Post on 03-Feb-2018
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
1/13
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 8 lb 8? Shjd FI #59993
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
2/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
7 Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
Ymfs ahttdr ohad lk blr mdhrfkj lk Ahy 88, 7384. Ymd Olurt mhs olksfidrdi
tmd _tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt, hs hadkidi, hki hnn lrhn hki wrfttdk lgedotflks, grfdbs,
hki olaadkts rdodfvdi rdjhrifkj tmd prlplsdi _dttndadkt, hki mhs rdvfdwdi tmd
dktfrd rdolri. Ymd Olurt mhs5 (8) prdvflusny jrhktdi prdnfafkhry hpprlvhn lb tmd
_tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt0 (7) gddk fkblradi gy tmd _dttndadkt Hiafkfstrhtlr tmht
kltfod lb tmd _dttndadkt mhs gddk jfvdk tl tmd _dttndadkt Onhss (hs idbfkdi gdnlw)0
(?) mdni h bfkhn bhfrkdss mdhrfkj ht wmfom hafof ourfhd, lgedotlrs, hki hnn phrtfds
hppdhrdi gy tmdfr oluksdn hki ht wmfom tmd Olurt hbblridi hafof ourfhdhki onhss
adagdrs tmd lpplrtukfty tl lgedot tl tmd _tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt (Hpprlvhn
Mdhrfkj)0 (9) rdodfvdi hki rdvfdwdi Snhfktfbbs Altflk blr Bfkhn Hpprlvhn lb tmd
_dttndadkt, Idbdkihkts Elfkidr fk supplrt lb Altflk blr Bfkhn Hpprlvhn lb tmd
_dttndadkt, hki hnn phpdrs bfndi fk olkkdotflk tmdrdwftm, fkonuifkj dvfidkod,
smlwfkj wmy tmd prlplsdi sdttndadkt fs bhfr, hidquhtd, hki fk tmd gdst fktdrdsts lb
tmd rdprdsdktdi onhss0 hki (4) olksfidrdi hnn ltmdr hrjuadkts hki sugafssflks fk
olkkdotflk wftm tmd prlplsdi sdttndadkt.
Gy lridr ihtdi Ahy 89, 7384, tmd Olurt5 (h) jrhktdi tmd phrtfds _dolki
_tfpunhtflk tl Hadki tmd _dttndadkt Hjrddadkt0 (g) jrhktdi pnhfktfbbs Altflk tl
Fkordhsd tmd Hwhris tl Gusfkdss Lpplrtukfty Onhfahkts0 (o) jrhktdi Snhfktfbbs
Altflk blr Bfkhn Hpprlvhn lb Onhss Hotflk _dttndadkt0 hki (i) jrhktdi fk phrt
Snhfktfbbs oluksdns Altflk blr Httlrkdys Bdds hki Dxpdksds.
Jlli ohusd hppdhrfkj,
FY F_ MDWDGV LWIDWDI, HIETIJDI HKI IDOWDDI H_ BLNNLZ_5
8.
Ymd Olurt, blr purplsds lb tmfs Bfkhn Euijadkt hki Lridr lb Ifsafsshn,hilpts tmd idbfkftflks sdt blrtm fk tmd _tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt (_tfpunhtflk lr
_dttndadkt) (I`t. 64), hki hnn tdras usdi mdrdfk smhnn mhvd tmd shad adhkfkjs hs
sdt blrtm fk tmd _tfpunhtflk, ukndss ltmdrwfsd sdt blrtm mdrdfk.
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 7 lb 8? Shjd FI #59998
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
3/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
? Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
7. Ymd Olurt mhs eurfsifotflk lvdr tmd sugedot ahttdr lb tmfs Hotflk, tmd
Snhfktfbbs, tmd _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdrs, hki Idbdkihkts Mdrghnfbd Fktdrkhtflkhn lb
Hadrfoh, Mdrghnfbd Fktdrkhtflkhn, Fko., hki Mdrghnfbd Nti. (olnndotfvdny,
Mdrghnfbd).
