Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

Post on 06-Apr-2018

217 views 0 download

Transcript of Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    1/70

    #!&%!!!$

    &$#!#$%%'$

    4:8041#05708039,9;08425043899:9438":0439

    % %%# %

    !% #%

    # $

    &$% % $&!#

    %%!!!$

    #!#$%%'$

    %&!$#$!

    # #

    % # '

    & #

    4907 .425,3,398

    .425783 ,9 0,89 430

    97/ 41 90 949,

    02-078 41 90 4:80 41

    #05708039,9;08 ,70

    3/.,90/-04

    425,3,398

    '#!%#!%

    &3/07830/ !%$ 2489 70850.91: 10 98 /:

    '0710/425,3914790250,.203941904347,-0#03,94

    4743, .:77039 90 01 :89.0 41 90 $:57020 4:79

    070,1907 #08543/039 :543 90 74:3/8 41 097,, 41 !:-.

    %7:89 :5,-0 '4,943 41 90 43899:943 ,3/ 7,19 ,3/

    477:5943,81448

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    2/70

    !#%#$%%%

    0;07,8905489434101:89.0479089,3/34190

    $:57020 4:79 ,8 ,3 3899:943 -003 84 9,390/ 9 90

    507.05943 41-,8,3/ 5,79,9 ,8 98 343490;03 390 /,7

    /,8 41 2,79, , ,8 90 .01 2,897,90 -0,;0/ 9 8:.

    ,774,3.025:39,3/.3.823/0914790,:9039.7:041

    ,94570;,905:-.2:89,;0,-84:9097:89,3/.431/03.0

    390 :89.0 574-9 39079 ,3/ 25,79,94190 202-078 41

    90$:570204:79%4,;0,3:89.02:.2470,01:89.0

    4/408349;0:59490050.9,94341-030,08,7810

    -043/70574,.8941,9,250/090,-9414:73899:943894

    1:3.943,3//85038097:0:89.0949050450

    %043899:943574;/08,574.0881474/390:/.,794

    ,..4:39 43 90 573.50 9,9 84;07039 708/08 3 90 50450

    ,3/ , 4;0732039 ,:9479 02,3,908 1742 902 %0

    43899:943574;/08147,20.,382947024;0411.,84

    -097, 5:-. 97:89 .4229 .:5,-0 ;4,9438 41 90 43899:943

    ,3/7,19,3/.477:5943

    3,,9904;07,2439,3/,,1-0147090

    304;0732039 ,8 94 -0 8473 3 #08543/039 #03,94 4743,

    ,8,554390/01:89.04190$:570204:799457490.9,/

    ,3/ ,-09 47, ,.,5,,7744 3 07 0114798 94 08.,50

    ,..4:39,-9 147 07 ,.98 ,8 !708/039 41 90 !55308 8

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    3/70

    ,554392039 ,8 2,/0 3 ;4,943 41 90 43899:943 ,3/ -

    4;079:733 43089,-80/09., ,3/ 0, 573.508 147-//3

    5708/0398 1742 2,3 2/39 ,5543920398 8 ,88:25943 41

    90 548943 41 01 :89.0 ,8 9:8 2,/0 5488-0 - ,

    .42-3,94341;4,939043899:943,3/90313/3,894

    :891 9 0 3473 0,2508 41 434:7,-0 ,3/ 09.,

    -0,;479,984:/,;02,/0925488-094,..0592:.088

    ,88:20411.0:3/078:./:-4:8,3//84347,-0.7.:289,3.08

    %0 $:57020 4:79 9801 3 943, ; ,894 070 9

    /0./0/ 94 :54/ !708/039 48/,/4 ,.,5,, 3 ;4/3 90

    2/39 ,5543920398 41 8 570/0.08847 ,748 ! ,7., 5,/

    97-:90944304198147207.018!43934:99,9!708/0395/4

    ":734 411070/ , 2/39 ,554392039 94 147207 01 :89.0

    ,3:047,303,2-,88,/473$5,3,3//087394709:7394

    98 4:79 0;03 ,8 ,884.,90 :89.0 47,3 ,8 903/070/ ,3 ,/

    39072 ,554392039 907094 - !708/039 ":734 ,1907 90 ,9907

    ,/ 489 90 00.943 94 !708/039 ,8,8, ,3/ -01470 0,;3

    90 !708/03. $,/ 2-,88,/47 /0.30/ 94 6:,1-03 41 90

    45343 9,9 90 2,9907 84:/ -0 019 94 90 3.423 30

    00.90/!708/039

    3 9,.3 !708/039 ,7.,8 2/39 ,5543920398 90

    $:570204:794-807;0/9,9/024.7,9.70850.9,3/411.,801

    70897,39 84:/ ,;0 .,7,.9070/ ,7.,8 ,.9438 03 ,

    ,3:,7

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    4/70

    3,943 02-,78 43 00.93 98 0,/0785 4:7 43899:943 ,8

    :/., ,3/ 8947., 570.0/0398 , 025,80 9,9 3.:2-0398

    2:89-0-,770/1742,-:839075407894;090280;0847907

    5,798,38 :3/:0 ,/;,39,0 9,79 90 5:-. 47 ,7,88 ,3/

    ,72 , 8:..088478 ,/23897,943 - 93 98 ,3/8 - 20,38 41

    2,.4:8249;,90/ ,5543920398 :79072470 9 8 .42243

    80380 94 -00;0 9,9 ,1907 90 574.,2,943 41 90 00.943 41

    !708/039 ,.,5,, 8 ,8 34 2470 9,3 , .,709,07

    ,/23897,943 0 ,8 /:9 -4:3/ 94 5705,70 147 90 47/07

    97,3810741,:947990 3.423 !708/039 ,3/ 0 84:/349 /4

    ,.98 . 0 4:9 94 34 4:/ 02-,77,88 47 4-897:.9 90

    54.084188:..0884790$:570204:798,/

    9 98 570.0/039 3 23/ ,3/ 9 90 0,9 ,999:/0

    94,7/8293 411., 5407,9 90 .48041,3 ,/23897,943 84

    ,8349948,-49,09030990570803943899:943038730/

    ,.0,7574-943432/39,554392039803!708/039/0

    '#,248970/942,0:/.,,5543920398390.483/,841

    8 ,/23897,943 90 $:57020 4:79 ;4/0/ 902 7089,93 90

    897.9 -,3 43 ,5543920398 349 :89 94 00.:9;0 /05,792039

    5489438-:990:/.,7

    4$4;02-073#05543920398/,90/,7.4143,904',03:0,,3/43!,./4',,79,,8:/084190#043,%7,4:79417,3.,49,3/417,3.,-,3,9:,3970850.9;0

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    5/70

    3/09903!708/03947,,.,5,,7744/0./0/94

    3470,5,89570.0/03983.:/390430089,-80/-0743

    1,907!708/03948/,/4,.,5,,347/0794,55439,01

    :89.003-,320,8:7090894741904:79,8843-

    90/0.,/0,4114720701:89.0,3:047,390,3/2,7

    .,80 41 943, 90 43899:943 9801 ,3/ 90 4;02-07

    03 -,3. #084:943 41 90 $:57020 4:79 ;4/3 !708/039

    #,2482/39:/.,,55439203988:.,3,554392039,8

    ;00/,8/,3074:8,3/32.,94,:9039./024.7,.

    %0 /0.843 41 78 7744 ,8 570280/ 43 #08543/0398

    574;03 :801:3088 ,3/ 8 ,2-9438 .42-33 9 07 549.,

    .,.:,9438 94 2,0 2 , 3 5,79307 3 78 77448 5,3 94

    0;,/0,3/,;4/,..4:39314707411.,,.94388:801:3088

    ,3/ 7:90883088 070 574;03 1742 90 920 0 807;0/ ,8 07

    !708/039, 01 41 $9,11 !708/039, $54082,3 ,3/ ,8 .93

    0.:9;0 $0.709,7 , 5489438 41 90 089 97:89 .431/03.0

    ,3/:999407307411.,,3/507843,,11,78

    84,9,3/8:-807;03.09:80,730/2,3,554392039

    94 90 $:57020 4:79 ,8 884.,90 :89.0 ,9 , 920 03 78

    7744,81,.33:2074:8.,0308,3/-0800/-,5:-.

    .,247147,..4:39,-9

    ,.0/9,;,.,3.3905489434101:89.080903

    039 430 8905 1:7907 ,3/ .438570/ 9 #08543/039 4743, 94

    2,30:;078,554392039,801:89.0--70,3570.0/0398

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    6/70

    089,-80/ - 07 43 1,907 . 570280/ 2/39

    ,5543920398 ,8 2,.4:8 390710703.0 3 90 ,-9 41 , 30

    00.90/5708/03994,;0,1700,3/31:1382,3/,90

    390$:570204:79#08543/039,8.43889039,.90/3,

    2,3307 9,9 57490.98 78 7744 07 0, 2,30:;078 0 3

    411.0,3/900,,3/,/23897,9;0,3/230880019-03/

    84 ,8 94 250/0 90 4;07320398 0114798 94 0,.9 ,..4:39,-9

    ,3/:89.0

    8 0,/0785 41 90 $:57020 4:79 ,8 80;070 074/0/

    5:-. .431/03.0390;07/0.8432,3 574.088 4190

    4:79 /:0 94 90 2,3307 3 . 90 4:79 ,8 ,3/0/ /43

    /0.8438 43 94 70.438/07 4;079:73 ,3/ 4;079:73 ,,3 9480

    /0.8438708:933,3:3570.0/0390/89,90411:3907284190

    ;07/.984190089.4:79390,3/

    801:89.0#08543/039,8-003,;83908503/3

    415:-.1:3/8-3/9409.,89,3/,7/841-0,;47050.90/349

    43412-:981,2397:0/,3/.438570/,,3898104

    :89.08 ,3/ -0,;0/ 2470 0 , 8.411, 9,3 01 :89.0 3

    701:8394/8.4808,88098,3/,-9084943,80-0,;0/

    3 , 2,3307 9,9 8 3.43889039 9 90 /39 ,3/ 574-9

    050.90/ 41 , 202-07 41 90 .4:79 -:9 ,8 :80/ 8

    ,/23897,9;0 54078 147 5,798,3 549., 03/8 94 57490.9 4907

    411.,85:93411.0147908,2070,8430,8,554390/9478

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    7/70

    !708/039 47, ,.,5,,7744 ,3/ 038:70 80 0;,/08

    ,..4:39,-914707,.98

    8 09., -3/3088 3974/:.943 41 549., 5,798,385 ,9

    90 050380 41 /:0 574.088 ,3/ 397:0 394 90 .4:79 ,9 90

    050380 41 90 705:9,943 41 8 104 :89.08 8 :3/07233

    -,8.,3/.0780/573.508413900.9:,13,3.,,3/09.,

    43089 - :83 8 54078 349 94 ,77;0 ,9 90 97:9 47 4/ 90

    .4:79949008989,3/,7/8-:93890,/94.4;07:5,3/0.:80

    908479.42384190.4:79,8-097,0/5:-.97:89-074/3

    5:-..431/03.0390,/23897,94341:89.0

    !:-.411.0 8 570280/ 4390 2,3903,3.0 41 5:-. 97:89

    ,;3-097,0/9,997:89#08543/039#03,944743,82,31089

    :31994.4393:0,801:89.002:89-0250,.0/

    %%$%

    %0701470 98 ,.943 147 250,.2039 8 -74:9 ,,389

    01:89.0#03,944743,3,..47/,3.0990574;843841

    $0.94379.0419043899:943439074:3/841 ,

    097,, 41 !:-. %7:89 - :5,-0 '4,943 41 90 43899:943

    ,3/.7,19,3/477:5943

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    8/70

    %!#%$

    425,3,398 ,70 .:77039 02-078 41 90 4:80 41

    #05708039,9;0 7085438-0534.9038 ,3/9,5,078 ,3/,70

    ,410, ,0 47 5:7548084190 389,39'0710/ 425,39147

    250,.2039.425,3,3982,-0807;0/950,/38349.08

    ,3/ 574.08808 ,9 90 4:80 41 #05708039,9;08 43899:943 8

    ,9,8,3 4250":043 9 %0 -73 98 ,.943 147 ,3/ 43

    -0,14190!04504190#05:-.4190!55308-,:9479

    419043899:943.438890399907.;.,3/.43899:943,/:908,8.90385:-.807;,398202-0784190-,7,3/02-078

    41904:8041#05708039,9;08,8,03984190!045090;,74:8

    80.947841903,943,3/490750450847,3,9438

    #08543/039 #% # 8 90 3.:2-039 01

    :89.04190$:570204:794190!55308,3/8-038:0/3

    8 411., .,5,.9 0 2, -0 807;0/ 9 8:22438 ,3/ 4907

    574.08808,98411.0,//7088,990$:570204:79:/3941

    ,3,

    #%$

    03#08543/039,88:20/411.0,801:89.043,

    0 // 84 /08590 , 43899:943,25480/ -,3 43

    ,5543920398 . 90 $:57020 4:79 2,/0 5488-0 ,3/

    5072990/:3/07,339075709,9439,9897,30/.70/:94.,3/.4224380380 ,3/ 0;03 4780 0110.9;0 -740 90 , %0

    :89.08 9,9 2,/0 98 5488-0 .43899:90 , ;493 -4. 9,9

    #08543/0390,/8,801:89.0

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    9/70

    %0,554392039,82099/08570,/5:-.3/3,943

    ,3/ 57490898 ,8 9 ,8 4-;4:8 247, /:-4:8 8 ,554392039

    .,20 :89 430 00 ,1907 , 30 !708/039 ,8 ,70,/ 00.90/

    ,3/:89,10008-01470,30!708/039,8941472,,88:20

    411.0 08590 90 43899:943, 574-943 90 570.0/039

    089,-80/3943,;,894./0.,70/9,9,33.:2-039

    !708/039 ,554393 411.,8,190790 00.943 418 8:..08847 ,8

    !708/039 48/,/4 ,.,5,, ,7:0/ 7057080390/ 2,.4:8

    8,-49,0 41 90 0570880/ 41 90 50450 ,3/ /08590 90

    $:570204:798438947.57080390/90890730,250

    41 , 147207 01 :89.0 ,3:0 47,3 4 /0.30/

    70,554392039 94 90 .4:79 - !708/039 5/4 ":734 ,8 9

    .43899:90/ , 2/39 ,554392039 #08543/039 0,07

    ,..0590/8548943%8,8349989,3/3901,.99,94190

    9700-7,3.08414;073203990:/.,7,890248970,9

    /0503/039 :543 247, ,8.03/,3. ,3/ 09., 39079 ,8 90

    14:3/,94341985407,3/092,.40;070,9902590/94

    .,24:1,08-7,03,2-943-9,384,941411.0-01470

    903 !708/039 47, ,.,5,,7744 3 80.709 8:55480/ ,9

    9033902473341,-043/908.7:9341902,88

    20/,,3/905:-.

