Post on 26-Dec-2015
1
Using Operational Excellence to Drive Sustainability
Overview and Case study
Craig Seyfried Sr. Director WyethISPE Annual Meeting Nov. 11, 2009
2
Session Objectives• Discuss the Scope of Sustainability• View One Company’s Approach using
Operational Excellence• Estimate Potential Benefits – to
Product, Cost and the Environment
We don’t give ourselves enough credit as an industry !
3
Sustainability means satisfying multiple concerns..…
….Able to be Maintained ….Maintaining ecological balance
– Operational – Improvements in operations and support that allow capacity gains while maintaining or improving
quality– Financial- A cost structure that can survive in the face of
increased pricing pressure and maintenance of profitable margin in all regions of the world
– Environmental- Processes that minimize environmental impacts thru energy efficiency, waste elimination and overall carbon reduction
4
“Climate change is the greatest humanitarian challenge of our time….”*
• Over 300 million people impacted resulting in hundreds of thousands of deaths per year
• 99% of those dying are in developing countries least likely to affect climate change
• Total economic costs is over $125 billion per year and rising
“…Now that we know we must act…”*
* Kofi Annan - Global Humanitarian Forum Report - May 2009
5
Our approach has been limited to date
• Only 17 % have a comprehensive strategy for combating climate change
• Most of the efforts to date - 94% - have been in building design and energy supply
• 62 % of us have improved energy efficiency over our global operations….and will continue to give this a high priority
• Government Regulations and Compliance will drive most (90%) companies climate change agendas*
“Company target setting is motivated by market forces not scientific requirements..”**
•Countdown to Copenhagen a report for the Economist Intelligence Unit 2009** Carbon Disclosure Project - The Carbon Chasm 2009
6
There are Three Platforms for addressing Sustainability Challenges
• Technology• Mitigation• Adaptation
....and the use of Operational Excellence (OE) as a process methodology for improving sustainability encompasses all three
7
Scope of the Initiative - Wyeth
• Sales of ~$22 Billion• 47,000+ employees • 28 Plants / 20 Countries and Puerto Rico• Major Product Lines in…
– Pharmaceuticals and Biopharmaceuticals– Vaccines– Consumer and Animal Health– Nutritionals
9
Aspire high; blend technical & organizational change;build capability and let your line leaders own and drive it
Our Approach: Three Key Levers
10
Deliver Savings & Continuous Improvement
Cost and Quality PerformanceDesign 25% operational cost
improvement by end of 2009
1111
3333 Create operational capabilities, behaviors, and mindsets to ensure sustainable, continuous improvement
Maintain and improve our quality and compliance performance
2222
1&21&21&21&2
3333
12
Diagnostics Cover Multiple Work Streams and Data
Savings opportunity ranges from 15 - 40% per site
13
Our ability to adapt and change manufacturing helps create value Our ability to adapt and change manufacturing helps create value to the business and competitive advantage through improved to the business and competitive advantage through improved
quality, speed, cost efficiency and carbon reduction. quality, speed, cost efficiency and carbon reduction.
Transformation Results as of Sept .2009
50 Mini TransformationsFinalized and More Than
80 Underway
25% Operational Run Rate Improvement
Designed by Year-End
17 Sites Have Implemented Standard Site
Structure
More Than 100 Mindsets and Behaviours Trainings
Across 16 Wave I/II Sites
No Compromises in Quality and
Supply Outcomes
7 Standardization Projects in
Process Across Sites
14
Transitioning to Sustainability:
Time
Per
form
ance Transition
Step change via mini-Ts
Sustained gains via continuous improvement
5 Requirementsn Continuously assessing against:
Original and new challenges
Desired future state
n Aligned team of local leaders: Setting targets for continuous
improvement
Staying highly visible
Engaging line leaders
n Incorporating targets into key systems:
Performance
Succession
Planning & budgeting
n Strategically communicating achievements & instilling pride
n Driving engagement & behavior change
15
Significant Savings Already Achieved
• ~ $250 M savings commitment against a stretch target of $150 M for 2009 budget
• ~1200+ headcount reduction in 2008
• Additional headcount reductions in 2009
• ~60 site mini-T teams coached in early stages of the transformation
• Frontline is engaged in change and new leaders have emerged from the floor
Program has exceeded expectations
250
2009(Committed)
2010(Expected)
Cost Savings$ M
16
Potential Impacts on Sustainability
• Operational - 25 % efficiency improvement Translates to billion of units additional mfg. capacity • Financial - $ 575 million /yr in cost reductions The equivalent of 1 major new drug each year
• Environmental – potential reduction of 15-40% energy consumption equates to a reduction of 200-500 k tons/year of GHG emissions
Avoids investment of over $150 mil for renewable energy generation capacity
17
Conclusion• To achieve overall Sustainability and meet the global CO2
reduction targets we have to think broader about the solutions
• OE is ideally suited as an approach because it is holistic in nature
• Need to routinely calculate environmental benefits and capture
CO2 e savings as part of project justifications • Transform mindsets toward more sustainable design of
processes and supply chain
Thank You!
Acknowledgement to OE Team Lead - Wendy Kouba
Presented by Craig SeyfriedSr. Director International Operations
WyethCollegeville, PA, 19426
484-865-3016 seyfriec@wyeth.com
20
Typical Biotech Environmental Considerations*
Table 15.1 Water/Materials usage for therapeutic proteins for a composite “typical” process.
MATERIALS kg/kg Protein
Glucose 200 - 400
Salts 200 - 300
Water 10,000 - 20,000
Acid/Base Buffers 100 - 200
Urea 0 – 1,000
Organic Solvents 0 - 200
Hazardous Solvents 0 - 5
KEY CONSUMABLES
Chromatographic resins 2 - 10
Filters 10 - 20
Membranes <1
TOTAL CONSUMABLES ~ 10 - 30
*ACS Draft Chapter 15. Environmental Considerations in Biologics Manufacturing
Sa V. Ho, in “Green Chemistry in the Pharmaceutical Industry”, Dunn, Wells, Williams (Eds)
21
Typical Biotech Environmental Considerations*
*ACS Draft Chapter 15. Environmental Considerations in Biologics Manufacturing
Sa V. Hoin, “Green Chemistry in the Pharmaceutical Industry”, Dunn, Wells, Williams (Eds)
Microbially-Derived Proteins mAbs from Cell Culture
A Highly
Optimized, Large-Scale
Typical “Composite”
Process
Optimized Large-Scale
Highly Intensified, Large-Scale
kg per kg API
Water Usage <1000 15,000 4500 1500
Salts + Buffers 1 400 300 100
Consumables (solid wastes)
1 20 4 2
Organic Solvents
~0 100 (alcohols, may involve some
hazardous solvents)
8 (alcohols)
8 (alcohols)