?. Sursuhkt tl Wunds 7?(h), 7?(g)(7), hki 7?(g)(?) lb tmd Bdidrhn Wunds lb
Ofvfn Srlodiurd, hki slndny blr purplsds lb tmd _dttndadkt, tmd Olurt mdrdgy bfkhnny
odrtfbfds h Wund 7?(g)(7) hki Wund 7?(g)(?) _dttndadkt Onhss, brla wmfom dxonusflks
wdrd pdrafttdi, idbfkdi hs5 hnn pdrslks wml hrd lr wdrd Mdrghnfbd adagdrs lr
ifstrfgutlrs fk tmd Tkftdi _thtds ht hky tfad brla Hprfn 8, 7336 tl Idodagdr 7,
7389. Dxonuidi brla tmd _dttndadkt Onhss hrd tmd Idbdkihkts, tmdfr dapnlydds,
bhafny adagdrs, hki hky adagdr wml mhs gddk h adagdr lb Mdrghnfbds
Srdsfidkts Ydha, Blukidrs Ofrond, Omhfrahks Onug, Afnnflkhfrd Ydha, lr JDY
Ydha. Hnsl dxonuidi brla tmd _dttndadkt Onhss hrd hnn Mdrghnfbd adagdrs lr
ifstrfgutlrs wml mhvd hjrddi tl gd sugedot tl tmd hrgftrhtflk prlvfsflks lb tmd
Hrgftrhtflk Hjrddadkt blr Ifsputds Gdtwddk Adagdrs hki Mdrghnfbd olkthfkdi fk
tmd Adagdr Hppnfohtflk Hjrddadkt rdvfsdi iurfkj lr hbtdr _dptdagdr 738?.
(_dttndadkt Onhss) Zftm rdspdot tl tmd Wund 7? (g)(7) hki Wund 7?(g)(?)
_dttndadkt Onhss, tmfs Olurt bfkis, slndny blr tmd purplsds lb tmd _dttndadkt, tmht tmd
prdrdqufsftds blr h onhss hotflk ukidr Wunds 7?(h) hki (g)(?) mhvd gddk shtfsbfdi.
9. Ymd khadi pnhfktfbbs fidktfbfdi hs phrtfds tl tmd Bfrst Hadkidi
Olapnhfkt smhnn sdrvd hs Onhss Wdprdsdkthtfvds lb tmd _dttndadkt Onhssds. Ymd nhw
bfras lb Blndy Gdzd` Gdmnd & Ourtfs, NNS hki Bhgfhk & Ondkidkfk, S.O. smhnn
olktfkud tl sdrvd hs Onhss Oluksdn.4. Ymd idbfkftflks lb tmd prlplsdi onhssds fk tmd Bfrst Hadkidi Olapnhfkt
hrd mdrdgy hadkidi tl gd tmd shad hs tmd _dttndadkt Onhssds bfkhnny odrtfbfdi hglvd.
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd ? lb 8? Shjd FI #59997
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
4/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
9 Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
2. Ymd Olurt bfkis tmht tmd blra, olktdkt, hki ifstrfgutflk (gy fkifvfiuhn
kltfod gy d-ahfn lr ifrdot ahfn tl hnn _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdrs wml oluni gd
fidktfbfdi tmrlujm rdhslkhgnd dbblrts) lb tmd Kltfod lb Srlplsdi _dttndadkt, tmd
Onhfa Blra, hki tmd _uaahry Kltfod hs prlvfidi gy tmd phrtfds (Onhss Kltfod)
wdrd hidquhtd hki rdhslkhgnd hki olkstftutdi tmd gdst kltfod prhotfohgnd ukidr tmd
ofrouasthkods tl hnn pdrslks bfttfkj wftmfk tmd idbfkftflk lb tmd _dttndadkt Onhss.
Ymd Onhss Kltfod bunny shtfsbfdi iud prlodss rdqufrdadkts, hki olkstftutdi hidquhtd
kltfod lb5 (h) tmd khturd lb tmd ohsd0 (g) tmd sdttndadkt tdras hs sdt blrtm fk tmd
_tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt0 (o) tmd Bfkhn Hpprlvhn Mdhrfkj0 (o) Onhss Oluksdn's
fktdktflk tl sdd` httlrkdys bdds hki dxpdksds hki olapdkshtflk blr tmd khadi
Snhfktfbbs0 (i) dhom Onhss Adagdrs rfjmt tl dxonuid mfa lr mdrsdnb brla tmd
_dttndadkt Onhss0 hki (d) dhom Onhss Adagdrs rfjmt tl lgedot tl tmd prlplsdi
sdttndadkt hki tl Onhss Oluksdns hppnfohtflk blr httlrkdys bdds hki dxpdksds. Ymd
Onhss Kltfod mhs gddk prlvfidi tl tmd _dttndadkt Onhss (hs idbfkdi hglvd fk
olkblrafty wftm tmd Idodagdr 7, 7389 Srdnfafkhry Hpprlvhn Lridr (I`t. Kl. 834).