    #08543/0398 ;493 5,99073 ,3/ ,.9438 ,1907 8,554392039 ,8 884.,90 :89.0 ,3/ ,907 ,8 01 :89.0 ,8

    /8.:880/-04,;0-003,393-:91,7,3/25,79,

    3 90 0,7 9,9 #08543/039 ,8 5708/0/ 4;07 90 4:79 41

    ,89#08479905345045081,9390:89.088902,8-003

    70,9:3/07230/7,9079,3:5190/974:,8070841/:-4:8

    /0.84380330070/-2

    8:077, !,-:,3 !,,.0 /08 4743, 4,99,3 1742 20/,!5530 , 36:707 , .45 4190,79.08 ,99,.0/,8 330

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    10/70

    3890,/41,88:73,3/897039033903/0503/03.0,3/

    25,79,94190:/.,7#08543/039,83890,//0243897,90/

    0 8 570/85480/ 94 1,;47 ,3/ 57490.9 78 47, ,.,5,,

    7744 4 ,/ ,554390/ 2 94 8 548943 ,8 01 :89.0 3

    -7,03/870,7/419043899:943

    3 1,.9 708:98 41 90 $4., 0,907 $9,9438 $:7;08 309

    8,981,.9437,93839097/6:,7907413/.,909,9,243

    90 .4:3978 945 411.,8 43 #08543/0398 8,981,.943 7,938

    ,;0-003,07483.0$05902-07088,981,.9437,93

    8.4388903930,90/-8/88,981,.9437,93

    4390,#08543/039.4397,794857434:3.020398

    ,8,40/,3/0;0303.4:7,0/90/090747,943419070850.9

    ,3/97:89/:094904:79-5:9934-89,.083905,941

    90 504508 80,7. 147 97:9 ,,389 7,19 ,3/ .477:5943

    03.74,.3 43 90 0.:8;0 5407 41 90 4:80 41

    #05708039,9;08 94 39,90 250,.2039 574.00/38 574;/3 ,

    802-,3.0 41 0, .4;07 94 ;0 47207 !708/039 47,

    ,.,5,,7744 ,3/ 07 :8-,3/ 90 455479:39 94 08.,50

    57480.:943 ,3/ 17:897,90 90 03/8 41 :89.0 5072993 90

    4:79 94 7050,90/ 15145 43 98 43 /0.8438 3 ;4,943 41 98

    437:080.:835,,7823.4397,899490897303989,3/,7/8050.90/ 41 47/3,7 .400 89:/0398 ,3/ 90,.078 ,3/ 0;03

    7054790/03,3349433.9,.6:73,8809841;,:0

    -:90;0370847939450997,19,3/.477:5943147843507843,

    57419,3/.43;0303.0

    !4-090 #,938 /0.30 147 945 411.,8 :8308847/.94-07 .454190,79.08,99,.0/,8330

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    11/70

    %0 425,3,398 070- ,..:80 #08543/039 41 3:2074:8

    ,.98 9,9 .425780 , 097,, 41 !:-. %7:89 - :5,-0

    '4,943 41 90 43899:943 ,3/ . 7,19 ,3/ 477:5943 9,9

    703/07 2 ,-84:90 :319 147 90 548943 41 01 :89.0 41 90

    $:570204:79

    #&$#!%

    #08543/039 -097,0/ 90 !:-. %7:89 .422990/ :5,-0

    '4,943 41 90 43899:943 ,3/ 7,19 ,3/ 477:5943 3 90

    14432,3307

    #%

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% %#& $

    %# ## # !#%%

    $&$#' $$ '' % ##

    $%#%#%%$!!%%$

    $&!# % &$% &% $ &&$

    !!%% $ % &$% % %

    !#$%

    #%

    #$!% %% &! '% %

    $%%&%#%#%!&%#&$%

    %$$%% !&$ $%%%$$%$ %$ %#%$#"

    $#%%$%%&%

    #%

    #$!%%%&!'%$ %

    $%%&% %# % !& %#&$%

    % % $#' % $%#%$%#$ #% ' $% %

    $%%&%%%!#'$%%(#%

    &$%!#$!#'!%

    %#% !#% !

    %$&!#%%%#%%#$

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    12/70

    &$ &$ % $$& !

    !! $$ &%# $$

    #% $$' %% %#$

    ## %#& # !!%% $ %

    $&$$%%%$##

    $$!#%$&!#%

    #%'

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% #

    %% &! '% % $%%&%

    %% $## % !#!

    $!#%!#$$$&$%%&$"&%## $% % &$ #!#$%%'$ %

    $ # % !% %

    &$#%$'##&%##

    #%'

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% %#&

    %#%##$$!#%%$$%%

    $## % !#! #$ &% %$$ '' % #% %$

    %!#%%$%!#'

    #%'

    #$!%%#%!&%#&$%##%

    &% $ % %% #% %&%#% $% % !#!#

    '$%% &$% % $&!#% # %

    !!$ &!% $& &%#%

    $%$!#!##!$%$%%&%

    %&$#!#$%%'$'!%

    #%'

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% %#& $!#%% #% %!## #$%#

    ## %# '# ## !#$% #

    !## # &$ $&

    ## ## % ' % !!#%&% %

    $! !#$&% % #&$%#% % $

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    13/70

    &$% $%#% % $&!# %

    $ % %'% % %# '

    #%!%%%$%

    $&!#%$%#

    #%'

    #$!% %# % !& %#&$% #

    %% #% ##&!%

    #&$ % &% # %

    '!%&$!#

    %$%$

    $&$$%#&$#!%

    #$!%%#%!&

    %#&$% %#& $ %#

    ## # !#%%

    $&$#' $$

    '' % ##

    $%#% # % %

    $!!%%$$&!#

    % &$%

    %& % $ &&$

    !!%% $ %

    &$% &! % %

    !#$%

    $0. 79.0 ' 41 90 43899:943 .0,7

    574-9890!708/03917422,3,5543920398939424398

    220/,90 -01470 90 309 5708/039, 00.9438 ,3/ :5 94 90

    03/ 41 8 9072 0.059 147 902547,7 ,5543920398 94 00.:9;0

    5489438 03 .4393:0/ ;,.,3.08 90703 570:/.0 5:-.

    807;.0 47 03/,307 5:-. 8,109 3 90 .,80 41 3 #0

    5543920398,90/,7. 41 43,904',03:0,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    14/70

    ,3/43!,./4',,79,,8:/084190#043,%7,4:7941

    7,3. ,4 9 ,3/ 41 7,3. ,-,3,9:,3 9 90

    $:57020 4:79 7:08 9,9 98 574;843 -,78 90 ,554392039 41

    202-0784190:/.,7

    40;07390.,804179:74/0,8974;:/.,,3/

    ,74:3. ,3/ !708/039 47,,.,5,,774409 , 3 #0

    55.,-9 1 $0.943 79.0 ' 1 %0 43899:943 %4

    5543920398 %4 %0 :/.,7 89094 !03/4, !5530 ,7

    884.,943 ;8 09 , 90 $:57020 4:79 70;0780/ 90

    ',03:0, 7:3 ,3/ 0/ 9,9 90 43899:943, 574-943

    83:,7 /408 349 ,55 94 90 $:57020 4:79 253 9,9 9

    ,550843949000.:9;0/05,792039,3/,4907.4:798407

    9,3 90 $:57020 4:79 08590 90 4-;4:8 30,9;0 ,3/

    .431/03.08,9907325,.99,9,2/39,554392039-,3

    4:943!708/0394:/,;043905045081,9390$:57020

    4:79,3/90:/.,88902#08543/0390,078,20088,3/

    94:9 0;03 , 39 41 80170897,39 ,3/ /0.,/0, ,..0590/ 8

    2/39 ,554392039 ,8 01 :89.0 - 903!708/039 47,

    ,.,5,,7744

    :/08 2:89 038:70 9,9 349 43 8 907 .43/:.9

    ,-4;070574,.-:99,998507.0;0/94-084390;041,

    70,843,-04-807;07

    3,//94390-0,;47,3/.43/:.941:/08 2:89 70,1172 90 504508 1,9 3 90 39079 41 90

    :/.,7:89.02:893492070-0/430-:92:89,84-0800394

    -0 /430 %080 ,70 706:70/ :3/07 94 41 90 2489 25479,39

    80.943841904/041:/.,43/:.9850.1.,,34343

    39079 40;07 ,8 , 2,9907 41 5:-. 70.47/ 1742 8 ;07

    57424943 94 90 089 548943 3 90 :/., 07,7.

    #08543/039,8;4,90/9080570207574;8438

    4$4;02-07$# # 48 4 $ # 4

    ,7. $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9 $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    15/70

    3/00/ 08-70, 7054790/ 9,9 90 ;493 70.47/ 41

    #08543/039 848 9,9 0 ,8 .43889 039 8/0/ 9 90

    ,/23897,943 3 549.,831.,39.,808 0 77448 54.08

    ,3/,/23897,94308-70,1:79077054790/03997,.0/90

    ;4935,9907341$:570204:79:89.084743,4/0/,

    507.039 3 1,;47 41 7744 ,3/ 98 ,8 -01470 8 2/39

    ,554392039,801:89.0

    %8 9703/ .4393:0/ 0;03 478030/ -097,3

    #08543/0398570/8548943948/09774447073907089,9,3

    ,3/ ,.4898 0;03 ,9 90 .489 41574899:93 90 34-0 .,:8041

    :89.0

    %:8 3 7,44 ; %0 !5530 %7:9 4228843 41

    #08543/039 /0,9 90 1,9, -4 94 0.:9;0 7/07 4

    /,90/ : 03990/ 70,93 90 !5530 %7:9

    422884341$25#08543/039570;0390/,38:.-4/

    1742 -03 .70,90/ 34 47 3 90 1:9:70 9070- 57490.93 8

    5,974308817423;089,943

    34907.,8090$9,9:8":43907/073,207,

    ,3,,3:.2,3;0.:9;0$0.709,7 !,6:94.4,7

    806:,,55,3$002343.:0#08543/0398$:570204:79

    4:/349-0.439039,,3898253:130.:9;07/074

    /,90/:%40903/77448.43974,3/31:03.04;07

    90 30 ,/23897,943 /430 974: 2,88;0 ,8923:90

    ,5543920398 3 .79., 5:-. 5489438 #08543/039 4:/ ,,3

    13/1,:930.:9;07/074/,90/:

    $00 :89.0 4743,8 ;493 70.47/ 1,;478 7744 08-70, 0-7:,7 995308-70,5:89.0.4743,8;49370.47/1,;478,77441,91:57394:98,99,.0/,8330 07041

    #40.02-07#4.94-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    16/70

    0.:9;0 7/07 4 ,8 88:0/ 570.80 94 70;40

    /39 5543920398 2,/0 - 90 7744 /23897,943 3

    /05,7920398 ,03.08 411.08 ,3/ 3897:2039,908 3.:/3

    4;0732039430/ 47 .439740/ .47547,9438 %080 /39

    5543920398 070 2,/0 5488-0 - 78 7744 .:733 4:9

    ,55439203981475:25489834;0732039430/,3/.439740/

    ,03.08 43 , /, -,88 ,3/ -,./,93 902 94 -01470 90

    .43899:943, -,3 43 ,5543920398 /:73 ,3 00.943 5074/

    :79078:.,5543920398,/900110.941074/3903907941

    9000.:9;0080908,20,82,/03.425090/870,7/

    41 90 39039 ,3/ 8579 41 90 .43899:943, -,3 43 2/39

    ,5543920398 0110.9;0 /057;3 90 30 ,/23897,943 41 90

    5407942,09843,554392039894908054894389,8147

    908070,84389,9,37/071742900.:9;0300/0/94-02,/0

    347/0794570;039901:7907/07,/,943419050450897:89,3/

    .431/03.034:74;07320393899:9438

    09 .43889039 9 8 5,99073 41 8:554793 47,

    ,.,5,,7744 #08543/0398 $:57020 4:79 88:0/ , $9,9:8

    ":43907/0794570;039902502039,943410.:9;07/07

    4 ,3 90 389,39 .,80 7010.98 ,3 ,117439 94 90

    3/0503/03.0 41 90 :/.,7 9 8 080 , .,80 41 :/.,

    4;0770,.:543,.406:,-7,3.414;073203920,3994/07,98011479894.:7-.477:5943-8:..088;03:139888:,3.08

    8 884.,90,3/01:89.0#08543/039,83470/

    09., 570.0/0398 -0,;0/ 9 , ,. 41 39079 .,893 90

    $:57020 4:79 3 /8705:90 :/08 ,70 050.90/ 94 -0 -043/

    70574,. 13,3., 09., ,3/ 90 :80 41 907 ,:9479 ,3/

    $00 7744 88:08 2/39 2,/3088 41 ,5543920398 $ 08 ,9995,-8.-3308.423,943,774488:082/392,/3088,5543920398,1,91:57394:941.8,99,.0/,833007041800,8490 89 41 /39 55439008 1742 $ 08 995,-8.-3308.428908/01,:910849078/434,/8%#/398*8*:305/1,1,91:57394:941.8,99,.0/,833007041

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    17/70

    54078!,798,385,1:701:8,9470.:80280184,894,;4/

    ,35488-025:9,94341,.431.94139070893.:/3905,3

    -,. 41 /0-98 41 549., 7,99:/0 47 4,9 ,70 , -097,, 41

    5:-.97:89,3/.4397,79490.,343841:/.,.43/:.9

    8 147 90 .,80 41 0334 $2043 6:34 ;

