Post on 24-Oct-2021
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
tions
r
May 31, 2001
Measurements and Simulaof CSR Effects in the
APS Bunch Compresso
Michael Borland
Argonne National Laboratory
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
, J. Lewellen,
ma,
. Soliday,
Contributors
• Simulation: M. Borland, J. Lewellen
• Design: V. Bharadwaj, M. Borland, P. EmmaS. Milton, K. Thompson
• Diagnostics: G. Decker, B. Lill, B. Yang
• Experiments and support: M. Borland, P. EmJ. Lewellen, Y. Li, S. Milton
• Software: N. Arnold, M. Borland, Y. Chae, RJ. Stein
• Management: S. Milton
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
Outline
• APS linac and bunch compressor overview
• Beam requirements and limitations
• CSR simulation methods
• Design simulation results
• Comparison of experiments and simulation
• Plans
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
D)
toFEL
ance measurement
tance measurement
CTRdiagnostic
APS Linac Schematic
TC RF guns
L1L2 (SLEα magnets
PC gun
L3
L4 (SLED)
emitt
L5 (SLED)
B1
B2 B3
B4
Q1 Q2emitmatching quads
BPMvertical bend diagnosticscraper flag
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
EL
0A wasas seen.
s achieved withollowed shortly.
Charge
nC
>0.5
>0.5
Beam Specifications for LEUTL F
• Prior to bunch compressor installation, ~15achieved with ~0.7nC. Modest FEL gain w
• With the bunch compressor, up to 600A wa~0.2nC. Saturation at 530nm and 385nm f
Energy PeakCurrent
RMSEnergySpread
NormalizedEmittance
MeV A % um
217 300 <0.1% 5
457 600 <0.15% 5
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ll
ressor
ωrf ∆to
E--------------------
δ
∆t
∆to2⟨ ⟩ 1
R56VωcE
-----------------+
2
Bunch Compression in a Nutshe
four-dipolechicane
precomplinac
δ δo
Vrf---------+=∆t ∆to δR56
c---------+=
∆t ∆toR56
c--------- δo
Vω∆toE
-----------------+ += ∆t2⟨ ⟩ ≈
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ffects.
icane.
to model.
Limits on Injector Performance
• Space charge and rf focusing in the gun.
• Wakefields in accelerating tanks.
• Jitter of rf systems and laser.
• Rf curvature and other nonlinear transport e
• Coherent synchrotron radiation (CSR) in ch
With the exception of CSR, these are “easy”
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ctory allowsm tail to catchhead.
bunch radiatet wavelengths
han the bunch
n produces aendent energy
along the
Qualitative Explanation of CSR
retardedposition
presentposition
(t=-s/c) (t=0)
s
Curved trajeradiation froup with the
Particles incoherently amuch less tlength.
This radiatioposition-depmodulationbunch.
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
dent energyin the energy
and inside thees of particle
ittance in the
e can be seenr the chicane.
How CSR Affects the Bunch
• CSR imposes a longitudinal-position-depenmodulation on the bunch. This will show upspectrum.
• This modulation is imparted inside a dipolechicane, producing a modulation of the sloptrajectories.
• This results in a growth of the projected embending plane.
• CSR also introduces x-p correlations. Theson a vertical bend (“Dowell diagnostic”) afte
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
m of Saldin, et
into the bend,
Simulation of CSR Effects
• Inside dipoles, use free-space, 1-D formalisal., in NIM A 398 (1997):
where R is the bend radius, is the angleand . The two terms are
and
dE s R φ, ,( )cdt
--------------------------- T1 s R φ, ,( ) T2 s R φ, ,( )+=
φs ct=
T1 s R φ, ,( ) K λ′ z( ) s---z
---13
------zd
s---sl
s
∫=
T2 s R φ, ,( ) Kλ s---sl( )---λ s---4sl( )
sl1 3/
------------------------------------------=
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ngth, and is
R wake ise end of eachach simulation
λ(s)
where , is the slippage lethe longitudinal density of the bunch.
• Dipoles are cut into ~100 slices and the CScomputed from the longitudinal density at thslice. This is used to modify the energy of eparticle.
K---2e2
3R2( )1 3/------------------------= sl
Rφ3
24----------=
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ole
ssian beam= 1.5m
50µm=
Examples of CSR Wakes in a Dip
GauR
σz
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
s
the radiation
ke propagatesis is confirmed
vertaking
for an idealizedhese are useduates.
Simulation of CSR in Drift Space
• CSR effects are not confined to dipoles, ascontinues to propagate with the beam.
• After dipoles, assume the terminal CSR wawith gradual attenuation but fixed shape. Thby detailed simulations (Dohlus et al.).
• Attenuation length is roughly given by the “o
length,” .
• Saldin et al. give equations for this radiationrectangular beam distribution. In elegant , tto determine how quickly the radiation atten
24σzR2( )1 3/
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
Attenuation of CSR in Drift
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ssor
tribution to
Simulation Method for APS Compre
• Photoinjector (J. Lewellen) uses PARMELA
• Simulate a nominal 1nC bunch.
