Managing a Complex World

Post on 14-Jul-2015

2.039 views 0 download

Tags:

Transcript of Managing a Complex World

Managing a complex world.

Innovation to commoditisation.

align to the business

keep up with latest trends

align to the business

keep up with latest trends focus on core

align to the business

keep up with latest trends focus on core

align to the business good

governance

keep up with latest trends focus on core

align to the business good

governance

detailed planning

keep up with latest trends focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

detailed planning

keep up with latest trends focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

detailed planning

flexible

keep up with latest trends focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

SAAS

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

Utility computingSAAS

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

Utility computingSAAS

Web 2.0

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

Utility computingSAAS

Web 2.0 Web 3.0

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

Utility computingSAAS

Web 2.0 Web 3.0

Enterprise 2.0

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

Utility computingSAAS

Web 2.0 Web 3.0

Enterprise 2.0

BPEL

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

Utility computingSAAS

Web 2.0 Web 3.0

Enterprise 2.0

BPELBPMN

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

Utility computingSAAS

Web 2.0 Web 3.0

Enterprise 2.0

BPELBPMNTOGAF

innovative

cost efficient

keep up with latest trends

show ROI

focus on core

adaptable

align to the business good

governance

secure

detailed planning

flexible

Utility computingSAAS

Web 2.0 Web 3.0

Enterprise 2.0

BPELBPMNTOGAF

Open source

Infamy, Infamy ...

PrintingDucksOpen Source

Information Tech.

Football

Chaos

Politics

Genetics

People

ParticipationFreedom

Environment

Electronics

PatentsCommoditisation

Maths

PrintingDucksOpen Source

Information Tech.

Football

Chaos

Politics

Genetics

People

ParticipationFreedom

Environment

Electronics

PatentsCommoditisation

Maths

Commoditisation

Commoditisation

Impact

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Why nothing is simple

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Why nothing is simple

Predictions

DANGER!Will Robinson

DANGER!

45 mins

385 slides

End of DANGER!

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Why nothing is simple

Predictions

change from monopolistic to perfect competition

Yesterday’s hot stuff

Today’s boredom

New ThingNew

New Thing Leading EdgeNew

New Thing ProductsLeading EdgeNew

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

1890’s

Electricity

Screenshot taken from web at http://www.sandowplus.co.uk/index2.htm

Screenshot taken from web at http://padovacultura.padovanet.it/homepage-6.0/Oliver%20twist%204.JPG

Chicago Daily News negatives collection, DN-0003451. Courtesy of the Chicago Historical Society.

Electricity is a powerful constitutional tonic

American Electrotherapeutic Association, 1892

Harvey Hubbell(1857-1927)

1890’s 1930’s

Electricity NationalGrid

Yesterday’s hot stuff

Today’s boredom

Internet

Power

CPU.

Internet

Power

CPU.

Google

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

The fundamental impulse that sets and keeps the capitalist engine in motion comes from the new consumers, goods, the new methods of production or transportation, the new markets, the new forms of industrial organization that capitalist enterprise creates.

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

The fundamental impulse that sets and keeps the capitalist engine in motion comes from the new consumers, goods, the new methods of production or transportation, the new markets, the new forms of industrial organization that capitalist enterprise creates.

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

Creative Destruction

New

Competitive Advantage

CommonUtility

Cost of doing business

Products

web

Competitive Advantage

Screenshots taken from web at http://www.strassmann.com/

Competitive Advantage

Nick Carr

As IT becomes ubiquitous ... it has no strategic

value

Cost of doing business

web 1.0

Yesterday’s hot stuff

Today’s boredom

web 2.0

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

Creative Destruction

1890’s 1930’s

Electricity NationalGrid

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Internet

Power

CPU.

Google

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

Creative Destruction

Nick Carr

As IT becomes ubiquitous ... it has no strategic

value

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Why nothing is simple

Predictions

+

+

Service

Service

Service

Service

Service

Service

App

Internal

App

Internal

Internal

Internal

Enterprise Service

Bus

External

Internal

External

App

Internal

Enterprise Service

Bus

External

Internal

External

App

App

Internal

External

Enterprise Service

Bus

App

External

Internal

External

App

App

Internal

External

Enterprise Service

Bus

App

External

Internal

External

App

App

Internal

External

Enterprise Service

Bus

Infrastructure

De ArchitecturaMarcus Vitruvius

Pollio(80-25 BC)

http://www.bl.uk/popups/science14-pop.html

Service Orientated Architecture

VirtualisationSoftware as a Service

(SaaS)

Utility computing

Grid Computing

modified from http://www.flickr.com/photos/juanillooo/471668553/

Definitions

Service Oriented Architecture (SOA)

An architectural style for creating and using business

processes as services.

