Post on 19-Oct-2014
description
1
Corporate Buy-Sell Agreements:Ticking Time Bombs or Reasonable Resolutions?
Z. Christopher Mercer, ASA, CFAMercer Capital » 901.685.2120 » mercerc@mercercapital.com
Celebrate the Past…Focus on the Future
2
You’ll never think about buy-sell
agreements the same way again
after this presentation
3
Three Things To Remember Today
1. Getting Agreement Now! • It is vital to get agreement among the parties now
2. Six Defining Elements
• There are six defining elements that must be in every buy-sell agreement if you want the valuation process and, therefore, the agreement, to work
3. Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
• We have a tool that can help you and/or your clients. Whenever you encounter a buy-sell agreement, you want to review the checklist while you review the buy-sell agreement
4
1.Getting Agreement – Now
2. The Six Defining Elements of Process Buy-Sell Agreements
3. The Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
5
Getting Agreement -- Now
6
Getting Agreement – Now
• Buy-Sell Agreements are agreements by and between the shareholders (or equity partners of whatever legal description) of a privately owned business and, perhaps, the business itself
• They establish the mechanism for the purchase of stock following the death (or other adverse changes) of one of the owners
• In the case of corporate joint ventures, they also establish the value for break-ups or for circumstances calling for one corporate venture partner to buy out the other partner
7
Getting Agreement – Now
1. Require agreement at a point in time
2. Relate to transactions that will or may occur at future points in time
3. Define the conditions that cause the buy-sell provisions to be “triggered”
4. Determine the price(s) at which the specified future transactions will occur
8
Remember This
• For professional advisors to business owners:– Use the almost universal need to improve buy-
sellagreements to help your clients and other
referralsources
• For business owners:– Get the buy-sell agreement
– Read it
– Review it with other shareholders and advisors
9
1. Getting Agreement – Now
2.The Six Defining Elements of Process Buy-Sell Agreements
3. The Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
10
The Six Defining Elements of Process Buy-Sell Agreements
1. Standard of Value 4. Qualifications of Appraisers
2. Level of Value 5. Appraisal Standards
3. The “as of” Date 6. Funding Mechanism
11
Types of Buy-Sell Agreements
1. Fixed price agreements
2. Formula agreements
3. Shotgun agreements
4. Rights of first refusal (ROFR)
5. Process agreements
12
1. Fixed Price Agreements
• Advantages
–Easy to understand
–Easy to negotiate
–Inexpensive
13
1. Fixed Price Agreements
• Disadvantages
– Parties seldom update the fixed prices, even over periods of many years
– Inequities are almost certainly a result of out-of-date fixed price agreements
14
• Disadvantages (continued)– While it is easy to set an initial price (indeed, it may
be set by a transaction), it can be difficult to reset as time passes and interests diverge
– The longer period of time between updates to fixed price buy-sell agreements, the greater the potential for a divergence of the interests of the various parties
– You are betting that the other guy(s) will die first!
1. Fixed Price Agreements
15
1. Fixed Price Agreements
Out of date when inked! Need I say more?
Recommendation:If you have one, update it now!
16
2. Formula Agreements
• State a single formula to be applied to balance sheet and/or income statement metrics
• Examples– Multiple of EBITDA – (5 x EBITDA)
– Multiple of Pre-tax Income – (6 x Pre-tax Income)
– Book Value• “Shareholders’ equity per the audited financial statements at
the end of the fiscal year immediately preceding the valuation date.”