Ghsdi lk tmd dvfidkod hki ltmdr ahtdrfhn sugafttdi fk olkeukotflk wftm tmd Bfkhn
Hpprlvhn mdhrfkj, tmd blra, olktdkt, hki ifstrfgutflk lb tmd Onhss Kltfod bunny
olapnfdi wftm Wund 7? lb tmd Bdidrhn Wunds lb Ofvfn Srlodiurd, tmd Tkftdi _thtds
Olkstftutflk, hki hky ltmdr hppnfohgnd nhw. Ymd Olurt bfkis tmht hpprlprfhtd kltfod
whs jfvdk gy Idbdkihkts tl hnn hpprlprfhtd _thtd hki Bdidrhn lbbfofhns ukidr 7=
T._.O. 8:84(h), hki tmht kl lgedotflks wdrd bfndi.
:. Ymd Olurt hpprlvds tmd _dttndadkt sdt blrtm fk tmd _tfpunhtflk hki dhom
lb tmd rdndhsds hki ltmdr tdras hs bhfr, rdhslkhgnd, hki hidquhtd tl tmd _dttnfkjShrtfds. Ymd _dttnfkj Shrtfds smhnn olksuaahtd tmd _dttndadkt fk hoolrihkod wftm fts
tdras hs sdt blrtm fk tmd _tfpunhtflk.
=. Ymd Olurt hnsl bfkis tmht _dttndadkt klw wfnn hvlfi hiiftflkhn hki
pltdktfhnny sugsthktfhn nftfjhtflk olsts, hki idnhy hki rfs`s fb tmd Shrtfds olktfkudi tl
nftfjhtd tmd ohsd. Hbtdr olksfidrfkj tmd prlspdotfvd hki alkdthry rdnfdb prlvfidi hs
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 9 lb 8? Shjd FI #5999?
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
5/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
4 Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
phrt lb tmd _dttndadkt fk nfjmt lb tmd omhnndkjds plsdi gy olktfkudi nftfjhtflk, tmd
Olurt olkonuids tmht Onhss Oluksdn sdourdi sfjkfbfohkt rdnfdb blr Onhss Adagdrs.
6. Ymd Olurt bfkis tmht tmd _dttndadkt mhs gddk rdhomdi gdohusd lb
fkblradi hki klk-olnnusfvd hras ndkjtm kdjltfhtflks. Ymd Olurt burtmdr bfkis tmht
Snhfktfbbs hki Idbdkihkts mhvd olkiuotdi dxtdksfvd fkvdstfjhtflk hki rdsdhrom, hki
tmdfr httlrkdys oluni rdhslkhgny dvhnuhtd tmdfr rdspdotfvd plsftflks. Ymd Olurt bfkis
tmht iurfkj tmd olursd lb tmd Hotflk, tmd _dttnfkj Shrtfds hki tmdfr rdspdotfvd oluksdn
ht hnn tfads olapnfdi wftm tmd rdqufrdadkts lb Wund 88 lb tmd Bdidrhn Wunds lb Ofvfn
Srlodiurd.
83. Hnn Onhss Adagdrs wdrd jfvdk h bunn hki bhfr lpplrtukfty tl phrtfofphtd
fk tmd Hpprlvhn Mdhrfkj, hki hnn Onhss Adagdrs wfsmfkj tl gd mdhri mhvd gddk
mdhri. Ymd Olurt mhs rdvfdwdi hki olksfidrdi tmd lgedotflks lb Dnvfh Holsth,
_hghs Hvfnh, Afjudn Ohnidrlk, Bdnfpd Olnlk, Dnfzhgdtm Olrrdh, Ahrfh Outzhn, Euhkh
Dsthnh, Elsd J. Jhrofh, Rhndktfkh Ndlk, Wlssfkh Ahrtfkdz, Jfngdrtl Adnomlr
_hkomdz, Vhidr H. Shstrhk, _ushkh Sdrdz, Drfo Wlidks`y, Elsd Yhblyh, Lnfvfh
Ylrrds, Eunfh Tnnlh, Ahrtfn Shnah Rdnndofnnl, hki Edbb Nl``dk lk tmd adrfts. Ymd
Olurt bfkis tmht tmd sugsthkod lb tmd lgedotflks tl tmd prlplsdi _tfpunhtflk lb
_dttndadkt hrd wftmlut adrft fk nfjmt lb tmd sugsthktfhn dvfidkod lb tmd bhfrkdss,
hidquhoy, hki rdhslkhgndkdss lb tmd prlplsdi _tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt, hki hrd
mdrdgy lvdrrundi. @lksthkod Hrastrlkjs hki Zyahk Elkjs rdqudsts tl wftmirhw
tmdfr lgedotflks hrd hpprlvdi. Onhss Adagdrs mhvd mhi h bunn hki bhfr lpplrtukfty tl
dxonuid tmdasdnvds brla tmd prlplsdi _dttndadkt hki tmd Onhss. Ymd tdras lb tmd
_tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt hki lb tmd Olurts Lridr smhnn gd blrdvdr gfkifkj lkadagdrs lb tmd Onhss wml ifi klt tfadny dxonuid tmdasdnvds. Htthomdi hs Dxmfgft
H tl tmfs Bfkhn Euijadkt fs h nfst sdttfkj blrtm tmd khad lb dhom pdrslk wml mhs
rdqudstdi dxonusflk brla tmd Wund 7?(g)(?) Onhss ukidr tmd prlodiurds sdt blrtm fk
tmd Srdnfafkhry Hpprlvhn Lridr.
