Post on 05-Apr-2018
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
1/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o >
Owakobkt# Xutao{
Bk`bck`bxw me pmta gnttkoh mux ki xbo HOWKTO Vtmlogx
Dnwoh mi towontgb nx Owakwobkt Mwjni`n|k _ikotwkx{# Xutao{
Xbo Owakobkt wxuh{ wkxo kw cmgnxoh ki xbo powxoti vntx me xbo goixtnc Ninxmckni Vcnxonu# nx kxw imtxboti
jnt`ki# nih vntxkncc{ nx xbo ecmmt me n xbtmu`b*`mki` hovtowwkmi# gnccoh xbo Owakobkt Dnwki)
Gmmthkinxow4$O
Wk|o< ;6 aj4 Ncxkxuho< 2>; >754 j Vtogkvkxnxkmi< 726 jj Xojvotnxuto< `oiotncc{ docmp 6G hutki`
pkixot nih jn{ orgooh 86G ki wujjot hn{w
Cnih uwo< ntndco cnih "gotoncw# wu`nt doox#wuiecmpot+# vnwxutow# emtowx
Kibndkxnixw< 7#686 Jnki ho`tnhnxkmi vtmgowwow< Pnxot nih
pkih otmwkmi# htmu`bxw# utdnikwnxkmi Jnlmt htkotw me ho`tnhnxkmi< Kinvvtmvtknxo
cnih jnin`ojoix# utdni orvniwkmi
Wxuh{ wkxo cmgnxkmi
Xboto nto jni{ gbnccoi`ow ki xbo Owakwobkt to`kmi) Xbo `tmpki` gkx{ me Owakwobkt kw nxxtngxki` iop ogmimjkg
kiowxjoix nih n`tkgucxuto kw ncwm orvnihki` xm wuvvmtx xbo ioohw me xbo vmvucnxkmi) Otmwkmi d{ pnxot#
otmwkmi d{ pkih# wnckikwnxkmi nih xbo oeeogxw me tnvkh utdnik|nxkmi nto ncc wooi ki nwwmgknxkmi pkxb cnih
ho`tnhnxkmi# ki ni nton pkxb wvntwo inxutnc o`oxnxkmi nih n xtoih me gckjnxo gbni`o xmpnthw kigtonwki`
ntkhkx{) Wxtnxo`kow emt wuwxnkindco hoocmvjoix iooh xm ekih n dncnigo njmi` gmjvoxki` vtowwutow) Gtmv
tmxnxkmi# jucgbki` nih xtoo vcnixki` jn{ do uwoh xm kjvtmo wmkc eotxkckx{# htkv kttk`nxkmi pkcc ckjkx pnxot
cmww# nih xottngow nih gboga hnjw jn{ tohugo wmkc otmwkmi nih pnxot cmww)
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
2/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o 4
Tkcc otmwkmi ki kgkikx{ me xbo xtknc ekoch# I) Owakobkt)
Wkigo xbo Owakobkt bmxwvmx kw wkxunxoh ki xbo jmuixnkimuw imtxboti vntx me xbo Owakwobkt bmxwvmx pboto
wcmvo `tnhkoixw nih vtogkvkxnxkmi nto tocnxkoc{ bk`b gmjvntoh xm ocwopboto# dnwkg `mnc boto kw xm hogtonwo
pnxot otmwkmi) Huo xm xbo cmi`*cnwxki` inxuto me xbkw vtmdcoj xm`oxbot pkxb imi*orkwxoigo me ni{ vtokmuw
vtooixkmi kikxknxko# wmkc vtmekcow nto xbki# wxmikioww kw bk`b nih mt`nikg jnxxot gmixoix kw cmp) Ht{*entjki`
ekochw ki kgkikx{ nto orbkdkxki` wooto tkcc otmwkmi pbkgb bnw dooi engkckxnxoh d{ eutxbot ptmi` vtngxkgow
wugb nw wcmvo vntnccoc nih ndimtjncc{ hoov vcmu`bki`)
Xbo kjvcojoixnxkmi ekoch kw hkkhoh kixm 7 vntxw#
mio kw imi*xogbimcm`{ "gmixtmc vntgoc+# k)o)
hmpiwcmvo vcmu`bki` nih mxbotw nto gmixmut
vcmu`bki` nih gmixmut vcmu`boh xottngki`)
Xottngki` "ncwm gnccoh eoigki`+ gmiwkwxw me
pmmhoi wxnaow me >?6 gj bk`b kiwotxoh kixm
`tmuih nih pmoi d{ xki{ dtnigbow ki
doxpooi) Vntx me xbo wmkc etmj xbo uvwcmvo me
xbo eoigo kw vkcoh uv xm wuvvmtx wxnaow nih
vtooix tui*mee mot xbo eoigo) Gmixmut
vcmu`bki` "kigcuhki` xkccn`o+ kw nvvckoh ki xbo
powxoti vntgoc me ndmux ?6 j cmi`) Gmixmutw boto nto IO*tuiiki`)