– Multiple of Book Value
17
2. Formula Agreements
• Advantages (like fixed price agreements)– Easy to understand– Easy to negotiate– Inexpensive (no appraisers)
• Disadvantages– No formula selected at a point in time provides
reasonable and realistic valuations over time – Changes occur in companies, industries, local,
regional, national and world economies, some or all of which can impact the “true value” of an enterprise relative to any set formula
18
Recommendation
If you have a formula agreement, have someone calculate the formula result as if there
were a trigger event now
And then deal with any issues that arise
2. Formula Agreements
19
3. Shotgun Agreements
• One side makes an offer
– Other side has choice to sell at that price
– In the alternative, if other side decides not to sell: • May have the right to buy• Does have the obligation to buy
20
3. Shotgun Agreements
• Concept is that the initial offering side (which
will that be?) virtually has to name a
“reasonable” price, i.e., one at which he would
be willing to buy or sell
• Assumes both parties have equal financial
capacities and knowledge about the business
and its prospects to engage in either a buy or a
sell transaction
21
3. Shotgun Agreements
• Advantage– Pressure on offering party to establish a “fair” price
• Disadvantages– Parties seldom have equal financial capacities and
may have different knowledge about the business
– Minority shareholders may be at a disadvantage • Easier for a 90% shareholder to acquire 10% than vice-versa
• Smaller shareholder, unable to swing the big deal, may have to offer lower price than “fair” in order to insure capability to either buy or sell, and therefore, receive a lower price on sale
22
4. Rights of First Refusal• Absent any other provisions, a right of first refusal
agreement may act like a buy-sell agreement
– Third party offer obtained by one shareholder
– Who has to offer shares to the other shareholders (time passes) and, perhaps, the company (time passes)
– If the other shareholders or the company do not buy on the same terms and conditions, then the third party may purchase the shares
– If third party purchases, normally becomes subject to the ROFR agreement
– If no one buys, there was no transaction
23
4. Rights of First Refusal
• Advantages– Simple and requires little thought
• Disadvantages– ROFRs actually act as restrictive elements
• Discourage third party bidding
• Favor the remaining shareholders who will take advantage of low offers and ignore high offers that are unlikely to be forthcoming
– Not really buy-sell agreements at all, since there is no assurance that there will be a transaction
24
5. Process Buy-Sell Agreements
• A buy-sell agreement provides a valuation process employing one or more appraisers
• Value is determined by the appraisers in a manner defined in the buy-sell agreement
• Two types of process buy-sell agreements:– Multiple appraiser
– Single appraiser
25
Multiple Appraiser
Agreement
Two and a Tie-Breaker
26
Multiple Appraiser
Agreement
Two and a Determiner
27
Multiple Appraiser
Agreement
Two and a Back-Breaker
28
Multiple Appraiser
Agreement
Two and Let’s Talk
29
Multiple Appraiser Agreements
Advantages1. Provide a defined structure
2. All parties know, at least generally, what the process will be in advance
3. Fairly commonly known and generally understood by attorneys (who know the problems with fixed price and formula agreements)
4. Illusory Benefit – False sense that “my appraiser” will protect “my interests”
Disadvantages1. Price not determined now2. Potential for dissatisfaction with the
process for all parties3. Danger of advocacy4. Uncertainty over what happens at trigger
event 5. Uncertainty over final price if the process
is invoked6. Problems with any other aspect of the
operation of the agreements are deferred until a trigger event
7. Expensive8. Time-consuming9. Distracting for management10. Potentially devastating for affected
shareholders and their families
30
Single Appraiser
Agreement
Select & Value at Trigger Event
31
Single Appraiser Agreement Select & Value at Trigger Event
Advantages
1. Defined Structure
2. Considerable uncertainty is eliminated upon agreement
3. Cost is reasonably known
32
Single Appraiser Agreement Select & Value at Trigger Event
Disadvantages
Single Appraiser – Select & Value at Trigger Event
1. Price not determined now x