Virtualisation

A technique for hiding physical characteristics of

computing resources from its consumers.

Grid computing

A technical architecture consisting of a collection of computers acting as though they are a single computer.

Utility computing

The packaging of computing resources, such as

computation and storage as a metered service.

Software as a Service (SaaS)

A delivery model where vendors operate and host

services for use by customers over the internet.

SOA

SaaS

Utility

Grid

Virtualisation

De ArchitecturaMarcus Vitruvius

Pollio(80-25 BC)

http://www.bl.uk/popups/science14-pop.html

Service Orientated Architecture

VirtualisationSoftware as a Service

(SaaS)

Utility computing

Grid Computing

Hardware

Application

Framework

New Thing ProductsLeading EdgeNew

Hardware

Application

Framework

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

Hardware

Application

Framework

Yesterday’s hot stuff

Today’s boredom

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Service

Service

Service

New

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

Creative Destruction

+

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Hardware

Application

Framework

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Why nothing is simple

Predictions

CommonNew

COMMODITISATION

CommonNew

New

Innovation

Innovation?

John Locke (1632 - 1704)

It being that term which, I think, serves best to stand for whatsoever is the object of understanding when man thinks.

InnovationIdea

Professor Jan Fagerberg

Innovation is the first attempt to carry out [an idea] into practice.

Q. the first wireless radio?

Nikola Tesla, 1893

Q. the first useable electric light bulb?

Sir Joseph Wilson Swan, 1860

Thomas Francois Dalibard, May 1752

Felix Du Temple, 1874

“Whenever you prove who was first, the harder you look you will find someone else who was

more first”

Eliot Sivowitch

Professor Jan Fagerberg

Innovation is the first-ish attempt to carry out [an idea] into practice.

InnovationIdea

InnovationIdea

Francesco Petrarca (1304 - 1374)

Founder of the Humanist movement (Renaissance)

InnovationIdea

Invention

Discovery

InnovationIdea

Invention

Discovery

InnovationIdea

Invention

Discovery

InnovationIdea

Invention

Discovery

InnovationIdea

Invention

Discovery

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

1. Not a straight line

Internet

Power

CPU.

Google

Idea

Invention

DiscoveryCo

mmo n

Innovation

Idea

Invention

DiscoveryCo

mmo n

Innovation

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

2. Not just things

Idea

Invention

Discovery

Practice

3. Not everything spreads

Idea

Invention

Discovery

Innovation

4. Acceleration

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

NETWORK EFFECTS

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

INTERNET

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

STANDARDS

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

OPEN SOURCE

5. Friend and Foe

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

NON STRATEGIC COST

Screenshot taken from web at http://www.sandowplus.co.uk/index2.htm

Distribution

Distribution

Distribution

Distribution

Barrier to Participation

Cost of Doing Business

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Hardware

Software

Framework

Service

Service

Service

New

Innovation?

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

Idea

Invention

Discovery

Practice

Idea

Invention

Discovery

Innovation

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

NETWORK EFFECTS

Printing and Distribution

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Why nothing is simple

Predictions

Idea

Invent

ion

Discov

ery

Common

Innova

tion

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

PrintingGraphsOpen Source

Information Tech.

Football

Fotango

Politics

Genetics

People

ParticipationFreedom

Environment

Electronics

PatentsCommoditisation

Maths

PrintingE=mc

Open Source

Information Tech.

Football

Fotango

Politics

Genetics

People

ParticipationFreedom

Environment

Electronics

PatentsCommoditisation

Maths

2

Activity

A process, sub-process or result thereof, including any product or service consumed

or created

Everett Rogers (1931-2004)

Adop

tion

Time

Ubiquity

Nove

l

Ubiquity

Nove

lCo

mmon

Ubiquity

Nove

lCo

mmon

Certainty

Nove

l

Low

Com

mon

Certainty

Nove

l CertaintyLow High

Com

mon

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Ubiquity

Certainty

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Ubiquity

Certainty

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Early 80s - innovation of CRM

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Mid 80s - early adoption of database

marketing.

