Post on 05-Apr-2018
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
1/55
1
NiTi based Shape Memory Alloys and its Medical
Applications
Seminar Report
By
Divyanshu Singh
Roll No. 08011002
Aniket Patni
Roll No. 08011018
Department of Metallurgical Engineering and Materials Science
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay
(April 2011)
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
2/55
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
3/55
3
4.2.1 Crystallographic Aspects in MT4.2.2 Superelasticity
4.3Transformation Thermodynamics4.3.1 Thermodynamic Characteristics
4.4Transformation Kinetics4.4.1 Reaction Order
4.5Thermodynamic & Kinetics Conclusion4.6Memory in MT4.7Stability in Material Response4.8Macroscopic Characterization of Shape Memory Alloys
4.8.1 Reaction Order4.8.2 StressStrain Temperature Tests
4.8.2.1Isobaric Tests4.8.2.2Isothermal Tests
5. Medical Applications ofNitinol.... 325.1Inferior Vena-Cava Filters5.1.1 Medical Complications5.1.2 Treatment Techniques5.1.3 Requirements of an Ideal Filter5.1.4 Advantages & Properties of Nitinol making it suitable for use as filters5.1.5 Disadvantages associated with using SMAs other than Nitinol
5.2Intra Vascular Stents5.2.1 Medical Complications5.2.2 Treatment Involved5.2.3 Requirements of an Ideal Stent5.2.4 Suitability of NiTi and properties that render it useful
5.3Stent Grafts5.3.1 Medical Complications5.3.2 Treatment Involved & Application of Nitinol
5.4Nitinol Guidewires & Other Surgical Instruments5.4.1 Medical Complications5.4.2 Suitability of NiTi for this application
5.5Orthopaedic Applications5.5.1
Medical Complications
5.5.2 Properties of Nitinol making it suitable for use5.6Dental Applications
References54
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
4/55
4
1. INTRODUCTIONShape memory alloys (SMAs) exhibit two fascinating characteristic behaviors, viz., shape
memory (SME) and superelasticity (SE) or pseudoelasticity (PE). Hence, they are also
classified as smart materials or intelligent materials or active materials. Two broad
classes of SMAs exist, viz., thermally activated and magnetically activated.
The focus of the present review is on the more prevalent thermally activated SMAs. The key
characteristic of SMAs is the martensitic phase transformation, brought about by temperature
change and/or by application of stress. In SMAs, Martensitic Transformation (MT) is
between a high-symmetric, usually cubic, austenitic/parent phase (A/P) and a low symmetric
martensitic phase (M), such as their monoclinic variants. This reversible phase change can be
brought about by much smaller temperature change compared to conventional phasetransformation like solidification. MT is usually accompanied by significant changes in
mechanical, electrical and thermal properties that render them as prime candidates for the
development of smart structures and devices. Typical examples of SMAs are NiTi
(commonly referred to as nitinol), NiTiCu, CuAlZn and CuAlNi.
Shape Memory Effect
Fig 1: Schematic of phase transformation in SMAs; (a)-(b)-(c) is a typical shape memory
cycle. (a)-(c) under stress cycling represents Superelastic cycle; (a)-(c) under thermal cycling
represents another shape memory path.[2]
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
5/55
5
2. Shape Memory AlloysA shape memory alloy (SMA, smart metal, memory metal, memory alloy, muscle wire, smart
alloy) is an alloy that "remembers" its original, cold-forged shape: returning the pre-
deformed shape by heating. This material is a lightweight, solid-state alternative to
conventional actuators such as hydraulic, pneumatic, and motor-based systems. Shape
memory alloys have applications in industries including medical and aerospace Definition
by Wikipedia
Mf is the temperature at which the transition to martensite completes upon cooling.
Accordingly, during heating As and Afare the temperatures at which the transformation from
martensite to austenite starts and finishes. Repeated use of the shape memory effect may lead
to a shift of the characteristic transformation temperatures (this effect is known as functional
fatigue, as it is closely related with a change of microstructural and functional properties of
the material).
The transition from the martensite phase to the austenite phase is only dependent on
temperature and stress, not time, as most phase changes are, as there is no diffusion involved.
Similarly, the austenite structure receives its name from steel alloys of a similar structure. It
is the reversible diffusionless transition between these two phases that results in special
properties. While martensite can be formed from austenite by rapidly cooling carbon-steel,
this process is not reversible, so steel does not have shape memory properties.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
6/55
6
Fig 2.1 (T) represents the martensite fraction. The difference between the heating transition
and the cooling transition gives rise to hysteresis where some of the mechanical energy is lost
in the process. The shape of the curve depends on the material properties of the shape
memory alloy, such as the alloying and work hardening. [B1]
2.1 Classification Shape Memory Alloys
Shape memory alloys are classified in many ways (like Two broad classes of SMAs exist,
viz., thermally activated and magnetically activated) but most it as they have different shape
memory effects. Two common effects are one-way and two-way shape memory. A schematic
of the effects is shown below.
Fig 2.2 - The procedures are very similar: starting from martensite (a), adding a reversible
deformation for the one-way effect or severe deformation with an irreversible amount for the
two-way (b), heating the sample (c) and cooling it again (d). [B1]
2.1.1 One-way memory effect
When a shape memory alloy is in its cold state (below As), the metal can be bent or stretched
and will hold those shapes until heated above the transition temperature. Upon heating, the
shape changes to its original. When the metal cools again it will remain in the hot shape, until
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:SMAtwoway.jpghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:SMAoneway.jpghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:SMAtwoway.jpghttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:SMAoneway.jpg7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
7/55
7
deformed again. With the one-way effect, cooling from high temperatures does not cause a
macroscopic shape change.
2.1.2 Two-way memory effect
The two-way shape memory effect is the effect that the material remembers two different
shapes: one at low temperatures, and one at the high-temperature shape. A material that
shows a shape memory effect during both heating and cooling is called two-way shape
memory. This can also be obtained without the application of an external force (intrinsic two-
way effect). The reason the material behaves so differently in these situations lies in training.
Training implies that a shape memory can "learn" to behave in a certain way. Under normal
circumstances, a shape memory alloy "remembers" its high-temperature shape, but upon
heating to recover the high-temperature shape, immediately "forgets" the low-temperature
shape. However, it can be "trained" to "remember" to leave some reminders of the deformed
low-temperature condition in the high-temperature phases. There are several ways of doing
this. A shaped, trained object heated beyond a certain point will lose the two-way memory
effect; this is known as "amnesia".
2.2 General Properties and Manufacture
2.2.1 Uniqueness of Shape Memory Alloys
Many metals have several different crystal structures at the same composition, but most
metals do not show this shape memory effect. The special property that allows shape
memory alloys to revert to their original shape after heating is that their crystal
transformation is fully reversible. In most crystal transformations, the atoms in the structure
will travel through the metal by diffusion, changing the composition locally, even though the
metal as a whole is made of the same atoms. A reversible transformation does not involve
this diffusion of atoms, instead all the atoms shift at the same time to form a new structure,
much in the way a parallelogram can be made out of a square by pushing on two opposing
sides. At different temperatures, different structures are preferred and when the structure is
cooled through the transition temperature, the martensitic structure forms from the austenitic
phase.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
8/55
8
2.2.2 Superelasticity
Pure mechanical loading can induce MT when the material is in the austenitic phase. Fig1
schematically illustrates this effect. Upon loading Stress Induced Martensite (SIM) is directly
produced from pure austenite phaseleading to large macroscopic strains which are recovered
by unloading when the temperature is above Af. This is referred to as Superelastic or
Pseudoelastic effect and is illustrated in Fig 2.3. Critical stresses at which the forward and
reverse transformation occurs again illustrate the associated hysteretic behavior. Most of the
bio-medical and damping applications of shape memory materials exploit this effect.
Fig 2.3: Superelasticity effect; (a) load path a-b-c-d-e-a on stress-temperature diagram; (b)
stress-strain hysteresis response. [2]
2.2.3 Mechanical Properties
The yield strength of shape memory alloys is lower than that of conventional steel, but some
compositions have a higher yield strength than plastic or aluminum. The yield stress for Ni Ti
can reach 500 MPa. The high cost of the metal itself and the processing requirements make it
difficult and expensive to implement SMAs into a design. As a result, these materials are
used in applications where the super elastic properties or the shape memory effect can be
exploited. The most common application is in actuation.