2. Potential for dissatisfaction with the process for all parties x
3. Danger of advocacy x
4. Uncertainty over what will happen when a trigger event occurs x
5. Uncertainty over final price if the process is invoked x
6. Problems or issues with definition of value, qualifications of appraisers, or any other aspects of the operation of the agreements are deferred until a trigger event – when the interests of the parties are adverse
x
7. Expensive
8. Time-consuming
9. Distracting for management
10. Potentially devastating for affected shareholders and their families
33
Single Appraiser
Agreement
Select Now & Value at Trigger
Event
34
Single Appraiser Agreement Select Now & Value at Trigger Event
Advantages
1. Defined structure
2. Some uncertainty eliminated
3. Cost reasonably known
4. Eliminates future uncertainty of selecting an appraiser
35
Single Appraiser Agreement Select Now & Value at Trigger Event
Disadvantages
Single Appraiser – Select & Value at Trigger Event
Single Appraiser – Select Now & Value at Trigger
Event
1. Price not determined now x x
2. Potential for dissatisfaction with the process for all parties x x
3. Danger of advocacy x Minimized
4. Uncertainty over what will happen when a trigger event occurs x x
5. Uncertainty over final price if the process is invoked x x
6. Problems or issues with definition of value, qualifications of appraisers, or any other aspects of the operation of the agreements are deferred until a trigger event – when the interests of the parties are adverse
x x
7. Expensive
8. Time-consuming
9. Distracting for management
10. Potentially devastating for affected shareholders and their families
36
Single Appraiser
Agreement
Select Now,Value Now
37
Single Appraiser Agreement Select Now & Value Now
Advantages
1. Selected appraiser viewed as independent
2. Appraiser’s valuation process is seen by all parties at the outset
3. Appraiser’s conclusion is known at outset and has established a baseline price for the agreement
4. Because process is observed at the outset, all parties know what will happen when trigger event occurs
5. Because the appraiser must interpret the “words on the pages” in conducting the initial appraisal, any issues regarding lack of clarity of valuation-defining terms will be resolved
6. Selected appraiser must maintain independence with respect to process and render future valuations consistent with terms of agreement and with prior reports
7. Subsequent appraisals, either annually or at trigger events, should be less time-consuming and expensive than other alternatives
8. Parties should gain confidence in the process
9. Parties will always know the current value for the buy-sell agreement (helpful for planning all-around)
10. Appraisers’ knowledge of the company and its industry will grow over time, enhancing confidence for all parties with the process
11. Creates a means of maintaining pricing for other transactions, thereby enhancing “the market” for a company’s shares
38
Single Appraiser Agreement Select Now & Value Now
Disadvantages
Single Appraiser – Select & Value at Trigger Event
Single Appraiser – Select Now & Value at Trigger
Event
Single Appraiser – Select Now, Value Now
1. Price not determined now x x
2. Potential for dissatisfaction with the process for all parties x x Minimized
3. Danger of advocacy x Minimized Minimized
4. Uncertainty over what will happen when a trigger event occurs x x Minimized
5. Uncertainty over final price if the process is invoked x x Minimized
6. Problems or issues with definition of value, qualifications of appraisers, or any other aspects of the operation of the agreements are deferred until a trigger event – when the interests of the parties are adverse
x x Minimized
7. Expensive
8. Time-consuming
9. Distracting for management
10. Potentially devastating for affected shareholders and their families
39
A Hybrid: Single Appraiser Agreement with Multiple
Appraiser Options
• Retain a single appraiser like in the Single Appraiser option
• Call this appraiser the “Third Appraiser” for now
• The “Third Appraiser” provides annual (or periodic) appraisal to update the buy-sell agreement– Just like the single appraiser option where the appraiser is
selected in advance
40
A Hybrid: Single Appraiser Agreement with Multiple
Appraiser Options
• In the event of a trigger event:– Step 1. “Third Appraiser” provides an appraisal.