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Early 90s - CRM products

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Early 00s - Utility-like

CRM

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Early 80s - innovation of CRM

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Innovation

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Early 00s - Utility-like

CRM

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Commodity

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Innovation

Commodity

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Innovation

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Scarcity of information

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Scarcity of information

Undefined

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Scarcity of information

Undefined

Few competitors

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Scarcity of information

Undefined

Few competitors

High Cost

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Deviation from norms is necessary

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Deviation from norms is necessary

Agile (XP, SCRUM)

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Deviation from norms is necessary

Agile (XP, SCRUM)

Competitive advantage

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Deviation from norms is necessary

Agile (XP, SCRUM)

VC like funding

Competitive advantage

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Web 3.0

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Commodity

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Wealth of information

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Wealth of information

Defined

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Wealth of information

Defined

Many competitors

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Wealth of information

Defined

Many competitors

Low Cost

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Deviation from norms is undesireable

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Deviation from norms is undesireable

Defined (Prince, Six Sigma)

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Deviation from norms is undesireable

Defined (Prince, Six Sigma)

Cost of doing business

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Deviation from norms is undesireable

Defined (Prince, Six Sigma)

Cost of doing business

Focus on cost

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Scarcity of information

Undefined

Few competitors

High Cost

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Telephone

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Innovation

Commodity

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Agile

Defined

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

CRM

CRM

Observation 1Methodologies

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Six Sigma

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Commodity

Six Sigma

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Six Sigma

Innovation

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Different Methodologies

Observation 2Outsourcing

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

IT Activities

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

IT Activities

Marketing Activities

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

Marketing Activities

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

Nove

l

Low

Commodity

High

Com

mon

Innovation

Nove

l

Low

Transition

High

Com

mon

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

Creative Destruction

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

Observation 3 Vendors

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Competitive Advantage

Exclusive

High ValueCustomer perception

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Product

Wealth of information

Low cost to produce

Many consumers

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Product

Customer perception

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Perception gap

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Branding

Observation 4Organisation

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

Nove

l

Low

Commodity

High

Com

mon

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

Six sigma

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Operations

IT

HR

Marketing

Sales

Finance

IT Activities

Marketing Activities

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Innovation CommodityTransition

Collective Intelligence

Knowledge Capture

Participation Architectures

Social Networks

Mass Collaboration

Wikis

Aggregation

Enterprise 2.0

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

The system must be able to equal the number of states in the input with at least an equivalent number of states in

the regulatory process

Ashby’s Law

Requisite Variety

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Defined

Survival requires ‘coherence, coordination and stability’.

Innovation requires the replacement of these erstwhile virtues.

Salaman & Storey

Innovation Paradox

Observation 5Order and Disorder

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Maintain office facilities

Set budgets

Manage payroll

Recruit staff

Capture customer request for service

Capture product predictions from information market

Audit site useabilityMaintain corporate wiki

Maintain search rank listing

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Maintain office facilities

Set budgets

Manage payroll

Recruit staff

Capture customer request for service

Capture product predictions from information market

Audit site useabilityMaintain corporate wiki

Maintain search rank listing

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Professor Leigh M. Van Valen

Red Queen Hypothesis

Adapt to survive today.

Adapt to survive today.

Innovate to survive tomorrow.

De ArchitecturaMarcus Vitruvius

Pollio(80-25 BC)

http://www.bl.uk/popups/science14-pop.html

Herbert A. Simon 1916-2001

Theory of Hiearchy

Competitive

Competitive

Cost of Doing Business

Competitive

Cost of Doing Business

Nove

l

Low

Commodity

High

Com

mon

Competitive

Cost of Doing Business

App

External

Internal

External

App

App

Internal

External

Enterprise Service Bus

Infrastructure

Competitive

Cost of Doing Business

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Innovation

Survival requires ‘coherence, coordination and stability’.

Innovation requires the replacement of these erstwhile virtues.

