Post on 08-Jul-2018
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
1/23
Federalism and Regionalism in India : Institutional Strategies and Political
Accommodation of Identity Bhattacharyya, Harihar URL: http:archi!"u#"uni$
heidel#erg"de!ollte%tser!er&&'' UR(: urn:n#n:de:#s):*+$heido$&&''- .atum:
*/" 0ay /''& Bitte #eachten Sie die (ut)ungs#edingungen: http:archi!"u#"uni$
heidel#erg"de!ollte%tser!erhelplicense1urhg"html Heidel#erg Papers in SouthAsian and 2omparati!e Politics South Asia Institute .epartment of Political Science
Uni!ersity of Heidel#erg Federalism and Regionalism in India Institutional Strategies
and Political Accommodation of Identity #y Harihar Bhattacharyya 3oring Paper
(o" /4 0ay /''& H5I.5LB5R6 PAP5RS I( S7U8H ASIA( A(. 270PARA8I95
P7LI8I2S 3oring Paper (o" /4 0ay /''& ISS( *+*4$&'+;
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
2/23
multinational So!iet Union, and the split up of the Federal Repu#lic of =ugosla!ia"
IndiaJs record of relati!e unity and integrity stands in sharp contrast to many
postcolonial federations,
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
3/23
Federalism is seen here as a political euili#rium,
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
4/23
Sihs *;,/*&,4E' *";Q Buddhists 4,;&&,/'4 '"DQ ains -,//&,'&E '"-Q 7ther
religions +,+E;,+/+ '"+Q Religion not stated n"a" '"*Q 8otal *,'/D,+*',E/D *''Q
Source: 2ensus Reports of India, /''*" 8hree features stand out from 8a#le * a#o!e
regarding regional concentration of religious groups in India" First, there is only one
0uslim maNority state in India, !i)", ammu Mashmir" 8his
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
5/23
languages @2ensus Report of India, *;;*,
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
6/23
language, 5nglish @lin language, and the Dth Schedule language, as mentioned
a#o!e" In actual political process, the demand for the ocial recognition of
languages has most often #een intertects" 8
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
7/23
eeping in mind the countryJs manifold di!ersity, and multiple identities" 8he
num#er of States in India has thus remained changing" 7ne
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
8/23
6o!ernor of the state concerned, and the rest shall #e elected on the #asis of
uni!ersal adult su>rage" @- 8he elected mem#ers of the 2ouncils shall hold oce
for a term of ?!e years from the date appointed for the ?rst meeting of the 2ouncil
after the general elections to the 2ouncils, unless the .istrict 2ouncil is dissol!ed
sooner #y the 6o!ernor, and the nominated mem#er shall hold oce at the
pleasure of the 6o!ernor" @& 8he 2ouncil has legislati!e po
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
9/23
identity, as a#o!e, are designed for self$rule" 8here are clear constitutional
distri#ution of po
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
10/23
mo#ilisation, often taing on a !iolent character, ected
State 6o!ernment, and the ethnic leaders for a negotiated settlement" Such ethnic
peace accords ha!e #een the #ases for su#seuent legislation at Union and State
legislatures for instituting a ne< state, or a su#$state" Region$#ased tri#al ethnicity,
not language,
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
11/23
religion as a #asis of demanding statehood in the late *;+'s" But, realising that
religion ecti!e
for a !ast and di!erse country lie India" 8he relati!e failure of their model of
go!ernance led them to introduce, #y degrees, since the *;/'s, doses of de!olution
and federalism in India in
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
12/23
federalism" Interestingly enough, the pro!incialists demanded increase re!enue for
pro!inces, #ut
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
13/23
made one of the ?rst authoritati!e HARIHAR BHA88A2HAR==A *+ comments on
Indian federalism and descri#ed the Indian constitution as Ga system of go!ernment
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
14/23
he did not fail to identify the HARIHAR BHA88A2HAR==A *4 critical aspects of Indian
federalism, and the forces
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
15/23
many dangerous predictions made a#out IndiaJs disintegration found in such