If both sides agree, price is set
– Step 2. If there is disagreement, company retains an appraiser (“First Appraiser”) and shareholder retains another (“Second Appraiser”). At the time of their retention, First and Second Appraisers are provided copies of Third Appraiser’s appraisal and are provided access to him or her
41
A Hybrid: Single Appraiser Agreement with Multiple
Appraiser Options
• In the event of a trigger event:– Step 3. Reconciliation can come about in two ways:
• Option 1 – Appraisal Review by “First” and “Second” Appraisers– Formal, Standard 3 Reviews– Informal Reviews, Provide Advice, Recommendations to the “Third
Appraiser”– “Third Appraiser” considers all input, then finalizes report, which
becomes the buy-sell value
• Option 2 – “First” and “Second” Appraisers provide appraisals – Just like in the Multi-Appraiser Process– Have benefit of the “Third Appraiser’s” report in advance– Process can specify how the three are averaged or considered in
final price
42
Single Appraiser Agreement with
Multiple Appraiser Options
Appraisal Review
43
Single Appraiser Agreement with
Multiple Appraiser Options
Additional Appraisals
44
A Hybrid: Single Appraiser Agreement with Multiple
Appraiser Options
• Advantages
– Built-in disagreement resolution process
– PLUS all the advantages of Single Appraiser – Select Now, Value Now
A Hybrid: Single Appraiser Agreement with Multiple
Appraiser Options
DisadvantagesMultiple
Appraiser
Single Appraiser – Select & Value at Trigger Event
Single Appraiser – Select Now & Value
at Trigger Event
Single Appraiser – Select Now,
Value Now Hybrid
1. Price not determined now Maybe
2. Potential for dissatisfaction with the process for all parties
Minimized Minimized further
3. Danger of advocacy Minimized Minimized Minimized further
4. Uncertainty over what will happen when a trigger event occurs
Minimized Minimized further
5. Uncertainty over final price if the process is invoked
Minimized Minimized further
6. Problems or issues with definition of value, qualifications of appraisers, or any other aspects of the operation of the agreements are deferred until a trigger event – when the interests of the parties are definitely adverse
Minimized Minimized further
7. Expensive Potentially
8. Time-consuming Potentially
9. Distracting for management Potentially
10. Potentially devastating for affected shareholders and their families
Minimized
46
The Defining Elements of Process Buy-Sell Agreements
1. Standard of Value 4. Qualifications of Appraisers
2. Level of Value 5. Appraisal Standards
3. The “as of” Date 6. Funding Mechanism
47
Defining Element #1 – Standard of Value
• Normally “fair market value”– Willing buyer, willing seller…. but buyers of what?
• “Fair value”– A defined term under state law and a defined term, of sorts,
under accounting rules
• “Investment value”– From the perspective of whom?
• “The Value”
• “Going Concern Value”
• And on and on and on…
48
Defining Element #2 – Level of Value
• Which level?
– In other words, the value of what?
• Should be specific
– Refer to specific language and specific
page in book (preferably mine!)
49
Defining Element #2 – Level of Value
50
Defining Element #2 – Level of Value
Price we hope to get if we sell the company together
Price the rest of us can reasonably pay if we have to buy out someone else
“Fair market value of the (minority) interest”
51
Defining Element #2 – Level of Value
$100 Per Share$100 Per Share
$60 Per Share
$140 Per Share
52
Defining Element #3 – The “As Of” Date
• Defines the situation at the Company,
• within the industry and
• national economy, and
• the pricing from guideline companies
• and comparable transactions
How could this be an issue?
53
Defining Element #4 – Qualifications
Qualifications of appraisers
• Education • Valuation training
• Credentials • Nature of firm’s business
• Experience in appraisal • Industry experience
• Size of the firm • Reputation
• Continuing education • Compliance with professional standards
54
Defining Element #5 – Appraisal Standards to be Followed
• The Institute of Business Appraisers Business Valuation Standards and Rules of Professional Conduct
• ASA Business Valuation Standards
• Principals of Appraisal Practice and Code of Ethics of the ASA
• Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice
• Professional Standards of NACVA
• Other professional standards? Specify
55
USPAP Changes
• SR 9-2(e)(iii)– An appraiser must….Identify the characteristics of the subject
company that are relevant to the standard (type) and definition of value and intended use of the appraisal, including…
– All buy-sell and option agreements, investment letter stock restrictions, restrictive corporate charter or partnership agreement clauses, and similar features or factors that may have an influence on value.
• SR 9-4(c)– An appraiser must, when necessary for credible assignment
results, analyze the effect on value, if any, of buy-sell and option agreements, investment letter stock restrictions, restrictive corporate charter or partnership agreement clauses, and similar features or factors that may influence value.
56
USPAP Changes
• SR 9-2(e)(v)
– An appraiser must….Identify the characteristics of the subject
company that are relevant to the standard (type) and definition of
value and intended use of the appraisal, including…
– The extent to which the interest is marketable and/or liquid.
• SR 9-4(d)
– An appraiser must, when necessary for credible assignment
results, analyze the effect on value, if any, of the extent to which
the interest appraised contains elements of ownership control
and is marketable and/or liquid
– Comment: An appraiser must analyze factors such as holding
period, interim benefits, and the difficulty and cost of marketing
the subject interest.