Wkigo xbo nton kw wkxunxoh ki xbo jmuixnkimuw imtxboti vntx me xbo Owakwobkt bmxwvmx pboto wcmvo `tnhkoixw
"/ >6+ nih vtogkvkxnxkmi "866 jj-{t+ nto tocnxkoc{ bk`b gmjvntoh xm ocwopboto# mut dnwkg `mnc boto pkcc
do hogtonwki` pnxot otmwkmi) Huo xm xbo cmi`*cnwxki` inxuto me xbkw vtmdcoj xm`oxbot pkxb imi*orkwxoigo
me ni{ vtokmuw vtooixkmi kikxknxko# wmkc vtmekcow nto xbki# wxmikioww kw bk`b nih mt`nikg jnxxot gmixoix kwcmp) Ht{*entjki` ekochw ki kgkikx{ nto orbkdkxki` wooto tkcc otmwkmi pbkgb bnw dooi engkckxnxoh d{ eutxbot
ptmi` vtngxkgow wugb nw wcmvo vntnccoc nih ndimtjncc{ hoov vcmu`bki`)
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
3/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o 7
Pmtawbmvw emt towontgbotw nih wxnaobmchotw xm wocogx wuwxnkindco cnih jnin`ojoix xogbimcm`kow
Towontgbotw xncaoh pkxb cmgnc vomvco nih vmckg{ jnaotw# nih xm`oxbot xbo{ hogkhoh mi xbo dowx mvxkmiw emt
wuwxnkindco cnih uwo) Ki xbo HOWKTO Vtmlogx xbo xbtoo Vntxw xm PMGNX joxbmhmcm`{ poto hoocmvoh nwmuxckioh ndmo) Xbkw vtmkhow hogkwkmi wuvvmtx emt gbmmwki` xogbimcm`kow wukxoh xm xbo cmgnc oiktmijoix
xbnx kigcuhow wmgknc# gucxutnc nih ogmimjkg engxmtw nw pocc nw vb{wkgnc wgkoigo)
Ki oot{ HOWKTO wxuh{ wkxo towontgbotw nih wxnaobmchotw boch xpm pmtawbmvw xm nttko nx xbokt wocogxkmi me
nvvtmngbow nih xogbimcm`kow) Nx xbo ektwx pmtawbmv wxnaobmchotw contioh ndmux bmp ho`tnhnxkmi
bnvvoiw# nih bmp xm nmkh kx)
Xpm xogbimcm`kow poto kjvcojoixoh ki xbo WKV nton huo xm muxgmjow me wxnaobmchot jooxki`w 1
>) Gmixmut xkccn`o4) Pmmhoi xottngow pkxb wmkc duihw
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
4/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o 8
Jmikmtki`
To`ucnt wmkc wutengo nwwowwjoix
Gtmv gbntogxntkwxkgw
Jncgb gmot etngxkmi
Otmwkmi eonxutow
Tovonxoh wmkc jmkwxuto# OG nih xojvotnxuto jonwutojoixw
Ojvx{ wohkjoix xnia jonwutojoixw
Jncgb gmot etngxkmi
N`tmimjkg jonwutojoixw
[koch nwwowwjoix
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
5/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o ?
Xbo ektwx HOWKTO pmtawbmvw towucxoh ki gbmmwki` xpm xogbimcm`kow xm vtooix pnxot otmwkmi ki xbo
Owakobkt wxuh{ wkxo) Xbowo "pmmhoi xottngow nih gmixmut xkccn`o+ poto nvvckoh nih jmikxmtoh emt xpm
{ontw nih xbo towucxw poto oncunxoh ki n ekinc pmtawbmv boch ki Luio 46>> ki Owakobkt) Nggmthki` xm xbo
mxki` towucxw# wxnaobmchotw wocogxoh pmmhoi xottngow jmwxc{ huo xm ogmimjkg nhnixn`ow) Xbo{ xbmu`bx
xbnx xbkw wxtnxo`{ kigtonwow gtmv {koch# hogtonwow tkwa me vtmhugxkmi xbmu`b kx bnw n wk`ikekgnix gmwx me
kiwxnccnxkmi) @oiotncc{ wvonaki`# xbo xottngki` xogbimcm`{ pnw gmiwkhotoh wuvotkmt ki xotjw me wmgkm*
ogmimjkg nih ogmcm`kgnc to`nthw xmm) Gmixmut xkccn`o kw wxkcc n wk`ikekgnix mvxkmi xm xboj pkxb ot{ cmp
kiwxnccnxkmi gmwx nih tocnxkoc{ `mmh gtmv {koch nih gmiwotnxkmi gbntngxotkwxkgw)
Xbo dnwkg mdwxngco n`nkiwx nhmvxkmi bnw dooi ogmimjkg nih hojm`tnvbkg "hogtonwki` pocento nih