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 4 lb 8? Shjd FI #59999
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
6/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
2 Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
88. Ymd Olurt mhs olksfidrdi tmd Altflk blr Httlrkdys Bdds, Dxpdksds,
hki Fkodktfvd Hwhris sdphrhtdny brla fts olksfidrhtflk lb tmd bhfrkdss,
rdhslkhgndkdss, hki hidquhoy lb tmd _tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt. Hky lridr lr
prloddifkj rdnhtfkj tl tmd Altflk blr Httlrkdys Bdds, Dxpdksds, hki Fkodktfvd
Hwhris, lr hky hppdhn brla hky lridr rdnhtfkj tmdrdtl lr rdvdrshn lr alifbfohtflk
tmdrdlb smhnn klt ifsturg lr hbbdot lr idnhy tmd bfkhnfty lb tmfs Euijadkt.
87. Ymfs Hotflk, hki hnn onhfas olkthfkdi tmdrdfk, hrd ifsafssdi lk tmd
adrfts hki wftm prdeuifod hs tl tmd Snhfktfbbs hki hnn _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdrs hki
wftmlut prdeuifod hs tl hky klk-odrtfbfdi pltdktfhn puthtfvd onhss adagdrs bhnnfkj
lutsfid tmd idbfkftflk lb tmd _dttndadkt Onhssds hpprlvdi gy tmd Olurt. Hs lb tmd
Dbbdotfvd Ihtd, Mdrghnfbd hki dhom lb tmdfr prdsdkt hki blradr, ifrdot hki fkifrdot,
sugsfifhrfds, phrdkts, hbbfnfhtds, ukfkolrplrhtdi dktftfds, ifvfsflks, jrlups, lbbfodrs,
ifrdotlrs, smhrdmlnidrs, phrtkdrs, phrtkdrsmfps, elfkt vdkturds, dapnlydds, hjdkts,
sdrvhkts, hssfjkdds, suoodsslrs, fksurdrs, fkidakftdds, httlrkdys, trhksbdrdds, hki/lr
rdprdsdkthtfvds (olnndotfvdny, tmd Wdndhsdi Shrtfds) smhnn gd rdndhsdi hki blrdvdr
ifsomhrjdi gy tmd Onhss Wdprdsdkthtfvds, blr tmdasdnvds hki hs tmd rdprdsdkthtfvds
lb dhom _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdr0 dhom _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdr lk gdmhnb lb
mfasdnb lr mdrsdnb0 hki tmdfr rdspdotfvd prdsdkt hki blradr, ifrdot hki fkifrdot,
sugsfifhrfds, phrdkts, hbbfnfhtds, ukfkolrplrhtdi dktftfds, ifvfsflks, jrlups, lbbfodrs,
ifrdotlrs, smhrdmlnidrs, phrtkdrs, phrtkdrsmfps, elfkt vdkturds, dapnlydds, hjdkts,
sdrvhkts, hssfjkdds, suoodsslrs, fksurdrs, fkidakftdds, httlrkdys, trhksbdrdds, hki/lr
rdprdsdkthtfvds (olnndotfvdny, tmd Wdndhsfkj Shrtfds) brla hnn onhfas, idahkis,
rfjmts, nfhgfnftfds, sufts, lr ohusds lb hotflk, `klwk lr uk`klwk, hs lb tmd DbbdotfvdIhtd tmht (8) wdrd lr oluni mhvd gddk hssdrtdi fk tmd olapnhfkts bfndi fk tmfs Hotflk
hjhfkst Mdrghnfbd, lr (7) hrd ghsdi uplk, hrfsd lut lb, lr rdhslkhgny rdnhtd tl5 (f) tmd
puromhsd lr shnd lr lbbdr lb shnd lb hky Mdrghnfbd prliuot, fkonuifkj tmd FGS hki
Afkf-FGS, iurfkj tmd Onhss Sdrfli0 (ff) hky pho`hjfkj hki mhkinfkj lr smfppfkj
omhrjds phfi fk olkkdotflk wftm puromhsd lr shnd lr lbbdr lb shnd lb hky Mdrghnfbd
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 2 lb 8? Shjd FI #59994
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
7/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
: Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
prliuot iurfkj tmd Onhss Sdrfli0 (fff) tmd Mdrghnfbd Adagdrsmfp Hppnfohtflk hki
Hjrddadkt, fkonuifkj hky ahtdrfhns htthomdi tmdrdtl hki/lr rdbdrdkodi tmdrdfk,
fkonuifkj tmd _thtdadkt lb Hvdrhjd Jrlss Olapdkshtflk0 (fv) hky hotuhn, pltdktfhn,
lr httdaptdi rdoruftadkt lb hky Mdrghnfbd adagdr lr ifstrfgutlr iurfkj tmd Onhss
Sdrfli0 (v) hky hnndjhtflk tmht, iurfkj tmd Onhss Sdrfli, Mdrghnfbd dkjhjdi fk hky
hots lb ukbhfr olapdtftflk0 bhnsd hki/lr afsndhifkj hivdrtfsfkj0 lr lpdrhtdi hky typd
lb fnndjhn, pyrhafi, dkindss omhfk, lr brhuiundkt somdad0 hki (vf) hky lb tmd bhots,
somdads, trhkshotflks, dvdkts, ahttdrs, loourrdkods, hots, ifsonlsurds, sthtdadkts,
afsrdprdsdkthtflks, lafssflks, lr bhfnurds tl hot tmht mhvd gddk lr oluni mhvd gddk
hnndjdi lr hssdrtdi fk tmd Hotflk (olnndotfvdny, tmd Wdndhsdi Onhfas)0 prlvfidi,
mlwdvdr, tmht tmd Wdndhsdi Onhfas il klt fkonuid onhfas hrfsfkj lut lb (8) tmd
puromhsd lr shnd lb Mdrghnfbds olaalk stlo`, pugnfony trhidi lk tmd Kdw Vlr`
_tlo` Dxomhkjd ukidr tmd tfo`dr syagln, MNB0 (7) tmd ohnounhtflk lb glkusds lr
phyadkts blr tmd shnd lb Mdrghnfbd prliuots lwdi gy Mdrghnfbd tl hky _dttndadkt
Onhss Adagdr, tl tmd dxtdkt suom glkusds lr phyadkts hrd klt rdnhtdi tl hky
Xuhnfbfdi Srliuots0 lr (?) hky hnndjhtflk tmht hk Mdrghnfbd prliuot whs idbdotfvd.
8?.
Kltwftmsthkifkj hky ltmdr tdra lb tmfs Bfkhn Euijadkt, tmd Wdndhsdi
Onhfas smhnn klt gd iddadi tl fkonuid hky onhfas hssdrtdi hjhfkst hky lb tmd
Wdndhsdi Shrtfds gy hky bdidrhn, sthtd, lr nlohn jlvdrkadkthn hjdkoy lr sfafnhr
hutmlrfty, hrfsfkj lut lb hky sthtutds, runds, rdjunhtflks lr lrifkhkods lvdr wmfom
suom dktfty mhs eurfsifotflk, prlvfidi tmht suom onhfas smhnn klt rdsunt fk lr hnnlw h
ilugnd rdolvdry blr hky _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdr. Ymfs Bfkhn Euijadkt smhnn klt gd
iddadi tl nfaft lr ifafkfsm Mdrghnfbds prlspdotfvd lgnfjhtflks tl olapny wftmhppnfohgnd olksuadr prltdotflk nhws lr nhws olkodrkfkj tmd lgnfjhtflks lb auntf-
ndvdn ahr`dtfkj olaphkfds, fkonuifkj, wftmlut nfafthtflk, hppnfohgnd nhws ahkihtfkj
odrthfk ndvdns lb guygho`s hki rdbukis lb prliuots, sdrvfods, hki ltmdr
olksfidrhtflk. Ymfs Bfkhn Euijadkt smhnn klt gd iddadi tl nfaft tmd rfjmt lb hky
_dttndadkt Onhss Adagdr tl prlvfid fkblrahtflk, bfnd olapnhfkts lr ollpdrhtd wftm
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd : lb 8? Shjd FI #59992
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
8/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
= Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
hky bdidrhn, sthtd, lr nlohn jlvdrkadkthn hjdkoy fk olkkdotflk wftm hky ahttdr
rdnhtfkj tl tmd Wdndhsdi Onhfas, klr ilds ft purplrt tl nfaft tmd eurfsifotflk lr
hutmlrfty lb hky jlvdrkadkthn hjdkoy tl olksfidr lr fkvdstfjhtd suom onhfas.
89.