57
Defining Element #6 – Funding Mechanism
• Who buys?– Other shareholders– Company– Other shareholders
and/or company
• Life insurance
• Adequacy of funding
• Nature of mechanism– Cash (is there a
sinking fund?)– Notes
• Down payment• Terms• Interest rate• Security
What does your buy-sell agreement say about the treatment of life insurance
proceeds in the event of the death of a shareholder subject to it?
58
1. Getting Agreement – Now
2. The Six Defining Elements of Process Buy-Sell Agreements
3.The Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
59
The purpose of the Buy-Sell Audit is to enable a
business owner(s), with the assistance of
accountants, attorneys, business consultants, and
appraisers, as necessary and appropriate, to
express the opinion that his company’s
buy-sell agreement(s) fairly reflect the wishes and
desires of the owners subject to it, in accordance
with good business practices and common sense.
All the shareholders and the company itself rely on
this “audit” in their personal and corporate planning
60
Buy-Sell Audit
• The Buy-Sell Audit is forward-looking and addresses questions like:
– Is there a reasonable probability that the agreement will operate to effectuate a reasonable transaction when trigger events occur?
– Are all shareholders who should be subject to the agreement parties to it?
– Do the shareholders who are parties to the agreement understand how the agreement will operate to determine prices and terms for future transactions?
– Has the agreement been reviewed by legal counsel to ensure compliance with applicable laws and statutes?
– Are the six defining elements of value as developed in this book clearly specified?
– Will the pricing mechanism provide a reasonable value if and when trigger events occur in the future?
– Is the funding mechanism in place and workable?
61
Structure of the Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
1. Nature, size and ownership of equity
2. Trigger events for consideration
3. Fixed Price Agreements
4. Formula Agreements
5. Six Defining Elements for Process Agreements
6. Multiple Appraiser & Single Appraiser Agreements
7. Financial Statements / Corporate Information
8. Process Timetables
9. Who Bears the Cost of the Appraisal(s)?
10. Tax-Pass Through Entity Appraisal Issues
62
Buy-Sell Audit Checklist Nature, Size & Ownership of Equity
• Parties to consider in discussions about the buy-sell agreement?
• Multiple classes of ownership?
• Groups of shareholders and relative ownership maintenance?
• Age of shareholders?
• Active vs. passive shareholders?
• State law considerations?
• Restrictions under loan agreement?
• ROFRs?
63
Buy-Sell Audit Checklist Trigger Events for Consideration
• Q Quits• F is Fired• R Retires• D Disabled• D Death
• D Divorce• B Bankruptcy
64
Buy-Sell Audit Checklist Fixed Price & Formula Agreements
• How do you resolve differences?– With a process?
65
Buy-Sell Audit Checklist Six Defining Elements for Process
Agreements
1. Standard of Value
2. Level of Value
3. The “as of” date
4. Appraiser Qualifications
5. Appraisal Standards
6. Funding Mechanisms
66
Funding MechanismWhat about Life Insurance Treatment
for Valuation Purposes?
Harry Proceeds are a Funding Vehicle Company (Estate) Sam
1 Stock Ownership (Shares) 100.0 50.0 50.02 Stock Ownership (%) 100.0% 50.0% 50.0%3 Pre and Post Life Insurance Value ($m) $10,000.0 $5,000.0 $5,000.04 Life Insurance Proceeds $6,000.05 Repurchase Liability ($5,000.0)6 Post-Life-Insurance Value $11,000.0
7 Repurchase Stock ($5,000.0) $5,000.08 Retire / Give Up Stock (50.0) (50.0)9 Remaining Stock 50.0 0.0 50.0
10 New Stock Ownership (%) 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%11 Post-Life Insurance Value of Co. $11,000.0 $0.0 $11,000.012 Post Life Insurance Proceeds $5,000.013 Net Change in Value from Repurchase $1,000.0
67
Funding MechanismWhat about Life Insurance Treatment
for Valuation Purposes?