ojvx{ki` me tutnc woxxcojoixw huo xm jk`tnxkmi+)
Eoohdnga etmj vntxkgkvnixw
Ncc kigcuwko inxuto me HOWKTO vtmlogx kw gmiwkhotoh ot{ uwoeuc dux xkjo*gmiwujki`) Hoxotjkiki` xboeuxuto wxovw me xbo vtmlogx pkxb wxnaobmchot hkwguwwkmiw kw vntxkgucntc{ oigmutn`ki` emt entjotw) Jmto
duh`ox nih kimcojoix me entjotw kixm orvotkjoixnc vbnwo me vtmlogx pmuch kigtonwo xbo gbnigo me
nhmvxkmi me wxtnxo`kow)
XOTTNGKI@ % GMIXM_T XKCCN@O
Xbo bkcc wcmvo ntonw iont Owakwobkt wueeot etmj wmkc
otmwkmi) Xbo nton kw wojk *ntkh# wmkcw nto wbnccmp#
wxmi{ nih mt`nikg jnxxot gmixoix kw cmp) Cnih uwo kw
tnkieoh pbonx pkxb mggnwkminc enccmp votkmhw) Cnxowvtki` nih ontc{ wujjot tnkienccw nto vntxkgucntc{
otmwko) Orvotkjoixw poto gnttkoh mux xbnx kixottuvx
xbo tuimee nih bocv kigtonwo kiekcxtnxkmi nih xbotod{
kigtonwki` wmkc jmkwxuto wxmtn`o) Xbo motncc
mdlogxko kw xm hogtonwo wutengo tuimee nih xm
tohugo wmkc cmwwow)
XBO ORVOTKJOIX< XOTTNGKI@ NIH GM_IXM_T XKCCN@OW
Xpm xogbimcm`kow "gmixmut vcmu`bki` nih xottngki`+ poto kiowxk`nxoh emt pnxot toxoixkmi nih gtmv
`tmpxb n`nkiwx xbo gmioixkminc gucxknxkmi vtngxkgo hutki`
xbo votkmh Hogojdot 466; nih Luc{ 46>>)
Xottngki` ki xbkw gmixorx joniw xbnx wbnccmp cooow poto
jnho ncmi` xbo gmixmut ckiow "hnwboh ckiow ki xbo htnpki` xm
xbo coex+) Vmcow nto bnjjotoh mi xmv nih dtnigbow nto pmoi
doxpooi xboj Xbkw vmxoixkncc{ wxmvw xbo wohkjoix nih wcmpw
hmpi tuimee nih pboi coex gmixkiumuwc{# n wcmvki` xottngo
pmuch ooixuncc{ emtj) Xbo xkccn`o doxpooi xbowo eoigow kw
ncmi` xbo gmixmutw) Xbo coex bnih vcmx pnw hmio pkxb gmixmut
vcmu`bki` mic{) Xbo tk`bx bnih vcmx uwow xbo gmioixkmincxkccn`o ncmi` xbo wcmvo nw kx `kow xbo cmi`owx wooh ckiow)
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
6/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o 5
Wmkc vntnjoxotw wugb nw jmkwxuto
gmixoix nih ocogxtkgnc gmihugxkkx{ poto
jonwutoh to`ucntc{ pkxb n vmtxndco XHT
nx vto*hoekioh cmgnxkmiw ">4 vot vcmx+#
nvntx etmj `otjkinxkmi tnxo nih gtmv
{koch mdwotnxkmiw "woo xndco docmp+)
@otjkinxkmi tnxo kw hoxotjkioh d{
gmuixki` xbo kihkkhunc wvtmuxw ki j4
migo pkxbki Lniunt{ ki xbo ontc{
wvtmuxki` votkmh) Gtmv {koch
nwwowwjoix pnw jnho hutki` xbo
bntowx nx xbo oih me `tmpki` wonwmi)
TOW_CXW
Xbo towucx wbmpw xbnx xbo pnxot gmixoix "PG+ me xbo wmkcw nt{ wonwmincc{) Hutki` xbo jmikxmtki`
votkmh "Im 466; Luio 46>>+ gmixmut xkccn`o xogbimcm`{ towucxw ki n wck`bxc{ bk`bot PG "Ek`uto
docmp+) Xottngki` `kow wogmih dowx towucxw xbmu`b imi*xogbimcm`{ nton orbkdkx bk`bot PG ki xbo
pkixot jmixbw) Xbo hkeeotoigow jk`bx ncwm do gnuwoh d{ wmkc ntknxkmi) Ki ni{ gnwo# xbo hkeeotoigow
nto imx wk`ikekgnix# gotxnkic{ imx ki n woiwo me gtmv pnxot nnkcndkckx{)
Notn`o jmkwxuto gmixoix ">4 jonwutojoixwvot jmjoix vot xtonxjoix+ hutki` xbo orvotkjoix)
Kx nvvontw xbnx hutki` xbo ektwx {ont# wooh `otjkinxkmi tnxo pnw xbo bk`bowx ki xbo xottngoh vcmx nw
