Bibliometrics  –  superbe0er  quest  

+7  concussions  and  next  steps  

Learning  objec;ves    

•  Prac;ce  iden;fying  the  differences  between  a  case  study,  a  scien;fic  study,  a  review  or  a  meta-­‐analysis  for  a  scholarly  ar;cle.    

•  Use  advanced  search  strategies  to  find  more  informa;on  on  the  topic.  

•  Use  Medical  Subject  Headings  (MeSH)  to  search  for  ar;cles  in  PubMed.  

•  Use  Mendeley  to  store  cita;ons  and  make  bibliographies.  

5  Most  cited  -­‐  concussions  Citaion  number  

Title   Cited  by  (GS)  

7

McCrory, P; (2009 Jul-Aug). "Consensus statement on concussion in sport: the 3rd International Conference on Concussion in Sport held in Zurich, November 2008.". Journal of athletic training 44 (4): 434–48. 835

29

Savitsky EA, R (2000). "Current controversies in the management of minor pediatric head injuries". American Journal of Emergency Medicine 18 (1): 96–101. 792

74

Alexander MP (1995). "Mild traumatic brain injury: Pathophysiology, natural history, and clinical management". Neurology 45 (7): 1253–60. 728

58

"Facts About Concussion and Brain Injury". Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2006. Retrieved 2008-01-13. 684

34

McCrory P, (April 2005). "Summary and agreement statement of the 2nd International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Prague 2004". Br J Sports Med 39 (4): 196–204. 596

5  Most  cited  -­‐  concussions  Citaion  number  

Title   Cited  by  (GS)  

Times  Cited  (WoS)  

7

McCrory, P; (2009 Jul-Aug). "Consensus statement on concussion in sport: the 3rd International Conference on Concussion in Sport held in Zurich, November 2008.". Journal of athletic training 44 (4): 434–48. 835 124

29

Savitsky EA, R (2000). "Current controversies in the management of minor pediatric head injuries". American Journal of Emergency Medicine 18 (1): 96–101. 792

74

Alexander MP (1995). "Mild traumatic brain injury: Pathophysiology, natural history, and clinical management". Neurology 45 (7): 1253–60. 728

58 "Facts About Concussion and Brain Injury". Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2006. Retrieved 2008-01-13. 684

34

McCrory P, (April 2005). "Summary and agreement statement of the 2nd International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Prague 2004". Br J Sports Med 39 (4): 196–204. 596

Pearling  

•  Cites/cited  by  •  Expands  a  search  •  WoS  &  Google  Scholar  

Ar;cle  1  

Ar;cle  2,  cites  ar;cle  1  

Ar;cle  3,  cites  ar;cle  1  or  2  or  both,  etc.  

Pearling  =  forwards  

WoS  =  Cited  References;  Wikipedia  =  References  Footnote  chasing  =  backwards  in  ;me  

5  Most  cited  –  Hierarchy?  Citaion  number  

Title   HoE  

7

McCrory, P; (2009 Jul-Aug). "Consensus statement on concussion in sport: the 3rd International Conference on Concussion in Sport held in Zurich, November 2008.". Journal of athletic training 44 (4): 434–48. other

29

Savitsky EA, R (2000). "Current controversies in the management of minor pediatric head injuries". American Journal of Emergency Medicine 18 (1): 96–101. Check PM

74

Alexander MP (1995). "Mild traumatic brain injury: Pathophysiology, natural history, and clinical management". Neurology 45 (7): 1253–60. Review

58

"Facts About Concussion and Brain Injury". Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2006. Retrieved 2008-01-13. other

34

McCrory P, (April 2005). "Summary and agreement statement of the 2nd International Conference on Concussion in Sport, Prague 2004". Br J Sports Med 39 (4): 196–204. Review,other

Rábago,  C.  A.,  &  Wilken,  J.  M.  (2011).    

Broglio,  S.  P.,  &  Puetz,  T.  W.  (2008).    

Parker,  T.  M.,  Osternig,  L.  R.,  Van  Donkelaar,  P.,  &  Chou,  L.-­‐S.  (2006)    

Leddy,  J.  J.,  Sandhu,  H.,  Sodhi,  V.,  Baker,  J.  G.,  &  Willer,  B.  (2012).    