Kltwftmsthkifkj hky ltmdr tdra lb tmfs Bfkhn Euijadkt, tmd Wdndhsdi
Onhfas smhnn klt fkonuid hky fkifvfiuhn onhfas hssdrtdi gy hky _dttndadkt Onhss
Adagdr wml fs dxonuidi brla tmd _dttndadkt Onhssds pursuhkt tl Shrhjrhpms ? hki
9 lb tmfs Bfkhn Euijadkt hki wml mhs hjrddi tl gd sugedot tl tmd hrgftrhtflk
prlvfsflks lb tmd Hrgftrhtflk Hjrddadkt blr Ifsputds Gdtwddk Adagdrs hki
Mdrghnfbd olkthfkdi fk tmd Adagdr Hppnfohtflk Hjrddadkt rdvfsdi iurfkj lr hbtdr
_dptdagdr 738?.
84. Hs lb tmd Dbbdotfvd Ihtd, hnn Wdndhsdi Shrtfds smhnn olkonusfvdny gd
iddadi tl mhvd ho`klwndijdi tmht tmd Wdndhsdi Onhfas fkonuid onhfas, idahkis,
rfjmts, nfhgfnftfds, sufts, lr ohusds lb hotflk, `klwk lr uk`klwk, hs lb tmd Dbbdotfvd
Ihtd. Ymd Wdndhsfkj Shrtfds klkdtmdndss rdndhsd hnn suom onhfas. Dhom _dttndadkt
Onhss Adagdr, wmdtmdr lr klt suom _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdr dxdoutds hki idnfvdrs
h Onhfa Blra, fs gluki gy tmfs Euijadkt, fkonuifkj, wftmlut nfafthtflk, tmd Wdndhsd
sdt blrtm hglvd. Hnn Wdndhsfkj Shrtfds smhnn burtmdr, hs lb tmd Dbbdotfvd Ihtd,
olkonusfvdny gd iddadi tl mhvd whfvdi tmd rfjmts hbblridi gy Ohnfblrkfh Ofvfn Olid
_dotflk 8497, hki hky sfafnhr sthtutd lr nhw, lr prfkofpnd lb olaalk nhw, lb
Ohnfblrkfh lr hky ltmdr eurfsifotflk.
82. Zftmlut hbbdotfkj tmd bfkhnfty lb tmfs Euijadkt fk hky why, tmfs Olurt
mdrdgy rdthfks olktfkufkj eurfsifotflk lvdr5 (f) fapndadkthtflk lb tmd _dttndadkt0 (ff)
tmd hnnlwhkod, ifshnnlwhkod lr hieustadkt lb hky _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdrs onhfalk dqufthgnd jrlukis hki hky hwhri lr ifstrfgutflk lb tmd _dttndadkt Buki hki
Srliuot Wdturk Buki (olnndotfvdny, tmd _dttndadkt Bukis), fkonuifkj hnn ifsputdi
qudstflks lb nhw hki bhot wftm rdspdot tl tmd vhnfifty lb hky onhfa lr rfjmt lb hky
Sdrslk tl phrtfofphtd fk tmd ifstrfgutflk lb tmd _dttndadkt Bukis0 (fff) ifsplsftflk lb
tmd _dttndadkt Bukis0 (fv) mdhrfkj hki idtdrafkfkj hppnfohtflks blr httlrkdys bdds,
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd = lb 8? Shjd FI #5999:
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
9/13
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
10/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
83 Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
g. il klt olkstftutd, hki smhnn klt gd lbbdrdi lr rdodfvdi hjhfkst lr
tl tmd prdeuifod lb Mdrghnfbd hs dvfidkod lb h prdsuaptflk,
olkodssflk, lr hiafssflk lb hky bhunt, afsrdprdsdkthtflk, lr
lafssflk wftm rdspdot tl hky sthtdadkt lr wrfttdk ilouadkt
hpprlvdi lr ahid gy Mdrghnfbd, lr hjhfkst lr tl tmd prdeuifod lb
Snhfktfbbs lr hky ltmdr _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdrs hs dvfidkod lb
hky fkbfrafty fk tmd onhfas lb Snhfktfbbs lr tmd ltmdr _dttndadkt
Onhss Adagdrs0
o. il klt olkstftutd, hki smhnn klt gd lbbdrdi lr rdodfvdi hjhfkst lr
tl tmd prdeuifod lb Mdrghnfbd, Snhfktfbbs, hky ltmdr _dttndadkt
Onhss Adagdrs, lr tmdfr rdspdotfvd oluksdn, hs dvfidkod lb h
prdsuaptflk, olkodssflk, lr hiafssflk wftm rdspdot tl hky