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
16/23
*;-4" But this crisis in Indian federalism
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
17/23
regional go!ernment, and therefore there too place a #alanced operation of the
IndiaJs federal system during the anata phase @Ray *;D4: *&4" .5BA85 SI(25 8H5
*;D'S 8he most distincti!e aspects of the de#ates on Indian federalism since the
*;D's are that apart from the persistent issue of statesJ rights, regional and local
identities, and decentralisation ha!e continuously #een the focussed" 8he ocial
commissions set up for the purpose,
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
18/23
country" For, e!ery urge for autonomy is not di!isi!e, #ut most pro#a#ly a
complementary forceC it
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
19/23
has percei!ed the issue of federalism in India ects of PresidentJs Rule in the States in India"6oing against all the e%isting accounts, he said although the increased freuency of
PresidentJs rule @Art" E&+ of the Indian 2onstitution, particularly since the si%ties,
ha!e resulted in the reduction in state autonomy, this reduction has not meant
e>ecti!e central control o!er state politics or e>ecti!e centralisation of po
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
20/23
of ho< a recogni)ed and secure identity rather than causing secessionism can #e a
factor for economic de!elopment" 3hat has #een the political impact of regional
accommodation of identityW Has it meant only the regionalisation of politicsW Is the
national identity a lost terrainW 8he a!aila#le researches do not suggest so" 8he
presence of the region on the national scene is seen #y many as positi!e, as part of
the process of community formation and empoect of such process in that IndiaJs
representati!e democracy has mo!ed closed to the people
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
21/23
political practice for such representati!e institutions throughout India" .emocracy
rather than ethnicity is thus the legitimacy #asis of such political institutions" .as
6upta @Mohli /''*: -; has termed this Gdemocratic responsi!eness to cultural
di>erences in India" Second, going #eyond the a#o!e, I ha!e argued elseer 8 eds" Intergo!ernmental Fiscal Relations in Fragmented Societies @Fri#ourg:
Institute of Federalism, /''' Bhattacharyya H, India s a 0ulticultural Federation:
Asian 9alues .emocracy and .ecentralisation @In 2omparison
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
22/23
Foundations of Indian Federalism @Bom#ay: Asia Pu#lishing House, *;+4 Bom#
8/19/2019 Federalism and Regionalism in India
23/23
@(e< .elhi: Segments, *;;D 0itra, S M and Singh, 9 B .emocracy and Social
2hange in India @(e< .elhi: Sage Pu#lications, *;;;, chapter &: G8he .ialectics of
(ation and Region in Indian Politics, pp *&&$4; 0orris$ones, 3 H, Parliament in
India @Hydera#ad: 7rient Longman, *;&4 0orris$ones 3 H, 8he 6o!ernment and
Politics of India @Hamshire, UM: 8he 5othen Press, *;D4, Erd edn 0uherNee, B"
Regionalism in Indian Perspecti!e @2alcutta: M P Bagchi 2o, *;;/ (am#udripad, 50 S, G (ational Political Bacground of Indian Federalism in Murian and 9arughese
eds" @*;D* 7p cit" (ossiter, 8 , 2ommunism in Merala @.elhi: 7UP, *;D/ (ossiter 8
, 0ar%ist State 6o!ernments in India @London and (e< =or: Pinter Pu#lishers,
*;DD Ram, 0" Hindi Against India @ (e< .elhi: Rachna, *;+D Rao, 6 R S,
Regionalism in India @(e< .elhi: S 2hand and 2o, *;4&" Rao, M 9, Parliamentary
.emocracy in India @2alcutta: 3orld Press P!t Ltd, *;+* Reddy, R 6 and Sharma, B
A, Regionalism in India: A Study of 8elengana @(e< .elhi: 2oncept, *;4; Rudolph L
and Rudolph, S, In Pursuit of Lashmi: 8he Political economy of the Indian State
@2hicago: 2hicago Uni!ersity Press, *;D4 Sarar, A, Regionalism, State and the
5merging Political Patterns of India @2alcutta: Firma M L 0, *;;* Sen 6upta B,
2ommunism in Indian Politics @(e< =or: 2olum#ia Uni!ersity Press, *;4/ Singh, 6,
2ommunism in PunNa# @.elhi: ANanta, *;;E Saar, S, 0odern India @*;DD&$*;-4
@(e< .elhi: 0acmillan, *;DE 9iNapur A P ed" .imensions of Federal (ation$Building
@(e< .elhi: 0ana Pu#lications, *;;D 3allace, P ed" Region and (ation in India
@ .elhi: 7UP, *;D& 3atts, R L, (e< Federations 5%periments in the 2ommon