Post on 04-Jun-2018
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
1/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
Deoband Reject Sahaba Sayings
Bismillahirrahmanirraheem, Alhamdulillah this is another one ofthe wonderful articles from the Magazines of Shaikh MuhammadZubair Sadiq Abadi (One of the authors of Shaikh Zubair Ali Zai'smagazine "Al Hadeeth"). The honours of translating this article isdone by brother Raza hasan. May Allaah reward him immenselyfor this crucial work. This article contains proof of how theDeobandis Reject the Saying of Sahaba.
The hadeeth which does not contain in it the mention of theProphet (sallallaahu alayhi wasallam) and is only the saying or actof a Sahaabi is called Mawqoof. Some people claim for all theAhlul Hadeeth that they do not accept the Mawqoofaat ofSahaabah. In this short and succinct article, we have proven fromthe books and passages of Deobandthat they themselves do notconsider the Mawqoofaat of Sahaba to be Hujjah and when thesaying or action of a Sahabi goes against these Taqleedis, thenthey are the first ones to reject it.
Muhammad Imraan Safdar Deobandi, the beloved of IlyasGhumman, writes:The Raafidis declared the Eemaan of Sahaabah to beunreliable while the minor Raafidis (GhayrMuqallideen) refused to accept the sayings and actionsof Sahaabah to be Hujjah. I seek Allaahs refuge from the
wickedness of Ghayr Muqallideen [Qaaflah Haqq, Vol. 1Shumarah 2, P. 44]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
2/48
IS
DearMuqa
up saDeob
1-
Therelieis a
AMIC
eaders!lideen t
ing: I sndis!Sarfaraz
re is no dod upon peeavy proo
ESEAR
Now ifen acc
eek Alla
han Saf
ubt in thesonality inin its plac
www.s
ww
CHCE
ou rearding t
hs ref
ar Deoban
act that ththe presee, but in li
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
the follthe De
ge from
i writes:saying of
ce of propht of the p
om
WALPI
wing sbandi
the wic
a Sahaabihet-hood lrinciples o
NDIPA
yings osool, yo
edness
specially tke Abdullf Hadeeth,
KISTAN
Deobawill e
of
he sayingh bin Masthe differe
did
f aoodnce
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
3/48
IS
thatavoialaySahe
2-Deob
As
AMIC
is establised. The sti wasalla
eh. [Raah-
he Shaykhandi said:or the act
ESEAR
ed betweeatus that a
) holds ise-Sunnat (P.
ul-Hadeeth
f a Sahaa
www.s
ww
CHCE
a MarfooMarfoo haertainly n
114)]
and the Sh
i, then it is
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
and Mawdeeth of Hot of the sa
aykh ul-Hin
not a Hujj
om
WALPI
oof hadeedhrat Mu
ying of a S
of Deoba
ah [Taqaa
NDIPA
h can notammad (s
ahaabi, ev
diyah, Mah
eer Shaykh
KISTAN
s well beallallaahun if it is
ood ul-Has
l-Hind P. 3
an
]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
4/48
IS AMIC ESEAR
www.s
ww
CHCE
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
om
WALPINDIPAKISTAN
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
5/48
IS
3-
ThiShay
4-UloosaidPro
AMIC
t another pl
one sayinh ul-Hind P
uhammadDeoband,
hat the sayhet. [See,
ESEAR
ace, he said:g of a Saha. 43]
Anwar Shawhile givining of a Saawdaad M
www.s
ww
CHCE
abi cannot
h Kaashmia testimon
haabi is nqaddimah
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
be a Hujja
ee, the prey to the cout a Hujjairzaaeeyy
om
WALPI
h for the
ious Shayrt in the Muas is theh Bahaawa
NDIPA
anafiyyah
h ul-Hadeeqaddimahaying of tlpoor Vol. 1
KISTAN
[Taqaareer
h of Daarahaawalpoe
P. 445]l-r
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
6/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
5- Khaleel Ahmed Sahaaranpoori Deobandi writes:" "And it is the Madhab of a Sahaabi which is notHujjah for anyone [Bazl al-Majhood 5/39 H. 821]6- The Imaam of Aal-e-Deoband, Mulla Ali Qaari al-Hanafi writes:"And it is the Madhab of a Sahaabi which is not"Hujjah for anyone [Mirqaat al-Mafaateeh SharhMishkaat al-Masaabeeh (2/549 H. 823)]
If someone says that the saying of a Sahaabi is not Hujjah
in our Madhab, then for such a person the beloved ofIlyaas Ghumman, Abdul Ghani Taariq LudhiyaanwiDeobandi writes:""If you ever utter such a thing from your tongue,then I will pull out your tongue and feed it to the
dogs [Shaadi ki pehli dus raatein P. 9]
7- Zafar Ahmed Thaanvi Deobandi said:""
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
7/48
IS
TcoH.