Salaman & Storey

Innovation Paradox

Yesterday’s hot stuff

Today’s boredom

Nick Carr

As IT becomes ubiquitous ... it has no strategic

value

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Hardware

Software

Framework

App

External

Internal

External

App

App

Internal

External

Enterprise Service

Bus

Infrastructure

Service

Service

Service

Innovations

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Innovation

Commodity

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Different Methodologies

Innovation

Nove

l

Low

Transition

High

Com

mon

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Perception gap

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Defined

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

Creative Destruction

Adapt to survive today.

Innovate to survive tomorrow.

Survival requires ‘coherence, coordination and stability’.

Innovation requires the replacement of these erstwhile virtues.

Salaman & Storey

Innovation Paradox

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Why nothing is simple

Predictions

DANGER!Will Robinson

DANGER!

Practical Steps

Low HighCertainty

Innovation

First Mover

Transitional

CommodityNo

vel

Com

mon

Ubiquity

Low HighCertainty

Transitional

CommodityNo

vel

Com

mon

Ubiquity

Low HighCertainty

Innovation

First Mover

Nove

lCo

mmon

Ubiquity

Uncertain & Risky

Investment strategy

Potential CA

Deviation is necessary

Unknown market / effect

You’re on your own

+ve

-ve

Time

Low HighCertainty

Nove

lCo

mmon

Ubiquity

Effe

ctInnovation

+ve

-ve

Time

Low HighCertainty

Nove

lCo

mmon

Ubiquity

Effe

ctFirst Mover

Prediction is possible

ROI strategy

Actual CA

Customisation focus

Estimate market / effect

Some competition

+ve

-ve

Time

Low HighCertainty

Nove

lCo

mmon

Ubiquity

Effe

ctTransition

Whitepapers / Conferences

ROI strategy

Declining CA

Standardisation focus

Early KPIs

Many competitors

+ve

-ve

Time

Low HighCertainty

Nove

lCo

mmon

Ubiquity

Effe

ctCommodity

Best practices etc.

Cost focus

Cost of doing business

Defined processes

KPI driven

Consolidation / outsourcing

Low HighCertainty

Pioneer

Colonist

Town PlannerNo

vel

Com

mon

Ubiquity

Map your business

Be aware of lifecycle

Think componentisation

Think organisation

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Defined

Commoditisation

Impact

Innovation

Why nothing is simple

Predictions

De ArchitecturaMarcus Vitruvius

Pollio(80-25 BC)

http://www.bl.uk/popups/science14-pop.html

Nove

l

Low

Commodity

High

Com

mon

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Hardware

Software

Framework

App

External

Internal

External

App

App

Internal

External

Enterprise Service

Bus

Infrastructure

Service

Service

Service

Innovations

Idea

Invention

Discovery

CommonInnovation

1. An increase in the rate at which innovative services and products are released to the web.

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Hardware

Software

Framework

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

Hardware

Software

Framework

NON STRATEGIC COST

Barrier to Participation

Non-StrategicCODB

Competitive Advantage

2. More disruption in the information markets.

New Thing Products CommonUtility

Leading EdgeNew

PRESSURE

Hardware

Software

Framework

De ArchitecturaMarcus Vitruvius

Pollio(80-25 BC)

http://www.bl.uk/popups/science14-pop.html

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Defined

Joseph A. Schumpeter (1883 - 1950)

Creative Destruction

Survival requires ‘coherence, coordination and stability’.

Innovation requires the replacement of these erstwhile virtues.

Salaman & Storey

Innovation Paradox

3. Increasing organisational pressure within IT.

App

External

Internal

External

App

App

Internal

External

Enterprise Service

Bus

Infrastructure

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Maintain office facilities

Set budgets

Manage payroll

Recruit staff

Capture customer request for service

Capture product predictions from information market

Audit site useabilityMaintain corporate wiki

Maintain search rank listing

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Innovation

Commodity

Nove

l

Low High

Com

mon

Branding

4.The architecture will never be completed.

1. Faster, Faster.

2. More disruption.

1. Faster, Faster.

3. Increasing pressure.

2. More disruption.

1. Faster, Faster.

4. Never completed.

3. Increasing pressure.

2. More disruption.

1. Faster, Faster.

Infamy, Infamy ...

swardley@mac.comhttp://blog.gardeviance.org

For Hire! Events &

ConsultancyInterim Exec.

Advisory Board.+ ...

swardley@mac.comhttp://blog.gardeviance.org

Sponsor! Your company

XTECHWeb 2.0 Strategy

+ many more ...