nfhgfnfty, ihahjds, kdjnfjdkod, bhunt, fkbfrafty lr wrlkjilfkj, lr
fk hky why rdbdrrdi tl blr hky ltmdr rdhslk hjhfkst lr tl tmd
prdeuifod lb hky lb Mdrghnfbd, Snhfktfbbs, hky ltmdr _dttndadkt
Onhss Adagdrs, lr tmdfr rdspdotfvd oluksdn, fk hky ltmdr ofvfn,
orfafkhn lr hiafkfstrhtfvd hotflk lr prloddifkj, ltmdr tmhk suom
prloddifkjs hs ahy gd kdodsshry tl dbbdotuhtd tmd prlvfsflks lb
tmd _dttndadkt0
i. il klt olkstftutd, hki smhnn klt gd olkstrudi hjhfkst Mdrghnfbd,
Snhfktfbbs, lr hky ltmdr _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdr, hs hk
hiafssflk lr olkodssflk tmht tmd olksfidrhtflk tl gd jfvdk
mdrdukidr rdprdsdkts tmd halukt wmfom oluni gd lr wluni mhvdgddk rdolvdrdi hbtdr trfhn0 hki
d. il klt olkstftutd, hki smhnn klt gd olkstrudi hs lr rdodfvdi fk
dvfidkod hs hk hiafssflk, olkodssflk, lr prdsuaptflk hjhfkst
Snhfktfbbs lr hky ltmdr _dttndadkt Onhss Adagdrs tmht hky lb
tmdfr onhfas hrd wftmlut adrft lr fkbfra lr tmht ihahjds
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 83 lb 8? Shjd FI #59996
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
11/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
88 Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
rdolvdrhgnd ukidr tmd Bfrst Hadkidi Olapnhfkt lr lrfjfkhn
Olapnhfkt wluni klt mhvd dxoddidi tmd _dttndadkt halukt.
73. Zftmlut burtmdr lridr lb tmd Olurt, tmd _dttnfkj Shrtfds ahy hjrdd tl
rdhslkhgnd dxtdksflks lb tfad tl ohrry lut hky lb tmd prlvfsflks lb tmd _tfpunhtflk.
78. Ymd _dttnfkj Shrtfds hrd mdrdgy ifrdotdi tl olksuaahtd tmd _tfpunhtflk
hki tl pdrblra fts tdras.
77. H sdphrhtd lridr smhnn gd dktdrdi rdjhrifkj Snhfktfbbs Oluksdns
hppnfohtflk blr httlrkdys bdds hki phyadkt lb dxpdksds hs hnnlwdi gy tmd Olurt.
7?. Kltmfkj fk tmfs Bfkhn Euijadkt fs fktdkidi tl lr smhnn alifby tmd tdras
lb tmd _dttndadkt hs dxprdssny hadkidi.
79. Bfkhn Euijadkt fk tmfs hotflk fs mdrdgy dktdrdi. Hnn onhfas hjhfkst
Idbdkihkts fk tmd Hotflk hrd mdrdgy ifsafssdi lk tmd adrfts wftm prdeuifod, wftm
dhom phrty tl gdhr fts lwk olsts, dxodpt hs hki tl tmd dxtdkt prlvfidi blr fk tmd
_dttndadkt. Ymdrd fs kl eust rdhslk blr idnhy fk tmd dktry lb tmfs Bfkhn Euijadkt hki
faadifhtd dktry gy tmd Ondr` lb tmd Olurt fs dxprdssny ifrdotdi pursuhkt tl Wund
49(g) lb tmd Bdidrhn Wunds lb Ofvfn Srlodiurd.
FKODKYFRD HZHWI_ HKI HYYLWKDV_ BDD_ HKI D]SDK_D_
Snhfktfbbs fk tmfs onhss hotflk mhvd hnsl alvdi blr hk hwhri lb httlrkdys bdds
hki dxpdksds, hs wdnn hs hpprlvhn lb fkodktfvd hwhris blr onhss rdprdsdkthtfvds.
(I`t Kl. 88?.) Ymd Olurt rdvfdwdi hki olksfidrdi hnn lgedotflks tl tmd sdttndadkt
hki Onhss Oluksdns rdqudst blr hk hwhri lb httlrkdys bdds, dxpdksds, hki fkodktfvd
hwhris. Ymd Olurt mdni h mdhrfkj lk tmd altflk lk Ahy 88, 7388, tll` tmd ahttdr
ukidr sugafssflk, hki lk Ahy 89, 7384, fssudi Ofvfn Afkutds fk Omhagdrs ah`fkjbfkifkjs lb bhot hki nhw rdjhrifkj Snhfktfbbs Altflk blr Httlrkdys Bdds hki
Dxpdksds (Ilo`dt Kl. 894), wmfom hrd fkolrplrhtdi fktl tmfs lridr.