One of the advantages to using shape memory alloys is the high level of recoverable plastic
strain that can be induced. The maximum recoverable strain these materials can hold without
permanent damage is up to 8% for some alloys. This compares with a maximum strain 0.5%
for conventional steels.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal_%28unit%29http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal_%28unit%297/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
9/55
9
2.2.4 Manufacturing
The copper-based and NiTi-based shape memory alloys are considered to be engineering
materials. These compositions can be manufactured to almost any shape and size.
Shape memory alloys are typically made by casting, using vacuum arc melting or induction
melting. These are specialist techniques used to keep impurities in the alloy to a minimum
and ensure the metals are well mixed. The ingot is then hot rolled into longer sections and
then drawn to turn it into wire.
The way in which the alloys are "trained" depends on the properties wanted. The "training"
dictates the shape that the alloy will remember when it is heated. This occurs by heating the
alloy so that the dislocations re-order into stable positions, but not so hot that the material
recrystallizes. They are heated to between 400 C and 500 C for 30 minutes. Typical
variables for some alloys are 500 C and for more than 5 minutes.
They are then shaped while hot and are cooled rapidly by quenching in water or by cooling
with air.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
10/55
10
3. NitinolOur case of study
Fig 3.1 Nitinol Strip [3]
Nickel titanium, also known as nitinol, is a metal alloy of nickel and titanium, where the two
elements are present in roughly equal atomic percentages.
Nitinol alloys exhibit two closely related and unique properties: shape memory and
superelasticity (also called pseudoelasticity). Shape memory refers to the ability of nitinol to
undergo deformation at one temperature, and then recover its original, undeformed shape
upon heating above its "transformation temperature". Superelasticity occurs at a narrow
temperature range just above its transformation temperature; in this case, no heating is
necessary to cause the undeformed shape to recover, and the material exhibits enormous
elasticity, some 10-30 times that of ordinary metal.
3.1 History
The term nitinol is derived from its composition and its place of discovery: (Nickel Titanium
Naval Ordnance Laboratory). William J. Buehleralong with Frederick Wang, discovered its
properties during research at the Naval Ordnance Laboratory in 1962.
While the potential applications for nitinol were realized immediately, practical efforts to
commercialize the alloy didn't take place until a decade later. This delay was largely because
of the extraordinary difficulty of melting, processing and machining the alloy. Even these
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
11/55
11
efforts encountered financial challenges that weren't really overcome until the 1990s, when
these practical difficulties finally began to be resolved.
The discovery of the shape-memory effect in general dates back to 1932 when Swedish
researcher Arne Olander first observed the property in gold-cadmium alloys. The same effect
was observed in Cu-Zn in the early 1950s.
3.2 NitinolMechanism Introduction
Fig 3.2 Austenite and Martensite structures of the NiTi compound. [B2]
Nitinol's unusual properties are derived from a reversible, solid state phase transformation
known as a martensitic transformation.
At high temperatures, nitinol assumes an interpenetrating simple cubic crystal structure
referred to as austenite (also known as the parent phase). At low temperatures, nitinolspontaneously transforms to a more complicated monoclinic crystal structure known as
martensite. The temperature at which austenite transforms to martensite is generally referred
to as the transformation temperature (To).
Crucial to nitinols properties are two key aspects of this phase transformation. First is that
the transformation is reversible, meaning that heating above the transformation
temperature will revert the crystal structure to the simpler austenite phase. Upon heating,
however, there is a slight upward shift in the temperatures, now beginning at the A s
temperature, and finishing at the Af temperature. The second key point is that the
transformation in both directions is instantaneous.
Martensite's crystal structure (known as a monoclinic, or B19' structure) has the unique
ability to undergo limited deformation in some ways without breaking atomic bonds. This
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Nitinol_Austenite_and_martensite.jpg7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
12/55
12
type of deformation is known as twinning, which consists of the rearrangement of atomic
planes without causing slip, or permanent deformation. It is able to undergo about 6-8%
strain in this manner. When martensite is reverted to Austenite by heating, the original
austenitic structure is restored, regardless of whether the martensite phase was deformed.
Thus the name "shape memory" refers to the fact that the shape of the high temperature
austenite phase is "remembered," even though the alloy is severely deformed at a lower
temperature.
A great deal of force can be produced by preventing the reversion of deformed martensite to
austenite - in many cases, more than 100,000 psi. One of the reasons that nitinol works so
hard to return its original shape is that it is not just an ordinary metal alloy, but what is
known as an intermetallic compound. In an ordinary alloy, the constituents are randomlypositioned on the crystal lattice; in an ordered intermetallic compound, the atoms (in this
case, nickel and titanium) have very specific locations in the lattice. The fact that nitinol is an
intermetallic is largely responsible for the difficulty in fabricating devices made from the
alloy.
Fig 3.3 The effect of nitinol composition on the Ms Temperature [B2]
The scenario described above (cooling austenite to form martensite, deforming the
martensite, then heating to revert to austenite, thus returning the original, undeformed shape)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Nitinol_Ms_vs_Ni_content.jpg7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
13/55
13
is known as the thermal shape memory effect. A second effect, called superelasticity or
pseudoelasticity is also observed in nitinol. This effect is the direct result of the fact that
martensite can be formed by applying a stress as well as by cooling. Thus in a certain
temperature range, one can apply a stress to austenite, causing martensite to form while at the
same time changing shape. In this case, as soon as the stress is removed, the nitinol will
spontaneously return to its original shape. In this mode of use, nitinol behaves like a super
spring, possessing an elastic range some 10 to 30 times greater than that of a normal spring
material. There are, however, constraints: the effect is only observed some 0-40 degrees C
above the Aftemperature.
Nitinol is typically composed of approximately 50 to 51% nickel by atomic percent (55 to
56% weight percent). Making small changes in the composition can change the transitiontemperature of the alloy significantly. One can control the Af temperature in nitinol to some
extent, but convenient super elastic temperature ranges are from about -20 degrees to +60
degrees C.
One often-encountered complication regarding nitinol is the so-called R-Phase. The R-Phase
is another martensitic phase that competes with the martensite phase mentioned above.
Because it does not offer the large memory effects of the martensite phase, it is, more often
than not, an annoyance. We will study the complete mechanism in just a short while
3.3 Making nitinol and nitinol devices
Nitinol is exceedingly difficult to make due to the exceptionally tight compositional control
required, and the tremendous reactivity of titanium. Every atom of titanium that combines
with oxygen or carbon is an atom that is robbed from the NiTi lattice, thus shifting the
composition and making the transformation temperature that much colder. There are two
primary melting methods used today:
Vacuum Arc Remelting: This is done by striking an electrical arc between the rawmaterial and a water-cooled copper strike plate. Melting is done in a high vacuum,
and the mold itself is water cooled copper, so no carbon is introduced during melting.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
14/55
14
Fig 3.4 Annealing Line [3]
Vacuum Induction Melting: This is done by using alternating magnetic fields to heatthe raw materials in a crucible (generally carbon). This is also done in a high vacuum,
but carbon is introduced during the process.
While both methods have advantages, there are no substantive data showing that material
from one process is better than the other. Other methods are also used on a boutique scale,
including plasma arc melting, induction skull melting, and e-beam melting. Physical vapor
deposition is also used on a laboratory scale.
Hot working of nitinol is relatively easy, but cold working is difficult because the enormous
elasticity of the alloy increases die or roll contact, leading to tremendous frictional resistance
and tool wear. For similar reasons, machining is extremely difficultto make things worse,
the thermal conductivity of nitinol is poor, so heat is difficult to remove. Grinding (abrasive
cutting), Electrical discharge machining (EDM) and laser cutting are all relatively easy.