    4228843 43 0.9438 8:57, 90 $:57020 4:79 /030/ 90

    509943 41 903 $03 0334 $ 6:34 ,,389 # 4

    .70,93 ,3/47 70/0133 90 1789 ,3/ 80.43/ /897.98 41

    ,2,7308$:79,8/0-00;0/,3/.431720/-8:-806:039

    0;03989,990/897.9807070/0130/,3/.70,90/94,88:709,9

    90 !708/039 47, ,.,5,,77448 843 ,94 7744 .4:/

    7:3 ,3/ 3 3 90 30 .70,90/ /897.9 94 ,;4/ , .439089

    -09003 90 5708/0398 843 ,3/ $0.709,7 #4,3/43/,,

    4,390/94709:7394,2,7308$:7947:3384//897.9%8

    30 /897.9 ,8 :50/ .4397,7 94 90 05.9 .43899:943,

    706:7020399,92,3/,908,232:2545:,9434194:3/70/

    11994:8,3/14790.70,94341,08,9;0/897.9

    %03 $03 6:34 ,7:0/ 9,9 #05:-. .9 4

    .70,93 90 1789 ,3/ 80.43/ /897.98 41 ,2,7308 $:7 ,8

    :3.43899:943, -0.,:80 90 5745480/ 1789 /897.9 4:/ 03/ :5

    9 , 545:,943 41 088 9,3 4743 08590 98.0,71,.9#08543/0394743,;490/3;4,943419043899:943

    ,,389903$036:348509943

    4780#08543/0394,99,9920,8,70,/-03

    .438/070/ -787744 ,890309 01:89.0 // 349 3-9

    $0.943 79.0 ' 41 90 43899:943 147 90 .70,943 41 08,9;0 /897.982,3/,9089,94370888,2,0,70,554794320394108,9;0/897.98-,80/43 90 89,3/,7/8 10/ 3 $0.943 %080 .43899:943, 89,3/,7/8 ,8 1,7 ,8545:,943 8 .43.0730/ ,70 574547943, 705708039,943 232:2545:,94341 507 08,9;0 /897.9 5747088;0 7,94 3 90 3.70,804108,9;0 /897.98 ,8 90 545:,943 -,80 3.70,808 ,3/ :314729 3,554794320394108,9;0/897.983574;3.08.908,3/900974549,3,3,,70,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    18/70

    2801%082501,.98#08543/03985,9743088,8902490741

    90573.5,-0301.,74190.70,943419030/897.9%:8,

    ;49031,;47419030/897.9,8,;49031,;47417877448

    843,3/4:/9:803/0,72247094787744,3/038:708

    ,554392039 3 825089 90728 #08543/039 ,390/ ,3/ 300/0/

    842093 1742 78 7744 0 8 ,554392039 ,8 309 01

    :89.0 78 7744 3 9:73 ,390/ 47 300/0/ 842093 147

    #08543/039094.70,90,3008,9;0/897.914707843,94

    7744%0!0450.,3/4902,9

    048,9,-09,997,.8#08543/0398;4935,99073

    3 .,808 2570880/ 9 5:-. 3907089 ,3/ 3;4;3 90

    77444;0732039817439,,88,:9843.43899:943,798574794

    8 ,554392039 ,8 01 :89.0 8 90 9,-0 84

    #08543/0398;4908/.9,90/349-8.438.03.0-:984,9

    ,3/8:-807;03.0948,5543935407

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    31472,943

    %0.344 ;

    ,3/ 0,

    !,.1. ,3:,7

    0,!,.1. .4397,.9 ;4/0/147 349 :3/0743 5:-.-//3

    880390/

    $,3,,8;0.:9;0

    $0.709,7 0-7:,7

    %0!708/039388:3!74.48 ,3/03 7/07 4 // 349 0.00/ 07 54078 ,801 0.:9;0 ,3/

    422,3/07301

    43.:770/

    %0.843 ; ,7.

    82880/ 5099438 94 /86:,1073,3/4 !40 7 77448 7;,.,3//,90147905708/03.,8, 5708/039,-0 43 90 74:3/9,9 0 8 349 , 3,9:7,-473534

    880390/

    !20390 ; 729,

    0.02-07%0 !708/039 2, 2,0,5543920398 3 ,3 ,.93.,5,.9 94:9 8003.43172,943 1742 904228843 43 55439203980;0303437088838088430 349 :89 ,/ 39072,5543920398

    43.:770/

    $03,90;729,57

    88:0/ - 78 7744. ,40/ 00.:9;0/05,792039 0,/8 94 3;4000.:9;057;008;,/

    43.:770/

    :/,3 ; $03,::89

    %0 5708/039, /70.9;0 .574-90/ .079,3411.,841 90

    43.:770/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    19/70

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    0.:9;0 -7,3. ,3/ 90 !1742 ,550,73 3 43708843,0,738 94:9 90 !708/0398.4380398;,/

    ,2-34;

    .94-07

    ,2-348$, 3 ,,38

    509943 147 94,4,504508 39,9;0 94 ,203/ 9043899:94394.43;0794:7147241 4;0732039 1742 5708/039,94 5,7,2039,7 9:8 ;37744 90 455479:39 94-0.420 90 5720 238907 ,3/0;,/0 90 43899:943,574-943 43 7000.943 ,8!708/039 ,8 /82880/ 147,;31,0/94.42599043899:943, 706:7020398 41

    .43/:.93,50450839,9;0

    880390/

    ,;/;7744,

    !708/039, !74.,2,943 485,79.43899:943,5,79:3.43899:943,

    880390/430/%3,8/88039%3,;490/94/8288, 90

    5099438 43 90 1443

    74:3/8$3.0!!3148,7,89

    8 ,3 007.80 41 90!708/0398 .,3 4:954078882,794!!9 84:/ 080 -08:89,30/ 1443 90

    7:3 3 $,3,,8 ;0.:9;0$0.709,7

    %0 9,04;07 41 90 ,

    %7-:30 8 34 4307 ,:89.,-0 88:00;0790088 %3, ,84.4220390/ 43 90!708/0398 020703.9,04;07 54078 3 9880 0 9 81:3/,2039, 84:3/ 94

    .43897:079$0.943419043899:943,8706:73 .43708843,,5574;, -01470 ,9,04;07 2, -00110.90/ 98 47/3 8,2-;,039 9:8 9 8 ,84.43899:943, 507288-0147 90 !708/039 94007.80 9,04;07 540780;03 94:9

    43708843, ,5574;, 30.05943, 389,3.08

    8:-0.9 43 94 :/.,70;0

    880390/ 1742 90

    2,479 7:3 9,9 904;07-70,/9 ,3/ ;4/ 147;,:03088/4.97308,5543 94 1,., .,0308

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    20/70

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    41 1700 8500. 89,9:9083.723,89,9:908,3/349 1700 8500. .,8082, -0 .,030/ 4390 74:3/ 9,9 90 ,70

    ;4/ 147 ;,:03088 7008500. .,808 ,70 2470574507 .,030/ 4390 74:3/ 414;07-70,/9:79072470 !! 30907 .70,908 347/23808 ,3 798 474-,9438,9840;07

    0307, 7/07 4 8

    080 ;,/ -0.,:80

    0;03 1 570280/ 43 ,89,90 41 020703. 9.,3349 ,:9470 9029,74754.094347047 ;4,90 .43899:943, 4789,9:947798 47 03147.0,8 .425090 ,03 9490 8:55708843 41 ,088;403.0

    %0$:570204:7984:/

    349 5,88 :543 903/;/:, .,28 41 3:7

    ,783 1742 ,30,23,943 41 !! ,3/ ,8 ,550/83.098349,9707411,.98

    ,;0 ; 43,0

    0-7:,7709,550/ .43;078,9438-09003 7744 ,3/ ,7.,34349574-90/1742,73

    880390/

    07;$03,90,7.

    07 349 ,-0 147 .4390259 147349,550,733$03,900,73843 % 0, . ,830/947744,3/07854:80

    -0.,:80890892438.4;070/-00.:9;057;00

    43.:770/

    -,,3 ; 6:34

    :!! .422:3.,9438 .4;070/- 00.:9;0 57;00 007.80/-787744,3/3491475:-./8.48:70

    43.:770/

    0334 $2043

    6:34 ;

    4228843 43

    0.9438 # 457

    030/ 90 509943 41 903 $030334$6:34,3/:50/# .70,93 90 1789 ,3/80.43//897.9841,2,7308$:790 /897.98 070 .70,90/ 94,88:70 9,9 77448 843 ,9477447:3:3.4390890/83.0

    903 $0.709,7 #4,3/43/,, ,8 709:733 94,2,7308 $:7 94 7:3 ,,3 147437088.4397,7949005.9.43899:943, 706:702039 9,9706:708 , 232:2 545:,943

    43.:770/ // 349 3-9/08590 -03 ,70,/.438/070/ ,8 430 41 903423008 147 90 309 01:89.0 - 90 24907 903! 41 90 573.5,-0301.,74190.70,94341

    9030/897.9%:8,;49031,;47 41 90 30 /897.9 8 ,;49031,;4741903!8843,3/9:8

    -/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    21/70

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    41 94 :3/70/ 119 94:8,3/ 147 90 .70,943 41 ,08,9;0 /897.9 %03 $036:34,7:0/9,9#05:-..94 9,9 .70,90/ 90 1789

    ,3/ 80.43/ /897.98 41,2,7308$:78:3.43899:943,-0.,:80 90 5745480/ 1789/897.9 03/ :5 9 ,545:,943410889,34743 08590 98 .0,71,.94743,;490/,,389903$036:3485099433;4,943419043899:943

    8/0 1742 90 850.1. .,808 0703 /8.:880/ 90

    1443 .,808 /0./0/ - 90 4:79 9 #08543/039 ,8 01

    :89.01:7907-097,8.43889039,.413/0503/03.0,3/-,8

    94,7/857490.937744

    ,80 $:570204:79#:3 4743,8'490

    7,44 ; %0

    !5530 %7:94228843 41 # 4 0.02-07

    0.:9;0 7/07 4 .70,93

    90 %7:9 4228843 ,8/0.,70/:3.43899:943,

    4743,.43.:770/

    , 207,

    ,3,,3:.2,3 ;

    0.:9;0 $0.709,7

    !,6:94.4,7# 4 .94-07

    $9,9:8":43907/07%0$:57020 4:79 706:70/ 905,7908 94 4-807;0 90 $%%&$"& 570;,3 -01470 9088:,3.0410.:9;07/074/,90/:

    %0 4743, $ 43.0 ,,39,790/ 90 4;073203980114798 94 6:08943 902/39 ,55439203982,/0 - 7744 94 ;,74:85489438 34;0732039,3/974 , 2430 703. ,990 30 ,/23897,94380114798 94 7047,30 90

    4;0732039 ,3/ 09 7/ 41.477:594;0732039411.,8

    47, ,.,5,,

    7744 ; 43 0,

    /0 2, 09 , #48 480:0 % 7744 ;

    430,/02,09

    , # 4 4;02-07

    %02547,770897,3347/07%#88:0/,,38990,9.8947/0788:0/,,3899077448

    %0 343 7744 ;493-4. 3 90 $:57020 4:790/ - #08543/039 ,8988:0/ , %# ,,389 90,9.89 47/07 9070-;3 ,3 455479:39 1479077448 94 08.,50 1742 90:78/.943 41 90 !55308%0 %# ,8 88:0/ /0859090 ,73 3.4388903.08 3

    90 509943 41 147207!708/039 7744 ,8.90/ -884.,90:89.0$07034%08,20 ;493 -4. 0/ 90%# 220/,90 00.:947/08590343.425,3.09,570.43/943

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    22/70

    #$!% %%&! '% %

    $%%&%# %#

    %!&%#&$%

    % $$ % % !& $

    $%%%$$%$ %$

    % #% $ #"

    $#%%

    $%%&%

    9 8 574;/0/ 147 3 79 $0.943 41 90

    43899:943 9,9 , 5:-. 411.07 47 025400 8, :543

    ,88:2594341411.0,3/,8419039070,1907,82,-0706:70/-

    ,8:-29,/0.,7,943:3/074,9418,88098,-908,3/309

    479390.,804190!708/03990'.0!708/0399002-078

    4190,-309,3/4907.43899:943,411.08,3/411.0784190

    ,720/ 147.08 9 0307, 47 1, 7,3 90 /0.,7,943 8, -0

    /8.480/94905:-.3902,3307574;/0/-,

    #08543/0391,0/94/8.48094905:-.889,902039

    41,88098,-908,3/309479,8706:70/-9043899:943

    9 8 ,84 7054790/ 9,9 8420 41 90 574507908 41

    #08543/039 ,70 349 3.:/0/ 3 8 /0.,7,943 41 8 ,88098

    ,-908 ,3/ 309 479 3 ;4,943 41 90 ,397,19 ,3/ .477:59

    57,.9.08,.9

    #08543/03980808:850.90/,3/,..:80/41,;3

    ,..:2:,90/499030,9,.6:73,8809841;,:08,3/

    0053 -,3 ,..4:398 9 :0 /054898 9 ,8 -003 7054790/

    9,9#08543/039,8,24349078,8620907,5,7920393,

    5480, 47/!745079 /0;0452039,9 90479 3%,:,8

    07054790/98,808.43899:943,706:70/:3/0779$0.

    419043899:94338$9,9020394188098,3/,-908,3/

    09 479 $ 8 98 ,.6:8943 8:89,30/ ,3/ /:8:554790/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    23/70

    -83.420,8,5:-.411.,$3.08,88:25943,8884.,90

    ,3/ 8:-806:039 01:89.0,8 0.4250/ 9 98/:9 41

    5:-./8.48:70

    #$!% %%&! '%$ %

    $%%&%%#%

    !& %#&$% %%

    $#' % $%#%

    $%#$ #% '

    $% %

    $%%&% %% !#'$

    %% ( # %&$%!#$

    !#'!% %#%

    !#% !

