
1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
(a) (b) (c) (d) (e)1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
10
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
11/15
P(f) (g) (h)
Figure 4 . Western Blot Analysis of Fibroblast Cells Treated with PDGF . In eachwestern blot image, lane 1 contains the marker, lane 2 contains fibroblast extract of unstimulated cells, lane 3 contains extract thirty minutes after the cells were stimulatedwith PDGF, and lane 4 contains extract two hours after stimulation. (a) Staining withanti-PDGFR antibodies. (b) Staining with anti-p-PDGFR antibodies. (c) Staining withanti-Raf antibodies. (d) Staining with anti-p-Raf antibodies. (e) Merge of images (d) and(e). (f) Staining with anti-ERK antibodies. (g) Staining with anti-p-ERK antibodies. (h)
Merge of images (f) and (g).The band is the most yellow, as opposed to green, thirty minutes after stimulation, which
indicates that this in when the most p-ERK is present. Therefore, with all three proteins,
they tend to be present in the unphosphorylated form before stimulation, the
phosphorylated form thirty minutes after stimulation, and again in the unphosphorylated
form after two hours.
Discussion
In our first experiment, we used brightfield microscopy to determine that anti-
PDGFR (platelet-derived growth factor receptor) antibody is a good antibody for use in
isolating fibroblasts. We then did a cell count and an antibody-based cell-sort to isolate
fibroblasts. We confirmed that the sort was successful using phase contrast microscopy.To further probe the efficiency of the sort, we used fluorescence microscopy to observe
the lack of epithelial cells. In the final experiment, we stimulated our pure culture of
fibroblasts with PDGF and took samples after different amounts of time. By western
11
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
12/15
blotting, we observed the relative amounts of three different proteins in their
phosphorylated and unphosphorylated forms. A similar pattern emerged for all three
proteins. For PDGFR, Raf, and ERK, all three were present mainly in their
unphosphorylated forms before stimulation. Thirty minutes after stimulation, all three of
these tended to exist more in their phosphorylated forms, while two hours after
stimulation, they were again unphosphorylated. It should be pointed out that in the
western blot that shows the relative amounts of phosphorylated PDGFR, it is a little
difficult to see the change in the strength of the band at the three different times. This is
because the first band, from the unstimulated cells, is relatively strong. It is thereforemore difficult to detect a change in band strength after thirty minutes and two hours.
However, our interpretation was that the band gets stronger after thirty minutes and
weaker after two hours.
Our results showing the relative amounts of the three phosphorylated and
unphosphorylated proteins are consistent with what is currently known about RTK
(receptor tyrosine kinase) pathways that are controlled by PDGF. Figure 5 shows a
typical RTK pathway that involves the proteins Ras and ERK. When cells in culture are
stimulated with a growth factor, such as PDGF, this molecule binds to its receptors, such
as PDGFR in this case. The PDGFR monomers in the cell membrane then dimerize and
12
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
13/15
GDPGTPGTP
GDP
membrane
PDGF
PDGFRDimer
PhosphorylatedPDGFR Dimer
PDGFRMonomers
GRB2 Sos Inactive Ras
Active Ras
Inactive Raf
Active Raf Inactive DisassociatedMEK Active Raf
Active MEK Inactive ERK Active ERK
Figure 5 . A Typical RTK Pathway . In a typical RTK pathway, such as one thatinvolves PDGFR (platelet-derived growth factor receptor), PDGFR initially exists astransmembrane monomers. Upon binding of PDGF, the monomers dimerize and
phosphorylate each other. This phosphorylated dimer can then bind GRB2, which bindsSos. This localizes Sos near the membrane so that it can bind to inactive Ras-GDP. This promotes dissociation of GDP and then binding of GTP, which produces Ras in itsmembrane-bound active form. Ras-GTP binds an inactive Raf and phosphorylates it.GTP hydrolysis leads to dissociation of Raf from Ras, and disassociated active Raf activates MEK by phosphorylating it. Active MEK in turn phosphorylates ERK so that itis in its active form. This can dimerize to enter the nucleus and activate manytranscription factors.
phosphorylate each other. This binds GRB2, which in turn binds Sos, which when
recruited to the membrane converts Ras-GDP to its active form, Ras-GTP. This proteinthen can active a pathway in which Raf gets phosphorylated. In this active form, it
activates MEK by phosphorylating it, which in turn activates ERK by phosphorylating it.
ERK can then dimerize to enter the nucleus and activate many transcription factors. We
13
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
14/15
started our experiment in this same way, because we added PDGF to our cells in culture.
It would make sense that this would bind to receptors and activate an RTK pathway. Our
results are consistent with the Ras-ERK kinase pathway, because we started with
relatively high levels of unphosphorylated PDGFR, Raf, and MEK, and low levels of
these proteins in the phosphorylated state. It was only after the fibroblasts were
stimulated with PDGF that the initial levels of these proteins in the phosphorylated state
increased and the levels in the unphosphorylated state decreased. This fits in with what is
known about RTK pathways, because all of these proteins get phosphorylated after being
initially stimulated with PDGF. Our results also showed that after two hours, these three proteins were present less in the phosphorylated state and more in the unphosphorylated
state. This is also consistent with what is known about RTK-controlled Ras-ERK kinase
pathways. In living cells, proteins that get activated by being phosphorylated in a
pathway must eventually be deactivated so that the signal is not transmitted forever.
Therefore, proteins tend to eventually get dephosphorylated. It would make sense that
this is what is happening to PDGFR, Raf, and ERK, and this is why the balance shifts
from the phosphorylated to the unphosphorylated state.
It is likely that PDGF activated the Ras-ERK pathway in the culture of fibroblasts
that we studied. This explains the initial phosphorylation and then subsequent
dephosphorylation of PDGFR, Raf, and ERK. Further experiments can be done to see
which other proteins are involved in this pathway. A similar pattern of phosphorylation
and dephosphorylation of the proteins being tested would indicate that the proteins are
involved in the pathway. The experiment can also be done using more time points, which
might provide information about the order in which the proteins get phosphorylated and
14
8/14/2019 PDGFR, Raf, and ERK Are Phosphorylated and Subsequently Dephosphorylated Upon Stimulation of Isolated Fibro
15/15
dephosphorylated. More information about this pathway can lead to many useful
applications. One is that it can lead to cures for cancer, because PDGF can be a powerful
mitogen. Research is also useful because PDGF is a very important factor in
development, new blood vessel formation, and the healing of wounds. Addition
experiments can also be done to study this pathway in types of cells other than
fibroblasts, and other types of growth factors. The possibilities are endless and all
information about these cellular processes can lead to countless applications.
Literature Cited
Heldin, C. and A. stman and L. Rnnstrand. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta
1378 (pp. F79-F113). Signal Transduction Via Platelet-derived Growth Factor Receptors.
Elsevier Science, 1998.
Young, B. and J. W. Heath. Skin, Chpt 9 (pp. 157-159, 162-164). Wheaters
Functional Histology. Harcourt Publishers, 2000.
15