Heat treating nitinol is delicate and critical. It is the essential tool in fine-tuning the
transformation temperature. Aging time and temperature controls the precipitation of various
Ni-rich phases, and thus controls how much nickel resides on the NiTi lattice; by depleting
the matrix of nickel, aging increases the transformation temperature. The combination of heat
treatment and cold working is essential in controlling the properties of nitinol.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
15/55
15
4. SHAPE MEMORY EFFECT: MECHANISM4.1 Martensitic Transformations
The face centered cubic austenite transformed into lens shaped or plate like regions with
body centered cubic lattices or body centered tetragonal lattices. The crystals created by such
transformations are called Martensite and lattice transformations without atomic diffusion
are called Martensitic Transformations or simply, MTs.
Diffusionless martensitic transformations have since been observed in many metals, alloys
and compounds other than steel. Today the term martensitic transformation is widely used
and signifies one type of phase transitions in solids.
Martensitic transformation can be defined simply and precisely: a lattice transformation
involving shearing deformation and resulting from cooperative atomic movement. The atoms
within the lens or plate shaped areas in the parent phase are not shifted independently but
undergo shearing deformation as a unit while maintaining a domino- like coordination until
the parent lattice transform into martensite. With this kind of cooperative movement of
atoms, a 1-to-1 correspondence, called a lattice correspondence, persists between the lattice
points in the parent phase and the points in the martensite phase. When the parent phase has a
superlattice structure, this ensures that the martensite phase obtained from transformations
maintaining such a lattice correspondence will have a specific superlattice.
The properties listed below follow from the martensitic transformations:
1. The martensite phase is a substitutional or interstitial solid solution.
2. The transformation is diffusionless. The concentration of solute atoms dissolved in the
martensitic phase is equal to that in the parent phase. There is no long distance diffusion such
as occurs in eutectoid transformations.
3. The transformation is accompanied by shape changes (or surface relief) of a definite value.
If the surface of a specimen which begins to transform below room temperature is, in the
parent(P) stage, polished and made planar and then cooled below room temperature to induce
the transformation, some regions where the martensite (M) phase appears on the surface will
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
16/55
16
exhibit relief effects like those shown in Fig(a).. Further, if a scratch line is constructed on
the surface in the line at the boundaries between the P and M phases as shown in (b). The
inclination of the surface relief and the bends in the scratch line will have definite values
depending upon the crystal orientation of the P phase. This is because the shape changes
accompanying the transformation are of a definite value and is typically taken as proof that
the transformation mechanism involved is shearing deformation.
Fig 4.1 Formation of Surface Relief and Bending of Scratch Line Accompanying Martensitic
Transformation [1]
4. An M crystal has a specific habit plane. This is the interference between the P and M
phases in Fig (4.1a), that is the plane along which shear occurs during the transformation.
Habit planes are specified by indices of planes in the parent phase: there are many cases in
which they are irrational.
5. There is a definite orientation relationship between the P and M phase lattices.
6. Lattice defects necessarily exist in the M crystal. Even if a shearing deformation equal to
the measured shape change is induced along the habit plane in the P phase lattice, a true M
phase lattice cannot be obtained. This contradiction can be resolved from the following
considerations. As shown in Fig 4.2, when a shearing deformation (b) like that which
changes P phase lattice to the M phase lattice is induced, complimentary slip (c) or twinning
(d) deformations occur.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
17/55
17
Fig 4.2 Lattice Deformation and Complimentary Slip Shear and Twinning Shear (dotted lines
show the actual shape change) [1]
Such complimentary deformations are called lattice invariants strains and their traces, such
as dislocation and stacking or twinning faults have been observed by electron microscopes.
The twin faults especially perform a major role in the shape memory effect and two closely
related phenomena, twinning pseudoelasticity and bending pseudo-elasticity.
4.2 Characteristics of the Martensitic Transformation in Shape Memory AlloysMartensitic transformation (MT) which has several fascinating features has been investigated
extensively in the context of both single and polycrystalline SMAs. Even after nearly four
decades of effort, several unresolved and challenging aspects in MT make it still an open
problem for active research. Thus, various disciplines in materials research ranging from
molecular dynamics to continuum irreversible thermodynamics at macroscale are being
employed. A brief discussion on several relevant aspects of MT in SMAs is presented here to
facilitate better understanding of modeling approaches for SMA response.
4.2.1 Crystallographic Aspects in MT
As noted earlier, MT is a diffusionless reversible solid-solid phase transformation occurring
by activation and/or nucleation and growth of the martensitic phase from a parent austenitic
phase.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
18/55
18
Generally inelastic shear or distortion associated with the crystal lattice is the dominant
deformation mechanism with only cooperative and collective motion of atoms on distances
smaller than the lattice parameters. The characteristic size of martensitic plates is very small,
typically of the order of few microns. The deformation mode is twinning rather than slip
(occurring during conventional plastic deformation) of the crystallographic planes which
gives it the reversible nature. A lattice invariant strain-free plane, also called habit plane
exists at the interface between the product and parent phases. Depending on the alloy, the
lattice vectors of the two phases possess well defined mutual orientation relationships (the
Bain correspondences).
Fig 4.3: Different martensitic transformation pathways in NiTi based alloys [2]
These bring out the coherency aspects of the two different microstructures and play a critical
role in the kinetics and morphology of phase transformation process. The absence of
diffusion makes MT almost instantaneous and also athermal or thermoelastic. Theoretically,
the transformation occurs at the speed of sound in the material . However, in polycrystalline
materials, it is possible that under certain conditions, the transformation occurs at much
slower rates.
Generally monoclinic B19 yields maximum transformation strain, followed by orthorhombic
(B19) with least transformation strain seen in trigonal (Rhombohedral- R) phase. The number
of variants of the lower symmetry structure that can form from the parent cubic structure is
determined by the nature of symmetry of the parent structure and the product structure.
Hence, even in a single crystal parent, when there is transformation, the product is
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
19/55
19
polycrystalline. For instance, in NiTi, 24 monoclinic variants can form from the parent cubic
phase. One of the important aspects in MT is the arrangement of these multiple variants and
the product and parent phases. In the absence of stress, these variants form twins wherein
the lattice strain is self-accommodated such that no macroscopic or long-range strain occurs.
For instance, pure thermal cycling of SMA under no stress would lead to cyclic
transformation between the parent austenite and twinned martensites. However, stress biases
the type of variant that forms (detwins and/or reorients the variant) giving rise to net
transformation strain. This is responsible for the SME and SE described above. In a single
crystal, the transformation strains can be really large (>>10%). However, in polycrystalline
SMAs, presence of grain boundaries, defects, precipitates etc., influence the morphology of
the evolving phase leading to higher complexity and heterogeneity. Thus, the reversible
macroscopic strains are much less (typically 5-6% for NiTi). One of the important aspects in
SMAs is the dependence of the phase morphology on the deformation history of the material;
this will be discussed later in this section. This is microscopically related to the memory or
path dependency in the response of material giving rise to hysteretic response. In this context,
in polycrystalline SMAs, the texture or the orientation of the grains in the material plays an
important role in the transformation characteristics and hence in SE and SME. Concomitant
to MT are significant changes in some of the material properties like moduli, specific heat,
thermal conductivity, electrical resistivity, which influence the thermomechanical response.
Issues of compatibility of microstructure, strain energy associated with lattice distortion,
transformation strain and the stress that arises due to incoherency and heterogeneity play a
vital role in determining the evolution of the MT. Since MT is treated as a first order
transformation, notion of order parameter associated with breaking of symmetry is used to
describe or characterize the transformation. Evolution of the phase can be related to
evolution of the order parameter and hence evolution of the inelastic strain associated with
the transformation. Another aspect that influences MT is the generation, growth and
stabilization of dislocations and/or defects in the material during transformation. These
introduce complexities in the microstructure evolution and influence the macroscopic
response. The crystallographic aspects outlined above give a brief sketch of the kinematics of
MT and factors influencing it.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
20/55
20
4.3 Transformation Thermodynamics
Driving forceIn order to induce the P M transformation, the chemical free energy of the
M phase must be lower than that of the P phase. However, since the transformation requires
an excess of non-chemical free energy ( such as transformation strain energy and interface
energy ), if the difference between the chemical free energies of both phases is not greater
than the necessary non-chemical free energy, the transformation will not begin Fig 4.4 In
other words, a driving force is necessary. If the specimen is not supercooled to a suitably low
temperature Ms below the equilibrium temperature T0 ( where the chemical free energy of the
M and P phases are equal), the transformation will not progress. A driving force is also
necessary for the reverse transformation, the specimen must be superheated to a suitably high
temperature As above T0.
