Post on 11-Jan-2016
1
Lesson 7Georg Simmel
Robert Wonser
SOC 368 – Classical Sociological Theory
Spring 2014
2Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
Simmel’s Life
Born in Berlin to a middle class Jewish family in 1858 which had converted to Christianity.
Simmel’s father died when Georg was very young, and he was not close to his mother.
Simmel experienced social marginality both in the family and in his academic life.
Simmel saw the social life of contemporary societies as creating social marginalization, but as opposed to Marx, Durkheim, and Weber, he saw this a having positive attributes.
3
Simmel’s Life
Attended the University of BerlinDoctoral thesis on the philosophy of Immanuel
KantSimmel was in the midst of a thriving intellectual
German communityJews and radicals were marginalized from this
community – Simmel among themBecause he could not secure a permanent
academic position, Simmel became a lecturer – living off student fees
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
4
Simmel’s Life
He became enormously popular among students and offered courses on a wide array of subjects – logic, ethics, philosophy, political science, psychology, sociology
Simmel experienced anti-Semitism and the jealously of the academic community
Simmel finally became a full professor in 1914, only to die 4 years later
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
5
Intellectual Influences: Max Weber
Simmel and Weber were very close friends and intellectual peers
Simmel disagreed with Weber’s search for historical particularities, and instead focused on invariant laws of social life
Simmel and Weber both offered challenges to the Marxian critique of the capitalist political economy
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
6
Intellectual Influences: Herbert SpencerSimmel’s first sociological work: Social
Differentiation (1890) was indebted to Spencerian sociology
Simmel’s later work maintains this focus of the importance of differentiation and more importantly the relevance of social structures in social life
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
7
Intellectual Influences: Immanuel KantKant is interested in what he calls “pure
reason” based upon a “categorical imperative”The “transcendental aesthetic” is that by which
human beings transform the buzz and chaos of the phenomenal world into meaningful order
This creates a “transcendental logic” whereby perceptual knowledge is transformed into conceptual knowledge
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
8
Intellectual Influences: Immanuel Kantsense knowledge perceptual knowledge
conceptual knowledgewhat drives this process is a structured set of
categories which are embedded in the human mindwhereas Kant argues that structures exist in the
mind, Simmel modifies Kant’s argument by suggesting that structures exist in social relationships
Simmel asks the question – what are the basic forms of interaction, or structures which affect social action?
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
9
Intellectual Influence: Karl Marx
Simmel argues against Marx’s labor theory of value – for Simmel the price of a product is based upon supply and demand, and social desire (social distance) The greater the difficulty in obtaining an object, the greater its value.
Simmel argues that alienation is natural in a society which is large, complex, and highly differentiated, and that competition is an important factor in the reduction of social alienation – free competition increases the free circulation of social exchanges
Money is not as oppressive commodity, as Marx contended, but is instead a generalized medium of social exchange which increases social interaction The ultimate tool
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
10
Simmel’s Approach to Sociology
What makes sociology different from other disciplines? Isn’t it just an arbitrary label?
Simmel says no. Sociology is the study of social interaction
and the consequences of social interaction.
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
11
Simmel’s Approach to Sociology
Simmel’s three questions:What is society?How should sociology study
society?What are the problem areas of
sociology?
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
12
Levels and Areas of Concern
1) Macroscopic assumptions about the psychological components of social life
2) Sociological components of interpersonal relationships
3) Structure of, changes in, cultural “spirit” of his times 1) higher levels emerge out of lower levels2) “if society is to be an autonomous object of an
independent science, then it can only be so through the fact that, out of the sum of the individual elements that constitute it, a new entity emerges; otherwise all problems of social science would be those of individual psychology”
4) Ultimate metaphysical principles of life
13
Simmel’s Approach to Sociology
Groups and the Forms of social lifeThe Geometric Metaphor: Focus on Form over Context
(goals, values, purposes, etc.)Sociology’s Problem Areas:General/Historical Sociology – focus on invariant
patterns of form (and content, while distinguishing both)Pure/Formal Sociology (generic social processes,
structured role relationships)Philosophical Sociology – (epistemological questions, or
metatheoretical questions) – what is the relationship between individual and society?
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
14
The Web of Group Affiliations
How does social differentiation affect social relationships and networks of group life?
The most important variable is social differentiation.
Change from organic (local in-group) to rational (cosmopolitan)
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
15
The Web of Group Affiliations
Consequences of social differentiation:role conflictrole strainmultiple identities and social uniquenessincreased personal freedomcognitive complexityEmpathy
social differentiation creativity social complexity
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
16
Conflict
Conflict is generally seen as a destructive social force.
This emerges when one looks at the contents of the conflict
Conflict, however, is a social form which facilitates social solidarity
While Simmel argues that humans have an innate fighting instinct that is the cause of social conflict, conflict is best understood as a socially organized phenomenon.
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
17
Conflict
The basic form of conflict: Generally, social conflict is oriented towards a goal/purpose.
Conflict within groups:With groups of strong similarity or personal connection
– conflict can emerge over very petty concerns, and these conflicts can be highly emotionally charged.
Differences can be a sign of personal and group threat.
