Post on 11-Jul-2015
Details, Mistakes & Cures in
IP Law Practice
Richard P. Beem BEEM PATENT LAW FIRM
www.BeemLaw.com
Chicago USA
Illinois Paralegal AssociationFall Education ConferenceNovember 20, 2014
My Mentor, Judge Edward S. SmithU.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
Slide 2
Are they honest?
Slide 3
Judge Smith’s Two Rules
1. Confidentiality
2. Mistakes
And a third…
3. Somebody (this might be you) should always know where to find everyone and everything
Slide 4
Goal is Zero Defects
Slide 5
We All Make Mistakes
• Recognize
• Raise
• Remedy
Slide 6
Three R’s
Illinois Rules of Professional Conduct
RULE 1.4: COMMUNICATION
(a) A lawyer shall:
* * *
(3) keep the client reasonably informed about the status of the matter;
* * *
Slide 7
Dumpster Dive 1
• Lawyer loses file –thinks it’s out the window
• Sees dumpster below and goes for a dive
Slide 8
Four Ways to Deal with Mistake
1. Ostrich approach
2. Hide or deny it
3. Say it was someone else’s mistake
4. Apologize on behalf of firm & fix it
Slide 9
Failure to Pay Issue Fee
• Phone calls (to straighten out important details) don’t suspend due dates
• Written action/payment is required
Slide 10
Close counts, in horseshoes
Slide 11
A Client Named Howard
• Lawyer writes letter to Howard
• Assistant finalizes and sends letter and goes home
• Howard calls lawyer: “Is this some kind of Freudian slip?”
Slide 12
Watch out for spell check
Slide 13
Prevention
• Last look / print
• Read aloud
• Recheck names, dates, serial numbers, docket numbers
• Docketing
• Send and document reminders
Slide 14
Correspondence
• More on last look –
– Content
– Attachments
• Will it make sense to reader?
• Is all pertinent information included?
• Match addressee and salutation
• Check headers on all pages
Slide 15
Slide 16
TRAIN FIRM
Slide 17
Slide 18
Dumpster Dive 2
• Lawyer prepares boxes of documents to produce in litigation
• Staff thinks they are trash and throws them out
• Lawyer traces boxes to recycling center
Slide 19
Names
• Dale Carnegie said, “A person’s name is the sweetest sound.”
• Use names, get them right, and spell them right.
Slide 20
Which is correct?
HON Technology Inc.or
Hon Technology, Inc.
(ca. 2000)
Slide 21
Names (cont.)
• Name misspelled on printed name tag at conference
• How should staff respond?
Slide 22
Cures
• When you discover mistake, tell your boss promptly and fully
• If you can, propose a solution
• Might be reportable to professional liability insurer
• Prompt candid communication to client– State situation and propose course of action
• Might cost the firm– Fees and costs for petition to revive
• Better now than later
Slide 23
Fear of mistakes can paralyze
Slide 24
Better to move forward and risk mistake than do nothing
Slide 25
Questions?
Slide 26
Thank you!
Richard P. Beem Beem Patent Law Firm
www.BeemLaw.com
Slide 27