Fig 4.4 Temperature Dependence of the Chemical Free Energies of the Parent and
Martensitic Phases and their relations to Martensitic Transformation [1]
Now,
Assume a lens shaped M crystal with radius r and average thickness 2t (r >> t) has nucleated.
Then,
Interface Energy = 2r2,
Here, 2r
2
is the approximate surface area
is the interface energy per unit area. The value ofthe expression varies widely according to the degree of coherency strain along the P-M
interface. Assuming the interface involves Frank dislocation loops, is estimated to be the
order of ( 1.2 ~ 2.4 ) X 10-5
cal/cm2.
The elastic strain energy is = r2t(At/r) = rt
2 A
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
21/55
21
r2t is the M crystals approximate volume and A(t/r) is the elastic strain per unit volume.
This strain is estimated to be 500 cal/cm3
at 250c. This sort of elastic strain is generally not
large enough to promote a reverse transformation when the specimen is heated, but in certain
alloys it does promote the reverse transformation which then becomes thermoelastic.
Apart from the above, there are other energies due to plastic deformations and elastic
oscillations. The former requires twinning or slip deformations in the form of lattice invariant
strain in the M crystal, the energy required for both types of plastic deformations is thought
to be enormous. If we assume for the time being that plastic deformation occurs only within
the M crystal, then by analogy with elastic energy,
r2t(Bt/r) = rt
2B
Since the energy of elastic oscillations is thought to be small, the main forms of non-
chemical free energies produced during the transformation are given by above formulas.
Accordingly, the total energy change due to M crystal nucleation is
G = r2tgc+ 2r
2 + r
2t(A + B)
Where gc is the change in the chemical free energy per unit volume.
At temperature Ms, when the radius r of a lens shaped M crystal nucleus exceeds a critical
value, the change in the chemical free energy, the first term on the right side of the above
equation will exceed the sum of the non-chemical free energies given by the second and third
terms. The nucleus will therefore grow and the transformation will proceed. The difference
between T0 and Ms is called the degree of supercooling. The degree of supercooling in
martensitic transformations in ferrous alloys and steels can be as much as 2000C, but in shape
memory alloys it is only 5~30oC. We can observe different degrees of cooling in Table 1.
4.3.1 Thermodynamic Characteristics
It has been experimentally observed that, in thermoelastic martensitic transformations, the M
crystals first formed at the temperature Ms are the last to undergo the reverse transformation
at temperature Af. In these transformations, the change in the total free energy can be written
G(T)PM
= gcPM
(T) + (gncPM
) + gsPM
For the reverse transformation, the change is,
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
22/55
22
G(T)MP
= gcMP
(T) + (gncMP
) + gsMP
gcis the change in the chemical free energy and gnc is the increase in the non-chemical
free energy (considering only the elastic energy accumulated in the thermoelastic
transformation). The energy term gs corresponds to the forces resisting either the growth
and shrinkage of existing M crystals or the creation and annihilation of new M crystals.
Table 1 Table of Data for Alloys which exhibit a Complete SME. [1]
4.4 Transformation Kinetics
Generally martensitic transformation advances only when the temperature drops below M s.
In other words, it is an athermal transformation. When this type of transformation occurs in
ferrous alloys or steels, the M crystals do not continue to grow after they are form. The
transformation process proceeds by nucleating new M crystals in the remaining P phase
material. Individual M crystals are then nucleated within the solid and grow quickly at about
1/3 the speed of elastic waves in solids. However, there are also cases when, if a temperature
above Ms is maintained, or if the specimen is super cooled below Ms and that temperature is
maintained after a partial athermal transformation has been induced, the transformation will
commence after an incubation period specific to the material. The extent of transformation
will increase with the passage of time. This type of behaviour is called an isothermal
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
23/55
23
transformation. Here too, the transformation advances with the nucleation of new M crystal,
and the M crystals are created and grow at very high speeds.
Regardless of whether the transformation is isothermal or athermal, the individual M crystals
appear and grow quickly into their final size and do not grow further even if the temperature
drops or time passes. When considering the nucleation and growth of individual, we call this
sort of transformation non-thermo-elastic. Conversely, in thermo-elastic transformations,
once M crystals are nucleated, they grow at a velocity proportional to the cooling rate during
dropping temperatures; some grow at rates detectable with the naked eye. Similarly, the
crystals shrink when heat is applied. Such thermo-elastic martensitic transformations are also
crucial to the realization of the shape memory effect.
4.4.1 Reaction Order
Thermodynamically, MT in SMAs is classified as either a weak first order or a second order
transformation (Ehrenfests criterion). First order transition requires only continuity of free
energy of individual phases at the equilibrium temperature (T0) whereas the second order
transformation additionally requires continuity in gradient of free energy at T 0. In a regular
first order phase transformation like solidification, there is a sharp change in the energy
parameter with respect to a state variable like temperature. Also, there is long range
movement of atoms (diffusion). However, in SMAs, though there is no diffusion, significant
strains result in sharp change in the gradient of the energy parameter. Thus, the
transformation in SMAs is displacive in nature and is a weak first-order or second order
transformation. The transformation usually occurs over a temperature range (Mf < Af) and
the start and end temperatures are affected by the stress. Generally, the transformation
temperatures increase almost proportionately with stress. Further, the difference between the
start and the end temperatures of martensitic and austenitic phases are approximately same.
The interdependence of transformation temperature and stress is usually expressed using the
Clausius-Clapeyron relation, in this context given by,
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
24/55
24
where, is the stress, H, the change in enthalpy due to transformation and 0, the total
inelastic strain, 0 is the molar volume, , the change in entropy due to transformation.
Usually the stress-transformation temperature relationship is obtained by conducting physical
experiments.
The athermal aspect of kinetics in MT implies that, in general, the process depends on the
instantaneous temperature (or stress) and not on the sweep rates of these driving parameters.
This implies a certain rate-independence in MT. Apparent rate effects seen in macroscopic
response like changes in shape of hysteresis due to rate of the loading parameter is more due
to the latent heat effects associated with phase transformation. Due to unstable (metastable)
nature of transformation, thermodynamic formulation based on equilibrium approach is
useful only in bringing out some essential aspects of transformation. Heat transfer, diffusion
and propagation effects that are not accounted for in the equilibrium approach are to be
considered in order to fully describe the thermoelastic behavior.
4.5 Thermodynamic & Kinetics Conclusion
From the above discussion it is clear that both thermal and elastic energies play a vital role in
phase transformation in SMAs. Further, there is a strong interaction or coupling between
these two energies manifesting as a highly nonlinear and coupled thermomechanical
behavior. For instance, even when MT is purely stress induced, it is accompanied by
exchange of latent heat of transformation. The forward (PM) transformation is exothermic
while the reverse transformation is endothermic. The amount of latent heat involved depends
on the alloy composition and processing history. In addition, MT is dissipative in nature
involving inelastic deformation.
Kinetics of phase evolution in terms of conditions for onset, direction of transformation
(forward PM or reverse MP), depending on the nature of loading and the amount ofphase evolution for a given load increment is central to understanding of MT. In this context,
several thermodynamic concepts like free-energy, dissipation potential, entropy production
and driving force are used extensively to describe MT. Usually, Helmholtz or Gibbs form of
free energy is used to explain MT in terms of the relative stability of the parent and product
phases. The temperature at which the chemical parts of free energies of the two phases are
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
25/55
25
equal is termed as equilibrium temperature (T0). In a defect free single crystal, the
transformation occurs instantaneously at T0, the direction of which is determined by the sign
ofT.
This unstable transformation at the microscopic level manifests as jump in the stress-strain
response. The slope of the stress-strain curve during transformation is associated with the
interaction between the parent and product phases and the thermal equilibrium due to latent
heat.