gmjvntoh xm gmixmut nih gmioixkminc xkccn`o# pbkco ki xbo wogmih {ont xbowo hkeeotoigow poto imx
mdwotoh) Xbkw wbmpw xbnx kixot*niiunc ntkndkckx{ kw wmjoxkjow cnt`o nih imx ncc oeeogxw wbmuch do
gmixtkduxoh xm xbo xogbimcm`{)
Ekincc{# gtmv {koch ki xbo xottngo nih gmixmut xkccn`o
vcmxw kw kigtonwoh d{ 4*7 xkjow) Pbkco xbkw gni do
orvcnkioh d{ n doxxot `otjkinxkmi ki 466;# xboto kw im
gcont orvcninxkmi emt 46>6) Xboto jk`bx do jmkwxuto
hkeeotoigow hoovot ki xbo wmkc xbnx nto imx hoxogxoh)
Hutki` xbo xpm {ontw xboto poto im hktogx otmwkmi
@otjkinxkmi tnxo pkixot Dntco{ ki Lniunt{ ki wvtmuxw-j4
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
7/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o 0
ooixw mi xbo vcmxw# Bmpoot n iok`bdmutki` uivtmxogxoh ekoch wbmpoh bon{ tkccw pbkgb poto wooi
mi xbo orvotkjoixnc wcmvo)
Bntowx -
gmccogxkmi hnxoxogbimcm`{
Nton
"bn+Gtmv x{vo
^unixkx{
"a`-bn+
Kigmjo
"vot bn+
^unixkx{
"a`-bn+
Kigmjo
"vot bn+
466; 46>660*60*>6 Xottngo >)>? dntco{*`tnki >5?4 578 >768 ?6>
60*60*>6 Xottngo >)>? wxtnp 56; 5> 57? 57
60*60*>6 Xottngo Xmxnc "4;7+ 5;? "?>4+ ?58
60*60*>6 Gmixmut xkccn`o 6)24 dntco{*`tnki 0?5 4;6 >24; 064
60*60*>6 Gmixmut xkccn`o 6)24 wxtnp 755 70 054 00
60*60*>6 Gmixmut xkccn`o Xmxnc "4;7+ 740 "?08+ 00;
60*60*>6 Gmixtmc 6)2 dntco{*`tnki 70? >88 7>7 >46
60*60*>6 Gmixtmc 6)2 wxtnp >22 >; 7>7 7>
60*60*>6 Gmixtmc Xmxnc "40>+ >57 "??2+ >?>
Wujjnt{ me {kochw ki a`-bn# orvoiwow "doxpooi dtngaoxw+ nih kigmjo emt xbo xpm {ontw) Jmioxnt{ uikx kw
Xutakwb C{tn) Imxo xbnx xboto kw ni kikxknc orvoiwo xm gtonxo xbo cooow me 4>06 XC)
OncunxkmiXbo towucxw nto oncunxoh etmj n vtmhugxkmi# wmgkm*gucxutnc nih ogmimjkg vmkix me kop) Xbo dntw orvtoww xbo
owxkjnxoh mt jonwutoh votgoixn`o me gbni`o pkxb towvogx xm xbo toeotoigo wkxunxkmi) Xbkw gbni`o gni do
vmwkxko "dcuo+ mt io`nxko "toh+) Imxo xbnx xbkw oncunxkmi kw dnwoh mi xbo orvotkjoixw# mi xbo cmi` xotj
orvotkoigo me xbo gmmthkinxki` xonj ki xbkw nton nih mi gmiwucxnxkmiw pkxb xbo entjotw)
IMXO< xbo oncunxkmi muxgmjo pnw iontc{ xbo wnjo emt dmxb xogbimcm`kow) Xbo mic{ hkeeotoigo kw xbnx emt
gmixmut vcmu`bki` ncmio xbo io`nxko luh`joix me entj mvotnxkmiw kw coww wooto) Gtonxki` nih jnkixnkiki` xbo
cooow kw gmiwkhotndco jmto oeemtx xbni xbo xtnhkminc xkccn`o)
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
8/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o 2
WXNAOBMCHOT MVKIKMIW
Xbo wxnaobmchotw jooxki` wbmpoh xbo kjvmtxnigo me dtki`ki` wmcuxkmiw xm xbkw ho`tnhnxkmi xtoih
pbkgb xbtonxw dmxb xbo oiktmijoix nih xbo entjotw kigmjo) Xbo entjotw orvotkoigo wbmpw xbnx
dntco{ kw xbo jmwx nvvtmvtknxo gtmv emt xbo xottngo nih xbo gmixmut vcmu`bki` xogbimcm`kow)
Wxnaobmchotw poto vnwwkoc{ kimcoh ki xbo gmiwxtugxkmi me pmmhoi xottngow nw mdwotot) Ki xbo cnwx
bntowxki` wonwmi# wxnaobmchotw kwkxoh juxuncc{ xbo kjvcojoixnxkmi nton nih hkwguwwoh xbo