8-comsaid:Thi
AMIC
e saytradi
432)]
ayyidunahenting on tnarratio
ESEAR
ng oftion t
bu Hurayrais fact, the
is Mawqo
www.s
ww
CHCE
Sahathe
h (radiallahShaykh ul-H
f, thus th
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
abi isarfo
nhu) used tadeeth of D
re is no H
om
WALPI
ot H [Ila
o read Qunoeobandis,
jjah in it
NDIPA
jjah ius-Su
ot in the Fajuhammad T
[Dars-e-Tir
KISTAN
an (1/
prayer. Whaqi Uthmaa
idhi 2/169]
63
ilei
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
8/48
IS AMIC ESEAR
www.s
ww
CHCE
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
om
WALPINDIPAKISTAN
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
9/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
9- Muhammad Taqi Uthmaani Deobandi said:From the side of Hanafiyyah, the answer to that was given as such that there is noapproval of him (sallallaahu alayhi wasallam) proven on this incident, and without
his approval, in contrast to the other ahaadeeth, the action of a Sahaabi cannot be aHujjah [Dars-e-Tirmidhi 1/319]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
10/48
IS AMIC ESEAR
www.s
ww
CHCE
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
om
WALPINDIPAKISTAN
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
11/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
10- Muhammad Taqi Uthmaani further said: " "Therefore, the correct answer to this is that it is the personal act and Ijtihaad ofIbn Umar, there is not differentiation in it narrated from the Marfoo ahaadeeth;moreover, the Ijtihaad of a Sahaabi is not Hujjah, especially when there are theother Athaar of Sahaabah present in opposition to it [Dars-e-Tirmidhi 1/191]
11- Muhammad Taqi Uthmaani said:So first of all, this is the personal Ijtihaad of Abu Hurayrah which is not Hujjahagainst the Marfoo ahaadeeth[Dars-e-Tirmidhi 2/84]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
12/48
IS
12-
No
that,to beHujj
AMIC
Muham
there re
firstly, it iauthenticah against
ESEAR
ad Taqi Ut
ains only
afflictedas per thethe Marfo
www.s
ww
CHCE
maani Deo
he athar o
ith a sevehain, stillHadeeth
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
andi further
f Abu Bakr
e Idtiraabit can be t[Dars-e-Tir
om
WALPI
said:Siddeeq,
, and secoe Ijtihaadidhi 1/283
NDIPA
nd the ans
dly even iof a Sahaa]
KISTAN
wer to this
it is accepi, which i
is
ednot
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
13/48
IS
Whereas,
Now hWahhaEven ifa proofpassageand un
AMIC
Ismaaeel J
ve a lookbi. This, Ithe act offor us agaiagain anderstandin
ESEAR
anghwi al-
t a new reave in my
bdullah bist the act
again as toover the
www.s
ww
CHCE
eobandi sai
erence anhand, Fatn Masoodf the Prop
whether itahaabah o
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
, while tau
imagine tawa Barkis provenhet!Look,seeks to g
r not!? [T
om
WALPI
ting on Ahl
he vast unatiyah, onith an aut
read, andve preferehfah Ahl-e-
NDIPA
l-Hadeeth:erstandin
Page 36 ofhentic cha
ay attentince to oneHadeeth, Pa
KISTAN
g of awhich it sn, it is stilln at this
s own intet 3 P. 49]
ys:not
lect
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
14/48
IS
We say tTaqi Uth
-13 " Yesone
AMIC
Ismaaeel Jaani and cl
Mufti Ja , we do finakah witr
ESEAR
hanghwi andarify the diff
meel Ahmed some nar
, but this
www.s
ww
CHCE
their partnerence betw
Nazeeri De rations froas their pe
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
r Deobandisen these tw
bandi write m some ofrsonal Ijti
om
WALPI
to read, agpassages!