Fig 4.6: Potential for A and M phases as a function of temperature. To is the equilibrium
temperature. Due to friction and other internal factors, additional energy is needed to initiate
transformation (undercooling to Ms or superheating to As) [2]
However, presence of defects, grain boundaries etc., alters the transformation temperature
requiring either undercooling or superheating (Fig 4.6). Once initiated, the transformation is
not self-sustaining (as in an initiation controlled process) and additional driving force is
necessary for further transformation (propagation controlled process). Additional driving
force is needed to overcome friction and other dissipative forces that exist due to interaction
energy. From a macroscopic perspective, MT is assumed to occur through a sequence of
metastable states associated with athermal nature of kinetics. Minimization of free energy is
used as the criterion to determine the state of SMA. For example, cubic austenite transforms
into several energetically equivalent, yet crystallographically different variants of martensite.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
26/55
26
Fig 4.7 shows the influence of stress on Landaus free energy parameter (based on Gibbs
free energy). It shows two symmetric low energy wells corresponding to the two variants of
martensite considered. Instead of the initial symmetry in the free energy structure
corresponding to different self-accommodating variants (under a stress free condition) the
direction of applied stress biases the free energy wells leading to the formation of martensites
with specific orientations thereby accumulating large macroscopic strain. The isothermal
stress-strain response shows two stable branches corresponding to the pure phases (P and M).
During transformation, equilibrium of the phase mixture line gives a line with negative slope
(corresponding to fully reversible and dissipation less transformation). Unstable branches at
different temperatures are identified based on the free energy structure as a function of
temperature and order parameter (in this case, the strain).
Fig 4.7 Schematic of free energy as a function of strain (order parameter) for a two variant
martensite and austenite transformation. [2]
4.6 Memory in MT
Path dependency in MT is attributed to the (rate of) entropy production in these materials. A
suitable notion of memory or information about the evolution for the load history within
that transformation zone is essential while defining the kinetics under arbitrary loading.
Ideally, due to history dependency, to predict the instantaneous state of the material during
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
27/55
27
transformation, the information about the entire load-deformation history is essential. In
order to capture the history dependency, suitable state variables are introduced into the free
energy function. However, under arbitrary thermodynamic loading, definition of memory
poses a significant challenge. Another aspect adding to the complexity is that the nature of
memory changes during transformation history over many cycles. The response for arbitrary
thermomechanical loading manifests as:
Shakedown or training or stabilization of material (stability in the hysteretic response)
Incomplete transformation (partial and inner hysteresis loops).
4.7 Stability in Material Response
An important aspect that governs the hysteretic response is the stabilization of the material
behavior under cyclic thermomechanical loading. Under repeated loading, the material
behavior is said to be stable, if the hysteresis for each load cycle is stable (shows no drift).
Else, the behavior is said to be non-stabilized and this could typically manifest as remnant
strain and/or stress at the end of each cycle, which could accumulate during subsequent
cycles (ratcheting response). This leads to non-closure of hysteresis loops. Stability is
desirable from a device or an application perspective and hence special thermomechanical
treatments are imparted to the material to achieve the same. For instance, dislocations and
defects are deliberately introduced and grown through thermomechanical process to obtain
desired levels and repeatability of SME and SE. Factors influencing stabilization are the load
levels, history and number of cycles at the given load level. Due to history dependency of the
material response, stability is observed only under loads not greater than the previous
maximum load levels. For higher loads, a certain number of additional cycles are necessary
before stabilization occurs. Such transformation behavior can be interpreted as imperfect
memory which needs multiple cycles to become perfect.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
28/55
28
Fig 4.8: Different inner or partial loop behavior; (a) return point memory behavior in a
commercially available NiTi ; (b) Schematic sink point behavior. [2]
4.8 Macroscopic Characterization of SMAs
4.8.1 Differential Scanning Calorimetry
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) is a thermo-analytical technique that is often used
to characterize thermally induced stress-free transformation in SMAs. ASTM F2004 provides
a standard procedure to conduct the tests and report the results. In DSC, essentially, the
difference in the amount of heat required to increase the temperature of a small quantity of
the sample (about 10 mg) and the reference are measured as a function of temperature. Both
the sample and reference are maintained at nearly the same temperature during thermal
cycling over the entire transformation temperature range at a typical rate of 10 oC/min. A
typical output from DSC test on SMA with and without R-Phase in terms of heat flow rate
versus temperature is shown in Fig 9. From these, the transition temperatures and the
enthalpy of transformation (H) associated with MP (heating) and PM (cooling)
transformations are determined. H is measured as the area under the transformation peaks
during the heating and cooling cycles. A more sophisticated test is the modulated DSC that
can differentiate both the reversible and irreversible components of heat flow. This is useful
to resolve multimode transformations or other second order effects.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
29/55
29
Fig 4.9: Heat flow vs. temperature trace in DSC for SMAs (a) without R-phase and (b) with
R-phase. Transformation temperatures are identified by drawing tangents as shown. [2]
4.8.2 Stress-strain-temperature tests
Although DSC is an excellent experimental technique to obtain the SMA transition
temperatures, it is suitable only under stress free condition. In order to characterize the
thermomechanical hysteresis of SMAs, an experimental technique to study the material
behavior under heating and cooling under a constant stress is required. Generally, two types
of tests are frequently employed for this purpose.
1. Constant stress thermal cycling (iso-baric test)
2. Constant temperature mechanical cycling (isothermal test)
Several important material parameters like moduli, total transformation strain (both one-way
and two-way), and Clausius-Clapeyron relation are estimated from these tests. This
information is used to obtain the phase diagram (discussed in detail in next section).
4.8.2.1 Isobaric tests
On either the tensile coupons or wires, constant stress is applied and the SMA is thermally
cycled between the martensite and austenite conditions. This experiment is usually conducted
with SMA under a dead weight or in a UTM under constant force mode. The rate of heating
and cooling is kept sufficiently low (order of 5 oC/min). In this case, SMA shows a hysteretic
strain-temperature (-T) response. A typical -T hysteresis response is plotted for a given
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
30/55
30
stress level as shown in Fig10. It is not always easy to identify the transformation
temperatures from this plot. For engineering purposes, usually, tangents are drawn to the
heating and cooling segments (Fig 4.10) to obtain the transformation temperatures (Ms, Mf,
As and Af). More analytical methods such as numerical differentiation of the curve can be
used to identify change in slope or curvatures and associate them with the critical
temperature. Another parameter that is obtained from this test is the amount of
transformation strain.
Fig 4.10: Strain-temperature hysteresis at 100 MPa stress for a commercially available NiTi.
[2]
4.8.2.2 Isothermal tests
Tensile tests involving complete load-unload cycle covering the range of SIM and its reverse
transformation are often performed to characterize SMA response. The tests have been done
in a controlled thermal environment at different constant temperatures; the range depending
on the transformation temperatures. The strain rates are typically small to obtain quasistatic
response (order of 0.001 /s). Typical stress-strain curves at a few temperatures are given in
Fig 11. Critical transformation stresses for both forward and reverse transformation are
obtained from this test as shown in Fig 4.11. The transformation strain can also be
determined from this test.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
31/55
31
Fig 4.11: Stress-strain response and tangents drawn to determine critical transformation
stresses for a commercially available NiTi. [2]
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
32/55
32
5 Medical Applications of Nitinol
5.1 Inferior Vena Cava Filters
Fig 5.1Nitinol Filter [5]
5.1.1Medical Complication -
Pulmonary embolism occurs when a fragment of blood clot detaches and reaches the lungs
via veins. As a result it causes shortness of breath, pain during inspiration and may ultimately
lead to heart failure and death. The blockage due to the emboli (fragment from the blood
clot) occurs more often from the lower extremities or pelvis.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
33/55
33
Fig 5.2 Diagrammatic representation of vessels of interest in a) Venous System b) Arterial
System [7]
5.1.2 Treatment Techniques:
(a)The complication is removed either by the use of anti-coagulant drugs (such as heparin or
warfarin which reduce the clotting ability of blood) or is surgically removed. Anti-coagulants
or drugs administered to inhibit thrombosis may be ineffective or unsuitable in certain cases
owing to the danger to patients health
(b)Another method involves surgery in which the inferior vena cava is closed by external
means such as clips, ties or sutures. As a result of this the venous blood reaches the right
hand side of heart through the other venous pathways which are small enough to disallow
emboli from entering.
