Post on 17-Nov-2014
description
Cost Effective Patent Protection
BySomashekar Ramakrishna
BananaIP Counsels
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Cost?
• Indian Patent (from filing to grant)- INR 4,00,000 to INR 6,00,000
• US Patent (from filing to grant)- USD 13,000 to USD 18,000
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Save! But How?
• Basic understanding of Patent Process
• Selecting Patent Professional
• Devising Strategy
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Basic understanding of Patent Process
• Pre-Filing• Filing• Publication• Examination• Prosecution• Grant
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Pre-Filing
• Patent search– Optional but very useful– Identifies relevant prior art– Helps in determining the scope of protection to be sought
• Invention disclosure form– Disclose every aspect of the invention– Disclose what problem does the invention solve– Provide drawings, examples and alternatives to the
invention – Provide the date when the invention will be first disclosed
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Filing
• Patent Application– Form of Application
• Provisional Application (Provisional Specification + Filing documents)
• Non Provisional/Complete Application (Complete specification + Filing documents)
• Priority Date- filing date of the first application in a chain of applications
• Combine similar inventions in one application• The product can be marked as “patent pending” immediately
after filing a patent application.
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Filing
• Entity• In India– Natural Person (75% reduction in govt. fee); or– Legal entity.
• In US– Small entity (50% reduction in govt. fee);– Large entity; or– Micro entity (75% reduction in govt. fee).
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
General Specification Contents
• Title• Technical field• Background • Summary• Brief description of the drawings• Detailed description• Claims• Abstract• Drawings
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
In Specification
• Title– Should embrace all variants of the invention
(apparatus and method)
• Background– Do not criticize the prior art
• Detailed Description– Terms should be consistent– Examples should be present wherever necessary
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
In Specification
• Claims
– Independent claims covering important broad embodiments
– Having varied scope– One set of claims having narrowed scope covering
the exact invention
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Filing
• Application Types• Domestic Application
• Convention Application
• Divisional Application• PCT Application
– International Application– National Stage Application
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Filing
• A provisional application was filed on June 20 20131. When can a complete application be filed?2. Can a PCT application be filed on July 20th 2013?3. Can a US application be filed on June 21st 2013?
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Publication
• Notice to Public (18 months from the priority date)
• Rights start from the date of publication
• Request for early publication- available both in US and India
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Examination
• In India• A Proper request for examination must be filed– Within 48 months from the priority date– By the Applicant– By the interested person (person engaged in or in
promoting, research in the field of the invention)
• In US• A non- complete specification application is
automatically queued up for examination after filing
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Examination
• Delay the Process• In India– File Complete specification followed by a provisional
specification at 12th month– File request for examination at 48th month
• In US– File Complete specification/non-provisional application
followed by a provisional specification at 12th month– Request deferral of examination for 3 years
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Examination
• Expedite the Process• In India– File Request for Examination along with filing the
application– File request for early publication
• In US– File accelerated examination
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Prosecution
• Cost consuming phase
• Inventor participation may reduce the cost involved
• Having claims with varied scope will help reduce the cost
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Prosecution• In US– First office action, second office action, final office
action– Request for continued examination – Response to be filed within 3 months from the
mailing date of the office action (can be extended to 6 months by paying extension fee)
– Examiner interviews– Patent office initiatives• Patent prosecution highway• AFCP 2.0
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Prosecution
• In India– First Examination Report– Prosecution should be completed within 12
months from the FER– Response may be filed early – Second examination report (if there is time)– Request for a hearing
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Grant
• Generally 3-4 years from the date of filing- both in India and US
• To be renewed every year after 2 years from the grant date- In India
• To be renewed at 3.5 years, 7.5 years and 11.5 years from the date of grant- In US
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Selecting Patent Professional
• Scientific background match– Basic Technical degree of the patent professional– Does the patent professional understand the invention?– Does the patent professional appreciate the invention?
• Is he/she asking relevant questions?– First disclosure date– Technical questions on the invention (alternatives, prior arts and so
on)
• Personal compatibility– Does the patent professional understand why you want the protection?– Is the patent professional easily accessible? – Correspond with you on a timely manner
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Devising strategy
• Objective
• Budget allocated
• Consider the shelf life of the product
• Consider the filing options
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Devising strategy
• Company A’s R&D department is in the process of developing a new process and a new apparatus for manufacturing rubber. The R&D department believes that it requires some more time to perfect the invention. Further, it is also believed that the new process and apparatus being developed by the R&D department is set to positively affect the rubber manufacturing process. 1. Should the company file for a patent at this stage?2. If yes, please suggest the cost effective ways for patent protection.
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Devising strategy
• Company A (SME) wants to file for patents for two similar inventions which are believed to be path breaking. The company will have to disclose the inventions to public (through exhibition) within next 5 days. What strategy should the company follow?
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
Devising strategy
• Company B has improved a product (having a shelf life predicted to be not more than 7 months) which is already available in the market. The improvement is not very substantial and is also not patentable. Since the market is crowded, Company B would like to try and keep the competitors away from the market for some time. What should the company do from IP perspective?
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014
THANK YOUFor further information contact
rsshekar@bananaip.comand/or visit
www.bananaip.comBlog: www.sinapseblog.com
Copyright, BananaIP Counsels, 2014