    % $&!# %

    %%#%%#$

    &$ &$ %

    $$& !!!

    $$

    &%# $$ #%

    $$' %%%#$##%#

    !!%% $ %

    $&$$%

    %%$ ## $$

    ! # % $&!#

    %

    #08543/039 ,8 ,554390/ 94 90 $:57020 4:79 43

    57 - 78 47, ,.,5,,7744 !747 94 8

    ,5543920390807;0/77441472,30,78,807.014189,11

    ,3/ 854082,3 03 80 ,8 '.0!708/039 ,3/ ,907 ,8 07

    !708/039, 0141$9,11 !708/039, $54082,3 ,3/ .93

    0.:9;0$0.709,7

    79 ' $0.943 41 90 43899:943 574;/08

    9,9 ,( 02-07 41 90 :/.,7 2:89 -0 , 507843 41 574;03

    $009958.:/.,74;5:89.08.4743,55

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    24/70

    .4250903.0 39079 574-9 ,3/ 3/0503/03.0 02-078 41

    90 :/.,7,70050.90/94,;0908014:76:,9082,3/,90/

    - 90 43899:943 -0.,:80 9080 1472 90 ;07 14:3/,943 147

    2,39,335045081,9390:/.,7%:89,8-0037:0/

    -340889,390$:570204:799,9

    !0450 4 7:3 90 :/.,7 5,79.:,7 :89.08

    ,3/ :/08 2:89 349 43 -0 5741.039 3 -49 908:-89,39;0,3/574.0/:7,,850.984190,-:9247025479,39 90 2:89 5488088 90 089 /0700 4139079 ,3/ 574-9 ,3/ ,3 :36:08943,-0 247,

    :5793088-4939075:-.,3/57;,90;0894:0;07411.03904;0732039807;.08

    , 5:-. 97:89 34548943 0,.98, 70,907/02,3/43247, 7904:83088 ,3/ :5793088 9,3 , 80,9 3 90

    :/.,709.,573.508,3/,8038041574570984:/ -0 2,39,30/ 94:9 . 90 1,9 41 90

    50450 3 90 :/.,7 84 3/85038,-0 3 ,3 47/07

    84.09.,3349-0570807;0/

    :89;0770.03990151455341904743,4:7943

    99903/,398,3/$90,7/8884.,9434190!55308$!

    ;!553073083.09,9070.,41,$05902-07

    0.8434190$:570204:798$0.43/;843/033,$0.43/

    4943147#0.438/07,94341907:331,;4741$!43,

    2070 09907 1742 !5530 7308 .4:380 99 89094 03/4,

    4 8 90 7054790/ 0,/ .4:380 41 #08543/0398 5,9743088 8003300894 317,,3/94:9706:73,.4220391742

    47349.0949049075,7908940,79078/0-097,#08543/0398

    ,. 41 09., 573.508 ,3/ 8 /8/,3 147 1,73088 . ,8

    074/0/ 90 1,9 41 90 50450 3 90 :/.,7 147 #08543/039

    2801 .,:80/ ,3/ ,40/ 90 ;4,943 41 90 ,/;0780 5,798

    .43899:943,7994/:0574.088

    ,-:8,3;:/0!,,,:,34#%.94-07

    3#0074,947089028,734:7941550,8884.,90:89.002097402097,9390710703.0430,141,$:850.90/7:":0034,7.

    #4370,94394/23897,9;04$

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    25/70

    %02,990782,/0478083.09070.,87054790/94

    ,;0 -003 ,9 90 389,3.0 41#08543/039 4743, 4 ,/2990/

    9,9303-90/174290.,804903.,30:8918

    390710703.0398.,8094/,9,05,79473907107034

    ,9 8 0;03 2470 /89:7-3 8 9,9 :3/07 #08543/039

    4743,8,9.,801:89.090$:570204:79,550,7894-0

    ,.93432070099078059//0317429480.43.0730/,3/90

    49075,7908,3/,1742908,20,078909403/4,

    92:89-070.,0/9,9908,208909403/4,7490

    ,507843,0990794#08543/039.,84.,:80/901514553

    3900,:041908;.,8092:89,84-070.,0/

    9,9 89094 03/4, 8 ,84 90 8,20 507843 4 10/

    /23897,9;0 ,9907 4 $ ,3/ ,8 ,243 90

    509943078390$:570204:79454890/9,97877442,

    ,55439 90 309 01 :89.0 /08590 90 .43899:943, -,3 ,3/

    974: . 509943 2,/0 9 5488-0 147 90 $:57020 4:79 94

    0920 ,3/ 574;/0 349 43 , 897,30/ -:9 4-;4:8 0774304:8

    -,88 147 90 2/39 ,3/ .43899:943,574-90/ ,554392039

    41#08543/039

    3 98 .4330.943 #08543/0398 ;493 5,99073 0;035747 948/:-4:8 ,554392039 ,8 01:89.0.0,7574;08 ,

    -,8 ,3/ 2,31089 5,79,9 147 78 7744 92:89 -0 3490/ 9,9

    :3/0790,-,8300/349-0574;0394,.9:,08998034:

    9,9 90 01 :89.08 ,.9438 03/ 90280;08 94 , 70,843,-0

    8:85.43 9,9 0 /408 349 5488088 90 706:70/ 574-9 ,3/

    25,79,93#48,:74;',3:0;,90$:570204:790/9,9

    :/084:/34943703/07,:89.4770.9,3/

    # 48 ::89 0-7:,7 57 :30

    79:74/0,8974;:/.,,3/,74:3.,3/!708/03947,,.,5,, 7744

    098:57,

    4#%:30

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    26/70

    25,79,/0.843-:984://48438:.,2,3307,894 -0 1700 1742 ,3 8:85.43 ,8 94 98 1,73088 ,3/25,79,9 ,3/,894 8 39079 0, :/0 84:/5488088 5741.03. 3 , 3 47/07 9,9 0 .,3

    .42509039 .43897:0 ,3/ 03147.0 90 , 9 8 247025479,39 9,9 0 84:/ ,.9 ,3/ -0,;0 3 8:. ,2,3307 9,9 90 5,7908 -01470 2 84:/ ,;0.431/03.0 38 25,79,9%:89 8349034:9,90 /0./08 .,808 94:9 -,8 ,3/ 1,;47982 47 8 9

    8:11.0399,9031,.97/828014157054880884388,.9:,9438 84:/ 24704;07 38570 9,9 -001 0

    ,08,7810,:/02:8934943-05:70-:9-043/

    8:85.43&3/078.4738:550/(

    %0-,7807147:/08,3/-310703.0089

    147:89.08,3/24890850.,9001:89.0-0.,:8090

    .,7,.90741,:/08507.0;0/-905045034943974:

    8411.,,.98-:9,84974:857;,90247,8,87010.90/3

    809073,-0,;47%:8

    , :/0 84:/ 3 , 503/3 47 574850.9;0

    9,943-014702-08.7:5:4:8.,701:94,;4/

    8:. ,.943 ,8 2, 70,843,- 903/ 94 ,03 90

    8:85.43 9,9 8 84., 47 -:83088 70,9438 47

    1703/858 .43899:90 ,3 002039 3 /0907233 8

    :/., .4:780 &3/078.473 ,3/ 025,8088:550/(

    1,/0.8439,9 8 0,.4770.947 :891,-0.,3

    8:11071742,8:85.434125,79,9247084,/0.8439,9803970:38:554790/-0,70,8433%:89,8-0030/9,9

    ,:/048347,39411,7002039,7,3/6:901,2,70,

    573.508 ,3/ ,/23897,9;0 70:,9438 ,8 , 2,70/ 503.,39

    147,553:34794/40;03897,30904708,3/.43.0598390

    ,/:/.,943 41 .43974;07808 0-98 3/110703.0 94 ,3/ 0;03

    /8/,3 147 /:0 574.088 ,3/ 90 7:0 41 , ,5508 90 ,

    28., .,57.4:8 ,3/ 4557088;0 ,3/ /85,8 -,8 ,3/

    ,, ; :/0 0 8, 4 % : 07 41 4:79:03.,234;:/008,4%:

    ,343,343841:/.,9.8/23897,9;07/074/,90/::89419005,79203941:89.0

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    27/70

    5,79,98:31994-0,:/0

    #08543/039 1:7907 .42574280/ 8 3/0503/03.0

    03 8 10 7893, 4743, ,..0590/ ,3 ,554392039 43

    ,7.17427847,774494904,7/419043,

    ,3,02039 47547,943 %0 8 , 4430/

    8:-8/,7 .47547,943 41 90 ,808 43;07843 0;0452039

    :9479,4;0732039430/,3/.439740/.47547,943

    .70,90/:3/07#05:-..94

    $479 ,1907 ,88:23 07 05,3 4- ,9

    8074:8 .425,398 070 10/ ,,389 78 4743, - 07 104

    4,7/202-078,80,8174290,3,02039,3/7,3,3/10

    0254008 41 90 78 4743,8 00.943 ,8 70.947 ,3/

    !708/039 ,8 7054790/ 9/7,3 3 , 7084:943 5,880/ - 90

    4,7/ 41 70.9478 41 -0.,:80 41 ,.98 41 28.43/:.9 ,3/

    3003.0450841904,7/#084:9439/7,378

    4743,8 00.943 ,8 !708/039 ,3/ ,72,3 90 !48943

    !,507 5705,70/ - 90 ,3,02039 ,3/ 90 7083,943

    09907 41 70970/ 4:7941 550,8 :89.0 %04/474 #0341742 90

    4,7/ 41 70.9478 , 41 . .743.0 90 8074:8

    770:,7908 .422990/ - 78 4743, ,70 ,99,.0/ 07094 ,8

    33008,3/70850.9;0

    3890,/ 41 ,.93 :543 90 8074:8 .425,398 ,,389

    78 4743, 78 7744 3897:.90/ , 202-078 41 90 94

    903/07 907 .4:7908 7083,9438 220/,90 1907 90

    7083,9438 78 4743, ,8 709,30/ ,3/ 0;03 5742490/ ,1907

    !708/039 7744 0570880/07 /0870147 784743,8 00.943,8

    ,72,341904,7/

    ,7,307,;4.84348#%#%#%#%#%#%,3/#%$05902-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    28/70

    08590 90 3:2074:8 4907 .425,398 ,,389 78

    4743,3.:/34301742,:4,47#03,/4,:989,070

    0 57490890/ 78 4743,8 24;0 94 705,.0 90 202-078 41 90

    ,3,02039%0,2 3;4,943419090728419 4:3.

    #084:9434.57490.989080.:7941903:70390

    414.,708/03984..:5305489438390.47547,943,.45

    41 8 09907 /,90/ : 8 ,99,.0/ ,8 330 ,3/

    /08590,/;078013/383907054799,9,84089,-80/9,9

    80 ,8 2574507 4/3 411.0 3 $9 3,9:8 ',0 3 ":043

    9784743,,83497024;0/174207548943$0,80;03

    ,40/ 94 7,. :5 :330.088,7 0503808 949,3 $ :3/70/

    309%4:8,3/3/30:3/70/9%700!0848!

    . 80 85039 4/3 411.0 3 ":043 9 03 8

    4507,9438 070 , 3 ,:4 9 .45 41 90 705479 8

    ,99,.0/,8330

    784743,84-,8038:70/9850.1.3897:.9438

    417877440570880/974:80;07,/087009907888:0/9490

    850.1., 94 038:70 90 00.943 41 78 4743, 9480;07,

    5489438390.450841.,70,99,.0/,833008

    ,3/%8,8405,38/08590908074:8.425,398

    ,,389784743,78774430;077024;0/071742-:9

    3890,/059435742493,3/57490.9307

    784743,8,5543920398,;4,94341904/041

    :/.,43/:.99,9574;/08

    :/08 8, 349 ,4 1,2 84., 47 490770,943858 94 31:03.0 :/., .43/:.947 :/2039

    %057089041:/.,411.08,349-0:80/4703994

    ,/;,3.0 90 57;,90 39070898 41 49078 347 .43;0 47

    507294907894.43;090257088439,990,703,850.,54894394 31:03.0 90 :/0$0.,343

    025,88,3/:3/078.4738:550/(

    :/08 8, 349 :80 47 03/ 90 570890 41 90:/.,411.094,/;,3.090757;,9039070898479480

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    29/70

    41,202-07419071,2 4741,34300803478,90 .43;0 47 50729 49078 94 .43;0 90 257088439,9 ,3430 8 3 , 850., 548943 2574507 9431:03.0 902 3 90 5071472,3.0 41 :/., /:908

    $0.,343025,88,3/:3/078.4738:550/(

    %004/041:/.,43/:.91:7907574;/089,9

    98:309.,147,2,897,90,3/202-0784181,294,814747

    70.0;0,31930.,30147,3,.9/4304794-0/430-90

    :/0390.4:780418:/.,1:3.9438

    :/08,3/202-078419071,2088,30907,8 147 347 ,..059 ,3 19 -06:089 4,3 47 1,;47 370,94394,393/4304794-0/4304742990/94-0/430-247073.4330.9439905071472,3.041 :/., /:908 $0. ,343 025,88 ,3/:3/078.4738:550/(

    :/08 8, 349 43 -0 1700 1742 3,557457,90

    .4330.94389,3/ 31:03.0- 9000.:9;0 ,3/08,9;0 -7,3.08 41 4;0732039 -:9 2:89 ,84,550,794-017009070174294,70,843,-04-807;07$0.,343025,88,3/:3/078.4738:550/(

    0,7 , 7488 2574507 ,94: 507843, ,3/

    2:9:,-0301.,70,94385-0900390#08543/039,3/78

    7744,8.70,90/03784743,,8,554390/9490%08,:3/07900.:9;005,7920390,/0/-

    787744%0,55439203941784743,3,898089

    2,3,02039 411.07 8 .0,7 3903/0/ 94 80.:70 90 4,9 ,3/

    ;490 41 #08543/039 3 90 $:57020 4:79 3 , 82,7 .,80 90

    $:57020 4:79 14:3/ 9 :309., 147 90 :/0 94 ,4 8

    /,:9078 94 ,..059 90 -:83088 41107 41 5078438 4 ,;0 ,

    503/3.,80-0147090:/08.4:79

    %0 0 4/0 41 :/., 43/:.9 147 90!5530 :/.,7 5708.7-08 9,9 :/08 8, 038:709,9349438907.43/:.9,-4;070574,.-:99,99