The above method involves surgery causing further pains to the patient already ill from the
pulmonary embolism. In order to overcome this drawback a method employing minimum
invasive surgery was investigated and employed.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
34/55
34
(c)A method requiring minimum invasive surgery uses a filter which is deployed inside the
inferior vena cava. It is placed inside the veins where it traps the emboli in its frame where
they dissolve over a period of time.
Procedure: The filter consists primarily of two parts: the filter and the locking system. The
locking system is made of sharp tipped leading and trailing wires which penetrate the
endothelium to a depth of 1-2mm to hold the filter in place. The sharp tipped ends are
prevented from further penetration by means of small metal studs.
Fig 5.3 Diagram for Delivery System for Filter [7]
Outside the body the filter is straightened in ice cold water and placed inside a catheter which
travels over a guidewire and releases the filter at the desired location. The filter is placed
inside the catheter in a manner such that the rear stud of the locking system is attached to a
special notch which helps to retain the filter inside the catheter. Throughout this process a
constant flow of cool saline is maintained through the catheter in order to prevent the filter
from taking shape before reaching the intended location. Once at the deployment site the
flow of the chilled saline solution is stopped and the straightened wire is pushed out of the
catheter where due to the body temperature it reverts back to its original shape of a filter.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
35/55
35
Fig 5.4 Deployment of Filter [7]
5.1.3 Requirements of an Ideal Filter
Be deliverable into the IVC using a standard angiographic catheter. Be able to be delivered quickly, accurately and have no problem of wrongful
orientation. Problem can be dealt by filter shapes. However implanting complex
shapes can be difficult which is assisted by SMA effect.
Look itself into position and not migrate heart ward. Capture all dangerous emboli. Be non-thrombogenic and have good biocompatibility.
5.1.4 Advantages & Properties of Nitinol making it suitable for use as a Filter
Shape Memory Effect and Thermal Deployment- The one way shape memory effect of
Nitinol alloys is utilized is to collapse the filter into a straightened wire and revert it back to
its original shape that is of a filter once it has been deployed at the desired spot inside the
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
36/55
36
Inferior vena cava. The shape memory effect allows for deployment of filters having
complex shapes into the vein. Properties such as Shape Memory Effect and Superelasticity
present in Nitinol further assist in making it more suitable for use as Inferior Vena Cava
Filter in the following ways
A correspondingly smaller entry hole is likely to reduce the risk of bleedingcomplications in a patient who is on anticoagulant drugs.
It allows deployment through an anticubital vein(in the elbow) where the deploymentand the puncture site is more easily controlled. {diagram}
One of the main characteristics exhibited by SMAs has already been utilized to greateffect. This is the ability of large complicated memorized structures to be drawn into
small diameters allowing percutaneous implantation and avoiding the risks of
surgery. On placement the alloy retains its original shape.
Biocompatibility- Nitinol is an alloy of Nickel and Titanium and though nickel is a
carcinogenic and biologically incompatible material it is more than compensated by the use
of Titanium which forms a layer of Titanium oxide on the surface of the alloy and thus
prevents the presence of pure nickel on the surface. Titanium being a biocompatible material
together with Titanium oxide renders biocompatibility to the alloy. Nitinol has been shown to
be non-thrombogenic.
Another concerns regarding the biocompatibility of nitinol is concerned with its cytotoxicity.
Cytotoxicity refers to the damage that the material may cause on cells and is usually
measured during in vitro testing. It has been shown that the cytotoxicity of nitinol is
comparable to that of other alloys used for implantation. Surface processing has been
observed to have a significant impact on cytotoxicity.
MR compatibility- Nitinol is non-ferromagnetic material with a lower magnetic susceptibility
than stainless steel. MRI compatibility is directly related to the susceptibility of the material
relative to human tissue. Nitinol thus provides a clear crisp image. MRI is a diagnostic
technique that yields high quality cross-sectional images of the body. It involves short bursts
of a powerful magnetic field and does not employ X-rays or other forms of radiation.
Stainless steel is susceptible to magnetic fields and as a result interferes with the image to the
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
37/55
37
point where it becomes unrecognizable, nitinol however is very much less sensitive to
magnetic resonance and therefore yields a much cleaner image and can thus be easily tracked
inside the body. The nitinol filter when compared with permanent filters has the additional
advantages of easy surveillance and retrievability.
5.1.5 Disadvantages associated with using SMAs other than Nitinol such as stainless
steel-
It uses a cut down procedure of a major vein requiring dissection of either neck orgroin, of an already ill patient so that the relatively large delivery capsule can be
placed through a venotomy.
The orientation of the filter is difficult to control on delivery within the Inferior venacava and unless the apex of the filter is centralized the efficiency of the filter may be
reduced.
5.2 Intravascular Stents
Fig 5.5 Intravascular Stent [5]
5.2.1 Medical Complication- Angioplasty is a technique for treating occlusion (blockage) or
stenosis (narrowing) of a blood vessel or heart valve. It is a medical treatment to remove the
constriction of the blood vessels. It is used extensively to restore correct blood flow and for
the treatment of coronary heart disease.
5.2.2 Treatment Involved
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
38/55
38
All vascular stents work on the same basic principlethey all hold up the walls of the artery
by mechanical means, ensuring a clear pathway. Stenting prevents recoil exhibited by arterial
walls and may also trap other debris against the vessel walls thus allowing a reduction in the
possible thrombus generation at the dilation site.
a) Balloon Expandable Stent- Essentially the treatment involves the passing of a thin
guidewire through the femoral artery until it is just past the blockage. A balloon tipped
catheter is then passed over the guidewire and pushed along it until the balloon reaches the
occlusion or stenosis. The cylindrical shaped balloon is then inflated to open and widen the
blocked vessel. Subsequently the catheter, the balloon and the guidewire are withdrawn.
However it may happen due to elasticity of the vessel wall, that it may recoil and fail to
remain dilated after the balloon is removed. This procedure thus suffers from a relatively
high rate of restenosis in the dilated region.
b) Self Expanding Stent- Permanently implantable metal cylinders known as stents are often
used to support the walls of the vessel and maintain arterial lumen. Stents are either balloon
expandable where the angioplasty balloon is employed to both open the blocked vessel and
expand the stent or as self-expanding where as the stent is pushed out of the catheter it
immediately opens out to support the already diluted solution.
The stent is shape set into the open condition and then compressed and inserted into the
delivery catheter. When the distal end of the catheter is in the correct position the stent can be
pushed out and will self-expand against the vessel wall. The catheter may then be withdrawn
leaving the stent permanently in place.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
39/55
39
Fig 5.6 Intravascular Stent portrayed in a cut away view of the internal carotid artery [5]
Two techniques used to deploy Ni-Ti stents
Cold Saline Technique- this involves a Ni-Ti wire whose TransformationTemperature Region is around body temperature. The stent is transformed at a
temperature well below its TTR and inserted into the delivery catheter where it is kept
cool by the flow of cold saline around it. On reaching the desired site it is pushed out
of the catheter and regains its original shape as it warms to body temperature.
Hot Saline Technique- This involves Ni-Ti with TTR just above body temperature. Itis inserted using a catheter into the placement site where warm saline is flushed over
the stent and warms the shape memory alloy above its transition temperature hence
returning it to its original shape.
5.2.3 Qualities required of an Ideal Stent
Stable support Good visibility Ease of deployment High expansion ratio
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
40/55
40
Biologically inert Thrombus resistant Reliable Expandability
5.2.4 Suitability of Ni-Ti & Properties that render it useful.
a) Superelasticity or Elastic DeploymentOne of the most common reasons to use Nitinol is
to allow the efficient deployment of a medical device. Modern medicine is constantly striving
towards less and less invasive procedures. Entire operations of increasing complexity are
performed through small leak tight portals into the body called trocars. These procedures
require instruments and devices that can pass through very small openings and then
elastically spring back into the desired shapes. The concept of elastically deploying a curved
device through a straight needle or cannula is the most common use of Nitinol for medical
instrumentation. A correspondingly smaller entry hole is likely to reduce the risk of bleeding
complications in a patient. It allows deployment through an anticubital vein(in the elbow)
where the deployment and the puncture site is more easily controlled.