Conflicts against accepted opponents can be direct or indirect (competition) – rule bound, “one unites in order to fight,” competition promotes social solidarity.
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
18
Conflict
Conflict between groups:increases group centralization – “miserable
people loves miserable company.”increases social solidarity within each group
reduces the amount of tolerance for deviance and dissent.
increases the probability of coalition formation among similarly aligned groups.
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
19
Philosophy of Money
the focus is on the establishment of social exchange relationships as a social form, in particular economic exchanges
Money is both a cause and consequence of social differentiation
Humans are teleological, and use many tools to accomplish their goals
Money is an incredible social tool because is it abstract, fluid, and subject to great manipulation
The use of money allows for an increase in the number of groups to which an individual can belong.
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
20
Philosophy of Money
The value of an object is based upon supply and demand, upon the subjective/objective split.
Money becomes a standardized yardstick for the measurement of value, and is an extension of human nature
Money can become the value of anything – ethics, love, aesthetics, etc. – and thus can change or replace social relationships.
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
21
Money
Money can become the value of anything – ethics, love, aesthetics, etc. – and thus can change or replace social relationships.Example: prostitution
How did Simmel feel about this ability of money?Money performs the interesting function of
creating distance between people and objects and then providing the means to overcome that distance.Another example of his dialectical thinking
22
Philosophy of Money
Money and the Social Whole:
1)increases the velocity of exchange
2)value of money increases as does the perception that needs can be realized
3)creates options for social exchange and helps to create social continuity
4)allows for the creation of multiple ties
5)increases the distance of exchange Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological
Theory
23
Philosophy of Money
6) promotes trust, solidarity, and commitment
7) increases the importance of a centralized government (taxes)
8) taxes promote solidarity
9) penetrates all social relations
10)increase the quantification and objectification of social relations
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
24
Philosophy of Money
Money and the Individual:1)increases personal freedom and choice
2)increases self expression through material acquisition
3)creates distance between self and material objects which can be discarded
4)money increases the multiplicity of social involvements, but reduces strong emotional ties
5)money mediates personal interaction
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
25
More Money, more…
Problems arise because all these developments are at the level of objective culture and are integral parts of the process by which objective culture grows and further impoverishes individual culture.
Money is the purest form of exchange, process continues on in perpetuity (unlike in barter systems)
26
Objective Culture and Individual (Subjective Culture)Cultural level of social reality, “objective culture,”
things that people produce (like art, science, philosophy, etc.)
People produce culture, but we can reify social reality, the cultural world and the social world come to have lives of their own, lives that come to dominate the actors who created and daily re-create them.
Over time objective culture exerts more control over the individual.
Individual (subjective culture) is the capacity of the actor to produce, absorb, and control elements of the objective culture.
27
Objective Culture
Grows and expands in various ways:
1) Absolute size grows with modernization
2) number of different components of the cultural realm grows
3) Elements of cultural world become more entwined in an ever more powerful, self-contained world that is increasingly beyond control of the actors.
28
Objective Culture
Simmel worried what would happen to individual culture…
“The total value of something increases to the same extent as the value of its individual parts decline.” (Simmel 1907/1978:199)
tragedy of culture
29
More-Life and More-Than-Life
Simmel’s answer to Marx’s fetishism of commodities.People possess a transcendent abilityFirst, creative capacities (more-life), people are able to
transcend themselves.Second, this transcendent, creative ability makes it
possible to produce sets of objects that transcend them.What we’ve created (more-than-life) come in opposition to
more-life that produced objects in the first place.We’ve reified our individual cultural output into objective
culture which restrict further cultural output.Stifling them, like an iron cage almost…
30
Urban Sociology
“Metropolis and Mental Life”Metropolis as the “genuine arena”
where objective culture comes to dominate individual culture.
It is where money lives…Creates the blasé and reserved
attitude
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory
31
Metropolis and Mental Life
The city is the “frightful leveler” where everyone is reduced to a rational calculating actor.
Cannot maintain individuality in the face of the expansion of objective culture.
Although, people are freer here than in small towns.
32
Tragedy of Culture
Simmel saw the significance of the individual declining as money transactions become an increasingly important part of society and as reified structures expand.
The loss of individual subjective culture in the face of the expansion of objective culture
33
Fashion
Conforming to fashion allows us to conform to the group
Fashion is also the norm if we wish to deviate that we depart from
Everyone accepts what is fashionable, then some deviate from this, creating a new sense of fashion. Process repeats ad infinitum…
Fashions are doomed to not last
34
Social Geometry
NumbersDyad – group of twoTriad – three-person group
what effect does adding a third person do to the group?
Movement from dyad to triad is essential to the development of social structures that can become separate and dominant over, individuals.
35
Social Geometry
Group size increases individual freedomAlso scares into retreating into small groups, like
the family.Distance “the properties of forms and the
meanings of things are a function of the relative distances between individuals and other individuals or things.”
“the stranger” is psychologically far but physically near
36
Key Ideas
society is composed of exchange relationships – through money, conversation, symbols, friendship, love, conflict
conflict can be functionaldeveloped an interest in urban environments
and the social alienation they producethe modern world creates a blasé attitude“the stranger”
Lesson 7: Georg Simmel, Classical Sociological Theory