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    30/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    31/70

    ,..4:39.,739490:/.,7507843,0503/9:708

    9890701470,55,70399,99070870,843,-074:3/

    944/#08543/039 147 90 7054790/28:80415:-.1:3/8,3/3

    ,.98 9,9 4:/ 6:,1 ,8 ;4,9438 41 90 ,397,19 ,3/ .477:59

    57,.9.08 ,.9 3.:/3 2,;078,943 41 5:-. 1:3/8 ,3/ :80 41

    5:-.1:3/814757;,905:754808

    3 ,//943 #08543/039 4743, 1,0/ 94 2,39,3

    89,3/,7/8 41 :/., .43/:.9 3 .4330.943 9 90 '.43/0

    2,88,.70 .,80 3 90 574.088.,890/ /4:-9 :543 90 3907941

    90$:570204:799801

    :/08 2:89 0-9,3/ 5742490 89,3/,7/8 41

    :/., .43/:.9 3 47/07 94 703147.0 5:-. .431/03.0 3 90

    :/.,7 . 8 1:3/,2039, 94 90 2,3903,3.0 41 :/.,

    3/0503/03.0 %4 /4 84 9 8 706:70/ 9,9 8 47 07 .43/:.9

    -493,3/4:941.4:792,39,38,3/03,3.0890.431/03.041

    905:-.900,574108843,3/9,39839025,79,94190

    :/0 ,3/ 41 90 :/.,7 3.:/0/ 3 98 5708.75943 41 ,9

    .43899:908 ,..059,-0 ,3/ 343,..059,-0 .43/:.9 8 9,9 7:0

    9,9 :/08 8, 349 343 0 , 574.00/3 8 -01470 47

    .4:/ .420 -01470 902 2,0 ,3 .422039 9,9 2970,843,--0050.90/94,110.9904:9.420418:.574.00/3

    4725,7902,310891,730884190574.088478, :/082,0

    ,3.42203935:-.474907809,929,110.9901,797,41

    ,3 507843 47 88:0 080 :/08 8, 349 3 90

    5071472,3.041:/.,/:908-47/847.43/:.9 2,31089-,8

    $008!7088#00,80890-4078,.98,5700259;024;0:,;,,-0,9995-,:42/,3/.4:707.425.9,8524/0 ,7.;08:.999 1,91: 57394:9 41 90 ,79.0 8,99,.0/,833007041

    $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9 $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9 $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    32/70

    47570:/.094,7/8,35078434774:5437700;,3974:3/8

    08590 9080 897.9:708 #08543/039 ,8 /70.9

    /0-07,90 ,3/ 8,20088 ,9902590/ 94 /08974 90 .70/-9

    ,3/ 89,3/3 4190 $:57020 4:79 9 70850.9 94 430 25479,39

    ,3/ 5:-..00-7,90/ .,80 9,9 ,8 -01470 9 43 ,:942,9.

    ,550,90.00-7,90/'.43/0,88,.70.,80

    $420920 3 0,7 $05902-07 ,:74 '.43/0

    8:7;;3 202-07 41 90 '.43/0 1,2 4 070 2:7/070/ 3

    ,3/ ,390 2030 41 90 '4:390078 ,389 720 ,3/

    477:5943'5,/,.4:7908.,:54390#08543/03938

    .,2-078,19078,554392039,801:89.0

    :73 90 .4:7908 ., '.43/0 ,80/ 90

    #08543/039 ,-4:9 90 89,9:8 41 90 2:950 2:7/07 .,80 ,,389

    :-079 0-- ,3/ 90 4907 ,..:80/ . ,8 ,9 90 920

    503/3 ,550, -01470 90 $:57020 4:79 08590 90 4-;4:8

    25745709 #08543/039 3890,/ 41 70-:113 '.43/0 147 ,83

    90 6:089438 03,0/ '.43/0 3 , 507843, ,3/ 05,790

    .43;078,943 70,7/3 , .,80903 503/3.438/07,943-01470

    90$:570204:79

    4780 3 90 .4:780 41 90 .43;078,943 #08543/039

    94/ '.43/0 3 90 570803.0 41 2030 9,9 104 :89.0

    39434,754 ,8,00/ 4--3 147 90 ,.6:99, 41:-079

    0-- ..47/3 94 '.43/0 3 , 8473 11/,;9 /,90/ ,3:,7

    #08543/039 8,/ 9,9 %,,,3 -73,-7,84 ,9 3

    25:038,,3 3 ,754 ,3 ,3,3 2, ,8,2, 5,7,

    2,5,,,38,, 8 0-- ,754 ,8 70, ,729893 ,3/

    31:03.38.40,:0894,.6:90--(4747/8949,90110.9

    $0.,34304/041:/.,43/:.9 !04504190!55308;0,3409,#0.02-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    33/70

    2030 .4774-47,90/ '.43/08 89,902039 3 8 43 8473

    11/,;9/,90/,3:,7

    %01,.99,9#08543/03985409'.43/070,7/3

    , .,80 503/3 -01470 90 $:57020 4:79 8 3 9801 ,70,/ ,

    8074:8-70,.41907:041.431/039,99,92:89-02,39,30/

    -904:79970850.994.,808503/3-014709,80,890

    /0-07,9438 41 90 202-078 41 90 4:79 $:. .431/039,9 8

    ,-84:90 30.088,7 347/07 94 038:709,9 202-078 41904:79

    ,70 38:,90/ 1742 4--3 ,3/ 57088:70 .423 1742 ,3 41 90

    9,39841,503/3.,80#08543/0398,.943,801:89.08

    39801:3-0.423,3/:347941,01:89.0

    3/00/ 3 #0 09907 41 !7 08/3 :89.0 437,/4

    ',86:090$:570204:798,3.9430/,:89.041904:7941

    550,8 147 , 82,7 ,.9 41 /8.:883 , 503/3 .,80 9

    39070890/5,7908147,;31,0/942,39,39089,3/,7/41

    3/0503/03.0,3/57457099,98706:70/412%0$:57020

    4:791:79070/

    %,3 8 .43;078,943 9 8 -74907 ,3/ 803.4:39078 9 7 /0 47, 940907 :89.0 $,-4;0890257088439,908,..088-0944--89844:/:31,797942,35:,90.4:79574.00/38;03

    ,88:23 ,7:03/4 9,9 :89.0 $,-4 ,8 349 24;0/- 8 -749078 706:089 ,3/ 9,9 0 700.90/ 7 /047,8 -7-0 41107 90 4:79 1008 .42500/ 94 .,:89.0 $,-48 ,9903943 94 8 43 8479.4238 :3/0790.7.:289,3.08990;070,89:89.0$,-484:/,;0 70,0/ 9,9 8 /8.:88438 41 .4:79 2,990780850.,94809,9,;034909-0032,/0415:-.

    70.47/950784384,7039070890/390.,800703.70/- 3/8.7009 ,3/ 903/0/ 94 :3/07230 90

    39079 41 :/., 574.08808 0 800 34 70,843 9470;0780 90 !,308 13/3 9,9 :89.0 $,-48.43;078,9438 9 8 -74907 ,3/ 7 /0 47, 070

    3/8.7009,3/257:/039

    4.94-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    34/70

    $31.,39#08543/039830/,3/.43.:770/990

    ,-4;02039430/ #084:943 41 90 $:57020 4:79 09

    #08543/039 4743, .422990/ 90 8,20 5073.4:8 ,.9 41

    /8.:883,503/3.,80939070890/5,7908

    4780 40;07 8 90 1,.9 9,9 #08543/039 397:0/

    ,,389904347,3/3907941,104:89.038,-803.03

    90 574.088 2,33 ,3/ :3/07233 90 .70/-9 41 90

    $:57020 4:79 ,8,3 3899:9435,393 147 '.43/0, 5.9:70

    41,4:799,988:-0.9949031:03.0414304:941:89.08

    ,3/2,39,550,79,9900;039:,/0.84341904:79390

    .,80 4:/ -0 ,997-:9,-0 94 39073, ,729893 ,3/ 31:03.0

    #08543/039 /089740/ 90 .70/-9 41 90 ;07 3899:943 9,9 0

    ,88:55480/94-00,/3

    3 973 94 53 90 -,20 41 , 5488-0 ,.6:99,

    :543,104:89.0#08543/039,8280184390800/841

    /8.439039,3//897:894190$:570204:799,5,799,398

    9,55030/'.43/0,3/2030//7,80908:55480/39073,

    ,729893,3/31:03.0-014709020/,090.,80,83

    9013,89,0841/0.843574;43'.43/094570025990

    /0.843 9 30,9;0 5:-.9 #08543/039 2801 8 :9 41

    /70.9 :3/07233 90 97:89 ,3/ .431/03.0 41 90 5:-. 3 90$:57020 4:79 70,7/088 41 ,9 98 /0.843 4:/ ,;0 ,907

    9:730/4:994-0

    47808989,990,.94190#08543/039;4,908$0.

    41 #05.9 47 90397,19,3/477:59!7,.9.08.9

    .574-98,3411.,1742/;:3;,:,-031472,94341

    , .431/039, .,7,.907 ,.6:70/ - 8 411.0 47 - 2 43

    ,..4:39418411.,54894394:3,:9470/507843847700,83

    8:. 31472,943 3 ,/;,3.0 41 98 ,:9470/ 700,80 /,90 9 8

    .0,7 1742 90 .43909 41 90 .43;078,943 9 '.43/0 ,3/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    35/70

    20309,9#08543/039,883,390,9907945705,70147,3

    ,.6:99,,3/ ;3 902 8420430 94 -,20 9070147 ;0390

    574104190.,8098349:370,843,-094,88:209,9,990

    920 41 90 .43807;,943 90 $:57020 4:79 ,/ ,70,/ -0:3

    /0-07,9438 43 90 .,80 ,3/ 9,9 #08543/039 ,70,/ ,/ ,

    8038041,990/0.84341904:794:/574-,--0

    #08543/039 4743, 9 :3/:0 ,890 25745709 ,3/

    770:,79/82880/903907509,70.70,943,.47547,943.,80

    :3/078:85.4:8.7.:289,3.08

    #08543/039 ,8 ,..:80/ - 073,3/4 ,2548 41

    :309., .43/:.9 03 0 209 0 5,790 9 90 ,07 41 90

    ,/;07805,793.4330.9439,503/3.,80-0147023,3

    ,990259 94 /0103/ 2801 ,,389 90 .425,39 147 :309.,

    .43/:.9 10/ ,,389 2 - ,2548 #08543/039 05.9

    ,/2990/;4,93 90 0 4/0 41:/., 43/:.9 38 09907

    /,90/ 0-7:,7 94 90 :/., ,3/ ,7 4:3.

    #08543/039701:90/90.,241,25489,90,00/2099

    ,,0741!0-47547,9433.4330.9439,.,80503/3

    -014702-:9.4:39070/9,9

    3 90 .4397,7 9 ,8 ,2548 2801 4 ,.9;0970/9457088:7020394/0./3#4381,;47,85089070/-.,81742/110703950450438

    -0,1843,/288433800.:9;08:22,70,80/ :89.0 303,:90770 $,39,4 ,5:3,3,3/ 043,7/4 ":8:2-3 ,243 49078 94 3907.0/0147225,888:550/

    38;074347/8#08543/039,/2990/9,9;,74:8

    5078438 070 ,-0 94 .422:3.,909 2 3.4330.943 9 ,

    .,80 9,9 ,8 503/3 -01470 2 570.80 3 ,3 ,990259 94

    #4

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    36/70

    31:03.02387084:94341908,/.,803,43280194

    -0,5574,.0/-5078438.03007097394007.80

    907 31:03.0 4;07 2 43 , 5,79.:,7 .,80 503/3 -01470 2

    ,3/ 3 1,3 94 9,0 47 39,90 ,557457,90 /8.53,7 20,8:708

    ,,389 8:. ,.9438 #08543/039 ;4,90/ -,8. 570.0598 41 90

    0 4/0 41 :/., 43/:.9 . 574;/08 ,243 49078

    9,9

    ,343

    3/0503/03.0

    $0. :/08 8, 007.80 90 :/., 1:3.9433/0503/039 43 90 -,88 41 907 ,880882039 41 901,.98 ,3/ 3 ,..47/,3.0 9 , .438.0394:8:3/0789,3/3 41 90 , 1700 1742 097,304:8

    31:03.0 3/:.02039 57088:70 970,9 47 390710703.0/70.9473/70.91742,36:,790747147,370,843

    $0. :/08 8, 349 ,4 1,2 84., 47 490770,943858 94 31:03.0 :/., .43/:.9 47 :/2039%057089041:/.,411.08,349-0:80/4703994,/;,3.0 90 57;,90 39070898 41 49078 347 .43;0 47507294907894.43;090257088439,990,703,850.,5489439431:03.090:/0$0.:/088,34943-0170017423,557457,90.4330.9438 9 ,3/ 31:03.0 - 90 00.:9;0 ,3/08,9;0 -7,3.08 41 4;0732039 -:9 2:89 ,84

    ,550,794-017009070174294,70,843,-04-807;07

    ,34339079

    $0.:/088,038:709,9349438907.43/:.9

    ,-4;070574,.-:9 9,9 98507.0;0/94-084390;041,70,843,-04-807;07

    $0. %0 -0,;47 ,3/ .43/:.9 41 :/08 2:8970,1172905045081,9390390794190:/.,7

    :89.02:893492070-0/430-:92:89,84-0800394-0/430$0. :/08 84:/ 9,0 47 39,90 ,557457,90

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    37/70

    /8.53,720,8:708,,389,07847.4:7950784330147:3574108843,.43/:.941.90:/02,,;0-0.420,,70

    ,34325,79,9

    $0. :/08 8,038:709,98 4707 .43/:.9-493

    ,3/4:941.4:792,39,38,3/03,3.0890.431/03.041 90 5:-. 90 0, 574108843 ,3/ 9,398 3 90

    25,79,94190:/0,3/4190:/.,7

    ,343'

    !745709

    !745709,3/90,550,7,3.0415745709,70088039,94905071472,3.041,90,.9;90841,:/0

    $0. :/08 8, ,;4/ 25745709 ,3/ 90,550,7,3.041257457093,41907,.9;908

    %47089,903 3#00990741!708/3:89.0437,/4

    ',86:090$:570204:790/9,98:..43/:.9,24:390/94

    , 1,:70 94 2,39,3 90 89,3/,7/ 41 3/0503/03.0 ,3/

    57457099,98706:70/41,:/0

    47 025,88 #08543/039 830/ ,3/ .43.:770/ 9

    90 ,-4;02039430/ #084:943 41 90 $:57020 4:79 $:70

    #08543/039,801:89.0.,3349-0002591742908,207:0

    ,3/573.50801:89.002:893 1,.9-00/94,07

    89,3/,7/%0$:570204:791:79078,/41:89.08

    0 9 2, -0 97:0 9,9 1742 , 58.44.,

    89,3/543947/3,75078438.,3,;0,/0;,70941;,/ 70,.9438 94 ,3 ;03 89:,943 :89.0 $,-4

    84:/-0,7323/8411.0,8,2,897,904190,550,90 .4:79 8098 2 ,5,79 1742 47/3,7 5078438

    03908:-0.941.4389,395:-.8.7:93202-07841

    90-03.84:/1700,3/3,..059-0,;47,

    70897.9438 9,92, -0;00/-47/3,7 .9038 ,8

    4.94-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    38/70

    -:7/038420025,888:550/

    4704;07#08543/0393494384:/,;08.7:5:4:8

    :,7/0/ 8 705:9,943 ,8 , $:57020 4:79 :89.0 9 -044;0/

    :543294,;0/430,5489;0,.994038:709,9,2548,3/

    90 ,99078 0288,708-0 /0,9 9 ,/23897,9;0 147 90 -7,03

    ,990259 94 31:03.0,2,897,90 4190$:57020 4:79%80

    :99071,0/94/4

    ' #$!%%#%!&

    %#&$% # %%

    &! '% %

    $%%&%%%%

    $## % !#!