The compliance or elasticity of an engineered component depends upon design as well as the
inherent elasticity of the material used. For instance one can increase the compliance of a coilspring by adding coils, but this would increase weight and size. Material properties dictate
the total elastic energy stored in the device. The use of Nitinol allows one to design more
compact, stiffer and more elastic devices by increasing the elastic energy storage.
Superelasticity allows one to pass a rather complex instrument through a straight trocar and
the instrument to elastically return to the deployed configuration once through. Nitinol
provides the ability to the stent to deal with large strains.
b) Dynamic Interference- Dynamic interference refers to the long range nature of nitinolstresses. For example in case of a balloon expandable stainless steel stent, following balloon
expansion after the balloon is deflated there is a spring back causing the stent to revert to a
smaller undeformed shape. This phenomena is called acute recoil and is highly undesirable as
it leads to the expansion of the stent to large dimensions which can either damage the vessel
or cause restenosis. In case if the vessel diameter relaxes with time or undergoes a temporary
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
41/55
41
spasm a stainless steel stent will not follow the vessel wall causing a reduction in the applied
stresses or the stent could even embolize. In contrast the forces in a nitinol stent are of a long
range nature. The stent is oversized for the vessel and continues to apply an outward force
until it fully reaches its preset diameter.
Fig 5.7 Stress-Strain Curve for Nitinol [4]
c) Hysteresis Loop: The stress strain behaviour of bone and tendon fits with the hysteresis of
nitinol. High elasticity, low deformation forces and constant force over wide ranges of strain
are characteristics of human tissue and bone as well as nitinol. Stainless steel stents will tend
to force the vessel straight; Nitinol is much more compliant to bends in the vessel con
contours in the lumen
The other aspect of the hysteresis loop that can be exploited in stenting applications is that of
the upper and lower plateau stresses. Ideally a stent should resist crushing during normalphysiological processes (radial resistive force) yet exert a small outward force on the vessel
wall during recovery (chronic outward force). In the hysteresis curve of Nitinol the upper
plateau represents the force required to deform the stent or the force that resists crushing
(radial resistive force) and the lower plateau represents the force exerted on the vessel during
self expansion. With appropriate heat treatments and alloy selection these plateaus may be
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
42/55
42
fine tuned for a given stent application. The plateau of the chronic outward force also means
that the stent continues to exert constant force over a considerable strain recovery range.
Fig 5.8 Stress vs Strain response for Nitinol, Stainless Steel, Bone & Tendon [4]
d) Shape memory effect or Thermal DeploymentThe shape memory effect of the Nitinol is
utilized to convert the complex shape of the stent into a relatively simpler one which can be
transported via the catheter to the desired spot inside the body where it is made to revert back
to the original shape by employing the higher temperature of the body.
e) Bio-compatibilty- Bio-compatibility is defined as the ability to perform with anappropriate host response in a specific application. It is well known that titanium is not toxic
when used inside the human body, nickel on the other hand is extremely toxic. Nickel is a
carcinogenic material that is cancer inducing. In Nitinol however there is the formation of a
passive layer of titanium oxide on the surface that protects the surrounding body from
contacting nickel. The titanium oxide layer also acts as both a physical barrier to nickel
oxidation as well as protects the bulk metal from corrosion.
f) MR compatibility- Nitinol is non-ferromagnetic material with a lower magneticsusceptibility than stainless steel. MRI compatibility is directly related to the susceptibility of
the material relative to human tissue. Nitinol thus provides a clear crisp image. MRI is a
diagnostic technique that yields high quality cross-sectional images of the body. It involves
short bursts of a powerful magnetic field and does not employ X-rays or other forms of
radiation. Stainless steel is susceptible to magnetic fields and as a result interferes with the
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
43/55
43
image to the point where it becomes unrecognizable, nitinol however is very much less
sensitive to magnetic resonance and therefore yields a much cleaner image and can thus be
easily tracked inside the body.
5.3 Stent Grafts
5.3.1 Medical Complication :A major problem involved with the installation of stents inside
the body is the possibility ofrestenosis. Restenosis involves the growth of tissue on the open
pattern of stent and thus creating a blockage. This can be prevented by covering the open
stent frame with a graft material.
Another problem involves the repair of abdominal aortic aneurysms(AAA). An abdominal
aortic aneurysm occurs when the pressure from the blood flow causes the wall of the
weakened artery to swell and expand. With time the aneurysm can become so swollen and
weakened that it may rupture thus leading to death. Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm results in
mortality rates approaching 90%.
5.3.2Treatment Involved & Application of Nitinol: The surgical repair of AAAs involves
by passing the constricted section of the artery and therefore the removal of the aneurismal
sac from circulation. Conventional treatment involves surgery and is thus traumatic for the
patient as well as carries a high risk. The surgical method involves accessing and opening the
aorta, cleaning of any debris and insertion of a graft to bypass the aneurysm and sewing of
the aorta back together. This operation has both high morbidity as well as high patient
recovery times (upto 6 months).
The treatment involving the use of Nitinol involves delivering the graft through a catheter via
the femoral artery and carries with it average recovery periods of just 11days. Nitinol has
found application in this procedure as the material for the supporting frame of the graft
material.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
44/55
44
Fig 5.9 AAA Stent Graft System [4]
5.4 Nitinol Guidewires & Other Surgical Instruments
5.4.1 Medical Application :
Angiography- Angiography or arteriography is a medical imaging technique involving the
passage of catheters into arteries and veins. It is used for the examination of blood or lymph
vessels by application of X-rays. In this process a radiopaque substance is introduced into the
body. Angiography involves introducing a radiopaque contrast medium through a catheter
into the cardiac chambers or coronary arteries. This assists in the X-ray imaging of blood
flow and vessels within the cardiovascular system and can also be used to locate blockages in
circulation.
Interventional radiologists employ X-ray imaging techniques such as X-ray fluoroscopy and
MRI to guide sophisticated instruments and carry out advanced medical procedures.
Fig 5.10 Nitinol Guidewire
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
45/55
45
Deployment of Catheters: The catheters are deployed by passing them over guidewires which
have earlier been inserted through an artery and manoeuvred into the desired position. In this
respect the guidewire acts as a rail for the catheter to travel along until it reaches the distal
location.
Complications of the Procedure :
If a catheter is inserted through the femoral artery at the groin and the final target is for
instance the heart or the brain, then the route through which the guidewire must pass to
deploy the catheter can be very long and tortuous. The brachial artery(just above the elbow)
or carotid arteries (in the neck) are also possible insertion points. These insertion points are
however smaller in size.
The route through which the guidewire must pass often involves very small vessels with tight
radii and branching points. The strains imposed on the guidewires can thus result in
permanent deformation and kinking of the wire.
Hingeless Instruments: Minimally invasive endoscopic surgery is intended to reduce the pain
and trauma of access to the body without compromising exposure of the operating field for
the surgeon. By working through an endoscope with small precision instruments, large
painful access wounds are avoided, internal tissue trauma is reduced, hospital stays are
shortened and recovery is accelerated. Conventional instrument development efforts have
taken the form of miniaturization of mechanical linkages in hinged type designs, resulting in
highly complicated systems with many individual parts which are difficult to assemble.
Hingeless instruments use the elasticity of spring materials instead of pivoting joints to open
and close the jaws of grasping forceps or the blades of scissors. Because of their simple
design without moving parts and hidden crevices, they are easier to clean and sterilize. A
new generation of hingeless instruments uses superelastic Nitinol as the actuating componentof these instruments as it provides higher elasticity. This results in an increased opening span
and/or reduced displacement of the constraining tube for better handling.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
46/55
46
Fig 5.11 Hingeless vs Conventional Instrument Design [6]
The nonlinear stress/strain characteristic of Nitinol provides a constant force gripping of
large and small objects. This reduces the risk of tissue damage.