• Scale the charge and emittance of this dismatch what we actually run.
• Linac-to-FEL uses elegant , including
• longitudinal and transverse matching
• longitudinal wakes
• exact rf curvature effects
• second-order matrix for quadrupoles
• symplectic integrator for chicane dipoles
• CSR in dipoles and drifts
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
R Effect
Example of Bunch Compression and CSADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
itions
Predictions for Design Operation CondADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ber problem),d rf phase.
irp and thus the
ergy fixed.
chicane)
nd line)
tem)
g)
Bunch Compressor Experiments
• Bunch compressor is fixed in position (chamso we basically have two knobs: charge an
• Rf phase scans allow varying the energy chbunch length.
• We vary the rf voltage to keep the beam en
• Measurements include:
• “incoming” energy spectrum (at center of
• energy spectrum after chicane (vertical be
• emittance after chicane (three screen sys
• bunch length after chicane (rf zero-phasin
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
1/01)
Phase Scan for 200pC Beam (3/3ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ion
Comparison with “Nominal” SimulatADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
nt
pace enteringemittance
asured bunchinal properties.
to have thetance.
Matching Simulation to Experime
• Knowledge of the initial longitudinal phase sL2 is critical to getting the bunch length andcorrect.
• Used elegant without CSR to match the melength data by adjusting initial RMS longitud
• “Morphed” the PARMELA-generated bunchsame RMS longitudinal properites and emit
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
e-Space
l
Nominal and Morphed Longitudinal Phas
morphed
nomina
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
imulation
Comparison with Bunch-Length-Matched SADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
amatic
Effect of Using a Gaussian Beam is DrADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
s Match
...Even Though the RMS Bunch LengthADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
nt
bend only
OL model
S54 model
.
CSR Model for Drifts is All-Importa
OL model uses Overtaking Length forCSR attenuation in drifts.
S54 model uses equations 53-54 fromSaldin et al. for CSR attenuation in drifts
Standard 0.4nCdesign simulations.
Bend only means no CSR in drifts.
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
30/01)
ase to vary the
the bunchal bend (“DD”
4.3µm and
Impact of CSR on Energy Spectra (3/
• In this experiment, we again varied L2 rf phbunch length.
• We recorded beam profiles at the center ofcompressor (“BCC” flag) and after the verticflag).
• Charge was 270pC, normalized emittances3.1µm for x and y.
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
Bunch Length Data
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ssion
Apparent Energy Spectra in DecompreADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
est
Apparent Energy Spectra Near CrADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ompression
Apparent Energy Spectra Near Maximum CADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ompression
Apparent Energy Spectra Near Maximum CADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ing
tive of the
the tail.
wake that lookserating leading
w in energy andoves them
linearize (or
Why CSR Causes Energy Clump
• The CSR wake has the shape of the derivalongitudinal density.
• CSR accelerates the head and decelerates
• A temporal clump produces a feature in thelike the derivative of the local density, accelparticles and decelerating trailing particles.
• In compression, the leading particles are lothe trailing particles are high. Thus, CSR mtogether into an energy clump.
• To reduce the impact of CSR, one needs tothermalize) the longitudinal distribution.
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
y Spreads
Measured and Simulated Apparent EnergADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
tra
Simulated Apparent Energy SpecADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
tra
Simulated Apparent Energy SpecADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
tra
Simulated Apparent Energy SpecADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
c) Images
Vertical Bend Diagnostic (Dowell DiagnostiADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
es
Simulation Produces Similar ImagADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
ing et al.)
ipoleis used
5nCrom theest Facility
Data from CTF II Experiments (L. Groen
0
0.25
0.5
0.75
1
1.25
1.5
1.75
2
0
0.25
0.5
0.75
1
1.25
1.5
1.75
2
5 10 15
Mom
entu
m L
oss
[MeV
/c]
σl = 1.25 mm
αl = 7.58
Exp CTF II hc = 15 mm
TraFiC4 hc = inf
ELEGANT hc = inf
σl = 1.00 mm
αl = 6.67
γεl = 350 µm
αl = 6.67
σl = 0.76 mm
αl = 5.63
R56 [mm]
σl = 0.53 mm
αl = 3.55
5 10 15
A four-dchicanewith a 1beam fCLIC TII.
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov
pressor
beam to match
ement.
e incoming
t dipole.
n wakefields.
symmetry.
er.)
Ideas for Future Work on APS Bunch Com
• New PARMELA simulations of photoinjectoractual conditions.
• Improve resolution of bunch length measur
• Perform tomography to accurately determinlongitudinal phase-space.
• Quantify effect of horizontal beamsize in las
• Verify that effects are due to CSR rather tha(Requires high charge.)
• Conduct experiments with variable and
(Requires completion of telescoping chamb
R56
ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE Operations Analysis Grouphttp://www.aps.anl.gov/asd/oag Michael Borland borland@aps.anl.gov