Using  the  items  from  survey  3,  determine  where  they  are  in  the  

Hierarchy  of  Evidence  

1.Rábago,  et.  al.,  2011    2.Parker,  et.  al.,  2006    3.Broglio,  et.  al.,  2008    4.Leddy,  et.  al.,  2012  

Meta-­‐analyses    

Scien;fic  studies  &    Randomised  controlled  trials    

Case  studies  

Review  

Where  in  the  Hierarchy  of  Evidence?  1.    Rábago,  C.  A.,  &  Wilken,  J.  M.  (2011).  h0p://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=22027473  

   

A.  Meta  analysis  B.  Review    C.  Scien;fic  Study  D.Case  studies  

Where  in  the  Hierarchy  of  Evidence?  2.  Parker,  T.  M.,  Osternig,  L.  R.,  Van  Donkelaar,  P.,  &  Chou,  L.-­‐S.  (2006)    h0p://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=16775541          

A.  Meta  analysis  B.  Review    C.  Scien;fic  Study  D.Case  studies  

Where  in  the  Hierarchy  of  Evidence?  3.  Broglio,  S.  P.,  &  Puetz,  T.  W.  (2008).    h0p://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=18081367  

A.  Meta  analysis  B.  Review    C.  Scien;fic  Study  D.Case  studies  

Where  in  the  Hierarchy  of  Evidence?  4.  Leddy,  J.  J.,  Sandhu,  H.,  Sodhi,  V.,  Baker,  J.  G.,  &  Willer,  B.  (2012).      h0p://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=23016082  

       

A.  Meta  analysis  B.  Review    C.  Scien;fic  Study  D.Case  studies  

The  Grid  

Boolean   AND,  OR,  NOT    

concussion  Trauma;c  Brain  Injur*  

Closed  head  injur*  

   

(concussion  OR  trauma;c  brian  injur*    OR  closed  head  injur*)  =  larger  set    

Boolean   AND,  OR,  NOT    

Concussion    brain  injur*   College  

athlet*  

Return  to  play  

(concussion  OR  brain  injur*)  AND  return  to  play  AND  college  athlete*)  =  more  precise  set    

 

Boolean  AND,  OR,  NOT  

 

concussions    comas  

Structure  of  informa;on  

Find  what  you  want  

How  do  you  find  your…  

How  is  informa;on  arranged  in  a  library?  

•  Party  Girl  h0p://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gzbDdgWiaS0&feature=share&list=FLqNg9nU6uEGnR2sNkn8GA6w  

Call  numbers  

Subject  headings  

Medical  Subject  Headings  (MeSH)  retrieve  informa;on  that  uses    

different  terminology    for  the  same  concepts.  

    syncope  

Used  for:  – Fain;ng  – Ver;go  – Drop  a0acks  

MeSH  

 Hierarchical  

changes  slowly    controlled  vocabulary  

 PTSD    and  HIV,  AIDS    

   

 

Subject  Headings  

•  Medical  Subject  Headings,  or  MeSH  terms  (Pubmed)  

•  Descriptors  (Academic  Search  Premier)  •  Library  of  Congress  Subject  Headings  –  LC  subjects  -­‐    (Library  catalog/OCLC/Janus)  

 

Precision  is  

If  I  use  MeSH  in  my  search  will  I  get    more  precise*  ar;cles  on  my  topic    

or    more  general  ar;cles?  

A. More  precise  

B. More  general  

When  should  a  college  athlete  return  to  playing  sports  aoer  a  concussion?  

Topic          

Bibliography  

A. Refine  search  –  limits,  change  words,  different  database  

B. Footnote  chase  C. Search  in  database  D. Generate  Keywords  E. Enter  good  ar;cles  into  Mendeley  

F. Brainstorm  G. Pearl    

Prac;ce  (extra,  op;onal)  How  much  screen  ;me  is  ok  for  high  

school  age/adolescents?  

Topic            

Bibliography      

NEW:  Berry  picking  

•  Pick  and  choose  •  Expert  in  your  topic  

h0ps://www.superbe0er.com  

From:  h0p://www.ted.com/talks/jane_mcgonigal_the_game_that_can_give_you_10_extra_years_of_life.html