    $!#% !#$

    $$& $%%&$ "& %

    ## $% % &$

    #!#$%%'$ % $# % !%

    % &$

    #%$ '##

    &%##

    3 $05902-07 2-:/82,3 07.0/9,8

    :90770 10/ , !09943 147 07947,7 ,3/ !74-943 -01470 90

    $:57020 4:79 8003 94034390 4229900 43:89.0 41 90

    4:80 41#05708039,9;08 1742 574.00/3 9 90 250,.2039

    574.00/38,,38907:907708895,0/!0994357,0/147

    , %02547,7 #0897,33 7/07 ,,389 90 250,.2039

    574.00/38

    -/ $0.943,343419004/041:/.,43/:.9254808:543:/08,3

    4-,943 94 9,0 47 39,90,557457,90 /8.53,7 20,8:708 ,,389 ,078 47.4:79 50784330 147:3574108843,.43/:.941.90 :/02, ,;0 -0.420,,70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    39/70

    9 :3/:0 ,890 90 1443 /, ,1907 13

    #08543/039220/,909,-0/:907708!09943/08590901,.9

    9,9 349 , 90 :89.08 ,/ 70.0;0/ 47 70,/ 90 !09943

    #08543/039 7,74,/0/ 90 574.00/38 3 47/07 94 ,;0 , $9,9:8

    ":43907/0788:0/31,;4741:90770%8,8.431720/-

    :89.0 ,7, 4:7/08 $07034 3 07 43.:773 5343 94 90

    0-7:,70.843

    3 , 13, 3490 90 88:,3.0 41 90 $9,9:8 ":4390 7/07 3 98 .,80 ,8 2489 :31479:3,90 9 ,8

    88:0/ 4;07 90 4-0.9438 41 :89.08 39434 ,75443.9,,75447,08,3/2801-00;0/903,8 -00;0 34 9,9 90 4:79 3 88:3 90 8,/ 47/07,8 4;07 397:8;0 9 70850.9 94 , 5407 9,9 /408349 -043 94 9 - 70897,33 94:9 0,73 , .406:, -7,3. 41 4;0732039 %8 -001 ,8 2,/02470,.:90-901,.99,99047/07,8;490/:5433

    902473341$05902-0794:990-0301941

    ,03:30314720//0-,9083.080;07,202-07841

    904:792801 3.:/0/,/3490990370.0;0/,

    .454190!09943

    $:570204:79/0;0770.0595:-80/-90308

    2,,3008-70,,84840/9,924894190:89.0870.0;0/

    90!09943,190790/0-07,943809700:89.084;490/

    94 88:0 90 $9,9:8 ":4390 7/07 70.0;0/ 90 509943 43 43

    $05902-07 , /, ,1907 9089,9:8 6:4 ,390 47/07 ,8

    7,390/%080:89.08070:89.08'0,8.4078,23,3/!070

    %088:,3.04190$9,9:8":43907/078,-097,,

    41 90 5:-. 97:89 83.0 9 .0,7 840/ #08543/0398

    ,3/0/3088-,88:-807;03.0,3/5,798,385%088:,3.041,

    #4$05902-07 $00 330, .454190/0;07705479,8 8039 -90$:57020 4:7994 90

    43 #4/414 ,7N,8 $00 ,84 330 147 , 1,91: 57394:9 41 90 /0;0770.059,85:-80/-08-70,398,79.00;0770.059848:89.08;490/43 :90770 509943 -01470 70.0;3 .4508 ,;,,-0 43995308-70,5/0;0770.059848:89.08;490/43:90770509943-0147070.0;3.4508

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    40/70

    $9,9:8":43907/07,,389,.406:,-7,3.414;0732039

    94:9 0;03 90 -03019 41 90 :89.08 70,/3 90 /0.843 8 ,

    97,33., ,-:80 41 5407 94 1,;47 , 9,39 ,3/ 94 4-897:.9 90

    250,.2039 574.088 %0 88:,3.0 41 90 47/07 ,84 /70.9

    ;4,908 90 573.50 41 805,7,943 41 54078 83.0 90 $:57020

    4:79570;0390/904:801742/4398.43899:943,2,3/,9041

    39,93250,.2039574.00/38

    ' #$!%%#%!&

    %#&$% %#& %

    #%##$$!#%%

    $$%%$##%

    !#!#$&%%

    $$''%

    #% %$ %

    !#% % $

    %!#'

    %0573.504122:9,-94113, :/20398843041

    90 57247/, 7:08 147 ,;3 , .70/-0 ,3/ 0110.9;0 88902 41

    ,/23897,94341:89.0&3/0798573.50

    9,943 2:89 03/ ,3/ 90723,90 8420920 ,3/8420070,3/98088039,94,30110.9;0,3/011.039,/23897,943 41 :89.0 9,9 43.0 , :/2039 ,8

    -0.42013,903335,79-0349 974:,20708:-9071:0/057;0/419017:984190;07/.9

    8 05,30/ - 90 $:57020 4:79 3 98 0,7089 0,78

    8:. , 573.50 8 ,3 25479,39 706:702039 147 , .70/-0 ,3/0110.9;08890241,/23897,94341:89.09:8

    43.,.;$,3/,3-,,3#,.932;,-,/0#457$#

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    41/70

    9 8 97:0 9,9 9 8 90 5:75480 ,3/ 3903943 41 90 ,9,9.4:79884://0./0,6:0894388:-2990/94902+,8 97:9 ,3/ :89.0 706:70 ,3/9,9 9 870,9 94 -0/0870/ 9,9 , :/20398 84:/ -0 84 /0./0/ -:9

    .439743,3/770889-070,8438415:-.54.,3/4184:3/ 57,.9.0 3 90 .4:798 /02,3/ 9,9 ,9 90 78414..,843, 07747 :/20398 41 .4:798 /0907233.43974;07808 8:-2990/ 94 902 84:/ -0.42013, ,98420/0139092010/-,47-,7:04157,.9.0

    70.430/ - , 84 ,8 94 -0 9070,1907 -043/ 90.43974 0;03 41 90 .4:79 . 703/070/ 902 147 90

    5:7548041.4770.93077478411,.94741,394.3 90 45343 41 90 .4:79 9 2, ,;0 1,03 %0 ;075:75480 147 . 90 .4:798 ,70 47,30/ 8 94 5:9 ,3

    03/94.43974;07894/0./0906:0894388:-2990/94909,398,3/94/09072309070850.9;079841905,7908 9 90 1: 340/0 9,9 .4:798 ,70 34931,-0 90 9,398 8:-29 907 70850.9;0 .,28 147:/2039,3/90,;0,79,9842092047490794,;0 13, :/2039 43 . 90 .,3 70 ,8 , 13,/8548943419088:08:-2990/,3/94349,990708,303/94909,943

    #08543/03940;07 ,89:730/8-,. 43 98920

    43470/ 573.50 41 90 22:9,-9 41 13, :/20398 3 349 :89

    430 -:9 80;07, .,808 41 5:-. 831.,3.0 9:8 ,43 90

    4:79 94 ,3 5:-. 3494709 ,8 , 1514553 4:79 9 0,89

    94 41 9080 151458 ,70 343 94 ,;0 -003 389,90/ 974:

    507843, 099078 47 05,790 .422:3.,9438 ,//70880/ 94 90

    #08543/039

    730/4;470390!,9 $00 1470,250 #06:04 #$:57020 4:79 151458 7/ 920 8 30 .908

    ,3,$9,3/,7/0-7:,733007041#06:04#9080,:0/054708 .4:79 15145 ,3,$9,3/,7/,7. 330! 07041.023,/, ! $:57020 4:79 15145 .431:808 .9 2,478 !5530 $9,70-7:,7 330" 07041 420 #4 43.908 7,08 ,8 $15145 7--0/!5530, 36:707 ,7. 330#07041 3,,938 3 30 $ 15145 $:7,4 %4/, , 3309958:7,494/,.42/3,,9383308.1514592 330$07041#42074!$:89.098500784;071514508-70,57330%07041

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    42/70

    %700.00-7,90/.,808,;05,79.:,7089,-80/90

    $:57020 4:798 1514553 705:9,943 90 0,:0 41 908 ;

    .,803;4;390.70,9434130.90890.,8041

    ,;,774;729,.3;4;0/9057424943413,,98,3/

    1742 2:3.5,994 574;3.0 ,3/ 90$! ;!55307308

    3.09,.,80.3;4;0/90709703.2039570;4:80/

    94-00,4119,9903/,398-903,94381,.,7707390

    900,:041908,3/$!.,80890#08543/0398.:5,-9

    ,8 -097,0/ - 90 1,.9 9,9 90 15145 ,8 570.0/0/ -

    507843, ,3/ 05,790 .422:3.,9438 349 50,/38 1742 ,

    ,0741,5,79,3/.0707,390/94:9;3904907

    5,79,3349.0 47/:0574.088 3 90 ,;,774 .,80 90 15145

    ,8 389,90/ - 90 3907;03943 41 3435,7908 4 8944/ 94

    -0301913,3.,,3/549.,174290704503341,13,,3/

    00.:947:/20399490473,.,80

    %0 0,:0 41 908 ; .,80 ,8 473,

    /0./0/-90$:570204:79434;02-07070390

    4:79 /0.,70/ ,8 :3.43899:943, ,3/ ;4/ 90 .43;07843 41

    2:3.5,908 394 .908 /:0 94 1,:70 94 2009 90 0,

    706:7020398 147 3.420 147 .908 :3/07 90 4., 4;0732039

    4/0 &543 24943 147 70.438/07,943 %0 4:79 ,11720/ 98

    :/2039 43 57 ,1907 90 4:79 /030/ , 574-90/80.43/2494314770.438/07,94310/-902:3.5,908%0

    7:3-0.,2013,43,

    08590 90 13,9 41 90 473, :/2039 ,8 0 ,8

    90 89,3/3 574-943 ,,389 , 80.43/ 24943 147

    70.438/07,943 90 ,70;0/ 5,7908 5078890/ 3 8003 ,

    70;078,41904:798473,/0.843%010/80;07,50,/38

    ,4-;4:83903/0/94.7.:2;03990574-943,,38980.43/

    0,:041908;8:57, #57$!;!8:57,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    43/70

    ,3/8:-806:03924943814770.438/07,943,3/948:-;079907:0

    4322:9,-94113,:/20398949

    , 4943 94 203/ 90 #084:943 41 57

    0.,733890,/9,9#08543/0398 4943147

    #0.438/07,9434190#084:94341,7.,3/

    49431470,;0940,3/%4/2999,.0/$0.43/

    4943 147 #0.438/07,943 41 90 0.843 ,90/

    4;02-07#02,3&37084;0/,3/9443/:.9

    :7907 !74.00/38 %07043 4943 94 203/ 90

    #084:9434157

    -4943147#0.438/07,9434190#084:94341

    :30

    .&7039494394#084;0!03/33./0398

    / 550, 944347,-001:89.0#03,94 $

    !:34,3/884.,90:89.039434/:,7/4,.:7,

    94 !,79.5,90 3 90 #084:943 41 #08543/0398 4943

    147#0.438/07,9434190#084:94341:30

    3,3:,7900,.4:380487054790/,84900,/.4:38041147207!708/0397744307!:3/07,3/

    4907 .,808800 33008 94 ( 147 90 89003 .908

    89094 03/4, 7490 , 507843, 09907 349 , 50,/3 94 90

    $:57020 4:79 ,83 147 90 4:79 94 70.438/07 98 /0.843 -

    ,43 90 5,79.5,943 41 :89.08 4 070 349 5708039 /:73

    90/0-07,9434190473,/0.843/,90/4;02-07

    34907 507843, 09907 349 , 50,/3 ,88039 94 90 $:57020

    4:79 - 90 4., .01 00.:9;08 41 90 89003

    2:3.5,908574850.9;0.908

    3.40,7$0990788978:85.4343.944/!5530,36:707::89

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    44/70

    30.02-0790$:570204:7970;0780/90

    /0.843 41 4;02-07 /08590 90 1,.9 9,9 90 /0.843

    ,8 ,70,/ 13, ,3/ 00.:947 ,3/ 9,9 90 50,/38 ,3/

    .422:3.,9438 9,9 0/ 94 90 /0.843 070 0907 057088

    574-90/ 50,/38 47 34350,/38 9,9 ,;0 34 5,.0 3

    9,9434790#:08414:79

    %8 5742590/ 90 0,:0 41 908 94 10 , 24943 147

    70.438/07,9439470;0780900.02-077:3.,390

    ,990394341904:7994903.4388903.4190/0.843990

    89,3/3#:08414:79,3/90573.5084113,941:/20393

    ::89 90 $:57020 4:79 70;0780/ 90 0.02-07

    /0.843,3/70389,90/98473,4;02-07/0.843

    8 01 :89.0 ,3/ 0,/07 41 90 $:57020 4:79 0 84:/ 349

    ,;0,40/904:7994039079,3574-90/50,/38-0.,:809

    :3/072308903907941904:79,3/987:0841574.0/:70

    08590 98 7:3 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07

    #08543/0398 0,/0785 903 039079,30/ ,3 :3:8:, ,3/ 949,

    :3570.0/0390/ 14:79 24943 147 70.438/07,943 10/ - 90

    2:3.5,908 43 $05902-07 3 0-7:,7 90

    4:79 7,390/ 90 24943 147 70.438/07,943 ,3/ 70;0780/ 90

    70;078, 41 90 70;078, 41 90 473, /0.843 0 9 70389,90/ 98 770:,7 /0.843 70;0783 , :/2039 9,9 ,/ 43 -003