: the Sahaaaad whic
NDIPA
in and again
ah conceris not Huj
KISTAN
, the passag
ning prayijah agains
of
gthe
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
15/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
numerous Marfoo ahaadeeth [Rasool-e-Akram (sallallaahu alayhi wasallam) ka tareeqahNamaaz (P. 259)]If the same athaar were in accordance to their Taqleedi Madhab then they would have said thatthe Sahaabah Karaam could not have offered an important Ibaadah like Salaah from their ownintellect, therefore these athaar are in the ruling of being Marfoo, as these people say concerning
some un-proven athaar in the issue of wiping over the neck!
14- Muhammad Taqi Uthmaani said:As for the second route then that is also Saheeh, but even this does not establish aclear Marfoo proof for the Shaafieeyyah and others, because that is the personalIjtihaad of Hadhrat Ubaadah, i.e. he considered the hadeeth there is no prayer forthe who does not recite to be general for both Imaam and Muqtadi and extractedthe ruling from this hadeeth that the recitation is obligatory even for the Muqtadi,
but this extraction of his can not be Hujjah against the Marfoo ahaadeeth [Dars-e-
Tirmidhi 2/75]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
16/48
IS
15-
Whthe t
behibut tespeJum
AMIC
The Im
ether Hadruth is tha
d the Imahe understcially agaihoor Saha
ESEAR
am of Deo
rat UbaadHadhratam and thianding ofst the Nobbah Karaa
www.s
ww
CHCE
andis, Sarfa
ah bin as-baadah ws was his rSahaabi a
le Quraanm [Ahsa
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
raz Khan Sa
aamit unds of the osearch an
nd the Ma, the authen ul-Kalaam
om
WALPI
fdar Karma
erstood itinion to r
d this wasqoof of atic ahaad
(2/156)]
NDIPA
gi Gakhrawi
orrectly ocite Surah
his MaslakSahaabi iseth, and t
KISTAN
wrote:incorrect
Faatihahand Madhnot Hujjahe athaar o
y,
ab,,f
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
17/48
IS
16-
Cerread
wassayi
AMIC
At anoth
tainly Hadthe kalimllam) andg of Aais
ESEAR
er place, Sar
rat Aaish(i.e. laa il
he said thaah? [Khaz
www.s
ww
CHCE
faraaz Safda
ah was notaha illalla
t the deadaain as-Sun
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
r wrote:
of the opiah) of than hear, s
n (3/64)]
om
WALPI
ion that dProphet
o should
NDIPA
ead can hesallallaahe accept hi
KISTAN
r, but wealayhi
s saying o
ave
the
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
18/48
IS AMIC ESEAR
www.s
ww
CHCE
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
om
WALPINDIPAKISTAN
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
19/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
17- Faqeerullaah Deobandi wrote::" " Thirdly because this is the personal saying and Fatwa of Hadhrat Abu Hurayrahradiallah anhu which is achieved through Qiyaas and is not a Marfoo hadeeth; andthe saying or Fatwa of a Sahaabi which is achieved through Qiyaas is not Hujjah
with agreement. [Khaatimah al-Kalaam P. 550]
18- Master Ameen Okaarvi wrote about Sayyidunah Abdullah az-Zubayr (radiallah anhu):The odd rulings of Hadhrat Abdullah bin az-Zubayr are not accepted by the Ahl us-Sunnah wal Jamaah as compared to the other Sahaabah, for example: He was ofthe opinion to give Adhaan and Iqaamah even for the prayers of Eedayn, and he
was also of the opinion to pray while leaving the hands (on the sides) [Tajalliyaat-e-Safdar (2/299)]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
20/48
IS
19-
Ma(1/17
AMIC
Sarfaraa
qoof is n)]
ESEAR
z Khaan Saf
t any Hujj
www.s
ww
CHCE
ar wrote:h against
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
he Marfoo
om
WALPI
ahaadeet
NDIPA
[Khazaain
KISTAN
as-Sunan
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
21/48
IS AMIC ESEAR
www.s
ww
CHCE
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
om
WALPINDIPAKISTAN
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
22/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
20- Imaam Bukhaari (rahimahullah) narrated the sayings of Sayyidunah Anas (radiallahanhu), Hasan Basri, and Qataadah that there is no Tashahhud after the prostration offorgetfulness [See, Saheeh al-Bukhaari (1/163)]. So while rejecting this, Sarfaraaz SafdarDeobandi said:
But this extraction of Imaam Bukhaari is weak because these are Mawqoofnarrations, while on the contrary there are clear, authentic and Marfoo narrations;
what is the use of Mawqoof narrations against them? [Khazaain as-Sunan (2/143)]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
23/48
IS AMIC ESEAR
www.s
ww
CHCE
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
om
WALPINDIPAKISTAN
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
24/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
21- Abdul Maajid Dariyaabaadee al-Deobandi, the Khaleefah of Ashraf Ali Thaanvi, wrote:""Even the Sahaabah are not free from errors and mistakes, let alone the piouspersonalities who are, anyhow, inferior from them [Hakeem ul-Ummat (P. 275)]
22- Abdul Qayyoom Haqqaani Deobandi wrote:The most reasonable and correct answer is that this was the personal act and theperson Ijtihaad of Hadhrat Ibn Umar..... After all the Ijtihaad of a Sahaabi is noteven Hujjah especially when there are the Athaar of other Sahaabah on thecontrary [Tozeeh us-Sunan (1/405)]