xogbimcm`kow) D{ uwki` xbokt mpi orvotkoigow xbo{ emuih xbnx dntco{ gtmv ki xottngoh nih gmixmut
vcmu`boh wvmxw nto jmto tmduwx gmjvntoh xm gmixtmc vntgoc) Wxnaobmchotw jmwxc{ xbkia xbnx huo xm
cmp tnkiencc tnxow xbtmu`bmux xbo `tmpki` wonwmi 466; nih cnga me enccmp ki mut nvvckgnxkmi tnhkgncc{
hogtonwoh xbo oeeogxkoioww me xbo xogbimcm`kow nvvckoh) Ki n pkhot woiwo xbo{ dockoo xbnx xbo
vmvucnxkmi kw dogmjki` mchot huo xm kixoiwo jk`tnxkmi me {mui` vomvco xm dk` gkxkow emt ogmimjkg
tonwmiw# pbkgb vuxw ni orxtn wxtoww mi kjvcojoixki` xogbimcm`kow nx n cnt`ot wgnco)
Xottngki` kimcow nhhkxkminc gmwxw nih vmwwkdc{ cmww me wmjo cnih pbotonw gmixmut vcmu`bki` gni do
pkhoc{ nvvckoh pkxbmux jugb oeemtx) Ncwm kx kw wooi nw n wck`bx cmww me cnih) Xbo ekoch bmpoot bnw xmdo pkho oimu`b dognuwo gmixmut vcmu`bki` jk`bx gtonxo jni{ wbmtx xtngaw nih xutiw me n xtngxmt#
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
9/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o ;
pbkgb gnuwow n {koch cmww) @oiotncc{ kx ioohw
mic{ gmwx emt euoc uwo pbkgb kw wkjkcnt xm
xtnhkxkminc vcmu`bki`) Bmpoot wmjo xtnkiki`
kw ioohoh emt kjvcojoixki` ki wxoovot wcmvow)
Ncwm wjnccot xtngxmtw pkxb jmto jnimouto
gnvndkckx{ pkcc do doxxot ki gucxknxki` xottngoh
cnih)
Dnwockio Wgointkm
VOWOTN dnwockio tui
Xbo dnwockio tui gcontc{ wbmpw hkwxkigx
otmwkmi tnxow emt xpm ntonw< xbo jmuixnki
wcmvow nih xbo vcnkiw) Wootnc ncco{ecmmtw
ncwm bno cmp otmwkmi tnxow) Tmu`bc{ 26/ me
xbo nton bnw wkjucnxoh otmwkmi tnxow me mot
> xmi-bn-{t# dux mic{ n ot{ wjncc nton
orvotkoigow otmwkmi tnxow me mot >6
xmi-bn-{t) Dkmjnww vtmhugxkmi muxvux
wbmpw n gcont gux hkeeotoigo doxpooi
ht{cnih entjki` "jmwxc{ ?66*>666 a`-bn+
nih kttk`nxoh entjki` "x{vkgncc{ cnt`ot xbni
7?66 a`-bn+) Vnwxutow mgguv{ xbo
kixotjohknxo tni`ow)
Wmkc otmwkmi
Cnihemtjw
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
10/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o >6
Dkmjnww vtmhugxkmi
Xogbimcm`{ Wgointkm5+
Xbo ndmo mvotnxkmi gmwxw kigcuho toixki` meo~ukvjoix xm kjvcojoix ongb vtngxkgo
N bntowx kihor emt `tnkiw me 8?/ me xmxnc dkmjnwwpnw nwwujoh
IVU pnw gncgucnxoh mi 46 {ont votkmh dnwkw nx>6/ hkwgmuix tnxo
Xbo vtkgo me `tnkiw kw 6)728 XT[-a` "6)>5+
Nvvckgndkckx{
Xbo xogbimcm`{ kw nvvckgndco mi ntndco cnih pkxbwcmvow doxpooi 4 nih 7?/ "imx ki vcnkiw nih
ncco{ ecmmtw+)
Nvvckgndkckx{
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
11/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o >>
Dkmvb{wkgnc kjvngx< wmkc otmwkmi
_ihot xtnhkxkminc vcmu`bki` _ihot gmixmut vcmu`bki` )
Ogmimjkg kndkckx{
Iox vtmekx uihot xtnhkxkminc vcmu`bki` Iox vtmekx uihot gmixmut vcmu`bki`
IVU uihot xtnhkxkminc vcmu`bki` IVU uihot gmixmut vcmu`bki`
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
12/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o >4
Gmixmut vcmu`bki` kw vtmekxndco nw kx hmow imx to~ukto orxtn gmwxw dux kigtonwow vtmhugxkmi)
