From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Post on 12-Dec-2014

3.029 views 2 download

Tags:

description

A talk I delivered at the O'Reilly Emerging Technology Conference in 2006, on how the devices we play games with affects the games we can play (amongst other things).

Transcript of From Paddles To Pads: is controller design killing creativity in videogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Iscontrollerdesignkillingcreativityinvideogames?

FromPaddlestoPads:

1

TomArmitage-tom@infovore.org

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

TomArmitage,aged2.5

2

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Iscontrollerdesignkillingcreativityinvideogames?

3

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 4

Current-genjoypads

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 5

Next-generationjoypad

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 6

New-lookshoulderbuttons!

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 7

RevolutionRemote

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Thanksverymuch!

8

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

9

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Thegamesindustryisbig

‣Halo2:firstdayonsale:

2.38millioncopies

$125m

‣Spider-man:openingweekend:

$114m

10

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 11

Thepowerofsequels

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 12

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 13

Thingswhicharethesame:

Itassumesyou’veusedajoypadbefore

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

What’swrongwiththis?

14

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

NESpad

15

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

SNESpad

16

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Playstationpad

17

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Playstation2pad

18

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Modernhandhelds

19

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Xboxpad

20

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Xboxpadbeingheld

21

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 22

“Complexitylostthecasualgamer...”

NolanBushnell

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 23

“...Ifyoulookattoday’scontrollerwithtriangles,Xs,squaresandcircles,it’sscary.It’slikeakeyboard.Peopleareinterfacephobic.”

NolanBushnell

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

“Peopleareinterfacephobic”

24

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Snake-gamingonaphone

25

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Bricks-gamingonaPDA

26

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Solitaire-gamingonaniPod

27

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 28

Current-genjoypads

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Alex

29

(notehappy,smiling

demeanour,priorto

playingHalo)

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

AlexplayingHalo

30

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Isitthecontrollersthatarescaringpeopleoff?

31

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Consoletake-upintheUS

32

0m

12m

24m

36m

48m

60m

8-bit 16-bit 32-bit now

52m48m

42m

31m

Consistently:about31-32%ofhouseholdshaveaconsole

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Currentjoypadsareaestheticallyuninspiring

33

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 34

Singstar

http://flickr.com/photos/paalb/80551306/

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 35

Buzz

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 36

DonkeyKonga

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 37

GuitarHero

http://flickr.com/photos/mayoff/71389886/

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 38

SteelBattalion

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Halo

39

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 40

MetroidPrime

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 41

Killer7

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 42

MicroMachines2

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 43

MicroMachines2cart

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 44

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 45

Sameidiominnext-gen

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Handedness

46

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Asymmetricpads

47

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

DonkeyKongcabinet

48

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Eventhispadhasabias

49

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 50

Entirelysymmetrical

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 51

Revolution“nunchuck”

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 52

Noincentivetousethesewell

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Iscontrollerdesignkillingcreativityinvideogames?

53

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

The“UncannyValley”

54

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

PS3controller

55

Controllerspecificsare

“nothingweneedtobeconcernedaboutasdevelopers”

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Isthisthebestwecando?

56

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 57

“Ifwecannotexpandthemarket,allwecandoiswaitforthe

industrytoslowlydie”

SatoruIwata

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 58

“Itisourresponsibilitytomakegamesforallskilllevels...includingpeoplewhoarenotplayinggamesnow”

SatoruIwata

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 59

Revolution

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Controllersincomicbooks

60

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Controllersinfilms

61

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 62

“Avideogameissomethingyouplaywithcontrols,usuallybutnotalwaysusingyour

thumbs.”

TomLangston

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 63

Arethesecontrollerswhatwewanttorepresentvideogames?

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames? 64

Gamesaremorethanthis

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Thisisnottheendofevolution

65

Emerging Tech 2006 - Tom Armitage - Is Controller Design Killing Creativity in Videogames?

Thanksverymuch!

66

TomArmitage-tom@infovore.org