23- There is narration in Sunan Abu Dawood (1/26 H. 198) that a Sahaabi started hisprayer and while in prayer he was shot with an arrow which made his blood flow but hecontinued his prayer, if the streaming of blood had been one of the invalidators of wudoo then he
would not have continued praying his Salaat. After narrating this act of the Sahaabi, SarfaraazKhaan Safdar did not consider it to be a Hujjah, rather on the contrary he presented the saying ofone of his own akaabireen in its place, saying: 122"1" Maulaana Sahaaranpoori writes in Vol. 1 P. 122 of Bazl al-Majhood that thisproceeding was on his own, the Prophet (sallallaahu alayhi wasallam) did not actupon this; neither was he aware of this nor did he give him the permission to dothis [Khazaain as-Sunan (1/182)]
24- Ashraf Ali Thaanvi said:The Madhab of Hadhrat Anas was (in favor of having) the second Jamaah (in aMasjid) [Malfoozaat Hakeem ul-Ummat 26/201]
Right after this saying, instead of accepting the act of Sayyidunah Anas (radiallah anhu) to beHujjah, Thaanvi wrote:Now since the Ijmaa has taken place against this, thats why the first action will beelevated [Same (P. 201)]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
25/48
IS
If theabou
25-
TheKarsuchSha
AMIC
act of a Sahthis self-pr
Zakariy
re has nevam radiallmistakeskhs can ne
ESEAR
abi was Hujclaimed Ijm
ah Tableegh
r come anah anhumrom the gr
ver be sup
www.s
ww
CHCE
jah accordinaa.
i Deobandi s
y jitterineshave madeeat Shaykrior to th
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
g to the Deo
aid:s in mindsome bigs is evensmallest
om
WALPI
bandis, then
bout the fistakes,
ore far-fef Sahaaba
NDIPA
they would
ct that sohereas thched and t [Sharee
KISTAN
ot have car
e Sahaaboccurrenhe biggestat wa Taree
d
he of
ofqat
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
26/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
ka Talaazum P. 11 & Sawaanih Muhammad Zakariyyah P. 278]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
27/48
IS AMIC ESEAR
www.s
ww
CHCE
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
om
WALPINDIPAKISTAN
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
28/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
29/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
30/48
IS
But a
Ha
At an
Anrak
AMIC
t another pl
hrat Sad
other place,
way, the sh witr [T
ESEAR
ce, he himse
ffered on
he wrote:mmary of
jalliyaat Saf
www.s
ww
CHCE
lf wrote:rakah wi
this is thaar (2/572)]
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
r... [Tajall
Hadhrat
om
WALPI
yaat Safdar
meer Mu
NDIPA
(2/571)]
awiyah pr
KISTAN
ayed one
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
31/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
32/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
And further he wrote:One Rakah witr is not permissible [Tajalliyaat-e-Safdar (2/573)]
28- According to Sayyidunah Abu Hurayrah (radiallah anhu), only the recitation of SurahFaatihah is obligatory in Salaah as this Fatwa of his is present in Saheeh al-Bukhaari (1/106 H.77) and Saheeh Muslim (1/170 H. 396). Although the Imaam of Deobandiyah, Sarfaraz Khaan,could not dare to criticize the authenticity of this narration, but instead of accepting it, herejected it with the following words:The narration of Hadhrat Abu Hurayrah that Mubaarakpooree sahab haspresented for the sufficiency of Surah Faatihah only, cannot be any beneficial forhis purpose, because this is Mawqoof upon Hadhrat Abu Hurayrah and these
words are not narrated in any Marfoo and Saheeh narration (See, Fath ul-Mulhim Vol.2 P. 31 etc)[Ahsan ul-Kalaam (2/32), second edition (2/35)]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
33/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
34/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
35/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
36/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
37/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
38/48
IS
Sinceis notDeobRab
" AftLimMuqsay
AMIC
this athar oHujjah for tand. In spiteana Lakal r completin Hamida
tadis will soth phras
ESEAR
Sayyidunahhe Ahl al-Hof that theyamd in his ng his rukh. If he isay Rabbans. [Rasool
www.s
ww
CHCE
Umar (radideeth. Howoppose thisprayer. Hen o, he shon Imaam ta Lakal He-Akram ka
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
llah anhu) iver, this aththar because Mufti Ja ld stand sthen he shmd, and itareeqah Na
om
WALPI
s not even par is provene the Deobaeel Deoban raight whiuld only s
f he is pramaaz (P. 22
NDIPA
oven from haccording todi Imaam di has writte
le saying Sy that muing alone t)]
KISTAN
im, thereforthe Scholaroes not say:
ami Allaah, and the
hen he sho
e, itof
"u
uld
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
39/48
IS
MastWefor t(Uso
Lookat onUma
AMIC
r Ameen Oreconcilede one pra
ol Karkhi
! Master Amplace to subehind so
ESEAR
aarvi writesbetween ting alone,. 84, 85)
en Okaarviport his mae Karkhi!!