Xogbimcm`{ Wgointkm5pkxb ni kikxknc kiowxjoix gmwx me
4?66 XT[-bn ">6>8 ektwx {ont mic{+# niiunc
jnkixoinigo gmwx me ?/ me kiowxjoix gmwx
Xbo ndmo mvotnxkmi gmwxw kigcuho toixki` meo~ukvjoix xm kjvcojoix ongb vtngxkgo
N bntowx kihor emt `tnkiw me 8?/ me xmxncdkmjnww pnw nwwujoh
Xbo ckeo me xbo xogbimcm`{ kw 46 {ontw) Xbo vtkgo me `tnkiw kw 6)728 XT[-a` "6)>5+ >6/ hkwgmuix tnxo pnw uwoh emt gncgucnxki` IVU
Nvvckgndkckx{
Xbo xogbimcm`{ kw nvvckgndco mi ntndco cnih pkxbwcmvow doxpooi 7 nih 7?/ "imx ki vcnkiw nih ncco{
ecmmtw+)
Nvvckgndkckx{
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
13/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o >7
Dkmvb{wkgnc kjvngx< wmkc otmwkmi
_ihot xtnhkxkminc vcmu`bki` _ihot pmoi eoigo nih gmixmut vcmu`bki`
Dkmvb{wkgnc kjvngx< gbni`o ki dkmjnww
Xbo xogbimcm`{ bnw# nggmthki` xm xbo jmhoc wkjucnxkmiw# xbo vmxoixknc xm hmudco {kochw ngtmww jugb me xbo
nvvckgndkckx{ nton) Iootxbocoww# xbo iox vtowoix ncuo me pmoi eoigow nih gmixmut vcmu`bki` kw io`nxko
huo xm xbo wudwxnixknc kikxknc kiowxjoix gmwxw) _ihot xbowo gktgujwxnigow# xbo xogbimcm`{ kw uickaoc{ xm do
nhmvxoh uicoww vmckg{ kigoixkow tohugo xbo kikxknc gmwxw) Ncwm# xbo xogbimcm`{ bnw dooi nwwujoh xm
to~ukto niiunc jnkixoinigo gmwxw o~unc xm ?/ me xbo kiowxjoix gmwxw) Vtmhugxkkx{ kigtonwow nto wugb
xbnx xbowo gni do onwkc{ gmotoh) N xbkth mdwotnxkmi pbkgb gni do jnho kw xbnx xtnhkxkminc vcmu`bki` ncwm
wbmpw io`nxko toxutiw ki jmwx me xbo nton gmiwkhotoh) Xbkw gmuch kihkgnxo xbnx entjotw nggovx cmpot
toxuti xm cndmut xbni xbo mvvmtxuikx{ gmwx uwoh ki xbo wkjucnxkmiw)
Dkmjnww gbni`o Votgoixn`o dkmjnww gbni`o
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
14/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o >8
Huo xm n bk`b kiowxjoix gmwx emt dukchki` xbo pmoi eoigo# pkxbmux orxotinc ekinigknc kigoixko ki ncc
vntxw me xbo wxuh{ nton pkhowvtonh nhmvxkmi me xbo xogbimcm`{ kw ot{ uickaoc{) Ki xbkw wgointkm xbo oeeogxw
me n wudwkh{ o~unc xm ?6/ me xbo kiowxjoix gmwxw mi vtmekxndkckx{ me xbo xogbimcm`{ nih xbo vmxoixknc emt
jkxk`nxki` cnih ho`tnhnxkmi poto orvcmtoh) Xbo kixtmhugxkmi me ?6/ wudwkh{ pmuch imx bno wk`ikekgnix
kjvngx nw xbo vtmvmtxkmi me xbo wxuh{ nton pkxb io`nxko ogmimjkg `nki tojnkiw xbo wnjo pkxb nih
pkxbmux xbo wudwkh{) Xbo xogbimcm`{ pnw tniaoh ektwx ki xbo wxnaobmchot oncunxkmi dnwoh mi kxw
votemtjnigo ki xbo orvotkjoix# pbkgb kw ncwm wuvvmtxoh d{ jmhoc muxvux) Bmpoot# xbo kiowxjoix gmwxw
poto ki xbo orvotkjoixnc gnwo imx dmtio d{ xbo cnih uwot# nih nw wugb kx gmuch bno dooi nwwujoh d{ xbo
vntxkgkvnixw xbnx xbowo pmuch do wudwkhkwoh) Xbkw wgointkm wbmpw xbnx wugb wudwkhkow pmuch do to~uktoh xm
wxkjucnxo nhmvxkmi# nw ooi n ?6/ tohugxkmi ki kiowxjoix gmwx hmow imx luwxke{ xbo kiowxjoix) Ni
nhhkxkminc ~uowxkmi pmuch do ke wugb bk`b tnxow me wudwkhkow pmuch wxkcc do gmwx*oeeogxko ki tohugki`
oiktmijoixnc ho`tnhnxkmi)