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 88 lb 8? Shjd FI #59943
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
12/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
87 Ohsd Kl. 758?-ov-379==-GWL-WUBFKHN ETIJADKY HKI LWIDW LB IF_AF__HN
Ymd Olurt hpprlvdi httlrkdys bdds fk tmd halukt lb $9.6 afnnflk hs bhfr hki
rdhslkhgnd.
Ymd Olurt idkfdi, wftmlut prdeuifod, Onhss Oluksdns rdqudst blr
rdfagursdadkt blr olsts hki dxpdksds fk tmd halukt lb $787,=27.29 gut jrhktdi tmd
rdqudst hs tl $8:4,236.27 lb dxpdksds, hnnlwfkj Onhss Oluksdn tl sugaft
suppndadkthn idonhrhtflks lr ilouadkthtflk burtmdr supplrtfkj tmdfr rdqudst hki
sdjrdjhtfkj adhn dxpdksds brla trhvdn dxpdksds.
Ymd Olurt hpprlvdi Onhss Oluksdns rdqudst blr fkodktfvd hwhris hki ifrdots
phyadkt lb $83,333 tl Ar. Glstfo` hki $4,333 dhom tl As. Rhs`l, As. Yrlttdr, As.
Alnkhr, hki Ar. Oltd.
Ymlahs J. Blndy, Er. hki _oltt A. Sdtdrsdk mhvd sugafttdi suppndadkthn
idonhrhtflks supplrtfkj tmdfr dxpdksds fkourrdi fk tmfs ohsd. Sursuhkt tl tmdfr
suppndadkthn idonhrhtflks, Onhss Oluksdn mhvd rdalvdi hky rdqudst blr
rdfagursdadkt lb adhns lr afsodnnhkdlus dxpdksds brla tmdfr dxpdksd
rdfagursdadkt rdqudst. Sursuhkt tl tmdfr suppndadkthn idonhrhtflks, Onhss Oluksdns
mhvd fkourrdi hk hiiftflkhn $4,4==.?4 fk olsts hki tmdfr dxpdksds rdnhtfkj tl ndjhn
rdsdhrom, olpyfkj, trhvdn, dxpdrt wftkdss sdrvfods, hki idnfvdry dxpdksds tmht tmht
wdrd klt rdqudstdi fk tmd Altflk blr hk Hwhri lb Httlrkdy Bdds hki Dxpdksds bfndi
lk Ahrom 83, 7384. Snhfktfbbs oluksdn mhvd hidquhtdny ilouadktdi tmdsd dxpdksds
hnn lb wmfom tmd Olurt bfkis tmdsd hiiftflkhn olsts wdrd kdodsshry blr tmfs nftfjhtflk
hki ahy gd rdfagursdi. Ymd Olurt tmdrdblrd hpprlvds rdfagursdadkt blr tmdsd
olsts, dquhnfkj $836,922.78 blr tmd Blndy Gdzd` Gdmnd & Ourtfs nhw bfra hki
$837,862.97 blr tmd Bhgfhk & Ondkidkfk nhw bfra, tlthnfkj $788,227.2?.FY F_ MDWDGV LWIDWDI
Sursuhkt tl _dotflks 83.7 hki 83.? lb tmd _tfpunhtflk lb _dttndadkt (I`t Kl.
64), tmd Dsorlw Hjdkt fs HTYMLWFUDI hki IFWDOYDI tl phy tmd blnnlwfkj
halukts brla tmd Ohsm Buki5
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 87 lb 8? Shjd FI #59948
7/21/2019 Bostick FINAL Order
13/13
8
7
?
9
4
2
:
=
6
83
88
87
8?
89
84
82
8:
8=
86
73
78
77
7?79
74
72
7:
7=
8. $9,633,333 blr httlrkdys bdds tl Onhss Oluksdn
7. $788,227.2? fk dxpdksds tl Onhss Oluksdn
?. $83,333 tl Ihkh Glstfo`
9. $4333 tl Hkfth Rhs`l
4. $4333 tl Euif Yrlttdr
2. $4333 tl Gdvdrny Alnkhr
:. $4333 tl Omdstdr Oltd
FY F_ _L LWIDWDI.
Ihtdi5 Eukd 8:, 7384
Gy5MLK. GDRDWNV WDFI LOLKKDNNTkftdi _thtds Ifstrfot Olurt Euijd
Ohsd 758?-ov-379==-GWL-_M Ilouadkt 849 Bfndi 32/8:/84 Shjd 8? lb 8? Shjd FI #59947