Harry Proceeds are a Corporate Asset Company (Estate) Sam
1 Stock Ownership (Shares) 100.0 50.0 50.02 Stock Ownership (%) 100.0% 50.0% 50.0%3 Pre-Life Insurance Value ($m) $10,000.0 $5,000.0 $5,000.04 Life Insurance Proceeds ($m) $6,000.0 $3,000.0 $3,000.05 Post-Life Insurance Value ($m) $16,000.0 $8,000.0 $8,000.06 Repurchase Liability ($8,000.0)7 Post-Life-Insurance Value $8,000.0
8 Repurchase Stock ($8,000.0) $8,000.09 Retire / Give Up Stock (50.0) (50.0)
10 Remaining Stock 50.0 0.0 50.011 New Stock Ownership (%) 100.0% 0.0% 100.0%12 Post-Life Insurance Value of Co. $8,000.0 $0.0 $8,000.013 Post Life Insurance Proceeds $8,000.014 Net Change in Value from Repurchase ($2,000.0)
68
Buy-Sell Audit Checklist Financial Statements / Corporate
information
• Financial statements to be used
– Most recent fiscal year
– Trailing 12 months at most recent quarter-
end
• Information “known” or “reasonably
knowable” as of the valuation date
69
Buy-Sell Audit Checklist Process Timetables
• When is appraisal due from appraiser?– Will a draft be supplied to all interested parties?
• Access of parties to talk to appraiser
• What happens to valuation date in the event of avoidable or unavoidable delays?– No change– Interest beyond ____ days– Reset the date
• Is appraisal conclusion binding?– Dispute resolution process
70
Process Activities (in days)
Multiple Appraisers
Single Appraiser – Select Now,
Value Now Hybrid
Trigger Event OccursTime to React
Pick Appraiser(s)Provide Appraisal(s)
Review Appraisals
01
306015
030609030
010
3015
0300
6030
010
3015
0300
6030
Earliest Time to Resolution 106 210 46 120 46 120
Select Other Appraiser(s)Reviews by Appraisers
Prepare Additional Appraisal(s)
Review Appraisals/ReviewsAgree on Conclusions
Finalize Transaction
30
3015150
60
60303030
30
3015150
60
60303030
Additional Time for Process 90 210 0 0 90 210
Potential Time to Resolution 196 420 46 120 136 330
Process Timetables
71
Buy-Sell Audit Checklist Who Bears the Cost of the Appraisal(s)?
• Cost of appraisal process– Both sides bear own expenses?
– Company pays for process?
– Fairness to minority shareholders?
72
1.Getting Agreement – Now
2. The Six Defining Elements of Process Buy-Sell Agreements
3. The Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
73
It is essential for the parties to discuss and reach agreement now as to how the agreement will work because when a
trigger event happens, the interests of the parties will almost certainly diverge
74
1. Getting Agreement – Now
2.The Six Defining Elements of Process Buy-Sell Agreements
3. The Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
75
There are six defining elements that must
be in every process buy-sell agreement if
you want the valuation process and,
therefore, the agreement, to work
76
1. Getting Agreement – Now
2. The Six Defining Elements of Process Buy-Sell Agreements
3.The Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
77
There is a tool to help you …
The Buy-Sell Audit Checklist
78
The One Percent Solution
79
Two Types of Wealth
Liquid Wealth
Wealth (asset) management
vs.
Pre-liquid Wealth
Pre-liquid asset management
80
American Economic ReviewProfessors Moskowitz and Vissing-Jorgenson (Vol. 4, 2002)
We find investment in private equity to be extremely
concentrated. About 75% of all private equity is owned by
households for whom it constitutes at least half of their total net
worth. Furthermore, households with entrepreneurial equity invest
on average more than 70% of their private holdings in a single
private company in which they have an active management interest.