GmigcuwkmiwGmixmut vcmu`bki` nih xottngki` woojw xm bno n wck`bx kigtonwo ki xmv wmkc jmkwxuto huo xm tohugoh tuimee
dux xbkw hovoihw mi xbo wonwminc tnkiencc) Xbo xogbimcm`{ bocvw ki kjvtmki` wmkc gmihkxkmi nih gtmv
`tmpxb nw pocc nw kigtonwoh {koch doioekxw) Xbo {kochw mot xpm {ontw poto jugb bk`bot ki xbo orvotkjoixw
xbni ki xbo gmixtmc vcmx# ooi pbkco xbo tnkiencc pnw ot{ hkeeotoix doxpooi xbo {ontw) To`nthki` tocnxkoc{
wjnccot gmwxw kimcoh ki gmixmut vcmu`bki`# xbo xogbimcm`{ kw nvvckgndco ki pkhot bkcc wcmvo ntonw me wojk*
ntkh Goixtnc Ninxmckn) Xbo cooow pkxb eoigow poto gmiwkhotoh coww nhnixn`omuw dognuwo me kikxknc gmwxw
nih cmww me n`tkgucxutnc nton# emt ckxxco `nki) Jnki dmxxcoioga emt xbo onw{ nvvckgnxkmi me xogbimcm`kow woojw
wmgkmcm`kgnc "cnga me oimu`b {mui` entjotw+ nih ogmimjkg "vtkgow oxg)+ tnxbot xbni wgkoixkekg)
Xbkw orvotkjoixnc wonwmi pnw `oiotncc{ wukxndco emt xtknc orgovx emt xbo cnga me enccmp) Xbkw gnuwoh
wk`ikekgnix hogtonwo ki vtmhugxkkx{ huo xm ckjkxoh pnxot gmixoix me xbo wmkc) Dux xbo vtowoix hnxn nccmp uw
n gmjvntkwmi me xogbimcm`{ oeekgkoigkow)
Xpm xogbimcm`kow nvvckoh gnuwoh doxxot wmkc nih gtmv `tmpxb vntnjoxotw nw pocc nw kigtonwoh {koch
doioekxw) Kx kw wu``owxoh xbnx xottngki` kigtonwoh pnxot gmixoix me wmkc d{ hogtonwki` tuimee hkwxnigo)
Towucxw wbmpoh xbnx gmixmut vcmu`bki` kw ncwm oeeogxko ki wkjkcnt pn{)
To`nthki` tocnxkoc{ wjnccot gmwxw me xottngki`# nih vntxkgucntc{ xbo gmixmut vcmu`bki`# kigtonwo ki
vtmhugxkkx{ kw ot{ bk`b) Emt xbkw tonwmi# xbowo xogbimcm`kow nto nvvckgndco ki pkhot bkccwcmvo ntonw me
wojk*ntkh Goixtnc Ninxmckn)
Jnki dmxxcoioga ki etmix me onw{ nvvckgnxkmi me xogbimcm`kow woojw wmgkmcm`kgnc "cnga me oimu`b {mui`
entjotw+ nih ogmimjkg "vtkgow oxg)+ tnxbot xbni wgkoixkekg)
Dnwockio wkjucnxkmiw wbmp xbnx xbo wxuh{ wkxo orvotkoigow gmiwkhotndco otmwkmi# owvogkncc{ ki xbowcmvki` ntonw1 tmu`bc{ 26/ me xbo nton bnw otmwkmi tnxow me mot > xmi-bn-{t# ncxbmu`b mic{ n ot{ wjncc
nton orvotkoigow otmwkmi tnxow me mot >6 xmi-bn-{t)
Xbo xogbimcm`kow wkjucnxoh nto xbo xogbimcm`kow emt pbkgb ekoch orvotkjoixw poto gmihugxoh) Xbowoxogbimcm`kow poto eutxbot wvogkekgnxkmiw me tojohknxkmi mvxkmiw wocogxoh d{ wgkoixkwxw nih cmgnc
wxnaobmchotw xm nhhtoww pnxot otmwkmi vtmdcojw) Xbo xogbimcm`{ wgointkm wbmpw xbnx gmixmut
vcmu`bki` "OXB87+ `mow wmjo pn{ ki tohugki` xbo nton pkxb otmwkmi tnxow `tonxot xbni 4 xmi-bn-{t
etmj ndmux 06 xm 56/ me xbo nvvckgndco nton) Jmto kjvtowwko kw kxw oeeogx mi dkmjnww vtmhugxkmi#
`oiotnxki` n jmto xbni >66/ kigtonwo ki ndmux ;6/ me xbo nvvckgndco nton) Xbo xogbimcm`{ to~uktow im
nhhkxkminc gmwxw# nih kw xbuw vtmekxndco oot{pboto pboto kx kigtonwow vtmhugxkkx{) Xbkw mic{ orgcuhowwmjo vtmhugxko cmp*c{ki` ntonw) Wkjkcntc{# pmoi eoigow pkxb gmixmut vcmu`bki` "AOI6?+ bno n jmto
7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Eskisehir Study Site
15/15
Owakwobkt# Xutao{ Vn`o >?