    13, ,3/ 00.:947 %0 :3570.0/0390/ 1514553 41 90

    $:570204:79,55030/3:89,85,341824398,3/:3/0790

    8,209:90,041#08543/0394743,

    $:-806:039 390.,8041,;,774;729,/0,3

    990.43899:943,94190.70,9434190!74;3.0413,,9

    1,91: 57394:9 41 90 ,79.0 ,8 14:3/ 399530831436:70730936:7070,/30870438;00,7$0990788978:85.43843.944/8,99,.0/,8330&

    $:57,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    45/70

    8,3/ 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07 #08543/0398 ,9. ,,3

    50714720/ :/., ,.74-,9.8 03 9 70;0780/ 98 473, /0.843

    0;0394:9,/,70,/-0.42013,,3/00.:947,89,9:8,

    90247090/-901,.99,99070,8,70,/,339741

    :/2039

    398.,8090$:570204:79,//0./0/,,38990

    .43899:943,9 41 90 .70,943 41 90 !74;3.0 41 3,,9 8,3/

    -,. 3 0-7:,7 %0 :/2039 -0.,20 13, ,3/

    00.:947,3/,339741:/2039,82,/043,

    ..47/3 94 90 #:08 41 4:79 90 397 41 :/2039 8 ,

    238907,,.99,9 70.47/890,-84:90 770;4.,-9 41,/0.843

    41,.4:79,1907908,20,8-0.42013,,3/00.:947043/

    ,5,:8-070,84340;0790$:570204:7914:3/9020,38

    94 .43/:.9 90 ;07-, 23,89.8 ,3/ 802,39. .439479438

    30.088,7945071472,949,:3570.0/0390/:/.,842078,:9

    %8 ,2,3 2,30:;07 ,8 ,..42580/ :543 90

    389,943 , 1: 2439 ,1907 90 0397 41 :/2039 41 84.,0/

    249438 147 3907;03943 - 90 574850.9;0 574;3., 411.,8 ,3/

    .43708843,705708039,9;08413,,98,3/.070/030/

    - 90 4:79 .438/073 9,9 90 070 349 0;03 5,7908 94 90

    473,574.00/38,3/3907;03943.,3349-0,40/,190790.,80,8,70,/-00390723,90/%8,81440/-,3&7039

    494394#0.,39741:/2039/,90/.94-0710/-

    90803435,7908.904:799037,390/5,;390,147

    ,70.438/07,943,3/70;078,4190:/2039.,8,70,/

    13,

    3 84 /43 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07 #08543/0398

    0,/0785,82,/0,97,;08941 98437:0841 574.0/:70,3/

    /0243897,90/9,990708,.9:,4343025479,397:0070

    90708,,3/.4330.94390708,,3/0;07939,9

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    46/70

    ,078 34 ,-4:9 :/., 574.0/:70 .42243 80380 1,7 5,

    ,3/ :89.0 -0.420 2449 ,3/ ,.,/02. 03 .43174390/

    998507;078434190#:08414:79$4-,9,39.4397,794,

    :/.,70,843,898,.941904:799,90;03884.,90:89.0

    74354390/4:93888039353439,990/0.843/70.9

    ;4,90/984339073,7:08,3/,90,8997002,4714:3/,943841

    90,/23897,94341:89.05,79.:,7

    ,907:04370.438/07,943-,43,24943

    147 70.438/07,943 .4397,7 94 90 7:0 ,,389 80.43/

    249438 147 70.438/07,943 ,3/ ,1907 90 574.00/38

    ,/,70,/90723,90/

    -907:04313,941:/20398-7045033,

    .,809,9,70,/,99,30/13,9974:90,791.041

    ,249439470.,039741:/2039,3/

    .907:0433907;03943-,433907;03943

    ,190790574.00/38,/,70,/90723,90/

    3 1,.9 884.,90 :89.0 743 .4:/ 349 /0 8

    ,-84:90 /8:89 9 90 4:798 7:3 3 8 /88039 .483 9 ,8

    1448

    &30 90 .,80 41 ,,7:8 4 7480 1742 90/0,/ 974: , 27,.0 3,,9 708:770.90/ -0.,:8090 4:79 /870,7/0/ 98 43 7:08 ,3/ 089,-80/:7857:/039, 573.508 1 .4:780 9 .,3 82,7 -0.,0/,27,.0,83470;078,.4:/,;09,035,.01:89430419080708 4197,38708843854390/ 4:9//349 9,0 5,.0 4 8:. 708:770.943 .,3 ,5503 3

    90$:570204:798,.4393:384:7.04143/07

    729,;,;,7748:57,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    47/70

    %080 94 .,808 43 0772,3/073 ,70 41 .4:780 43

    945 41 90 .,80 41 $! ; !5530 7308 3. .

    84.,808 90 $:57020 4:798 503.,39 147 88:3 1514553

    /0.8438 3 98 .,80 90 $:57020 4:79 ,/ ,70,/

    5742:,90/ , /0.843 /,90/ : 4/3 9,9 90

    709703.20390110.90/-!34124709,3419819

    ,9903/,398,80,%8/0.843-0.,2013,,190790$:57020

    4:79/030/913,9!8 49438 147 #0.438/07,943 43

    .94-07 ,3/ $05902-07 :74:8 40;07 90

    #084:9438/033!849438147#0.438/07,94307070.,0/

    - ,34907 #084:943 3 ,9 80020/ 94 -0 , 805,7,90

    ,/23897,9;0 .,80 4 $ 43 90 840 -,88 41 ,

    507843,099078:-2990/9490$:570204:79-8909403/4,

    !8,073/,89900,:041908;.,8034

    455479:39 ,8 ;03 94 90 4907 5,79 94 708543/ 94 89094

    03/4,8 507843, ,550, 09907 ,9 9080 1514553

    /0.8438 .0,7 089,-8 8 9,9 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07

    #08543/039 4743,8 ,9. 83 94 -03/ 4;07 -,.,7/8 94

    ,..424/,902070099078-0,739083,9:704147207!708/039

    47,,.,5,,77448,07

    ' #08543/039 097,0/ 90 !:-.

    %7:89 774,93 &394 28013/%44229900070,90/

    %0 :9479 3/ :78/.943 %4

    25745073;089,90300/

    773 02-07 1 %0 $:57020

    4:79 47 %0 !:75480 1

    .:5,93 2 $:. :9479

    3/ :78/.943 8 !74507

    #05480/%043899:943390

    4:80 41 #05708039,9;08 ;,

    250,.2039

    ,343 80. 41 90 0 4/0 41 :/., 43/:.9

    /02,3/8097020247,89,3/,7/841,:/08,3/:89.08

    $:57,

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    48/70

    90 2:89 038:70 9,9 349 43 907 .43/:.9 8 ,-4;0 70574,.

    -:9 9,9 9 8 507.0;0/ 94 -0 84 3 90 ;0 41 , 70,843,-0

    4-807;07%88-:9.438890399,;07433041:7857:/03.0

    ,/ - 90 $:57020 4:79 9,9 :/08 84:/ ,;4/ , 14728 41

    25745709 3.:/3 90 ,550,7,3.0 41 25745709 9 8 ,84

    57,.9.,,:3;078,7:0,243:/.,70847//0

    %0'3:,;80.:9;0$0.709,7 .,80.43.0730/ ,

    509943 - 4907 0, 8.4,78 43 -0,1 41 90 8:7;;3 534

    .42147942034203570880/39480:,8,;07-4..:53,5,3080147.08/:7390$0.43/47/,7439090479,9

    90574-943 ,,3897,50,3/80:,,-:80 3920841,7 8:8

    .4038339073,943,,,3/9070147090$9,90,/,/:994

    5:78:0907.,28174290,5,30804;0732039&54370;041

    90 4:798 /0.843 /033 90 .421479 42038 509943 9 ,8

    ,00/ 9,9 7,25,39 5,,782 ,8 .422990/ - 90 5430390

    884.,90:89.0,7,34/0,894

    %0,00/5,,7823'3:,.425780/90;07-,92

    193 94:9 ,997-:943 ,3/ 03.425,883 -49 90 473,

    ,:9478 79903 909 ,3/ 144934908 41 831.,39 5479438 41 -448

    ,3/ ,79.08 1742 39073,943, , 4:73,8 9,9 8:554790/ 90

    9047 9 0,89 9700 14703 ,:9478 478 070 ,00/

    5,,70/:9,8/017429088:0415,,7829801,1907.453

    174290,79.08904:79,00/2,/0902,550,7948:55479

    90 4554890 .43.:843 0 90 4:79 :80/ 902 94 /03 90

    509943 070,8 90 2,907,8 507 80 84:/ ,;0 -003 8003 94

    1,;47907,39907041

    9 ,550,78 9,9 9 , .0,7 39039 41 04307,93 ,

    202-07 41 90 $:57020 4:79 #08543/039 3 ;4,943 41 90

    #457

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    49/70

    43899:943 14720/ ,3 9.8 4229900 9,9 /0907230/ 90

    .:5,-9 41 , :89.0 41 90 $:57020 4:79 ,3 250,.,-0

    411.07 #08543/039 ,/ 34 5407 94 /4 98 83.0 :3/07 90

    43899:943905407942,0,..4:39,-0250,.,-0411.078

    -0430/ 94 90 4:80 41 #05708039,9;08 %:8 #08543/039

    -097,0/ 90 5:-. 97:89 - ,774,93 :394 2801 ,3/ 94 ,

    42299000.70,90/ 90,:9479,3/ :78/.943943;089,90

    ,3 ,00/ 202-07 41 90 $:57020 4:79 %4 70907,90 8:.

    ,:9479,3/:78/.943,8-003705480/-9043899:943390

    4:8041#05708039,9;08;, 250,.2039 .43899:93 8:. ,

    .4229900,3/-,774,93:3942801540794/090723090

    .:5,-9 41 :89.0 /0 ,894 ,3/ 04307,93 2 3 90 03/

    #08543/0399070-03.74,.0/43908405407,3//:94190

    4:8041#05708039,9;0894/0907230-250,.20390907

    :89.00,894 ,8 94-00/,..4:39,-03;4,943 4190

    573.50 41 805,7,943 41 54078 41 90 08,9:70 ,3/ 90

    :/.,7

    9 2, -0 70.,0/ 9,9 90 473, ,:9478 805,7,90.425,30/ 94 90 $:57020 4:79 ,-4:9 90 3./039 0 90

    509943078 10/ , 24943 147 70.438/07,943 -:9 90 #08543/039

    850,3 974: 90 4:79 /23897,947 39, ,334:3.0/ 9,9

    34 ,.943 4:/ -0 9,03 43 90 2,9907

    %8 ,8 /08590 9070.0594190.425,3981742901789419700,:9478303

    903:2-0741,:9478,/3.70,80/949700//90#08543/039

    $00,57416:0894385,,7824147,,,::89,;,,-0,99952,,,.42530892 , 1,91: 57394:9 41 . 8,99,.0/ ,8330' $00 ,84 90 3/;/:, 09907 41 7 789,3 %,28 .:80/ 94 -0 ,;,,-0 ,9 9958.7-/.42/4.%,280990794$:570204:79 ,.4541 .8 ,99,.0/07094,8330'02,417

    ,7 8 . ,8 6:490/ 09038;0 3 !,-:,3 :947 108 .425,399$!5530,36:707:,.4541.8,99,.0/07094,8330 ' ,3/ , .422039 2,/0 - 7 ;,3 7//0 3 70854380 94 : 39073,943, , 5,,782 -0/0;8 !55308 $:57020 4:79 :89.09954534:784739073,943,,5,,782.,70-0/0;85553088:57020.4:79:89.0,1,91:57394:941.8,99,.0/07094,8330'

    !,-:,3.4:79349 574-35,,782!5530,36:707:30.454190,79.08,99,.0/,8330

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    50/70

    /0./0 94 ,.9 - ,334:3.3 90 1472,943 41 ,3 9.8 #0;0

    4229900.425780/41202-0784190 4:79 94 3;089,9090

    2,9907

    ' #$!%%#%!&

    %#&$% %#&$ !#%%

    #% %!##

    #$%# ## %#

    '# ## !#$%

    # !##

    # &$ $ &

    ####%'%

    !!#%&% % $!!#$&% % #&$%#%

    % $ &$%

    $%#% % $&!# %

    $ % %'%

    % %# ' #

    % ! % %

    %$ % $&!#

    %$%#

    %0$:570204:79:3/0790#08543/039305.,-

    .4384/,90/90805,7,90509943810/-147207!708/03947,

    ,.,5,,7744 ,3/ 07 :8-,3/ :0 7744 3 47/07 94

    6:0894390;,/94190,9.897/07888:0/,,389902-

    9005,79203941:89.05:78:,39947.:,74743.,

    88:0/ - 90 :3/07 77448 ,/23897,943 .4384/,93

    90 5099438 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07 #08543/039 :3/: ,;0