Despite this dramatic lack of diversification, the average
annual return to all equity in privately held companies is rather
unimpressive. Private equity returns are on average no higher
than the market return on all publicly traded equity. [emphasis added]
81
The One Percent Solution
Allocate a percentage of value for the illiquid assets under management to provide the budget necessary
to manage wealth
Liquid Assets
1% of assets under management, +/-, depending on asset category
Pre-Liquid Assets
0.5% to 2% of value (AUM) for businesses depending on value
82
The One Percent Solution for Managing Wealth in a Closely Held
BusinessAssumed Pre-Tax
Income ($m)
Assumed Valuation Multiple
Estimated Value of Business
($m)
Management Fee as % of
Value
Budget for Investment
Mgt ($m)
Management Fee as % of
Earnings
$1,250 4.0 $5,000 2.00% $100 8.0%
$2,222 4.5 $10,000 1.50% $150 6.8%
$4,000 5.0 $20,000 1.00% $200 5.0%
$8,333 6.0 $50,000 0.75% $375 4.5%
$14,286 7.0 $100,000 0.50% $500 3.5%
$62,500 8.0 $500,000 0.25% $1,250 2.0%
83
Current Role of Wealth Manager
Current Role of the
Business OwnerPhase
Investment Principles
Liquid Wealth
Pre-Liquid Wealth
1 Set Objectives Yes Maybe Sometimes
2 Establish Strategies Yes Maybe Sometimes
3 Regular Monitoring Yes No Seldom
4 Constantly
Enhancing
Yes No Occasionally
5 Review Re:
Reallocating
Yes No Seldom
84
One Percent Solution Activities
• Life insurance funding • Wealth manager compensation • Annual valuations and monitoring value growth• Buy-Sell agreement pricing (per annual
valuations)• Annual legal reviews• Estate planning• Financial planning• “Make ready” consulting projects
85
What is the Yield/Return …
on an Investment?
(Dividends + Change in Price)
Beginning Price
86
What is the Yield/Return …
In a Business?
(Dividends + Change in Price)
Beginning Price
87
Critical Valuation Issues
Growth
Margin
Activity
Financing
Y i e l d
Return on Capital
Valuation :: Essential Element of Monitoring Performance
Value = Earnings x Multiple
88
PrivateCo Performance Relative to Market Indices
Wealth Management Scenario #1
0%
50%
100%
150%
200%
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Private Company
S&P 500
Dow Jones
NASDAQ
89
PrivateCo PerformanceRelative to Market Indices
Wealth Management Scenario #2
0%
50%
100%
150%
200%
250%
300%
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Private Company
S&P 500
Dow Jones
NASDAQ
90
A Word About Recurring Valuation
• Numerous qualified, independent business valuation firms – Investment banking firms?
– Business brokers?
• Look for experience of the firm and credentials (ASA, ABV, CFA are preferred)
• Ability to value over multiple periods, reconciling value changes with changes in company, industry and markets – with credibility
• Investment in recurring valuations
• Resource: www.appraisers.org (American Society of Appraisers)
91
How to Obtain Liquidity and Diversification Without Selling
ALL the Business
• Dividends
• Special dividends
• Dividend recapitalizations
• Stock repurchases
• Leveraged stock repurchases
• Combined special dividends and redemption (with leverage)
• Partial management buy-in (installment sale)
• Management buy-in with outside equity
• Private equity investment
• Private equity recapitalization
• ESOP (Service Companies)
• Private merger with partial redemption
92
Too Many Business Owners Put The Majority of Their Eggs in Only One Basket – This Can Be a
Mistake
93
Is There Such a Thing as a Free Lunch?
• Many One Percent Solution “costs”
pay for themselves
• Others are added back to
“normalized earnings” in valuation
94
Helpful Resources
MERCER CAPITAL website
• www.mercercapital.com
– Library of articles
– Levels of Value charts
– Access to complimentary resources
– Sign up for newsletters, including:• Value AddedTM (e-mail)
• Value MattersTM (e-mail)
• The Transaction AdvisorTM (e-mail)
For a full listing of available resources, please see www.mercercapital.com
95
Will you ever think about buy-sell
agreements the same way again?
96
Other Resources
97
MERCER CAPTIAL5860 Ridgeway Center Parkway, Suite 400 • Memphis, TN 38120
901.685.2120 (P) • 901.685.2199 (F)
www.mercercapital.com
Questions?
Z. Christopher Mercer, ASA, CFA
mercerc@mercercapital.com
901.685.2120