5.4.2 Suitability of Ni-Ti for this Application :
a) High Recoverable Strains : Recoverable strains of upto 8% are possible if appropriate
processing of nitinol is carried out. This high elastic limit and associated plateau stress make
nitinol behave in a very flexible manner.
b) Good Kink Resistance : The kink resistance of nitinol is very closely related to the plateau
in the stress vs. strain curve of the alloy. If the localized strain in a guidewire is such that it
exceeds beyond the end of the plateau region then the localized stress increases sharply. This
increased stress is accommodated by surrounding areas of lower strain. This means that the
localized peak strain is more uniformly distributed and kinking is prevented. These features
allow bending through tortuous paths while preventing strain localization and plastic
deformation.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
47/55
47
Fig 5.12 Stress Strain response of Nitinol & Stainless Steel [4]
c) Steerability & Torquability : The ability of the nitinol wire to pass through tortuous paths
during angiographic procedures without permanently deforming or kinking greatly improves
its torquability (The ability to translate or twist one end of the guidewire and into a turn of
nearly identical degree at the other end) and steerability. They are both dependent on the
ability of the guidewire to translate twist and motion from the proximal end to the distal end.
Any small kink or permanent deformation in the wire will cause the distal end to whip and
accurate steering and torque translation becomes almost impossible.
5.5 Orthopaedic Applications
5.5.1 Medical Complication:
a)Scoliosis- Scoliosis is by basic definition a deformity of spine. A normal spine is notabsolutely straight, instead it curves in the lower region however it should still remain
vertical. In scoliotic backs the spine is seen to have one or more lateral curves. These curves
may vary in severity and can cause disability or internal organ difficulties.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
48/55
48
Fig 5.13 Lateral Curvature Caused by Scoliosis [7]
Treatment Involved : Surgical internal correction which involves the use of a distraction rod
to correct spinal curvature. The distraction rod technique involves the attachment of hooks
under the laminae of vertebrae above and below the curve to be corrected. The spine is then
longitudinally straightened by an external device and a distraction(Harrington) rod attached
to the hooks. Bone material is then applied around the spine to provide a basis for tissue
growth and eventual bone fusion in the straightened position. In conventional treatments
which did not involve the use of Nitinol after the correcting force exerted by the distraction
rod decreases to approximately 30% of its original value, the re-establishment of this force
required a second operation to be performed. The use of Nitinol however eliminates a second
surgery as after a set period of time the alloy may be externally heated above its austenitic
forming temperature and hence transform into its preset shape and exert the same or nearly
the same force as originally applied.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
49/55
49
Fig 5.14 L shaped rod used for stepwise correction of Scoliosis [7]
b) Surface Arthroplasty- Knee replacement or knee arthroplasty is a surgical procedure to
replace the weight bearing surfaces of the knee joint to relieve pain. It involves the placement
of a corrosion resistant cup on the top of the femoral head. The use of shape memory alloy
simplifies this procedure by the utilization of inverted memorized hooks. At zero degree the
hooks are deformed so that the cups can be placed on the femoral head. Once set the
warming created by body temperature reverts the hooks back into their original position and
in doing so clamps the alloy cup to the bone.
Fig 5.15 Diagrammatic representation of a Ni-Ti cup used in Surface Arthroplasty [7]
c) Treatment of Fractures- In cases of osteotomy, bone fracture or bone fusion the hospitals
involved used wavy staples with sixty degree spikes at each end. The staples are elongated at
zero degree along their U-section and spikes placed within the pre-drilled holes in the bones.
Upon warming by a hot saline pack the wavy section returns to its original shape and thus
produces a compressive force between the two subject bones. This compressive force
encourages tissue growth and hence quick fracture recovery.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
50/55
50
Fig 5.16 Diagrammatic representation of Ni-Ti orthopaedic staples a)Before deformation
b)After deformation at the time of implant c)Return to the original shape causing a
compressive force [7]
Fig 5.17 Schematic of Compressive Staple used. [7]
5.5.2 Properties of Nitinol making it suitable for Use
a) Constant Stress: An important feature of Nitinol is that it exhibits constant unloading stress
over large strains. Thus the force applied by the Superelastic device is determined by
temperature, not strain as in conventional materials. Since body temperature is substantially
constant, one can design a device that applies a constant stress over a wide range of shapes.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
51/55
51
This property of Nitinol is utilized in correction of spine by use of distraction rods as well as
the treatment of fractures of bone.
Fig 5.18 Stress-Strain response of Nitinol highlighting the region of constant stress over
varying strain [5]
b) Biomechanical Compatibility: Stainless steel, titanium and other metals are very stiff
relative to biological materials yielding very little in response to pressure from the
surrounding tissue. The extraordinary compliance of nitinol makes it the most mechanically
similar to biological materials. This improved physiological similarity promotes bone in
growth and proper healing by sharing loads with surrounding tissue. A large number of
orthopaedic devices take advantage of this property, including hip implants, bone spacers,
bone staples, skull plates etc.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
52/55
52
Fig 5.19 Stress vs Strain response for Nitinol, Stainless Steel, Bone & Tendon [4]
5.6 Dental Applications
Dental Arch Wires or Braces- The adjustments that the teeth are subjected to during an
orthodontic treatment are due to remodelling of the bone by the force exerted by braces. As a
result the mechanical stimulation allows the remodelling of the periodontal level. The
strength of the force must in a narrow range to permit a proper correction of the dental
malformations. Too much force leads to the absorption of the bone while too little force
increases the possibility that the remodelling will not occur.
The use of Nitinol for orthodontic arch wires is favoured because of its superelasticity. The
unloading curve for Nitinol is flat over large strains. Stainless steel and other conventional
wires are tightened by the orthodontist often to the point of causing pain. As treatment
continues the teeth move and the forces applied by stainless steel quickly relax. This causes
treatment to slow retarding tooth movement. Re-tightening by the orthodontist recycles the
process, with only a narrow optimum treatment period. In contrast, Nitinol wires are able to
move with the teeth applying a constant force over a broad treatment time and tooth position.
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
53/55
53
Fig 5.20 Stress-Strain Response of Nitinol highlighting the region of constant stress over
varying strain. [5]
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
54/55
54
References
1. H. Funakubo, Shape Memory Alloys, translated from Japanese by J.B. Kennedy,Standford University , Gordon and Breach Science Publishers, (1987), pp 1-58
2. Ashish Khandelwal and Vidyashankar Buravalla, Models for Shape Memory AlloyBehavior: An overview of modeling approaches, GM R&D, India Science Lab,
Bangalore, India, International Journal of Structural Changes in Solids Mechanics
and Application, Volume 1, Number 1, December 2009, pp. 111-148
3. Diego Mantovani, Shape Memory Alloys: Properties and Biomedical Applications,JOM October 2000
4. N.B Morgan, Medical shape memory alloy applications- the market and itsproducts, Materials Science & Engineering A 378 (2004) 16-23.
5. T. Duerig, A. Pelton and D. Stockel, An overview of Nitinol Medical Applications,Materials Science and Engineering A273-275 (1999) 149-160.
6. Dieter Stockel & Andreas Melzer, The use of Ni-Ti alloys for Surgical Instruments,Materials in Clinical Applications 1995.
7. Lipscomb and L D M Nokes, The Application of Shape Memory Alloys inMedicine Antony Rowe Ltd. Wiltshire (1996) pp 27-110.
Bibliography
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_memory_alloy2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel_titanium
7/31/2019 Junior Undergraduate Thesis
55/55
55
Declaration
In the preparation of this `B.Tech. Seminar Report the following members of the
team have contributed to different parts of the report, nevertheless all of us have gonethrough the whole report carefully.
Name & Roll No. Contributed mainly
to the following
chapters / sections
Contents
(titles / subtitles only)
(i) Aniket Patni
08011018
All Shape Memory Effect: Mechanism
(ii) Divyanshu Singh
08011002
All Medical Applications of Nitinol
Further, we are aware that if the report write-up does not conform to the standard
format (given on the MEMS website), it (report) is likely to be rejected.
The oral presentation of different parts of the seminar shall be made by the respective
student(s).
Signatures:
Date: 5th April 2010
__________________