imxndco oeeogx mi vtmhugxkmi xbni mi tohugxkmi me otmwkmi) Mi dmxb gtkxotkn# AOI6? muxvotemtjw
OXB87) Howvkxo me xbkw# nvvckgnxkmi me xbo pmoi eoigow kw imx ogmimjkgncc{ kndco uihot xbo
nwwujvxkmiw jnho)
Oncunxki` xbo towucxw ki n pmtawbmv# wxnaobmchotw vtoeottoh pmoi eoigow mot gmixmut vcmu`bki`)Xbo{ hkh wm dnwoh mi xbo orvotkjoixnc towucxw# pbkgb wbmpoh wuvotkmt votemtjnigo me xbo pmoi
eoigow) Xboto pnw ncwm gmigoti xbnx gmixmut vcmu`bki` pmuch imx do oeeogxko uihot bk`b kixoiwkx{tnkiencc) Xbo jmhoccki` towucxw wuvvmtx xbo khon xbnx gmixmut vcmu`bki` kw imx ot{ oeeogxko ki ntonw
pkxb bk`b otmwkmi tnxow) Xbo{ ngaimpcoh`oh xbo kiowxjoix gmwxw me pmoi eoigow# dux hm imx wooj xm
bno kixotinckwoh xbowo xm xbokt hogkwkmi*jnaki` votwvogxko votbnvw nwwujki` xbnx xbkw pmuch do
wudwkhkwoh nw pnw xbo gnwo emt xbo orvotkjoix) Xbo wxnxojoix xbnx kigoixkow pmuch wxkjucnxo
nhmvxkmi gmuch kjvc{ bmpoot xbnx cnih uwotw nto npnto me xbo engx xbnx vtmekxndkckx{ kw ni kwwuo)
N vmckg{ wgointkm wudwkhkwki` kiowxjoix gmwxw me pmoi eoigow d{ ?6/ wmtxoh im oeeogx mi kxwvtmekxndkckx{) Kx gmuch do xbnx cndmut mvvmtxuikx{ gmwxw poto xmm bk`b "k)o) entjotw jn{ nggovx toxuti xm
cndmut cmpot xbni xbo `mki` pn`o tnxo+) @koi xbo kgkikx{ me Owakobkt gkx{ xbkw kw vtmdndc{ imx n ot{
wk`ikekgnix engxmt) Bk`b coocw me wudwkh{ pmuch do hkeekgucx xm luwxke{ mi gmwx*oeeogxkoioww gtkxotkn)
Xbo `cmdnc wgointkmw wbmp xbnx xbo xogbimcm`kow gni ngbkoo {koch kigtonwow nih otmwkmi tohugxkmiwngtmww ktxuncc{ xbokt oixkto nvvckgndkckx{ ntonw) [koch kigtonwow nto kjvtowwko# nx 466/ motncc nih emt
pmoi eoigow ki jmwx me xbo nton "k)o) n xtkvcki` me {kochw+# nih wxkcc >46/ mi notn`o emt gmixmut
vcmu`bki`) Motncc# otmwkmi gni do tohugoh d{ uv xm 4?/# bmpoot gmixmut vcmu`bki` mic{ hockotw
tohugxkmiw me mot >?/ ki ndmux 86/ me kxw nvvckgndkckx{ nton) Xbo notn`o {koch kigtonwo kw 022
a`-bn-{t nih xbo notn`o otmwkmi tohugxkmi 6)5 xmi-bn-{t# nx n gmwx me >4;7 nih >582-xmi emmh
vtmhugx nih wmkc towvogxkoc{)
Dnwoh mi xbo ninc{wow nih votwvogxkow# gmixmut vcmu`bki` gni onwkc{ do nhmvxoh dux gmuch oixnkcwmjo cooc me tkwa ki bk`b otmwkmi tkwa ntonw nih uihot bk`b kixoiwkx{ ooixw) Xbo oeeogxw me pmoi
eoigow pkxb gmixmut vcmu`bki` nto gcontc{ hojmiwxtnxoh# dux xbokt kjvcojoixnxkmi kw imx
togmjjoihoh dnwoh mi ogmimjkg ninc{wkw) N gnwo emt wudwkhkow wbmuch owxndckwb xbo cooc me mee*wkxo
doioekxw xm do mdxnkioh)
Conhki` Wgkoixkwx7
emgnaFm`u)ohu)xt
Gmixngx nhhtoww< NCXOTTN# Wmkc Wgkoigo Goixto- Gmoi Tkxwojn# V)M)
Dmr 80# 5066 NN Pn`oiki`oi# Xbo Ioxbotcnihw
Vbmio< !7> 7>0 82 5? >0
Enr< !7> 7>0 8> ;6 66
Xbkw vtmlogx bnw dooi euihoh d{ xbo Outmvoni
Gmjjkwwkmi H@ TowontgbOiktmijoix Vtm`tnjjo
_ikx me Jnin`ojoix me Inxutnc Towmutgow
Bonh me _ikx Vkotto Jnxb{# Vtmlogx meekgot Jntkn
[otm{niik
Hutki` xbo votkmh Lniunt{ 4660* Lniunt{ 46>4# xbkw pmta pnw gnttkoh mux d{