www.s
ww
CHCE
about Samie two and
while the[Tajalliyaat-
as also presdhab, but no
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
Allaahu Lisaid that tivision is-Safdar (6/
ented this Aw in anothe
om
WALPI
an Hamidahe combinor the Im61)]
thar of Sayyiplace, he le
NDIPA
Rabbana Ltion of bo
am and th
dunah Umaft the athar
KISTAN
akal Hamdh phrasesMuqtadi
(radiallahf Sayyiduna
that:is
nhu)
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
40/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
Now the Deobandis must explain why they dont accept this athar of Sayyidunah Umar (radiallahanhu)?
Note: Haafidh Zubayr Alee Zaee hafidhahullah has presented forty one (41) Authentic and
Proven Athaar of Sahaabah in the Magazine: Al-Hadeeth # 30 P. 30-42 which the people ofDeoband oppose.
At the end, we say that the People of Deoband or their Akaabireen have also targeted thepersonalities of Sahaabah Karaam (radiallah anhum) in order NOT to act upon some narrations.For example:1- In order not to act upon the athar of Sayyidunah Anas (radiallah anhu) concerning joiningthe feet with the feet, Ameen Okaarvi wrote: " " Hadhrat Anas was also an immature child at the time of the Prophet (sallallaahualayhi wasallam) and he used to stand in the back rows
He further said: "" Hadhrat Anas only narrated what he did in his childhood with the other children.But when he grew up, the Sahaabah and Taabieen were disgusted by his childhood
practice [Haashiah Tafheem ul-Bukhaari Alaa Saheeh Bukhaari Vol. 1 P. 370]
2- In order to reject the hadeeth of Sayyidunah Abdullah bin Umar (radiallah anhu) on raisingthe hands in Salaah, Ameen Okaarvi said:""However, Imaam Bukhaari did not bring any narration from a Muhaajir or an
Ansaari. He only brought one hadeeth from Abdullah bin Umar, who was a child or
a minor Sahaabi and used to stand in back rows, and the other is from HadhratMaalik bin al-Huwayrith, who only stayed with the Prophet for twenty nights as atraveler. [Tafheem ul-Bukhaari Vol. 1 P. 375]
3- Okaarvi further said:Similarly, Instead of some Badri Sahaabi, Imaam Bukhaari has proven Raf ul-
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
41/48
IS
Yadnigh
4-
ImSah
AMIC
yn at ninets Hadhrat
oncerning S
am Musliabi, Waail
ESEAR
places incMaalik bi
ayyidunah
jumped ebin Hujr a
www.s
ww
CHCE
mplete fral-Huway
aail bin H
ven furthetraveler [
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
m a kid Ibrith [Tajal
jr (radiallah
r and besiTajalliyaat-e
om
WALPI
Umar anliyaat-e-Safd
anhu), Oka
es these t-Safdar (7/9
NDIPA
d a travelear (Vol. 7 P.