    :0 7744 ,3 :3,77,390/ -03019 83.0 90 ,00/ :7039

    0,9300/841!708/03977444:/34-00903/0/942

    4780 90 $:57020 4:79 :3/07 90 #08543/039

    220/,90,.90/:54390!09943,3/7,390/90%#/08590

    90 1,.9 9,9 9070 ,70 .0,7 3.4388903.08 3 147207 !708/039

    77448 509943 9,9 .,898 8074:8 /4:-98 43 90 83.079 ,3/

    :703. 41 07 706:089 94 0,;0 90 !55308 8 /09,0/ 3 90

    33$:570204:797010785,,782.,809409.8.4229900!5530,36:707:.454190,79.08,99,.0/,8330

    #48,3/4;02-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    51/70

    /88039 41 :89.0 , 4:7/08 $07034 !708/039 7744 57080390/

    3.43889039 ,3/ 574-,- :397:91: 89,9020398 ,-4:9 07

    89:,943 :89.0 $07034 .90//4.:203988:-2990/- 90 147207

    5708/0398 /4.9478 -03 07 .,28 41 970,9 94 10 8/0 1742

    .,3083908941.4:3970880,390/94;89!708/0397744

    ,8,845,333945,79.5,90394.4310703.0803.0:89.0

    $07034 3490/ 9 80028 3.437:4:8 147 50994307 4 ,8 ,80/

    9005,79203941:89.0,3/984:7994449:2,39,7,3

    .43.073 43 07 570.,74:8 89,90 41 0,9 94 .4229 07801 94

    ,9903/9080200938,3/.4310703.08,990784147803307

    58.,.43/943

    4704;07 9 ,550,78 1742 7054798 9,9 90 5430390 94

    429050994380707,110/,8,3884.,90:89.0&3/0790

    39073,#:084190$:570204:79,%#.,343-0.438/070/

    :543 90 70.42203/,943 41 90 5430390 ;/039 3 ;0 41

    .079,3 4-0.9438 ,,389 90 7,39 41 90 %# , 4/3 41 ,

    0,73939084795074/411;0/,8,870.42203/0/

    08590 98 70.42203/,943 90 #08543/039 0330070/ ,

    2,479 41 ;4908,8,,3891;0 /88039078 90 220/,907,39

    ,3/88:,3.04190%#31,;4:741147207!708/0397744,3/07

    :8-,3/3-,9,39;4,943419074339073,7:08

    9,84,550,78174290.447/3,90/,.98419077448

    9,990070.447/3,939#08543/03984:79474.,39

    -0 05,30/ 9,9 90 2,/0 2:950 -4438 43 90 8,20 /,

    050.93 9,9 90 .,3 0,;0 90 .4:397 43 90 ;078,20 /,

    90750,147,%#,894-0/0./0/98349/11.:9948009,9

    90,8988:,3.04190%#,8,-7,03,..4224/,9439490

    7744849439,9#08543/039-0394;07-,.,7/894,/,3/

    ,-0990774485,3940,;090.4:3974390;07/,4190

    80884343907%#50,%04:798411.04:789,9:8:,03/,9

    52070 0903/0/ 94 ,4 90 77448 94 5489 , 20,8 !

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    52/70

    243-43/,907,3/904:79574.088807;07,8/7,190/94807;0

    90%#:54390,3/90$,1907411.04:78

    84/085909,91,.99,9904:79:3/07#08543/039

    ,/ /43 .43/9438 147 90 88:,3.0 41 90 %# #08543/039

    ,40/9088:,3.04190%#349989,3/3901,.99,99,8

    089,-80/ 9,9 !708/039 7744 ,3/ :0 7744 1,0/ 94

    .425 9 ,3 088039, 570.43/943 9,9 ,8 20,39 94 038:70

    90 ;0893 41 .4:79 :78/.943 3 90 0;039 90 77448 100

    57480.:943%0.43/943,8949

    %0 509943078 8, ,55439 , 0,705708039,9;0.4224394-4941902470.0;0

    8:-5403, 47/078 ,3/ 4907 0, 574.08808 43 907

    -0,1 /:73 907 ,-803.0%05099430788, 8:-29903,2041900,705708039,9;0,84931;0

    /,81742349.00704125,888:550/

    %0$50.,!40741994730/,90/4;02-07

    .9088:0/94907.4:3801,89489,909,9907.4:380,/

    9054079470.0;08:-5403,847/078,3/49070,574.08808

    3890,/90430254070/907.4:38094574/:.08:22438

    4770.0;0/4.:2039,70;/03.0

    %,9 # ! ## 41 0,,02,770/5349708/03.0,9,/,4$97009!,384 ":043 9 /4 070- 3,20 .43899:90 ,3/

    ,55439 %% # %! 080 41 0,,05349411.0,//7088,974:3/1447$,%3 %4078 ,;07 $9 79,8 03907 !,8 0974,3,,82 0,705708039,9;0390!55308,3/94-0297:0,3/,1:,99473031,.914723,205,.0,3/ 890,/ 94 /4,3/5071472 901443 ,.98,3/938949

    %483;071,3/10,7990389,902039

    %42,0,3/57080399490.4:79,3,55.,9433.4330.9439,3574.00/383908:9%4574/:.08:224384770.0;0/4.:2039,7

    0;/03.0

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    53/70

    %42,0,3/10.4257428047,.4310884341:/2039,3/947010790.,8094,7-97,943%4/05489,3/9/7,,32430147905:75480

    41,3574.00/3%44-9,3.450841/4.:20398,3/5,5078,3/0307,94/4,4907,1:,.9830.088,714790.43/:.941908,/.,8025,888:550/

    ;79:0419077448,-0.91,:7094.425998570

    .43/943 90 %# 84:/ 349 ,;0 -003 88:0/ 347 /0020/

    0110.9;0

    :0 94 90 77448 ,-0.9 1,:70 94 .425 9

    43/943 90 $:57020 4:79 03-,3.3984;02-07

    /0-07,9438-,;4904114:3/9,99070,834.425,3.0

    9 90 80.43/ .43/943 41 90 %# 43806:039 147 1,:70 94

    .425 9 ,3 088039, .43/943 147 90 %# 90 %# 8 349

    0110.9;040;07-,;4904190$:570204:79/0./0/

    9070,834300/9405.989,90900,0110.94390%#41

    90 343.425,3.0-5099430789 43/943 :2-07 4190

    0,707 #084:943 8 8:..3.9 89,90/ 3 :89.0 , 4:7/08

    $070348/88039

    %0 2,479 ,7:0/ 9,9 8:. , .,71.,943 8

    :330.088,7 -0.,:80 9 8 .0,7 9,9 90 %# 8

    .43/943, ,3/ .,3349 -0 2,/0 :80 41 :39

    .425,3.0 ,8 -003 /430 9,890701470 90 803804190 2,479 9,9 ,8,3 411844941 90 333 ;4909,9 9070 ,8 1,:70 - 509943078 94 .425 943/943 :2-07 90 %# 8 25.9 /0020/8:8503/0/:3990708.425,3.098:..43/943;07430 -00;0/ 9,9 9 4:/ -0 .0,7 94 , 9,9 ,

    .43/943,%#8,998.43/943,

    40;07 90 $:57020 4:79 $5408507843 /,8

    ,76:02,/0,5:-..,2.,8,70/3,20/,4:9098

    9,9904:79489038-/0./0/9,990%#,80110.9;0/08590

    #48,3/4;02-07

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    54/70

    343.425,3.0 9 ,3 088039, .43/943 41 90 %# 0 0;03

    54890/9,99077448.,3890,;090.4:39798349,-09,9

    #08543/039 // 349 .,8980 ,76:0 147 8 4:979 1,80 ,3/

    5:-.28705708039,943#08543/039,801:89.084:/,;0

    .,0/949,8,76:0147280,/3905:-.,894902547941

    90$:570204:79803-,3.7:33890,/0702,30/8039,3/

    // 349 -4907 94 .4397,/.9 ,76:0 9070- ,/3 ,76:0 3

    8570,/31,80308,-4:990,.9434190$:570204:79

    478090#08543/039//349.4770.990/0.8439,9

    ,8 88:0/ /08590 90 1,.9 9,9 90 /0.843 // 349 7010.9 90

    ,7002039 ,3/ /0.843 2,/0 -90$:57020 4:79/:73 907

    /0-07,9438434;02-07#08543/0398:-;0790/90

    41 90 $:57020 4:79 ,3/ 25480/ 8 :3,907, - 2,3 9

    080,550,79,990%#,80110.9;0/08590343.425,3.0

    984325480/570.43/943

    0,7 90701470 #08543/039 343 10/ ,76:0

    9074380380,3/254794190/0-07,943841904:794390

    %# 88:0 %8 1,80 2088,3 3903/0/ 147 90 5:-. ,8

    /0-07,902,/0 - #08543/039 94 2,0 9,550,7 9,9 3/00/

    90 77448 .,3 0,;0 220/,90 ,3/ ,9 ,3 920 0,7

    #08543/0398,.943840/-,8,3/,5,798,389,3.031,;474190 77448 #08543/0398 ,.943 41 .,:83 , 1,80 2088,0 ,3/

    9893 90 80380 ,3/ :3/0789,3/3 41 90 4:79 /:73 98

    /0-07,9438 43 98 2,9907 -097, 349 43 8 ,. 41

    3/0503/03.0.4250903.0,3/574-9-:9247025479,3990

    247, 1-07 94 /850380 :89.0 ,8 0 4:/ ,4 , 17:897,943 41

    :89.014790534!0450147507843,,3,3/.4229203994

    82/39-0301,.947

    4780 /08590 90 13/3 9,9 90 77448 1,0/ 94

    .4259,3088039,.43/9434190%#90$:570204:79

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    55/70

    0,/0/ - #08543/039 4743, 3 , ;490 7:0/ 9,9 90 %#

    ,830110.9

    ' #$!%%#%!&%#&$%#%%#%

    ##&!%

    #&$ %

    &% # %

    '!% &

    $! # %

    $%$

    %0 $:57020 4:79 ,8 ,3 3/0503/039 84:7.0 41

    3.42049079,398 8,703903,943,-:/09 9.40.98 1742

    0;079,3913,.425,39/4.091008.,70:80/14790

    $50., 4,3.0 147 90 :/.,7 $ ,3/ -,8. 0, 1008

    .49490:/.,0;0452039:3/984793493

    9,9 90 :/.,7 0;0452039 :3/ ,3/ 90 /:.,7 :3/

    5,79,04190 3,9:70 4197:89 1:3/8 %0 8-03 .40.90/ 14790-03019 4190202-078 ,3/507843304190:/.,79405

    038:70 ,3/ :,7,3900 90 3/0503/03.0 41 90 :/.,7 3 90

    ,/23897,943 41 :89.0 9 8 ,84 3903/0/ 94 ,:2039 90

    ,4,3.084190202-078,3/507843304190:/.,7,3/94

    13,3.0 90 ,.6:8943 2,3903,3.0 ,3/ 705,7 41 411.0

    06:52039,3/1,.908

    #08543/039,8 7054790/1,0/ ,3/ 701:80/ 94 705479

    43 90 89,9:8 41 90 :3/8 ,3/ 90 $ .40.9438 &3/07 8

    0,/078590$:570204:79,87054790/1,0/9470299490

    :70,: 41 %70,8:7 , $ .40.9438 3 ;4,943 41 90 54. 41

    97,385,703. ,..4:39,-9 ,3/ 44/ 4;073,3.0 %070 8

    080 90 7054790/ 1,:70 41 #08543/039 94 ,..4:39 147 1:3/8

    700,80/ ,3/ 85039 147 :310/ 5489438 3 90 :/.,7 ,3/ 1742

    ,:9470/,3/1:3/0/-:9349.70,90/.4:798

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    56/70

    3 5,79.:,7 90 ,33:, ,:/9 705479 41 90 $:57020

    4:794190!55308330.439,30/904-807;,9439,9

    :3702990/1:3/89490:70,:41%70,8:7,24:390/94!43

    5,041330

    3904907,3/ 90 $50., ,4,3.0147 :/.,7,43 9 90 0307, :3/ :/.,7 0;0452039 :3/ 3 90

    ,24:39 41 ! 43 070 2889,90/ 708:93 1742 /0,0/

    ,3/473435705,7,94341-,370.43.,94389,9020398,3/343

    70.47/3:3.4770.90/70.43.390285,041330

    #$&%,3/!##

    ##5:78:,399490574.0/:70,//43-$0.943

    79.0 41 90 43899:943 43 ..4:39,-9 41 !:-.

    11.078 90 :3/07830/425,3,398 ,8 02-078 4190 4:80

    41#05708039,9;08.43899:93,90,8943097/41,90202-078

    907041 070- 10 90 389,39 '0710/ 425,39#084:943 41

    250,.2039,,389#08543/0394347,-001:89.0#03,94

    4743, ..47/3 9 8 2489 70850.91: 57,0/ 9,9 3

    ,..47/,3.09#:0'4190#:0841!74.0/:703250,.2039

    !74.00/38 5742:,90/ - 90 4:80 41 #05708039,9;08 94

    97,3829 94 90 $03,90 41 90 !55308 90 389,39 '0710/

    425,39#084:943 41 250,.2039 94 807;0 ,8 90 79.08 41

    250,.203914797,

    %070,1907 :3/07830/ 425,3,398 70850.91: 57, 9,9

    90 4347,-0 02-078 41 90 $03,90 .43/:.9 97, 14799 ,3/

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    57/70

    9070,1907 703/07 , :/2039 41 .43;.943 ,,389 #08543/039

    4347,-001:89.0#03,944743,

    90770018:89,3/06:9,-0,7008057,0/147

    ":04390974,3,0.02-07

    !%$

    $% $%#%

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    58/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    59/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    60/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    61/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    62/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    63/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    64/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    65/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    66/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    67/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    68/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    69/70

  • 8/3/2019 Impeachment Complaint vs. Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona

    70/70