FESTF Gopher: Improving data management, accessibility, and use

Ashlea Frank1, Bernalyn McGaughey1, Tilghman Hall2, Lula Ghebremichael3

1Compliance Services International, 2Bayer CropScience, 3Syngenta Crop Protection

American Chemical Society

Boston, MA

August 19-23, 2018

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

1

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

An Introduction to FESTF

2

The FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force (FESTF), incorporated in 1996, is a pesticide registrant data development task force, comprised of 20 companies, responding to species/proximity data requirements published in a 2000 PR Notice

FESTF has been providing data to the EPA for their evaluation of the effects of pesticides on ESA-listed species for over 20 years and has seen the process evolve

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

FESTF Data and Work Products

• Are a result of exploration, applied application and data gathering that started even before when the LLC was incorporated in 1996, over 20 years ago

• We’ve also learned what is necessary for data aggregation and delivery. FESTF first designed an Information Management System in early 2000s. The next generation, Gopher, brings a spatial platform and flexibility

3

• Aggregated data useful to risk assessment• Species locations, including licensed dataset from

NatureServe• Range maps for FWS using aggregated data

• Pesticide use locations• Species biology, local data and conditions

• Status of Species (SOS) files for FWS, including recovery information

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

A system to…address the primary challenges to meeting national level risk assessment data needs

4

Data change over time

Dissimilar elements

describe one attribute

What is authoritative source?

A system to…consider all available lines of evidence for an accurately informed assessment

http://newsroom.ucr.edu/1573

• Information on species size, behavior, diets, habitats and temporal presence and the relationship of those attributes to pesticide use and toxicity

• Expert knowledge on local conditions and interactions

• Regulatory reports on primary stressors and factors critical to survival and reproduction

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

FESTF’s New Generation of the IMS

• Gopher is a password protected, web-based tool kit of data related to ESA-listed species, including species-specific conservation efforts and local/regional knowledge

• Provides a way to bring all of it together, tabular and spatial, for input at various stages throughout the process in a stable, and well-documented system

Species range maps

Pesticide Potential Use Distribution

Pesticide Application Information

Listed Species Attributes

6

BMP Practices and Measures

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher’s GIS Mapping Functionality

7

Over 20 tabular and spatial datasets integrated, pre-calculating millions of possible species-use site proximity relationships

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Initial Gopher Datasets – Species Locations

8

Dataset Name Source

MJD-FESTF NatureServe

NMFS shapefiles supplied to FESTF NMFS

NMFS Salmonids NMFS

FWS Species Range Maps FWS

FWS Critical Habitat FWS

NMFS Critical Habitat NMFS

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Initial Gopher Datasets – Use Sites

9

Individual crops, single and multi-yraggregation

Crop Groups following OP BE groupings and aggregation

Dataset Name Source

Census of Agriculture USDA

Cropland Data Layer (CDL) USDA

National Land Cover Database (NLCD) USGS

NLCD Alaska USGS

NLCD Hawaii USGS

Crop Groups USDA/CSI

ADCi – (golf courses, parks, schools, etc) ADCi

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

10

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Co-occurrence and proximity

• Generate co-occurrences based on core species and use site datasets and user-selected taxa, use sites, and locations

• Can set a No Effect Distance to explore various proximity distances and results

11

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Heat Map

• Heat map shows co-occurrence

• Provides a quick visual of areas with highest co-occurrence

12

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Export

• Export co-occurrences and proximities to a Scenario or Excel file to conduct more in-depth analysis

13

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Spatial Data Viewing

• Aggregated Species and Use Site Data Layers are available for viewing

14

Element Occurrences from Licensed dataset from NatureServe and NLCD

FWS Everglade snail kite Critical Habitat and CDL

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Spatial Data Viewing (2)

Allows for dataset comparisons, identify areas needing closer examination such as this area identified as a golf course (ADCi, 2017) but also alfalfa (CDL, 2017)

15

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Spatial Data Exploration• Identify feature, buffer, and measure tools

16

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

BMP enrollment areas

Gopher – Additional Data Layers

17

Additional datasets, can added and integrated

http://www.landfire.gov/

Spatial extent of non-crop uses such as conifer seed plantations and forestry

USGS Soils Maps

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Query Attributes

18

Query data from licensed NatureServe dataQuery data from EPA’s

ESKB and additional attributes

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – FWS Status of Species

19

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – NMFS Status of Species

20

Gopher houses NMFS SOSs from OP BiOpin PDF format

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – ScenariosUsers create Projects to examine different Scenarios, allows focus on national state regional local

21

Data Source: NatureServe and its Natural Heritage Member Programs

Toolkit allows users to document findings specific to species, use sites, and/or locations through Maps, Queries, Proximity Calculations, user input/data, and other tools

Query elevation data

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Dataset Download

• Datasets in system can be downloaded by users with proper access

• Users can upload datasets to be added to the system

• Uploaded datasets go to a Data Steward for review and validation before being added to system

22

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher - Applications• Gopher can inform and facilitate preparation of USEPA’s endangered species pesticide assessments by bringing efficiency and transparency in a stable and documented system

• Allows analysis at various levels of resolution and considers multiple lines of evidence using best available data– National-level scoping

– State and regional examination

– Local and species-specific analysis

• The flexibility of Gopher allows for further applications such as capturing voluntary measures as a mechanism to better inform the interface of pesticide use and endangered species data

23

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Gopher – Take-away• Gopher is a web-based, password-protected software developed by FESTF; provides a platform to access and spatially interact with best available datasets related to pesticides and ESA-listed species

• Spatial and tabular data can be viewed, mapped, queried, and exported in various formats

• Can lift species-specific conservation efforts and local/regional knowledge to the national-level

• With data integration platform, can explore opportunities to enhance species recovery while minimizing over-regulation and adverse grower impact in a way that provides transparency

24

Thank you for this opportunity and please contact me with any

questions!

7501 Bridgeport Way West – Lakewood, WA 98499

253-473-9007

AFrank@ComplianceServices.com

FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

Ashlea FrankPrincipal Consultant, Compliance Services InternationalTechnical Consultant, FIFRA Endangered Species Task Force

25