rvi said:
o, he foun4)]
KISTAN
of twenty94)]
d another
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
42/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
43/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
44/48
IS
7-" He
NoteSayyi
while
AMIC
oncerning S s not kno
:According tdunah Anasrefuting Yo
ESEAR
ayyidunah A"for Fiqh
o Mahmood(radiallah anus Nomaa
www.s
ww
CHCE
nas (radiall
nd Ijtihaa
Aalam Safdhu) were alsi al-Deoba
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
h anhu), M
[Futuhaat
r Deobandio said by Yodi, Master
om
WALPI
lla Jeewan
Safdar (3/3
Hayaati, theonus Numameen Okarv
NDIPA
anafi wrote
82)]
se words coni Deoband
i said:
KISTAN
:
cerningi Mamaati. nd
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
45/48
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
46/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
ISLAMICRESEARCHCENTRERAWALPINDIPAKISTAN
In counter response to this comment of Master Ameen Okaarvi Hayaati Deobandi, YoonusNumaani Mamaati Deobandi commented:My Dear Friends, Brothers. In this passage, Moulvi Sahab has done a hugeinjustice as he attributed towards me that I said about the Sahaabi (radiallah anhu)that he is not Aadil and he was a Faasiq. (Rather) I had only quoted with reference
to Noor al-Anwaar and Usool Shaashi that it is written in them: He was not knownfor Fiqh and Ijtihaad. Now what the Moulvi Sahab should have done is ask me forthe proof and I would have showed him that: see, it is written in such and suchplace. But in order to enrage the people, as is the way of Liars, he instead tried touse this trick on me. If a Ghayr Muqallid had said this, it was not a problem, but Iam amazed that this objection came from a man who claims to be the preacher ofHanafi Usool al-Fiqh. I only said, He is not known for his Fiqh and Ijtihaad and if
you can find that I said Hadhrat Anas (radiallah anhu) was not Aadil, but a Faasiq if you can find these words then I am ready to confess my defeat in writing, but whydo you speak such useless things? The Hanafi Usool al-Fiqh, which is accepted evenaccording to you, contains the saying that Hadhrat Anas (radiallah anhu) is a GhayrMaroof narrator in Fiqh and Ijtihaad. And if his narration goes against the Qiyaasthen the Qiyaas will be given precedence. This is written in Noor al-Anwaar and
Usool Shaashi. [Futuhaat Safdar (3/382-383)]
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
47/48
IS
Then
MoShathinHangive
AMIC
after this co
lvi Sahab
shi, and th. O Moulvfi Fiqh haFatwa on
ESEAR
ment of Yo
says thatat if a GhaSahab, yorejected t
a Marjooh
www.s
ww
CHCE
onus Numa
"
hat I said ir Muqallisay that i
his. And itopinion is
stemoflife.c
.ircpk.co
TRER
ani, Master
s present ihad said
t is an acceis written ia Jaahil an
om
WALPI
meen Okaa
n Noor al-his, it woupted thingn Hanafi Fd an oppo
NDIPA
rvi replied a
nwaar an
ld have be, (but) thisiqh that ther of Ijma
KISTAN
ain, saying:
Usooln a differeis a Lie. Te one who. This s
" nte
ying
8/13/2019 Deobandi Rejects Sahaba Sayings
48/48
www.systemoflife.comwww.ircpk.com
that is written concerning Hadhrat Anas radiallah anhu is not at all Raajih. This is aMarjooh saying. And these types of Marjooh sayings are rejected by
Ahnaaf. [Futuhaat Safdar (3/386)]
From this family conflict between Hayaati and Mamaati Deobandis, this saying is establishedthat Sayyidunah Anas (radiallah anhu) was not known (Ghayr Maroof) in Fiqh and Ijtihaadaccording to Mulla Jeewan al-Hanafi. And these words are absolutely correct according to
Yoonus Numaani Deobandi Mamaati, and absolutely a severe insult according to Master AmeenOkaarvi Hayaati Deobandi. That is why Okaarvi Hayaati rejected this saying of Mulla JeewanHanafi.
However, if until Mulla Jeewan Hanafi is himself not proven to have repented from this insult,until then it can be said that they (i.e. Deobandi Akaabir) are the ones who insulted Sayyidunah
Anas (radiallah anhu).
According to Okaarvi, the objection of Mulla Jeewan Hanafi on Sayyidunah Anas (radiallahanhu) is like the objection of Mirza Ghulaam Ahmed Qaadiyaani. Because the things that Master
Ameen Okaarvi said attributing them to Yoonus Numaani that Mirza Qaadiyaani also used to dothis is, at least, in Futuhaat Safdar not proven from Yoonus Numaani, and Yoonus Numaanionly quoted the saying of Mulla Jeewan!
All the above proofs show that Deoband Reject Sahaba Saying.And Allaah knows best.